1




LEARNER LANGUAGE
Learner Language
2


       Interlanguage
       Generalization
       Transfer
       Internal sequences
Interlanguage
3




      Input   Noticing   Intake   Interlanguage
Interlanguage Rules
4


       Learners create language rules from intake
       Rules determine learners’
           Comprehension
           Production
       Interlanguage rules are changeable
           From the outside (input)
           From the inside (learner hypotheses)
Interlanguage Rules
5


       Learners’ interlanguage changes with time
           Rules are altered
           Rules are deleted
           Rules are added
Irregular verbs
6
Interlaguage Continuum
7




     L1     IL               L2


     L1              IL      L2
Interlanguage
8


       Has rules
       Is changeable, but not random
       Moves towards L2, but may become fossilized
Processes
9


       Processes that create interlanguage
         Generalizations

         Transfer

         Internal   sequences
Generalizations
10


        Generalizations are used in many learning
         situations
        Learners group similar things, events,
         information, etc. together into categories
        Learners make rules to predict how different
         items will behave
Generalization
11


        Learners categorize what they hear and make
         rules for those categories
        Learners use those categories and rules in
         new situations
Overgeneralization
12


        Learners sometimes make mistakes because
          Categories  have exceptions
            Learners put language in the wrong categories
Overgeneralization
13


        An item belongs to a category but it is an
         exception to a general rule for the category
          Irregular verbs: go – went, choose – chose
          Irregular plurals: wife – wives, mouse – mice

        An item belongs to a different category
            Auxiliary verbs and third person aspect: He goes to
             the store – He will goes to the store
Transfer
14


        Learners use their knowledge of their first
         language to understand and organize second
         language information
          When   there are differences in the first and second
           language, transfer can lead learners to make
           errors
          When first and second language are the same,
           transfer help learners
Examples of errors due to
15
     transfer
        Pronunciation
        Vocabulary
        Speech acts
Pronunciation
16


        How do you pronounce the following?
          Salad
          Shirt
          Earth
          19
          90
          Base – vase
          Rob – lob
Vocabulary
17



           Idiom            Meaning in English       Meaning in Arabic

       day after day             every day            every other day

        red-faced              embarrassed                furious

                          (jokingly) say something
       pull one's leg                                   let him talk
                                   untrue

     stretch one's legs         take a walk              lie down

      head over heels       completely (in love)        upside down
Speech acts
18




        Americans hosts tend to offer food and drink
         three times. American guests tend to refuse
         the first two offers and accept the third.
        Dutch hosts tend to offer food and drink only
         once. Dutch guests are expected to accept if
         they are thirsty or hungry or refuse if they are
         not.
Transfer and generalization
19


        Transfer and overgeneralization are not distinct
         processes
        Generalization: Learners make use of their
         knowledge of the second language
        Transfer: Learners make use of their knowledge
         of their first language to produce or understand
         a second language
Successful learning
20


        Overgeneralization and transfer are not bad
        Overgeneralization and transfer lead learners
         to successfully produce language more often
         than they lead them to make errors
        Errors are part of the learning process
Internal Sequences
   Learners
       Hear different language, for example, in
        classrooms
       Have different first languages
   Therefore, we expect that learners learn a
    second language in different ways
Morpheme studies
   Researchers studied how accurately learners
    used different morphemes
   Studied learners with different first languages
   Analyzed how accurately the morphemes were
    used
Morpheme Study Results 1

   Group 1: present progressive -ing as in boy
    running
       plural -s as in two books
       copula `to be' as in he is big
   Group 2: auxiliary `to be' as in he is running
       articles the and a
   Group 3: irregular past forms as in she went
   Group 4: regular past -ed as in she climbed
       third-person singular -s as in she runs
       possessive -s as in man's hat
Morpheme study results 2

   Learners used morphemes in Group 1 most
    accurately
   Researchers assumed that degree of
    accuracy indicated the order in which
    morphemes are learned
   English morphemes are learned in a
    predictable sequence
Morpheme study results 3

   Sequence is only a tendency
       Variation in all studies
   Other studies have shown contradictory results
   Thus, morpheme studies are not completely
    reliable
Questions
   Second language learners go through the
    same stages in learning questions as first
    language learners
Question Stages
27


              Stage                     Examples
     Stage 1:                  What daddy doing?
     wh-word goes in front     Why Sarah crying?
                               Where you go?
     Stage 2:                  Where he will go?
     Adds the auxiliary verb   What he is doing?
                               Why Sarah is crying?
     Stage 3:                  What is daddy doing?
     Grammatically correct     Where will you go?
                               Why do you work?
Progress through the stages
   Progress is gradual
   One stage slowly disappears and is replaced
    by another
   Learners often produce questions from
    different stages
Conclusions

   Second language learners tend to learn
    some language features in sequences
       Morphemes
       Negatives
       Questions
   Sequences are usually independent of the
    learners first language
   Sequences indicate that there may be
    something internal helping learners learn
    second languages
Learner Language
30


        Interlanguage
        Generalization
        Transfer
        Internal sequences

Learner language

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Learner Language 2  Interlanguage  Generalization  Transfer  Internal sequences
  • 3.
    Interlanguage 3 Input Noticing Intake Interlanguage
  • 4.
    Interlanguage Rules 4  Learners create language rules from intake  Rules determine learners’  Comprehension  Production  Interlanguage rules are changeable  From the outside (input)  From the inside (learner hypotheses)
  • 5.
    Interlanguage Rules 5  Learners’ interlanguage changes with time  Rules are altered  Rules are deleted  Rules are added
  • 6.
  • 7.
    Interlaguage Continuum 7 L1 IL L2 L1 IL L2
  • 8.
    Interlanguage 8  Has rules  Is changeable, but not random  Moves towards L2, but may become fossilized
  • 9.
    Processes 9  Processes that create interlanguage  Generalizations  Transfer  Internal sequences
  • 10.
    Generalizations 10  Generalizations are used in many learning situations  Learners group similar things, events, information, etc. together into categories  Learners make rules to predict how different items will behave
  • 11.
    Generalization 11  Learners categorize what they hear and make rules for those categories  Learners use those categories and rules in new situations
  • 12.
    Overgeneralization 12  Learners sometimes make mistakes because  Categories have exceptions  Learners put language in the wrong categories
  • 13.
    Overgeneralization 13  An item belongs to a category but it is an exception to a general rule for the category  Irregular verbs: go – went, choose – chose  Irregular plurals: wife – wives, mouse – mice  An item belongs to a different category  Auxiliary verbs and third person aspect: He goes to the store – He will goes to the store
  • 14.
    Transfer 14  Learners use their knowledge of their first language to understand and organize second language information  When there are differences in the first and second language, transfer can lead learners to make errors  When first and second language are the same, transfer help learners
  • 15.
    Examples of errorsdue to 15 transfer  Pronunciation  Vocabulary  Speech acts
  • 16.
    Pronunciation 16  How do you pronounce the following?  Salad  Shirt  Earth  19  90  Base – vase  Rob – lob
  • 17.
    Vocabulary 17 Idiom Meaning in English Meaning in Arabic day after day every day every other day red-faced embarrassed furious (jokingly) say something pull one's leg let him talk untrue stretch one's legs take a walk lie down head over heels completely (in love) upside down
  • 18.
    Speech acts 18  Americans hosts tend to offer food and drink three times. American guests tend to refuse the first two offers and accept the third.  Dutch hosts tend to offer food and drink only once. Dutch guests are expected to accept if they are thirsty or hungry or refuse if they are not.
  • 19.
    Transfer and generalization 19  Transfer and overgeneralization are not distinct processes  Generalization: Learners make use of their knowledge of the second language  Transfer: Learners make use of their knowledge of their first language to produce or understand a second language
  • 20.
    Successful learning 20  Overgeneralization and transfer are not bad  Overgeneralization and transfer lead learners to successfully produce language more often than they lead them to make errors  Errors are part of the learning process
  • 21.
    Internal Sequences  Learners  Hear different language, for example, in classrooms  Have different first languages  Therefore, we expect that learners learn a second language in different ways
  • 22.
    Morpheme studies  Researchers studied how accurately learners used different morphemes  Studied learners with different first languages  Analyzed how accurately the morphemes were used
  • 23.
    Morpheme Study Results1  Group 1: present progressive -ing as in boy running  plural -s as in two books  copula `to be' as in he is big  Group 2: auxiliary `to be' as in he is running  articles the and a  Group 3: irregular past forms as in she went  Group 4: regular past -ed as in she climbed  third-person singular -s as in she runs  possessive -s as in man's hat
  • 24.
    Morpheme study results2  Learners used morphemes in Group 1 most accurately  Researchers assumed that degree of accuracy indicated the order in which morphemes are learned  English morphemes are learned in a predictable sequence
  • 25.
    Morpheme study results3  Sequence is only a tendency  Variation in all studies  Other studies have shown contradictory results  Thus, morpheme studies are not completely reliable
  • 26.
    Questions  Second language learners go through the same stages in learning questions as first language learners
  • 27.
    Question Stages 27 Stage Examples Stage 1: What daddy doing? wh-word goes in front Why Sarah crying? Where you go? Stage 2: Where he will go? Adds the auxiliary verb What he is doing? Why Sarah is crying? Stage 3: What is daddy doing? Grammatically correct Where will you go? Why do you work?
  • 28.
    Progress through thestages  Progress is gradual  One stage slowly disappears and is replaced by another  Learners often produce questions from different stages
  • 29.
    Conclusions  Second language learners tend to learn some language features in sequences  Morphemes  Negatives  Questions  Sequences are usually independent of the learners first language  Sequences indicate that there may be something internal helping learners learn second languages
  • 30.
    Learner Language 30  Interlanguage  Generalization  Transfer  Internal sequences

Editor's Notes

  • #3 Learner text handout here.
  • #7 At first irregular verbs are not analyzed – just memorized – and so they get them right. Then they go through a stage where they realize that there are irregular verbs and finally they have them mastered.Came >> comed & came >> came
  • #8 Learners seldom reach L2; they usually fossilize, stop at a point short of their goal. BUT they can come close.
  • #10 Grammar CR worksheets here
  • #14 it’s / itsFurniture / money
  • #27 See handout