SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Virtual reality simulation in SURGERYVirtual reality simulation in SURGERY
Dr sumer yadavDr sumer yadav
What isWhat is virtual realityvirtual reality ??
 Virtual realityVirtual reality ((VRVR))
is a technology whichis a technology which
allows a user toallows a user to
interact with ainteract with a
computer-simulatedcomputer-simulated
environment, whetherenvironment, whether
that environment is athat environment is a
simulation of the realsimulation of the real
world or an imaginaryworld or an imaginary
world.world.
simulation
network communication
full-body immersion telepresence
immersion
artificiality
interaction
Components of virtual reality
What isWhat is simulationsimulation ??
 SimulationSimulation is theis the imitationimitation of some real thing.of some real thing.
 UsesUses
 1. natural systems or human systems in order to1. natural systems or human systems in order to
gain insight into their functioning.gain insight into their functioning.
 2. Testing2. Testing
 3.Training3.Training
 4. Education4. Education
 5.Simulation of technology for performance5.Simulation of technology for performance
optimizationoptimization
 6. Video games6. Video games
What isWhat is Virtual surgeryVirtual surgery ??
virtual reality simulation of surgicalvirtual reality simulation of surgical
procedures.procedures.
analog for the actual surgery whereanalog for the actual surgery where
doctors can practice on a virtual patientdoctors can practice on a virtual patient
before performing the surgery.before performing the surgery.
Advantage to the surgeonsAdvantage to the surgeons
1.Improved surgical planning1.Improved surgical planning
2. practice surgery process on 3D2. practice surgery process on 3D
modelsmodels
VIRTUAL SURGERY SIMULATIONVIRTUAL SURGERY SIMULATION
2 STEPS
3D IMAGE SIMULATION TOUCH SIMULATION
3D IMAGE SIMULATION3D IMAGE SIMULATION
 generate a 3D modelgenerate a 3D model
of the part of the bodyof the part of the body
that undergoesthat undergoes
surgery.surgery.
 first construct afirst construct a
reference model of areference model of a
normal person.normal person.
 anatomical images cananatomical images can
be derived from a seriesbe derived from a series
of patient’s Magneticof patient’s Magnetic
Resonance ImagesResonance Images
(MRI), Computed(MRI), Computed
Tomography (CT) orTomography (CT) or
video recording, whichvideo recording, which
are 2D images. Theseare 2D images. These
images are segmentedimages are segmented
using varioususing various
segmentation methodssegmentation methods
 final model is obtained byfinal model is obtained by
deforming the reference modeldeforming the reference model
according to the condition ofaccording to the condition of
organ that is operated upon.organ that is operated upon.
 The image is digitally mappedThe image is digitally mapped
on to theon to the polygonal meshpolygonal mesh
representing whatever part ofrepresenting whatever part of
the body on organ is beingthe body on organ is being
examined. Each vortex of theexamined. Each vortex of the
polygon is assigned attributespolygon is assigned attributes
like colour and reflectivity fromlike colour and reflectivity from
the reference model.the reference model.
 software algorithmssoftware algorithms that canthat can
calculate the whereabouts ofcalculate the whereabouts of
the virtual instrument andthe virtual instrument and
determines whether it hasdetermines whether it has
collide with a body part orcollide with a body part or
anything else.anything else.
 algorithms to solvealgorithms to solve how ithow it
looks or behave when thelooks or behave when the
body part is cutbody part is cut. We need. We need
models of how various tissuesmodels of how various tissues
behave when cut, prodded,behave when cut, prodded,
punctured and so on.punctured and so on.
The parameters of this model can then beThe parameters of this model can then be
tweakedtweaked to match what a surgeonto match what a surgeon
experiences during an actual procedure.experiences during an actual procedure.
To create graphic that move withoutTo create graphic that move without
flickering collision detection and tissueflickering collision detection and tissue
deformation must be calculated at least 30deformation must be calculated at least 30
times/sec.times/sec.
whole-body voxel humanwhole-body voxel human
modelsmodels
 Whole-bodyWhole-body voxelvoxel humanhuman
models depict the shapemodels depict the shape
of the human bodyof the human body
(tissues and organs) as(tissues and organs) as
an aggregate of minutean aggregate of minute
elements. Each minuteelements. Each minute
block, or voxel, is labeledblock, or voxel, is labeled
with a tag representingwith a tag representing
the name of a tissue orthe name of a tissue or
an organ such as musclean organ such as muscle
or fat, and assigned withor fat, and assigned with
the electrical, physicalthe electrical, physical
properties and color ofproperties and color of
the respectivethe respective
tissue/organ.tissue/organ.
TOUCH SIMULATIONTOUCH SIMULATION
hapticshaptics = the ability to simulate touch= the ability to simulate touch
Physicians rely a great deal on their sensePhysicians rely a great deal on their sense
of touch for everything from routineof touch for everything from routine
diagnosis to complex, life saving surgicaldiagnosis to complex, life saving surgical
procedure. So haptics, or the ability toprocedure. So haptics, or the ability to
simulate touch, goes a long way to makesimulate touch, goes a long way to make
virtual reality simulators more life like.virtual reality simulators more life like.
  While the brain can be tricked into seeingWhile the brain can be tricked into seeing
seamless motion by flipping through 30 orseamless motion by flipping through 30 or
so images per second, touch signals needso images per second, touch signals need
to be refreshed up to once a millisecondto be refreshed up to once a millisecond
  The precise rate at which a computerThe precise rate at which a computer
must update a haptic interface variesmust update a haptic interface varies
depending on what type of virtual surfacedepending on what type of virtual surface
is encounteredis encountered
soft object require lower update rates thansoft object require lower update rates than
harder objectsharder objects
Why??Why??
A low update rate may not prevent a usersA low update rate may not prevent a users
surgical instrument fromsurgical instrument from sinking into thesinking into the
virtual fleshvirtual flesh, but in soft tissues that sinking, but in soft tissues that sinking
is what is expected.is what is expected.
Most difficult to simulate is two floppyMost difficult to simulate is two floppy
objects interacting with each other-suchobjects interacting with each other-such
as colon and sigmoidocope, the longas colon and sigmoidocope, the long
bendable probe used to view the colon-bendable probe used to view the colon-
because of multiple collision point. Inbecause of multiple collision point. In
addition, the mechanics of such interactionaddition, the mechanics of such interaction
are complicated, because each objectare complicated, because each object
may deform the other.may deform the other.
simulating touch sensationsimulating touch sensation
 calculate the forces applied to cut, probed,calculate the forces applied to cut, probed,
puncture the various tissues.puncture the various tissues.
 Also how they react or behave when cut,Also how they react or behave when cut,
probed, punctured using surgical instruments.probed, punctured using surgical instruments.
 First we have to make physical models ofFirst we have to make physical models of
various tissues. The major difficulty in modelingvarious tissues. The major difficulty in modeling
organs is the physical behavior as they have allorgans is the physical behavior as they have all
kinds of complexities-they are anisotropic, nonkinds of complexities-they are anisotropic, non
homogeneous and nonlinear.homogeneous and nonlinear.
 If the haptic device is to give a realistic impression of sayIf the haptic device is to give a realistic impression of say
pressing the skin on a patient’s arm, the mechanicalpressing the skin on a patient’s arm, the mechanical
contributions of the skin, the fatty tissue benefit, musclecontributions of the skin, the fatty tissue benefit, muscle
and even bone must be summed up.and even bone must be summed up.
 The equations to solve such a complex problem areThe equations to solve such a complex problem are
known, but so far the calculations cannot be made fastknown, but so far the calculations cannot be made fast
enough to update a display at 30Hz, let alone update aenough to update a display at 30Hz, let alone update a
haptic interface at 500-1000Hz.haptic interface at 500-1000Hz.
VIRTUAL SURGERY SIMULATOR
POWERFUL PC HAPTIC INTERFACER
Working principleWorking principle
 force feedback loop.force feedback loop.
Advantage to the surgeonAdvantage to the surgeon
 Surgeons improve surgery plans and practice surgery process on 3DSurgeons improve surgery plans and practice surgery process on 3D
models.models.
 Pre operative evaluation of results.Pre operative evaluation of results.
 Error correction - repeat the surgical procedure as many number of timesError correction - repeat the surgical procedure as many number of times
 Better anatomical picture of procedure – wide angles availableBetter anatomical picture of procedure – wide angles available
 Familiarity with actual procedureFamiliarity with actual procedure
VIRTUAL REALITY APPLICATIONS IN SURGERY
TRAINING AND EDUCATION
SURGICAL PLANNING
IMAGE GUIDANCE
TELESURGERY
TRAINING AND EDUCATIONTRAINING AND EDUCATION
 Surgeon must be ready to manage potentially life-Surgeon must be ready to manage potentially life-
threatening situations in dynamic, unpredictablethreatening situations in dynamic, unpredictable
environments.environments.
Traditional teaching
textbook images cadavers
DisadvantageDisadvantage
 textbook images, limit one’stextbook images, limit one’s
perspective of anatomicalperspective of anatomical
structures to 2D planestructures to 2D plane
 cadavers; limited in supply andcadavers; limited in supply and
generally allowing one-timegenerally allowing one-time
use only.use only.
Advantage of VR simulatorAdvantage of VR simulator
 view the anatomy from a wide range of anglesview the anatomy from a wide range of angles
and “fly through” organs to examine bodies fromand “fly through” organs to examine bodies from
inside. The experience can be highly interactiveinside. The experience can be highly interactive
allowing students to strip away the variousallowing students to strip away the various
layers of tissues and muscles to examine eachlayers of tissues and muscles to examine each
organ separately.organ separately.
 Unlike cadavers, VR models enable the user toUnlike cadavers, VR models enable the user to
perform a procedure countless times.perform a procedure countless times.
It is interactive.It is interactive.
An instructor presence is not necessaryAn instructor presence is not necessary
Changes can be made that demonstrateChanges can be made that demonstrate
variation in anatomy or disease statevariation in anatomy or disease state
Students could also try different techniqueStudents could also try different technique
and loot at tissues from perspective thatand loot at tissues from perspective that
would be impossible during realwould be impossible during real
operations.operations.
SURGICAL PLANNINGSURGICAL PLANNING
 In traditional surgery planning, the surgeon calculatesIn traditional surgery planning, the surgeon calculates
various parameters and procedure for surgery from hisvarious parameters and procedure for surgery from his
earlier experience and imaginationearlier experience and imagination
 The surgeon does not have an exact idea about theThe surgeon does not have an exact idea about the
result of the surgery after it has been performed.result of the surgery after it has been performed. So theSo the
result of the surgery depends mainly on human factorsresult of the surgery depends mainly on human factors
 This leads to lots of errors and even to the riskThis leads to lots of errors and even to the risk
of losing the life of the patientsof losing the life of the patients
examplesexamples
minimally invasive neurosurgicalminimally invasive neurosurgical
procedures.procedures.
craniofacial surgery.craniofacial surgery.
Liver resection on a 3D deformable liverLiver resection on a 3D deformable liver
model with aid of a virtual laparoscopicmodel with aid of a virtual laparoscopic
tooltool
 If we want something to come to an abrupt stopIf we want something to come to an abrupt stop
that is in the case of bone , etc it requires athat is in the case of bone , etc it requires a
higher update rates than bumping intohigher update rates than bumping into
something a little squishy like skin, liver etc.something a little squishy like skin, liver etc.
 But still, simulating squish is no easy task either.But still, simulating squish is no easy task either.
The number of collision point between a virtualThe number of collision point between a virtual
squishy object and a virtual instrument is largersquishy object and a virtual instrument is larger
and more variable than between a virtual rigidand more variable than between a virtual rigid
object and an instrument.object and an instrument.
‘‘The virtual reality technology can serve asThe virtual reality technology can serve as
useful adjunctuseful adjunct to traditional surgicalto traditional surgical
planning techniques.planning techniques.
3D reconstruction of important anatomical3D reconstruction of important anatomical
structuresstructures
complex anatomical relationships incomplex anatomical relationships in
specific patientspecific patient prior to surgery and also toprior to surgery and also to
examine and display the microsurgicalexamine and display the microsurgical
anatomy of various internal operations.anatomy of various internal operations.
IMAGE GUIDANCEIMAGE GUIDANCE
computer-aided surgery.computer-aided surgery.
integration ofintegration of
Advanced imaging
3D graphicsimage processing
application of computationalapplication of computational
algorithm and VR visualizationalgorithm and VR visualization
Diagnostic imaging
intraoperative surgical navigation
preoperative surgical planning
Navigation in surgeryNavigation in surgery
stereotactic principlesstereotactic principles
ability to locate a given point usingability to locate a given point using
geometric referencegeometric reference
Used till now in neurosurgery and RoboticUsed till now in neurosurgery and Robotic
SurgerySurgery
‘‘X-ray vision’ of surgeonX-ray vision’ of surgeon
intra operative mapping of 3D imageintra operative mapping of 3D image
overlays on live videooverlays on live video
used in conjunction with an open MRIused in conjunction with an open MRI
scanscan
updates of patient’s position and intraupdates of patient’s position and intra
operative shape changes in soft tissuesoperative shape changes in soft tissues
with in reasonable time frame.with in reasonable time frame.
TELESURGERYTELESURGERY
 allows surgeons to operate on people who areallows surgeons to operate on people who are
physically separated from themselves.physically separated from themselves.
 master-slave robotmaster-slave robot
 video cameras configured to provide avideo cameras configured to provide a
stereoscopic viewstereoscopic view
 surgeon relies on a 3D virtual representation ofsurgeon relies on a 3D virtual representation of
the patientthe patient
 successful in humans undergoing endoscopicsuccessful in humans undergoing endoscopic
Coronary Artery Bypass graftingCoronary Artery Bypass grafting
 basic vascular and urologic procedures inbasic vascular and urologic procedures in
swinesswines
VIRTUAL REALITY APPLICATIONS IN SURGERY
TRAINING AND EDUCATION
SURGICAL PLANNING
IMAGE GUIDANCE
TELESURGERY
IMPORTANCE OF VIRTUALIMPORTANCE OF VIRTUAL
REALITY IN SURGICAL FIELDREALITY IN SURGICAL FIELD
Intelligent computer backup minimizes theIntelligent computer backup minimizes the
number of medical ‘mistakes’number of medical ‘mistakes’
More effective use of minimal-accessMore effective use of minimal-access
surgical techniquesurgical technique
Better training in anatomy and surgicalBetter training in anatomy and surgical
skill, with reduced need for cadavers.skill, with reduced need for cadavers.
current limitations of VRcurrent limitations of VR
implementationimplementation
 shortcomings in the realism ofshortcomings in the realism of
the simulations.the simulations.
 cost and processing power ofcost and processing power of
available hardware.available hardware.
 Need to improve human-Need to improve human-
computer interfacescomputer interfaces
 problem of time delays in theproblem of time delays in the
simulator’s response to thesimulator’s response to the
users movementsusers movements
 Simulator sicknessSimulator sickness eyestrain,eyestrain,
nausea, loss of balance andnausea, loss of balance and
disorientationdisorientation
CONCLUSIONCONCLUSION
 A recent report released by Institute of Medicine inA recent report released by Institute of Medicine in
Washington DC, estimates thatWashington DC, estimates that medical errors maymedical errors may
cause 1,00,000 patient deaths each year in US alonecause 1,00,000 patient deaths each year in US alone
 Proponent of virtual reality believes that incorporation ofProponent of virtual reality believes that incorporation of
this technology into medical training will bring this grimthis technology into medical training will bring this grim
statistic downstatistic down..
 the benefits of VR systems in medicines have clearlythe benefits of VR systems in medicines have clearly
been established in several areas, including improvedbeen established in several areas, including improved
training, better access to services, and increase costtraining, better access to services, and increase cost
effectiveness and accuracy in performing certaineffectiveness and accuracy in performing certain
conventional surgical procedures.conventional surgical procedures.
Thank youThank you

More Related Content

What's hot

Robotic Surgery PPT
Robotic Surgery PPTRobotic Surgery PPT
Robotic Surgery PPT
Sai Charan
 
Robotics in surgery by DR.Mahipal reddy
Robotics in surgery  by DR.Mahipal reddyRobotics in surgery  by DR.Mahipal reddy
Robotics in surgery by DR.Mahipal reddy
mahipal33
 
Laparoscopy instruments
Laparoscopy instrumentsLaparoscopy instruments
Laparoscopy instruments
abestinst
 

What's hot (20)

Robotic Surgery
Robotic SurgeryRobotic Surgery
Robotic Surgery
 
Robotic surgery
Robotic surgeryRobotic surgery
Robotic surgery
 
Principles in Electrosurgery
Principles in ElectrosurgeryPrinciples in Electrosurgery
Principles in Electrosurgery
 
ROBOTIC SURGERY
ROBOTIC SURGERYROBOTIC SURGERY
ROBOTIC SURGERY
 
Robotic surgery presentation
Robotic surgery presentationRobotic surgery presentation
Robotic surgery presentation
 
Indocyanine green (ICG) in liver surgery.pptx
Indocyanine green (ICG) in liver surgery.pptxIndocyanine green (ICG) in liver surgery.pptx
Indocyanine green (ICG) in liver surgery.pptx
 
Robotic Surgery PPT
Robotic Surgery PPTRobotic Surgery PPT
Robotic Surgery PPT
 
Robotics in surgery by DR.Mahipal reddy
Robotics in surgery  by DR.Mahipal reddyRobotics in surgery  by DR.Mahipal reddy
Robotics in surgery by DR.Mahipal reddy
 
Energy sources in surgery
Energy sources in surgeryEnergy sources in surgery
Energy sources in surgery
 
Electrosurgical unit
Electrosurgical unitElectrosurgical unit
Electrosurgical unit
 
Robotic surgery
Robotic surgeryRobotic surgery
Robotic surgery
 
Staplers in Surgery
Staplers in SurgeryStaplers in Surgery
Staplers in Surgery
 
Laparoscopy instruments
Laparoscopy instrumentsLaparoscopy instruments
Laparoscopy instruments
 
Laparoscopic instruments and Ergonomics
Laparoscopic instruments and ErgonomicsLaparoscopic instruments and Ergonomics
Laparoscopic instruments and Ergonomics
 
Basics of laparoscopic surgery.pptx
Basics of laparoscopic surgery.pptxBasics of laparoscopic surgery.pptx
Basics of laparoscopic surgery.pptx
 
Notes presentation
Notes presentationNotes presentation
Notes presentation
 
Laparoscopy instruments
Laparoscopy instrumentsLaparoscopy instruments
Laparoscopy instruments
 
PCNL - the Perfect Puncture
PCNL - the Perfect PuncturePCNL - the Perfect Puncture
PCNL - the Perfect Puncture
 
Robotic surgery
Robotic  surgeryRobotic  surgery
Robotic surgery
 
Robot assisted surgery 05.05.2021
Robot assisted surgery 05.05.2021Robot assisted surgery 05.05.2021
Robot assisted surgery 05.05.2021
 

Viewers also liked

VR in Education
VR in Education VR in Education
VR in Education
yyao
 
Reimagine Education - Virtual Reality and Laboratory Simulations
Reimagine Education - Virtual Reality and Laboratory SimulationsReimagine Education - Virtual Reality and Laboratory Simulations
Reimagine Education - Virtual Reality and Laboratory Simulations
Michael Jensen
 
planning systems in radiotherapy
 planning systems in radiotherapy planning systems in radiotherapy
planning systems in radiotherapy
fondas vakalis
 

Viewers also liked (16)

Simulation PowerPoint
Simulation PowerPointSimulation PowerPoint
Simulation PowerPoint
 
VR in Education to ARNY Oct. 25th, 2016
VR in Education to ARNY Oct. 25th, 2016VR in Education to ARNY Oct. 25th, 2016
VR in Education to ARNY Oct. 25th, 2016
 
VR in Education
VR in Education VR in Education
VR in Education
 
Reimagine Education - Virtual Reality and Laboratory Simulations
Reimagine Education - Virtual Reality and Laboratory SimulationsReimagine Education - Virtual Reality and Laboratory Simulations
Reimagine Education - Virtual Reality and Laboratory Simulations
 
importance of ct-simulator in radiotherapy
importance of ct-simulator in radiotherapyimportance of ct-simulator in radiotherapy
importance of ct-simulator in radiotherapy
 
Vr for education in korea conception and case
Vr for education in korea   conception and caseVr for education in korea   conception and case
Vr for education in korea conception and case
 
Virtual Reality and Augmented Reality in Education
Virtual Reality and Augmented Reality in EducationVirtual Reality and Augmented Reality in Education
Virtual Reality and Augmented Reality in Education
 
Radiotherapy Treatment Simulation
Radiotherapy Treatment SimulationRadiotherapy Treatment Simulation
Radiotherapy Treatment Simulation
 
Cobalt 60
Cobalt 60Cobalt 60
Cobalt 60
 
VR in Education: How Virtual Reality Can Impact Learning
VR in Education: How Virtual Reality Can Impact LearningVR in Education: How Virtual Reality Can Impact Learning
VR in Education: How Virtual Reality Can Impact Learning
 
PET CT
PET CTPET CT
PET CT
 
x ray machine ppt
x ray machine pptx ray machine ppt
x ray machine ppt
 
Is Virtual Reality Ready for the Classroom?
Is Virtual Reality Ready for the Classroom?Is Virtual Reality Ready for the Classroom?
Is Virtual Reality Ready for the Classroom?
 
planning systems in radiotherapy
 planning systems in radiotherapy planning systems in radiotherapy
planning systems in radiotherapy
 
Virtual Reality
Virtual RealityVirtual Reality
Virtual Reality
 
The Emerging Virtual Reality Landscape: a Primer
The Emerging Virtual Reality Landscape: a PrimerThe Emerging Virtual Reality Landscape: a Primer
The Emerging Virtual Reality Landscape: a Primer
 

Similar to virtual simulation

Air Products Final Poster.
Air Products Final Poster.Air Products Final Poster.
Air Products Final Poster.
Fernando Caralt
 
Medical Handsfree System - Project Paper
Medical Handsfree System - Project PaperMedical Handsfree System - Project Paper
Medical Handsfree System - Project Paper
Guy Peleg
 

Similar to virtual simulation (20)

Virtual surgery [new].ppt
Virtual surgery [new].pptVirtual surgery [new].ppt
Virtual surgery [new].ppt
 
virtual surgery
virtual surgeryvirtual surgery
virtual surgery
 
Virtual Reality (bring distant near)
Virtual Reality (bring distant near)Virtual Reality (bring distant near)
Virtual Reality (bring distant near)
 
Introduction
IntroductionIntroduction
Introduction
 
Principles of Virtual Reality In Surgical Training - Review by Sanjoy Sanyal
Principles of Virtual Reality In Surgical Training - Review by Sanjoy SanyalPrinciples of Virtual Reality In Surgical Training - Review by Sanjoy Sanyal
Principles of Virtual Reality In Surgical Training - Review by Sanjoy Sanyal
 
HAPTIC SUIT- Project Report(2018)
HAPTIC SUIT- Project Report(2018)HAPTIC SUIT- Project Report(2018)
HAPTIC SUIT- Project Report(2018)
 
A Simulation Method of Soft Tissue Cutting In Virtual Environment with Haptics
A Simulation Method of Soft Tissue Cutting In Virtual Environment with HapticsA Simulation Method of Soft Tissue Cutting In Virtual Environment with Haptics
A Simulation Method of Soft Tissue Cutting In Virtual Environment with Haptics
 
HAPTIC_TECH ppt final.pptx
HAPTIC_TECH ppt final.pptxHAPTIC_TECH ppt final.pptx
HAPTIC_TECH ppt final.pptx
 
Air Products Final Poster.
Air Products Final Poster.Air Products Final Poster.
Air Products Final Poster.
 
GSR_PhobiAR_04
GSR_PhobiAR_04GSR_PhobiAR_04
GSR_PhobiAR_04
 
VR simulations for neurosurgery
VR simulations for neurosurgeryVR simulations for neurosurgery
VR simulations for neurosurgery
 
Robotics and simulation in neurosurgery
Robotics and simulation in neurosurgeryRobotics and simulation in neurosurgery
Robotics and simulation in neurosurgery
 
Cg ptu assigement
Cg ptu assigementCg ptu assigement
Cg ptu assigement
 
B04540914
B04540914B04540914
B04540914
 
Visual reality
Visual realityVisual reality
Visual reality
 
Mems sensors controlled haptic forefinger robotic aid
Mems sensors controlled haptic forefinger robotic aidMems sensors controlled haptic forefinger robotic aid
Mems sensors controlled haptic forefinger robotic aid
 
HAPTICS
HAPTICSHAPTICS
HAPTICS
 
Haptic technology
 Haptic technology Haptic technology
Haptic technology
 
Medical Handsfree System - Project Paper
Medical Handsfree System - Project PaperMedical Handsfree System - Project Paper
Medical Handsfree System - Project Paper
 
Virtual Reality
Virtual RealityVirtual Reality
Virtual Reality
 

More from Sumer Yadav

More from Sumer Yadav (20)

Peripheral vascular disease and Clinical features of acute and chronic arteri...
Peripheral vascular disease and Clinical features of acute and chronic arteri...Peripheral vascular disease and Clinical features of acute and chronic arteri...
Peripheral vascular disease and Clinical features of acute and chronic arteri...
 
Oral precancerous lesions and anatomy of oral cavity
Oral precancerous lesions and anatomy of oral cavityOral precancerous lesions and anatomy of oral cavity
Oral precancerous lesions and anatomy of oral cavity
 
Malignancies of Oral Cavity, Lip, Tongue
Malignancies of Oral Cavity, Lip, TongueMalignancies of Oral Cavity, Lip, Tongue
Malignancies of Oral Cavity, Lip, Tongue
 
Neck mass differential diagnosis
Neck mass differential diagnosisNeck mass differential diagnosis
Neck mass differential diagnosis
 
Cleft lip and palate
Cleft lip and palate Cleft lip and palate
Cleft lip and palate
 
Classification of arterial disease and invstigations
Classification of  arterial disease and invstigationsClassification of  arterial disease and invstigations
Classification of arterial disease and invstigations
 
Cervical lymph adenopathy
Cervical lymph adenopathyCervical lymph adenopathy
Cervical lymph adenopathy
 
Carcinoma buccal mucosa
Carcinoma buccal mucosaCarcinoma buccal mucosa
Carcinoma buccal mucosa
 
Aneurysm and av fistula
Aneurysm and av fistulaAneurysm and av fistula
Aneurysm and av fistula
 
salivary gland neoplasm
 salivary gland neoplasm salivary gland neoplasm
salivary gland neoplasm
 
Acute limb ischaemia
Acute limb ischaemiaAcute limb ischaemia
Acute limb ischaemia
 
radial nerve palsy
radial nerve palsy radial nerve palsy
radial nerve palsy
 
scar management - nonsurgical
scar management - nonsurgicalscar management - nonsurgical
scar management - nonsurgical
 
common congenital deformities of hand
common congenital deformities of handcommon congenital deformities of hand
common congenital deformities of hand
 
gastrocnemius flap
 gastrocnemius flap gastrocnemius flap
gastrocnemius flap
 
extensor tendons injury and deformity
extensor tendons injury and deformityextensor tendons injury and deformity
extensor tendons injury and deformity
 
lip reconstruction
 lip reconstruction lip reconstruction
lip reconstruction
 
secondary deformities of cleft LIP AND NOSE
secondary deformities of cleft LIP AND NOSEsecondary deformities of cleft LIP AND NOSE
secondary deformities of cleft LIP AND NOSE
 
fractures of hand bones
fractures of hand bonesfractures of hand bones
fractures of hand bones
 
nasal reconstruction
nasal reconstructionnasal reconstruction
nasal reconstruction
 

Recently uploaded

Alcohol_Dr. Jeenal Mistry MD Pharmacology.pdf
Alcohol_Dr. Jeenal Mistry MD Pharmacology.pdfAlcohol_Dr. Jeenal Mistry MD Pharmacology.pdf
Alcohol_Dr. Jeenal Mistry MD Pharmacology.pdf
Dr Jeenal Mistry
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Gauri Gawande(9) Constipation Final.pptx
Gauri Gawande(9) Constipation Final.pptxGauri Gawande(9) Constipation Final.pptx
Gauri Gawande(9) Constipation Final.pptx
 
linearity concept of significance, standard deviation, chi square test, stude...
linearity concept of significance, standard deviation, chi square test, stude...linearity concept of significance, standard deviation, chi square test, stude...
linearity concept of significance, standard deviation, chi square test, stude...
 
Non-Invasive assessment of arterial stiffness in advanced heart failure patie...
Non-Invasive assessment of arterial stiffness in advanced heart failure patie...Non-Invasive assessment of arterial stiffness in advanced heart failure patie...
Non-Invasive assessment of arterial stiffness in advanced heart failure patie...
 
𝕔ALL #𝕘IRLS Service in Jaipur %(8901183002)# Jaipur #𝕔ALL #𝕘IRLS
𝕔ALL #𝕘IRLS Service in Jaipur %(8901183002)#  Jaipur #𝕔ALL #𝕘IRLS𝕔ALL #𝕘IRLS Service in Jaipur %(8901183002)#  Jaipur #𝕔ALL #𝕘IRLS
𝕔ALL #𝕘IRLS Service in Jaipur %(8901183002)# Jaipur #𝕔ALL #𝕘IRLS
 
DECIPHERING COMMON ECG FINDINGS IN ED.pptx
DECIPHERING COMMON ECG FINDINGS IN ED.pptxDECIPHERING COMMON ECG FINDINGS IN ED.pptx
DECIPHERING COMMON ECG FINDINGS IN ED.pptx
 
Hemodialysis: Chapter 2, Extracorporeal Blood Circuit - Dr.Gawad
Hemodialysis: Chapter 2, Extracorporeal Blood Circuit - Dr.GawadHemodialysis: Chapter 2, Extracorporeal Blood Circuit - Dr.Gawad
Hemodialysis: Chapter 2, Extracorporeal Blood Circuit - Dr.Gawad
 
Antiplatelets in IHD, Dose Duration, DAPT vs SAPT
Antiplatelets in IHD, Dose Duration, DAPT vs SAPTAntiplatelets in IHD, Dose Duration, DAPT vs SAPT
Antiplatelets in IHD, Dose Duration, DAPT vs SAPT
 
ANATOMY OF THE LOWER URINARY TRACT AND MALE [Autosaved] [Autosaved].pptx
ANATOMY OF THE LOWER URINARY TRACT AND MALE [Autosaved] [Autosaved].pptxANATOMY OF THE LOWER URINARY TRACT AND MALE [Autosaved] [Autosaved].pptx
ANATOMY OF THE LOWER URINARY TRACT AND MALE [Autosaved] [Autosaved].pptx
 
DIGITAL RADIOGRAPHY-SABBU KHATOON .pptx
DIGITAL RADIOGRAPHY-SABBU KHATOON  .pptxDIGITAL RADIOGRAPHY-SABBU KHATOON  .pptx
DIGITAL RADIOGRAPHY-SABBU KHATOON .pptx
 
Book Trailer: PGMEE in a Nutshell (CEE MD/MS PG Entrance Examination)
Book Trailer: PGMEE in a Nutshell (CEE MD/MS PG Entrance Examination)Book Trailer: PGMEE in a Nutshell (CEE MD/MS PG Entrance Examination)
Book Trailer: PGMEE in a Nutshell (CEE MD/MS PG Entrance Examination)
 
TEST BANK For Williams' Essentials of Nutrition and Diet Therapy, 13th Editio...
TEST BANK For Williams' Essentials of Nutrition and Diet Therapy, 13th Editio...TEST BANK For Williams' Essentials of Nutrition and Diet Therapy, 13th Editio...
TEST BANK For Williams' Essentials of Nutrition and Diet Therapy, 13th Editio...
 
A thorough review of supernormal conduction.pptx
A thorough review of supernormal conduction.pptxA thorough review of supernormal conduction.pptx
A thorough review of supernormal conduction.pptx
 
Impact of cancers therapies on the loss in cardiac function, myocardial fffic...
Impact of cancers therapies on the loss in cardiac function, myocardial fffic...Impact of cancers therapies on the loss in cardiac function, myocardial fffic...
Impact of cancers therapies on the loss in cardiac function, myocardial fffic...
 
The POPPY STUDY (Preconception to post-partum cardiovascular function in prim...
The POPPY STUDY (Preconception to post-partum cardiovascular function in prim...The POPPY STUDY (Preconception to post-partum cardiovascular function in prim...
The POPPY STUDY (Preconception to post-partum cardiovascular function in prim...
 
1130525--家醫計畫2.0糖尿病照護研討會-社團法人高雄市醫師公會.pdf
1130525--家醫計畫2.0糖尿病照護研討會-社團法人高雄市醫師公會.pdf1130525--家醫計畫2.0糖尿病照護研討會-社團法人高雄市醫師公會.pdf
1130525--家醫計畫2.0糖尿病照護研討會-社團法人高雄市醫師公會.pdf
 
The hemodynamic and autonomic determinants of elevated blood pressure in obes...
The hemodynamic and autonomic determinants of elevated blood pressure in obes...The hemodynamic and autonomic determinants of elevated blood pressure in obes...
The hemodynamic and autonomic determinants of elevated blood pressure in obes...
 
Temporal, Infratemporal & Pterygopalatine BY Dr.RIG.pptx
Temporal, Infratemporal & Pterygopalatine BY Dr.RIG.pptxTemporal, Infratemporal & Pterygopalatine BY Dr.RIG.pptx
Temporal, Infratemporal & Pterygopalatine BY Dr.RIG.pptx
 
Alcohol_Dr. Jeenal Mistry MD Pharmacology.pdf
Alcohol_Dr. Jeenal Mistry MD Pharmacology.pdfAlcohol_Dr. Jeenal Mistry MD Pharmacology.pdf
Alcohol_Dr. Jeenal Mistry MD Pharmacology.pdf
 
Young at heart: Cardiovascular health stations to empower healthy lifestyle b...
Young at heart: Cardiovascular health stations to empower healthy lifestyle b...Young at heart: Cardiovascular health stations to empower healthy lifestyle b...
Young at heart: Cardiovascular health stations to empower healthy lifestyle b...
 
Compare home pulse pressure components collected directly from home
Compare home pulse pressure components collected directly from homeCompare home pulse pressure components collected directly from home
Compare home pulse pressure components collected directly from home
 

virtual simulation

  • 1. Virtual reality simulation in SURGERYVirtual reality simulation in SURGERY Dr sumer yadavDr sumer yadav
  • 2. What isWhat is virtual realityvirtual reality ??  Virtual realityVirtual reality ((VRVR)) is a technology whichis a technology which allows a user toallows a user to interact with ainteract with a computer-simulatedcomputer-simulated environment, whetherenvironment, whether that environment is athat environment is a simulation of the realsimulation of the real world or an imaginaryworld or an imaginary world.world.
  • 3. simulation network communication full-body immersion telepresence immersion artificiality interaction Components of virtual reality
  • 4. What isWhat is simulationsimulation ??  SimulationSimulation is theis the imitationimitation of some real thing.of some real thing.  UsesUses  1. natural systems or human systems in order to1. natural systems or human systems in order to gain insight into their functioning.gain insight into their functioning.  2. Testing2. Testing  3.Training3.Training  4. Education4. Education  5.Simulation of technology for performance5.Simulation of technology for performance optimizationoptimization  6. Video games6. Video games
  • 5.
  • 6. What isWhat is Virtual surgeryVirtual surgery ?? virtual reality simulation of surgicalvirtual reality simulation of surgical procedures.procedures. analog for the actual surgery whereanalog for the actual surgery where doctors can practice on a virtual patientdoctors can practice on a virtual patient before performing the surgery.before performing the surgery.
  • 7. Advantage to the surgeonsAdvantage to the surgeons 1.Improved surgical planning1.Improved surgical planning 2. practice surgery process on 3D2. practice surgery process on 3D modelsmodels
  • 8. VIRTUAL SURGERY SIMULATIONVIRTUAL SURGERY SIMULATION 2 STEPS 3D IMAGE SIMULATION TOUCH SIMULATION
  • 9. 3D IMAGE SIMULATION3D IMAGE SIMULATION  generate a 3D modelgenerate a 3D model of the part of the bodyof the part of the body that undergoesthat undergoes surgery.surgery.  first construct afirst construct a reference model of areference model of a normal person.normal person.
  • 10.  anatomical images cananatomical images can be derived from a seriesbe derived from a series of patient’s Magneticof patient’s Magnetic Resonance ImagesResonance Images (MRI), Computed(MRI), Computed Tomography (CT) orTomography (CT) or video recording, whichvideo recording, which are 2D images. Theseare 2D images. These images are segmentedimages are segmented using varioususing various segmentation methodssegmentation methods
  • 11.  final model is obtained byfinal model is obtained by deforming the reference modeldeforming the reference model according to the condition ofaccording to the condition of organ that is operated upon.organ that is operated upon.  The image is digitally mappedThe image is digitally mapped on to theon to the polygonal meshpolygonal mesh representing whatever part ofrepresenting whatever part of the body on organ is beingthe body on organ is being examined. Each vortex of theexamined. Each vortex of the polygon is assigned attributespolygon is assigned attributes like colour and reflectivity fromlike colour and reflectivity from the reference model.the reference model.
  • 12.  software algorithmssoftware algorithms that canthat can calculate the whereabouts ofcalculate the whereabouts of the virtual instrument andthe virtual instrument and determines whether it hasdetermines whether it has collide with a body part orcollide with a body part or anything else.anything else.  algorithms to solvealgorithms to solve how ithow it looks or behave when thelooks or behave when the body part is cutbody part is cut. We need. We need models of how various tissuesmodels of how various tissues behave when cut, prodded,behave when cut, prodded, punctured and so on.punctured and so on.
  • 13. The parameters of this model can then beThe parameters of this model can then be tweakedtweaked to match what a surgeonto match what a surgeon experiences during an actual procedure.experiences during an actual procedure. To create graphic that move withoutTo create graphic that move without flickering collision detection and tissueflickering collision detection and tissue deformation must be calculated at least 30deformation must be calculated at least 30 times/sec.times/sec.
  • 14. whole-body voxel humanwhole-body voxel human modelsmodels  Whole-bodyWhole-body voxelvoxel humanhuman models depict the shapemodels depict the shape of the human bodyof the human body (tissues and organs) as(tissues and organs) as an aggregate of minutean aggregate of minute elements. Each minuteelements. Each minute block, or voxel, is labeledblock, or voxel, is labeled with a tag representingwith a tag representing the name of a tissue orthe name of a tissue or an organ such as musclean organ such as muscle or fat, and assigned withor fat, and assigned with the electrical, physicalthe electrical, physical properties and color ofproperties and color of the respectivethe respective tissue/organ.tissue/organ.
  • 15. TOUCH SIMULATIONTOUCH SIMULATION hapticshaptics = the ability to simulate touch= the ability to simulate touch Physicians rely a great deal on their sensePhysicians rely a great deal on their sense of touch for everything from routineof touch for everything from routine diagnosis to complex, life saving surgicaldiagnosis to complex, life saving surgical procedure. So haptics, or the ability toprocedure. So haptics, or the ability to simulate touch, goes a long way to makesimulate touch, goes a long way to make virtual reality simulators more life like.virtual reality simulators more life like.
  • 16.   While the brain can be tricked into seeingWhile the brain can be tricked into seeing seamless motion by flipping through 30 orseamless motion by flipping through 30 or so images per second, touch signals needso images per second, touch signals need to be refreshed up to once a millisecondto be refreshed up to once a millisecond   The precise rate at which a computerThe precise rate at which a computer must update a haptic interface variesmust update a haptic interface varies depending on what type of virtual surfacedepending on what type of virtual surface is encounteredis encountered
  • 17. soft object require lower update rates thansoft object require lower update rates than harder objectsharder objects Why??Why?? A low update rate may not prevent a usersA low update rate may not prevent a users surgical instrument fromsurgical instrument from sinking into thesinking into the virtual fleshvirtual flesh, but in soft tissues that sinking, but in soft tissues that sinking is what is expected.is what is expected.
  • 18. Most difficult to simulate is two floppyMost difficult to simulate is two floppy objects interacting with each other-suchobjects interacting with each other-such as colon and sigmoidocope, the longas colon and sigmoidocope, the long bendable probe used to view the colon-bendable probe used to view the colon- because of multiple collision point. Inbecause of multiple collision point. In addition, the mechanics of such interactionaddition, the mechanics of such interaction are complicated, because each objectare complicated, because each object may deform the other.may deform the other.
  • 19. simulating touch sensationsimulating touch sensation  calculate the forces applied to cut, probed,calculate the forces applied to cut, probed, puncture the various tissues.puncture the various tissues.  Also how they react or behave when cut,Also how they react or behave when cut, probed, punctured using surgical instruments.probed, punctured using surgical instruments.  First we have to make physical models ofFirst we have to make physical models of various tissues. The major difficulty in modelingvarious tissues. The major difficulty in modeling organs is the physical behavior as they have allorgans is the physical behavior as they have all kinds of complexities-they are anisotropic, nonkinds of complexities-they are anisotropic, non homogeneous and nonlinear.homogeneous and nonlinear.
  • 20.  If the haptic device is to give a realistic impression of sayIf the haptic device is to give a realistic impression of say pressing the skin on a patient’s arm, the mechanicalpressing the skin on a patient’s arm, the mechanical contributions of the skin, the fatty tissue benefit, musclecontributions of the skin, the fatty tissue benefit, muscle and even bone must be summed up.and even bone must be summed up.  The equations to solve such a complex problem areThe equations to solve such a complex problem are known, but so far the calculations cannot be made fastknown, but so far the calculations cannot be made fast enough to update a display at 30Hz, let alone update aenough to update a display at 30Hz, let alone update a haptic interface at 500-1000Hz.haptic interface at 500-1000Hz.
  • 21. VIRTUAL SURGERY SIMULATOR POWERFUL PC HAPTIC INTERFACER
  • 22.
  • 23. Working principleWorking principle  force feedback loop.force feedback loop.
  • 24. Advantage to the surgeonAdvantage to the surgeon  Surgeons improve surgery plans and practice surgery process on 3DSurgeons improve surgery plans and practice surgery process on 3D models.models.  Pre operative evaluation of results.Pre operative evaluation of results.  Error correction - repeat the surgical procedure as many number of timesError correction - repeat the surgical procedure as many number of times  Better anatomical picture of procedure – wide angles availableBetter anatomical picture of procedure – wide angles available  Familiarity with actual procedureFamiliarity with actual procedure
  • 25. VIRTUAL REALITY APPLICATIONS IN SURGERY TRAINING AND EDUCATION SURGICAL PLANNING IMAGE GUIDANCE TELESURGERY
  • 26. TRAINING AND EDUCATIONTRAINING AND EDUCATION  Surgeon must be ready to manage potentially life-Surgeon must be ready to manage potentially life- threatening situations in dynamic, unpredictablethreatening situations in dynamic, unpredictable environments.environments. Traditional teaching textbook images cadavers
  • 27. DisadvantageDisadvantage  textbook images, limit one’stextbook images, limit one’s perspective of anatomicalperspective of anatomical structures to 2D planestructures to 2D plane  cadavers; limited in supply andcadavers; limited in supply and generally allowing one-timegenerally allowing one-time use only.use only.
  • 28. Advantage of VR simulatorAdvantage of VR simulator  view the anatomy from a wide range of anglesview the anatomy from a wide range of angles and “fly through” organs to examine bodies fromand “fly through” organs to examine bodies from inside. The experience can be highly interactiveinside. The experience can be highly interactive allowing students to strip away the variousallowing students to strip away the various layers of tissues and muscles to examine eachlayers of tissues and muscles to examine each organ separately.organ separately.  Unlike cadavers, VR models enable the user toUnlike cadavers, VR models enable the user to perform a procedure countless times.perform a procedure countless times.
  • 29. It is interactive.It is interactive. An instructor presence is not necessaryAn instructor presence is not necessary Changes can be made that demonstrateChanges can be made that demonstrate variation in anatomy or disease statevariation in anatomy or disease state Students could also try different techniqueStudents could also try different technique and loot at tissues from perspective thatand loot at tissues from perspective that would be impossible during realwould be impossible during real operations.operations.
  • 30. SURGICAL PLANNINGSURGICAL PLANNING  In traditional surgery planning, the surgeon calculatesIn traditional surgery planning, the surgeon calculates various parameters and procedure for surgery from hisvarious parameters and procedure for surgery from his earlier experience and imaginationearlier experience and imagination  The surgeon does not have an exact idea about theThe surgeon does not have an exact idea about the result of the surgery after it has been performed.result of the surgery after it has been performed. So theSo the result of the surgery depends mainly on human factorsresult of the surgery depends mainly on human factors  This leads to lots of errors and even to the riskThis leads to lots of errors and even to the risk of losing the life of the patientsof losing the life of the patients
  • 31. examplesexamples minimally invasive neurosurgicalminimally invasive neurosurgical procedures.procedures. craniofacial surgery.craniofacial surgery. Liver resection on a 3D deformable liverLiver resection on a 3D deformable liver model with aid of a virtual laparoscopicmodel with aid of a virtual laparoscopic tooltool
  • 32.  If we want something to come to an abrupt stopIf we want something to come to an abrupt stop that is in the case of bone , etc it requires athat is in the case of bone , etc it requires a higher update rates than bumping intohigher update rates than bumping into something a little squishy like skin, liver etc.something a little squishy like skin, liver etc.  But still, simulating squish is no easy task either.But still, simulating squish is no easy task either. The number of collision point between a virtualThe number of collision point between a virtual squishy object and a virtual instrument is largersquishy object and a virtual instrument is larger and more variable than between a virtual rigidand more variable than between a virtual rigid object and an instrument.object and an instrument.
  • 33. ‘‘The virtual reality technology can serve asThe virtual reality technology can serve as useful adjunctuseful adjunct to traditional surgicalto traditional surgical planning techniques.planning techniques. 3D reconstruction of important anatomical3D reconstruction of important anatomical structuresstructures complex anatomical relationships incomplex anatomical relationships in specific patientspecific patient prior to surgery and also toprior to surgery and also to examine and display the microsurgicalexamine and display the microsurgical anatomy of various internal operations.anatomy of various internal operations.
  • 34. IMAGE GUIDANCEIMAGE GUIDANCE computer-aided surgery.computer-aided surgery. integration ofintegration of Advanced imaging 3D graphicsimage processing
  • 35. application of computationalapplication of computational algorithm and VR visualizationalgorithm and VR visualization Diagnostic imaging intraoperative surgical navigation preoperative surgical planning
  • 36. Navigation in surgeryNavigation in surgery stereotactic principlesstereotactic principles ability to locate a given point usingability to locate a given point using geometric referencegeometric reference Used till now in neurosurgery and RoboticUsed till now in neurosurgery and Robotic SurgerySurgery
  • 37. ‘‘X-ray vision’ of surgeonX-ray vision’ of surgeon intra operative mapping of 3D imageintra operative mapping of 3D image overlays on live videooverlays on live video used in conjunction with an open MRIused in conjunction with an open MRI scanscan updates of patient’s position and intraupdates of patient’s position and intra operative shape changes in soft tissuesoperative shape changes in soft tissues with in reasonable time frame.with in reasonable time frame.
  • 38. TELESURGERYTELESURGERY  allows surgeons to operate on people who areallows surgeons to operate on people who are physically separated from themselves.physically separated from themselves.  master-slave robotmaster-slave robot  video cameras configured to provide avideo cameras configured to provide a stereoscopic viewstereoscopic view  surgeon relies on a 3D virtual representation ofsurgeon relies on a 3D virtual representation of the patientthe patient  successful in humans undergoing endoscopicsuccessful in humans undergoing endoscopic Coronary Artery Bypass graftingCoronary Artery Bypass grafting  basic vascular and urologic procedures inbasic vascular and urologic procedures in swinesswines
  • 39. VIRTUAL REALITY APPLICATIONS IN SURGERY TRAINING AND EDUCATION SURGICAL PLANNING IMAGE GUIDANCE TELESURGERY
  • 40. IMPORTANCE OF VIRTUALIMPORTANCE OF VIRTUAL REALITY IN SURGICAL FIELDREALITY IN SURGICAL FIELD Intelligent computer backup minimizes theIntelligent computer backup minimizes the number of medical ‘mistakes’number of medical ‘mistakes’ More effective use of minimal-accessMore effective use of minimal-access surgical techniquesurgical technique Better training in anatomy and surgicalBetter training in anatomy and surgical skill, with reduced need for cadavers.skill, with reduced need for cadavers.
  • 41. current limitations of VRcurrent limitations of VR implementationimplementation  shortcomings in the realism ofshortcomings in the realism of the simulations.the simulations.  cost and processing power ofcost and processing power of available hardware.available hardware.  Need to improve human-Need to improve human- computer interfacescomputer interfaces  problem of time delays in theproblem of time delays in the simulator’s response to thesimulator’s response to the users movementsusers movements  Simulator sicknessSimulator sickness eyestrain,eyestrain, nausea, loss of balance andnausea, loss of balance and disorientationdisorientation
  • 42. CONCLUSIONCONCLUSION  A recent report released by Institute of Medicine inA recent report released by Institute of Medicine in Washington DC, estimates thatWashington DC, estimates that medical errors maymedical errors may cause 1,00,000 patient deaths each year in US alonecause 1,00,000 patient deaths each year in US alone  Proponent of virtual reality believes that incorporation ofProponent of virtual reality believes that incorporation of this technology into medical training will bring this grimthis technology into medical training will bring this grim statistic downstatistic down..  the benefits of VR systems in medicines have clearlythe benefits of VR systems in medicines have clearly been established in several areas, including improvedbeen established in several areas, including improved training, better access to services, and increase costtraining, better access to services, and increase cost effectiveness and accuracy in performing certaineffectiveness and accuracy in performing certain conventional surgical procedures.conventional surgical procedures.

Editor's Notes

  1. Speaker