SlideShare a Scribd company logo
SYNTHESIZING
INFORMATION FROM
RELEVANT LITERATURE
LESSON 13
What is a synthesis?
A synthesis is a discussion that draws on one or more
sources. Your ability to infer relationships among sources
such as essays, articles, fiction and also non-written sources
such as lecture, interviews and observations.
It refers to the bringing together of materials from different
sources and the creation of an integrated whole.
Types of Synthesis?
1. Explanatory Synthesis. It helps the readers to understand
a topic. Its primary aim is to present the facts in a
reasonably objective manner. Explanations given may entail
descriptions, sequences of events or state of affairs.
2. Argument synthesis. Its purpose is for you to present your
own point of view with the support of relevant facts drawn
from services and presented in a logical manner.
Categories of Sources
1. Documents
2. Numerical Records
3. Oral Statements
4. Relics
How to write a Synthesis
1. Consider your purpose in writing.
2. Select and read carefully your sources according to your purpose.
3. Formulate a thesis. It is the main ideas that you want to present in
your synthesis.
4. Decide how you will use your source material and take down notes.
5. Develop an organizational plan according to your thesis.
6. Write the first draft of your synthesis, following your organizational
plan.
7. Revise your synthesis.
Techniques for Writing a Synthesis
1. Summary – it is the simplest way of organizing a synthesis. Here you
write one after the other the most relevant information and sources
you gathered.
2. Example or illustration –it is a reference to a particular illuminating
example or illustration that you have included in your review.
3. Two (or more) reasons –this approach can be an effective method by
simply stating thesis, then give reasons why it is true. Your reasons
need to be supported by evidence from your data and sources.
4.Comparison and Contrast – These techniques will lead to examining
two subjects or data in terms of one another. Comparison considers
similarities while contrast highlights differences.
Preparing a Synthesis Matrix
The synthesis matrix is a chart that will allow you to sort and
categorize the different opinions and arguments given on
issue in relation to your study. Across the top of the chart
are the spaces to record sources and along the side of the
chart are the spaces to record the main points on the topic
being undertaken.
SYNTHESIS MATRIX FORMAT
Topic:__________________________
Label: Author’s last name and or few keywords from the title of the work.
Main Idea A Source # 1 Source # 2 Source # 3 Source # 4
Main idea B
Sample of Literature Review Synthesis
Synthesis taken from “World War Two and its Effect on Women”
◦ While the articles used in this research agree that women made many advances during
the World War II period, it is crucial to realize that not all these changes were
welcomed. In most cases women faced discrimination from just about everyone around
them. Women in the workplace were often place in positions of inferiority or treated as
being less physically able to do the same work the men did. Many women were often
not trained because they were viewed as temporary employees who were only there for
the duration of the war. (Bruley, 2003). Women were very rarely given equal pay as
men, even though some of them did the same work. Women in the military faced not
only mental abuse but also physical harm from their male counterparts. According to
Cornelsen (2005), there were many instances where female aviators were injured or
killed due to being made to fly ill-maintained aircrafts or aircrafts that had been
sabotaged.
Example of Comparison and Contrast
Student A
◦ Smith (2000) concludes that personal privacy in their living quarters is the most
important factor in nursing home residents perception of their autonomy. He
suggest that physical environment in the more public space of the building did
not have much impact on their perceptions. Neither the layout of the building,
nor the activities available seem to make much difference. Jones and Johnstone
make the claim that he need to control one’s environment is a fundamental need
of life (2001) and suggest that the approach of most institutions, which is to
provide total care may be as bad as no care at all. If people have no choices or
think that they have none, they become depresses.
Example of Comparison and Contrast
Student B
◦ After studying residents and staff from two intermediate care facilities' in Calgary,
Alberta, Smith (2000) came to the conclusion that except for the amount of personal
privacy available to the residents, the physical environment of these institutions, had
minimal, if any effect on their perceptions of control. However, French(1998) and
Haroon (2000) found that availability of private areas is not the only aspect of the
physical environment that determines residents autonomy. Haroon interviewed 115
residents from 32 different nursing homes known to have different levels of autonomy
(2000). It was found out that physical structures, such as standardized furniture, heating
that could not be individually regulated and no possession of a house key for residents
limited their feelings of independence. Moreover, Hope(2000), who interviewd 225
residents from various nursing homes, substantiates the claim that characteristics of the
institutional environment such as the extent of resources in the facility, as well as its
location are features which residents have indicated as being of great importance to
their independence.

More Related Content

What's hot

Review of related literature
Review of related literatureReview of related literature
Review of related literature
Bean Malicse
 

What's hot (20)

Lesson 11 selecting relevant literature
Lesson 11 selecting relevant literatureLesson 11 selecting relevant literature
Lesson 11 selecting relevant literature
 
Chapter 2
Chapter 2Chapter 2
Chapter 2
 
Lesson 5 writing a research title
Lesson 5 writing a research titleLesson 5 writing a research title
Lesson 5 writing a research title
 
Reaction Paper-Review-Critique Paper.pptx
Reaction Paper-Review-Critique Paper.pptxReaction Paper-Review-Critique Paper.pptx
Reaction Paper-Review-Critique Paper.pptx
 
The 3 Claims
The 3 ClaimsThe 3 Claims
The 3 Claims
 
The Philippine Literary History
The Philippine Literary HistoryThe Philippine Literary History
The Philippine Literary History
 
Writing the rrl
Writing the rrlWriting the rrl
Writing the rrl
 
10. review-of-related-literature (1)
10. review-of-related-literature (1)10. review-of-related-literature (1)
10. review-of-related-literature (1)
 
Techniques in organizing information
Techniques in organizing informationTechniques in organizing information
Techniques in organizing information
 
PRACTICAL RESEARCH 2 Modular Approach
PRACTICAL RESEARCH 2 Modular ApproachPRACTICAL RESEARCH 2 Modular Approach
PRACTICAL RESEARCH 2 Modular Approach
 
Kaugnay na pag aaral at literatura
Kaugnay na pag aaral at literaturaKaugnay na pag aaral at literatura
Kaugnay na pag aaral at literatura
 
Writing chapter 2
Writing chapter 2Writing chapter 2
Writing chapter 2
 
Literature Review Lesson Plan
Literature Review Lesson PlanLiterature Review Lesson Plan
Literature Review Lesson Plan
 
Literary approaches
Literary approachesLiterary approaches
Literary approaches
 
Chapter 4
Chapter 4Chapter 4
Chapter 4
 
Content (reading & writing)
Content (reading & writing)Content (reading & writing)
Content (reading & writing)
 
Review of related literature
Review of related literatureReview of related literature
Review of related literature
 
Creative Nonfiction Module 1.pdf
Creative Nonfiction Module 1.pdfCreative Nonfiction Module 1.pdf
Creative Nonfiction Module 1.pdf
 
Mga Bahagi at Proseso ng Pananaliksik
Mga Bahagi at Proseso ng PananaliksikMga Bahagi at Proseso ng Pananaliksik
Mga Bahagi at Proseso ng Pananaliksik
 
Practical Research 1
Practical Research 1Practical Research 1
Practical Research 1
 

Similar to Lesson 13 synthesizing information from relavant literature

1 English Composition II Social Inequality .docx
1 English Composition II Social Inequality  .docx1 English Composition II Social Inequality  .docx
1 English Composition II Social Inequality .docx
mercysuttle
 
PAGE 52What is Action ResearchViaA review of the Literat.docx
PAGE  52What is Action ResearchViaA review of the Literat.docxPAGE  52What is Action ResearchViaA review of the Literat.docx
PAGE 52What is Action ResearchViaA review of the Literat.docx
gerardkortney
 
GregorThe Nature of Theory in ISMIS Quarterly Vol. 30 No..docx
GregorThe Nature of Theory in ISMIS Quarterly Vol. 30 No..docxGregorThe Nature of Theory in ISMIS Quarterly Vol. 30 No..docx
GregorThe Nature of Theory in ISMIS Quarterly Vol. 30 No..docx
whittemorelucilla
 
Writing the Research Paper
Writing the Research PaperWriting the Research Paper
Writing the Research Paper
dalwritingcentre
 
Examine changes introduced to reform or restruct
Examine   changes   introduced   to   reform   or   restructExamine   changes   introduced   to   reform   or   restruct
Examine changes introduced to reform or restruct
BetseyCalderon89
 
Writing in SociologyA Quick ModelIntroduction1.docx
Writing in SociologyA Quick ModelIntroduction1.docxWriting in SociologyA Quick ModelIntroduction1.docx
Writing in SociologyA Quick ModelIntroduction1.docx
jeffevans62972
 
AP LanguageMrs. MathewUnit 3 Synthesis ProjectYou will .docx
AP LanguageMrs. MathewUnit 3 Synthesis ProjectYou will .docxAP LanguageMrs. MathewUnit 3 Synthesis ProjectYou will .docx
AP LanguageMrs. MathewUnit 3 Synthesis ProjectYou will .docx
jesuslightbody
 
Heider (1958) was the first to note the naïve scientist in human.docx
Heider (1958) was the first to note the naïve scientist in human.docxHeider (1958) was the first to note the naïve scientist in human.docx
Heider (1958) was the first to note the naïve scientist in human.docx
aidaclewer
 

Similar to Lesson 13 synthesizing information from relavant literature (20)

1 English Composition II Social Inequality .docx
1 English Composition II Social Inequality  .docx1 English Composition II Social Inequality  .docx
1 English Composition II Social Inequality .docx
 
PAGE 52What is Action ResearchViaA review of the Literat.docx
PAGE  52What is Action ResearchViaA review of the Literat.docxPAGE  52What is Action ResearchViaA review of the Literat.docx
PAGE 52What is Action ResearchViaA review of the Literat.docx
 
GregorThe Nature of Theory in ISMIS Quarterly Vol. 30 No..docx
GregorThe Nature of Theory in ISMIS Quarterly Vol. 30 No..docxGregorThe Nature of Theory in ISMIS Quarterly Vol. 30 No..docx
GregorThe Nature of Theory in ISMIS Quarterly Vol. 30 No..docx
 
Pierfrancesco Bresolini - Ethnography and Participant Observation
Pierfrancesco Bresolini - Ethnography and Participant ObservationPierfrancesco Bresolini - Ethnography and Participant Observation
Pierfrancesco Bresolini - Ethnography and Participant Observation
 
Writing the Research Paper
Writing the Research PaperWriting the Research Paper
Writing the Research Paper
 
Examine changes introduced to reform or restruct
Examine   changes   introduced   to   reform   or   restructExamine   changes   introduced   to   reform   or   restruct
Examine changes introduced to reform or restruct
 
Writing in SociologyA Quick ModelIntroduction1.docx
Writing in SociologyA Quick ModelIntroduction1.docxWriting in SociologyA Quick ModelIntroduction1.docx
Writing in SociologyA Quick ModelIntroduction1.docx
 
Researh
ResearhResearh
Researh
 
Conceptual Framework By Zewde Alemayehu Tilahun
Conceptual Framework By Zewde Alemayehu TilahunConceptual Framework By Zewde Alemayehu Tilahun
Conceptual Framework By Zewde Alemayehu Tilahun
 
AP LanguageMrs. MathewUnit 3 Synthesis ProjectYou will .docx
AP LanguageMrs. MathewUnit 3 Synthesis ProjectYou will .docxAP LanguageMrs. MathewUnit 3 Synthesis ProjectYou will .docx
AP LanguageMrs. MathewUnit 3 Synthesis ProjectYou will .docx
 
Ppt
PptPpt
Ppt
 
Research Paper Essay Examples.pdf
Research Paper Essay Examples.pdfResearch Paper Essay Examples.pdf
Research Paper Essay Examples.pdf
 
Heider (1958) was the first to note the naïve scientist in human.docx
Heider (1958) was the first to note the naïve scientist in human.docxHeider (1958) was the first to note the naïve scientist in human.docx
Heider (1958) was the first to note the naïve scientist in human.docx
 
8 essay test
8 essay test8 essay test
8 essay test
 
Attribution Theory Essay
Attribution Theory EssayAttribution Theory Essay
Attribution Theory Essay
 
A Review And Evaluation Of Prominent Theories Of Writing
A Review And Evaluation Of Prominent Theories Of WritingA Review And Evaluation Of Prominent Theories Of Writing
A Review And Evaluation Of Prominent Theories Of Writing
 
Case study final
Case study finalCase study final
Case study final
 
ON THE ORIGINS OF VIOLENCE.docx
ON THE ORIGINS OF VIOLENCE.docxON THE ORIGINS OF VIOLENCE.docx
ON THE ORIGINS OF VIOLENCE.docx
 
Inductive & deductive reasoning (advance research methodology)
Inductive & deductive reasoning (advance research methodology)Inductive & deductive reasoning (advance research methodology)
Inductive & deductive reasoning (advance research methodology)
 
The Literature and Study Review and Ethical Concern
The Literature and Study  Review and Ethical ConcernThe Literature and Study  Review and Ethical Concern
The Literature and Study Review and Ethical Concern
 

More from mjlobetos

Lesson 21 designing the questionaire and establishing validity and reliabilty
Lesson 21 designing the questionaire and establishing validity and reliabiltyLesson 21 designing the questionaire and establishing validity and reliabilty
Lesson 21 designing the questionaire and establishing validity and reliabilty
mjlobetos
 

More from mjlobetos (20)

Lesson 32 presenting a research workbook
Lesson 32 presenting a research workbookLesson 32 presenting a research workbook
Lesson 32 presenting a research workbook
 
Lesson 31 presenting the written research report
Lesson 31 presenting the written research reportLesson 31 presenting the written research report
Lesson 31 presenting the written research report
 
Lesson 30 listing references
Lesson 30 listing referencesLesson 30 listing references
Lesson 30 listing references
 
Lesson 29 formualting recommendations
Lesson 29 formualting recommendationsLesson 29 formualting recommendations
Lesson 29 formualting recommendations
 
Lesson 28 drawing logical conclusions from research findings
Lesson 28 drawing logical conclusions from research findingsLesson 28 drawing logical conclusions from research findings
Lesson 28 drawing logical conclusions from research findings
 
Lesson 27 using statistical techniques in analyzing data
Lesson 27 using statistical techniques in analyzing dataLesson 27 using statistical techniques in analyzing data
Lesson 27 using statistical techniques in analyzing data
 
Lesson 26 presenting and interpreting data in tabular and graphical froms
Lesson 26 presenting and interpreting data in tabular and graphical fromsLesson 26 presenting and interpreting data in tabular and graphical froms
Lesson 26 presenting and interpreting data in tabular and graphical froms
 
Lesson 24 testing the hypothesis
Lesson 24 testing the hypothesisLesson 24 testing the hypothesis
Lesson 24 testing the hypothesis
 
Lesson 23 planning data analyses using statistics
Lesson 23 planning data analyses using statisticsLesson 23 planning data analyses using statistics
Lesson 23 planning data analyses using statistics
 
Lesson 22 planning data collection procedures
Lesson 22 planning data collection proceduresLesson 22 planning data collection procedures
Lesson 22 planning data collection procedures
 
Lesson 21 designing the questionaire and establishing validity and reliabilty
Lesson 21 designing the questionaire and establishing validity and reliabiltyLesson 21 designing the questionaire and establishing validity and reliabilty
Lesson 21 designing the questionaire and establishing validity and reliabilty
 
Lesson 20 describing sample size and sampling procedures
Lesson 20 describing sample size and sampling proceduresLesson 20 describing sample size and sampling procedures
Lesson 20 describing sample size and sampling procedures
 
Lesson 19 choosing an appropriate research design
Lesson 19  choosing an appropriate research designLesson 19  choosing an appropriate research design
Lesson 19 choosing an appropriate research design
 
Lesson 18 listing research hypotheses
Lesson 18 listing research hypothesesLesson 18 listing research hypotheses
Lesson 18 listing research hypotheses
 
Lesson 17 defining terms in the study
Lesson 17 defining terms in the studyLesson 17 defining terms in the study
Lesson 17 defining terms in the study
 
Lesson 16 illustrating and explaining conceptual framewok
Lesson 16 illustrating and explaining conceptual framewokLesson 16 illustrating and explaining conceptual framewok
Lesson 16 illustrating and explaining conceptual framewok
 
Lesson 9 citing benefits and beneficiaries of research study
Lesson 9 citing benefits and beneficiaries of research studyLesson 9 citing benefits and beneficiaries of research study
Lesson 9 citing benefits and beneficiaries of research study
 
Lesson 8 indicating the scope and delimitation
Lesson 8  indicating the scope and delimitationLesson 8  indicating the scope and delimitation
Lesson 8 indicating the scope and delimitation
 
Lesson 7 stating research questions
Lesson 7 stating research questionsLesson 7 stating research questions
Lesson 7 stating research questions
 
Lesson 4 designing a research usefu; in daily life
Lesson 4 designing a research usefu; in daily lifeLesson 4 designing a research usefu; in daily life
Lesson 4 designing a research usefu; in daily life
 

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (20)

Salient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptx
Salient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptxSalient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptx
Salient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptx
 
Instructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptx
Instructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptxInstructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptx
Instructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptx
 
Morse OER Some Benefits and Challenges.pptx
Morse OER Some Benefits and Challenges.pptxMorse OER Some Benefits and Challenges.pptx
Morse OER Some Benefits and Challenges.pptx
 
How to Create Map Views in the Odoo 17 ERP
How to Create Map Views in the Odoo 17 ERPHow to Create Map Views in the Odoo 17 ERP
How to Create Map Views in the Odoo 17 ERP
 
PART A. Introduction to Costumer Service
PART A. Introduction to Costumer ServicePART A. Introduction to Costumer Service
PART A. Introduction to Costumer Service
 
Application of Matrices in real life. Presentation on application of matrices
Application of Matrices in real life. Presentation on application of matricesApplication of Matrices in real life. Presentation on application of matrices
Application of Matrices in real life. Presentation on application of matrices
 
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: Limitations and Solutions with LLMs"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: Limitations and Solutions with LLMs"Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: Limitations and Solutions with LLMs"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: Limitations and Solutions with LLMs"
 
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdfSectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
 
How to Break the cycle of negative Thoughts
How to Break the cycle of negative ThoughtsHow to Break the cycle of negative Thoughts
How to Break the cycle of negative Thoughts
 
[GDSC YCCE] Build with AI Online Presentation
[GDSC YCCE] Build with AI Online Presentation[GDSC YCCE] Build with AI Online Presentation
[GDSC YCCE] Build with AI Online Presentation
 
B.ed spl. HI pdusu exam paper-2023-24.pdf
B.ed spl. HI pdusu exam paper-2023-24.pdfB.ed spl. HI pdusu exam paper-2023-24.pdf
B.ed spl. HI pdusu exam paper-2023-24.pdf
 
Sha'Carri Richardson Presentation 202345
Sha'Carri Richardson Presentation 202345Sha'Carri Richardson Presentation 202345
Sha'Carri Richardson Presentation 202345
 
The impact of social media on mental health and well-being has been a topic o...
The impact of social media on mental health and well-being has been a topic o...The impact of social media on mental health and well-being has been a topic o...
The impact of social media on mental health and well-being has been a topic o...
 
Open Educational Resources Primer PowerPoint
Open Educational Resources Primer PowerPointOpen Educational Resources Primer PowerPoint
Open Educational Resources Primer PowerPoint
 
MARUTI SUZUKI- A Successful Joint Venture in India.pptx
MARUTI SUZUKI- A Successful Joint Venture in India.pptxMARUTI SUZUKI- A Successful Joint Venture in India.pptx
MARUTI SUZUKI- A Successful Joint Venture in India.pptx
 
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
 
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumersBasic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
 
Telling Your Story_ Simple Steps to Build Your Nonprofit's Brand Webinar.pdf
Telling Your Story_ Simple Steps to Build Your Nonprofit's Brand Webinar.pdfTelling Your Story_ Simple Steps to Build Your Nonprofit's Brand Webinar.pdf
Telling Your Story_ Simple Steps to Build Your Nonprofit's Brand Webinar.pdf
 
Basic Civil Engineering Notes of Chapter-6, Topic- Ecosystem, Biodiversity G...
Basic Civil Engineering Notes of Chapter-6,  Topic- Ecosystem, Biodiversity G...Basic Civil Engineering Notes of Chapter-6,  Topic- Ecosystem, Biodiversity G...
Basic Civil Engineering Notes of Chapter-6, Topic- Ecosystem, Biodiversity G...
 
Operations Management - Book1.p - Dr. Abdulfatah A. Salem
Operations Management - Book1.p  - Dr. Abdulfatah A. SalemOperations Management - Book1.p  - Dr. Abdulfatah A. Salem
Operations Management - Book1.p - Dr. Abdulfatah A. Salem
 

Lesson 13 synthesizing information from relavant literature

  • 2. What is a synthesis? A synthesis is a discussion that draws on one or more sources. Your ability to infer relationships among sources such as essays, articles, fiction and also non-written sources such as lecture, interviews and observations. It refers to the bringing together of materials from different sources and the creation of an integrated whole.
  • 3. Types of Synthesis? 1. Explanatory Synthesis. It helps the readers to understand a topic. Its primary aim is to present the facts in a reasonably objective manner. Explanations given may entail descriptions, sequences of events or state of affairs. 2. Argument synthesis. Its purpose is for you to present your own point of view with the support of relevant facts drawn from services and presented in a logical manner.
  • 4. Categories of Sources 1. Documents 2. Numerical Records 3. Oral Statements 4. Relics
  • 5. How to write a Synthesis 1. Consider your purpose in writing. 2. Select and read carefully your sources according to your purpose. 3. Formulate a thesis. It is the main ideas that you want to present in your synthesis. 4. Decide how you will use your source material and take down notes. 5. Develop an organizational plan according to your thesis. 6. Write the first draft of your synthesis, following your organizational plan. 7. Revise your synthesis.
  • 6. Techniques for Writing a Synthesis 1. Summary – it is the simplest way of organizing a synthesis. Here you write one after the other the most relevant information and sources you gathered. 2. Example or illustration –it is a reference to a particular illuminating example or illustration that you have included in your review. 3. Two (or more) reasons –this approach can be an effective method by simply stating thesis, then give reasons why it is true. Your reasons need to be supported by evidence from your data and sources. 4.Comparison and Contrast – These techniques will lead to examining two subjects or data in terms of one another. Comparison considers similarities while contrast highlights differences.
  • 7. Preparing a Synthesis Matrix The synthesis matrix is a chart that will allow you to sort and categorize the different opinions and arguments given on issue in relation to your study. Across the top of the chart are the spaces to record sources and along the side of the chart are the spaces to record the main points on the topic being undertaken.
  • 8. SYNTHESIS MATRIX FORMAT Topic:__________________________ Label: Author’s last name and or few keywords from the title of the work. Main Idea A Source # 1 Source # 2 Source # 3 Source # 4 Main idea B
  • 9. Sample of Literature Review Synthesis Synthesis taken from “World War Two and its Effect on Women” ◦ While the articles used in this research agree that women made many advances during the World War II period, it is crucial to realize that not all these changes were welcomed. In most cases women faced discrimination from just about everyone around them. Women in the workplace were often place in positions of inferiority or treated as being less physically able to do the same work the men did. Many women were often not trained because they were viewed as temporary employees who were only there for the duration of the war. (Bruley, 2003). Women were very rarely given equal pay as men, even though some of them did the same work. Women in the military faced not only mental abuse but also physical harm from their male counterparts. According to Cornelsen (2005), there were many instances where female aviators were injured or killed due to being made to fly ill-maintained aircrafts or aircrafts that had been sabotaged.
  • 10. Example of Comparison and Contrast Student A ◦ Smith (2000) concludes that personal privacy in their living quarters is the most important factor in nursing home residents perception of their autonomy. He suggest that physical environment in the more public space of the building did not have much impact on their perceptions. Neither the layout of the building, nor the activities available seem to make much difference. Jones and Johnstone make the claim that he need to control one’s environment is a fundamental need of life (2001) and suggest that the approach of most institutions, which is to provide total care may be as bad as no care at all. If people have no choices or think that they have none, they become depresses.
  • 11. Example of Comparison and Contrast Student B ◦ After studying residents and staff from two intermediate care facilities' in Calgary, Alberta, Smith (2000) came to the conclusion that except for the amount of personal privacy available to the residents, the physical environment of these institutions, had minimal, if any effect on their perceptions of control. However, French(1998) and Haroon (2000) found that availability of private areas is not the only aspect of the physical environment that determines residents autonomy. Haroon interviewed 115 residents from 32 different nursing homes known to have different levels of autonomy (2000). It was found out that physical structures, such as standardized furniture, heating that could not be individually regulated and no possession of a house key for residents limited their feelings of independence. Moreover, Hope(2000), who interviewd 225 residents from various nursing homes, substantiates the claim that characteristics of the institutional environment such as the extent of resources in the facility, as well as its location are features which residents have indicated as being of great importance to their independence.