Meaning in
  Context
Pragmatics

1. shared attitude, beliefs, knowledge
  between the speaker and the hearer

 a. The mayor denied the criminal’s request
     because he is cautious. (he – mayor)

 b. The mayor denied the criminal’s request
     because he is dangerous. (he –criminal)


Note: Exactly the same sentence except for the adjective
 which defines the antecedent of ‘he’ in (a) and (b).


      Linguistics for language teachers/Dr. Jessie Grace U. Rubrico
2. Presupposition
 • assumption on belief/knowledge implied
   by a particular word

   a. Have you stopped exercising?
     > stopped presupposes . . .

   b. Ninoy Aquino was assassinated in 1983.
      > assassination presupposes. . .



    Linguistics for language teachers/Dr. Jessie Grace U. Rubrico
• speaker (S) assumption of the utterance to be
  true or known by the hearer (H)

 When did you stop smoking?
   –you used to smoke
   - you no longer smoke

• Constancy under negation
   My car is a wreck
   My car is not a wreck

   presupposition: you have a car
3. DEIXIS – forms used and interpreted based on
            the location of the speaker or hearer

  • this, here – near the speaker
  • that, there – near the listener

  • come – go
     a. The cobra is coming into the tent
       - towards the speaker
     b. The cobra is going into the tent
        - away from the speaker

     Linguistics for language teachers/Dr. Jessie Grace U. Rubrico
a) spatial deixis– here, there

b) temporal deixis
   – now, then, today,
     yesterday, tomorrow

c) person deixis – him, them, etc.

d) things – it, this, these, that, those
4. Inference
  - connection between what is said
    and what must be meant

  a. Jennee is wearing a Calvin Klein.
   b. Can I borrow your O’Grady?


Note: (a) Calvin Klein signature design or accessories

      (b) O’Grady book on Contemporary Linguistics

     Linguistics for language teachers/Dr. Jessie Grace U. Rubrico
5. Anaphora – referring back
 a. We saw a lady washing a puppy in a small
    bath. When she let go, it jumped out of the
    small bath.
 • lady, puppy – antecedents
 • she, it - anaphora

 b. I was waiting for the cab, but he just drove
    by without stopping.
 • antecedent – bus ; anaphora – he
 • If X is a bus, then X has a driver
    – inference
6. Speech Acts
 • type of action performed by speaker
   with the utterance
    • command
    • request
    • promise
    • question
    • information
Direct speech act
• asks information
  • Did you dine out last night?
  • Are they coming?
  • Can they sing well?
Performatives
• direct speech act with verbs whose action is
  a speech act
  • I assert that UM will beat USM in the
    ranking.
  • I promise to take her to the resto?
  • I order John to eat the meal.

• declarative, interrogative, imperative
Structure                   Function

You can drive         Declarative                 Statement
a car

Can you drive a Interrogative                     Question
car?


Drive the car         Imperative                  Command/
(please)                                          Request


      Linguistics for language teachers/Dr. Jessie Grace U. Rubrico
Identifying performatives
Which of these use the verb promise as PERFORMATIVE?
1. I promise to take Zoe to dinner tonight.
2. Zoe promises to take me to dinner tonight.
3. I will promise to take Zoe to dinner tonight.

  Hints
    (a) subject of the verb must be “I”; performative
        is about an interaction between speaker
        and hearers.
     (b) Performatives must take place in the present.
Felicity Conditions
 • allow us to determine under when it is
   appropriate to ask questions, give
   commands, and so forth.
Felicity Conditions: Asking Questions

S questions H about X (a mutual friend)
 1.   S does not know the truth about X.
 2.   S wants to know the truth about X.
 3.   S believes H may know the truth about X.


Assumptions:
 1. if someone asks a question, s/he doesn't know the answer to
        the question > inherent in condition #1.

 2. If someone asks, s/he actually wants to know the truth. (#2)

 3. If someone asks you, they think you may know the truth
     (or answer). (#3)
Felicity Conditions: Promise
S promises H to do Y:
 1. S believes H wants Y done.
 2. S is able to do Y.
 3. S is willing to do Y.
Felicity Conditions: Requests
S requests H to do Z (action):
 1. Speaker believes that Z has not yet been
    done.
 2. Speaker believes that Hearer is able to do Z.
 3. Speaker believes that Hearer is willing to do
    Z-type things for S.
Indirect speech act
a. Can     you meet me tonight?
     • structure: interrogative
     • function: request
b.    You left the door open.
     • structure: declarative
     • function : request
c. Can you open the door for me?
 - the speaker is requesting, not asking about the
   ability of the listener to open the door


d1. Do you know where the bus stop is?
d2. Yes, I know where it is
    (and walks away)
 (1) request for help in finding the bus stop
 (2) reads the speech act of (1) as a question,
      not as a request.
7. Politeness
• awareness of and consideration for
   another person’s face

• FACE : person’s public image
  • emotional and social sense of self
    everyone has and expects everyone
    else to recognize
• face-threatening act
 - threatens a person’s image
  Give me that book! – S conveys he/she has
                      social power over the H

• face-saving act
 -lessens the possible threat
   Could you give me that book?
    – less threatening
    - removes the assumption of social power
Negative face

• the need to be independent and free
   from imposition

 • face-saving act: show concern
   about imposition
 – I’m sorry to bother you, but …
Positive face
• the need to be connected, to belong
  • face-saving act
     • show solidarity
     • rally to a common goal

      • let’s do this together. . .
      • we have the same problem
References

• O'Grady, William D., Archibald, John,
  [eds.] (2009). Contemporary Linguistic
  Analysis: An Introduction, 6th edition.
  Ontario: Pearson Education Canada.

• Yule G. 2006. The study of language.
  Cambridge: CUP.

Pragmatics

  • 1.
    Meaning in Context
  • 2.
    Pragmatics 1. shared attitude,beliefs, knowledge between the speaker and the hearer a. The mayor denied the criminal’s request because he is cautious. (he – mayor) b. The mayor denied the criminal’s request because he is dangerous. (he –criminal) Note: Exactly the same sentence except for the adjective which defines the antecedent of ‘he’ in (a) and (b). Linguistics for language teachers/Dr. Jessie Grace U. Rubrico
  • 3.
    2. Presupposition •assumption on belief/knowledge implied by a particular word a. Have you stopped exercising? > stopped presupposes . . . b. Ninoy Aquino was assassinated in 1983. > assassination presupposes. . . Linguistics for language teachers/Dr. Jessie Grace U. Rubrico
  • 4.
    • speaker (S)assumption of the utterance to be true or known by the hearer (H) When did you stop smoking? –you used to smoke - you no longer smoke • Constancy under negation My car is a wreck My car is not a wreck presupposition: you have a car
  • 5.
    3. DEIXIS –forms used and interpreted based on the location of the speaker or hearer • this, here – near the speaker • that, there – near the listener • come – go a. The cobra is coming into the tent - towards the speaker b. The cobra is going into the tent - away from the speaker Linguistics for language teachers/Dr. Jessie Grace U. Rubrico
  • 6.
    a) spatial deixis–here, there b) temporal deixis – now, then, today, yesterday, tomorrow c) person deixis – him, them, etc. d) things – it, this, these, that, those
  • 7.
    4. Inference - connection between what is said and what must be meant a. Jennee is wearing a Calvin Klein. b. Can I borrow your O’Grady? Note: (a) Calvin Klein signature design or accessories (b) O’Grady book on Contemporary Linguistics Linguistics for language teachers/Dr. Jessie Grace U. Rubrico
  • 8.
    5. Anaphora –referring back a. We saw a lady washing a puppy in a small bath. When she let go, it jumped out of the small bath. • lady, puppy – antecedents • she, it - anaphora b. I was waiting for the cab, but he just drove by without stopping. • antecedent – bus ; anaphora – he • If X is a bus, then X has a driver – inference
  • 9.
    6. Speech Acts • type of action performed by speaker with the utterance • command • request • promise • question • information
  • 10.
    Direct speech act •asks information • Did you dine out last night? • Are they coming? • Can they sing well?
  • 11.
    Performatives • direct speechact with verbs whose action is a speech act • I assert that UM will beat USM in the ranking. • I promise to take her to the resto? • I order John to eat the meal. • declarative, interrogative, imperative
  • 12.
    Structure Function You can drive Declarative Statement a car Can you drive a Interrogative Question car? Drive the car Imperative Command/ (please) Request Linguistics for language teachers/Dr. Jessie Grace U. Rubrico
  • 13.
    Identifying performatives Which ofthese use the verb promise as PERFORMATIVE? 1. I promise to take Zoe to dinner tonight. 2. Zoe promises to take me to dinner tonight. 3. I will promise to take Zoe to dinner tonight. Hints (a) subject of the verb must be “I”; performative is about an interaction between speaker and hearers. (b) Performatives must take place in the present.
  • 14.
    Felicity Conditions •allow us to determine under when it is appropriate to ask questions, give commands, and so forth.
  • 15.
    Felicity Conditions: AskingQuestions S questions H about X (a mutual friend) 1. S does not know the truth about X. 2. S wants to know the truth about X. 3. S believes H may know the truth about X. Assumptions: 1. if someone asks a question, s/he doesn't know the answer to the question > inherent in condition #1. 2. If someone asks, s/he actually wants to know the truth. (#2) 3. If someone asks you, they think you may know the truth (or answer). (#3)
  • 16.
    Felicity Conditions: Promise Spromises H to do Y: 1. S believes H wants Y done. 2. S is able to do Y. 3. S is willing to do Y.
  • 17.
    Felicity Conditions: Requests Srequests H to do Z (action): 1. Speaker believes that Z has not yet been done. 2. Speaker believes that Hearer is able to do Z. 3. Speaker believes that Hearer is willing to do Z-type things for S.
  • 18.
    Indirect speech act a.Can you meet me tonight? • structure: interrogative • function: request b. You left the door open. • structure: declarative • function : request
  • 19.
    c. Can youopen the door for me? - the speaker is requesting, not asking about the ability of the listener to open the door d1. Do you know where the bus stop is? d2. Yes, I know where it is (and walks away) (1) request for help in finding the bus stop (2) reads the speech act of (1) as a question, not as a request.
  • 20.
    7. Politeness • awarenessof and consideration for another person’s face • FACE : person’s public image • emotional and social sense of self everyone has and expects everyone else to recognize
  • 21.
    • face-threatening act - threatens a person’s image Give me that book! – S conveys he/she has social power over the H • face-saving act -lessens the possible threat Could you give me that book? – less threatening - removes the assumption of social power
  • 22.
    Negative face • theneed to be independent and free from imposition • face-saving act: show concern about imposition – I’m sorry to bother you, but …
  • 23.
    Positive face • theneed to be connected, to belong • face-saving act • show solidarity • rally to a common goal • let’s do this together. . . • we have the same problem
  • 24.
    References • O'Grady, WilliamD., Archibald, John, [eds.] (2009). Contemporary Linguistic Analysis: An Introduction, 6th edition. Ontario: Pearson Education Canada. • Yule G. 2006. The study of language. Cambridge: CUP.