Alignment Of Highways
1
Vertical Curves
Transportation Engineering
(CE-421)
2
Vertical Curves
• Vertical alignment: specifies the
elevations of points along a
roadway
• Need to find elevation of
roadway points:
– to provide proper drainage
– an acceptable level of driver
safety/ comfort
3
Vertical Curves
• A primary concern in vertical alignment: is establishing the
transition of roadway elevations between two grades
• This transition is achieved by means of vertical curves
• Broadly classification of vertical curves:
– crest vertical curves
– sag vertical curves
4
Vertical Curves
• Factors influencing the vertical alignment of a highway:
– Natural terrain
– Minimum stopping sight distance for the selected design speed
– The number of trucks and other heavy vehicles in the traffic
stream
– The basic roadway cross-section; i.e., two lanes versus multiple
lanes
– Natural environmental factors, such as wetlands and historic,
cultural, and community resources
5
Vertical Curves
o When grade is expressed as a percent, the grade indicates the
relative rise (or fall) of the facility in the longitudinal direction as a
percentage of the length of the section under study
o Thus, a 4% grade of 2,000 ft. involves a vertical rise of
2,000* (4/100) = 80 ft.
o Upgrades have positive slopes and percent grades, while
o downgrades have negative slopes and percent grades
6
Vertical Curves
o Maximum recommended grades depend upon the :
 type of facility (road functional class)
 terrain in which it is built
 design speed
o Terrain Classification
– Level - highway sight distances are long without major expense,
small amounts of earthwork
– Rolling - the natural slopes rise above or fall below the road
elevation with occasional steep slopes that restrict highway
alignment, moderate amounts of earthwork
– Mountainous - highway alignment is strongly influenced by the
ground slopes, large amount of earthwork
7
Vertical Curves
• Cars: negotiate 4-5% grades without significant speed reduction
• Trucks: significant speed changes
– 5% increase on short descending grades
– 7% decrease on short ascending grades
– On upgrades, the maximum speed that can be maintained by a
truck is dependent primarily on
• length of the grade
• steepness of the grade
• the truck’s weight/power ratio, which is the gross vehicle
weight divided by the net engine power
• Entering speed
8
Vertical Curves
Source:AASHTO’s 'A Policy on Geometric Design of Highways and Streets (2011) '
9
Vertical Curves
Source:AASHTO’s 'A Policy on Geometric Design of Highways and Streets (2011) '
10
Vertical Curves
• Maximum grades:
– 5 % for a design speed of 110 km/h [70 mph]
– 7 to 12% for a design speed of 50 km/h [30 mph] depending on
terrain
• Minimum grades:
– Flat grades can typically provide proper surface drainage on
uncurbed highways where the cross slope is adequate to drain the
pavement surface laterally
– With curbed highways or streets, longitudinal grades should be
provided to facilitate surface drainage
– An appropriate minimum grade is typically 0.5 percent, but grades
of 0.30 percent may be used
11
Vertical Curves
Grades
12
Vertical Curves
Critical Lengths of Grade for Design
The term “critical length of grade” is used to
indicate the maximum length of a designated upgrade
on which a loaded truck can operate without an
unreasonable reduction in speed.
If the desired freedom of operation is to be
maintained on grades longer than critical, design
adjustments such as changes in location to reduce
grades or addition of extra lanes should be considered.
13
Vertical Curves
*Based on accident Involvement rates with
10 mph speed reduction as threshold.
14
Vertical Curves
• a 3% grade causes a reduction in speed of 10 mph after 1600 feet
1800-ft
15
Vertical Curves
• The general form of the parabolic equation, as applied to vertical
curves, is
• A parabolic function has been found suitable in this regard
because, among other things, it provides a constant rate
of change of slope.
y  ax2
 bx  c
16
Vertical Curves
For the purpose of describing vertical curve let:
• y =Y(x)= elevation of vertical curve at a point at distance x from the
beginning of the vertical curve (PVC) in stations or ft.
• x = distance from PVC in stations or ft.
• a, b = coefficients
• c = Y(o)= elevation of the PVC when x = 0 in ft.
Yx  ax2
 bx Yo
17
Vertical Curves
G1 G2
G1 G2
Crest Vertical Curve
Sag Vertical Curve
18
Vertical Curves
G1
G2
PVI
PVT
PVC
L/2
A
L
x
y  ax2
 bx  c
Yx  ax2
 bx Yo
Vertical Curves
Fundamentalso In defining a and b, the first derivative of equation (1) gives the slope as:
𝒅𝒀
𝒅𝒙
= 𝟐𝒂𝒙 + 𝒃
o At the PVC, x = 0, so, 𝒃 = 𝒅𝒀
= 𝑮 𝟏 (when X=0, slope is equal to entry grade)
𝒅𝒙
o where G1 is the initial slope in ft./ft.
o Also the second derivative of equation (1) is the rate of change of slope and is
𝒅 𝟐 𝒀
= 𝟐𝒂
𝒅𝒙 𝟐
o However, the average rate of change of slope, by observation (previous figure),
can also be written as
𝒅 𝟐 𝒀 𝑮 𝟐 − 𝑮 𝟏
𝒅𝒙 𝟐 =
𝑳
o Equating two equations we get
𝒂 =
𝑮 𝟐 − 𝑮 𝟏
𝟐𝑳
o Where: L – curve length in ft., G1– initial grade in ft./ft. and G2– final grade in
ft./ft.
2
19
 (1)x oY  ax  bx Y
Vertical CurvesVertical Curves
20
Vertical Curves
21
Vertical Curves
Example: A crest vertical curve joins a +3% and –4% grade. Design
speed is 75 mph. Length = 2184.0 ft. Station at VPI is 345+ 60.00,
elevation at VPI = 250 feet. Find elevations and station for VPC and VPT.
22
Vertical Curves
Minimum lengths of crest vertical
curves based on sight distance criteria
generally are satisfactory from the
standpoint of
• Safety
• Comfort
• appearance.
Vertical Curve
Design• Provision of a minimum stopping sight distance (SSD) is the only
criterion used for design of a crest vertical curve
• Sight distance is measured from an assumed eye height of 3.5 ft.
and an object height of 2.0 ft.
• For crest vertical curves, the daylight sight line controls minimum
length of vertical curves
23
Vertical Curve
Design• Two possible scenarios that could control the design length:
– (1) the SSD is greater than the length of the vertical curve
– (2) the SSD is less than the length of the vertical curve
24
Vertical Curve
Design
Assistant with Target Rod (2ft object height)
Observer with Sighting
Rod (3.5 ft)
25
2158
26
ASSD2
L 
A

2158
L  2SSD
For SSD/ S/ d(s) < L For SSD / S/ d(s) >L
Minimum Length of Crest Vertical Curve Design
• Longer curve lengths provide more SSD all else being equal, but more costly
to construct
• Shorter curve lengths are less expensive to construct but may not provide
adequate SSD due to more rapid changes in slope
• Requirement: An expression for minimum curve length given a required
SSD for crest vertical curve
• SSD = stopping sight distance in ft (m), and
• A = algebraic difference in grades in percent
• L = minimum length of vertical curve in ft
Vertical Curve Design
27
28
Vertical Curves
At least four different criteria for establishing
lengths of sag vertical curves are recognized to
some extent. These are
• Headlight sight distance,
• Passenger comfort,
• Drainage control, and
• General appearance.
29
Vertical Curves
• The headlight SSD requirement is based on the fact that sight distance will be
restricted during periods of darkness whereas during daylight periods, sight
distance is unaffected by the sag curve
• As a vehicle is driven on a sag vertical curve at night, the position of the
headlight and the direction of the headlight beam will dictate the stretch of
highway ahead that is lighted
• Assumptions for design (AASHTO)
– h1 = headlight height = 2.0ft.
– β = 1 degree (inclined angle of the headlight beam
relative to the horizontal
plan of the car)
Vertical Curves
G1
G2
PVI
PVTPVC
h2=0h1
L
Light Beam Distance =(S)
For SSD < L
For SSD > L
headlight beam (diverging from LOS by β degrees)
ASSD2
30
L 
4003.5SSD 
 A
 4003.5SSD
L  2SSD
D
31
Vertical Curves
• The comfort criterion is based on the fact that when a vehicle travels on a sag
vertical curve, both the gravitational and centrifugal forces act in combination,
resulting in a greater effect than on a crest vertical curve where these forces act in
opposition to each other
• Several factors such as weight carried, body suspension of the vehicle, and tire
flexibility affect comfort due to change in vertical direction, making it difficult for
comfort to be measured directly
• It is generally accepted that a comfortable ride will be provided if the radial
acceleration is not greater than 1 ft /sec-sq.
• Minimum length of curve
– where V is the design speed in mph
– L the minimum length based on comfort
– A the algebraic difference in grades
32
Vertical Curves
• The criterion for acceptable appearance is usually satisfied by
assuring that the minimum length of the sag curve is not less than
expressed by the following equation:
L  100A
– L the minimum length based on appearance criterion
– A the algebraic difference in grades
• Longer curves are frequently necessary for major arterials if the
general appearance of these highways is to be considered to be
satisfactory
33
Vertical Curves
Length of Sag Vertical Curves Based on Drainage Criterion
• The drainage criterion for sag vertical curves must be
considered when the road is curbed
• This criterion is different from the others in that there is a
maximum length requirement rather than a minimum
length
• The maximum length requirement to satisfy the drainage
criterion is that a minimum slope of 0.35 percent be
provided within 50 ft. of the lowest point of the curve
Additional Properties of Vertical Curves
32
o G1 = initial roadway grade in percent or ft/ft (m/m) (this grade is also
referred to as the initial tangent grade(viewing from left to right)
o G2 = final roadway (tangent) grade in percent or ft/ft(m/m),
o PVC = point of the vertical curve (the initial point of the curve),
o PVI = point of vertical intersection (intersection of initial and final grades),
o PVT = point of vertical tangent, which is the final point of the vertical curve
(the point where the curve returns to the final grade or, equivalently, the
final tangent),
Additional Properties of Vertical Curves
o L = length of the curve in stations or ft (m) measured in a constant-
elevation horizontal plane,
o x =
o Y =
distance from the PVC in ft (m),
offset at any distance x from the PVC in ft (m),
o Ym = mid-curve offset in ft (m), and
o Yf= offset at the end of the vertical curve in ft (m).
o Making use of the properties of an equal-tangent parabola
o Where A = absolute value of the difference in grades (|G1 - G2|)
expressed in percent
x2
35
A
200L
Y 
Additional Properties of Vertical Curves
o Mid-curve offset
o Offset at the end of curve
o Note that in this equation, 200 is used in the denominator insteadof
2 because A is expressed in percent instead of ft/ft
o The K-value defined as (with L in ft and A in percent)
o K = value that is the horizontal distance, in ft. required to affect a
1% change in the slope of the vertical curve,
o A = absolute value of the difference in grades (|G1  G2|)
expressed in percent), and
o L = length of curve in ft (m).
A L
8 0 0
mY 
A L
2 0 0fY 
K 
L
A
36

Vertical alignment of highway (transportation engineering)

  • 1.
    Alignment Of Highways 1 VerticalCurves Transportation Engineering (CE-421)
  • 2.
    2 Vertical Curves • Verticalalignment: specifies the elevations of points along a roadway • Need to find elevation of roadway points: – to provide proper drainage – an acceptable level of driver safety/ comfort
  • 3.
    3 Vertical Curves • Aprimary concern in vertical alignment: is establishing the transition of roadway elevations between two grades • This transition is achieved by means of vertical curves • Broadly classification of vertical curves: – crest vertical curves – sag vertical curves
  • 4.
    4 Vertical Curves • Factorsinfluencing the vertical alignment of a highway: – Natural terrain – Minimum stopping sight distance for the selected design speed – The number of trucks and other heavy vehicles in the traffic stream – The basic roadway cross-section; i.e., two lanes versus multiple lanes – Natural environmental factors, such as wetlands and historic, cultural, and community resources
  • 5.
    5 Vertical Curves o Whengrade is expressed as a percent, the grade indicates the relative rise (or fall) of the facility in the longitudinal direction as a percentage of the length of the section under study o Thus, a 4% grade of 2,000 ft. involves a vertical rise of 2,000* (4/100) = 80 ft. o Upgrades have positive slopes and percent grades, while o downgrades have negative slopes and percent grades
  • 6.
    6 Vertical Curves o Maximumrecommended grades depend upon the :  type of facility (road functional class)  terrain in which it is built  design speed o Terrain Classification – Level - highway sight distances are long without major expense, small amounts of earthwork – Rolling - the natural slopes rise above or fall below the road elevation with occasional steep slopes that restrict highway alignment, moderate amounts of earthwork – Mountainous - highway alignment is strongly influenced by the ground slopes, large amount of earthwork
  • 7.
    7 Vertical Curves • Cars:negotiate 4-5% grades without significant speed reduction • Trucks: significant speed changes – 5% increase on short descending grades – 7% decrease on short ascending grades – On upgrades, the maximum speed that can be maintained by a truck is dependent primarily on • length of the grade • steepness of the grade • the truck’s weight/power ratio, which is the gross vehicle weight divided by the net engine power • Entering speed
  • 8.
    8 Vertical Curves Source:AASHTO’s 'APolicy on Geometric Design of Highways and Streets (2011) '
  • 9.
    9 Vertical Curves Source:AASHTO’s 'APolicy on Geometric Design of Highways and Streets (2011) '
  • 10.
    10 Vertical Curves • Maximumgrades: – 5 % for a design speed of 110 km/h [70 mph] – 7 to 12% for a design speed of 50 km/h [30 mph] depending on terrain • Minimum grades: – Flat grades can typically provide proper surface drainage on uncurbed highways where the cross slope is adequate to drain the pavement surface laterally – With curbed highways or streets, longitudinal grades should be provided to facilitate surface drainage – An appropriate minimum grade is typically 0.5 percent, but grades of 0.30 percent may be used
  • 11.
  • 12.
    12 Vertical Curves Critical Lengthsof Grade for Design The term “critical length of grade” is used to indicate the maximum length of a designated upgrade on which a loaded truck can operate without an unreasonable reduction in speed. If the desired freedom of operation is to be maintained on grades longer than critical, design adjustments such as changes in location to reduce grades or addition of extra lanes should be considered.
  • 13.
    13 Vertical Curves *Based onaccident Involvement rates with 10 mph speed reduction as threshold.
  • 14.
    14 Vertical Curves • a3% grade causes a reduction in speed of 10 mph after 1600 feet 1800-ft
  • 15.
    15 Vertical Curves • Thegeneral form of the parabolic equation, as applied to vertical curves, is • A parabolic function has been found suitable in this regard because, among other things, it provides a constant rate of change of slope. y  ax2  bx  c
  • 16.
    16 Vertical Curves For thepurpose of describing vertical curve let: • y =Y(x)= elevation of vertical curve at a point at distance x from the beginning of the vertical curve (PVC) in stations or ft. • x = distance from PVC in stations or ft. • a, b = coefficients • c = Y(o)= elevation of the PVC when x = 0 in ft. Yx  ax2  bx Yo
  • 17.
    17 Vertical Curves G1 G2 G1G2 Crest Vertical Curve Sag Vertical Curve
  • 18.
    18 Vertical Curves G1 G2 PVI PVT PVC L/2 A L x y ax2  bx  c Yx  ax2  bx Yo
  • 19.
    Vertical Curves Fundamentalso Indefining a and b, the first derivative of equation (1) gives the slope as: 𝒅𝒀 𝒅𝒙 = 𝟐𝒂𝒙 + 𝒃 o At the PVC, x = 0, so, 𝒃 = 𝒅𝒀 = 𝑮 𝟏 (when X=0, slope is equal to entry grade) 𝒅𝒙 o where G1 is the initial slope in ft./ft. o Also the second derivative of equation (1) is the rate of change of slope and is 𝒅 𝟐 𝒀 = 𝟐𝒂 𝒅𝒙 𝟐 o However, the average rate of change of slope, by observation (previous figure), can also be written as 𝒅 𝟐 𝒀 𝑮 𝟐 − 𝑮 𝟏 𝒅𝒙 𝟐 = 𝑳 o Equating two equations we get 𝒂 = 𝑮 𝟐 − 𝑮 𝟏 𝟐𝑳 o Where: L – curve length in ft., G1– initial grade in ft./ft. and G2– final grade in ft./ft. 2 19  (1)x oY  ax  bx Y Vertical CurvesVertical Curves
  • 20.
  • 21.
    21 Vertical Curves Example: Acrest vertical curve joins a +3% and –4% grade. Design speed is 75 mph. Length = 2184.0 ft. Station at VPI is 345+ 60.00, elevation at VPI = 250 feet. Find elevations and station for VPC and VPT.
  • 22.
    22 Vertical Curves Minimum lengthsof crest vertical curves based on sight distance criteria generally are satisfactory from the standpoint of • Safety • Comfort • appearance.
  • 23.
    Vertical Curve Design• Provisionof a minimum stopping sight distance (SSD) is the only criterion used for design of a crest vertical curve • Sight distance is measured from an assumed eye height of 3.5 ft. and an object height of 2.0 ft. • For crest vertical curves, the daylight sight line controls minimum length of vertical curves 23
  • 24.
    Vertical Curve Design• Twopossible scenarios that could control the design length: – (1) the SSD is greater than the length of the vertical curve – (2) the SSD is less than the length of the vertical curve 24
  • 25.
    Vertical Curve Design Assistant withTarget Rod (2ft object height) Observer with Sighting Rod (3.5 ft) 25
  • 26.
    2158 26 ASSD2 L  A  2158 L 2SSD For SSD/ S/ d(s) < L For SSD / S/ d(s) >L Minimum Length of Crest Vertical Curve Design • Longer curve lengths provide more SSD all else being equal, but more costly to construct • Shorter curve lengths are less expensive to construct but may not provide adequate SSD due to more rapid changes in slope • Requirement: An expression for minimum curve length given a required SSD for crest vertical curve • SSD = stopping sight distance in ft (m), and • A = algebraic difference in grades in percent • L = minimum length of vertical curve in ft
  • 27.
  • 28.
    28 Vertical Curves At leastfour different criteria for establishing lengths of sag vertical curves are recognized to some extent. These are • Headlight sight distance, • Passenger comfort, • Drainage control, and • General appearance.
  • 29.
    29 Vertical Curves • Theheadlight SSD requirement is based on the fact that sight distance will be restricted during periods of darkness whereas during daylight periods, sight distance is unaffected by the sag curve • As a vehicle is driven on a sag vertical curve at night, the position of the headlight and the direction of the headlight beam will dictate the stretch of highway ahead that is lighted • Assumptions for design (AASHTO) – h1 = headlight height = 2.0ft. – β = 1 degree (inclined angle of the headlight beam relative to the horizontal plan of the car)
  • 30.
    Vertical Curves G1 G2 PVI PVTPVC h2=0h1 L Light BeamDistance =(S) For SSD < L For SSD > L headlight beam (diverging from LOS by β degrees) ASSD2 30 L  4003.5SSD   A  4003.5SSD L  2SSD D
  • 31.
    31 Vertical Curves • Thecomfort criterion is based on the fact that when a vehicle travels on a sag vertical curve, both the gravitational and centrifugal forces act in combination, resulting in a greater effect than on a crest vertical curve where these forces act in opposition to each other • Several factors such as weight carried, body suspension of the vehicle, and tire flexibility affect comfort due to change in vertical direction, making it difficult for comfort to be measured directly • It is generally accepted that a comfortable ride will be provided if the radial acceleration is not greater than 1 ft /sec-sq. • Minimum length of curve – where V is the design speed in mph – L the minimum length based on comfort – A the algebraic difference in grades
  • 32.
    32 Vertical Curves • Thecriterion for acceptable appearance is usually satisfied by assuring that the minimum length of the sag curve is not less than expressed by the following equation: L  100A – L the minimum length based on appearance criterion – A the algebraic difference in grades • Longer curves are frequently necessary for major arterials if the general appearance of these highways is to be considered to be satisfactory
  • 33.
    33 Vertical Curves Length ofSag Vertical Curves Based on Drainage Criterion • The drainage criterion for sag vertical curves must be considered when the road is curbed • This criterion is different from the others in that there is a maximum length requirement rather than a minimum length • The maximum length requirement to satisfy the drainage criterion is that a minimum slope of 0.35 percent be provided within 50 ft. of the lowest point of the curve
  • 34.
    Additional Properties ofVertical Curves 32 o G1 = initial roadway grade in percent or ft/ft (m/m) (this grade is also referred to as the initial tangent grade(viewing from left to right) o G2 = final roadway (tangent) grade in percent or ft/ft(m/m), o PVC = point of the vertical curve (the initial point of the curve), o PVI = point of vertical intersection (intersection of initial and final grades), o PVT = point of vertical tangent, which is the final point of the vertical curve (the point where the curve returns to the final grade or, equivalently, the final tangent),
  • 35.
    Additional Properties ofVertical Curves o L = length of the curve in stations or ft (m) measured in a constant- elevation horizontal plane, o x = o Y = distance from the PVC in ft (m), offset at any distance x from the PVC in ft (m), o Ym = mid-curve offset in ft (m), and o Yf= offset at the end of the vertical curve in ft (m). o Making use of the properties of an equal-tangent parabola o Where A = absolute value of the difference in grades (|G1 - G2|) expressed in percent x2 35 A 200L Y 
  • 36.
    Additional Properties ofVertical Curves o Mid-curve offset o Offset at the end of curve o Note that in this equation, 200 is used in the denominator insteadof 2 because A is expressed in percent instead of ft/ft o The K-value defined as (with L in ft and A in percent) o K = value that is the horizontal distance, in ft. required to affect a 1% change in the slope of the vertical curve, o A = absolute value of the difference in grades (|G1  G2|) expressed in percent), and o L = length of curve in ft (m). A L 8 0 0 mY  A L 2 0 0fY  K  L A 36

Editor's Notes

  • #8 While, Aerodynamic resistance and Driver’s Skill has little influence and so are neglected.