Beginning Concepts in
      Psycholinguistics

              Ahmed Qadoury Abed
              PH D Candidate
              Bagdad University-College of Arts
              English Dept
              2012/2013




1
Definition of psycholinguistics


     Psycholinguistics   is an interdisciplinary field
      of study:
     How do people acquire language?
     How do people use language to speak and
      understand one another?
     How is language presented and processed in
      the brain?
     Brain vs mind


2
Psycholinguistics and other disciplines

     Psycholinguistics   is a sub-field of psychology
      and linguistics
     It is related to:
     Developmental psychology
     Cognitive psychology
     Neurolinguistics
     Speech science


3
Creativity              1

     Creativity   is the nost important feature people
      have.
     Creativity and other types:prose,poetry..
     Linguistic creativity
     All people have it since they know language
     Know ≠ speak




4
Human language creativity vs animal
    communication 2

    1- Speakers of a language can create ,understand, and
        process novel sentences for an entire lifetime
    -   Both children and adults
    -   Unconscious process (depends on interlocutors)
    -   True for sign language
    -   Possibility of creating infinite set out of finite set
        Chomskyan orientation



5
Creativity           3
     2-  the kind of creativity we have is the ability
      of communicating:
     Whatever , wherever ,
     Animals have a little range of topics
     Human language is flexible:
     i- diffeent purposes
     Ii- social interaction
     Dominating the planet

6
Language & Speech
       Speech is the most frequent mode for transmitting
        language (linguistic information)
       -sign language is creative ,transmitted by gestures
       Graphics
       The crucial differences:
       Human is articulatory and auditory
       It is based on knowledge of language as a finite
        system to yield infinite set of possible


7
Language & Writing
       Writing is materially based compared with speaking
        or signing are biological
       Writing is cultural artifact
       Letter referring to sounds or symbolic
       Writing is for formal ,history recording,court
       Children learn to speak before to write (unconscious
        vs conscious)
       The complexity or sophistication of human lang is
        independent of writing


8
Language & Thought
       Thought is verbalized through lang
       People can think but not speak like infants ,
       children with Specific Language impairment SLI
       People with neurological pathologies
       Animals can think but expressed by movements , cries,..
       Bilinguals can express one thought in two langs
       Translation as a means for thought transmission
       Fordor (1975) The Language of Thought Hypothesis
        (LOTH):intelligence responsible for generating the language of
        thought



9
Language & Communication
      Language   is the primary communication
       system:
      Logic, mathematical, graphic,
       programming,visual arts traffic lights
       gestures
      Verbal vs non verbal
      Psycholinguists concerned with language as
       a biologically- based characteristic of human

10
Some Characteristics of the Linguistic
     System
        Language is a formal system for pairing signals and meanings:
        Encoding vs Deccoding
        Both speaker /listener have the same linguistic form for pairing
         sound and meaning
        Their linguistic system enables sounds and meanings to be
         paired,and this is done by a complex and highly organized set
         of principles and rules (grammar and lexicon)
        Knowledge of such system is an implicit or tacit
        Explicit knowledge is temporary and artificial like telephone
         numbers
        Tacit knowledge in the brain /mind and unconscious


11
Descriptive vs Prescriptive              1

      ‘Grammar’   refers differently to teachers and
       linguists.
      Teachers are concerned with a standardized
       set of rules.Prescriptive
      Linguists are concerned with studying the
       language system that underlies ordinary
       use.Descriptive


12
Descriptive vs Prescriptive                    2
        Examples of Prescriptive grammar:
        1-The use of pronouns like me,her initially
        -Me and Mary went to the movie.
        /mary and me went to the movie.
        In descriptive terms, these sentences are generated
         by the speaker’s internalized grammar .
        Members of one language community acquire
         colloquial form of this internalized grammar
        Prescriptive rules are tedious ,difficult ,conscious
         learning is needed.

13
Descriptive vs Prescriptive                                3
        2-the notion of correctness The bulk of linguistic ability acquired
         is not influenced or associated by linguistic correctness.
        There are differences between acquired colloquial internalized
         grammar and prescriptive rules.
        This notion is related to dialect variations:
        Geographic
        Ethnic
        Community
        These all can result in systematic , lexical ,and syntactic
         differences from the transitional standard version of the
         acquired language


14
Descriptive vs Prescriptive                   4
        Which is more important:
        Standard English or colloquial English
        1- standard is used by few
        2-Colloquial acquired naturally (the fruit of
         psycholinguists)
        3- linguists and psycholinguists are interested in
         understanding how these internalized grammars are
         acquired and then put into use


15
The Universality of Human Language
           1

      We    have thousands of languages or versions
       spoken by different language communities
       ,all treated as a single entity by linguists
      This is justified by all have an organization of
       grammar and lexicon
      Chomskyan finite into infinite




16
Universality                   2
        Universality has profound consequences for the way
         psycholinguists analyze the human use of language
        Psycholinguists state that all languages are cut from
         the same mold because the organization of lexicons
         and the formal properties of grammatical systems
         are similar in all human languages
     .
        What is specific and what is universal about
         knowledge of the language the mechanisms that put
         the knowledge of language to use.

17
The Implication for the Acquisition of
     Language

        Language acquisition is an important area in
         psycholinguistics.
        Children in every culture acquire the formal
         properties and lexicon of their languages
         (competence)
        This competence or ability will be developed into
         natural performance
        This is the story behind the profound similarity in
         child acquisition
        Other skills like riding a bike are learned behaviours.

18
Language acquisition                     2
        The story is completely different and complicated
         with L2 acquisition after childhood.
        Children acquire another language/dialect naturally
         vs conscious learning of adults
        Certain aspects (pronunciation) are difficult to
         master.
        Exceptions are those who be native-like
        Research now focus on psych- social factors:
         proximity of exposure to L2 ,and now on age effects
         in L2 acquisition( as memory ability).

19
How Language Pairs Sound to Meaning
             1

      The  grammar of any language has three
       kinds of rules:
      1- phonological rules

      i - they describe the sound patterns of the
       language
      ii- they are used to create individual words
       with the appropriate rhthem and intonation.

20
How Language Pairs Sound to Meaning
            2
       2- Morphological rules
      3- syntactic rules
      These are responsible creating the structural
        organization of words and sentences
      The word –phrase relationships indicate:
       - the basic operation of these various rules
        -The organization of the lexicon
     A fundamental concept in psycholinguistics is that the
        meaning is the resullt of the function of individual
        words and how they organized stuturally.

21
How Language Pairs Sound to Meaning
             3

        People aware of sentence individuals: consonants,
         vowels, syllables ,words which can be identified
         acoustically.
        Sentence structure is not since it is regarded an
         abstract unit, or has no actual physical reality.
        Sentence structure has a psychological reality : it
         must be represented by the speaker and then
         recovered by the hearer in order for the meaning to
         be conveyed.

22
How Language Pairs Sound to Meaning
             4

      Learning   a new language is not memorizing
       new vocabulary ,but how these vocabularies
       are structured for meaningful sentences.
      Bilinguals are more aware, sensitive
       conscious towards this mechanisms than
       monolinguals:
      -issues related to ambiguity are easily
       identified
      Word-for-word translation is not working
23
How Language Pairs Sound to Meaning
             5
        -The senators objected to the plans proposed by the generals.

        -The senators proposed the plans objected by the generals.
        -*The to plans senators objected proposed the by gerenals the.

        Thus a person with good knowledge of the lexicon of a
         language with no sufficient proficiency in combining these
         vocabulary into meaning structures, will not be able to have
         solid idea representation.




24
How Language Pairs Sound to Meaning
             6

      Anotherinstance of how meaning depends
       upon sentence structure is ambigious
       sentences:
      -The man saw the boy with the binaculars.




25
Linguistic Competence and Linguistic
     Performance 1

        The formal properties of grammar ana a lexicon =
         internalized grammar= linguistic competence
        Linguistic competence is a technical term to refer to
         the use of the knowledge of language resorted in
         person’s mind in the actual processing of sentences
         (production and understanding)
        Linguistic performance is the use of such knowledge
         in the actual processing of sentences ( production
         and understanding)

26
Linguistic Competence and Linguistic
     Performance 2

      Linguistic   competence is the fruit basket of
       linguistics
      Linguistic performance is the fruit basket of
       psycholinguistics.
      Pragmatics is the description of how
       language is actually used.



27
Linguistic Competence and Linguistic
     Performance 3

      Grammatical   aspects vs pragmatic aspects
      The man saw the boy with the binaculars.

     - identical grammatical aspects
     - different meanings or interpretation
     - one conveyed message by speaker
       (intention) and hearer (recovery)
      - if the message is conveyed differently , a
       case of misunderstanding.

28
Linguistic Competence and Linguistic
     Performance 4

      Encoding   vs decoding process




29
Linguistic Competence and Linguistic
      Performance 5 Process is so common
       Encoding vs Decoding
         (unconscious) so that people never think of its complex
         cognitive activity.
        No one can tackle even a part of the whole process.
        Recently psycholinguists have developed experimental
         procedures which had led them to understand a great
         deal about this unconscious , complex process.
        Why complex to be observed? Any abstract idea must
         have a physical representation deep in the neurological
         connections of the brain, while the hearer has no such
         representation.


30
The Speech Signal and Linguistic
     Representation       1

        The signal is the only physical link between the
         speaker and the hearer.
        This is a critical psycholinguistic point.
        This signal must contain enough information for the
         hearer to help him reconstruct the abstract structures
         into abstract ideas.
        Understanding the relationship between the signal
         and its decoded linguistic representation is
         necessary

31
The Speech Signal and Linguistic
     Representation       2

      What is the relationship between the
       phonological representation and the physical
       speech signal?

      The phonological representation can be
       thought of as an idealization of the physical
       signal.


32
The Speech Signal and Linguistic
     Representation       3

        Are the physical speech signal and abstract
         phonological representation similar or different?
        They are different.
        The abstract phonological representation is made up
         of discrete phonological units (consonants, vowels ,
         syllables, rhythmic units, words with varied vocal
         effects) whereas their corresponding portions in the
         physical signals overlap and the therefore the
         utterance is continuous

33
The Speech Signal and Linguistic
     Representation       4
        Is the relationship between the continuous physical signal the
         hearer receives its idealized phonological representation
         direct ?
        Not always.
        This continuous physical signal is subject to other linguistic and
         extralinguistic factors:
        Noise - chewing- radio- driving
        What will be done in the hearer’s mind?
        A set of complex mental processing mechanisms must consult
         the hearer’s grammar and lexicon in order to reconstruct the
         linguistic representation of the speaker’s meaning. This is the
         result of neurophysiological operations specialized for speech
         perception as a linguistic object.
        A process done unconsciously since the actual stimulus (the
         physical signal) is not available to us.
34
The Speech Signal and Linguistic
     Representation       5

        Perception requires that the hearer should have
         linguistic competence or knowledge .
        Otherwise , what he perceives is just a jumble of
         disorganized sounds.
        Animal knowledge is a matter of a set of acoustic
         signals associated with their names and commands.
        For human , understanding a message involves
         different processes related to sounds, words,
         sentences takes the form of mental representation
         reconstructed from the physical speech signal.

35
Origins of Contemporary
     Psycholinguistics     1
        The modern era of psycholinguistics started with the two
         seminars sponsored by the Social Science Research Councils
         (1951,1953) and then the subsequent publishing of Osgood
         and Sebeek’s Psycholinguistics (1965).
        Taxonomic analysis was dominating where their method of
         analysis was to listen to the speaker of the language, figure out
         the phonological units, and then classify them into higher –level
         categories.
        This was adopted by the behaviourist psychologists who
         believed that all behaviours (language is one of them) could be
         associated linked chains of smaller behaviours.
        The thread that bound linguists and psychologists was the view
         that everything interesting about language is directly
         observable in the physical speech signal.

36
Origins of Contemporary
     Psycholinguistics     2
        Sapir (1949) didn’t satisfied with this traditional view stating, in
         his paper The Psychological Reality of Phonemes, that the
         mental representation of language should be addressed rather
         than its physical representation.
        Chomsky opened the door for a new way to study the human
         language stating that speech shouldn’t be the object of the
         study, instead the rules in the mind that create sentences and
         underlie observable speech .
        George Miller (1965) supported this Chomskyan view , and
         their papers published in the second book of the Social Science
         Research Council (Saporta1965).
        The adaptation of Chomsky’s ideas in this 2010 book indicates
         clear their domination nature.


37

Beginning concepts in psycholinguistics

  • 1.
    Beginning Concepts in Psycholinguistics Ahmed Qadoury Abed PH D Candidate Bagdad University-College of Arts English Dept 2012/2013 1
  • 2.
    Definition of psycholinguistics  Psycholinguistics is an interdisciplinary field of study:  How do people acquire language?  How do people use language to speak and understand one another?  How is language presented and processed in the brain?  Brain vs mind 2
  • 3.
    Psycholinguistics and otherdisciplines  Psycholinguistics is a sub-field of psychology and linguistics  It is related to:  Developmental psychology  Cognitive psychology  Neurolinguistics  Speech science 3
  • 4.
    Creativity 1  Creativity is the nost important feature people have.  Creativity and other types:prose,poetry..  Linguistic creativity  All people have it since they know language  Know ≠ speak 4
  • 5.
    Human language creativityvs animal communication 2 1- Speakers of a language can create ,understand, and process novel sentences for an entire lifetime - Both children and adults - Unconscious process (depends on interlocutors) - True for sign language - Possibility of creating infinite set out of finite set Chomskyan orientation 5
  • 6.
    Creativity 3  2- the kind of creativity we have is the ability of communicating:  Whatever , wherever ,  Animals have a little range of topics  Human language is flexible:  i- diffeent purposes  Ii- social interaction  Dominating the planet 6
  • 7.
    Language & Speech  Speech is the most frequent mode for transmitting language (linguistic information)  -sign language is creative ,transmitted by gestures  Graphics  The crucial differences:  Human is articulatory and auditory  It is based on knowledge of language as a finite system to yield infinite set of possible 7
  • 8.
    Language & Writing  Writing is materially based compared with speaking or signing are biological  Writing is cultural artifact  Letter referring to sounds or symbolic  Writing is for formal ,history recording,court  Children learn to speak before to write (unconscious vs conscious)  The complexity or sophistication of human lang is independent of writing 8
  • 9.
    Language & Thought  Thought is verbalized through lang  People can think but not speak like infants ,  children with Specific Language impairment SLI  People with neurological pathologies  Animals can think but expressed by movements , cries,..  Bilinguals can express one thought in two langs  Translation as a means for thought transmission  Fordor (1975) The Language of Thought Hypothesis (LOTH):intelligence responsible for generating the language of thought 9
  • 10.
    Language & Communication  Language is the primary communication system:  Logic, mathematical, graphic, programming,visual arts traffic lights gestures  Verbal vs non verbal  Psycholinguists concerned with language as a biologically- based characteristic of human 10
  • 11.
    Some Characteristics ofthe Linguistic System  Language is a formal system for pairing signals and meanings:  Encoding vs Deccoding  Both speaker /listener have the same linguistic form for pairing sound and meaning  Their linguistic system enables sounds and meanings to be paired,and this is done by a complex and highly organized set of principles and rules (grammar and lexicon)  Knowledge of such system is an implicit or tacit  Explicit knowledge is temporary and artificial like telephone numbers  Tacit knowledge in the brain /mind and unconscious 11
  • 12.
    Descriptive vs Prescriptive 1  ‘Grammar’ refers differently to teachers and linguists.  Teachers are concerned with a standardized set of rules.Prescriptive  Linguists are concerned with studying the language system that underlies ordinary use.Descriptive 12
  • 13.
    Descriptive vs Prescriptive 2  Examples of Prescriptive grammar:  1-The use of pronouns like me,her initially  -Me and Mary went to the movie.  /mary and me went to the movie.  In descriptive terms, these sentences are generated by the speaker’s internalized grammar .  Members of one language community acquire colloquial form of this internalized grammar  Prescriptive rules are tedious ,difficult ,conscious learning is needed. 13
  • 14.
    Descriptive vs Prescriptive 3  2-the notion of correctness The bulk of linguistic ability acquired is not influenced or associated by linguistic correctness.  There are differences between acquired colloquial internalized grammar and prescriptive rules.  This notion is related to dialect variations:  Geographic  Ethnic  Community  These all can result in systematic , lexical ,and syntactic differences from the transitional standard version of the acquired language 14
  • 15.
    Descriptive vs Prescriptive 4  Which is more important:  Standard English or colloquial English  1- standard is used by few  2-Colloquial acquired naturally (the fruit of psycholinguists)  3- linguists and psycholinguists are interested in understanding how these internalized grammars are acquired and then put into use 15
  • 16.
    The Universality ofHuman Language 1  We have thousands of languages or versions spoken by different language communities ,all treated as a single entity by linguists  This is justified by all have an organization of grammar and lexicon  Chomskyan finite into infinite 16
  • 17.
    Universality 2  Universality has profound consequences for the way psycholinguists analyze the human use of language  Psycholinguists state that all languages are cut from the same mold because the organization of lexicons and the formal properties of grammatical systems are similar in all human languages .  What is specific and what is universal about knowledge of the language the mechanisms that put the knowledge of language to use. 17
  • 18.
    The Implication forthe Acquisition of Language  Language acquisition is an important area in psycholinguistics.  Children in every culture acquire the formal properties and lexicon of their languages (competence)  This competence or ability will be developed into natural performance  This is the story behind the profound similarity in child acquisition  Other skills like riding a bike are learned behaviours. 18
  • 19.
    Language acquisition 2  The story is completely different and complicated with L2 acquisition after childhood.  Children acquire another language/dialect naturally vs conscious learning of adults  Certain aspects (pronunciation) are difficult to master.  Exceptions are those who be native-like  Research now focus on psych- social factors: proximity of exposure to L2 ,and now on age effects in L2 acquisition( as memory ability). 19
  • 20.
    How Language PairsSound to Meaning 1  The grammar of any language has three kinds of rules:  1- phonological rules i - they describe the sound patterns of the language ii- they are used to create individual words with the appropriate rhthem and intonation. 20
  • 21.
    How Language PairsSound to Meaning 2  2- Morphological rules  3- syntactic rules  These are responsible creating the structural organization of words and sentences  The word –phrase relationships indicate: - the basic operation of these various rules -The organization of the lexicon A fundamental concept in psycholinguistics is that the meaning is the resullt of the function of individual words and how they organized stuturally. 21
  • 22.
    How Language PairsSound to Meaning 3  People aware of sentence individuals: consonants, vowels, syllables ,words which can be identified acoustically.  Sentence structure is not since it is regarded an abstract unit, or has no actual physical reality.  Sentence structure has a psychological reality : it must be represented by the speaker and then recovered by the hearer in order for the meaning to be conveyed. 22
  • 23.
    How Language PairsSound to Meaning 4  Learning a new language is not memorizing new vocabulary ,but how these vocabularies are structured for meaningful sentences.  Bilinguals are more aware, sensitive conscious towards this mechanisms than monolinguals:  -issues related to ambiguity are easily identified  Word-for-word translation is not working 23
  • 24.
    How Language PairsSound to Meaning 5  -The senators objected to the plans proposed by the generals.  -The senators proposed the plans objected by the generals.  -*The to plans senators objected proposed the by gerenals the.  Thus a person with good knowledge of the lexicon of a language with no sufficient proficiency in combining these vocabulary into meaning structures, will not be able to have solid idea representation. 24
  • 25.
    How Language PairsSound to Meaning 6  Anotherinstance of how meaning depends upon sentence structure is ambigious sentences:  -The man saw the boy with the binaculars. 25
  • 26.
    Linguistic Competence andLinguistic Performance 1  The formal properties of grammar ana a lexicon = internalized grammar= linguistic competence  Linguistic competence is a technical term to refer to the use of the knowledge of language resorted in person’s mind in the actual processing of sentences (production and understanding)  Linguistic performance is the use of such knowledge in the actual processing of sentences ( production and understanding) 26
  • 27.
    Linguistic Competence andLinguistic Performance 2  Linguistic competence is the fruit basket of linguistics  Linguistic performance is the fruit basket of psycholinguistics.  Pragmatics is the description of how language is actually used. 27
  • 28.
    Linguistic Competence andLinguistic Performance 3  Grammatical aspects vs pragmatic aspects  The man saw the boy with the binaculars. - identical grammatical aspects - different meanings or interpretation - one conveyed message by speaker (intention) and hearer (recovery) - if the message is conveyed differently , a case of misunderstanding. 28
  • 29.
    Linguistic Competence andLinguistic Performance 4  Encoding vs decoding process 29
  • 30.
    Linguistic Competence andLinguistic  Performance 5 Process is so common Encoding vs Decoding (unconscious) so that people never think of its complex cognitive activity.  No one can tackle even a part of the whole process.  Recently psycholinguists have developed experimental procedures which had led them to understand a great deal about this unconscious , complex process.  Why complex to be observed? Any abstract idea must have a physical representation deep in the neurological connections of the brain, while the hearer has no such representation. 30
  • 31.
    The Speech Signaland Linguistic Representation 1  The signal is the only physical link between the speaker and the hearer.  This is a critical psycholinguistic point.  This signal must contain enough information for the hearer to help him reconstruct the abstract structures into abstract ideas.  Understanding the relationship between the signal and its decoded linguistic representation is necessary 31
  • 32.
    The Speech Signaland Linguistic Representation 2  What is the relationship between the phonological representation and the physical speech signal?  The phonological representation can be thought of as an idealization of the physical signal. 32
  • 33.
    The Speech Signaland Linguistic Representation 3  Are the physical speech signal and abstract phonological representation similar or different?  They are different.  The abstract phonological representation is made up of discrete phonological units (consonants, vowels , syllables, rhythmic units, words with varied vocal effects) whereas their corresponding portions in the physical signals overlap and the therefore the utterance is continuous 33
  • 34.
    The Speech Signaland Linguistic Representation 4  Is the relationship between the continuous physical signal the hearer receives its idealized phonological representation direct ?  Not always.  This continuous physical signal is subject to other linguistic and extralinguistic factors:  Noise - chewing- radio- driving  What will be done in the hearer’s mind?  A set of complex mental processing mechanisms must consult the hearer’s grammar and lexicon in order to reconstruct the linguistic representation of the speaker’s meaning. This is the result of neurophysiological operations specialized for speech perception as a linguistic object.  A process done unconsciously since the actual stimulus (the physical signal) is not available to us. 34
  • 35.
    The Speech Signaland Linguistic Representation 5  Perception requires that the hearer should have linguistic competence or knowledge .  Otherwise , what he perceives is just a jumble of disorganized sounds.  Animal knowledge is a matter of a set of acoustic signals associated with their names and commands.  For human , understanding a message involves different processes related to sounds, words, sentences takes the form of mental representation reconstructed from the physical speech signal. 35
  • 36.
    Origins of Contemporary Psycholinguistics 1  The modern era of psycholinguistics started with the two seminars sponsored by the Social Science Research Councils (1951,1953) and then the subsequent publishing of Osgood and Sebeek’s Psycholinguistics (1965).  Taxonomic analysis was dominating where their method of analysis was to listen to the speaker of the language, figure out the phonological units, and then classify them into higher –level categories.  This was adopted by the behaviourist psychologists who believed that all behaviours (language is one of them) could be associated linked chains of smaller behaviours.  The thread that bound linguists and psychologists was the view that everything interesting about language is directly observable in the physical speech signal. 36
  • 37.
    Origins of Contemporary Psycholinguistics 2  Sapir (1949) didn’t satisfied with this traditional view stating, in his paper The Psychological Reality of Phonemes, that the mental representation of language should be addressed rather than its physical representation.  Chomsky opened the door for a new way to study the human language stating that speech shouldn’t be the object of the study, instead the rules in the mind that create sentences and underlie observable speech .  George Miller (1965) supported this Chomskyan view , and their papers published in the second book of the Social Science Research Council (Saporta1965).  The adaptation of Chomsky’s ideas in this 2010 book indicates clear their domination nature. 37