Urban Transport
Traffic Study – Traffic Impact
                 Assessment
              Riza Atiq bin O.K. Rahmat
Traffic Impact Assessment (TIA)

All development will generate traffic
 into current or future transport facilities

All big development will generate
 internal traffic
TIA will answer the question of:
What will the effect of a development
 to the surrounding transport facilities
What is the magnitude additional traffic
 due to the development to the existing
 traffic
How will the additional traffic effect
 the current traffic
What is the proposal to alleviate or
 minimise the impact
TIA activities
             Developer


      Architect / town planner


          Local Authority
                                                            Traffic Survey

     Instruction by the local
     authority to execute TIA           Analyses:
                                        •Trip generation
                                        •Modal split
     Appointment of a                   •Trip distribution
     transport engineer                 •Trip assignment
                                        •Analyses of LOS (Level of service)
                                        •Problem evaluation
Discussion to determine the scope,      •Proposal to alleviate or reduce the identified problems
study area and study methodology

                                              Review the original lay-out plan and
Collate existing data and information
                                              propose any improvement to the client
                                              and land use


                                                            Final Report
TIA Content

Existing Situation
Analyses
Impact to the Road Network
Road Safety
Internal Lay-out
Parking Space
Public Transport
Pedestrian, bicycle and disable facilities
TIA Content: 1.Existing Situation

Existing government transport policies for
 the development area
Structure plan and local plan prepared by
 the Local Authority
Existing traffic and public transport
 facilities
TIA Content: 1.Existing Situation (Cont
….)


                               1200


                               1000
      Traffic Volume (PCU/Hr




                               800


                               600


                               400


                               200


                                 0
                                      6-7   7-8   8-9   9-10   10-11 11-12 12-13 13-14 14-15 15-16 16-17 17-18 18-19 19-20 20-21 21-22
                                                                         Masa
                                                                                                 Menuju P/Bandar
                                                                                                 Dari P/Bandar



                                                               Existing traffic flows
TIA Content: 1.Existing Situation (Cont..)
….)




            658
          345 542
               5
  287
  527               423
  621               598
                    597

        621 451
           758
TIA Content: Existing Situation (Cont ….)
 Road safety record
 Pedestrian facilities
 Identify all planned transport facilities in the
  vicinity of the development
 Identify all other developments in the vicinity
  of the development and quantify the combine
  impact to the external traffic
 Identify all existing public transport facilities
  and the impact of the development to the
  facilities
 Identify potential traffic problem in the
  development
TIA Content: 2. Analyses
                                                           Trip Generation
    Land use           Attraction per 100 sq.m   Production per 100 sq.m
                          floor area (morning)      floor area (afternoon)

      Office               3.7 person / hr            4.05 person / hr

     Hospital              1.52 person / hr           1.32 person / hr

 Shopping Centre           0.45 person / hr           0.95 person / hr

  Primary school           5.5 person / hr            5.5 person / hr

   High School             4.5 person / hr            4.5 person / hr

College / University       2.0 person / hr            1.8 person / hr
TIA Content: 2. Analyses (Cont ….)
                                           Trip Generation
   Land use     Production per unit   Attraction per unit
                     (morning)             (afternoon)
   Apartment      2.11 person / hr     1.79 person / hr
  Condominium                          1.73 person / hr
TIA Content: 2. Analyses (Cont ….)
                                                         Example: Trip Generation
Morning
Land use                          Residential unit   Production          Morning
                                                        rate                production
Flat                                           845                2.51               2121
Single story link house                        725                2.21               1602
Double story link house                        934                2.52               2354
Condominium                                    837                2.05               1716
                          Total                                                      7793
Afternoon
Land use                          Residential unit   Production     Afternoon
                                                        rate            Attraction
Flat                                           845           2.1                     1775
Single story link house                        725          1.81                     1312
Double story link house                        934          2.15                     2008
Condominium                                    837          1.73                     1448
                          Total                                                      6543
TIA Content: 2. Analyses (Cont ….)
 Trip Distribution
    Gravity model                              PiAj
       Where                          Tij = KiKj α
       Tij = Trip from zone i to               Tij
        zone j
       Pi = Production of zone
        i                                              1
                                           Ki =
       Aj = Attraction of zone j
       Tij = Travel time or travel
                                                  ∑j
                                                    K j A j / Tijα
        cost between zone i and
        zone j
       α = Parameter to be                            1
                                           Kj =
        calibrated. In Klang
        Valley, α = 2.05 for                      ∑i K i Pi / Tijα
        morning and afternoon
        peaks.
TIA Content: 2. Analyses (Cont ….)
                                                     α
Production Constrain               Aj / T          ij
                        Tij = Pi
 Model:
                                   ∑   j
                                               Aj / T     α
                                                         ij




Attraction Constrain                                α
                                       Pi / T       ij
 Model:                 Tij = A j
                                    ∑ P /T i    i
                                                          α
                                                         ij
TIA Content: 2. Example




                          Project
                          Site
TIA Content: 2. Example
Trip Generation

Land use          QTY   Rates   Production

Flat              205    2.51
                                      515
Link house        431    2.21
                                      953
Semi-D            125    2.55
                                      319
Bungalow           52    2.65
                                      138
                        Total
                                     1924
TIA Content: 2. Example (Cont ….)
Trip Distribution

Destination         Travel Time Estimated             Aj /          Distribution          Trip
                       (min)    attraction                Tij2.05                  Distribution

Ipoh                      35               92000        62.871        0.271               522

Batu Gajah                30               16500        15.466        0.067               128

Gopeng                    10               17200 153.295              0.662              1273

                                       ΣAj/ Tij2.05   231.632         1.000              1924



Distribution = (Aj / Tij2.05 ) / (Σ Aj / Tij2.05)
TIA Content: 2. Example (Cont ….)

Modal Split (Modal Choice)
Influencing factors
  Car ownership
  Household Income
  Distance to the transport facilities
  Travel Time
  Travel Cost
  Car park availability
TIA Content: 2. Example (Cont ….)
 Peak Hour Modal Split in Kuala Lumpur
      Land use                Bus %       Car / van / jeep   Motor cycle
                                                   %             %
  1   Government Office        27.6             57.4            15.0

  2   Company Office           48.0             45.6             6.4
  3   Bank                     49.9             45.0             5.1
  4   Hotel                    35.9             60.1             4.0
  5   Shopping Centre          54.3             40.7             5.0
  6   Bungalow house           12.1             84.0             3.9
  7   Semi-D house             16.2             79.4             4.4
  8   Link House               42.1             48.5             9.4
  9   Condominium              13.7             85.1             1.2
 10   Apartment                39.9             45.0            15.1
 11   Flat                     49.5             28.3            21.7

(Source JKAL, DBKL Annual Report, 1991)
TIA Content: 2. Example (Cont ….)
Average Passenger (including driver) in Kuala Lumpur

     Land Use         Car / Van /    M / Cycle     Bus (big)   Bus (Mini)
                          Jeep

1    Office              1.55          1.25            75         35


2    Hotel               1.55          1.25            40          25


3    Shopping            2.14          1.30            75         35
        Centre
4    Houses              2.05          1.38            75         35


(Source: JKAL, DBKL Annual Report, 1991)
TIA Content: 2. Example (Cont ….)

A local authority has approved a proposed
development of a housing estate. It consists
of 1250 link houses, 155 semi-D houses, 78
bungalow houses, 390 units condominiums,
820 units apartments and 970 units of flats.
Calculate both inbound and outbound traffic
flows during morning peak hours.
TIA Content: 2. Example (Cont ….)
Land use     Unit   Product    Prod         Modal Split                Person trip         Number of Vehicles
                    ion rate   ucio
                                      Bus     car     M/C        Bus      car    M/C       Bus   car        M/C
                               n


Link house   1250      2.21    2763   42.1     48.5        9.4   1163      134       260    16     654       188
                                        %        %          %                0
Semi-D        155      2.55     395   16.2     79.4        4.4     64      314        17     1     153        13
                                        %        %          %
Bungalow       78      2.65     207   12.1     84.0        3.9     25      174         8     1         85         6
                                        %        %          %
Condo         390      2.05     800   13.7     85.1        1.2    110      680        10     1     332            7
                                        %        %          %
Apartment     820      2.11    1730   39.9     45.0       15.1    690      779       261     9     380       189
                                        %        %          %
Flat          970      2.51    2435   49.5     28.3       21.7   1205      689       528    16     336
                                        %        %          %


                                                                                 total      44    1939       786
TIA Content: 2. Example (Cont ….)
                                         to Ipoh




                                                      To PLUS H’way

                        981
                        pcu/hr

                            247
                            pcu/hr       759 pcu/hr
              Proposed
              Development

                                                      Assumption: Traffic growth 4.1%
                      365                             Base year: 2010
                      pcu/hr
    to Batu                            603 pcu/hr
    Gajah              61 pcu/hr

                       1021
                       pcu/hr


                                 to Gopeng
TIA Content: 2. Example (Cont ….)
                                                 To Ipoh

2014

Traffic generated by
the development
                                                                 To PLUS H’way




                                 247 pcu/hr


                   Proposed
                   Development
                                                    790 pcu/hr


                          380 pcu/hr

         To Batu                              603 pcu/hr
         Gajah              61 pcu/hr
                             1063
                             pcu/hr



                                        to Gopeng
TIA Content: 3. Impact to the Road
Network
Level-Of-Service (LOS) =
  Flow/Capacity (or V/C)

v/c < 0.9 OK


                                       V/C > 1.0
                                       (LOS = F)




                           V/C < 0.3
                           (LOS = A)
TIA Content: 4. Road Safety

Safe to the
 residences
Safe to the visitors
TIA Content: 5. Internal Lay-out
TIA Content: 6. Parking Space

Malaysia:
1 cps / 50sq.m floor
  area
or
1.25 / residential
  unit
TIA Content: 7. Public Transport
TIA Content: 8. Pedestrian, bicycle and
                disable facilities
Terimakasih
 Thank you

02 traffic impact assessment

  • 1.
    Urban Transport Traffic Study– Traffic Impact Assessment Riza Atiq bin O.K. Rahmat
  • 2.
    Traffic Impact Assessment(TIA) All development will generate traffic into current or future transport facilities All big development will generate internal traffic
  • 3.
    TIA will answerthe question of: What will the effect of a development to the surrounding transport facilities What is the magnitude additional traffic due to the development to the existing traffic How will the additional traffic effect the current traffic What is the proposal to alleviate or minimise the impact
  • 4.
    TIA activities Developer Architect / town planner Local Authority Traffic Survey Instruction by the local authority to execute TIA Analyses: •Trip generation •Modal split Appointment of a •Trip distribution transport engineer •Trip assignment •Analyses of LOS (Level of service) •Problem evaluation Discussion to determine the scope, •Proposal to alleviate or reduce the identified problems study area and study methodology Review the original lay-out plan and Collate existing data and information propose any improvement to the client and land use Final Report
  • 5.
    TIA Content Existing Situation Analyses Impactto the Road Network Road Safety Internal Lay-out Parking Space Public Transport Pedestrian, bicycle and disable facilities
  • 6.
    TIA Content: 1.ExistingSituation Existing government transport policies for the development area Structure plan and local plan prepared by the Local Authority Existing traffic and public transport facilities
  • 7.
    TIA Content: 1.ExistingSituation (Cont ….) 1200 1000 Traffic Volume (PCU/Hr 800 600 400 200 0 6-7 7-8 8-9 9-10 10-11 11-12 12-13 13-14 14-15 15-16 16-17 17-18 18-19 19-20 20-21 21-22 Masa Menuju P/Bandar Dari P/Bandar Existing traffic flows
  • 8.
    TIA Content: 1.ExistingSituation (Cont..) ….) 658 345 542 5 287 527 423 621 598 597 621 451 758
  • 9.
    TIA Content: ExistingSituation (Cont ….)  Road safety record  Pedestrian facilities  Identify all planned transport facilities in the vicinity of the development  Identify all other developments in the vicinity of the development and quantify the combine impact to the external traffic  Identify all existing public transport facilities and the impact of the development to the facilities  Identify potential traffic problem in the development
  • 10.
    TIA Content: 2.Analyses Trip Generation Land use Attraction per 100 sq.m Production per 100 sq.m floor area (morning) floor area (afternoon) Office 3.7 person / hr 4.05 person / hr Hospital 1.52 person / hr 1.32 person / hr Shopping Centre 0.45 person / hr 0.95 person / hr Primary school 5.5 person / hr 5.5 person / hr High School 4.5 person / hr 4.5 person / hr College / University 2.0 person / hr 1.8 person / hr
  • 11.
    TIA Content: 2.Analyses (Cont ….) Trip Generation Land use Production per unit Attraction per unit (morning) (afternoon) Apartment 2.11 person / hr 1.79 person / hr Condominium 1.73 person / hr
  • 12.
    TIA Content: 2.Analyses (Cont ….) Example: Trip Generation Morning Land use Residential unit Production Morning rate production Flat 845 2.51 2121 Single story link house 725 2.21 1602 Double story link house 934 2.52 2354 Condominium 837 2.05 1716 Total 7793 Afternoon Land use Residential unit Production Afternoon rate Attraction Flat 845 2.1 1775 Single story link house 725 1.81 1312 Double story link house 934 2.15 2008 Condominium 837 1.73 1448 Total 6543
  • 13.
    TIA Content: 2.Analyses (Cont ….)  Trip Distribution  Gravity model PiAj Where Tij = KiKj α Tij = Trip from zone i to Tij zone j Pi = Production of zone i 1 Ki = Aj = Attraction of zone j Tij = Travel time or travel ∑j K j A j / Tijα cost between zone i and zone j α = Parameter to be 1 Kj = calibrated. In Klang Valley, α = 2.05 for ∑i K i Pi / Tijα morning and afternoon peaks.
  • 14.
    TIA Content: 2.Analyses (Cont ….) α Production Constrain Aj / T ij Tij = Pi Model: ∑ j Aj / T α ij Attraction Constrain α Pi / T ij Model: Tij = A j ∑ P /T i i α ij
  • 15.
    TIA Content: 2.Example Project Site
  • 16.
    TIA Content: 2.Example Trip Generation Land use QTY Rates Production Flat 205 2.51 515 Link house 431 2.21 953 Semi-D 125 2.55 319 Bungalow 52 2.65 138 Total 1924
  • 17.
    TIA Content: 2.Example (Cont ….) Trip Distribution Destination Travel Time Estimated Aj / Distribution Trip (min) attraction Tij2.05 Distribution Ipoh 35 92000 62.871 0.271 522 Batu Gajah 30 16500 15.466 0.067 128 Gopeng 10 17200 153.295 0.662 1273 ΣAj/ Tij2.05 231.632 1.000 1924 Distribution = (Aj / Tij2.05 ) / (Σ Aj / Tij2.05)
  • 18.
    TIA Content: 2.Example (Cont ….) Modal Split (Modal Choice) Influencing factors Car ownership Household Income Distance to the transport facilities Travel Time Travel Cost Car park availability
  • 19.
    TIA Content: 2.Example (Cont ….) Peak Hour Modal Split in Kuala Lumpur Land use Bus % Car / van / jeep Motor cycle % % 1 Government Office 27.6 57.4 15.0 2 Company Office 48.0 45.6 6.4 3 Bank 49.9 45.0 5.1 4 Hotel 35.9 60.1 4.0 5 Shopping Centre 54.3 40.7 5.0 6 Bungalow house 12.1 84.0 3.9 7 Semi-D house 16.2 79.4 4.4 8 Link House 42.1 48.5 9.4 9 Condominium 13.7 85.1 1.2 10 Apartment 39.9 45.0 15.1 11 Flat 49.5 28.3 21.7 (Source JKAL, DBKL Annual Report, 1991)
  • 20.
    TIA Content: 2.Example (Cont ….) Average Passenger (including driver) in Kuala Lumpur Land Use Car / Van / M / Cycle Bus (big) Bus (Mini) Jeep 1 Office 1.55 1.25 75 35 2 Hotel 1.55 1.25 40 25 3 Shopping 2.14 1.30 75 35 Centre 4 Houses 2.05 1.38 75 35 (Source: JKAL, DBKL Annual Report, 1991)
  • 21.
    TIA Content: 2.Example (Cont ….) A local authority has approved a proposed development of a housing estate. It consists of 1250 link houses, 155 semi-D houses, 78 bungalow houses, 390 units condominiums, 820 units apartments and 970 units of flats. Calculate both inbound and outbound traffic flows during morning peak hours.
  • 22.
    TIA Content: 2.Example (Cont ….) Land use Unit Product Prod Modal Split Person trip Number of Vehicles ion rate ucio Bus car M/C Bus car M/C Bus car M/C n Link house 1250 2.21 2763 42.1 48.5 9.4 1163 134 260 16 654 188 % % % 0 Semi-D 155 2.55 395 16.2 79.4 4.4 64 314 17 1 153 13 % % % Bungalow 78 2.65 207 12.1 84.0 3.9 25 174 8 1 85 6 % % % Condo 390 2.05 800 13.7 85.1 1.2 110 680 10 1 332 7 % % % Apartment 820 2.11 1730 39.9 45.0 15.1 690 779 261 9 380 189 % % % Flat 970 2.51 2435 49.5 28.3 21.7 1205 689 528 16 336 % % % total 44 1939 786
  • 23.
    TIA Content: 2.Example (Cont ….) to Ipoh To PLUS H’way 981 pcu/hr 247 pcu/hr 759 pcu/hr Proposed Development Assumption: Traffic growth 4.1% 365 Base year: 2010 pcu/hr to Batu 603 pcu/hr Gajah 61 pcu/hr 1021 pcu/hr to Gopeng
  • 24.
    TIA Content: 2.Example (Cont ….) To Ipoh 2014 Traffic generated by the development To PLUS H’way 247 pcu/hr Proposed Development 790 pcu/hr 380 pcu/hr To Batu 603 pcu/hr Gajah 61 pcu/hr 1063 pcu/hr to Gopeng
  • 25.
    TIA Content: 3.Impact to the Road Network Level-Of-Service (LOS) = Flow/Capacity (or V/C) v/c < 0.9 OK V/C > 1.0 (LOS = F) V/C < 0.3 (LOS = A)
  • 26.
    TIA Content: 4.Road Safety Safe to the residences Safe to the visitors
  • 27.
    TIA Content: 5.Internal Lay-out
  • 28.
    TIA Content: 6.Parking Space Malaysia: 1 cps / 50sq.m floor area or 1.25 / residential unit
  • 29.
    TIA Content: 7.Public Transport
  • 30.
    TIA Content: 8.Pedestrian, bicycle and disable facilities
  • 31.