Blended Learning: The
                     Future of Higher
                        Education

                                  Professor Mike Keppell
                              Professor of Higher Education
                          Director, The Flexible Learning Institute
                                  Charles Sturt University



Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                               1
Overview
                          Assumptions and principles

                          What is blended learning?

                          Benefits of blended learning - from an activity,
                          subject, course, university perspective

                          Paradigms of blended learning - enabling,
                          enhancing, transforming

                          Affordances of learning spaces

                          Examples of blended learning

Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                      2
Assumptions
              Universities value and seek to inculcate the skills
              essential for lifelong and life wide learning,
              producing graduates who will continue to develop
              intellectually, professionally and socially beyond the
              bounds of formal education.

              Universities believe that programs, services and
              teaching methods should be responsive to the
              diverse cultural, social and academic needs of
              students, enabling them to adapt to the demands of
              university education and providing them with the
              cultural capital for life success.

Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                3
Higher Education Principles
               Equivalence of Learning Outcomes    ethical obligations

                                                   traverses physical,
                     Student Learning Experience   blended and virtual
                                                     learning spaces
                                                   learning outcomes,
                                                     subject, degree
                          Constructive Alignment
                                                    program, generic
                                                       attributes

                                                    specific needs of
                          Discipline Pedagogies
                                                       disciplines

Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                  4
What is Blended Learning?
              Combination of face-to-face teaching and learning with
              online teaching and learning

              “It is a design approach whereby both face-to-face and
              online learning are made better by the presence of
              each other” (Garrison & Vaughan, 2008, p.5).

              “Thoughtful fusion of face-to-face and online
              experiences” (p.5).

              “Combines the properties and possibilities of both to go
              beyond the capabilities of each separately” (p.6)

              “It is a complete rethinking and redesign of the
              educational environment and learning experience” (p.x)
Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                  5
What is Unique about
                           Blended Learning?
             Convergence of classroom and communications
             technology

             Transformation of how we approach teaching and
             learning

             Synchronous and asynchronous communication

             Diversified range of learning spaces that are both
             physical and virtual


Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                           6
Activity-Level Blended
                                  Learning
     Activity-level blending
     Includes both face-to-face and online        Discussion / Project/ Reflection /
     components. e.g online debate and                 Debate Topic Posted
     face-to-face debate; off-line reading and
     online discussion.
                                                    Individual Response Posted

                                                        Blackboard Platform

                                                 Student-Student Interaction: React
                                                  to Three Responses from Peers

                                                               Results

                                                   Synthesis of Discussion (e.g.
                                                 85% peers agreed) Collaboration
                                                   Products (e.g., Top five best)


Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                                7
Activity-Level Blending in
                         Practice
                                         Student Resources Resources
                      Instructor Role                                 Assessment
                                          Role   (Content) (Services)
           Allocate reading.
                                                                                  Some
            Ask students to
                              Read                                              discussion
             read required
  Off-line reading and post respective               Reading                  about topic in
                             chapter                                           face-to-face
              summary in
                                                                                   class
                 LMS

                                                                             Feedback from
                                        Post a one
                                                      Student                peers in online
                                        paragraph
                                                        and                   discussion.
                                         summary
                                                     instructor   Discussion Feedback from
   Online                 Facilitator      and
                                                      posts in      forum     instructor in
                                         comment
                                                    discussion                   online
                                          on two
                                                       forum                   discussion
                                        other posts
                                                                                 forum.
Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                                        8
Subject and Course
                              Level Blending
            Subject-Level Blending

                          One of the most common
                          Distinct face-to-face and online activities as part of
                          course/subject.
                          For example designing learning resources (50/50
                          blended approach)

            Course-level blending
                          Degree program level
                          Teaching Fellowship Scheme

Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                            9
Paradigms of Blended
                                Learning
     Enabling blends
     These address issues of access and equity and add
     flexibility. This might include the same opportunities in
     face-to-face, online and blended learning environments.
     Enhancing blends
     These focus on incremental changes to the pedagogy in
     both the face-to-face and online components.
     Transforming blends
     Transformation of the pedagogy. Major redesign of
     teaching and learning e.g. online PBL.

Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                          10
Problem-based
                 Traditional model
                                                                     learning model


                          Content                                       Problem




           Teacher                   Student                 Coach                Problem
                                                                                   solver
                                           Tan (2003) p.12



                                                   11
Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                                     11
Wednesday, 21 July 2010   12
What are Affordances?
                 When you first see something you have never seen
                 before, how do you know what to do?

                 “An affordance is the design aspect of an object
                 which suggests how the object should be
                 used” (Norman, 1988).

                 Determined by context, culture, instinct, mental
                 model e.g. hyperlinked text on website.

                 When designers make use of affordances the user
                 knows what to do just by looking

Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                             13
Diversity of Learning Spaces
                   Physical          Blended          Virtual


    Formal                Informal             Formal     Informal



                              Mobile       Personal

                                     Outdoor

Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                              14
Learning Space            Affordance              Example


                 Face-to-Face
                                                        Oral feedback to a
                 Teaching and    Oral communication
                                                             question
                   Learning


                                 Information access
                  Learning                               Subject outline
                                 Interactive learning
                 Management                             Multimedia forum
                                 Networked learning
                  Systems                                    project
                                Materials development


                                                        Discussion about
          Learning Commons        Informal learning          lecture
                                                          Peer learning


Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                      15
Learning Space                 Affordance                Example


                                        In-depth group       Discussion of reading
                          Tutorial        discussion             Discussion of
                                         Peer learning           presentation


                                        Practical work
                                       Peer interaction      Practical work on IT
           Residential School
                                     Sense of belonging to        networks
                                          university


                                       Authentic learning
                                                              Applied learning in
                      Practice       Community of Practice
                                                                  discipline
                                        Mentor/mentee


Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                              16
An Example of Blended
         Learning - Critical Decisions
                          What are the learning goals?

                          What are the learning activities?

                          What are the affordances of the technology?

                          What should be off-line and online?

                          What is the assessment?



Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                 17
An Example of Blended
                           Learning
                           Postgraduate Diploma in Education
            Programme
                           (Professional and Vocational Education)

                 Module    IIT5078 - Designing Learning Resources

                           Blended learning (Five face-to-face classes of four
                           hours duration - 20 hours and 10 hours of online
              Approach     discussion activities). Emphasis on peer learning,
                           project-based learning and learning-oriented
                           assessment.
                           In this module it was essential for the student to
                           interact within the Blackboard LMS as the online
               Essential
                           component was designed to be a significant
                           component of the module.
Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                          18
Learning Design

                              Problem-based


                               Project-based


                          Authentic Learning Cases

Wednesday, 21 July 2010                              19
Project-based Learning




                                   Howard, (2002)

Wednesday, 21 July 2010                             20
Interactivity Decisions

                           Information access

                           Interactive learning

                           Networked learning

                           Materials development

                                            (Oliver & Herrington, 2001)



Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                   21
Information Access
                          CONVEY INFORMATION ALONE TO THE
                                     LEARNER

                              Examples                  Rationale

                             Module outline       information accessibility

                           Assessment outline   timely delivery of information

                           PowerPoint slides          review of content

                             Task outlines        administrative efficiency



Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                          22
Information Access Examples
              Announcements       weekly announcement to students

                                  teaching schedule document
                                  module outline document
           Module Information     weekly topics document
                                  module assessment document
                                  project assessment rubric document

              Staff Information   lecturer background and contact details

                          Books   reading list

                     Resources    websites

           Course Material for
                                  powerpoint files, etc
             Five Classes

Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                     23
Interactive Learning
                    INCREASED LEVEL OF ENGAGEMENT WITH
                                RESOURCES

                                Examples                      Rationale
                             Search and review
                                                         independent learning
                                documents
                            Database searching           independent learning

                          External links to websites     independent learning
                                                         simulations of real life
                                 Simulations
                                                                 activities
                                                       tutorial type activities and
                                 Multimedia
                                                          immediate feedback


Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                               24
Interactive Learning
                                 Examples
                          Problem-based learning cases
                          Project-based learning videos
                          Interactive concept maps
                          Synchronized audio-lecture and PowerPoint files
                          Online Survey
                          Online encyclopedia: Wikipedia
                          Encyclopedia of Educational Technology

Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                     25
Networked Learning
                          PROVIDE COMMUNICATION BETWEEN
                              STUDENTS AND TEACHERS

                            Examples                    Rationale
                          Announcements        one way communication in Bb
                                                 initial communication with
                          Staff information
                                                           students
                               Email             one-to-one, one-to-many

           Discussion forums, group tasks social construction of knowledge

                          Online debates      social construction of knowledge

                          Real-time chats     social construction of knowledge


Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                          26
Networked Learning
                              Examples
                          Four online discussion groups
                          related to module readings
                          Two in-class discussion groups
                          Discussion forums for module-
                          related questions
                          Group spaces for projects

Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                    27
Materials Development
                   DEVELOPING AND PRESENTING PRODUCTS
                              AND ARTEFACTS

                               Examples                    Examples

                           Stories/digital stories           Portfolios

                             Reflective journals     Teaching practice journals

                                  Reports                 Concept maps

                               Presentations                Interviews

                          Photographs/video/audio            Projects

                            > Combined with discussion forums
Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                           28
Materials Development
                            Examples
                      The group project provided an
                      opportunity to apply principles and
                      skills in the module to create a
                      learning resource (i.e. needs
                      analysis, concept map, video,
                      photos, report, presentation)


Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                     29
1.                                              4.
                               2. Criteria   3. Needs                5. Student
           Authentic                                        Concept
                                - Rubric     Analysis               Presentation
             Task                                            Map
                                                Feedback                            Feedback
                                                 as feed-                            as feed-
            Assessment
                                                 forward                             forward
            AS learning
               task

                                                          Teacher feedback
                                         Teacher feedback     - Verbal
          Student feedback                   - Written     Peer feedback -
              - Verbal                                         Verbal

                                                                 Needs analysis
                                             6. Learning          Concept map
                       Students as                               Digital learning
                      self-evaluators         Resource              resource
                                                                     Report


                                                                                            30



Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                                          30
Conclusion
                   Blended learning is a combination of face-to-face
                   teaching and learning with online teaching and
                   learning

                   Examples of blended learning include problem-
                   based, project-based and authentic learning tasks

                   Benefits of blended learning expound from an
                   activity, subject, course, and university perspective

                   Paradigms of blended learning include enabling,
                   enhancing, transforming

Wednesday, 21 July 2010                                                    31
Professor Mike Keppell
                      mkeppell@csu.edu.au



Wednesday, 21 July 2010                        32
Wednesday, 21 July 2010   33

Blended Learning: The Future of Higher Education

  • 1.
    Blended Learning: The Future of Higher Education Professor Mike Keppell Professor of Higher Education Director, The Flexible Learning Institute Charles Sturt University Wednesday, 21 July 2010 1
  • 2.
    Overview Assumptions and principles What is blended learning? Benefits of blended learning - from an activity, subject, course, university perspective Paradigms of blended learning - enabling, enhancing, transforming Affordances of learning spaces Examples of blended learning Wednesday, 21 July 2010 2
  • 3.
    Assumptions Universities value and seek to inculcate the skills essential for lifelong and life wide learning, producing graduates who will continue to develop intellectually, professionally and socially beyond the bounds of formal education. Universities believe that programs, services and teaching methods should be responsive to the diverse cultural, social and academic needs of students, enabling them to adapt to the demands of university education and providing them with the cultural capital for life success. Wednesday, 21 July 2010 3
  • 4.
    Higher Education Principles Equivalence of Learning Outcomes ethical obligations traverses physical, Student Learning Experience blended and virtual learning spaces learning outcomes, subject, degree Constructive Alignment program, generic attributes specific needs of Discipline Pedagogies disciplines Wednesday, 21 July 2010 4
  • 5.
    What is BlendedLearning? Combination of face-to-face teaching and learning with online teaching and learning “It is a design approach whereby both face-to-face and online learning are made better by the presence of each other” (Garrison & Vaughan, 2008, p.5). “Thoughtful fusion of face-to-face and online experiences” (p.5). “Combines the properties and possibilities of both to go beyond the capabilities of each separately” (p.6) “It is a complete rethinking and redesign of the educational environment and learning experience” (p.x) Wednesday, 21 July 2010 5
  • 6.
    What is Uniqueabout Blended Learning? Convergence of classroom and communications technology Transformation of how we approach teaching and learning Synchronous and asynchronous communication Diversified range of learning spaces that are both physical and virtual Wednesday, 21 July 2010 6
  • 7.
    Activity-Level Blended Learning Activity-level blending Includes both face-to-face and online Discussion / Project/ Reflection / components. e.g online debate and Debate Topic Posted face-to-face debate; off-line reading and online discussion. Individual Response Posted Blackboard Platform Student-Student Interaction: React to Three Responses from Peers Results Synthesis of Discussion (e.g. 85% peers agreed) Collaboration Products (e.g., Top five best) Wednesday, 21 July 2010 7
  • 8.
    Activity-Level Blending in Practice Student Resources Resources Instructor Role Assessment Role (Content) (Services) Allocate reading. Some Ask students to Read discussion read required Off-line reading and post respective Reading about topic in chapter face-to-face summary in class LMS Feedback from Post a one Student peers in online paragraph and discussion. summary instructor Discussion Feedback from Online Facilitator and posts in forum instructor in comment discussion online on two forum discussion other posts forum. Wednesday, 21 July 2010 8
  • 9.
    Subject and Course Level Blending Subject-Level Blending One of the most common Distinct face-to-face and online activities as part of course/subject. For example designing learning resources (50/50 blended approach) Course-level blending Degree program level Teaching Fellowship Scheme Wednesday, 21 July 2010 9
  • 10.
    Paradigms of Blended Learning Enabling blends These address issues of access and equity and add flexibility. This might include the same opportunities in face-to-face, online and blended learning environments. Enhancing blends These focus on incremental changes to the pedagogy in both the face-to-face and online components. Transforming blends Transformation of the pedagogy. Major redesign of teaching and learning e.g. online PBL. Wednesday, 21 July 2010 10
  • 11.
    Problem-based Traditional model learning model Content Problem Teacher Student Coach Problem solver Tan (2003) p.12 11 Wednesday, 21 July 2010 11
  • 12.
  • 13.
    What are Affordances? When you first see something you have never seen before, how do you know what to do? “An affordance is the design aspect of an object which suggests how the object should be used” (Norman, 1988). Determined by context, culture, instinct, mental model e.g. hyperlinked text on website. When designers make use of affordances the user knows what to do just by looking Wednesday, 21 July 2010 13
  • 14.
    Diversity of LearningSpaces Physical Blended Virtual Formal Informal Formal Informal Mobile Personal Outdoor Wednesday, 21 July 2010 14
  • 15.
    Learning Space Affordance Example Face-to-Face Oral feedback to a Teaching and Oral communication question Learning Information access Learning Subject outline Interactive learning Management Multimedia forum Networked learning Systems project Materials development Discussion about Learning Commons Informal learning lecture Peer learning Wednesday, 21 July 2010 15
  • 16.
    Learning Space Affordance Example In-depth group Discussion of reading Tutorial discussion Discussion of Peer learning presentation Practical work Peer interaction Practical work on IT Residential School Sense of belonging to networks university Authentic learning Applied learning in Practice Community of Practice discipline Mentor/mentee Wednesday, 21 July 2010 16
  • 17.
    An Example ofBlended Learning - Critical Decisions What are the learning goals? What are the learning activities? What are the affordances of the technology? What should be off-line and online? What is the assessment? Wednesday, 21 July 2010 17
  • 18.
    An Example ofBlended Learning Postgraduate Diploma in Education Programme (Professional and Vocational Education) Module IIT5078 - Designing Learning Resources Blended learning (Five face-to-face classes of four hours duration - 20 hours and 10 hours of online Approach discussion activities). Emphasis on peer learning, project-based learning and learning-oriented assessment. In this module it was essential for the student to interact within the Blackboard LMS as the online Essential component was designed to be a significant component of the module. Wednesday, 21 July 2010 18
  • 19.
    Learning Design Problem-based Project-based Authentic Learning Cases Wednesday, 21 July 2010 19
  • 20.
    Project-based Learning Howard, (2002) Wednesday, 21 July 2010 20
  • 21.
    Interactivity Decisions Information access Interactive learning Networked learning Materials development (Oliver & Herrington, 2001) Wednesday, 21 July 2010 21
  • 22.
    Information Access CONVEY INFORMATION ALONE TO THE LEARNER Examples Rationale Module outline information accessibility Assessment outline timely delivery of information PowerPoint slides review of content Task outlines administrative efficiency Wednesday, 21 July 2010 22
  • 23.
    Information Access Examples Announcements weekly announcement to students teaching schedule document module outline document Module Information weekly topics document module assessment document project assessment rubric document Staff Information lecturer background and contact details Books reading list Resources websites Course Material for powerpoint files, etc Five Classes Wednesday, 21 July 2010 23
  • 24.
    Interactive Learning INCREASED LEVEL OF ENGAGEMENT WITH RESOURCES Examples Rationale Search and review independent learning documents Database searching independent learning External links to websites independent learning simulations of real life Simulations activities tutorial type activities and Multimedia immediate feedback Wednesday, 21 July 2010 24
  • 25.
    Interactive Learning Examples Problem-based learning cases Project-based learning videos Interactive concept maps Synchronized audio-lecture and PowerPoint files Online Survey Online encyclopedia: Wikipedia Encyclopedia of Educational Technology Wednesday, 21 July 2010 25
  • 26.
    Networked Learning PROVIDE COMMUNICATION BETWEEN STUDENTS AND TEACHERS Examples Rationale Announcements one way communication in Bb initial communication with Staff information students Email one-to-one, one-to-many Discussion forums, group tasks social construction of knowledge Online debates social construction of knowledge Real-time chats social construction of knowledge Wednesday, 21 July 2010 26
  • 27.
    Networked Learning Examples Four online discussion groups related to module readings Two in-class discussion groups Discussion forums for module- related questions Group spaces for projects Wednesday, 21 July 2010 27
  • 28.
    Materials Development DEVELOPING AND PRESENTING PRODUCTS AND ARTEFACTS Examples Examples Stories/digital stories Portfolios Reflective journals Teaching practice journals Reports Concept maps Presentations Interviews Photographs/video/audio Projects > Combined with discussion forums Wednesday, 21 July 2010 28
  • 29.
    Materials Development Examples The group project provided an opportunity to apply principles and skills in the module to create a learning resource (i.e. needs analysis, concept map, video, photos, report, presentation) Wednesday, 21 July 2010 29
  • 30.
    1. 4. 2. Criteria 3. Needs 5. Student Authentic Concept - Rubric Analysis Presentation Task Map Feedback Feedback as feed- as feed- Assessment forward forward AS learning task Teacher feedback Teacher feedback - Verbal Student feedback - Written Peer feedback - - Verbal Verbal Needs analysis 6. Learning Concept map Students as Digital learning self-evaluators Resource resource Report 30 Wednesday, 21 July 2010 30
  • 31.
    Conclusion Blended learning is a combination of face-to-face teaching and learning with online teaching and learning Examples of blended learning include problem- based, project-based and authentic learning tasks Benefits of blended learning expound from an activity, subject, course, and university perspective Paradigms of blended learning include enabling, enhancing, transforming Wednesday, 21 July 2010 31
  • 32.
    Professor Mike Keppell mkeppell@csu.edu.au Wednesday, 21 July 2010 32
  • 33.