Qualitative Content Analysis session for MSc Media Psychology students at the University of Salford.
The aim of the session is to consider knowledge and research on a continuum from positivist to interpretivist, realist to relativist, quantitative to qualitative. It's taken me the best part of four years to get a handle on my epistemological and ontological positions so I am hoping my 'pain' will be someone else's 'gain'. This is the first lecture where my PhD work is really showing its worth for my teaching. Would be interested to hear others thoughts on how to teach and learn qualitative research methods.
A further aim is to expand what we consider to be 'data' and think about how we can generate new knowledge about new media in innovative and creative ways. Sometimes the more traditional methods don't translate very well to contemporary issues. The session therefore introduces the concept of researcher-as-bricoleur.
As an exercise to develop our interpretative skills, Plan B's ill Manors track will be analysed in the session from different perspectives. We will start with the text, then listen to the song, then watch the music video, then see the trailer to the film to build more complex interpretations of Plan Bs work and consider its relationship to the 'real world'. Hopefully the session will work will:)
Qualitative data analysis: many approaches to understand user insightsAgnieszka Szóstek
The fifth lecture at HITLab, Canterbury University in New Zealand was all about how important it is to run a proper analysis of the qualitative data. We discussed the value in looking at data from individual (phenomenological) perspective versus combined (reductionist) perspective. But we agreed that regardless of the chosen approach it is crucial to look at the data from more than just one perspective to be sure the interpretation is not biased by researcher's on view of the world.
Braun, Clarke & Hayfield Thematic Analysis Part 2Victoria Clarke
The second part of a four part lecture providing an introduction to thematic analysis and specifically the reflexive approach outlined by Braun and Clarke.
Content Analysis Overview for Persona DevelopmentPamela Rutledge
After developing an Ad Hoc persona as the core of your engagement strategy, it's important to test your assumptions against real people and real data. Content analysis is a methodology for evaluating text-based data that can be gathered from social media tools.
Qualitative data analysis: many approaches to understand user insightsAgnieszka Szóstek
The fifth lecture at HITLab, Canterbury University in New Zealand was all about how important it is to run a proper analysis of the qualitative data. We discussed the value in looking at data from individual (phenomenological) perspective versus combined (reductionist) perspective. But we agreed that regardless of the chosen approach it is crucial to look at the data from more than just one perspective to be sure the interpretation is not biased by researcher's on view of the world.
Braun, Clarke & Hayfield Thematic Analysis Part 2Victoria Clarke
The second part of a four part lecture providing an introduction to thematic analysis and specifically the reflexive approach outlined by Braun and Clarke.
Content Analysis Overview for Persona DevelopmentPamela Rutledge
After developing an Ad Hoc persona as the core of your engagement strategy, it's important to test your assumptions against real people and real data. Content analysis is a methodology for evaluating text-based data that can be gathered from social media tools.
Overview of the media psychology certificate in Brand Psychology & Audience Engagement offered through Fielding Graduate University. Lead faculty Pamela Rutledge, PhD and Jerri Lynn Hogg, PhD
Media psychology is the application of psychological science--the study of human behavior, emotions, and cognitions--to all forms of mediated communications and technologies. It takes into account the spectrum of activity from production, content, and consumption to distribution and impact. It is a continually changing, multi-disciplinary field with implications for individuals, organizations and society. We apply it to technology design, such as augmented and mixed realities, marketing and brand development, with approaches such as transmedia storytelling, and usability and audience engagement based on core human goals, needs and motivations.
Thematic analysis is a poorly demarcated, rarely-acknowledged, yet widely-used qualitative analytic method within psychology. In this paper, we argue that it offers an accessible and theoretically-flexible approach to analysing qualitative data. We outline what thematic analysis is, locating it in relation to other qualitative analytic methods that search for themes or patterns, and in relation to different epistemological and ontological positions. We then provide clear guidelines to those wanting to start thematic analysis, or conduct it in a more deliberate and rigorous way, and consider potential pitfalls in conducting thematic analysis. Finally, we outline the disadvantages and advantages of thematic analysis. We conclude by advocating thematic analysis as a useful and flexible method for qualitative research in and beyond psychology.
Keywords: thematic analysis, qualitative psychology, patterns, epistemology, flexibility
Braun, V. and Clarke, V., 2006
Hyperspectral Imagery for Environmental Mapping and MonitoringDominique BUFFET
Hyperspectral Imagery for Environmental Mapping and Monitoring: Case Study of Grassland in Belgium.
The objective of this study is to show that hyperspectral imagery can be used to characterise grassland as well as its biophysical and biochemical properties.
Digital turn-what-next--pecha-kucha, Berlin--21-sept-5-2015Heiner Benking
EDUCAMP & OER2 & DIGITAL TURN & ELIG
check http://hochschulforumdigitalisierung.de Sept. 4-11
EduCamp Digital Turn, Wake-up call: What is the next "Turn" ? http://www.newciv.org/nl/newslog.php/_v396/__show_article/_a000396-000385.htm
EduCamp Digital Turn, Wake-up call: What is the next "Turn" ?
Proposal of an integrative, eclectic turn, call it a spacial/scaffolding turn which in form of macroscopic superstructures/supersigns allow to relate and integrate earlier "turns" consider GLocal integration of scales, sectors, cultures, times, media, ... in an overview, orientation mode, but also connecting to the micro-scales
see also: http://www.newciv.org/nl/newslog.php/_v396/__show_article/_a000396-000384.htm
Conceptual framing for educational research through Deleuze and GuattariDavid R Cole
This presentation will address the issue of conceptual framing for educational research through the philosophy of Deleuze & Guattari. The picture of what this means is complicated by the fact that in their combined texts, Deleuze and Guattari present different notions of conceptual framing. In their final joint text, What is Philosophy? conceptual framing appears in the context of concept creation, and helps with the analysis of western philosophy through concepts such as ‘geophilosophy’. In their joint texts on Capitalism and Schizophrenia, concepts are aligned with pre-personal and individualising flows that pass through any context. This presentation will make sense of the disparate deployment of concepts in the work of Deleuze & Guattari to aid clear conceptual work in the growing international field of educational research inspired by their philosophy.
Research Philosophy- Dr Ryan Thomas WilliamsRyan Williams
What is the nature of reality?
What is the nature of knowledge?
Unless you have studied philosophy you may not have considered these questions at any length
Similar to Qualitative content analysis in Media Psychology (20)
Slidedeck for workshop with Travel in the Digital Age (TinDA) students at Western Sydney University. For their assignments, students have to pitch and propose a new Smartphone app for travel. This workshop is designed to support them in generating the evidence-base for their app development and avoiding techno-solutionism.
The Travel in the Digital Age unit is designed and coordinated by Dr Garth Lean. If you would like more information about the unit, please contact him on g.lean@westernsydney.edu.au
A guide to co-creating digital learning cultures Jenna Condie
This presentation was delivered for the School of Social Sciences School Meeting in June 2020. It overviews a guide developed in response to the COVID-19 period and the transitions to digital teaching required during this time. The guide builds upon a decade of technology-enhanced learning practices and existing research to provide practical and usable guidance for developing a supportive learning culture in online spaces. It extends learning dialogues beyond the classroom to consider using social media spaces for enhanced connect and a stronger sense of community and belonging.
In the spirit of digital scholarship, the guide is open access, live and ongoing: https://tinyurl.com/digitallearningcultures
Presentation for the Greater Sydney Commission's Women's Charter Community of Practice Webinar, 11th June 2020. In this talk, I generated overarching findings or key themes from three projects that examine women's mobilities and their safety concerns in different contexts - during travel, when dating, on public transport, and within the home. The key themes focus on techno-solutionism and the rise of an 'app for that culture' where digital innovations are expected to address long standing systemic issues such as gender inequality and men's violence towards women. Another key theme is that new technologies often require women to rework their safety strategies and the ways in which they keep themselves safe during their everyday lives. Technologies that create additional labour for women, or responsibility them for their own safety might be avoided if women were involved in the design and development of new technologies from beginning to end. What is also necessary is collective, connected action to shift the status of women in society through social movements that address gender justice head on. Technology has an important role to play in creating safer cities for women, but that technology must be integrated and embedded well and with women at the centre of its design.
Presentation at #SoMeEthics Social Media & Social Science Research Ethics Conference, Academy of Social Sciences, UK
March 21st 2016
Abstract: Since its launch in 2012, the location-based dating app Tinder has attracted significant attention and holds a firm place in the media spotlight. With an estimated 10 million global users daily and 26 million ‘matches’ every day, Tinder has become a prevalent site of online sociality that is ripe for social science research. Indeed, many research studies on Tinder are currently underway. It is therefore timely to consider the ways in which researchers are navigating this new ethical terrain. Like other social media platforms, Tinder raises the issues of informed consent, data ownership, and blurred boundaries between public and private space. However, given its primary use as a dating space, its location-based functionality, and its ‘mobile-only’ accessibility, Tinder presents a number of unique ethical challenges. This paper focuses on the ethical approach developed for using Tinder as a study context for exploring how social geo-tagging (or location-based) apps mediate travel experiences in the digital age. Tinder acts as an appropriate research site in this case due to the introduction of ‘Passport’, a feature of Tinder’s premium service, which is central to its current market positioning and recent advertising campaigns. The ‘Passport’ feature enables users who are “planning vacations or business trips” to search for people who are in different locations (Tinder, 2015). The ethical approach developed resists the application of traditional research methodologies and facilitates an innovative research strategy to carry out research ‘in’, rather than ‘on’, Tinder.
Social media is an increasingly prominent feature of contemporary academic practice. Many academics are using social media platforms to extend their professional networks, refine their researcher identities, discover the latest developments in their field, enhance learning experiences within teaching, and to share their research with new audiences. This workshop explores how you, as postgraduate researchers, can make full use of new and emerging online spaces for your research and your employability. #SSAPChat
A workshop for PhD researchers in the School of Social Sciences and Psychology, University of Western Sydney.
A presentation for colleagues in the School of Social Sciences and Psychology, University of Western Sydney, Australia.
A massive thank you to my Twitter network. I can't think of a better way to convey the value of social media than this!
Selling social psychology to industry: working in enterprise and research con...Jenna Condie
Slides for a postgraduate workshop at the British Psychological Society's Social Psychology Conference at Canterbury Christchurch University in Kent, UK.
Helping students develop their online professional identities (ATP Workshop 2...Jenna Condie
Slides for workshop on developing students' professional identities at the Association for the Teaching of Psychology conference at Loughborough University, 2014. Based on collaborative work with Birkdale School, Sheffield
SalfordPsych and Public Health Twitter workshopJenna Condie
Twitter workshop for colleagues in my department which started as a 'how to' workshop and moved to a 'why to' workshop based on input from my twitter network. This workshop showcases how great our students are at using social media for learning.
RRUKA Next Generation Rail PresentationJenna Condie
The Next Generation Rail Conference, organised by RRUKA, 15-16th July 2013
This event aims to provide the opportunity for young rail professionals and early career researchers to talk about their projects, to exchange ideas and experiences, and to be inspired by the new (and exciting!) challenges of the rail industry.
This presentation focuses on my PhD research and the need to understand residents' experiences of living alongside railways.
Social media for learning and employability - ATP conference 2013Jenna Condie
Workshop for the Association for the Teaching of Psychology Conference 2013 at Keele University.
Workshop overview: The use of social media is now everyday and commonplace, embedded into many peoples social lives. We are in a period of disruption and rapid adaptation where the opportunities and challenges of social media communication require our constant attention. As the online and offline worlds traverse, particularly within educational contexts, various professional and ethical dilemmas can arise when creating learning communities online. This workshop aims to unravel the complexities of how students construct themselves online and explore how teachers can enhance learning through social media platforms. A psychological perspective can help teachers understand their online activities and the potential of social media for engaging students. This workshop will also consider the importance of social media for students’ employability and how it might assist in their transition to employment or higher education.
It's #theselfonline week this week!
Lecture for Level 4 students and also visiting students from local colleges - Xaverian College and Cheadle and Marple Sixth Form College
2. Session Overview
• Myth bust the quant-qual divide
• Understand importance of epistemology and
ontology
• Move from dichotomies to continuums.
• Explore the constructive nature of language
• Find your interpretative, subjective lens
• Interpret media content with two different
methodologies.
• Expand notion of what can be data.
• Examine evaluative criteria for qualitative
research.
2
3. Commonly held assumption…
Quantitative and Qualitative methods are distinct
from one another
Quantitative Qualitative
• the collection and analysis of • collecting and analysing
data in numeric form information in as many forms,
(Hughes, 2006) chiefly non-numeric, as possible
(Hughes, 2006)
3
4. Flickr: marcinlachowicz.com'
An oversimplification
• Both aim to understand the world
• Both interpret data
• Overlap
Unhelpful
• “…two opposing camps of researchers”
(Onwuegbuzie & Leech, 2005, p. 375)
• “real consequences” for those in the qualitative
camp (Abell & Walton, 2010, p. 688)
For more on the quantitative-qualitative debate see Hammersley (1992); Newman &
4
Benz, (1998); Wood & Welch, (2010); Whaley & Krane, (2011)
5. Method – a word with three meanings
(Bernard, 2000)
The epistemology guides
the question A.K.A
How can we Epistemology
know
A.K.A. Strategic
Methodology choices
The question guides A.K.A.
Techniques
the method Method
5
6. Flickr: CarbonNYC
Epistemology: How can we know
• “Epistemology is inescapable” (Carter & Little,
2007, p. 1319)
• A branch of philosophy (Willig, 2001)
• A theory of knowledge concerned with
knowing (Sullivan, 2012).
• Epistemology guides the research question
(Whaley & Krane, 2011)
• What counts as knowledge or ‘truth’?
6
7. Flickr: SebastianDooris
Ontology: what can we know
• Concerned with what is there to know (Willig, 2001)
• Concerned with existence, what it means “to be”
(Packer & Goicoechea, 2000)
• At the core of this ‘debate’ is how researchers can
theorise about a world in a way which is independent of
our representations (i.e. language, perceptions, values,
beliefs) of it (Nightingale & Cromby, 2002).
• Realist (there is an external objective world that can be
known through research)
• Relativist (an external objective world is inaccessible to
us, we can only know the world through our
representations of it)
7
8. Epistemological continuum
Positivism Interpretivism/
Constructionism
Today, very few researchers would align themselves
at the extreme ends of the continuum
How far along the continuum are you
prepared to travel?
8
9. Ontological continuum
Realism Relativism
Today, very few researchers would align themselves
at the extreme ends of the continuum
How far along the continuum are you
prepared to travel?
9
10. Positivism Review literature
• Only phenomena that are observable and Formulate Hypothesis
agreeable to testing can claim a truth in the and design study
world (Ashworth, 2008).
Collect data
• There is a unitary real world (aka realism).
• Events of interest to psychologists (e.g. Carry out descriptive
memory, identity, cognition, emotion) take statistics
place in that ‘real’ world.
Carry out statistical
• A positivist epistemology pursues objective (inferential) tests
and unbiased knowledge through
Decide whether result
‘reductionist and empirically based, rational is significant or not
enquiry’ (Jones, 2002, p. 247).
• Subsequently, quantitative methodology Interpret and write up
study
often most appropriate. 10
11. Review literature
Post-positivism
Formulate Hypothesis
• The limitations of positivism in terms of and design study
developing new theory and dealing with
complex human issues led to Collect data
postpositivism.
• In contemporary times, many scientists Carry out descriptive
statistics
and social scientists take a postpostivist
stance to knowledge and research. Carry out statistical
(inferential) tests
• While positivism asserts that there is a
reality out there to be studied and to be Decide whether result
is significant or not
captured in research, postpositivists
argue that reality can only be Interpret and write up
approximated (Guba, 1990). study
11
14. Flickr: Leonard John Matthews
Social Constructionism
• There is no one knowledge, there are knowledges
(Burr, 2003)
• No two people perceive, experience, and understand
their worlds in the same way.
• What we experience or perceive is not a direct
reflection of objective environmental conditions
(Willig, 2001). It is constructed in talk and interaction.
• Research carried out from a constructionist standpoint
identifies the ways in which people construct their
social realities by taking into account the specific
linguistic, cultural and historical influences.
• ‘Critical’ approaches
• Subsequently, qualitative methodology often most
appropriate.
14
15. Research as continuum
Ontology – what can we know?
Realism Relativism
Epistemology – how can we know?
Positivism Interpretivism/
Constructionism
Methodology – how can we find out?
Quantitative Qualitative
15
16. Ensuring ‘quality’ in qualitative research
It is the researcher’s responsibility to
make clear their epistemological and
ontological positions
(Madill et al., 2000)
This goes for (post)positivists too!
16
17. The Turn to Language
Discursive/narrative
Language does not simply
describe our world
From out of the heads of people
into the dialogues between them
Language is action oriented,
used to construct particular
versions of events
Language enables and constrains
what can be said, by whom,
where and when (Willig, 2001) 17
18. Discursive Psychology
• A theoretical approach from social psychology
which emphasises how knowledge is created in
interactions between people rather than
through direct perception of a true reality (SC).
• Discourse analysis is the method most used by
social constructionists.
• Preference for naturally occurring text/data.
• Usually ontological relativism but also critical
realism.
18
19. Discursive Psychology: Two Strands or One?
Individual Structure
Discursive Foucauldian
Discourse
Psychology Analysis
Eclectic Discursive Approach
(Wetherell, 1998)
19
20. Analysing Discourse
(no rule book, too many varieties!)
Exploring language ‘in action’.
Discursive Strategies
– E.g. “I’m not racist, but”
Interpretative Repertoires: reoccurring patterns
– E.g. “you just get used to it” Flickr: drbexl
Lived Ideologies & Ideological Dilemmas
– E.g. London as growing vs deprived
Subject Positions
– E.g. “Your country needs you”
20
21. Discursive Psychology and Media Texts
How are we
being
What is all this constructed?
media saying to How is the
us? world being
constructed?
How does media impact upon our
subjectivity/lived experience?
21
22. Flickr: Leonard John Matthews
Subjectivity
• Problematic for discursive psychology
• We are more than discourse (talk)
• Ontological relativism = everything is socially
constructed in language, what about
embodiment, materiality, power? (Cromby &
Nightingale, 2002)
• What can we say about experience when we are
reading for ‘suspicion’? (Ricoeur, 1981)
• Suspicion - what is the text/speaker aiming to
achieve?
• Reading for ‘trust’…
22
23. Flickr: mohammadali
Interpretative
Phenomenological
Analysis
• An approach which
aims to understand
how people make sense of their worlds as they
are experienced by people.
• Sometimes referred to as ‘lived experience’.
• Research is dynamic – researcher has an active
role.
• Often uses interviews & thematic analysis.
• What people say is what they mean - ‘trust’. 23
24. How IPA works
(for Smith & Osborn 2008)
• Identifying the experiential claims, concerns and
understandings of speaker (participant)
• Look for themes in the first case (e.g. interview
transcript), then across cases
f
• Dialogue between researcher and data – what
does this mean?
• Connect the themes (clusters)
f
• Organise – final structure of themes f
• Test for coherence through reflexivity (tbd),
discussions with others, supervision etc
• Write up
f d f 24
25. Move from a position of knowing to a
position of understanding
(Condie & Brown, 2009)
What are the How does
effects of music reflect
listening to youth culture?
music?
When Qs are Why are
‘how’ and particular
‘why’, qual forms of
has the music
advantage popular?
(Maginn et al., 2008) 25
Flickr: Mike White Photo!
26. Interpreting
Content
We know the world
through our
interpretations
(representations).
Attending to our
interpretations in a
rigorous way for
media psychological
research…
26
27. Case Study: Plan B “Ill Manors”
Oi! I said oi!
• Analyse song lyrics What you looking at, you
little rich boy!
• Read on Trust (IPA) We’re poor round here,
run home and lock your
• Read as Suspicion (DP) door
Don’t come round here no
• Make Interpretations more, you could get
• Which approach seems robbed for
Real (yeah) because my
more appropriate? manors ill
My manors ill
• Research question? For real
Yeah you know my
manors ill, my manors ill!
27
28. The sound: Another layer of meaning
What does it add beyond the written word?
How does listening impact on your interpretation?
28
29. The Visual: Another layer of meaning
What does it add beyond the spoken word?
How does seeing impact on your interpretation?
Link: http://vimeo.com/38223344
29
30. The Narrative: Another layer of meaning
The flexibility of qualitative analysis
enables us to broaden our notions of
what can be data in media psychological research
30
33. The pragmatic researcher
Do whatever is best to answer the research question
Bricolage: concept adopted by qualitative researchers to
define those who are increasingly using an eclectic range
of methodological approaches together (Denzin &
Lincoln, 2000, McLeod, 2001, Kincheloe, 2001)
Researcher-as-bricoleur (from French word for craftsman)
Blurred boundaries: “We are no longer bound by the rigid
scientific rigour and instead we seem to adopt a ‘pick n
mix’ approach that is adaptable to the circumstance and
needs of the research question” (Watt, 2010, p. 51).
33
Flickr: gregheo
34. Reflexivity – examining your role in research
“…how does who I am, who I have been, who I think I am,
and how I feel affect data collection and analysis”
(Pillow, 2003, p. 176)
• A central methodological tool for qualitative
researchers, contributes to ‘quality’
• Finlay (2002) argues reflexive analysis should ideally
start from the beginning of the research process.
• Challenged the fundamental and “conventional ideas of
science, which favour professional objectivity and
distance over engagement and subjectivity” (Finlay &
Gough, 2002, p. 1).
34
35. The trouble with reflexivity
Difficulties psychology students can face when asked to
be reflexive:
“For psychology students, the expectation of writing
reflexively about the qualitative studies that they have
conducted constitutes a transgression of the scientized
code of detached, depersonalized, supposedly objective
narrative style that characterizes the pseudoscientific
model of their training. In my experience such
expectations usually generate some incredulity, and
occasionally resistance from too well absorbed
disciplinary codes; however, they are usually experienced
as relief, and even as emancipatory.”
(Burman, 1997, p. 796)
35
36. Can never fully know how you
influence the research…
“Reflexive analysis can only ever be a partial,
tentative, provisional account”
(Finlay, 2002, p. 542).
But you should
still try!
36
Flickr: astroshots42
37. ‘Quality’ Criteria for Qualitative Research
• Make clear epist. & ontol. positions
• Reflexivity – from personal to disciplinary
• Transparency - processes
• ‘Fruitfulness’ (Wetherell, 1998)
• Systematic interpretation
• ‘Good’ interpretation takes time and practice.
• Qualitative research should not be evaluated by
positivist criteria i.e. reliability, validity,
generalisation etc…doesn’t aim to be these things!
37
38. Next session
• How to be systematic in qualitative research
• Prepare and practice qualitative interviewing
• Further reading
– Read Mauthner & Doucet (2003) Reflexive Accounts
and Accounts of Reflexivity in Qualitative Data (bb)
– Read one other research paper that interests you.
Identify the epistemological, ontological and
methodological positions of the research. Are they
identified? Are they assumed?
38