RASA Conference, Cambridge MA, November 8-9, 2014 ! 
1! 
Chirality! 
from particles and nuclei to ! 
quantum materials ! 
D. Kharzeev 
! 
!
Outline! 
! What is Chirality?! 
! Chirality, light, and matter! 
! Chirality in nuclear and particle physics! 
example: Chiral Magnetic Effect (CME)! 
! Chirality in quantum materials:! 
CME, optoelectronics, photonics, imaging! 
! 
example: precision surgical guidance in! 
cancer treatment!
Chirality: the definition 
Greek word: χειρ (cheir) - hand! 
Lord Kelvin (1893): 
“I call any geometrical figure, or groups of 
points, chiral, and say it has chirality, if its 
image in a plane mirror, ideally realized, 
cannot be brought to coincide with itself.”!
Chirality: DNA
Living organisms contain almost only ! 
left-handed (LH) amino-acids and right-handed (RH) sugars – ! 
you would starve on LH sugar! (artificial sweeteners)! 
www.rowland.harvard.edu/rjf/fischer! 
2500 chiral drugs! (most of the new)!
Chirality: practical application, 240 B.C.! 
6! The Archimedes screw!
Chirality and hydrodynamics, 
300 million years ago 
! 
7! 
The Archimedes screw, 
Carboniferous period 
(360 - 300 million 
years ago) 
common in fossils; 
extinct since 
Triassic 
(250 million 
years ago)
Chirality: light and matter! 
Louis Pasteur! 
1822-1895! 
Rotation of light polarization in! 
tartaric acid - absent in synthesized one,! 
but present in the one derived from! 
wine lees different mixtures of! 
left and right crystals !
Chirality in subatomic world: the neutrinoOnly left-handed neutrinos! 
exist in the Standard Model!
Chirality and matter! 
Spin parallel to momentum:! 
right-handed! 
Spin anti-parallel to momentum:! 
left-handed! 
Chirality depends on ! 
the reference frame:!
Chirality and matter! 
Chirality depends on the reference frame;! 
but, nothing can move faster than light!! 
! 
So for massless particles (moving with the speed! 
of light) chirality is conserved:!
12! 
Chiral particles! 
non-relativistic,! 
massive! 
massless,! 
relativistic! 
nuclear physics, electrons! 
in solids, ...! 
photons, neutrinos,! 
light quarks,! 
quasi-particles in chiral materials
Chiral 
13! 
par(cles 
and 
Dirac 
sea 
p 
m2c4 + p2c2 
E = ±
Chirality and light 
Circularly polarized electromagnetic wave! 
can be left- or right-handed! 
14! 
!
Chirality and light, 2000 BC 
15! 
The scarab beetle – the symbol of ! 
reincarnation in ancient Egypt!
Chirality and light 
Photographs of a scarab beetle (Potosia aeruginosa 
jousselini) taken through a left- and a right-handed 
circular polarizer, showing that the cuticle reflects ! 
left-handed circularly polarized light! 
16!
Light and electromagnetism! 
James C. Maxwell, 1831-1879! 
Michael Faraday, 1791-1867! 
Maxwell theory! 
is left-right ! 
symmetric!
Chirality 
in 
electrodynamics: 
Maxwell-­‐Chern-­‐Simons 
theory 
Chiral current 
Photons! 
DK, Annals Phys. 325 (2010) 
205-218 !
Chiral Magnetic Effect: 
chirality + magnetic field = current! 
spin! 
momentum! 
19! 
DK,McLerran,! 
Warringa ‘07!
Chiral magnetic conductivity: 
discrete symmetries! 
20! 
P-even 
T-odd! 
P-odd 
! 
P-odd! 
T-odd! 
P-odd effect!! 
T-even! 
Non-dissipative current! 
(chiral electronics)! 
cf Ohmic 
conductivity: 
T-odd, 
dissipative! 
Effect persists in! 
hydrodynamics!! 
P – parity (mirror)! 
T – time reversal!
CME on supercomputers! arXiv:1105.0385, PRL ! 
21!
The 
Chiral 
Magne9c 
Wave: 
oscilla9ons 
of 
electric 
and 
chiral 
charges 
coupled 
by 
the 
chiral 
anomaly 
In strong magnetic field, CMW 
propagates with the speed of light!! 
DK, H.-U. Yee, Phys Rev D’11 22! 
Chiral! 
Electric!
Chirality in nuclear collisions: ! 
experimental test! 
LHC! 
NICA, JINR 
Dubna!
Is there a way to observe chirality 
fluctuations in a nuclear experiment?! 
Relativistic ions create! 
a strong magnetic field:! 
H! 
DK, McLerran, Warringa ‘07!
47! 
Heavy ion collisions: the strongest magnetic 
field ever achieved in the laboratory!
Charge asymmetry w.r.t. reaction plane 
as a signature of chirality! 
+! 
-! 
excess of positive 
charge! 
excess of negative 
charge! 
Electric dipole moment due to chiral imbalance! 
DK, Phys.Lett.B633(2006)260!
NB: P-even quantity (strength of P-odd fluctuations)!
In Brookhaven Collider, Scientists Briefly Break a Law of 
Nature 
By DENNIS OVERBYE 
Published: February 15, 2010 
Physicists said Monday that they had whacked a tiny region of space with enough energy to briefly distort the laws of physics, 
providing the first laboratory demonstration of the kind of process that scientists suspect has shaped cosmic history.! 
Atom smasher shows vacuum of space 
in a twist 
17:27 15 February 2010 by Rachel Courtland! 
Quark Soup 
Physicists create conditions not seen since the big bang. 
Feb 16, 2010! 
28! 
Sharon Begley! 
Scientists re-create high temperatures from Big 
Bang! 
Hottest Temperature Ever Heads Science to 
Big Bang!
The discovery of Dirac semimetals 
– 3D chiral materials! 
Z.K.Liu et al., Science 343 p.864 (Feb 21, 2014)! 
Ongoing experimental studies of Chiral Magnetic Effect!
Ongoing studies of CME 
in the Dirac semimetal Cd3As2! 
CME?! 
T. Liang et al., 14014.7749! 
and to appear in Science ! 
(September 2014)! 
! 
S. Jeon et al., ! 
Nature Materials 13, ! 
851–856 (2014)!
Chiral electronics! 
DK and H.Yee, Phys.Rev.B88(2013)115119;! 
G.Basar, DK and H.Yee, Phys.Rev.B89(2014)035142! 
Practical applications of Chiral Magnetic Effect: sensors,! 
quantum amplifiers, generators, …!
Chirality at the tip of a pencil: 
graphene!
Graphene: single-atom-thick marvel!
Graphene:! 
from the lab to! 
industrial! 
production!
Graphene: new generation of electronic devices!
“Graphene is an impending 
turning point in high tech as 
important as silicon and 
integrated circuitry were half a 
century ago.” !
Why is graphene visible?!
Chirality in graphene 
left! right! 
E = v k 
v = 1/300 c! 
Massless, chiral particles! strong coupling to light !
Quantum tunneling of chiral particles 
Left-handed! 
Chirality ! 
conservation! 
dictates 100%! 
wall penetration!! 
Right-handed! Right-handed!
Klein chiral tunneling 
O. Klein! 
1894-1977!
Klein tunneling in graphene
42! 
The goal: fight the power ! 
dissipation using chirality! 
Geim group, 2013!
43! 
Ultra-fast, low-power! 
optical information! 
processing;! 
graphene-based! 
photonic circuits!
Breaking the left-right symmetry! 
Circularly polarized! 
photoluminiscence:! 
coupling of light to currents! 
44! 
Right! Left! 
T.Cao et al, Nature Comm 3 (2012) 887 !
Graphene 
and 
THz 
radia9on 
(T-­‐rays): 
the 
“last 
fron9er” 
in 
electromagne9c 
spectrum 
non-ionizing!!
visible! THz!
THz 
cancer 
diagnos9cs 
Squamos cell carcinoma ! 
Tumor! Tumor! 
of the lung ! 
SONY Corp and Tokyo University! 
visible! 
THz!
Graphene-­‐based 
devices 
for 
THz 
medical 
imaging
Integrated 
medical 
imaging 
device 
for 
precision 
surgical 
guidance
Cutting-edge science: 
fast and precise 
THz surgical guidance ! 
S.Nakajima et al., Advanced navigation in! 
neurosurgery!
Chirality 
in 
fundamental 
and 
applied 
science 
There is no such thing as a special category of science called 
applied science; there is science and its applications, which are 
related to one another as the fruit is related to the tree that 
has borne it. 
51! 
Louis Pasteur!

Chirality: from particles and nuclei to quantum materials. Дмитрий Харзеев.

  • 1.
    RASA Conference, CambridgeMA, November 8-9, 2014 ! 1! Chirality! from particles and nuclei to ! quantum materials ! D. Kharzeev ! !
  • 2.
    Outline! ! Whatis Chirality?! ! Chirality, light, and matter! ! Chirality in nuclear and particle physics! example: Chiral Magnetic Effect (CME)! ! Chirality in quantum materials:! CME, optoelectronics, photonics, imaging! ! example: precision surgical guidance in! cancer treatment!
  • 3.
    Chirality: the definition Greek word: χειρ (cheir) - hand! Lord Kelvin (1893): “I call any geometrical figure, or groups of points, chiral, and say it has chirality, if its image in a plane mirror, ideally realized, cannot be brought to coincide with itself.”!
  • 4.
  • 5.
    Living organisms containalmost only ! left-handed (LH) amino-acids and right-handed (RH) sugars – ! you would starve on LH sugar! (artificial sweeteners)! www.rowland.harvard.edu/rjf/fischer! 2500 chiral drugs! (most of the new)!
  • 6.
    Chirality: practical application,240 B.C.! 6! The Archimedes screw!
  • 7.
    Chirality and hydrodynamics, 300 million years ago ! 7! The Archimedes screw, Carboniferous period (360 - 300 million years ago) common in fossils; extinct since Triassic (250 million years ago)
  • 8.
    Chirality: light andmatter! Louis Pasteur! 1822-1895! Rotation of light polarization in! tartaric acid - absent in synthesized one,! but present in the one derived from! wine lees different mixtures of! left and right crystals !
  • 9.
    Chirality in subatomicworld: the neutrinoOnly left-handed neutrinos! exist in the Standard Model!
  • 10.
    Chirality and matter! Spin parallel to momentum:! right-handed! Spin anti-parallel to momentum:! left-handed! Chirality depends on ! the reference frame:!
  • 11.
    Chirality and matter! Chirality depends on the reference frame;! but, nothing can move faster than light!! ! So for massless particles (moving with the speed! of light) chirality is conserved:!
  • 12.
    12! Chiral particles! non-relativistic,! massive! massless,! relativistic! nuclear physics, electrons! in solids, ...! photons, neutrinos,! light quarks,! quasi-particles in chiral materials
  • 13.
    Chiral 13! par(cles and Dirac sea p m2c4 + p2c2 E = ±
  • 14.
    Chirality and light Circularly polarized electromagnetic wave! can be left- or right-handed! 14! !
  • 15.
    Chirality and light,2000 BC 15! The scarab beetle – the symbol of ! reincarnation in ancient Egypt!
  • 16.
    Chirality and light Photographs of a scarab beetle (Potosia aeruginosa jousselini) taken through a left- and a right-handed circular polarizer, showing that the cuticle reflects ! left-handed circularly polarized light! 16!
  • 17.
    Light and electromagnetism! James C. Maxwell, 1831-1879! Michael Faraday, 1791-1867! Maxwell theory! is left-right ! symmetric!
  • 18.
    Chirality in electrodynamics: Maxwell-­‐Chern-­‐Simons theory Chiral current Photons! DK, Annals Phys. 325 (2010) 205-218 !
  • 19.
    Chiral Magnetic Effect: chirality + magnetic field = current! spin! momentum! 19! DK,McLerran,! Warringa ‘07!
  • 20.
    Chiral magnetic conductivity: discrete symmetries! 20! P-even T-odd! P-odd ! P-odd! T-odd! P-odd effect!! T-even! Non-dissipative current! (chiral electronics)! cf Ohmic conductivity: T-odd, dissipative! Effect persists in! hydrodynamics!! P – parity (mirror)! T – time reversal!
  • 21.
    CME on supercomputers!arXiv:1105.0385, PRL ! 21!
  • 22.
    The Chiral Magne9c Wave: oscilla9ons of electric and chiral charges coupled by the chiral anomaly In strong magnetic field, CMW propagates with the speed of light!! DK, H.-U. Yee, Phys Rev D’11 22! Chiral! Electric!
  • 23.
    Chirality in nuclearcollisions: ! experimental test! LHC! NICA, JINR Dubna!
  • 24.
    Is there away to observe chirality fluctuations in a nuclear experiment?! Relativistic ions create! a strong magnetic field:! H! DK, McLerran, Warringa ‘07!
  • 25.
    47! Heavy ioncollisions: the strongest magnetic field ever achieved in the laboratory!
  • 26.
    Charge asymmetry w.r.t.reaction plane as a signature of chirality! +! -! excess of positive charge! excess of negative charge! Electric dipole moment due to chiral imbalance! DK, Phys.Lett.B633(2006)260!
  • 27.
    NB: P-even quantity(strength of P-odd fluctuations)!
  • 28.
    In Brookhaven Collider,Scientists Briefly Break a Law of Nature By DENNIS OVERBYE Published: February 15, 2010 Physicists said Monday that they had whacked a tiny region of space with enough energy to briefly distort the laws of physics, providing the first laboratory demonstration of the kind of process that scientists suspect has shaped cosmic history.! Atom smasher shows vacuum of space in a twist 17:27 15 February 2010 by Rachel Courtland! Quark Soup Physicists create conditions not seen since the big bang. Feb 16, 2010! 28! Sharon Begley! Scientists re-create high temperatures from Big Bang! Hottest Temperature Ever Heads Science to Big Bang!
  • 29.
    The discovery ofDirac semimetals – 3D chiral materials! Z.K.Liu et al., Science 343 p.864 (Feb 21, 2014)! Ongoing experimental studies of Chiral Magnetic Effect!
  • 30.
    Ongoing studies ofCME in the Dirac semimetal Cd3As2! CME?! T. Liang et al., 14014.7749! and to appear in Science ! (September 2014)! ! S. Jeon et al., ! Nature Materials 13, ! 851–856 (2014)!
  • 31.
    Chiral electronics! DKand H.Yee, Phys.Rev.B88(2013)115119;! G.Basar, DK and H.Yee, Phys.Rev.B89(2014)035142! Practical applications of Chiral Magnetic Effect: sensors,! quantum amplifiers, generators, …!
  • 32.
    Chirality at thetip of a pencil: graphene!
  • 33.
  • 34.
    Graphene:! from thelab to! industrial! production!
  • 35.
    Graphene: new generationof electronic devices!
  • 36.
    “Graphene is animpending turning point in high tech as important as silicon and integrated circuitry were half a century ago.” !
  • 37.
    Why is graphenevisible?!
  • 38.
    Chirality in graphene left! right! E = v k v = 1/300 c! Massless, chiral particles! strong coupling to light !
  • 39.
    Quantum tunneling ofchiral particles Left-handed! Chirality ! conservation! dictates 100%! wall penetration!! Right-handed! Right-handed!
  • 40.
    Klein chiral tunneling O. Klein! 1894-1977!
  • 41.
  • 42.
    42! The goal:fight the power ! dissipation using chirality! Geim group, 2013!
  • 43.
    43! Ultra-fast, low-power! optical information! processing;! graphene-based! photonic circuits!
  • 44.
    Breaking the left-rightsymmetry! Circularly polarized! photoluminiscence:! coupling of light to currents! 44! Right! Left! T.Cao et al, Nature Comm 3 (2012) 887 !
  • 45.
    Graphene and THz radia9on (T-­‐rays): the “last fron9er” in electromagne9c spectrum non-ionizing!!
  • 46.
  • 47.
    THz cancer diagnos9cs Squamos cell carcinoma ! Tumor! Tumor! of the lung ! SONY Corp and Tokyo University! visible! THz!
  • 48.
    Graphene-­‐based devices for THz medical imaging
  • 49.
    Integrated medical imaging device for precision surgical guidance
  • 50.
    Cutting-edge science: fastand precise THz surgical guidance ! S.Nakajima et al., Advanced navigation in! neurosurgery!
  • 51.
    Chirality in fundamental and applied science There is no such thing as a special category of science called applied science; there is science and its applications, which are related to one another as the fruit is related to the tree that has borne it. 51! Louis Pasteur!