SURGERY FOR
LOW BACK PAIN
Paul Licina
Not all spine surgery is the same…
DISCECTOMY FOR DISC HERNIATION
DISCECTOMY FOR DISC HERNIATION
tear in outer disc
migration of inner gel
What
causes it ?
nerve pressure
leg pain (sciatica)
What does it
cause ?
DISCECTOMY FOR DISC HERNIATION
cauda equina syndrome
unremitting pain
When do we
operate ?
relief of leg pain
Why do we
operate ?
DISCECTOMY FOR DISC HERNIATION
Prerequisites
• symptoms > 6 weeks
• leg pain > back pain
• leg pain in radicular distribution
• nerve tension signs (reduced SLR)
• nerve compression signs (weakness,
numbness, reflex loss)
• confirmed on imaging
DISCECTOMY FOR DISC HERNIATION
Outcome
• Day Surgery procedure
• back to sedentary duties in 3 weeks
• back to sport in 6 weeks
• good or excellent result in 90-95%
•small incision • interlaminar space
exposed
•adequate retraction •laminotomy
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
What is fusion good for?
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
What about low back pain?
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
Results not as good as
for deformity or instability
Results not as good as for
discectomy surgery
WRONG diagnosis
WRONG patient
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
DISEASE DIAGNOSIS
symptoms and signs
Hx, Ex & Ix
TREATMENTCURE
directed at pathology
The medical model
DISEASE DIAGNOSIS
symptoms and signs
Hx, Ex & Ix
The medical model
back pain is a complex
symptom rather than a
discrete illness
structural lesion cannot
be identified in many
cases
does not account for
individual variation in
human response
15%
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
CHRONIC
SPECIFIC
ACUTE
SPECIFIC
CHRONIC
NON
SPECIFIC
ACUTE
NONSPECIFIC
SUITABLE CANDIDATE
• Self-employed
• Successful business
• No specific injury
• No compensation or litigation
• Works with some difficulty
• Has given up some of more active sports
• Uses intermittent over-the-counter analgesics
• Non-smoker
• Normal body weight
• Goal is to be able to return to active lifestyle
• No abnormal illness behaviour
UNSUITABLE CANDIDATE
• Employee undertaking manual work
• Dissatisfied with employment
• Unremitting pain after lifting at work
• Unresolved WorkCover claim with civil action
pending
• Failed attempts at return to work
• Has given up all social activities
• Uses regular narcotic analgesia
• Smoker
• Unfit and overweight
• Goal is for someone to get rid of their pain
• Abnormal illness behaviour on examination
Techniques
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
Noninstrumented
fusion
Instrumented
fusion
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
Interbody
fusion
remove the disc
Interbody
fusion
• remove the pain source
• stop the movement
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
benefits
Anterior
interbody
• anterior muscle-splitting
only
• minimal tissue trauma
indications
• isolated degeneration
• L5-S1 (L4-5)
• no need to enter canal
• thin, no previous major
abdominal surgery
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
benefits
Transforaminal
interbody
• allows nerve
decompression
• allows all levels
• familiarity
indications
• not suitable for ALIF
• nerve compression esp
foraminal compression
• correction of deformity
What’s new?
When is fusion good for LBP?
•specific diagnosis
•clearly defined pain source
•suitable candidate
•no negative psychosocial factors
•appropriate technique for pathology
•some surgeon variation

Surgery for Lower Back Pain

  • 1.
    SURGERY FOR LOW BACKPAIN Paul Licina
  • 2.
    Not all spinesurgery is the same…
  • 3.
  • 4.
    DISCECTOMY FOR DISCHERNIATION tear in outer disc migration of inner gel What causes it ? nerve pressure leg pain (sciatica) What does it cause ?
  • 5.
    DISCECTOMY FOR DISCHERNIATION cauda equina syndrome unremitting pain When do we operate ? relief of leg pain Why do we operate ?
  • 6.
    DISCECTOMY FOR DISCHERNIATION Prerequisites • symptoms > 6 weeks • leg pain > back pain • leg pain in radicular distribution • nerve tension signs (reduced SLR) • nerve compression signs (weakness, numbness, reflex loss) • confirmed on imaging
  • 7.
    DISCECTOMY FOR DISCHERNIATION Outcome • Day Surgery procedure • back to sedentary duties in 3 weeks • back to sport in 6 weeks • good or excellent result in 90-95%
  • 8.
    •small incision •interlaminar space exposed •adequate retraction •laminotomy
  • 13.
    FUSION FOR LOWBACK PAIN
  • 14.
    FUSION FOR LOWBACK PAIN What is fusion good for?
  • 18.
    FUSION FOR LOWBACK PAIN What about low back pain?
  • 19.
    FUSION FOR LOWBACK PAIN Results not as good as for deformity or instability Results not as good as for discectomy surgery WRONG diagnosis WRONG patient
  • 20.
    FUSION FOR LOWBACK PAIN DISEASE DIAGNOSIS symptoms and signs Hx, Ex & Ix TREATMENTCURE directed at pathology The medical model
  • 21.
    DISEASE DIAGNOSIS symptoms andsigns Hx, Ex & Ix The medical model back pain is a complex symptom rather than a discrete illness structural lesion cannot be identified in many cases does not account for individual variation in human response 15% FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
  • 22.
  • 25.
    SUITABLE CANDIDATE • Self-employed •Successful business • No specific injury • No compensation or litigation • Works with some difficulty • Has given up some of more active sports • Uses intermittent over-the-counter analgesics • Non-smoker • Normal body weight • Goal is to be able to return to active lifestyle • No abnormal illness behaviour
  • 26.
    UNSUITABLE CANDIDATE • Employeeundertaking manual work • Dissatisfied with employment • Unremitting pain after lifting at work • Unresolved WorkCover claim with civil action pending • Failed attempts at return to work • Has given up all social activities • Uses regular narcotic analgesia • Smoker • Unfit and overweight • Goal is for someone to get rid of their pain • Abnormal illness behaviour on examination
  • 27.
  • 28.
    FUSION FOR LOWBACK PAIN Noninstrumented fusion
  • 29.
  • 30.
    FUSION FOR LOWBACK PAIN Interbody fusion
  • 31.
    remove the disc Interbody fusion •remove the pain source • stop the movement FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
  • 32.
    benefits Anterior interbody • anterior muscle-splitting only •minimal tissue trauma indications • isolated degeneration • L5-S1 (L4-5) • no need to enter canal • thin, no previous major abdominal surgery FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
  • 35.
    benefits Transforaminal interbody • allows nerve decompression •allows all levels • familiarity indications • not suitable for ALIF • nerve compression esp foraminal compression • correction of deformity
  • 38.
  • 46.
    When is fusiongood for LBP? •specific diagnosis •clearly defined pain source •suitable candidate •no negative psychosocial factors •appropriate technique for pathology •some surgeon variation