SURGERY	
  FOR	
  	
  
LOW	
  BACK	
  PAIN	
  
	
  
Paul	
  Licina	
  
Not	
  all	
  spine	
  surgery	
  is	
  the	
  same…	
  
DISCECTOMY FOR DISC HERNIATION
DISCECTOMY FOR DISC HERNIATION
Outcome
•  Day	
  Surgery	
  procedure	
  
•  back	
  to	
  sedentary	
  duHes	
  in	
  3	
  weeks	
  
•  back	
  to	
  sport	
  in	
  6	
  weeks	
  
•  good	
  or	
  excellent	
  result	
  in	
  90-­‐95%	
  
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
What	
  is	
  fusion	
  good	
  for?	
  
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
What	
  about	
  low	
  back	
  pain?	
  
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
	
   	
  Results	
  not	
  as	
  good	
  as	
  
for	
  deformity	
  or	
  instability	
  
	
  
Results	
  not	
  as	
  good	
  as	
  for	
  
discectomy	
  surgery	
  
	
  
WRONG	
  diagnosis	
  
WRONG	
  paHent	
  
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
	
   	
  Results	
  not	
  as	
  good	
  as	
  
for	
  deformity	
  or	
  instability	
  
	
  
Results	
  not	
  as	
  good	
  as	
  for	
  
discectomy	
  surgery	
  
	
  
WRONG	
  diagnosis	
  
WRONG	
  paHent	
  
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
DISEASE DIAGNOSIS
symptoms and signs
Hx, Ex & Ix
TREATMENTCURE
directed at pathology
The medical model
DISEASE DIAGNOSIS
symptoms and signs
Hx, Ex & Ix
The medical model
back pain is a complex
symptom rather than a
discrete illness
structural lesion cannot
be identified in many
cases
does not account for
individual variation in
human response
15%
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
CHRONIC	
  
SPECIFIC	
  
ACUTE	
  
SPECIFIC	
  
CHRONIC	
  
NON	
  
SPECIFIC	
  
ACUTE	
  
NONSPECIFIC	
  
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
	
   	
  Results	
  not	
  as	
  good	
  as	
  
for	
  deformity	
  or	
  instability	
  
	
  
Results	
  not	
  as	
  good	
  as	
  for	
  
discectomy	
  surgery	
  
	
  
WRONG	
  diagnosis	
  
WRONG	
  paHent	
  
SUITABLE	
  CANDIDATE	
  
•  Self-­‐employed	
  
•  Successful	
  business	
  
•  No	
  specific	
  injury	
  
•  No	
  compensa5on	
  or	
  li5ga5on	
  
•  Works	
  with	
  some	
  difficulty	
  
•  Has	
  given	
  up	
  some	
  of	
  more	
  acHve	
  sports	
  
•  Uses	
  intermiCent	
  over-­‐the-­‐counter	
  analgesics	
  
•  Non-­‐smoker	
  
•  Normal	
  body	
  weight	
  
•  Goal	
  is	
  to	
  be	
  able	
  to	
  return	
  to	
  ac5ve	
  lifestyle	
  
•  No	
  abnormal	
  illness	
  behaviour	
  
UNSUITABLE	
  CANDIDATE	
  
•  Employee	
  undertaking	
  manual	
  work	
  
•  DissaHsfied	
  with	
  employment	
  
•  UnremiYng	
  pain	
  aZer	
  liZing	
  at	
  work	
  
•  Unresolved	
  WorkCover	
  claim	
  with	
  civil	
  ac5on	
  
pending	
  
•  Failed	
  aCempts	
  at	
  return	
  to	
  work	
  
•  Has	
  given	
  up	
  all	
  social	
  acHviHes	
  
•  Uses	
  regular	
  narco5c	
  analgesia	
  
•  Smoker	
  
•  Unfit	
  and	
  overweight	
  
•  Goal	
  is	
  for	
  someone	
  to	
  get	
  rid	
  of	
  their	
  pain	
  
•  Abnormal	
  illness	
  behaviour	
  on	
  examina5on	
  
Techniques	
  
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
Noninstrumented
fusion
Instrumented
fusion
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
Interbody
fusion
remove the disc
Interbody
fusion
• remove the pain source
• stop the movement
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
benefits
Anterior
interbody
• anterior muscle-splitting
only
• minimal tissue trauma
indications
• isolated degeneration
• L5-S1 (L4-5)
• no need to enter canal
• thin, no previous major
abdominal surgery
FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
benefits
Transforaminal
interbody
• allows nerve
decompression
• allows all levels
• familiarity
indications
• not suitable for ALIF
• nerve compression esp
foraminal compression
• correction of deformity
What’s	
  new?	
  
When	
  is	
  fusion	
  good	
  for	
  LBP?	
  
• specific	
  diagnosis	
  
• clearly	
  defined	
  pain	
  source	
  
• suitable	
  candidate	
  
• no	
  negaHve	
  psychosocial	
  factors	
  
• appropriate	
  technique	
  for	
  pathology	
  
• some	
  surgeon	
  variaHon	
  
END	
  

Surgery for back pain

  • 1.
    SURGERY  FOR     LOW  BACK  PAIN     Paul  Licina  
  • 2.
    Not  all  spine  surgery  is  the  same…  
  • 3.
  • 5.
    DISCECTOMY FOR DISCHERNIATION Outcome •  Day  Surgery  procedure   •  back  to  sedentary  duHes  in  3  weeks   •  back  to  sport  in  6  weeks   •  good  or  excellent  result  in  90-­‐95%  
  • 6.
    FUSION FOR LOWBACK PAIN
  • 7.
    FUSION FOR LOWBACK PAIN What  is  fusion  good  for?  
  • 11.
    FUSION FOR LOWBACK PAIN What  about  low  back  pain?  
  • 12.
    FUSION FOR LOWBACK PAIN    Results  not  as  good  as   for  deformity  or  instability     Results  not  as  good  as  for   discectomy  surgery     WRONG  diagnosis   WRONG  paHent  
  • 13.
    FUSION FOR LOWBACK PAIN    Results  not  as  good  as   for  deformity  or  instability     Results  not  as  good  as  for   discectomy  surgery     WRONG  diagnosis   WRONG  paHent  
  • 14.
    FUSION FOR LOWBACK PAIN DISEASE DIAGNOSIS symptoms and signs Hx, Ex & Ix TREATMENTCURE directed at pathology The medical model
  • 15.
    DISEASE DIAGNOSIS symptoms andsigns Hx, Ex & Ix The medical model back pain is a complex symptom rather than a discrete illness structural lesion cannot be identified in many cases does not account for individual variation in human response 15% FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
  • 16.
    CHRONIC   SPECIFIC   ACUTE   SPECIFIC   CHRONIC   NON   SPECIFIC   ACUTE   NONSPECIFIC  
  • 20.
    FUSION FOR LOWBACK PAIN    Results  not  as  good  as   for  deformity  or  instability     Results  not  as  good  as  for   discectomy  surgery     WRONG  diagnosis   WRONG  paHent  
  • 21.
    SUITABLE  CANDIDATE   • Self-­‐employed   •  Successful  business   •  No  specific  injury   •  No  compensa5on  or  li5ga5on   •  Works  with  some  difficulty   •  Has  given  up  some  of  more  acHve  sports   •  Uses  intermiCent  over-­‐the-­‐counter  analgesics   •  Non-­‐smoker   •  Normal  body  weight   •  Goal  is  to  be  able  to  return  to  ac5ve  lifestyle   •  No  abnormal  illness  behaviour  
  • 22.
    UNSUITABLE  CANDIDATE   • Employee  undertaking  manual  work   •  DissaHsfied  with  employment   •  UnremiYng  pain  aZer  liZing  at  work   •  Unresolved  WorkCover  claim  with  civil  ac5on   pending   •  Failed  aCempts  at  return  to  work   •  Has  given  up  all  social  acHviHes   •  Uses  regular  narco5c  analgesia   •  Smoker   •  Unfit  and  overweight   •  Goal  is  for  someone  to  get  rid  of  their  pain   •  Abnormal  illness  behaviour  on  examina5on  
  • 23.
  • 24.
    FUSION FOR LOWBACK PAIN Noninstrumented fusion
  • 25.
  • 26.
    FUSION FOR LOWBACK PAIN Interbody fusion
  • 27.
    remove the disc Interbody fusion • removethe pain source • stop the movement FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
  • 28.
    benefits Anterior interbody • anterior muscle-splitting only • minimal tissuetrauma indications • isolated degeneration • L5-S1 (L4-5) • no need to enter canal • thin, no previous major abdominal surgery FUSION FOR LOW BACK PAIN
  • 31.
    benefits Transforaminal interbody • allows nerve decompression • allows alllevels • familiarity indications • not suitable for ALIF • nerve compression esp foraminal compression • correction of deformity
  • 34.
  • 42.
    When  is  fusion  good  for  LBP?   • specific  diagnosis   • clearly  defined  pain  source   • suitable  candidate   • no  negaHve  psychosocial  factors   • appropriate  technique  for  pathology   • some  surgeon  variaHon  
  • 43.