Strengths-Based Leadership
(and Followership)
Presented by Eric K. Kaufman
July 23, 2013
Who is Eric Kaufman?
• Associate Professor &
Extension Specialist
• Lead researcher for
VALOR program launch
• Coordinator of VT’s
Graduate Certificate in
Collaborative Community
Leadership
• Former H.S. AgriScience
Teacher
Our Agenda…
1. Personalizing
Leadership
2. Principles of Strengths-
Based Leadership
3. Partnering with
Courageous Followers
4. Strategies for
Application
Virginia Agriculture’s Interest
(Kaufman et al., 2010)
“Growing new leaders and enhancing the skills of
current leaders is vitally important to the future of
agriculture.”
“I believe that the more involved one becomes in
problem solving, working in team/group settings with a
strong community commitment the more people can
work together to solve any and all problems their
community is faced with. Since agriculture is so critical
anything we can do to provide leadership learning in
this area would be extremely beneficial.”
VALOR Vision Statement
The Virginia Agriculture Leaders Obtaining
Results (VALOR) program will provide a
sustainable future for Virginia's agricultural
community by maximizing potential for
successful growth through a system of
networking, collaborative decision-making,
and development of strong leaders.
WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT
LEADERSHIP?
GALLUP POLL – LEADERSHIP ABILITY
Out of 1,001 U.S. adults
surveyed, 97% rated their
ability to lead as being at or
above average.
97%
3%
At or Above Average
Below Average
What % of U.S. adults rate their leadership ability
as being at or above average?
GALLUP POLL – LEADERSHIP EXPERIENCE
Out of 1,001 U.S. adults
surveyed, more than two-
thirds reported that they
have led a group or team.
67%
33%
Led a Group or Team
Yes No
What % of U.S. adults have led a group or team?
How Do You Define Leadership?
• Defining Leadership through
Personalized Plates
– Use template to create a
personalized license plate that
identifies a characteristic of
leadership.
– Your plate may have a
combination of up to seven
letters, numbers, and/or special
characters.
– Creativity is encouraged.
Leadership Lessons
from Dancing Guy
How Do You Define Leadership?
• Defining Leadership through
Personalized Plates
– Use template to create a
personalized license plate that
identifies a characteristic of
leadership.
– Your plate may have a
combination of up to seven
letters, numbers, and/or special
characters.
– Creativity is encouraged.
Caveat on Studying Leadership
“The distinctive feature of leadership is that it would
appear the more we learn about leadership, the more
we realize we have to and want to learn.”
(Jackson & Parry, 2008, p. 9)
Leadership Defined
“Leadership is the art of accomplishing more than the
science of management says is possible.”
– Colin Powell, American statesman and retired four-star general in the
United States Army
“Leadership is the art of mobilizing others to want to
struggle for shared aspirations.”
– James Kouzes & Barry Posner, leadership researchers and authors of
The Leadership Challenge
“Leadership is a process whereby an individual
influences a group of individuals to achieve a common
goal.”
– Peter Northouse, professor of communication and author of Leadership:
Theory and Practice
Five Ways to Study Leadership
(Jackson & Parry, 2008)
• Attempt to lead
• Observe leadership in action
• Talk about leadership
• Read about leadership
• Write about leadership
Exemplary Leadership Practices
(Kouzes & Posner, 2007)
Challenging the Process
Inspiring a Shared Vision
Enabling Others to Act
Modeling the Way
Encouraging the Heart
FINDING YOURSELF AS A
LEADER
Multi-Level View of Leadership Development
(Avolio, 2005)
Life
Experiences
Talents &
Capacities
Self
Aware
Self-
Regulate
Self-
Develop
Triggers
Culture
Vision
How am I Supported?
Where do I come from?
Who am I?
Personal SWOT Analysis
Strengths
•What do you do well?
•What do others see as your
strengths?
Weaknesses
•What could you improve?
•What are others likely to see as
weaknesses?
Opportunities
•What trends could you take
advantage of?
•How can you turn your strengths
into opportunities?
Threats
•What trends could harm you?
•What threats do your weaknesses
expose you to?
Time Remaining:
Personal SWOT
•Complete the SWOT worksheet
STOP!
What do we do with the SWOT
data?
According to Gallup’s research the most
effective leaders:
1. Are always investing in strengths
2. Surround themselves with the right people
and then maximize their team
3. Understand their followers needs
• Reference: Rath & Conchie’s (2008) Strengths Based Leadership
STRENGTHS-BASED
LEADERSHIP
Early Leadership Theory: Traits
• Premise:
– All great leaders have
common traits
• Challenge:
1. Identify the
leadership traits
2. Make people with
those traits the
leaders
Explaining Leadership Differences:
Style Approaches to Leadership
Leadership Grid Situational Leadership
Strengths-Based Leadership
• Argues that we all have
innate talents to be
developed into strengths
• Views leadership as a
collective process
• Recommends different
strengths for different
leadership situations
Leadership Myths and Truths
Myths
– Each of us can be anything we want to be if
we just work hard.
– We grow most where we are weakest.
– Strengths will take care of themselves.
Truths
– You can be anything your strengths allow you
to be.
– We grow most in the areas we are already
strong.
– I can be taught knowledge and skills, but I
can’t learn talents.
“A leader needs to know his strengths as a
carpenter knows his tools, or as a physician
knows the instruments at her disposal. What
great leaders have in common is that each truly
knows his or her strengths – and can call on the
right strength at the right time. This explains why
there is no definitive list of characteristics that
describes all leaders.”
- Donald O. Clifton, Gallup Researcher and
Father of Strengths Psychology
What is a Strength? Weakness?
STRENGTH
• Consistent, near perfect performance
in an activity
= STRENGTH
WEAKNESS
• Something that gets in the way of
excellent performance
Knowledge + Skills + Talents
INDICATORS OF WEAKNESS
• Feel defensive about performance
– Develop obsessive behavior
• Exhibit slow learning
– Do not profit from with repeated experience
• Experience a reduction of confidence
from performing the activity
• Lack futuristic thinking about the activity
• Suffer burnout while practicing
How Do I Find My Strengths?
 Listen to your yearnings
 Watch for satisfactions
 Watch for rapid learning
 Glimpses of excellence
 Total performance of excellence
Domains of Leadership Strength
Executing Relationship Building
Strategic Thinking Influencing
Task-
Oriented
People-
Oriented
Future-Oriented
Present-Oriented
Executing Domain
Description
• Know how to make things
happen
• Have ability to “catch” an
idea and make it happen
Talent Themes
• Achiever
• Arranger
• Belief
• Consistency
• Deliberative
• Discipline
• Focus
• Responsibility
• Restorative
Relationship Building Domain
Talent Themes
• Adaptability
• Developer
• Connectedness
• Empathy
• Harmony
• Includer
• Individualization
• Positivity
• Relator
Description
• Provide essential glue
that holds the team
together
• Create groups and
organizations that are
much greater than the
sum of their parts
Strategic Thinking Domain
Description
• Keep us all focused on
what could be
• Constantly absorbing and
analyzing information and
helping the team make
better decisions
Talent Themes
• Analytical
• Context
• Futuristic
• Ideation
• Input
• Intellection
• Learner
• Strategic
Influencing Domain
Talent Themes Description
• Help the team reach a
broader audience
• Take charge, speak
up, and make sure the
group is heard
• Activator
• Command
• Communication
• Competition
• Maximizer
• Self-Assurance
• Significance
• Woo
What Are Others’ Strengths?
• Discover the strengths and domains of others
– Complete the worksheet with those around you
• Draw one inclusive picture of the main strengths
of those in your group
– Include in the picture
• The Strengths
• The Domains
Time Remaining:
Prepare a hieroglyphic that
represents collaborative use of
strengths represented in your
group
STOP!
Gallup’s Approach to Strengths-
Based Development
COURAGEOUS FOLLOWERS
Leaders vs. Followers
Common
Purpose
A New Model of Leader-
Follower Relationships
Leader Followers
Shared Values
Leaders and Followers
Serve a Common Purpose
Pursued Within Shared Values
Leading and Following Through Tango
46
Leader-Follower Organization
Leader-follower Leader-follower
Leader-follower Leader-follower
Leader-follower
Leader-follower Leader-follower Leader-follower
Leader-follower
Leader-follower
Source: Gene Dixon
Five Dimensions of
Courageous Followership
Courage
to
Assume Responsibility
for common purpose
Support
leader and
group
energetically
Take moral action
when needed
Participate in
transformation
Constructively
challenge
counterproductive
policies &
behaviors
FOLLOWERS’ BASIC NEEDS
(ACCORDING TO GALLUP POLLS; RATH & CONCHIE, 2008)
• Trust
– Chances of being engaged at work when the
individual does not trust the company’s leaders is just
1 in 12.
• Compassion
– Those who indicate “My supervisor, or someone at
work, seems to care about me as a person” are:
• Significantly more likely to stay with the
organization
• Substantially more productive
FOLLOWERS’ BASIC NEEDS (continued) (ACCORDING TO
GALLUP POLLS; RATH & CONCHIE, 2008)
• Stability
– Those with high confidence in their company’s
financial future are nine times more likely to be
engaged in their jobs.
• Hope
– Among those who disagreed that their company’s
leadership made them “feel enthusiastic about the
future,” only 1% were engaged in their jobs.
Leader-Follower Organization
Leader-follower Leader-follower
Leader-follower Leader-follower
Leader-follower
Leader-follower Leader-follower Leader-follower
Leader-follower
Leader-follower
50
Source: Gene Dixon
What Strong Teams Have in
Common (Rath & Conchie, 2008)
1. Conflict doesn’t destroy strong teams
because strong teams focus on results
2. Strong teams prioritize what’s best for the
organization and then move forward
3. Members of strong teams are as
committed to their personal lives as they
are to their work
4. Strong teams embrace diversity
5. Strong teams are magnets for talent
APPLYING WHAT WE HAVE
LEARNED
Lesson for Practice
“A leader is someone who can get
things done through other people.”
-Warren Buffet
Where Can We Apply Leadership?
• Business
• Community
• Family
• Professional
Organizations
Multi-Level View of Leadership Development
(Avolio, 2005)
Life
Experiences
Talents &
Capacities
Self
Aware
Self-
Regulate
Self-
Develop
Triggers
Culture
Vision
How am I Supported?
What am I Experiencing?
How do I develop and behave?
Where do I come from?
Who am I?
What am I becoming?
Your Individual Development Plan
• Name It
• Claim It
• Aim It
Implications for You and Others?
Thank you!
Let me know how I can help
• Eric Kaufman
– EKaufman@VT.Edu

Strengths-Based Leadership for VALOR

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Who is EricKaufman? • Associate Professor & Extension Specialist • Lead researcher for VALOR program launch • Coordinator of VT’s Graduate Certificate in Collaborative Community Leadership • Former H.S. AgriScience Teacher
  • 3.
    Our Agenda… 1. Personalizing Leadership 2.Principles of Strengths- Based Leadership 3. Partnering with Courageous Followers 4. Strategies for Application
  • 4.
    Virginia Agriculture’s Interest (Kaufmanet al., 2010) “Growing new leaders and enhancing the skills of current leaders is vitally important to the future of agriculture.” “I believe that the more involved one becomes in problem solving, working in team/group settings with a strong community commitment the more people can work together to solve any and all problems their community is faced with. Since agriculture is so critical anything we can do to provide leadership learning in this area would be extremely beneficial.”
  • 5.
    VALOR Vision Statement TheVirginia Agriculture Leaders Obtaining Results (VALOR) program will provide a sustainable future for Virginia's agricultural community by maximizing potential for successful growth through a system of networking, collaborative decision-making, and development of strong leaders.
  • 6.
    WHAT DO WEKNOW ABOUT LEADERSHIP?
  • 7.
    GALLUP POLL –LEADERSHIP ABILITY Out of 1,001 U.S. adults surveyed, 97% rated their ability to lead as being at or above average. 97% 3% At or Above Average Below Average What % of U.S. adults rate their leadership ability as being at or above average?
  • 8.
    GALLUP POLL –LEADERSHIP EXPERIENCE Out of 1,001 U.S. adults surveyed, more than two- thirds reported that they have led a group or team. 67% 33% Led a Group or Team Yes No What % of U.S. adults have led a group or team?
  • 9.
    How Do YouDefine Leadership? • Defining Leadership through Personalized Plates – Use template to create a personalized license plate that identifies a characteristic of leadership. – Your plate may have a combination of up to seven letters, numbers, and/or special characters. – Creativity is encouraged.
  • 10.
  • 12.
    How Do YouDefine Leadership? • Defining Leadership through Personalized Plates – Use template to create a personalized license plate that identifies a characteristic of leadership. – Your plate may have a combination of up to seven letters, numbers, and/or special characters. – Creativity is encouraged.
  • 13.
    Caveat on StudyingLeadership “The distinctive feature of leadership is that it would appear the more we learn about leadership, the more we realize we have to and want to learn.” (Jackson & Parry, 2008, p. 9)
  • 14.
    Leadership Defined “Leadership isthe art of accomplishing more than the science of management says is possible.” – Colin Powell, American statesman and retired four-star general in the United States Army “Leadership is the art of mobilizing others to want to struggle for shared aspirations.” – James Kouzes & Barry Posner, leadership researchers and authors of The Leadership Challenge “Leadership is a process whereby an individual influences a group of individuals to achieve a common goal.” – Peter Northouse, professor of communication and author of Leadership: Theory and Practice
  • 15.
    Five Ways toStudy Leadership (Jackson & Parry, 2008) • Attempt to lead • Observe leadership in action • Talk about leadership • Read about leadership • Write about leadership
  • 16.
    Exemplary Leadership Practices (Kouzes& Posner, 2007) Challenging the Process Inspiring a Shared Vision Enabling Others to Act Modeling the Way Encouraging the Heart
  • 17.
  • 18.
    Multi-Level View ofLeadership Development (Avolio, 2005) Life Experiences Talents & Capacities Self Aware Self- Regulate Self- Develop Triggers Culture Vision How am I Supported? Where do I come from? Who am I?
  • 19.
    Personal SWOT Analysis Strengths •Whatdo you do well? •What do others see as your strengths? Weaknesses •What could you improve? •What are others likely to see as weaknesses? Opportunities •What trends could you take advantage of? •How can you turn your strengths into opportunities? Threats •What trends could harm you? •What threats do your weaknesses expose you to?
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
    What do wedo with the SWOT data? According to Gallup’s research the most effective leaders: 1. Are always investing in strengths 2. Surround themselves with the right people and then maximize their team 3. Understand their followers needs • Reference: Rath & Conchie’s (2008) Strengths Based Leadership
  • 23.
  • 24.
    Early Leadership Theory:Traits • Premise: – All great leaders have common traits • Challenge: 1. Identify the leadership traits 2. Make people with those traits the leaders
  • 25.
    Explaining Leadership Differences: StyleApproaches to Leadership Leadership Grid Situational Leadership
  • 26.
    Strengths-Based Leadership • Arguesthat we all have innate talents to be developed into strengths • Views leadership as a collective process • Recommends different strengths for different leadership situations
  • 27.
    Leadership Myths andTruths Myths – Each of us can be anything we want to be if we just work hard. – We grow most where we are weakest. – Strengths will take care of themselves. Truths – You can be anything your strengths allow you to be. – We grow most in the areas we are already strong. – I can be taught knowledge and skills, but I can’t learn talents.
  • 28.
    “A leader needsto know his strengths as a carpenter knows his tools, or as a physician knows the instruments at her disposal. What great leaders have in common is that each truly knows his or her strengths – and can call on the right strength at the right time. This explains why there is no definitive list of characteristics that describes all leaders.” - Donald O. Clifton, Gallup Researcher and Father of Strengths Psychology
  • 29.
    What is aStrength? Weakness? STRENGTH • Consistent, near perfect performance in an activity = STRENGTH WEAKNESS • Something that gets in the way of excellent performance Knowledge + Skills + Talents
  • 30.
    INDICATORS OF WEAKNESS •Feel defensive about performance – Develop obsessive behavior • Exhibit slow learning – Do not profit from with repeated experience • Experience a reduction of confidence from performing the activity • Lack futuristic thinking about the activity • Suffer burnout while practicing
  • 31.
    How Do IFind My Strengths?  Listen to your yearnings  Watch for satisfactions  Watch for rapid learning  Glimpses of excellence  Total performance of excellence
  • 32.
    Domains of LeadershipStrength Executing Relationship Building Strategic Thinking Influencing Task- Oriented People- Oriented Future-Oriented Present-Oriented
  • 33.
    Executing Domain Description • Knowhow to make things happen • Have ability to “catch” an idea and make it happen Talent Themes • Achiever • Arranger • Belief • Consistency • Deliberative • Discipline • Focus • Responsibility • Restorative
  • 34.
    Relationship Building Domain TalentThemes • Adaptability • Developer • Connectedness • Empathy • Harmony • Includer • Individualization • Positivity • Relator Description • Provide essential glue that holds the team together • Create groups and organizations that are much greater than the sum of their parts
  • 35.
    Strategic Thinking Domain Description •Keep us all focused on what could be • Constantly absorbing and analyzing information and helping the team make better decisions Talent Themes • Analytical • Context • Futuristic • Ideation • Input • Intellection • Learner • Strategic
  • 36.
    Influencing Domain Talent ThemesDescription • Help the team reach a broader audience • Take charge, speak up, and make sure the group is heard • Activator • Command • Communication • Competition • Maximizer • Self-Assurance • Significance • Woo
  • 38.
    What Are Others’Strengths? • Discover the strengths and domains of others – Complete the worksheet with those around you • Draw one inclusive picture of the main strengths of those in your group – Include in the picture • The Strengths • The Domains
  • 39.
    Time Remaining: Prepare ahieroglyphic that represents collaborative use of strengths represented in your group
  • 40.
  • 41.
    Gallup’s Approach toStrengths- Based Development
  • 42.
  • 43.
  • 44.
    Common Purpose A New Modelof Leader- Follower Relationships Leader Followers Shared Values Leaders and Followers Serve a Common Purpose Pursued Within Shared Values
  • 45.
    Leading and FollowingThrough Tango
  • 46.
    46 Leader-Follower Organization Leader-follower Leader-follower Leader-followerLeader-follower Leader-follower Leader-follower Leader-follower Leader-follower Leader-follower Leader-follower Source: Gene Dixon
  • 47.
    Five Dimensions of CourageousFollowership Courage to Assume Responsibility for common purpose Support leader and group energetically Take moral action when needed Participate in transformation Constructively challenge counterproductive policies & behaviors
  • 48.
    FOLLOWERS’ BASIC NEEDS (ACCORDINGTO GALLUP POLLS; RATH & CONCHIE, 2008) • Trust – Chances of being engaged at work when the individual does not trust the company’s leaders is just 1 in 12. • Compassion – Those who indicate “My supervisor, or someone at work, seems to care about me as a person” are: • Significantly more likely to stay with the organization • Substantially more productive
  • 49.
    FOLLOWERS’ BASIC NEEDS(continued) (ACCORDING TO GALLUP POLLS; RATH & CONCHIE, 2008) • Stability – Those with high confidence in their company’s financial future are nine times more likely to be engaged in their jobs. • Hope – Among those who disagreed that their company’s leadership made them “feel enthusiastic about the future,” only 1% were engaged in their jobs.
  • 50.
    Leader-Follower Organization Leader-follower Leader-follower Leader-followerLeader-follower Leader-follower Leader-follower Leader-follower Leader-follower Leader-follower Leader-follower 50 Source: Gene Dixon
  • 51.
    What Strong TeamsHave in Common (Rath & Conchie, 2008) 1. Conflict doesn’t destroy strong teams because strong teams focus on results 2. Strong teams prioritize what’s best for the organization and then move forward 3. Members of strong teams are as committed to their personal lives as they are to their work 4. Strong teams embrace diversity 5. Strong teams are magnets for talent
  • 52.
    APPLYING WHAT WEHAVE LEARNED
  • 53.
    Lesson for Practice “Aleader is someone who can get things done through other people.” -Warren Buffet
  • 54.
    Where Can WeApply Leadership? • Business • Community • Family • Professional Organizations
  • 55.
    Multi-Level View ofLeadership Development (Avolio, 2005) Life Experiences Talents & Capacities Self Aware Self- Regulate Self- Develop Triggers Culture Vision How am I Supported? What am I Experiencing? How do I develop and behave? Where do I come from? Who am I? What am I becoming?
  • 56.
    Your Individual DevelopmentPlan • Name It • Claim It • Aim It
  • 57.
  • 58.
    Thank you! Let meknow how I can help • Eric Kaufman – EKaufman@VT.Edu

Editor's Notes

  • #3 Each of us shares a brief story about our background
  • #4 Based on 50 years of research on both leaders and followers, Gallup has identified three key characteristics of effective leaders:The most effective leaders are always investing in their strengths.The most effective leaders surround themselves with the right people and then maximize their team.The most effective leaders understand their followers’ needs.The benefits of focusing on strengths extend beyond the leader; organizations that help their employees focus on personal strengths dramatically increase the chance of employees being engaged and productive at work. This interactive workshop will help participants identify their personal areas of talent and develop a plan for transforming those talents into strengths. In addition, participants will explore the four domains of leadership strength (executing, influencing, relationship building, and strategic thinking) as well as the four basic needs of followers (trust, compassion, stability, and hope). Participants will leave the workshop with specific ideas for promoting strengths-based leadership and followership in the workplace and other professional settings.
  • #10 Share examples by table.What do these vanity plates tell us about our definition and perspective of leadership?
  • #11 http://sivers.org/ff
  • #13 Share examples by table.What do these vanity plates tell us about our definition and perspective of leadership?
  • #14 What do you hope to learn from this class?Leadership Cartoon by Mark Hill and Russ Volckmann, published in Integral Leadership Review, October 2009
  • #17 Note that these may be related to personality traits, but they are action oriented.How do these relate to the qualities previously identified of leaders we admire?
  • #19 Avolio, B. J. (2005). Leadership development in balance: made/born. Mahwah, N.J.: L. Erlbaum. Page 192, Figure 11.1
  • #20 Share worksheet available at http://www.mindtools.com/pages/article/newTMC_05_1.htm
  • #23 Refer participants to pages 2-3 in book
  • #33 “Although individuals need not be well-rounded, teams should be” (Rath & Conchie, 2008, p. 23)
  • #34 Example: Monique McBride (associate minister for Christian education @ Trinity GNV) can lead any project, but sometimes people get bowled over in the process.
  • #35 Example: Pastor Jeff (Marty’s minister in Nashville) was great with small groups, but struggled when promoted to senior minister
  • #36 Example: Karen Kaufman (NEO Synod Resource Center Director) connects people to resources and examples that highlight what could be, but becomes frustrated when others don’t see the opportunity.
  • #37 Example: Troy Holloway (Director of Generosity @ Trinity GNV) is charismatic and has a proven record with securing support for projects missions, but hates to get bogged down with details.
  • #38 Which leadership domain best captures your leadership strengths – executing, influencing, relationship building, or strategic thinking?When were you at your leadership best?When did you benefit from partnering with another to lead an effort?
  • #44 Refer back to dancing guy videoGraphic from: http://www.uufec.com/wordpress/sermons/from-crack-pot-to-leader/
  • #46 Tango is a close, improvisational dance that requires excellence in both the leader and follower role. Ira has produced a video in which one of the leading Tango practitioners in the US demonstrates the ways in which following well brings out the creativity of the leader and following poorly undermines the leader and the dance.http://www.courageousfollower.net/blog/video/leading-and-following-through-tango-2/
  • #49 Data drawn from Rath & Conchie (2008) part III (pages 79-91)
  • #50 Data drawn from Rath & Conchie (2008) part III (pages 79-91)
  • #54 (Rath & Conchie, 2008, p. 79)
  • #55 Image Source: http://michael-danger.tumblr.com/post/5561753724/this-is-a-map-of-the-usa-made-of-sports-logos-i
  • #56 Avolio, B. J. (2005). Leadership development in balance: made/born. Mahwah, N.J.: L. Erlbaum. Page 192, Figure 11.1
  • #57 Use the worksheet titled “Creating Your Personal Vision”(Phillips-Jones, 2009)