SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Global pattern of moraine-dammed
Gacial Lake Outburst Floods
Stephan Harrison
John Reynolds (Aberystwyth)
Christian Hugel (Zurich)
Jeff Kargel (Arizona)
Andy Wiltshire (UKMO)
Richard Betts (UKMO)
Liam Reinhardt (Exeter)
hulme Trust Helix
Rationale and structure
• AR5 stress on adaptation to climate change
• New focus on Detection and Attribution as important for
extreme events (includes litigation as well as development)
• Important debates on Equilibrium Climate Sensitivity,
Transient Climate Response and policy implications
• Geomorphological sensitivity and D&A for GLOFs
• Stress global scale approach needed
Climate Change: Detection
Bottom: estimate of uncertainty
for one dataset (black). Anomalies
are relative to the mean of
1961-1990.
Energy accumulation (1021 J on
Earth from 1971-2010. Upper
ocean is 700m. Estimates below
2000m started in 1992.
The Radiative Forcing of
WMGHG in AR5 is 2.83 ±
0.28 Wm–2
Milankovitch cycles
around 1.5 Wm–2
The range of
climate sensitivities in
climate models used for
IPCC AR4 is a warming of
0.6–1.2K per Wm–2 of
forcing.
Attribution: Global average radiative forcing
estimates and ranges
We can show a response to this:
• Glacier recession
• Paraglaciation
• GLOFs
– Important as responsible for thousands of deaths per
year
– Huge infrastructure costs
– Implications for economic and social development in
remote mountain regions
Global glacier recession
From 169 glacier length records
(Oerlemans 2006)
West Rongbuk Glacier in
1921 and 2008.
(RGS & David Breashears)
Imja Glacier, central
Himalaya in 1955 and
2009
(Fritz Müller and Alton Byers).
Does paraglaciation become the
dominant mechanism of
sediment movement in
glaciated mountain systems?
Implications for changes in the
magnitude/frequency of natural hazards?
Paraglacial....
landsystems and
processes driven by
deglaciation
Knight and Harrison,
2013,2014
GLOFs seen as paraglacial
phenomena and as a non-linear
response to warming and glacier
recession
No global assessment
Major problem in parameterising
RCMs……so development of predictive
tools difficult
ICIMOD
11
Nare Glacier GLOF, Khumbu Himal, Nepal ASTER image, Bhutan & Tibet
Questions: Can we detect a climate signal in GLOF
development? Will Climate change affect the
magnitude/frequency of GLOFs?
Three issues have to be addressed
• Climate sensitivity
• Geomorphological sensitivity
• Attribution and glacial systems
How much will the temperature warm? i.e.
what is climate sensitivity?
AR5 definitions:
Equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS): “defined as the equilibrium
change in global surface temperature following a doubling of the
atmospheric equivalent CO2 concentration”*
Transient climate response (TCR): “the change in global surface
temperature in a global coupled climate model in a 1%yr-1 CO2
increase experiment at the time of CO2 doubling”*
*Note: Units are in degrees Celsius (°C).
PDFs, distribution and ranges
for ECS (IPCC AR5)
• no central figure given
• lower limit may be reduced
(problem of using recent data sets to
constrain this?)
• long tail…..although figures greater
than 6°C unlikely (and palaeo record
doesn’t suggest this)
• TCR lower than this….but may be
more relevant for adaptation policy
What is
‘geomorphological
sensitivity’?
GLOFs become valuable
metric with which to test
‘geomorphological
sensitivity’ and to discuss
uncertainties
1. Is there a warming
trend in mountain
regions?
2. Can we detect trends
in magnitude and
frequency of GLOFs?ICIMOD
However, Attribution problem....How can we
Attribute Extreme Events to Human Forcing
• Difficult problem to solve because:
– Relates to a set of small scale events
– These may be stochastic and/or display chaos
– Understanding them depends on assessing nature of
initial conditions as well as forcing (i.e. the precise
conditions of the system before the event began as
well as whatever might be acting on the system)
– To model events we need probabilistic framework...lots
of model runs (ensembles)….and with a suitable
model!
Event based attribution
Approach:
Find out how many times
a specific event of interest
occurs in a model with
predindustrial GHG forcing
(‘natural world’).
Find out how many times
a specific event of interest
occurs in a model with
current levels of GHG
forcing (‘actual world’).
Assess the difference
(Fraction of Attributable
Risk).
Requires:
a model capable of simulating
the event(s) of interest
many runs of the model
FAR = 1 – P0 / P1
Problem of running meaningful model
ensembles which can help develop attribution
for GLOFs
Very difficult in mountains:
• Large changes in albedo, water vapour fluxes, ice temperature,
supraglacial debris fluxes, landcover etc over small spatial scales
• Topography difficult to model and model resolution still much too
coarse
• How to model paraglacial triggers?
• How to model initial conditions?
Tasman Glacier, New
Zealand
Charles Warren
Attribution and debris
covered glaciers
Debris obscures the
glacier-climate
signal...and difficult to
model and parameterise
Baltoro Glacier
The GLOF record
• We need a Global record of GLOFs and a more complete data
set than hitherto.
In Zailiskiy Alatau GLOFs
concentrated in 1960s-
90s…few in recent years
Passmore, Harrison et al
2008. AAAR
Developing a record for D&A was the
motivation for the GLOF inventory
• 567 glacier hazard events had to be cross-checked
• Problem is that many events named after the
glacial lake in some datasets; in others the same
event named after the glacier or mountain region
• Eventually these whittled down to 191 GLOFs
associated with moraine dam failure…best candidates
for Atrribution
We can show that
world’s mountains are
warming….but data
resolution is 5°
Black crosses are
glaciers from WGI-XF
Harrison et al. in
submission
• For Attribution….we need integration between
glacier and climate models (RCMs) at scales
where debris supply, lake initiation, trigger
mechanisms can be modelled.
• And we need an uncensored data base of GLOF
magnitude and frequency in the past.
• Pattern so far shows rising temperatures in the
world’s mountains but the number of GLOFs has
fallen and there is no trend in magnitude.
Conclusions
• Attributing GLOFs to AGW too early because attribution
studies have not been done (and are problematic).
• Modelling at scale required and in mountain regions also
difficult. Parameterisation of crucial processes needed.
• No global GLOF inventory and data sets are incomplete
(so Detection difficult)
• However, an important task….for adaptation policy,
litigation issues (Climate Justice Programme) and
assessing impact of climate on extreme geomorphological
events.

More Related Content

What's hot

3.3 Climate data and projections
3.3 Climate data and projections3.3 Climate data and projections
3.3 Climate data and projections
NAP Events
 
Democratising climate science: how climate model emulators add robustness and...
Democratising climate science: how climate model emulators add robustness and...Democratising climate science: how climate model emulators add robustness and...
Democratising climate science: how climate model emulators add robustness and...
ipcc-media
 
Modeling the Climate System: Is model-based science like model-based engineer...
Modeling the Climate System: Is model-based science like model-based engineer...Modeling the Climate System: Is model-based science like model-based engineer...
Modeling the Climate System: Is model-based science like model-based engineer...
Steve Easterbrook
 
Key messages from the IPCC WGI Report
Key messages from the IPCC WGI ReportKey messages from the IPCC WGI Report
Key messages from the IPCC WGI Report
ipcc-media
 
Why is it difficult to resolve future projections of Arctic-midlatitude linka...
Why is it difficult to resolve future projections of Arctic-midlatitude linka...Why is it difficult to resolve future projections of Arctic-midlatitude linka...
Why is it difficult to resolve future projections of Arctic-midlatitude linka...
Zachary Labe
 
Modeling Past and Future Climate
Modeling Past and Future ClimateModeling Past and Future Climate
Modeling Past and Future Climate
Andreas Schmittner
 
Decadal warming slowdown predictions by an artificial neural network
Decadal warming slowdown predictions by an artificial neural networkDecadal warming slowdown predictions by an artificial neural network
Decadal warming slowdown predictions by an artificial neural network
Zachary Labe
 
Topic related to the Physical Science Basis of Climate Change
Topic related to the Physical Science Basis of Climate Change Topic related to the Physical Science Basis of Climate Change
Topic related to the Physical Science Basis of Climate Change
ipcc-media
 
Climate Change in the Arctic
Climate Change in the ArcticClimate Change in the Arctic
Climate Change in the Arctic
Zachary Labe
 
Arctic climate change through the lens of data visualization
Arctic climate change through the lens of data visualizationArctic climate change through the lens of data visualization
Arctic climate change through the lens of data visualization
Zachary Labe
 
Climate models
Climate modelsClimate models
Climate models
Prof. A.Balasubramanian
 
Observations and climate model projections of Arctic climate change
Observations and climate model projections of Arctic climate changeObservations and climate model projections of Arctic climate change
Observations and climate model projections of Arctic climate change
Zachary Labe
 
Communicating Arctic climate change through data-driven stories
Communicating Arctic climate change through data-driven storiesCommunicating Arctic climate change through data-driven stories
Communicating Arctic climate change through data-driven stories
Zachary Labe
 
Climate science part 3 - climate models and predicted climate change
Climate science part 3 - climate models and predicted climate changeClimate science part 3 - climate models and predicted climate change
Climate science part 3 - climate models and predicted climate change
LPE Learning Center
 
Irvine and schaefer 2021 solar geoengineering
Irvine and schaefer 2021 solar geoengineeringIrvine and schaefer 2021 solar geoengineering
Irvine and schaefer 2021 solar geoengineering
Advanced-Concepts-Team
 
Event Attribution
Event AttributionEvent Attribution
Event Attribution
ipcc-media
 
Dissertation Defense: Zachary Labe
Dissertation Defense: Zachary LabeDissertation Defense: Zachary Labe
Dissertation Defense: Zachary Labe
Zachary Labe
 
The Pan-Arctic Impacts of Thinning Sea Ice
The Pan-Arctic Impacts of Thinning Sea IceThe Pan-Arctic Impacts of Thinning Sea Ice
The Pan-Arctic Impacts of Thinning Sea Ice
Zachary Labe
 
Refining projections of the 'warm Arctic, cold Siberia' pattern in climate mo...
Refining projections of the 'warm Arctic, cold Siberia' pattern in climate mo...Refining projections of the 'warm Arctic, cold Siberia' pattern in climate mo...
Refining projections of the 'warm Arctic, cold Siberia' pattern in climate mo...
Zachary Labe
 
Intro and brief demo of the Interactive Atlas
Intro and brief demo of the Interactive AtlasIntro and brief demo of the Interactive Atlas
Intro and brief demo of the Interactive Atlas
ipcc-media
 

What's hot (20)

3.3 Climate data and projections
3.3 Climate data and projections3.3 Climate data and projections
3.3 Climate data and projections
 
Democratising climate science: how climate model emulators add robustness and...
Democratising climate science: how climate model emulators add robustness and...Democratising climate science: how climate model emulators add robustness and...
Democratising climate science: how climate model emulators add robustness and...
 
Modeling the Climate System: Is model-based science like model-based engineer...
Modeling the Climate System: Is model-based science like model-based engineer...Modeling the Climate System: Is model-based science like model-based engineer...
Modeling the Climate System: Is model-based science like model-based engineer...
 
Key messages from the IPCC WGI Report
Key messages from the IPCC WGI ReportKey messages from the IPCC WGI Report
Key messages from the IPCC WGI Report
 
Why is it difficult to resolve future projections of Arctic-midlatitude linka...
Why is it difficult to resolve future projections of Arctic-midlatitude linka...Why is it difficult to resolve future projections of Arctic-midlatitude linka...
Why is it difficult to resolve future projections of Arctic-midlatitude linka...
 
Modeling Past and Future Climate
Modeling Past and Future ClimateModeling Past and Future Climate
Modeling Past and Future Climate
 
Decadal warming slowdown predictions by an artificial neural network
Decadal warming slowdown predictions by an artificial neural networkDecadal warming slowdown predictions by an artificial neural network
Decadal warming slowdown predictions by an artificial neural network
 
Topic related to the Physical Science Basis of Climate Change
Topic related to the Physical Science Basis of Climate Change Topic related to the Physical Science Basis of Climate Change
Topic related to the Physical Science Basis of Climate Change
 
Climate Change in the Arctic
Climate Change in the ArcticClimate Change in the Arctic
Climate Change in the Arctic
 
Arctic climate change through the lens of data visualization
Arctic climate change through the lens of data visualizationArctic climate change through the lens of data visualization
Arctic climate change through the lens of data visualization
 
Climate models
Climate modelsClimate models
Climate models
 
Observations and climate model projections of Arctic climate change
Observations and climate model projections of Arctic climate changeObservations and climate model projections of Arctic climate change
Observations and climate model projections of Arctic climate change
 
Communicating Arctic climate change through data-driven stories
Communicating Arctic climate change through data-driven storiesCommunicating Arctic climate change through data-driven stories
Communicating Arctic climate change through data-driven stories
 
Climate science part 3 - climate models and predicted climate change
Climate science part 3 - climate models and predicted climate changeClimate science part 3 - climate models and predicted climate change
Climate science part 3 - climate models and predicted climate change
 
Irvine and schaefer 2021 solar geoengineering
Irvine and schaefer 2021 solar geoengineeringIrvine and schaefer 2021 solar geoengineering
Irvine and schaefer 2021 solar geoengineering
 
Event Attribution
Event AttributionEvent Attribution
Event Attribution
 
Dissertation Defense: Zachary Labe
Dissertation Defense: Zachary LabeDissertation Defense: Zachary Labe
Dissertation Defense: Zachary Labe
 
The Pan-Arctic Impacts of Thinning Sea Ice
The Pan-Arctic Impacts of Thinning Sea IceThe Pan-Arctic Impacts of Thinning Sea Ice
The Pan-Arctic Impacts of Thinning Sea Ice
 
Refining projections of the 'warm Arctic, cold Siberia' pattern in climate mo...
Refining projections of the 'warm Arctic, cold Siberia' pattern in climate mo...Refining projections of the 'warm Arctic, cold Siberia' pattern in climate mo...
Refining projections of the 'warm Arctic, cold Siberia' pattern in climate mo...
 
Intro and brief demo of the Interactive Atlas
Intro and brief demo of the Interactive AtlasIntro and brief demo of the Interactive Atlas
Intro and brief demo of the Interactive Atlas
 

Similar to Stephan harrison

2014 Climate Change Connections - Workshop Content & Activities
2014 Climate Change Connections - Workshop Content & Activities 2014 Climate Change Connections - Workshop Content & Activities
2014 Climate Change Connections - Workshop Content & Activities
Teresa Eastburn
 
General circulation model
General circulation modelGeneral circulation model
General circulation model
Absar Ahmed
 
Long term climate change projections, commitment and irreversibility
Long term climate change projections, commitment and irreversibilityLong term climate change projections, commitment and irreversibility
Long term climate change projections, commitment and irreversibility
ICES - International Council for the Exploration of the Sea
 
Ted Shepherd, University of Reading, OECD Workshop on “Climate change, Assump...
Ted Shepherd, University of Reading, OECD Workshop on “Climate change, Assump...Ted Shepherd, University of Reading, OECD Workshop on “Climate change, Assump...
Ted Shepherd, University of Reading, OECD Workshop on “Climate change, Assump...
OECD Environment
 
Scientists - Introduction to climate change science
Scientists - Introduction to climate change science Scientists - Introduction to climate change science
Scientists - Introduction to climate change science
ipcc-media
 
Program on Mathematical and Statistical Methods for Climate and the Earth Sys...
Program on Mathematical and Statistical Methods for Climate and the Earth Sys...Program on Mathematical and Statistical Methods for Climate and the Earth Sys...
Program on Mathematical and Statistical Methods for Climate and the Earth Sys...
The Statistical and Applied Mathematical Sciences Institute
 
Tim Palmer, University of Oxford - OECD Workshop on “Climate change, Assumpti...
Tim Palmer, University of Oxford - OECD Workshop on “Climate change, Assumpti...Tim Palmer, University of Oxford - OECD Workshop on “Climate change, Assumpti...
Tim Palmer, University of Oxford - OECD Workshop on “Climate change, Assumpti...
OECD Environment
 
Incorporating Climate Tipping Points Into Policy Analysis
Incorporating Climate Tipping Points Into Policy AnalysisIncorporating Climate Tipping Points Into Policy Analysis
Incorporating Climate Tipping Points Into Policy Analysis
OECD Environment
 
Climate Change and the New Industrial Revolution
Climate Change and the New Industrial RevolutionClimate Change and the New Industrial Revolution
Climate Change and the New Industrial Revolution
Glenn Klith Andersen
 
Dr Andrew Rawson: Soil Carbon Sequestration in a Changing Climate
Dr Andrew Rawson: Soil Carbon Sequestration in a Changing ClimateDr Andrew Rawson: Soil Carbon Sequestration in a Changing Climate
Dr Andrew Rawson: Soil Carbon Sequestration in a Changing Climate
Carbon Coalition
 
The truth on climate change
The truth on climate changeThe truth on climate change
The truth on climate change
centinel2012
 
Lesson 7 Basis for projection of climate change
Lesson 7   Basis for projection of climate changeLesson 7   Basis for projection of climate change
Lesson 7 Basis for projection of climate change
Dr. P.B.Dharmasena
 
Adam Smith
Adam SmithAdam Smith
Adam Smith
CCCASTAFF
 
Global climate change unit 2
Global climate change unit 2Global climate change unit 2
Global climate change unit 2
Martin Wildenberg
 
CLIM Undergraduate Workshop: Applications in Climate Context - Michael Wehner...
CLIM Undergraduate Workshop: Applications in Climate Context - Michael Wehner...CLIM Undergraduate Workshop: Applications in Climate Context - Michael Wehner...
CLIM Undergraduate Workshop: Applications in Climate Context - Michael Wehner...
The Statistical and Applied Mathematical Sciences Institute
 
CLIMATE CHANGE AND GLOBAL WATER RESOURCES
CLIMATE CHANGE AND GLOBAL WATER RESOURCESCLIMATE CHANGE AND GLOBAL WATER RESOURCES
CLIMATE CHANGE AND GLOBAL WATER RESOURCES
Shyam Mohan Chaudhary
 
Climate Change: Frequently Asked Questions
Climate Change: Frequently Asked QuestionsClimate Change: Frequently Asked Questions
Climate Change: Frequently Asked Questions
Northern Institute of Applied Climate Science
 
Assessing ecosystem vulnerability
Assessing ecosystem vulnerabilityAssessing ecosystem vulnerability
Assessing ecosystem vulnerability
Jennifer Costanza
 
IAHR 2015 - Coastal sustainability for ,sanchez-arcilla,30062015
IAHR 2015 - Coastal sustainability for ,sanchez-arcilla,30062015IAHR 2015 - Coastal sustainability for ,sanchez-arcilla,30062015
IAHR 2015 - Coastal sustainability for ,sanchez-arcilla,30062015Deltares
 
IAHR 2015 - Coastal sustainability for uncertain futures, Sanchez-Arcilla, 30...
IAHR 2015 - Coastal sustainability for uncertain futures, Sanchez-Arcilla, 30...IAHR 2015 - Coastal sustainability for uncertain futures, Sanchez-Arcilla, 30...
IAHR 2015 - Coastal sustainability for uncertain futures, Sanchez-Arcilla, 30...
Deltares
 

Similar to Stephan harrison (20)

2014 Climate Change Connections - Workshop Content & Activities
2014 Climate Change Connections - Workshop Content & Activities 2014 Climate Change Connections - Workshop Content & Activities
2014 Climate Change Connections - Workshop Content & Activities
 
General circulation model
General circulation modelGeneral circulation model
General circulation model
 
Long term climate change projections, commitment and irreversibility
Long term climate change projections, commitment and irreversibilityLong term climate change projections, commitment and irreversibility
Long term climate change projections, commitment and irreversibility
 
Ted Shepherd, University of Reading, OECD Workshop on “Climate change, Assump...
Ted Shepherd, University of Reading, OECD Workshop on “Climate change, Assump...Ted Shepherd, University of Reading, OECD Workshop on “Climate change, Assump...
Ted Shepherd, University of Reading, OECD Workshop on “Climate change, Assump...
 
Scientists - Introduction to climate change science
Scientists - Introduction to climate change science Scientists - Introduction to climate change science
Scientists - Introduction to climate change science
 
Program on Mathematical and Statistical Methods for Climate and the Earth Sys...
Program on Mathematical and Statistical Methods for Climate and the Earth Sys...Program on Mathematical and Statistical Methods for Climate and the Earth Sys...
Program on Mathematical and Statistical Methods for Climate and the Earth Sys...
 
Tim Palmer, University of Oxford - OECD Workshop on “Climate change, Assumpti...
Tim Palmer, University of Oxford - OECD Workshop on “Climate change, Assumpti...Tim Palmer, University of Oxford - OECD Workshop on “Climate change, Assumpti...
Tim Palmer, University of Oxford - OECD Workshop on “Climate change, Assumpti...
 
Incorporating Climate Tipping Points Into Policy Analysis
Incorporating Climate Tipping Points Into Policy AnalysisIncorporating Climate Tipping Points Into Policy Analysis
Incorporating Climate Tipping Points Into Policy Analysis
 
Climate Change and the New Industrial Revolution
Climate Change and the New Industrial RevolutionClimate Change and the New Industrial Revolution
Climate Change and the New Industrial Revolution
 
Dr Andrew Rawson: Soil Carbon Sequestration in a Changing Climate
Dr Andrew Rawson: Soil Carbon Sequestration in a Changing ClimateDr Andrew Rawson: Soil Carbon Sequestration in a Changing Climate
Dr Andrew Rawson: Soil Carbon Sequestration in a Changing Climate
 
The truth on climate change
The truth on climate changeThe truth on climate change
The truth on climate change
 
Lesson 7 Basis for projection of climate change
Lesson 7   Basis for projection of climate changeLesson 7   Basis for projection of climate change
Lesson 7 Basis for projection of climate change
 
Adam Smith
Adam SmithAdam Smith
Adam Smith
 
Global climate change unit 2
Global climate change unit 2Global climate change unit 2
Global climate change unit 2
 
CLIM Undergraduate Workshop: Applications in Climate Context - Michael Wehner...
CLIM Undergraduate Workshop: Applications in Climate Context - Michael Wehner...CLIM Undergraduate Workshop: Applications in Climate Context - Michael Wehner...
CLIM Undergraduate Workshop: Applications in Climate Context - Michael Wehner...
 
CLIMATE CHANGE AND GLOBAL WATER RESOURCES
CLIMATE CHANGE AND GLOBAL WATER RESOURCESCLIMATE CHANGE AND GLOBAL WATER RESOURCES
CLIMATE CHANGE AND GLOBAL WATER RESOURCES
 
Climate Change: Frequently Asked Questions
Climate Change: Frequently Asked QuestionsClimate Change: Frequently Asked Questions
Climate Change: Frequently Asked Questions
 
Assessing ecosystem vulnerability
Assessing ecosystem vulnerabilityAssessing ecosystem vulnerability
Assessing ecosystem vulnerability
 
IAHR 2015 - Coastal sustainability for ,sanchez-arcilla,30062015
IAHR 2015 - Coastal sustainability for ,sanchez-arcilla,30062015IAHR 2015 - Coastal sustainability for ,sanchez-arcilla,30062015
IAHR 2015 - Coastal sustainability for ,sanchez-arcilla,30062015
 
IAHR 2015 - Coastal sustainability for uncertain futures, Sanchez-Arcilla, 30...
IAHR 2015 - Coastal sustainability for uncertain futures, Sanchez-Arcilla, 30...IAHR 2015 - Coastal sustainability for uncertain futures, Sanchez-Arcilla, 30...
IAHR 2015 - Coastal sustainability for uncertain futures, Sanchez-Arcilla, 30...
 

More from ClimDev15

Nir y. krakauer
Nir y. krakauerNir y. krakauer
Nir y. krakauerClimDev15
 
Nicky shree shrestha
Nicky shree shresthaNicky shree shrestha
Nicky shree shresthaClimDev15
 
Gerald spreitzhofer
Gerald spreitzhoferGerald spreitzhofer
Gerald spreitzhoferClimDev15
 
Dibas shrestha
Dibas shresthaDibas shrestha
Dibas shresthaClimDev15
 
Anita khadka
Anita khadkaAnita khadka
Anita khadkaClimDev15
 
Md. abu hanif
Md. abu hanifMd. abu hanif
Md. abu hanifClimDev15
 
Keshav prasad khanal
Keshav prasad khanalKeshav prasad khanal
Keshav prasad khanalClimDev15
 
Gokarna jung thapa
Gokarna jung thapaGokarna jung thapa
Gokarna jung thapaClimDev15
 
Bhawani s. dongol
Bhawani s. dongolBhawani s. dongol
Bhawani s. dongolClimDev15
 
Sarah mc kune
Sarah mc kuneSarah mc kune
Sarah mc kuneClimDev15
 
Smrittee kala panta
Smrittee kala pantaSmrittee kala panta
Smrittee kala pantaClimDev15
 
Praju gurung
Praju gurungPraju gurung
Praju gurungClimDev15
 
Netra p. osti
Netra p. ostiNetra p. osti
Netra p. ostiClimDev15
 
Md. monowar hossain ronee
Md. monowar hossain roneeMd. monowar hossain ronee
Md. monowar hossain roneeClimDev15
 
Dinesh pandey
Dinesh pandeyDinesh pandey
Dinesh pandeyClimDev15
 
Soni m pradhanang
Soni m pradhanangSoni m pradhanang
Soni m pradhanangClimDev15
 
Prakash tiwari
Prakash tiwariPrakash tiwari
Prakash tiwariClimDev15
 

More from ClimDev15 (20)

Nir y. krakauer
Nir y. krakauerNir y. krakauer
Nir y. krakauer
 
Nicky shree shrestha
Nicky shree shresthaNicky shree shrestha
Nicky shree shrestha
 
Gerald spreitzhofer
Gerald spreitzhoferGerald spreitzhofer
Gerald spreitzhofer
 
Dibas shrestha
Dibas shresthaDibas shrestha
Dibas shrestha
 
Anita khadka
Anita khadkaAnita khadka
Anita khadka
 
Rinku verma
Rinku vermaRinku verma
Rinku verma
 
Md. abu hanif
Md. abu hanifMd. abu hanif
Md. abu hanif
 
Keshav prasad khanal
Keshav prasad khanalKeshav prasad khanal
Keshav prasad khanal
 
Gokarna jung thapa
Gokarna jung thapaGokarna jung thapa
Gokarna jung thapa
 
Bhawani s. dongol
Bhawani s. dongolBhawani s. dongol
Bhawani s. dongol
 
Sarah mc kune
Sarah mc kuneSarah mc kune
Sarah mc kune
 
Smrittee kala panta
Smrittee kala pantaSmrittee kala panta
Smrittee kala panta
 
Praju gurung
Praju gurungPraju gurung
Praju gurung
 
Metthew
MetthewMetthew
Metthew
 
Madhav giri
Madhav giriMadhav giri
Madhav giri
 
Netra p. osti
Netra p. ostiNetra p. osti
Netra p. osti
 
Md. monowar hossain ronee
Md. monowar hossain roneeMd. monowar hossain ronee
Md. monowar hossain ronee
 
Dinesh pandey
Dinesh pandeyDinesh pandey
Dinesh pandey
 
Soni m pradhanang
Soni m pradhanangSoni m pradhanang
Soni m pradhanang
 
Prakash tiwari
Prakash tiwariPrakash tiwari
Prakash tiwari
 

Stephan harrison

  • 1. Global pattern of moraine-dammed Gacial Lake Outburst Floods Stephan Harrison John Reynolds (Aberystwyth) Christian Hugel (Zurich) Jeff Kargel (Arizona) Andy Wiltshire (UKMO) Richard Betts (UKMO) Liam Reinhardt (Exeter) hulme Trust Helix
  • 2. Rationale and structure • AR5 stress on adaptation to climate change • New focus on Detection and Attribution as important for extreme events (includes litigation as well as development) • Important debates on Equilibrium Climate Sensitivity, Transient Climate Response and policy implications • Geomorphological sensitivity and D&A for GLOFs • Stress global scale approach needed
  • 3. Climate Change: Detection Bottom: estimate of uncertainty for one dataset (black). Anomalies are relative to the mean of 1961-1990. Energy accumulation (1021 J on Earth from 1971-2010. Upper ocean is 700m. Estimates below 2000m started in 1992.
  • 4. The Radiative Forcing of WMGHG in AR5 is 2.83 ± 0.28 Wm–2 Milankovitch cycles around 1.5 Wm–2 The range of climate sensitivities in climate models used for IPCC AR4 is a warming of 0.6–1.2K per Wm–2 of forcing. Attribution: Global average radiative forcing estimates and ranges
  • 5. We can show a response to this: • Glacier recession • Paraglaciation • GLOFs – Important as responsible for thousands of deaths per year – Huge infrastructure costs – Implications for economic and social development in remote mountain regions
  • 6. Global glacier recession From 169 glacier length records (Oerlemans 2006)
  • 7. West Rongbuk Glacier in 1921 and 2008. (RGS & David Breashears) Imja Glacier, central Himalaya in 1955 and 2009 (Fritz Müller and Alton Byers).
  • 8. Does paraglaciation become the dominant mechanism of sediment movement in glaciated mountain systems? Implications for changes in the magnitude/frequency of natural hazards?
  • 9. Paraglacial.... landsystems and processes driven by deglaciation Knight and Harrison, 2013,2014
  • 10. GLOFs seen as paraglacial phenomena and as a non-linear response to warming and glacier recession No global assessment Major problem in parameterising RCMs……so development of predictive tools difficult ICIMOD
  • 11. 11 Nare Glacier GLOF, Khumbu Himal, Nepal ASTER image, Bhutan & Tibet Questions: Can we detect a climate signal in GLOF development? Will Climate change affect the magnitude/frequency of GLOFs?
  • 12. Three issues have to be addressed • Climate sensitivity • Geomorphological sensitivity • Attribution and glacial systems
  • 13. How much will the temperature warm? i.e. what is climate sensitivity? AR5 definitions: Equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS): “defined as the equilibrium change in global surface temperature following a doubling of the atmospheric equivalent CO2 concentration”* Transient climate response (TCR): “the change in global surface temperature in a global coupled climate model in a 1%yr-1 CO2 increase experiment at the time of CO2 doubling”* *Note: Units are in degrees Celsius (°C).
  • 14. PDFs, distribution and ranges for ECS (IPCC AR5) • no central figure given • lower limit may be reduced (problem of using recent data sets to constrain this?) • long tail…..although figures greater than 6°C unlikely (and palaeo record doesn’t suggest this) • TCR lower than this….but may be more relevant for adaptation policy
  • 15. What is ‘geomorphological sensitivity’? GLOFs become valuable metric with which to test ‘geomorphological sensitivity’ and to discuss uncertainties 1. Is there a warming trend in mountain regions? 2. Can we detect trends in magnitude and frequency of GLOFs?ICIMOD
  • 16. However, Attribution problem....How can we Attribute Extreme Events to Human Forcing • Difficult problem to solve because: – Relates to a set of small scale events – These may be stochastic and/or display chaos – Understanding them depends on assessing nature of initial conditions as well as forcing (i.e. the precise conditions of the system before the event began as well as whatever might be acting on the system) – To model events we need probabilistic framework...lots of model runs (ensembles)….and with a suitable model!
  • 17. Event based attribution Approach: Find out how many times a specific event of interest occurs in a model with predindustrial GHG forcing (‘natural world’). Find out how many times a specific event of interest occurs in a model with current levels of GHG forcing (‘actual world’). Assess the difference (Fraction of Attributable Risk). Requires: a model capable of simulating the event(s) of interest many runs of the model FAR = 1 – P0 / P1
  • 18. Problem of running meaningful model ensembles which can help develop attribution for GLOFs Very difficult in mountains: • Large changes in albedo, water vapour fluxes, ice temperature, supraglacial debris fluxes, landcover etc over small spatial scales • Topography difficult to model and model resolution still much too coarse • How to model paraglacial triggers? • How to model initial conditions?
  • 19. Tasman Glacier, New Zealand Charles Warren Attribution and debris covered glaciers Debris obscures the glacier-climate signal...and difficult to model and parameterise Baltoro Glacier
  • 21. • We need a Global record of GLOFs and a more complete data set than hitherto. In Zailiskiy Alatau GLOFs concentrated in 1960s- 90s…few in recent years Passmore, Harrison et al 2008. AAAR
  • 22. Developing a record for D&A was the motivation for the GLOF inventory • 567 glacier hazard events had to be cross-checked • Problem is that many events named after the glacial lake in some datasets; in others the same event named after the glacier or mountain region • Eventually these whittled down to 191 GLOFs associated with moraine dam failure…best candidates for Atrribution
  • 23.
  • 24. We can show that world’s mountains are warming….but data resolution is 5° Black crosses are glaciers from WGI-XF Harrison et al. in submission
  • 25. • For Attribution….we need integration between glacier and climate models (RCMs) at scales where debris supply, lake initiation, trigger mechanisms can be modelled. • And we need an uncensored data base of GLOF magnitude and frequency in the past. • Pattern so far shows rising temperatures in the world’s mountains but the number of GLOFs has fallen and there is no trend in magnitude.
  • 26. Conclusions • Attributing GLOFs to AGW too early because attribution studies have not been done (and are problematic). • Modelling at scale required and in mountain regions also difficult. Parameterisation of crucial processes needed. • No global GLOF inventory and data sets are incomplete (so Detection difficult) • However, an important task….for adaptation policy, litigation issues (Climate Justice Programme) and assessing impact of climate on extreme geomorphological events.