Language Learning Strategies M.Sajid us Salam M.Phil Linguistics The Islamia University Bahawalpur [email_address]
Using Learning Strategies to Overcome Affective Barriers to Efficient Learning Affective:   Motivation; Anxiety; Willingness to communicate; Attitudes and Beliefs toward language learning. But what are strategies? 
Definition Learning strategies are "operations…to aid the: acquisition,  storage,  retrieval, and  use of information. . .” (Oxford, 1990, p.8)
Definition LLS are the specific actions…to make learning easier,  faster,  more enjoyable,  more self-directed,  more effective, and  more transferable to new situations.  (Oxford, 1990, p. 8).
Operational Definition LLS are the [purposeful steps] used by language learners to  comprehend and process new information more deeply,  to help to recall old information, and  apply knowledge and skills to facilitate problem-solving.  (Nyikos, 1991/[2003], p.25).
Definition LLS are "behaviors or thoughts that a learner engages in during… the learner's encoding process."  These strategies "are the techniques for the learner's  conscious  construction of language rules, vocabulary, pronunciation, discourse, and sociocultural understanding.  (Weinstein & Mayer, 1986, p. 315).  
Definition Language learning strategies are steps  the learner takes to:   Facilitate the    Storage     Retrieval ---    Use of  language.  What about stress, anxiety, lack of motivation?
Common Elements Conscious Planful/Purposeful Task-oriented Not readily observable Focus on cognitive functions Coupled with social and affective needs during communication
Focus on the Learner Students are rarely shown HOW to learn and study  (modeling) Just told: “ You must learn +memorize ”  In reality, they must listen and read meaningfully,  speak and write… so  others  can understand
Oxford’s strategy types in  taxonomy  (1990) Memory Strategies Cognitive Strategies Compensation Strategies Metacognitive Strategies Affective Strategies Social Strategies
Direct Strategies I.  Memory strategies A. Creating mental  linkages B. Applying images and sounds C.  Reviewing  well D. Employing action II.  Cognitive strategies A . Practicing B. Receiving and sending messages C.  Analyzing  and reasoning D. Creating  structure  for input and output III.  Compensation strategies A.  Guessing  intelligently B.  Overcoming  limitations in speaking and writing
Indirect Strategies I.  Metacognitive strategies A. Centering your learning B. Arranging and  planning  your learning C.  Evaluating  your learning II.  Affective strategies A. Lowering your  anxiety B.  Encouraging  yourself C. Taking your emotional temperature III.  Social strategies A. Asking questions B.  Cooperating  with others C.  Empathizing  with others
Learner Autonomy By using selected, task-appropriate strategies, language students are viewed as being:   in transition to be autonomous,  self-regulated learners, that is,   learners who take significant responsibility for their own learning.
Research has demonstrated  That learners are  actively   involved in their learning Use different kinds of strategies Have different  beliefs  about strategy use and learning approaches That several  factors  have powerful influence on strategy choice/use: Motivation, proficiency, years of study, sex, major, if requirement
Major findings related to  successful  language learning : Adapted from Naiman et al (1978), p. 103 The learner must be  active  in learning and practice. must begin to view the language as a  system. must  use  the language in real  communication. must  monitor  his interlanguage. must come to terms with the  affective   demands  of language learning.
The good language learner: Rubin, 1975, p.45-47 is guesser, but an accurate guesser! has a strong drive to communicate. is not often inhibited (a risk-taker). focuses on communication, but also attends to form. practices—and creates opportunities to do so. knows what is appropriate. monitors his own and the speech of others. attends to meaning. Actively participates (aloud and silently).
All Learning VARIES  with   TASK   (Skehan) Age LEARNING STYLE   (Reid) GENDER   (Nyikos) CULTURE  (Peacock & Ho) MOTIVATION   (Dornyei) PROFICIENCY  (Oxford & Nyikos)
Key Theories Guiding Learning Strategy Research Information Processing Theory –  Associative Learning (associate personally meaningful links, e.g. Keyword mnemonic), Depth of Processing (longer engaged the student, the deeper the processing and thus, memory) Sociocognitive Theory  -(esp, in cooperative learning)
Research approaches to discover students’ strategies through tasks TASK-  Must Memorize Given List While memorizing ask ss. to write down what they notice they are doing to memorize. (1) in a NARRATIVE form; and (2) in STEP-BY-STEP fashion. OR: Diagram the process graphically (picture, arrows).
HOW TO LEARN BEST   associate! EVENTS  SHAPES   COLORS   IMAGES   EMOTIONS/   FEELINGS  Movements   TIME OF DAY SIMILAR To Native Lang   MEMORIES   OF    Events NOISES   CONTEXT  SETTING  PEOPLE INFO
Research Approaches to discovering learner strategies Oral interviews and  Questionnaires Observation Verbal Report via  Think Aloud Diaries and dialogue journals Retrospective studies via  interviews  or stimulated recall
Oral Interviews and Questionnaires Number   of respondents too much information too individualized, therefore difficult to determine patterns too simplistic may suggest a “preferred” response Disadvantages respondents free to pursue personal interest lends itself to statistical analysis Advantages Low High Degree of Structure  difficult to generalize unless a large number are gathered responses influenced by social desirability or shyness may not transfer well from one setting to another Disadvantages more detail useful insights time and cost potential for generating and testing hypotheses Advantages Low  (e.g., case study) High  (e.g., group interview or questionnaire)
Observation inability to produce descriptions of internal or mentalistic strategies likely to derive data only on more verbal students bias inherent in an observer’s description student behavior may change with observer’s presence Disadvantages impartial, objective likely to be more quantitative Advantages
Verbal Report (e.g. Think-aloud protocol) cognitive processing is inaccessible because it is unconscious, therefore researchers must raise respondents’ level of awareness or only measure consciously accessible processes probes may force the subject to produce a verbal response not closely related to actual thought processes because of a lack of verbal skills or L2 ability intrusive effect take too much time, e.g., 20 minutes to explain 1.5 second of thought Disadvantages dependent on the information processing model as a framework works best as a complement to other means of research has a strong, historical foundation of use high correlations with subsequent behavior reveal what information is attended to while performing tasks Advantages
Diaries & Dialogue Journals volume of data potentially random nature of the entries ss. may not mention language learning strategies at all small number of subjects restricts generalizability Disadvantages find out what is significant to learners information may be inaccessible through other research techniques can be kept anywhere by anyone Advantages
Retrospective Studies memory deterioration between the experience and the study, therefore should be considered anecdotal individualistic and possibly distorted Disadvantages more objective because of distance from experience more likely to be summary students can gain important personal insights about language learning strategies that worked for them Advantages
We have looked at research approaches, now let’s look at the research on affective side of learning. Anxiety (Horowitz,  Horwitz & Cope,   1986) Cooperation (Naughton, 2006) Motivation (Dornyei, 2001) Willingness to communicate  Attitudes and Beliefs toward language learning (Horwitz;
Social Strategies Join the group Pretend you understand everything Count on your friends to help Also called Communication Strategies Used by Children (Wong-Filmore 1976 /79)
More Social strategies Suggestions for the classroom Cooperating with Others increases performance, fluency awareness and self-concept Strategies :  Cooperate with peers Cooperate with proficient users and native speakers ( who can scaffold, negotiate meaning, provide i+1)
Social/ Affective  strategies Ask Questions for clarification or verification for correction and  support -  to find out appropriateness -  to find alternatives Use discourse markers to signal  need for assistance : “ I wonder if…”  “Could you please…”
Affective support strategies Empathizing with Others to develop cultural awareness and understanding become aware of own and others’ feelings Takes off stress and anxiety when empathy gained
Affective: In the classroom: Lower the anxiety level – learner plays music while studying Use encouragement – Give the students a social reward (smile, praise, handshake, high 5) Have them reward themselves for successfully completing a task
Social  +  Affective Ask questions    Encourage learners to always ask for clarification or verification Cooperation and Empathy   Invite students to develop understanding of others “ If anyone can do this, you can!” “ Good job!”  “Nice try!”
Speaking strategies Teacher: “it is OK to make mistakes” Model to ss  how  to say: “ please slow down” Say that again, please Could you repeat that again? Conversation Management Strategies “ Ok, I think you are saying…” “ so in other words…”
Metacognitive  The KEY! Center the learning –> Show the student  how  to link new information with already known material Arrange and Plan –> Help student to set outlines, goals Identify –> Ask the learner “ How  did you learn that?”  This enables them to  know  their own learning strategies.
How to find out your students’ language learning strategies Ask ss to write a short essay or simply ask: How do you study vocabulary?  grammar? What do you do when you need to talk to a partner in class? How often read? What  enjoy  reading? *  What are tips for fellow students?
Discover  cont. Give a TASK: Ask students to tell you or a partner how they complete the task.  memorize  vocablary Give students a quiz or test,  when done , ask them to write down next to the item how they remembered the item, What did you do to write better or read correctly?
Ask students to  reflect  on how they completed the task: memorize vocabulary study grammar      jot down next to reading passage  study and/or take a quiz
Strategies promote: Language competence Risk-taking + confidence Memory and retention Self-monitoring  Good study habits Awareness of strengths and individual differences
Resources-Websites Prof. Andrew Cohen’s Strategies-based Instruction web page: http://www.carla.umn.edu/bibliography/strategies.html Styles-and Strategies-Based Instruction: A Teachers' Guide http://www.carla.umn.edu/resources/ working-papers/index.html http://www.nclrc.org/essentials/motivating/strategytable.htm
Further readings on strategies Please see handout with r eferences . Thank you!   Questions, please!

Nyikos Strategy Presentation07

  • 1.
    Language Learning StrategiesM.Sajid us Salam M.Phil Linguistics The Islamia University Bahawalpur [email_address]
  • 2.
    Using Learning Strategiesto Overcome Affective Barriers to Efficient Learning Affective: Motivation; Anxiety; Willingness to communicate; Attitudes and Beliefs toward language learning. But what are strategies? 
  • 3.
    Definition Learning strategiesare "operations…to aid the: acquisition, storage, retrieval, and use of information. . .” (Oxford, 1990, p.8)
  • 4.
    Definition LLS arethe specific actions…to make learning easier, faster, more enjoyable, more self-directed, more effective, and more transferable to new situations. (Oxford, 1990, p. 8).
  • 5.
    Operational Definition LLSare the [purposeful steps] used by language learners to comprehend and process new information more deeply, to help to recall old information, and apply knowledge and skills to facilitate problem-solving. (Nyikos, 1991/[2003], p.25).
  • 6.
    Definition LLS are"behaviors or thoughts that a learner engages in during… the learner's encoding process." These strategies "are the techniques for the learner's conscious construction of language rules, vocabulary, pronunciation, discourse, and sociocultural understanding. (Weinstein & Mayer, 1986, p. 315).  
  • 7.
    Definition Language learningstrategies are steps the learner takes to: Facilitate the  Storage  Retrieval ---  Use of language. What about stress, anxiety, lack of motivation?
  • 8.
    Common Elements ConsciousPlanful/Purposeful Task-oriented Not readily observable Focus on cognitive functions Coupled with social and affective needs during communication
  • 9.
    Focus on theLearner Students are rarely shown HOW to learn and study (modeling) Just told: “ You must learn +memorize ” In reality, they must listen and read meaningfully, speak and write… so others can understand
  • 10.
    Oxford’s strategy typesin taxonomy (1990) Memory Strategies Cognitive Strategies Compensation Strategies Metacognitive Strategies Affective Strategies Social Strategies
  • 11.
    Direct Strategies I. Memory strategies A. Creating mental linkages B. Applying images and sounds C. Reviewing well D. Employing action II. Cognitive strategies A . Practicing B. Receiving and sending messages C. Analyzing and reasoning D. Creating structure for input and output III. Compensation strategies A. Guessing intelligently B. Overcoming limitations in speaking and writing
  • 12.
    Indirect Strategies I. Metacognitive strategies A. Centering your learning B. Arranging and planning your learning C. Evaluating your learning II. Affective strategies A. Lowering your anxiety B. Encouraging yourself C. Taking your emotional temperature III. Social strategies A. Asking questions B. Cooperating with others C. Empathizing with others
  • 13.
    Learner Autonomy Byusing selected, task-appropriate strategies, language students are viewed as being:  in transition to be autonomous, self-regulated learners, that is,  learners who take significant responsibility for their own learning.
  • 14.
    Research has demonstrated That learners are actively involved in their learning Use different kinds of strategies Have different beliefs about strategy use and learning approaches That several factors have powerful influence on strategy choice/use: Motivation, proficiency, years of study, sex, major, if requirement
  • 15.
    Major findings relatedto successful language learning : Adapted from Naiman et al (1978), p. 103 The learner must be active in learning and practice. must begin to view the language as a system. must use the language in real communication. must monitor his interlanguage. must come to terms with the affective demands of language learning.
  • 16.
    The good languagelearner: Rubin, 1975, p.45-47 is guesser, but an accurate guesser! has a strong drive to communicate. is not often inhibited (a risk-taker). focuses on communication, but also attends to form. practices—and creates opportunities to do so. knows what is appropriate. monitors his own and the speech of others. attends to meaning. Actively participates (aloud and silently).
  • 17.
    All Learning VARIES with TASK (Skehan) Age LEARNING STYLE (Reid) GENDER (Nyikos) CULTURE (Peacock & Ho) MOTIVATION (Dornyei) PROFICIENCY (Oxford & Nyikos)
  • 18.
    Key Theories GuidingLearning Strategy Research Information Processing Theory – Associative Learning (associate personally meaningful links, e.g. Keyword mnemonic), Depth of Processing (longer engaged the student, the deeper the processing and thus, memory) Sociocognitive Theory -(esp, in cooperative learning)
  • 19.
    Research approaches todiscover students’ strategies through tasks TASK- Must Memorize Given List While memorizing ask ss. to write down what they notice they are doing to memorize. (1) in a NARRATIVE form; and (2) in STEP-BY-STEP fashion. OR: Diagram the process graphically (picture, arrows).
  • 20.
    HOW TO LEARNBEST  associate! EVENTS SHAPES COLORS IMAGES EMOTIONS/ FEELINGS Movements TIME OF DAY SIMILAR To Native Lang MEMORIES OF Events NOISES CONTEXT SETTING PEOPLE INFO
  • 21.
    Research Approaches todiscovering learner strategies Oral interviews and Questionnaires Observation Verbal Report via Think Aloud Diaries and dialogue journals Retrospective studies via interviews or stimulated recall
  • 22.
    Oral Interviews andQuestionnaires Number  of respondents too much information too individualized, therefore difficult to determine patterns too simplistic may suggest a “preferred” response Disadvantages respondents free to pursue personal interest lends itself to statistical analysis Advantages Low High Degree of Structure  difficult to generalize unless a large number are gathered responses influenced by social desirability or shyness may not transfer well from one setting to another Disadvantages more detail useful insights time and cost potential for generating and testing hypotheses Advantages Low (e.g., case study) High (e.g., group interview or questionnaire)
  • 23.
    Observation inability toproduce descriptions of internal or mentalistic strategies likely to derive data only on more verbal students bias inherent in an observer’s description student behavior may change with observer’s presence Disadvantages impartial, objective likely to be more quantitative Advantages
  • 24.
    Verbal Report (e.g.Think-aloud protocol) cognitive processing is inaccessible because it is unconscious, therefore researchers must raise respondents’ level of awareness or only measure consciously accessible processes probes may force the subject to produce a verbal response not closely related to actual thought processes because of a lack of verbal skills or L2 ability intrusive effect take too much time, e.g., 20 minutes to explain 1.5 second of thought Disadvantages dependent on the information processing model as a framework works best as a complement to other means of research has a strong, historical foundation of use high correlations with subsequent behavior reveal what information is attended to while performing tasks Advantages
  • 25.
    Diaries & DialogueJournals volume of data potentially random nature of the entries ss. may not mention language learning strategies at all small number of subjects restricts generalizability Disadvantages find out what is significant to learners information may be inaccessible through other research techniques can be kept anywhere by anyone Advantages
  • 26.
    Retrospective Studies memorydeterioration between the experience and the study, therefore should be considered anecdotal individualistic and possibly distorted Disadvantages more objective because of distance from experience more likely to be summary students can gain important personal insights about language learning strategies that worked for them Advantages
  • 27.
    We have lookedat research approaches, now let’s look at the research on affective side of learning. Anxiety (Horowitz, Horwitz & Cope, 1986) Cooperation (Naughton, 2006) Motivation (Dornyei, 2001) Willingness to communicate Attitudes and Beliefs toward language learning (Horwitz;
  • 28.
    Social Strategies Jointhe group Pretend you understand everything Count on your friends to help Also called Communication Strategies Used by Children (Wong-Filmore 1976 /79)
  • 29.
    More Social strategiesSuggestions for the classroom Cooperating with Others increases performance, fluency awareness and self-concept Strategies : Cooperate with peers Cooperate with proficient users and native speakers ( who can scaffold, negotiate meaning, provide i+1)
  • 30.
    Social/ Affective strategies Ask Questions for clarification or verification for correction and support - to find out appropriateness - to find alternatives Use discourse markers to signal need for assistance : “ I wonder if…” “Could you please…”
  • 31.
    Affective support strategiesEmpathizing with Others to develop cultural awareness and understanding become aware of own and others’ feelings Takes off stress and anxiety when empathy gained
  • 32.
    Affective: In theclassroom: Lower the anxiety level – learner plays music while studying Use encouragement – Give the students a social reward (smile, praise, handshake, high 5) Have them reward themselves for successfully completing a task
  • 33.
    Social + Affective Ask questions  Encourage learners to always ask for clarification or verification Cooperation and Empathy  Invite students to develop understanding of others “ If anyone can do this, you can!” “ Good job!” “Nice try!”
  • 34.
    Speaking strategies Teacher:“it is OK to make mistakes” Model to ss how to say: “ please slow down” Say that again, please Could you repeat that again? Conversation Management Strategies “ Ok, I think you are saying…” “ so in other words…”
  • 35.
    Metacognitive TheKEY! Center the learning –> Show the student how to link new information with already known material Arrange and Plan –> Help student to set outlines, goals Identify –> Ask the learner “ How did you learn that?” This enables them to know their own learning strategies.
  • 36.
    How to findout your students’ language learning strategies Ask ss to write a short essay or simply ask: How do you study vocabulary? grammar? What do you do when you need to talk to a partner in class? How often read? What enjoy reading? * What are tips for fellow students?
  • 37.
    Discover cont.Give a TASK: Ask students to tell you or a partner how they complete the task. memorize vocablary Give students a quiz or test, when done , ask them to write down next to the item how they remembered the item, What did you do to write better or read correctly?
  • 38.
    Ask students to reflect on how they completed the task: memorize vocabulary study grammar  jot down next to reading passage study and/or take a quiz
  • 39.
    Strategies promote: Languagecompetence Risk-taking + confidence Memory and retention Self-monitoring Good study habits Awareness of strengths and individual differences
  • 40.
    Resources-Websites Prof. AndrewCohen’s Strategies-based Instruction web page: http://www.carla.umn.edu/bibliography/strategies.html Styles-and Strategies-Based Instruction: A Teachers' Guide http://www.carla.umn.edu/resources/ working-papers/index.html http://www.nclrc.org/essentials/motivating/strategytable.htm
  • 41.
    Further readings onstrategies Please see handout with r eferences . Thank you! Questions, please!