SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Combustible Dust Safety
John Newquist
Draft 8 2 2015
History of Dust Explosions
• First recorded dust
explosion occurred in
Turin, Italy back in 1785
• 281 combustible dust
incidents in the US from
1980-2005
• Resulted in 119 deaths
and 718 injuries
Introduction
 Accidents in Industry caused by Combustible Dusts
For example, combustible sugar dust was the fuel for a
massive explosion and fire that occurred Feb. 7, 2008, at the
Imperial Sugar Co. plant in Port Wentworth, GA., resulting in
13 deaths and hospitalization of 40 more workers, some of
whom received severe burns.
Below is an illustration of the facility after the explosion.
Introduction
• Accidents in North Carolina caused by Combustible Dusts
Above: Courtesy U.S. Chemical Safety Investigation Board
Above: Aerial View of explosion and fire that occurred on Jan 29, 2003, at
West Pharmaceutical Services plant in Kinston, N.C
Introduction
 What Materials Can Form a Combustible Dust?
A combustible dust explosion hazard may exist in a variety
of industries, including: food (e.g., candy, sugar, spice,
starch, flour, feed), grain, tobacco, plastics, wood, paper,
pulp, rubber, furniture, textiles, pesticides,
pharmaceuticals, dyes, coal, metals (e.g., aluminum,
chromium, iron, magnesium, and zinc), and fossil fuel
power generation.
 Above: Courtesy U.S. Chemical Safety Investigation Board, November 2003, fatal accident at an automotive parts
plant explosion in the U.S. that involved aluminum dust that originated near an aluminum chip melting furnace.
Combustible Dust Events in US: 1980-2005
Food Products
24%
Lumber &
Wood
15%Chemical
Manufacturing
12%
Primary Metal
Industries
8%
Rubber &
Plastic
Products
8%
Electric
Services
8%
Other
7%
Fabricated
Metal Products
7%
Equipment
Manufacturing
7%
Furniture &
Fixtures
4%
Distribution of Dust Events by
Industry
Food
23%
Wood
24%Metal
20%
Plastic
14%
Coal
8%
Inorganic
4%
Other
7%
Distribution of Dust Events by
Material Type
Note: Coal mines & grain handling facilities excluded from study
(Ref. U.S. Chemical Safety Board Report No. 2006-H-1)
Dust Explosion by Equipment Type
Equipment Type % of Incidents
Dust Collector 52
Impact Equipment 17
Silos & Bins 13
Dryers & Ovens 9
Processing Equipment 6
Conveyor 3
Source: FM Global Property Loss Prevention Data Sheet 7-76, “Prevention and
Mitigation of Combustible Dust Explosion and Fire”, May 2008
NFPA Dust Standards
• Keyway Documents
Standard Industry Edition
NFPA 652 All New
NFPA 654 All – General Industry Document 2013
NFPA 61 Food/Agricultural 2013
NFPA 664 Wood 2012
NFPA 484 Metal 2012
NFPA 655 Sulfur 2012
NFPA Dust Standards
• How-to Documents
Standard Purpose Edition
NFPA 68 Explosion Venting 2013
NFPA 69 Suppression/Isolation/Containment/Inerting 2014
NFPA 77 Static Hazards 2014
NFPA 70 National Electric Code 2014
NFPA 499 Practical Electric Classification 2013
April 2014
• Corrigan TX
• Four people remain hospitalized, three in critical condition, after an
explosion and fire at a Polk County plywood mill
• a) dust collector bags impeded the venting area of the dust collector
deflagration vents.
• b) explosion vents releasing in the dust collector without taking measure
to protect employees from the fireball path
• c) dust collector vented and the deflagration traveled upstream to the
sander.
• d) responding to a fire within the sander dust collection system without
the main blower remaining in operation.
• e) responding to a fire within the sander dust collection system without a
choke between the sander dust collector and silo leading to the briquetter.
Chemical Safety Board
• From 2008 to 2012, The CSB board
documented, 50 combustible dust accidents
that led to 29 fatalities and 161 injuries.
Objectives)
• Identify the NFPA 654/664 Standards
applicable to your dust issues.
• Identify three OSHA Standards cited in
COMDUST NEP
• Identify three questions that a plant would be
asked in an OSHA COMDUST NEP inspection.
OSHA
• OSHA has regularly stated that NFPA standards that have not
been specifically incorporated into OSHA standards or
adopted by state or local jurisdictions should be considered by
companies as guidance.
• At the same time, however, the NEP Compliance Directive
instructs OSHA inspectors to consult the NFPA standards to
“obtain evidence of hazard recognition and feasible
abatement methods” to support a citation under the GDC.
• Consequently, companies should consult NFPAs when
evaluating and mitigating potential combustible dust hazards
at their facilities.
The Long and Winding Road
• History of Hazards
• OSHA Inspections
• Issues
• Citations
• Trends
Trend 1 – Rare Events but Still Occurring
• Two British Columbia
sawmills - 2012
• Four dead and 52
injured
• Fines of up to $652,000
• These were wood dust
explosions
Trend 2 – OSHA NEP continues
• Combustible Dust
National Emphasis
Program (NEP) –
revised March 2008
• CSB issues
recommendations in
2005
• Advanced Notice of
Proposed
Rulemaking
(ANPRM) –
published October
2009
• Expert panel met
May 2011
Possible Ignition Sources
• Possible ignition sources include:
– Open flames and sparks (welding, industrial grinding and
cutting, matches, etc.)
– Hot Surfaces (dryers, bearings, heaters, etc.)
– Heat from Mechanical Impacts
– Electrical Discharges (switch and outlet activation)
– Electrostatic Discharges (static electricity)
– Smoldering or burning dust
– Smoking materials (cigarettes, lighters, cigars, etc.)
OSHA Inspections
• Over 1000 COMDUST NEP
inspections since 2008
• High Violations per
inspections (Over
6.0/inspection)
Triggers are:
• Complaint or referral
• Media reports of fires and
explosions
• Inspection Targeting List
~150-300 inspections in 2014
Sample Accident Jan 2009
• The laminate panels pass on
a conveyor underneath a
curing UV light.
• A panel jammed up
underneath the UV light.
• The panel heated up to the
point where it charred,
smoldered and eventually
caught fire.
• The charred pieces were
sucked up into the local
exhaust system, where they
ignited the dust collector
located outside the plant.
• The dust collector blew up,
sending a shock wave back
into/through the plant.
Several overhead doors were blown
off, and one of these struck 4
employees, injuring them.
COMDUST NEP
• Plant history of fires
• Employer’s Dust
Management System
• MSDS’s
• Dust Accumulation
• Dust Collectors
• Ventilation Specifications
• One liter of dust sampled
• Photos
• Interviews – Employees,
Employers
Sample OSHA Questions
• What is the Plant’s
Housekeeping program?
• Is there dust accumulation
of 1/32 inch thick?
• Dust collectors located
inside of buildings?
• Explosion relief venting
distributed over the exterior
walls of buildings and
enclosures?
NFPA 654 Layer Depth Criterion Method 6.1.3
Hazard is present if dust 1/32 inches thick
covers
• 5% of room or building area up to 20,000 ft2
• Up to 1000 ft2 in a building 20,000 ft2 or larger
100
feet
200
feet
20,000 sq. ft.
Building
5% or
1000 sq.
ft.
40 feet
50 ft
1000 sq. ft.
Building or
Room
5% or 50 sq.
ft.
200
feet
200
feet
40,000 sq. ft. Building
1000
sq. ft.
22
How much dust is too much?
Fugitive dust outside equipment –
Permitted thickness
NFPA 654 Particulate
Solids
1/32 inch at 75 lbs/ft3 ,
adjusted for other bulk
densities
NFPA 664 Wood 1/8 inch assumes 20 lbs/ft3
bulk density
NFPA 484 Metals No accumulation – clean daily
NFPA 61 Food +
Agriculture
Remove along with operations
– references NFPA 654
OSHA
Grain
Grain
Handling
1/8 inch – program and
priority areas listed
OSHA
NEP
General
Industry
1/32 inch – Refers to NFPA
654 and FM Data Sheet 7-76
Adapted from: Application of NFPA 654 . . . Samuel A. Rogers, Process Safety, 3 - 2012
23
Sample OSHA Questions
• Does the facility have
isolation devices to prevent
deflagration propagation
between pieces of
equipment connected by
ductwork?
• Does the facility have an
ignition control program,
such as grounding and
bonding?
Fire through a duct is bad
Sample OSHA Questions
• Are Vacuum cleaners
used in dusty areas and
approved for the hazard
classification?
• Are separator devices to
remove foreign
materials used?
• Can tramp metal ignite
combustible dusts in
the dust collection
systems? Check the label for Class II
Sample OSHA Questions
• Is the exhaust from the
dust collectors
recycled?
• Does the dust collector
system have spark
detection and
explosion/deflagration
suppression systems?
Sample OSHA Questions
• Are ducts designed to maintain
sufficient velocity to ensure the
transport of both coarse and fine
particles?
• What is the design basis for the
ventilation?
• Are duct systems, dust collectors,
and dust-producing machinery
bonded and grounded to minimize
accumulation of static electrical
charge?
Sample OSHA Questions
• Is metal ductwork used?
• Are bulk storage containers
constructed of
noncombustible materials?
• Are employees trained in
the hazards of the
combustible dust?
• Are MSDSs for the
chemicals which could
become combustible dust
under normal operations
available to employees?
NEP Citations
• 1910.22, Housekeeping
• 1910.38, Emergency action plans
• 1910.94, Ventilation
• 1910.132, PPE Hazard Analysis
• 1910.146, Permit-required confined
spaces
• 1910.307, Hazardous (classified)
locations
• 1910.1000 Z table, Toxic and
hazardous substances
• 1910.1200, Hazard communication
• General duty clause
5/16/2002 Vicksburg, MS
5 fatalities, 7 injured
23 serious, 2 unclassified
$210,000
Fire in the baghouse, then rubber
dust explosion
No explosion venting or
suppression in baghouse
Poor housekeeping
88 fire reports in 13 years
Trend 3 – OSHA will continue to use
the General Clause Violation
• Dust collectors (Air
Material Separator)
inside
• No proper explosion
protection systems
such as explosion
venting or explosion
suppression systems
NFPA 654 – 2013
7.13.1.1.1 Where an explosion hazard
exists, air-material separators with a
dirty-side volume of 8 ft3 (0.2 m3) or
greater shall be located outside of
buildings.
There are exceptions.
Typical 5(a)(1) Violations
• Systems were not
provided to prevent
deflagration
propagation from
dust collectors to
other parts of the
plant.
October 29, 2003 - Hayes Lemmerz
Manufacturing Plant, IN
Shawn Boone, 33, died in the
Aluminum Dust explosion
Typical 5(a)(1) Violations
• No explosion relief
venting distributed
over the exterior
walls and roofs of the
buildings.
CTA Acoustics 2003 – 7 dead
Fiberglass fibers and excess phenolic resin
powder probably went to the oven while
workers were using compressed air and
lance to break up a cogged bag house
filter
Typical 5(a)(1) Violations
• Dust Collector and
ducts do not prevent
propagation to other
parts of the plant
From BS&B
Typical 5(a)(1) Violations
• Ducts and system were
not grounded
Typical 5(a)(1) Violations
• Airborne fugitive dust
Typical 5(a)(1) Violations
• A means of tramp metal
protection was not
provided to keep any
unwanted metal
fragments out of the
air-material separators
From Duramag
Typical 5(a)(1) Violations
• Excessive dust
• Not cleaning per the
appropriate NFPA
Standard
Typical 5(a)(1) Violations
• Compressed Air was
used for cleaning
• Tip: Clean fugitive dust
• Regular program
• Access to hidden areas
• Safe cleaning methods
• Maintain dust free as possible
• No blow down unless All
electrical power and
processes have been
shutdown and other means
cannot work.
• See NFPA
Typical 5(a)(1) Violations
• No PVC or
nonconductive ducts
Typical 5(a)(1) Violations
• Not maintaining duct
velocity
• While conditions can
vary, 4000 ft/min is
generally accepted as a
minimum conveying
velocity for wood
particulate.
• Sec 8.2.2.1.5
Strategy for Employers
• Test for Combustible
Dust
• Find Applicable NFPA
standards
• Implement a Safety
Management System
• Housekeeping
• Electrical Classification
• Conduct Process Hazard
Analysis for Dust
Generation Processes
• Control Ignition sources
• Develop safety
procedures for working
on dust collectors
• Investigate leaks, hot
spots, near misses
• Train Employees in
hazards of combustible
dust
• Plan for fires and
emergencies
Hazard Assessment & Mitigation
• Below Illustrations: Examples of Woodworking Shop area
that is kept clean, uses engineering controls (dust collection
systems), and is kept free of dust accumulation.
Hazard Assessment & Mitigation
• Below Illustration: An example of another Woodworking
Shop area that is kept clean and free of dust accumulation.
Hazard Assessment & Mitigation
• Below Illustration: An example of an overhead exhaust
ducting at Woodworking Shop area that is kept clean and free
of dust accumulation.
Where are Dust Sources?
• Bag Openers (Slitters)
• Blenders/Mixers
• Dryers
• Dust Collectors
• Pneumatic Conveyors
• Size Reduction Equipment (Grinders)
• Silos and Hoppers
• Hoses, Loading Spouts, Flexible Boots
Ignition Source Control
Electrical equipment
Hot Works
Static electricity control
Mechanical sparks & friction
Open flame control
Design of heating systems &
heated surfaces
Use of tools, & vehicles
Maintenance
Mitigation - Venting
Venting:
• Rupture panels to relieve
pressure preventing a vessel
failure
• Amount of vent area needed is
determined using NFPA 68
equations
• Explosion vent need to
exhaust into a safe area or a
quenching device
Mitigation – Suppression
Suppression:
• Detect a deflagration at early
stage and quench the event with
chemical suppressant
• Cannon/bottle consist of
pressurized gas and suppressant
chemical
• System triggers by pressure or
optical sensor
• Higher maintenance
requirements
Mitigation – Suppression
Factors that Impact Suppression
• Vessel Volume
• Vessel Strength
– Reduced Pressure (Pred)
• Vessel Geometry
– (L/D Ratio)
– Filter Bag/Cartridges
Factors that Impact Suppression
• Initial Pressure (+/-)
• Material (Kst)
• Activation Pressure (Pstat)
Isolation
Isolation
Isolation:
• Must be used to prevent
propagation of an event in
one vessel to
interconnected equipment
• Usually always needed in
conjunction with venting or
suppression
Hierarchy of Equipment Use
6.) Containment
7.) Inerting
1.) Free venting a vessel outdoors
2.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior wall using a duct
3.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior roof using a duct
4.) Flameless venting
5.) Active Suppression
Prevention
Maintenance
– It is also important
to ensure that all
dust-collection
systems are
operating properly
and collected dust is
recycled and/or
disposed according
to the manufacture
specifications for the
equipment.
Maintenance
Check dust collection
systems to make sure
all leaks are sealed
and dust is not
accumulating in the
ductwork. Check
bonding and ground
of all components in
accordance with the
manufacturer
instructions.
Hazard Assessment & Mitigation
• Below Illustrations: An example of an industrial dust
collection system connected to a woodworking shop exhaust
ventilation system to capture generated dust.
NFPA 654 - 2013
• Chapters 1 – 3
Administrative
• Chapter 4 General
Requirements
• Chapter 5 Performance-
based Design Option
• Chapter 6 Facility and
Systems Design
• Chapter 7 Process
Equipment
• Chapter 8 Fugitive Dust
Control and
Housekeeping
• Chapter 9 Ignition
Sources
• Chapter 10 Fire
Protection
• Chapter 11 Training and
Procedures
• Chapter 12 Inspection
and Maintenance
Seven Key NFPA 654 Changes
• 4.2 Process Hazard
Analysis (PHA)
• TREND 5 – PHA are
conducted in less than
10% of companies, but
increasing rapidly
• OSHA VPP facilities have
conducted numerous
PHAs
• 4.2.1* The design of the
fire and explosion safety
provisions shall be
based on a process
hazard analysis of the
facility, the process, and
the associated fire or
explosion hazards.
NFPA 654 PHA
• Examine the facility,
process, and fire and
explosion hazards
• Actual test data required to
support analysis
• Which materials are
combustible?
• If not known, but
suspected, then data are
needed
• Closed or open processes?
• Rate of generation or
release of solids to an
environment?
• Any collection methods in
place?
• Conclusion: processes
generates or handles solids
and dusts are formed in
process, potential exists
Seven Key NFPA 654 Changes
• 4.3 Management of
Change. Written
procedures to manage
change to process
materials, technology,
equipment, procedures,
and facilities shall be
established and
implemented.
Seven Key NFPA 654 Changes
• 4.4.1* Incidents
that result in a fire
or explosion of a
magnitude that
causes property
damage,
production
shutdown time, or
injury shall be
investigated.
• 4.4.3* A written report
…
• 4.4.4* A summary of
the incident
investigation report
shall be shared with
affected personnel…
Seven Key NFPA 654 Changes
• 6.1.1.1 Those portions of
the process and facility
interior where dust
accumulations exist
external to equipment in
sufficient depth to
prevent discerning the
underlying surface color
shall be evaluated to
determine if a dust
explosion hazard or flash
fire hazard exists.
Seven Key NFPA 654 Changes
• 6.1.1.3* Dust flash fire or
dust explosion hazard
areas shall additionally be
determined in accordance
with any one of the
following four methods:
 Layer depth criterion
method in 6.1.3
 Mass method A in 6.1.4
 Mass method B in 6.1.5
 Risk evaluation method in
6.1.6
The NFPA 2 day course on combustible
dust covers these assessment.
Seven Key NFPA 654 Changes
• 6.2 Segregation, Separation, or
Detachment of Combustible Dust
Handling and Processing Areas.
• 6.2.1 General. Areas in which
combustible dusts are produced,
processed, handled, or collected such
that combustible dust accumulation
on exposed or concealed surfaces,
external to equipment or containers,
exceeds the threshold as determined
in Section 6.1, shall be detached,
segregated, or separated from other
occupancies to minimize damage
from a fire or explosion.
Seven Key NFPA 654 Changes
• 7.3.2* Pneumatic Conveying,
Dust Collection, and Centralized
Vacuum Cleaning Systems.
• 7.3.2.1 The design of the system
shall be documented, and the
documentation shall include the
following information:
 Data on the range of particulate
size
 Concentration of combustible
dust in the conveyance air stream
 Potential for reaction between
the transported particulates and
the extinguishing media used to
protect process equipment
 Conductivity of the particulates
 Other physical and chemical
properties that could affect the
fire protection of the process
Mitigation Ignition source control
• Electrical equipment
• Class II, Division 1 and 2
• Consider equipment both inside dust handling equipment and outside
• Static electricity control
• Grounding and bonding are key
• Inspection of ground and bonding means
• Vibrating equipment (e.g., sifters) may cause fatigue failure in straps
• Mechanical sparks & friction
• Rotating equipment bearing failure can lead to very hot surfaces (above the
MIT)
• Sliding surfaces can develop charges
• Steel tools dropping onto concrete or steel
• Mechanical integrity management system/vibration analysis system
• Hot work program
• Open flames
• Design of heating systems & heated surfaces
• Use of tools & vehicles
• Maintenance
• Comfort heating equipment shall obtain combustion air from clean outside source
Damage Control
• Detachment (outside or other bldg.)
• Separation (distance within same room)
• Segregation (barrier)
• Pressure resistant construction
• Pressure relieving construction
• Pressure Venting
• Relief valves
• Maintenance
• Specialized detection systems
• Specialized suppression systems
• Explosion prevention systems
• Maintenance
Dust Collectors
Dust Collectors
Hierarchy of Equipment Use
6.) Containment
7.) Inerting
1.) Free venting a vessel outdoors
2.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior wall using a duct
3.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior roof using a duct
4.) Flameless venting
5.) Active Suppression
Prevention
Dust Collectors
Dust Collectors
Hierarchy of Equipment Use
6.) Containment
7.) Inerting
1.) Free venting a vessel outdoors
2.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior wall using a duct
3.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior roof using a duct
4.) Flameless venting
5.) Active Suppression
Prevention
Dust Collectors
Dust Collectors
Hierarchy of Equipment Use
6.) Containment
7.) Inerting
1.) Free venting a vessel outdoors
2.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior wall using a duct
3.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior roof using a duct
4.) Flameless venting
5.) Active Suppression
Prevention
Dust Collectors
Dust Collectors
Dust Collectors
Milton Hershey School
Location: Hershey, PA
Application: Woodworking
Model: CYLK4440
Air Flow: 8,500 CFM
Dust Collectors
Lincoln Middle School
Location: Passaic, NJ
Application: Woodworking
Model: DKLD48015
Air Flow: 4,800 CFM
Dust Collectors
William Patterson University
Location: Wayne, NJ
Application: Woodworking
Model: DKPD72015
Air Flow: 5,700 CFM
Dust Collectors
Gloucester HS
Location: Gloucester, MA
Application: Woodworking
Model: CYLK4450
Air Flow: 10,000 CFM
Dust Collectors
New Oxford Middle School
Location: New Oxford, PA
Application: Woodworking
Model: DKLD48015
Air Flow: 8,500 CFM
Hierarchy of Equipment Use
6.) Containment
7.) Inerting
1.) Free venting a vessel outdoors
2.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior wall using a duct
3.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior roof using a duct
4.) Flameless venting
5.) Active Suppression
Prevention
Multiple tasks involving exposures may involve use of
FR as normal work wear.
NFPA 2113 (2012) Recommends FR use for combustible dust
A.5.2
• Work where dust
is present on
equipment or
structure
• Changing dust
collector bags
For example, FR garments
should be required for the
following:
Per OSHA NEP
84
Dust depth Frequency Hsk’pg Req. Classification
Negligible
dust (color
discernable)
N/A N/A Unclassified –
general purpose
Negligible
dust to <
1/32 inch
(paper clip)
Infrequent –
Episodic release,
not > 2-3 times
yearly
Clean up
during same
shift
Unclassified –
general purpose
Negligible
dust to <
1/32 inch
Continuous to
frequent –
Continuous with
< 1/32 inch per
24 hours or
Episodic release,
> 3 times yearly
Clean as
needed –
maintain
average <
1/64 inch
(puffy little
cloud with
each step)
Unclassified –
NEMA 12 dust
entry resisting
enclosures and
/sealed non- heat
producing equip.
(For existing plants –
New to be Class II,
Div. 2)Groups F and G Dusts 85
1/32 to
1/8 inch
(Two
Quarters
stacked)
Infrequent Clean up during
same shift
Unclassified – NEMA 12
dust entry resisting
enclosures and /sealed
non- heat producing
equip. (For existing
plants – New to be Class
II, Div. 2)
1/32 to
1/8 inch
Continuous
to frequent
Clean as needed –
maintain average
< 1/16 inch
Class II, Division 2
>1/8 inch Infrequent Immediately shut
down and clean
Class II, Division 2
> 1/8
inch
Continuous
to frequent
Clean frequently –
minimize
accumulation
Class II, Division 1
Groups F and G Dusts 86
NFPA 654 – Housekeeping 8.1,2
Fugitive dust control is
to be provided by
continuous suction
wherever dust is
liberated in normal
operations
The dust is to be
conveyed to air-
material separators
Cleaning frequency, methods and portable vacuum
cleaner requirements are RETROACTIVE for all
facilities
Continuous Suction ?
87
Cleaning Frequency 8.2.1
At facilities operated with LESS than the chosen threshold
dust mass/accumulation per 6.1, cleaning frequency
must ensure:
• Accumulated dust
levels do not exceed
the chosen amount
of dust
• There is a planned
inspection process
that maintains
cleaning at the
correct rate
89
Cleaning Frequency 8.2
For facilities operated with LESS than the chosen
threshold dust mass/accumulation
• Set specific time requirements for cleaning local and
short term spills
• The intent is to remove the excess materials quickly so
that such spills do not need to be included in the
mass calculations of 6.1
90
Timing of Unscheduled Cleaning
Longest Time to Complete
Unscheduled Local Cleaning
Accumulation on the worst
single square meter of
surface
Accessible
Surface
Remote
Surface
1 to 2 times threshold dust
mass/accumulation limit
(TDM/AL)
8 Hours 24 Hours
2 to 4 times TDM/AL 4 Hours 12 Hours
>4 times TDM/AL 1 Hour 3 Hours
Adapted from NFPA 654 Table A.8.2.1.3(a)
91
Cleaning Frequency 8.2.1
For facilities operated with MORE THAN the chosen criterion
for threshold dust mass/ accumulation per 6.1:
DUST
• FR clothing and properly
installed explosion venting
would be included
• Chapter 4 identifies some
general safety requirements
92
• Additional protective measures are necessary per
A.8.2.1.4.
• It is permitted to prepare a documented risk
assessment to determine the level of housekeeping
consistent with protection requirements
Cleaning Methods 8.2.2
Surfaces shall be cleaned in
a manner that minimizes the
risk of generating a fire or
explosion hazard.
Vacuuming shall be the
preferred method of
cleaning.
Where vacuuming is
impractical, permitted
cleaning
methods shall include
sweeping and water wash-down.
93
Cleaning Methods 8.2.2
Blow-downs are permitted for cleaning inaccessible
surfaces or surfaces where personal safety risk is less
than other methods. Use the following precautions:
Vacuuming, sweeping, or water wash-down methods are
to be used first
Dust accumulations in the
area after vacuuming,
sweeping or water
wash-down are not to
exceed the threshold
dust accumulation.
94
Cleaning Methods 8.2.2
NEMA 12 (resists ingress
dust of particles)
• All ignition sources and hot
surfaces capable of
igniting a dust cloud or
dust layer must be shut
down or removed from
the area
Additional requirements for dust blow-down
• Compressed air hose nozzles must be limited to 30
psi discharge pressure as per OSHA
• All electrical equipment potentially exposed to
airborne dust in the area is to meet
95
Housekeeping Procedures 8.2.2.5
Housekeeping
program is BIG
Must be documented (and addressed) in the dust
process hazard analysis and management of
change procedures
Housekeeping procedures should include:
• Risk analysis of the dust
• Particle size
• Moisture content
• MEC and MIE
• Other safety risks introduced
by cleaning methods
• Personal safety procedures and fall
protection
• Flame-resistant garments per NFPA
2113 96
Housekeeping Procedures 8.2.2.5
Procedures should also
include:
• Cleaning sequence and
methods to be used
• Equipment including:
• lifts,
• vacuum systems,
• attachments, etc.
Safety Note: Large and high velocity fans may be used to prevent dust
accumulations. Use of such fans to blow down significant dust
accumulations present the same risks as compressed air blow-downs.
97
Portable Vacuum cleaners 8.2.3.1
• Hoses are to be conductive or static-
dissipative – both suction and air
delivery hoses
• All conductive components including
wands and attachments must be
bonded and grounded
• Dust-laden air must not pass through
the fan or blower
Conductive or Static-
dissipative Hose
They are to meet the following:
• Generally non-combustible construction and meet
requirements for construction and static electrical hazard
controls per 9.3.2 and 7.13.2
98
Portable Vacuum cleaners 8.2.3.1
Additional requirements
• Electrical motors must not be in the
dust laden air stream unless listed for
Class II, Division 1 locations
• No paper filter elements for liquid or
wet pick-up
• Metal dust vacuums are to be listed for
Class II, Division 1, Group E and meet
other NFPA 484 requirements for
specific metal used
99
Vacuum Cleaners for Use in Hazardous Locations
8.2.3.2 And .3
• Use vacuums listed for the
location or
• Provide a fixed-pipe
suction system with
appropriate remotely located
exhauster and dust collector.
• Where flammable
vapors are present,
units are to be listed for
both Class I and Class II
locations
HAZ LOC 100
Spills of Large quantities of dust A.8.2.3.1
In UNCLASSIFIED areas
• Bulk material should be collected by sweeping, or
shoveling
• Listed Class II vacuums may also be used
• Vacuum cleaners per 8.3.2.1 (e.g.: compliant air driven
units) may be used afterwards for residue
Vacuum Truck See also
OSHA Fact Sheet
DSG FS-3589
10 2012
Vacuum trucks are similar to vacuum cleaners. They
require analysis with management of change (MOC)
to remove large quantity spills or releases of dust per
4.3
101
Concluding Remarks
• No two dust explosions are the same.
– No uniform dust laws like there are for gases
• Standards are evolving
• The dust explosion hazard exists
– Be aware of the “I’ve never had a dust explosion
before”
Questions?
Safety and Health Information Bulletin
Purpose
Background
Elements of a Dust Explosion
Facility Dust Hazard Assessment
Dust Control
Ignition Control
Damage Control
Training
References
Resources and Questions?
• NFPA 2-day
Combustible Dust
Seminar
• Combustible Dust
Guidebook - NFPA
• OSHA SHIB
• www.csb.gov
• LinkedIn
Combustible Dust
Forums
• Facebook Grain Mill
Accident page

More Related Content

What's hot

Overview: Rig inspection training
Overview: Rig inspection training Overview: Rig inspection training
Overview: Rig inspection training
Lloyd's Register Energy
 
ADIS Study notes.pdf
ADIS Study notes.pdfADIS Study notes.pdf
ADIS Study notes.pdf
santosh51116
 
Silo safety
Silo safety Silo safety
Elements of Process Safety Management
Elements of Process Safety ManagementElements of Process Safety Management
Elements of Process Safety Management
Shirazeh arghami
 
Combustible Dust 2015 nfpa 644
Combustible Dust 2015 nfpa 644Combustible Dust 2015 nfpa 644
Combustible Dust 2015 nfpa 644
vtsiri
 
Risk Management Plan - Deepwater Oil Rig Deployment
Risk Management Plan - Deepwater Oil Rig DeploymentRisk Management Plan - Deepwater Oil Rig Deployment
Risk Management Plan - Deepwater Oil Rig DeploymentDeborah Obasogie
 
Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill Overview Presentation
Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill Overview PresentationDeepwater Horizon Oil Spill Overview Presentation
Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill Overview PresentationRichard Allaway
 
Piper alpha disaster 1988
Piper alpha disaster 1988Piper alpha disaster 1988
Piper alpha disaster 1988
Fikri Abdul Rahim
 
Sand Control
Sand Control Sand Control
Sand Control
petroEDGE
 
Safety in confined space
Safety in confined space   Safety in confined space
Safety in confined space
The Apprentiice
 
Bhopal gas tragedy
Bhopal gas tragedyBhopal gas tragedy
Bhopal gas tragedyKinjal Jain
 
BP-Deepwater horizon-Macondo-Gulf Of Mexico Oil Spill
BP-Deepwater horizon-Macondo-Gulf Of Mexico Oil Spill BP-Deepwater horizon-Macondo-Gulf Of Mexico Oil Spill
BP-Deepwater horizon-Macondo-Gulf Of Mexico Oil Spill
Dhanish Ahsen
 
Maintenance and inspection of lpg storage tank
Maintenance and inspection of lpg storage tankMaintenance and inspection of lpg storage tank
Maintenance and inspection of lpg storage tank
lpgbnhgastank
 
Explosion of a sulphuric acid tank
Explosion of a sulphuric acid tankExplosion of a sulphuric acid tank
Explosion of a sulphuric acid tank
Usama Khan
 
Safe Operations of Cranes, Hoists and Truck Hoists by Reagan Safety
Safe Operations of Cranes, Hoists and Truck Hoists by Reagan SafetySafe Operations of Cranes, Hoists and Truck Hoists by Reagan Safety
Safe Operations of Cranes, Hoists and Truck Hoists by Reagan Safety
Atlantic Training, LLC.
 
Dust Explosion Prevention
Dust Explosion PreventionDust Explosion Prevention
Dust Explosion Prevention
ChetwinBrandon
 
Safety handbook Saudi Aramco BY Muhammad Fahad Ansari 12IEEM14
Safety handbook Saudi Aramco  BY Muhammad Fahad Ansari  12IEEM14Safety handbook Saudi Aramco  BY Muhammad Fahad Ansari  12IEEM14
Safety handbook Saudi Aramco BY Muhammad Fahad Ansari 12IEEM14
fahadansari131
 
Chernobyl disaster
Chernobyl disasterChernobyl disaster
Chernobyl disasterSteven Heath
 

What's hot (20)

Overview: Rig inspection training
Overview: Rig inspection training Overview: Rig inspection training
Overview: Rig inspection training
 
ADIS Study notes.pdf
ADIS Study notes.pdfADIS Study notes.pdf
ADIS Study notes.pdf
 
Silo safety
Silo safety Silo safety
Silo safety
 
Elements of Process Safety Management
Elements of Process Safety ManagementElements of Process Safety Management
Elements of Process Safety Management
 
Saudi Aramco Inspection Checklist (SAIC)
Saudi Aramco Inspection Checklist (SAIC)Saudi Aramco Inspection Checklist (SAIC)
Saudi Aramco Inspection Checklist (SAIC)
 
Combustible Dust 2015 nfpa 644
Combustible Dust 2015 nfpa 644Combustible Dust 2015 nfpa 644
Combustible Dust 2015 nfpa 644
 
Risk Management Plan - Deepwater Oil Rig Deployment
Risk Management Plan - Deepwater Oil Rig DeploymentRisk Management Plan - Deepwater Oil Rig Deployment
Risk Management Plan - Deepwater Oil Rig Deployment
 
Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill Overview Presentation
Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill Overview PresentationDeepwater Horizon Oil Spill Overview Presentation
Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill Overview Presentation
 
Piper alpha disaster 1988
Piper alpha disaster 1988Piper alpha disaster 1988
Piper alpha disaster 1988
 
Sand Control
Sand Control Sand Control
Sand Control
 
Safety in confined space
Safety in confined space   Safety in confined space
Safety in confined space
 
Bhopal gas tragedy
Bhopal gas tragedyBhopal gas tragedy
Bhopal gas tragedy
 
BP-Deepwater horizon-Macondo-Gulf Of Mexico Oil Spill
BP-Deepwater horizon-Macondo-Gulf Of Mexico Oil Spill BP-Deepwater horizon-Macondo-Gulf Of Mexico Oil Spill
BP-Deepwater horizon-Macondo-Gulf Of Mexico Oil Spill
 
IOC jaipur
IOC jaipurIOC jaipur
IOC jaipur
 
Maintenance and inspection of lpg storage tank
Maintenance and inspection of lpg storage tankMaintenance and inspection of lpg storage tank
Maintenance and inspection of lpg storage tank
 
Explosion of a sulphuric acid tank
Explosion of a sulphuric acid tankExplosion of a sulphuric acid tank
Explosion of a sulphuric acid tank
 
Safe Operations of Cranes, Hoists and Truck Hoists by Reagan Safety
Safe Operations of Cranes, Hoists and Truck Hoists by Reagan SafetySafe Operations of Cranes, Hoists and Truck Hoists by Reagan Safety
Safe Operations of Cranes, Hoists and Truck Hoists by Reagan Safety
 
Dust Explosion Prevention
Dust Explosion PreventionDust Explosion Prevention
Dust Explosion Prevention
 
Safety handbook Saudi Aramco BY Muhammad Fahad Ansari 12IEEM14
Safety handbook Saudi Aramco  BY Muhammad Fahad Ansari  12IEEM14Safety handbook Saudi Aramco  BY Muhammad Fahad Ansari  12IEEM14
Safety handbook Saudi Aramco BY Muhammad Fahad Ansari 12IEEM14
 
Chernobyl disaster
Chernobyl disasterChernobyl disaster
Chernobyl disaster
 

Viewers also liked

Combustible Dust Hazards
Combustible Dust HazardsCombustible Dust Hazards
Combustible Dust Hazards
Albert V. Condello III CSP CHMM
 
SMART Explosion Isolation
SMART Explosion IsolationSMART Explosion Isolation
SMART Explosion Isolation
UBMCanon
 
SMART Explosion Venting
SMART Explosion VentingSMART Explosion Venting
SMART Explosion Venting
UBMCanon
 
Explosion Protection in the Food Industry
Explosion Protection in the Food IndustryExplosion Protection in the Food Industry
Explosion Protection in the Food IndustryTeresa Long
 
Osha update june 2016
Osha  update  june 2016Osha  update  june 2016
Osha update june 2016
John Newquist
 
2015 industrial hygiene & respiratory care
2015 industrial hygiene & respiratory care2015 industrial hygiene & respiratory care
2015 industrial hygiene & respiratory care
John Newquist
 
General Industry Fire Safety SIOSH 2014
General Industry Fire Safety SIOSH 2014General Industry Fire Safety SIOSH 2014
General Industry Fire Safety SIOSH 2014
John Newquist
 
Tree Trimming Safety Update MI 2015
Tree Trimming Safety Update MI 2015Tree Trimming Safety Update MI 2015
Tree Trimming Safety Update MI 2015
John Newquist
 
2015 respirators ppe
2015 respirators ppe2015 respirators ppe
2015 respirators ppe
John Newquist
 
1926 health hazards in industry 2016
1926 health hazards in industry 20161926 health hazards in industry 2016
1926 health hazards in industry 2016
John Newquist
 
Construction Fall Protection
Construction Fall Protection Construction Fall Protection
Construction Fall Protection
John Newquist
 
OSHA recordkeeping four hour
OSHA recordkeeping four hourOSHA recordkeeping four hour
OSHA recordkeeping four hour
John Newquist
 
OSHA Lockout Safety General Industry
OSHA Lockout Safety General IndustryOSHA Lockout Safety General Industry
OSHA Lockout Safety General Industry
John Newquist
 
Criminal Prosecution for Safety and Health Feb 2016
Criminal Prosecution for Safety and Health  Feb 2016Criminal Prosecution for Safety and Health  Feb 2016
Criminal Prosecution for Safety and Health Feb 2016
John Newquist
 
Discussing osha 1910 106 nfpa 30 and recent fire incidents of 2015 2016
Discussing osha 1910 106 nfpa 30 and recent fire incidents of 2015 2016Discussing osha 1910 106 nfpa 30 and recent fire incidents of 2015 2016
Discussing osha 1910 106 nfpa 30 and recent fire incidents of 2015 2016
John Newquist
 
Chst prep core 2016
Chst prep core 2016Chst prep core 2016
Chst prep core 2016
John Newquist
 
7205 health hazards in construction 2015
7205 health hazards in construction 2015 7205 health hazards in construction 2015
7205 health hazards in construction 2015
John Newquist
 
Ghs 2016 one hour
Ghs 2016 one hourGhs 2016 one hour
Ghs 2016 one hour
John Newquist
 
General Industry Introduction to OSHA Safety
General Industry Introduction to OSHA SafetyGeneral Industry Introduction to OSHA Safety
General Industry Introduction to OSHA Safety
John Newquist
 
Gi 2016 machine guarding waubonsee
Gi 2016 machine guarding waubonseeGi 2016 machine guarding waubonsee
Gi 2016 machine guarding waubonsee
John Newquist
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Combustible Dust Hazards
Combustible Dust HazardsCombustible Dust Hazards
Combustible Dust Hazards
 
SMART Explosion Isolation
SMART Explosion IsolationSMART Explosion Isolation
SMART Explosion Isolation
 
SMART Explosion Venting
SMART Explosion VentingSMART Explosion Venting
SMART Explosion Venting
 
Explosion Protection in the Food Industry
Explosion Protection in the Food IndustryExplosion Protection in the Food Industry
Explosion Protection in the Food Industry
 
Osha update june 2016
Osha  update  june 2016Osha  update  june 2016
Osha update june 2016
 
2015 industrial hygiene & respiratory care
2015 industrial hygiene & respiratory care2015 industrial hygiene & respiratory care
2015 industrial hygiene & respiratory care
 
General Industry Fire Safety SIOSH 2014
General Industry Fire Safety SIOSH 2014General Industry Fire Safety SIOSH 2014
General Industry Fire Safety SIOSH 2014
 
Tree Trimming Safety Update MI 2015
Tree Trimming Safety Update MI 2015Tree Trimming Safety Update MI 2015
Tree Trimming Safety Update MI 2015
 
2015 respirators ppe
2015 respirators ppe2015 respirators ppe
2015 respirators ppe
 
1926 health hazards in industry 2016
1926 health hazards in industry 20161926 health hazards in industry 2016
1926 health hazards in industry 2016
 
Construction Fall Protection
Construction Fall Protection Construction Fall Protection
Construction Fall Protection
 
OSHA recordkeeping four hour
OSHA recordkeeping four hourOSHA recordkeeping four hour
OSHA recordkeeping four hour
 
OSHA Lockout Safety General Industry
OSHA Lockout Safety General IndustryOSHA Lockout Safety General Industry
OSHA Lockout Safety General Industry
 
Criminal Prosecution for Safety and Health Feb 2016
Criminal Prosecution for Safety and Health  Feb 2016Criminal Prosecution for Safety and Health  Feb 2016
Criminal Prosecution for Safety and Health Feb 2016
 
Discussing osha 1910 106 nfpa 30 and recent fire incidents of 2015 2016
Discussing osha 1910 106 nfpa 30 and recent fire incidents of 2015 2016Discussing osha 1910 106 nfpa 30 and recent fire incidents of 2015 2016
Discussing osha 1910 106 nfpa 30 and recent fire incidents of 2015 2016
 
Chst prep core 2016
Chst prep core 2016Chst prep core 2016
Chst prep core 2016
 
7205 health hazards in construction 2015
7205 health hazards in construction 2015 7205 health hazards in construction 2015
7205 health hazards in construction 2015
 
Ghs 2016 one hour
Ghs 2016 one hourGhs 2016 one hour
Ghs 2016 one hour
 
General Industry Introduction to OSHA Safety
General Industry Introduction to OSHA SafetyGeneral Industry Introduction to OSHA Safety
General Industry Introduction to OSHA Safety
 
Gi 2016 machine guarding waubonsee
Gi 2016 machine guarding waubonseeGi 2016 machine guarding waubonsee
Gi 2016 machine guarding waubonsee
 

Similar to Combustible Wood Dust Safety 2015 nfpa 644

What is Combustible Dust, What are the Dangers, and how to lessen your risk
What is Combustible Dust, What are the Dangers, and how to lessen your riskWhat is Combustible Dust, What are the Dangers, and how to lessen your risk
What is Combustible Dust, What are the Dangers, and how to lessen your risk
Craig Rutledge
 
Risks Associated to Combustible Dust Handling
Risks Associated to Combustible Dust Handling Risks Associated to Combustible Dust Handling
Risks Associated to Combustible Dust Handling
Atlantic Training, LLC.
 
Combustible Dust Safety 2017
Combustible Dust Safety 2017Combustible Dust Safety 2017
Combustible Dust Safety 2017
John Newquist
 
Com dust 511 2018
Com dust 511 2018Com dust 511 2018
Com dust 511 2018
John Newquist
 
Com dust 7125 seminar 2017
Com dust 7125 seminar 2017Com dust 7125 seminar 2017
Com dust 7125 seminar 2017
John Newquist
 
Respirators 2018
Respirators 2018Respirators 2018
Respirators 2018
John Newquist
 
Gi 2018 subpart h hazardous materials
Gi 2018 subpart h hazardous materialsGi 2018 subpart h hazardous materials
Gi 2018 subpart h hazardous materials
John Newquist
 
OSHA Compliance Update
OSHA Compliance UpdateOSHA Compliance Update
OSHA Compliance Update
Triumvirate Environmental
 
Dust Collection: Governmental Rules, Standards and Regulations
Dust Collection: Governmental Rules, Standards and RegulationsDust Collection: Governmental Rules, Standards and Regulations
Dust Collection: Governmental Rules, Standards and Regulations
Steve Ragan
 
2017 respirators ppe
2017 respirators ppe2017 respirators ppe
2017 respirators ppe
John Newquist
 
INDUSTRIAL FIRE
INDUSTRIAL FIRE INDUSTRIAL FIRE
Combustible Dust
Combustible DustCombustible Dust
Combustible Dust
Atlantic Training, LLC.
 
Safety Index and Fire Index
Safety Index and Fire IndexSafety Index and Fire Index
Safety Index and Fire Index
shiyunkuan
 
Environmental legislation powerpoint
Environmental legislation powerpointEnvironmental legislation powerpoint
Environmental legislation powerpoint
wirethehouse
 
5_Fire Hazard Analysis.ppt
5_Fire Hazard Analysis.ppt5_Fire Hazard Analysis.ppt
5_Fire Hazard Analysis.ppt
IanMardiansyah2
 
Kitchen extract fire safety & fire risk assessments
Kitchen extract fire safety & fire risk assessmentsKitchen extract fire safety & fire risk assessments
Kitchen extract fire safety & fire risk assessments
Jackielansley
 
Introduction to OSHA
Introduction to OSHAIntroduction to OSHA
Introduction to OSHA
John Newquist
 
Swiftclean & CBIO, compliance seminar, Leicester Tigers
Swiftclean & CBIO, compliance seminar, Leicester TigersSwiftclean & CBIO, compliance seminar, Leicester Tigers
Swiftclean & CBIO, compliance seminar, Leicester Tigers
Jackielansley
 

Similar to Combustible Wood Dust Safety 2015 nfpa 644 (20)

What is Combustible Dust, What are the Dangers, and how to lessen your risk
What is Combustible Dust, What are the Dangers, and how to lessen your riskWhat is Combustible Dust, What are the Dangers, and how to lessen your risk
What is Combustible Dust, What are the Dangers, and how to lessen your risk
 
Risks Associated to Combustible Dust Handling
Risks Associated to Combustible Dust Handling Risks Associated to Combustible Dust Handling
Risks Associated to Combustible Dust Handling
 
Combustible Dust Safety 2017
Combustible Dust Safety 2017Combustible Dust Safety 2017
Combustible Dust Safety 2017
 
Com dust 511 2018
Com dust 511 2018Com dust 511 2018
Com dust 511 2018
 
Com dust 7125 seminar 2017
Com dust 7125 seminar 2017Com dust 7125 seminar 2017
Com dust 7125 seminar 2017
 
Respirators 2018
Respirators 2018Respirators 2018
Respirators 2018
 
Gi 2018 subpart h hazardous materials
Gi 2018 subpart h hazardous materialsGi 2018 subpart h hazardous materials
Gi 2018 subpart h hazardous materials
 
OSHA Compliance Update
OSHA Compliance UpdateOSHA Compliance Update
OSHA Compliance Update
 
Dust Collection: Governmental Rules, Standards and Regulations
Dust Collection: Governmental Rules, Standards and RegulationsDust Collection: Governmental Rules, Standards and Regulations
Dust Collection: Governmental Rules, Standards and Regulations
 
2017 respirators ppe
2017 respirators ppe2017 respirators ppe
2017 respirators ppe
 
INDUSTRIAL FIRE
INDUSTRIAL FIRE INDUSTRIAL FIRE
INDUSTRIAL FIRE
 
Combustible Dust
Combustible DustCombustible Dust
Combustible Dust
 
Group13 fracking
Group13 frackingGroup13 fracking
Group13 fracking
 
Safety Index and Fire Index
Safety Index and Fire IndexSafety Index and Fire Index
Safety Index and Fire Index
 
Lecture 10
Lecture 10Lecture 10
Lecture 10
 
Environmental legislation powerpoint
Environmental legislation powerpointEnvironmental legislation powerpoint
Environmental legislation powerpoint
 
5_Fire Hazard Analysis.ppt
5_Fire Hazard Analysis.ppt5_Fire Hazard Analysis.ppt
5_Fire Hazard Analysis.ppt
 
Kitchen extract fire safety & fire risk assessments
Kitchen extract fire safety & fire risk assessmentsKitchen extract fire safety & fire risk assessments
Kitchen extract fire safety & fire risk assessments
 
Introduction to OSHA
Introduction to OSHAIntroduction to OSHA
Introduction to OSHA
 
Swiftclean & CBIO, compliance seminar, Leicester Tigers
Swiftclean & CBIO, compliance seminar, Leicester TigersSwiftclean & CBIO, compliance seminar, Leicester Tigers
Swiftclean & CBIO, compliance seminar, Leicester Tigers
 

More from John Newquist

1926 motor vechicles and struck by 2021
1926 motor vechicles and struck by 20211926 motor vechicles and struck by 2021
1926 motor vechicles and struck by 2021
John Newquist
 
Circular saw safety 2021
Circular saw safety 2021Circular saw safety 2021
Circular saw safety 2021
John Newquist
 
Fy20 Most Frequently Cited OSHA Standards in Construction
Fy20 Most Frequently Cited OSHA Standards in ConstructionFy20 Most Frequently Cited OSHA Standards in Construction
Fy20 Most Frequently Cited OSHA Standards in Construction
John Newquist
 
Fy20 most frequently cited manufacturing OSHA
Fy20 most frequently cited manufacturing OSHA Fy20 most frequently cited manufacturing OSHA
Fy20 most frequently cited manufacturing OSHA
John Newquist
 
Cy19 gi most freq cited general industry
Cy19 gi most freq cited general industryCy19 gi most freq cited general industry
Cy19 gi most freq cited general industry
John Newquist
 
Silica 2018 construction
Silica 2018 constructionSilica 2018 construction
Silica 2018 construction
John Newquist
 
Gi 2017 loto seven hour
Gi 2017 loto seven hourGi 2017 loto seven hour
Gi 2017 loto seven hour
John Newquist
 
Hepatitis c
Hepatitis cHepatitis c
Hepatitis c
John Newquist
 
Gi 2017 lockout 503
Gi 2017 lockout 503Gi 2017 lockout 503
Gi 2017 lockout 503
John Newquist
 
Safety Training Techniques 2017
Safety Training Techniques 2017Safety Training Techniques 2017
Safety Training Techniques 2017
John Newquist
 
Outreach Training Requirements 2017 new
Outreach Training Requirements 2017 newOutreach Training Requirements 2017 new
Outreach Training Requirements 2017 new
John Newquist
 
Safety and Health Training
Safety and Health Training Safety and Health Training
Safety and Health Training
John Newquist
 
Swimming Pool Safety 2017
Swimming Pool Safety 2017 Swimming Pool Safety 2017
Swimming Pool Safety 2017
John Newquist
 
Pesticide safety
Pesticide safetyPesticide safety
Pesticide safety
John Newquist
 
Lockout Minor Servicing Exceptions
Lockout Minor Servicing ExceptionsLockout Minor Servicing Exceptions
Lockout Minor Servicing Exceptions
John Newquist
 
Osha Update 2017 July 2017
Osha Update 2017 July 2017Osha Update 2017 July 2017
Osha Update 2017 July 2017
John Newquist
 
Extreme Weather 2017
Extreme Weather 2017Extreme Weather 2017
Extreme Weather 2017
John Newquist
 
Health and Safety Apps 2017
Health and Safety Apps 2017Health and Safety Apps 2017
Health and Safety Apps 2017
John Newquist
 
Trenching 8 hour 2017
Trenching 8 hour 2017Trenching 8 hour 2017
Trenching 8 hour 2017
John Newquist
 
Gi 2017 recordkeeping four hour
Gi 2017 recordkeeping four hourGi 2017 recordkeeping four hour
Gi 2017 recordkeeping four hour
John Newquist
 

More from John Newquist (20)

1926 motor vechicles and struck by 2021
1926 motor vechicles and struck by 20211926 motor vechicles and struck by 2021
1926 motor vechicles and struck by 2021
 
Circular saw safety 2021
Circular saw safety 2021Circular saw safety 2021
Circular saw safety 2021
 
Fy20 Most Frequently Cited OSHA Standards in Construction
Fy20 Most Frequently Cited OSHA Standards in ConstructionFy20 Most Frequently Cited OSHA Standards in Construction
Fy20 Most Frequently Cited OSHA Standards in Construction
 
Fy20 most frequently cited manufacturing OSHA
Fy20 most frequently cited manufacturing OSHA Fy20 most frequently cited manufacturing OSHA
Fy20 most frequently cited manufacturing OSHA
 
Cy19 gi most freq cited general industry
Cy19 gi most freq cited general industryCy19 gi most freq cited general industry
Cy19 gi most freq cited general industry
 
Silica 2018 construction
Silica 2018 constructionSilica 2018 construction
Silica 2018 construction
 
Gi 2017 loto seven hour
Gi 2017 loto seven hourGi 2017 loto seven hour
Gi 2017 loto seven hour
 
Hepatitis c
Hepatitis cHepatitis c
Hepatitis c
 
Gi 2017 lockout 503
Gi 2017 lockout 503Gi 2017 lockout 503
Gi 2017 lockout 503
 
Safety Training Techniques 2017
Safety Training Techniques 2017Safety Training Techniques 2017
Safety Training Techniques 2017
 
Outreach Training Requirements 2017 new
Outreach Training Requirements 2017 newOutreach Training Requirements 2017 new
Outreach Training Requirements 2017 new
 
Safety and Health Training
Safety and Health Training Safety and Health Training
Safety and Health Training
 
Swimming Pool Safety 2017
Swimming Pool Safety 2017 Swimming Pool Safety 2017
Swimming Pool Safety 2017
 
Pesticide safety
Pesticide safetyPesticide safety
Pesticide safety
 
Lockout Minor Servicing Exceptions
Lockout Minor Servicing ExceptionsLockout Minor Servicing Exceptions
Lockout Minor Servicing Exceptions
 
Osha Update 2017 July 2017
Osha Update 2017 July 2017Osha Update 2017 July 2017
Osha Update 2017 July 2017
 
Extreme Weather 2017
Extreme Weather 2017Extreme Weather 2017
Extreme Weather 2017
 
Health and Safety Apps 2017
Health and Safety Apps 2017Health and Safety Apps 2017
Health and Safety Apps 2017
 
Trenching 8 hour 2017
Trenching 8 hour 2017Trenching 8 hour 2017
Trenching 8 hour 2017
 
Gi 2017 recordkeeping four hour
Gi 2017 recordkeeping four hourGi 2017 recordkeeping four hour
Gi 2017 recordkeeping four hour
 

Recently uploaded

Get Government Grants and Assistance Program
Get Government Grants and Assistance ProgramGet Government Grants and Assistance Program
Get Government Grants and Assistance Program
Get Government Grants
 
What is the point of small housing associations.pptx
What is the point of small housing associations.pptxWhat is the point of small housing associations.pptx
What is the point of small housing associations.pptx
Paul Smith
 
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 362024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
JSchaus & Associates
 
Canadian Immigration Tracker March 2024 - Key Slides
Canadian Immigration Tracker March 2024 - Key SlidesCanadian Immigration Tracker March 2024 - Key Slides
Canadian Immigration Tracker March 2024 - Key Slides
Andrew Griffith
 
PPT Item # 7 - BB Inspection Services Agmt
PPT Item # 7 - BB Inspection Services AgmtPPT Item # 7 - BB Inspection Services Agmt
PPT Item # 7 - BB Inspection Services Agmt
ahcitycouncil
 
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 372024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
JSchaus & Associates
 
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) AmendmentPPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
ahcitycouncil
 
ZGB - The Role of Generative AI in Government transformation.pdf
ZGB - The Role of Generative AI in Government transformation.pdfZGB - The Role of Generative AI in Government transformation.pdf
ZGB - The Role of Generative AI in Government transformation.pdf
Saeed Al Dhaheri
 
PNRR MADRID GREENTECH FOR BROWN NETWORKS NETWORKS MUR_MUSA_TEBALDI.pdf
PNRR MADRID GREENTECH FOR BROWN NETWORKS NETWORKS MUR_MUSA_TEBALDI.pdfPNRR MADRID GREENTECH FOR BROWN NETWORKS NETWORKS MUR_MUSA_TEBALDI.pdf
PNRR MADRID GREENTECH FOR BROWN NETWORKS NETWORKS MUR_MUSA_TEBALDI.pdf
ClaudioTebaldi2
 
Russian anarchist and anti-war movement in the third year of full-scale war
Russian anarchist and anti-war movement in the third year of full-scale warRussian anarchist and anti-war movement in the third year of full-scale war
Russian anarchist and anti-war movement in the third year of full-scale war
Antti Rautiainen
 
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptxMHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
ILC- UK
 
PPT Item # 5 - 5330 Broadway ARB Case # 930F
PPT Item # 5 - 5330 Broadway ARB Case # 930FPPT Item # 5 - 5330 Broadway ARB Case # 930F
PPT Item # 5 - 5330 Broadway ARB Case # 930F
ahcitycouncil
 
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
850fcj96
 
一比一原版(WSU毕业证)西悉尼大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(WSU毕业证)西悉尼大学毕业证成绩单一比一原版(WSU毕业证)西悉尼大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(WSU毕业证)西悉尼大学毕业证成绩单
evkovas
 
The Role of a Process Server in real estate
The Role of a Process Server in real estateThe Role of a Process Server in real estate
The Role of a Process Server in real estate
oklahomajudicialproc1
 
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
GrantManagementInsti
 
一比一原版(UQ毕业证)昆士兰大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(UQ毕业证)昆士兰大学毕业证成绩单一比一原版(UQ毕业证)昆士兰大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(UQ毕业证)昆士兰大学毕业证成绩单
ehbuaw
 
Effects of Extreme Temperatures From Climate Change on the Medicare Populatio...
Effects of Extreme Temperatures From Climate Change on the Medicare Populatio...Effects of Extreme Temperatures From Climate Change on the Medicare Populatio...
Effects of Extreme Temperatures From Climate Change on the Medicare Populatio...
Congressional Budget Office
 
Up the Ratios Bylaws - a Comprehensive Process of Our Organization
Up the Ratios Bylaws - a Comprehensive Process of Our OrganizationUp the Ratios Bylaws - a Comprehensive Process of Our Organization
Up the Ratios Bylaws - a Comprehensive Process of Our Organization
uptheratios
 
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdfPACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
Mohammed325561
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Get Government Grants and Assistance Program
Get Government Grants and Assistance ProgramGet Government Grants and Assistance Program
Get Government Grants and Assistance Program
 
What is the point of small housing associations.pptx
What is the point of small housing associations.pptxWhat is the point of small housing associations.pptx
What is the point of small housing associations.pptx
 
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 362024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
 
Canadian Immigration Tracker March 2024 - Key Slides
Canadian Immigration Tracker March 2024 - Key SlidesCanadian Immigration Tracker March 2024 - Key Slides
Canadian Immigration Tracker March 2024 - Key Slides
 
PPT Item # 7 - BB Inspection Services Agmt
PPT Item # 7 - BB Inspection Services AgmtPPT Item # 7 - BB Inspection Services Agmt
PPT Item # 7 - BB Inspection Services Agmt
 
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 372024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
 
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) AmendmentPPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
 
ZGB - The Role of Generative AI in Government transformation.pdf
ZGB - The Role of Generative AI in Government transformation.pdfZGB - The Role of Generative AI in Government transformation.pdf
ZGB - The Role of Generative AI in Government transformation.pdf
 
PNRR MADRID GREENTECH FOR BROWN NETWORKS NETWORKS MUR_MUSA_TEBALDI.pdf
PNRR MADRID GREENTECH FOR BROWN NETWORKS NETWORKS MUR_MUSA_TEBALDI.pdfPNRR MADRID GREENTECH FOR BROWN NETWORKS NETWORKS MUR_MUSA_TEBALDI.pdf
PNRR MADRID GREENTECH FOR BROWN NETWORKS NETWORKS MUR_MUSA_TEBALDI.pdf
 
Russian anarchist and anti-war movement in the third year of full-scale war
Russian anarchist and anti-war movement in the third year of full-scale warRussian anarchist and anti-war movement in the third year of full-scale war
Russian anarchist and anti-war movement in the third year of full-scale war
 
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptxMHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
 
PPT Item # 5 - 5330 Broadway ARB Case # 930F
PPT Item # 5 - 5330 Broadway ARB Case # 930FPPT Item # 5 - 5330 Broadway ARB Case # 930F
PPT Item # 5 - 5330 Broadway ARB Case # 930F
 
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
 
一比一原版(WSU毕业证)西悉尼大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(WSU毕业证)西悉尼大学毕业证成绩单一比一原版(WSU毕业证)西悉尼大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(WSU毕业证)西悉尼大学毕业证成绩单
 
The Role of a Process Server in real estate
The Role of a Process Server in real estateThe Role of a Process Server in real estate
The Role of a Process Server in real estate
 
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
 
一比一原版(UQ毕业证)昆士兰大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(UQ毕业证)昆士兰大学毕业证成绩单一比一原版(UQ毕业证)昆士兰大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(UQ毕业证)昆士兰大学毕业证成绩单
 
Effects of Extreme Temperatures From Climate Change on the Medicare Populatio...
Effects of Extreme Temperatures From Climate Change on the Medicare Populatio...Effects of Extreme Temperatures From Climate Change on the Medicare Populatio...
Effects of Extreme Temperatures From Climate Change on the Medicare Populatio...
 
Up the Ratios Bylaws - a Comprehensive Process of Our Organization
Up the Ratios Bylaws - a Comprehensive Process of Our OrganizationUp the Ratios Bylaws - a Comprehensive Process of Our Organization
Up the Ratios Bylaws - a Comprehensive Process of Our Organization
 
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdfPACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
 

Combustible Wood Dust Safety 2015 nfpa 644

  • 1. Combustible Dust Safety John Newquist Draft 8 2 2015
  • 2. History of Dust Explosions • First recorded dust explosion occurred in Turin, Italy back in 1785 • 281 combustible dust incidents in the US from 1980-2005 • Resulted in 119 deaths and 718 injuries
  • 3. Introduction  Accidents in Industry caused by Combustible Dusts For example, combustible sugar dust was the fuel for a massive explosion and fire that occurred Feb. 7, 2008, at the Imperial Sugar Co. plant in Port Wentworth, GA., resulting in 13 deaths and hospitalization of 40 more workers, some of whom received severe burns. Below is an illustration of the facility after the explosion.
  • 4. Introduction • Accidents in North Carolina caused by Combustible Dusts Above: Courtesy U.S. Chemical Safety Investigation Board Above: Aerial View of explosion and fire that occurred on Jan 29, 2003, at West Pharmaceutical Services plant in Kinston, N.C
  • 5. Introduction  What Materials Can Form a Combustible Dust? A combustible dust explosion hazard may exist in a variety of industries, including: food (e.g., candy, sugar, spice, starch, flour, feed), grain, tobacco, plastics, wood, paper, pulp, rubber, furniture, textiles, pesticides, pharmaceuticals, dyes, coal, metals (e.g., aluminum, chromium, iron, magnesium, and zinc), and fossil fuel power generation.  Above: Courtesy U.S. Chemical Safety Investigation Board, November 2003, fatal accident at an automotive parts plant explosion in the U.S. that involved aluminum dust that originated near an aluminum chip melting furnace.
  • 6. Combustible Dust Events in US: 1980-2005 Food Products 24% Lumber & Wood 15%Chemical Manufacturing 12% Primary Metal Industries 8% Rubber & Plastic Products 8% Electric Services 8% Other 7% Fabricated Metal Products 7% Equipment Manufacturing 7% Furniture & Fixtures 4% Distribution of Dust Events by Industry Food 23% Wood 24%Metal 20% Plastic 14% Coal 8% Inorganic 4% Other 7% Distribution of Dust Events by Material Type Note: Coal mines & grain handling facilities excluded from study (Ref. U.S. Chemical Safety Board Report No. 2006-H-1)
  • 7. Dust Explosion by Equipment Type Equipment Type % of Incidents Dust Collector 52 Impact Equipment 17 Silos & Bins 13 Dryers & Ovens 9 Processing Equipment 6 Conveyor 3 Source: FM Global Property Loss Prevention Data Sheet 7-76, “Prevention and Mitigation of Combustible Dust Explosion and Fire”, May 2008
  • 8. NFPA Dust Standards • Keyway Documents Standard Industry Edition NFPA 652 All New NFPA 654 All – General Industry Document 2013 NFPA 61 Food/Agricultural 2013 NFPA 664 Wood 2012 NFPA 484 Metal 2012 NFPA 655 Sulfur 2012
  • 9. NFPA Dust Standards • How-to Documents Standard Purpose Edition NFPA 68 Explosion Venting 2013 NFPA 69 Suppression/Isolation/Containment/Inerting 2014 NFPA 77 Static Hazards 2014 NFPA 70 National Electric Code 2014 NFPA 499 Practical Electric Classification 2013
  • 10. April 2014 • Corrigan TX • Four people remain hospitalized, three in critical condition, after an explosion and fire at a Polk County plywood mill • a) dust collector bags impeded the venting area of the dust collector deflagration vents. • b) explosion vents releasing in the dust collector without taking measure to protect employees from the fireball path • c) dust collector vented and the deflagration traveled upstream to the sander. • d) responding to a fire within the sander dust collection system without the main blower remaining in operation. • e) responding to a fire within the sander dust collection system without a choke between the sander dust collector and silo leading to the briquetter.
  • 11. Chemical Safety Board • From 2008 to 2012, The CSB board documented, 50 combustible dust accidents that led to 29 fatalities and 161 injuries.
  • 12. Objectives) • Identify the NFPA 654/664 Standards applicable to your dust issues. • Identify three OSHA Standards cited in COMDUST NEP • Identify three questions that a plant would be asked in an OSHA COMDUST NEP inspection.
  • 13. OSHA • OSHA has regularly stated that NFPA standards that have not been specifically incorporated into OSHA standards or adopted by state or local jurisdictions should be considered by companies as guidance. • At the same time, however, the NEP Compliance Directive instructs OSHA inspectors to consult the NFPA standards to “obtain evidence of hazard recognition and feasible abatement methods” to support a citation under the GDC. • Consequently, companies should consult NFPAs when evaluating and mitigating potential combustible dust hazards at their facilities.
  • 14. The Long and Winding Road • History of Hazards • OSHA Inspections • Issues • Citations • Trends
  • 15. Trend 1 – Rare Events but Still Occurring • Two British Columbia sawmills - 2012 • Four dead and 52 injured • Fines of up to $652,000 • These were wood dust explosions
  • 16. Trend 2 – OSHA NEP continues • Combustible Dust National Emphasis Program (NEP) – revised March 2008 • CSB issues recommendations in 2005 • Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPRM) – published October 2009 • Expert panel met May 2011
  • 17. Possible Ignition Sources • Possible ignition sources include: – Open flames and sparks (welding, industrial grinding and cutting, matches, etc.) – Hot Surfaces (dryers, bearings, heaters, etc.) – Heat from Mechanical Impacts – Electrical Discharges (switch and outlet activation) – Electrostatic Discharges (static electricity) – Smoldering or burning dust – Smoking materials (cigarettes, lighters, cigars, etc.)
  • 18. OSHA Inspections • Over 1000 COMDUST NEP inspections since 2008 • High Violations per inspections (Over 6.0/inspection) Triggers are: • Complaint or referral • Media reports of fires and explosions • Inspection Targeting List ~150-300 inspections in 2014
  • 19. Sample Accident Jan 2009 • The laminate panels pass on a conveyor underneath a curing UV light. • A panel jammed up underneath the UV light. • The panel heated up to the point where it charred, smoldered and eventually caught fire. • The charred pieces were sucked up into the local exhaust system, where they ignited the dust collector located outside the plant. • The dust collector blew up, sending a shock wave back into/through the plant. Several overhead doors were blown off, and one of these struck 4 employees, injuring them.
  • 20. COMDUST NEP • Plant history of fires • Employer’s Dust Management System • MSDS’s • Dust Accumulation • Dust Collectors • Ventilation Specifications • One liter of dust sampled • Photos • Interviews – Employees, Employers
  • 21. Sample OSHA Questions • What is the Plant’s Housekeeping program? • Is there dust accumulation of 1/32 inch thick? • Dust collectors located inside of buildings? • Explosion relief venting distributed over the exterior walls of buildings and enclosures?
  • 22. NFPA 654 Layer Depth Criterion Method 6.1.3 Hazard is present if dust 1/32 inches thick covers • 5% of room or building area up to 20,000 ft2 • Up to 1000 ft2 in a building 20,000 ft2 or larger 100 feet 200 feet 20,000 sq. ft. Building 5% or 1000 sq. ft. 40 feet 50 ft 1000 sq. ft. Building or Room 5% or 50 sq. ft. 200 feet 200 feet 40,000 sq. ft. Building 1000 sq. ft. 22
  • 23. How much dust is too much? Fugitive dust outside equipment – Permitted thickness NFPA 654 Particulate Solids 1/32 inch at 75 lbs/ft3 , adjusted for other bulk densities NFPA 664 Wood 1/8 inch assumes 20 lbs/ft3 bulk density NFPA 484 Metals No accumulation – clean daily NFPA 61 Food + Agriculture Remove along with operations – references NFPA 654 OSHA Grain Grain Handling 1/8 inch – program and priority areas listed OSHA NEP General Industry 1/32 inch – Refers to NFPA 654 and FM Data Sheet 7-76 Adapted from: Application of NFPA 654 . . . Samuel A. Rogers, Process Safety, 3 - 2012 23
  • 24. Sample OSHA Questions • Does the facility have isolation devices to prevent deflagration propagation between pieces of equipment connected by ductwork? • Does the facility have an ignition control program, such as grounding and bonding? Fire through a duct is bad
  • 25. Sample OSHA Questions • Are Vacuum cleaners used in dusty areas and approved for the hazard classification? • Are separator devices to remove foreign materials used? • Can tramp metal ignite combustible dusts in the dust collection systems? Check the label for Class II
  • 26. Sample OSHA Questions • Is the exhaust from the dust collectors recycled? • Does the dust collector system have spark detection and explosion/deflagration suppression systems?
  • 27. Sample OSHA Questions • Are ducts designed to maintain sufficient velocity to ensure the transport of both coarse and fine particles? • What is the design basis for the ventilation? • Are duct systems, dust collectors, and dust-producing machinery bonded and grounded to minimize accumulation of static electrical charge?
  • 28. Sample OSHA Questions • Is metal ductwork used? • Are bulk storage containers constructed of noncombustible materials? • Are employees trained in the hazards of the combustible dust? • Are MSDSs for the chemicals which could become combustible dust under normal operations available to employees?
  • 29. NEP Citations • 1910.22, Housekeeping • 1910.38, Emergency action plans • 1910.94, Ventilation • 1910.132, PPE Hazard Analysis • 1910.146, Permit-required confined spaces • 1910.307, Hazardous (classified) locations • 1910.1000 Z table, Toxic and hazardous substances • 1910.1200, Hazard communication • General duty clause 5/16/2002 Vicksburg, MS 5 fatalities, 7 injured 23 serious, 2 unclassified $210,000 Fire in the baghouse, then rubber dust explosion No explosion venting or suppression in baghouse Poor housekeeping 88 fire reports in 13 years
  • 30. Trend 3 – OSHA will continue to use the General Clause Violation • Dust collectors (Air Material Separator) inside • No proper explosion protection systems such as explosion venting or explosion suppression systems NFPA 654 – 2013 7.13.1.1.1 Where an explosion hazard exists, air-material separators with a dirty-side volume of 8 ft3 (0.2 m3) or greater shall be located outside of buildings. There are exceptions.
  • 31. Typical 5(a)(1) Violations • Systems were not provided to prevent deflagration propagation from dust collectors to other parts of the plant. October 29, 2003 - Hayes Lemmerz Manufacturing Plant, IN Shawn Boone, 33, died in the Aluminum Dust explosion
  • 32. Typical 5(a)(1) Violations • No explosion relief venting distributed over the exterior walls and roofs of the buildings. CTA Acoustics 2003 – 7 dead Fiberglass fibers and excess phenolic resin powder probably went to the oven while workers were using compressed air and lance to break up a cogged bag house filter
  • 33. Typical 5(a)(1) Violations • Dust Collector and ducts do not prevent propagation to other parts of the plant From BS&B
  • 34. Typical 5(a)(1) Violations • Ducts and system were not grounded
  • 35. Typical 5(a)(1) Violations • Airborne fugitive dust
  • 36. Typical 5(a)(1) Violations • A means of tramp metal protection was not provided to keep any unwanted metal fragments out of the air-material separators From Duramag
  • 37. Typical 5(a)(1) Violations • Excessive dust • Not cleaning per the appropriate NFPA Standard
  • 38. Typical 5(a)(1) Violations • Compressed Air was used for cleaning • Tip: Clean fugitive dust • Regular program • Access to hidden areas • Safe cleaning methods • Maintain dust free as possible • No blow down unless All electrical power and processes have been shutdown and other means cannot work. • See NFPA
  • 39. Typical 5(a)(1) Violations • No PVC or nonconductive ducts
  • 40. Typical 5(a)(1) Violations • Not maintaining duct velocity • While conditions can vary, 4000 ft/min is generally accepted as a minimum conveying velocity for wood particulate. • Sec 8.2.2.1.5
  • 41. Strategy for Employers • Test for Combustible Dust • Find Applicable NFPA standards • Implement a Safety Management System • Housekeeping • Electrical Classification • Conduct Process Hazard Analysis for Dust Generation Processes • Control Ignition sources • Develop safety procedures for working on dust collectors • Investigate leaks, hot spots, near misses • Train Employees in hazards of combustible dust • Plan for fires and emergencies
  • 42. Hazard Assessment & Mitigation • Below Illustrations: Examples of Woodworking Shop area that is kept clean, uses engineering controls (dust collection systems), and is kept free of dust accumulation.
  • 43. Hazard Assessment & Mitigation • Below Illustration: An example of another Woodworking Shop area that is kept clean and free of dust accumulation.
  • 44. Hazard Assessment & Mitigation • Below Illustration: An example of an overhead exhaust ducting at Woodworking Shop area that is kept clean and free of dust accumulation.
  • 45. Where are Dust Sources? • Bag Openers (Slitters) • Blenders/Mixers • Dryers • Dust Collectors • Pneumatic Conveyors • Size Reduction Equipment (Grinders) • Silos and Hoppers • Hoses, Loading Spouts, Flexible Boots
  • 46. Ignition Source Control Electrical equipment Hot Works Static electricity control Mechanical sparks & friction Open flame control Design of heating systems & heated surfaces Use of tools, & vehicles Maintenance
  • 47. Mitigation - Venting Venting: • Rupture panels to relieve pressure preventing a vessel failure • Amount of vent area needed is determined using NFPA 68 equations • Explosion vent need to exhaust into a safe area or a quenching device
  • 48. Mitigation – Suppression Suppression: • Detect a deflagration at early stage and quench the event with chemical suppressant • Cannon/bottle consist of pressurized gas and suppressant chemical • System triggers by pressure or optical sensor • Higher maintenance requirements
  • 49. Mitigation – Suppression Factors that Impact Suppression • Vessel Volume • Vessel Strength – Reduced Pressure (Pred) • Vessel Geometry – (L/D Ratio) – Filter Bag/Cartridges Factors that Impact Suppression • Initial Pressure (+/-) • Material (Kst) • Activation Pressure (Pstat)
  • 51. Isolation Isolation: • Must be used to prevent propagation of an event in one vessel to interconnected equipment • Usually always needed in conjunction with venting or suppression
  • 52. Hierarchy of Equipment Use 6.) Containment 7.) Inerting 1.) Free venting a vessel outdoors 2.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior wall using a duct 3.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior roof using a duct 4.) Flameless venting 5.) Active Suppression Prevention
  • 53. Maintenance – It is also important to ensure that all dust-collection systems are operating properly and collected dust is recycled and/or disposed according to the manufacture specifications for the equipment.
  • 54. Maintenance Check dust collection systems to make sure all leaks are sealed and dust is not accumulating in the ductwork. Check bonding and ground of all components in accordance with the manufacturer instructions.
  • 55. Hazard Assessment & Mitigation • Below Illustrations: An example of an industrial dust collection system connected to a woodworking shop exhaust ventilation system to capture generated dust.
  • 56. NFPA 654 - 2013 • Chapters 1 – 3 Administrative • Chapter 4 General Requirements • Chapter 5 Performance- based Design Option • Chapter 6 Facility and Systems Design • Chapter 7 Process Equipment • Chapter 8 Fugitive Dust Control and Housekeeping • Chapter 9 Ignition Sources • Chapter 10 Fire Protection • Chapter 11 Training and Procedures • Chapter 12 Inspection and Maintenance
  • 57. Seven Key NFPA 654 Changes • 4.2 Process Hazard Analysis (PHA) • TREND 5 – PHA are conducted in less than 10% of companies, but increasing rapidly • OSHA VPP facilities have conducted numerous PHAs • 4.2.1* The design of the fire and explosion safety provisions shall be based on a process hazard analysis of the facility, the process, and the associated fire or explosion hazards.
  • 58. NFPA 654 PHA • Examine the facility, process, and fire and explosion hazards • Actual test data required to support analysis • Which materials are combustible? • If not known, but suspected, then data are needed • Closed or open processes? • Rate of generation or release of solids to an environment? • Any collection methods in place? • Conclusion: processes generates or handles solids and dusts are formed in process, potential exists
  • 59. Seven Key NFPA 654 Changes • 4.3 Management of Change. Written procedures to manage change to process materials, technology, equipment, procedures, and facilities shall be established and implemented.
  • 60. Seven Key NFPA 654 Changes • 4.4.1* Incidents that result in a fire or explosion of a magnitude that causes property damage, production shutdown time, or injury shall be investigated. • 4.4.3* A written report … • 4.4.4* A summary of the incident investigation report shall be shared with affected personnel…
  • 61. Seven Key NFPA 654 Changes • 6.1.1.1 Those portions of the process and facility interior where dust accumulations exist external to equipment in sufficient depth to prevent discerning the underlying surface color shall be evaluated to determine if a dust explosion hazard or flash fire hazard exists.
  • 62. Seven Key NFPA 654 Changes • 6.1.1.3* Dust flash fire or dust explosion hazard areas shall additionally be determined in accordance with any one of the following four methods:  Layer depth criterion method in 6.1.3  Mass method A in 6.1.4  Mass method B in 6.1.5  Risk evaluation method in 6.1.6 The NFPA 2 day course on combustible dust covers these assessment.
  • 63. Seven Key NFPA 654 Changes • 6.2 Segregation, Separation, or Detachment of Combustible Dust Handling and Processing Areas. • 6.2.1 General. Areas in which combustible dusts are produced, processed, handled, or collected such that combustible dust accumulation on exposed or concealed surfaces, external to equipment or containers, exceeds the threshold as determined in Section 6.1, shall be detached, segregated, or separated from other occupancies to minimize damage from a fire or explosion.
  • 64. Seven Key NFPA 654 Changes • 7.3.2* Pneumatic Conveying, Dust Collection, and Centralized Vacuum Cleaning Systems. • 7.3.2.1 The design of the system shall be documented, and the documentation shall include the following information:  Data on the range of particulate size  Concentration of combustible dust in the conveyance air stream  Potential for reaction between the transported particulates and the extinguishing media used to protect process equipment  Conductivity of the particulates  Other physical and chemical properties that could affect the fire protection of the process
  • 65. Mitigation Ignition source control • Electrical equipment • Class II, Division 1 and 2 • Consider equipment both inside dust handling equipment and outside • Static electricity control • Grounding and bonding are key • Inspection of ground and bonding means • Vibrating equipment (e.g., sifters) may cause fatigue failure in straps • Mechanical sparks & friction • Rotating equipment bearing failure can lead to very hot surfaces (above the MIT) • Sliding surfaces can develop charges • Steel tools dropping onto concrete or steel • Mechanical integrity management system/vibration analysis system • Hot work program • Open flames • Design of heating systems & heated surfaces • Use of tools & vehicles • Maintenance • Comfort heating equipment shall obtain combustion air from clean outside source
  • 66. Damage Control • Detachment (outside or other bldg.) • Separation (distance within same room) • Segregation (barrier) • Pressure resistant construction • Pressure relieving construction • Pressure Venting • Relief valves • Maintenance • Specialized detection systems • Specialized suppression systems • Explosion prevention systems • Maintenance
  • 69. Hierarchy of Equipment Use 6.) Containment 7.) Inerting 1.) Free venting a vessel outdoors 2.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior wall using a duct 3.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior roof using a duct 4.) Flameless venting 5.) Active Suppression Prevention
  • 72. Hierarchy of Equipment Use 6.) Containment 7.) Inerting 1.) Free venting a vessel outdoors 2.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior wall using a duct 3.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior roof using a duct 4.) Flameless venting 5.) Active Suppression Prevention
  • 75. Hierarchy of Equipment Use 6.) Containment 7.) Inerting 1.) Free venting a vessel outdoors 2.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior wall using a duct 3.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior roof using a duct 4.) Flameless venting 5.) Active Suppression Prevention
  • 78. Dust Collectors Milton Hershey School Location: Hershey, PA Application: Woodworking Model: CYLK4440 Air Flow: 8,500 CFM
  • 79. Dust Collectors Lincoln Middle School Location: Passaic, NJ Application: Woodworking Model: DKLD48015 Air Flow: 4,800 CFM
  • 80. Dust Collectors William Patterson University Location: Wayne, NJ Application: Woodworking Model: DKPD72015 Air Flow: 5,700 CFM
  • 81. Dust Collectors Gloucester HS Location: Gloucester, MA Application: Woodworking Model: CYLK4450 Air Flow: 10,000 CFM
  • 82. Dust Collectors New Oxford Middle School Location: New Oxford, PA Application: Woodworking Model: DKLD48015 Air Flow: 8,500 CFM
  • 83. Hierarchy of Equipment Use 6.) Containment 7.) Inerting 1.) Free venting a vessel outdoors 2.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior wall using a duct 3.) Free venting a vessel indoors next to an exterior roof using a duct 4.) Flameless venting 5.) Active Suppression Prevention
  • 84. Multiple tasks involving exposures may involve use of FR as normal work wear. NFPA 2113 (2012) Recommends FR use for combustible dust A.5.2 • Work where dust is present on equipment or structure • Changing dust collector bags For example, FR garments should be required for the following: Per OSHA NEP 84
  • 85. Dust depth Frequency Hsk’pg Req. Classification Negligible dust (color discernable) N/A N/A Unclassified – general purpose Negligible dust to < 1/32 inch (paper clip) Infrequent – Episodic release, not > 2-3 times yearly Clean up during same shift Unclassified – general purpose Negligible dust to < 1/32 inch Continuous to frequent – Continuous with < 1/32 inch per 24 hours or Episodic release, > 3 times yearly Clean as needed – maintain average < 1/64 inch (puffy little cloud with each step) Unclassified – NEMA 12 dust entry resisting enclosures and /sealed non- heat producing equip. (For existing plants – New to be Class II, Div. 2)Groups F and G Dusts 85
  • 86. 1/32 to 1/8 inch (Two Quarters stacked) Infrequent Clean up during same shift Unclassified – NEMA 12 dust entry resisting enclosures and /sealed non- heat producing equip. (For existing plants – New to be Class II, Div. 2) 1/32 to 1/8 inch Continuous to frequent Clean as needed – maintain average < 1/16 inch Class II, Division 2 >1/8 inch Infrequent Immediately shut down and clean Class II, Division 2 > 1/8 inch Continuous to frequent Clean frequently – minimize accumulation Class II, Division 1 Groups F and G Dusts 86
  • 87. NFPA 654 – Housekeeping 8.1,2 Fugitive dust control is to be provided by continuous suction wherever dust is liberated in normal operations The dust is to be conveyed to air- material separators Cleaning frequency, methods and portable vacuum cleaner requirements are RETROACTIVE for all facilities Continuous Suction ? 87
  • 88.
  • 89. Cleaning Frequency 8.2.1 At facilities operated with LESS than the chosen threshold dust mass/accumulation per 6.1, cleaning frequency must ensure: • Accumulated dust levels do not exceed the chosen amount of dust • There is a planned inspection process that maintains cleaning at the correct rate 89
  • 90. Cleaning Frequency 8.2 For facilities operated with LESS than the chosen threshold dust mass/accumulation • Set specific time requirements for cleaning local and short term spills • The intent is to remove the excess materials quickly so that such spills do not need to be included in the mass calculations of 6.1 90
  • 91. Timing of Unscheduled Cleaning Longest Time to Complete Unscheduled Local Cleaning Accumulation on the worst single square meter of surface Accessible Surface Remote Surface 1 to 2 times threshold dust mass/accumulation limit (TDM/AL) 8 Hours 24 Hours 2 to 4 times TDM/AL 4 Hours 12 Hours >4 times TDM/AL 1 Hour 3 Hours Adapted from NFPA 654 Table A.8.2.1.3(a) 91
  • 92. Cleaning Frequency 8.2.1 For facilities operated with MORE THAN the chosen criterion for threshold dust mass/ accumulation per 6.1: DUST • FR clothing and properly installed explosion venting would be included • Chapter 4 identifies some general safety requirements 92 • Additional protective measures are necessary per A.8.2.1.4. • It is permitted to prepare a documented risk assessment to determine the level of housekeeping consistent with protection requirements
  • 93. Cleaning Methods 8.2.2 Surfaces shall be cleaned in a manner that minimizes the risk of generating a fire or explosion hazard. Vacuuming shall be the preferred method of cleaning. Where vacuuming is impractical, permitted cleaning methods shall include sweeping and water wash-down. 93
  • 94. Cleaning Methods 8.2.2 Blow-downs are permitted for cleaning inaccessible surfaces or surfaces where personal safety risk is less than other methods. Use the following precautions: Vacuuming, sweeping, or water wash-down methods are to be used first Dust accumulations in the area after vacuuming, sweeping or water wash-down are not to exceed the threshold dust accumulation. 94
  • 95. Cleaning Methods 8.2.2 NEMA 12 (resists ingress dust of particles) • All ignition sources and hot surfaces capable of igniting a dust cloud or dust layer must be shut down or removed from the area Additional requirements for dust blow-down • Compressed air hose nozzles must be limited to 30 psi discharge pressure as per OSHA • All electrical equipment potentially exposed to airborne dust in the area is to meet 95
  • 96. Housekeeping Procedures 8.2.2.5 Housekeeping program is BIG Must be documented (and addressed) in the dust process hazard analysis and management of change procedures Housekeeping procedures should include: • Risk analysis of the dust • Particle size • Moisture content • MEC and MIE • Other safety risks introduced by cleaning methods • Personal safety procedures and fall protection • Flame-resistant garments per NFPA 2113 96
  • 97. Housekeeping Procedures 8.2.2.5 Procedures should also include: • Cleaning sequence and methods to be used • Equipment including: • lifts, • vacuum systems, • attachments, etc. Safety Note: Large and high velocity fans may be used to prevent dust accumulations. Use of such fans to blow down significant dust accumulations present the same risks as compressed air blow-downs. 97
  • 98. Portable Vacuum cleaners 8.2.3.1 • Hoses are to be conductive or static- dissipative – both suction and air delivery hoses • All conductive components including wands and attachments must be bonded and grounded • Dust-laden air must not pass through the fan or blower Conductive or Static- dissipative Hose They are to meet the following: • Generally non-combustible construction and meet requirements for construction and static electrical hazard controls per 9.3.2 and 7.13.2 98
  • 99. Portable Vacuum cleaners 8.2.3.1 Additional requirements • Electrical motors must not be in the dust laden air stream unless listed for Class II, Division 1 locations • No paper filter elements for liquid or wet pick-up • Metal dust vacuums are to be listed for Class II, Division 1, Group E and meet other NFPA 484 requirements for specific metal used 99
  • 100. Vacuum Cleaners for Use in Hazardous Locations 8.2.3.2 And .3 • Use vacuums listed for the location or • Provide a fixed-pipe suction system with appropriate remotely located exhauster and dust collector. • Where flammable vapors are present, units are to be listed for both Class I and Class II locations HAZ LOC 100
  • 101. Spills of Large quantities of dust A.8.2.3.1 In UNCLASSIFIED areas • Bulk material should be collected by sweeping, or shoveling • Listed Class II vacuums may also be used • Vacuum cleaners per 8.3.2.1 (e.g.: compliant air driven units) may be used afterwards for residue Vacuum Truck See also OSHA Fact Sheet DSG FS-3589 10 2012 Vacuum trucks are similar to vacuum cleaners. They require analysis with management of change (MOC) to remove large quantity spills or releases of dust per 4.3 101
  • 102. Concluding Remarks • No two dust explosions are the same. – No uniform dust laws like there are for gases • Standards are evolving • The dust explosion hazard exists – Be aware of the “I’ve never had a dust explosion before”
  • 104. Safety and Health Information Bulletin Purpose Background Elements of a Dust Explosion Facility Dust Hazard Assessment Dust Control Ignition Control Damage Control Training References
  • 105. Resources and Questions? • NFPA 2-day Combustible Dust Seminar • Combustible Dust Guidebook - NFPA • OSHA SHIB • www.csb.gov • LinkedIn Combustible Dust Forums • Facebook Grain Mill Accident page