Sister Mary Joseph's nodule is a cutaneous metastasis of intra-abdominal cancers, most commonly from the stomach and ovaries. It presents as a painless nodule on the umbilicus. This case report describes a 74-year-old woman who presented with a fungating umbilical mass after being treated for suspected cellulitis. Imaging and biopsy revealed metastatic adenocarcinoma to the umbilicus from a primary gastric cancer. She was also found to have cystic ovarian carcinoma. Physicians must consider gastrointestinal tumors when non-healing abdominal lesions are not responding to antibiotics.