Large-scale Net House for Vegetable Production: Pest Management Successes & ChallengesAyanava MajumdarExtension Entomologist  (Peanuts, Vegetables)State SARE Coordinator (Auburn U)Alabama Cooperative Extension System&Mike PowellAmerican Farm Systems (PolyProductos de Guatemala)
Vegetable Production in Alabama50 vegetables produced2006: 5700 acres  >> 2008: 5,950 acres100% fresh market produceValue: ~$17 millionTomato: ~1300 acres = $12 million6 organic producers
Need for net house researchInsect pest pressures in southeast U.S. are very high (struggle for organic producers)Vegetable production is insecticide dependentBlocking insects by physical exclusion reduces insecticide use (nothing new!)Net house is a closed crop production system that excludes insect pests via a physical barrier.Could be of interest to organic farmers…
Past research on insect nettingMartin et al. (2006): Africa, cabbage production, 25-mesh, reduction in caterpillars - Spodopteralittoralis66%, Trichoplusiani97%, Hellulaundalis88%, Plutellaxylostella (moths) 78%, no change in aphids (6% infestation), net return $247, 3-10x spray reductionFang-Cheng et al. (2010): China, tomato seedlings, 50-mesh, whitefly reduction 98%, 5x spray reduction, small structureHarmanto (2006), Mutwiwa & Tantau (2009): Germany, greenhouse + netting (50-mesh), 40% reduction in air velocity, thrips & whitefly reduction on tomatoesMovable net house (Africa)Low net house (Malaysia)
Past research on large net housesTalekar et al. (2003): Taiwan, 15 crop cycles of leafy greens, 2 m or 6.5 ft structure, 32-mesh netKaur et al. (2004): India, egg plant production, doubled plant yield in net house, mesh size??Anonymous (2010): Malaysia, okra & tomatoAnonymous (2008): Vietnam, cost $186Guatemala, Israel: commercial tomato & bell pepper in net housesLarge net house (India)Large net house (Vietnam)
Large net house vegetable production (Guatemala)Large commercial scale net housePhotos:Polyproductos de GuatemalaTop Greenhouses Ltd., Israel
Commercial net houses in the U.S.Top Greenhouse Ltd., Israel: flat net houses on 280,000 m2 (~70 acres) in CA; bell pepper, tomato, chili production.Commercial citrus production, FL
First net house in Alabama (2010)Location: Baldwin County, AL Dimensions: 150 ft x 46 ftEntrance: Double door50-mesh fabric (any between above 16- to 50-mesh is fine)Mesh size depends on target insect & costHeight provides air movement…fans can also be installedCrops, 2010: Celebrity tomatoes, California Wonder  peppers
The making of a net house… April 2010: Setting up the polesApril 2010: Sewing the long net pieces 17-ft14-ftApril 2010: Stretching the support cablesMay 2010: Fabric on cable with S-hooks
Soil preparation before sealing side-wallsMid-May, 201010 ft17 ft14 ft
Crops grown with partial success (Year 1)40% black shade cloth for cooling the interior!TomatoesBell peppers
Temperature and humidity challenge**Year 2010 was an unusually dry and hot year in Alabama: increased disease pressure and shocked the plantsAWIS = Alabama Weather Information System
Does net house block insect pests?Pheromone trap catches (moths)Trapping method: Sticky wing trap with replaceable bottom were used for season long monitoring of moths. Traps were serviced every 10 days.
Does net house block insect pests?Caterpillar counts: Net house vs. conventional vegetablesSampling method: Number of caterpillars in 10 plants every 10 ft of row. Plants sampled from 4 locations each row (4 replications). Sampling done in July 2010.
Insects in a net houseCotton aphid (Aphis gossypii) and potato aphid (Macrosiphumeuphorbiae) outbreaks in July.
Managed with one spray of Fulfill 50WDG (selective feeding blocker)
Armyworm moths lay eggs on fabric near joints

Net house vegetable production (2011)

  • 1.
    Large-scale Net Housefor Vegetable Production: Pest Management Successes & ChallengesAyanava MajumdarExtension Entomologist (Peanuts, Vegetables)State SARE Coordinator (Auburn U)Alabama Cooperative Extension System&Mike PowellAmerican Farm Systems (PolyProductos de Guatemala)
  • 2.
    Vegetable Production inAlabama50 vegetables produced2006: 5700 acres >> 2008: 5,950 acres100% fresh market produceValue: ~$17 millionTomato: ~1300 acres = $12 million6 organic producers
  • 3.
    Need for nethouse researchInsect pest pressures in southeast U.S. are very high (struggle for organic producers)Vegetable production is insecticide dependentBlocking insects by physical exclusion reduces insecticide use (nothing new!)Net house is a closed crop production system that excludes insect pests via a physical barrier.Could be of interest to organic farmers…
  • 4.
    Past research oninsect nettingMartin et al. (2006): Africa, cabbage production, 25-mesh, reduction in caterpillars - Spodopteralittoralis66%, Trichoplusiani97%, Hellulaundalis88%, Plutellaxylostella (moths) 78%, no change in aphids (6% infestation), net return $247, 3-10x spray reductionFang-Cheng et al. (2010): China, tomato seedlings, 50-mesh, whitefly reduction 98%, 5x spray reduction, small structureHarmanto (2006), Mutwiwa & Tantau (2009): Germany, greenhouse + netting (50-mesh), 40% reduction in air velocity, thrips & whitefly reduction on tomatoesMovable net house (Africa)Low net house (Malaysia)
  • 5.
    Past research onlarge net housesTalekar et al. (2003): Taiwan, 15 crop cycles of leafy greens, 2 m or 6.5 ft structure, 32-mesh netKaur et al. (2004): India, egg plant production, doubled plant yield in net house, mesh size??Anonymous (2010): Malaysia, okra & tomatoAnonymous (2008): Vietnam, cost $186Guatemala, Israel: commercial tomato & bell pepper in net housesLarge net house (India)Large net house (Vietnam)
  • 6.
    Large net housevegetable production (Guatemala)Large commercial scale net housePhotos:Polyproductos de GuatemalaTop Greenhouses Ltd., Israel
  • 7.
    Commercial net housesin the U.S.Top Greenhouse Ltd., Israel: flat net houses on 280,000 m2 (~70 acres) in CA; bell pepper, tomato, chili production.Commercial citrus production, FL
  • 8.
    First net housein Alabama (2010)Location: Baldwin County, AL Dimensions: 150 ft x 46 ftEntrance: Double door50-mesh fabric (any between above 16- to 50-mesh is fine)Mesh size depends on target insect & costHeight provides air movement…fans can also be installedCrops, 2010: Celebrity tomatoes, California Wonder peppers
  • 9.
    The making ofa net house… April 2010: Setting up the polesApril 2010: Sewing the long net pieces 17-ft14-ftApril 2010: Stretching the support cablesMay 2010: Fabric on cable with S-hooks
  • 10.
    Soil preparation beforesealing side-wallsMid-May, 201010 ft17 ft14 ft
  • 11.
    Crops grown withpartial success (Year 1)40% black shade cloth for cooling the interior!TomatoesBell peppers
  • 12.
    Temperature and humiditychallenge**Year 2010 was an unusually dry and hot year in Alabama: increased disease pressure and shocked the plantsAWIS = Alabama Weather Information System
  • 13.
    Does net houseblock insect pests?Pheromone trap catches (moths)Trapping method: Sticky wing trap with replaceable bottom were used for season long monitoring of moths. Traps were serviced every 10 days.
  • 14.
    Does net houseblock insect pests?Caterpillar counts: Net house vs. conventional vegetablesSampling method: Number of caterpillars in 10 plants every 10 ft of row. Plants sampled from 4 locations each row (4 replications). Sampling done in July 2010.
  • 15.
    Insects in anet houseCotton aphid (Aphis gossypii) and potato aphid (Macrosiphumeuphorbiae) outbreaks in July.
  • 16.
    Managed with onespray of Fulfill 50WDG (selective feeding blocker)
  • 17.
    Armyworm moths layeggs on fabric near joints

Editor's Notes

  • #5 Spodopteralittoralis = cotton leafworm; Trichoplusiani = cabbage looper; Hellulaundalis = cabbage webworm; Plutellaxylostella = diamondback moth
  • #16 Green peach aphid: