Product Management 101:
The Search for Product-Market Fit
             Jeff Bussgang
     General Partner, Flybridge Capital
  Senior Lecturer, Harvard Business School
             December 10, 2012



                                   CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE1
Session Objectives

• What is great product management?
• What people mean when they use the phrase,
  “Product Market Fit” (PMF), plus:
  – Customer Development Process
  – Lean Start-Up Theory
• Help you devise your approach to achieving PMF
  and avoid wasting a lot of money


                                   CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE2
Agenda
•   Introduce Concepts – 30 minutes
•   Exercise – 30 minutes
•   Debrief – 15 minutes
•   Q&A and Wrap – 15 minutes




                                      CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE3
Context for My Perspective

• General Partner at Flybridge Capital, early-stage VC firm in
  Boston/NY, $560M under management
  60+ portfolio companies

• Senior Lecturer at Harvard Business School
• Former entrepreneur
  Cofounder/Pres. Upromise (acq’d by SallieMae)
  VP at Open Market (IPO ‘96)

• Author: Mastering the VC Game


                                                   CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE4
Leading Thinkers/Books/Blogs

• Geoffrey Moore: Crossing the Chasm (read this!)
• Steve Blank: Customer Development Process (read Four
  Steps to the Epiphany)
• Eric Ries: Lean Startups (read this too!)
• Marty Cagan: Silicon Valley Product Group (great book
  and blog)
• HBS Prof Tom Eisenmann: Launching Tech Ventures
  (great blog)
• Sean Ellis: Startup Marketing (great blog)
• Andrew Chen: Growth Hackers (great blog)

                                           CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE5
Startup
 1. A team launching a new product under
    conditions of extreme uncertainty
 2. A vehicle for testing hypotheses about
    such an entity


Entrepreneurship: the pursuit of opportunity beyond
resources you currently control
                    - HBS Professor Howard Stevenson

                                                                 6
                                      CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE6
Old School Product Management

•   Report to: Marketing
•   Output: Requirements Documents
•   Methodology: Waterfall
•   Product lifecycles: Years
•   Decision-Making: Opinion-Driven




                                  CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE7
Modern Product Management

•   Report to: CEO
•   Output: Prototypes
•   Methodology: Agile
•   Product lifecycles: Weeks
•   Decision-Making: Data-Driven




                                   CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE8
Customer Development
                          vs. Product Development

                           Product Development
              Concept/      Product     Alpha/Beta             Launch/
              Bus. Plan      Dev.          Test                1st Ship




                          Customer Development

             Customer      Customer     Customer               Company
             Discovery     Validation   Creation               Building




Source: Steve Blank
                                                     CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE9
Product Management Skills
• Responsibilities:
   – Define the new product to be built
   – Secure the resources to build it
   – Manage its development, launch and
     ongoing improvement
   – Lead the cross-functional product team
• Attributes:
   –   Ability to influence and lead
   –   Resilience and tolerance for amibiguity
   –   Business judgment and market knowledge
   –   Strong process skills and detail orientation
   –   Fluency with technology and implications on product design, business
   –   Design/UX instincts
              Mini CEO – with none of the authority
                                                        CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE10
The Lean Startup
• Many startups fail because they waste capital and
  time developing and marketing a product that no
  one wants
• Lean startups rapidly and iteratively test hypotheses
  about a new venture based on customer feedback,
  then quickly refine promising concepts and cull flops
• Being lean does NOT mean being cheap, it is a
  methodology for optimizing—not minimizing—
  resources expenditures by avoiding waste
• Being lean does NOT mean avoiding rigorous,
  analytical or strategic thinking
                                                                    11
                                         CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE11
Lean Startup Principles
• No idea survives first customer contact, so get
  out of the building ASAP to test ideas
• Goal: validation of business model hypotheses,
  based on rigorous experiments and clear metrics
• Minimum viable product (MVP): smallest set of
  features/marketing initiatives that delivers the
  most validated learning
• Rapidly pivot your MVP/business model until you
  have validation and product-market fit (PMF)
• Don’t scale until you have achieved PMF
                                                                12
                                     CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE12
Crossing The Chasm




               CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE13
Where are You?
 Before Product-Market Fit:       After Product-Market Fit:
 Search & Validation              Scaling & Optimization
• Lean startup approach           • Building a robust, feature-rich
• Hunch-driven hypotheses           product
• Minimum viable product (MVP)    • Crossing the chasm
• Customer development process    • Metrics, analytics, funnels
• Selling to early adopters       • Designing for virality &
• Pivoting                          scalability
• Bootstrapping                   • Challenges with corporate
                                    partnerships
• Small, founding team
                                  • Building a brand
• Product-centric culture;
   informal roles                 • Scaling the team; more
                                    formal roles
• Early in sales learning curve
                                  • Scaling a sales force
                                                CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE14
Tools/Techniques
•   Structured idea generation   •   Conversion funnel analysis
•   Business model generation    •   Landing page optimization
•   Customer discovery process   •   SEM/SEO optimization
•   Focus groups                 •   Inbound marketing design
•   Customer survey              •   PR strategy
•   Persona development          •   Customer support analysis
•   Competitor benchmarking      •   Product feature prioritization
•   Wireframing                  •   Sales pitch
•   Prototype development        •   Lead qualification
•   Usability testing            •   Bus dev screening
•   Charter user program         •   Net Promoter Score
•   A/B test                     •   Lifetime value vs. Customer
                                     acquisition costs
                                                                             15
                                                  CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE15
“Lessons Learned” Drives Funding


                   Business       Test       Lessons
Concept           Plan/Canvas   Hypotheses                        Series A
                                             Learned




         Do this first instead of fund raising
  (or raise seed round to test hypotheses…rigorously)



Source: Steve Blank
                                                   CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE16
Exercise: Blackberry 10




                    1. Milk cash cow
Strategic Choices   2. Copy iPhone
                    3. Leapfrog
                            CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE17
Exercise Instructions
• Pick a product development methodology
   – Agile vs. Waterfall
• Pick the product manager’s role
   – Czar
   – Democratic leader
   – Oligarchy / committee
• Allocate 100 points across key product features
   –   Apps
   –   Screen / keyboard
   –   Form factor (small, light)
   –   Browser / reading
• Design a falsifiable test to help you with your scoring
                                                 CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE18
A Few Resources
• My blog: www.SeeingBothSides.com
• Quora on product management:
   • http://b.qr.ae/W1npOi (product mgt skills)
   • http://b.qr.ae/sYy4jS (Google product mgt)
• HBS Case Note on Product Mgt - http://bit.ly/TQhw7w




                                              CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE19
Product Management 101:
The Search for Product-Market Fit
          Jeff Bussgang
              @bussgang
          jeff@flybridge.com


          December 10, 2012


                               CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE20

Intelligently class 12 2012

  • 1.
    Product Management 101: TheSearch for Product-Market Fit Jeff Bussgang General Partner, Flybridge Capital Senior Lecturer, Harvard Business School December 10, 2012 CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE1
  • 2.
    Session Objectives • Whatis great product management? • What people mean when they use the phrase, “Product Market Fit” (PMF), plus: – Customer Development Process – Lean Start-Up Theory • Help you devise your approach to achieving PMF and avoid wasting a lot of money CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE2
  • 3.
    Agenda • Introduce Concepts – 30 minutes • Exercise – 30 minutes • Debrief – 15 minutes • Q&A and Wrap – 15 minutes CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE3
  • 4.
    Context for MyPerspective • General Partner at Flybridge Capital, early-stage VC firm in Boston/NY, $560M under management 60+ portfolio companies • Senior Lecturer at Harvard Business School • Former entrepreneur Cofounder/Pres. Upromise (acq’d by SallieMae) VP at Open Market (IPO ‘96) • Author: Mastering the VC Game CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE4
  • 5.
    Leading Thinkers/Books/Blogs • GeoffreyMoore: Crossing the Chasm (read this!) • Steve Blank: Customer Development Process (read Four Steps to the Epiphany) • Eric Ries: Lean Startups (read this too!) • Marty Cagan: Silicon Valley Product Group (great book and blog) • HBS Prof Tom Eisenmann: Launching Tech Ventures (great blog) • Sean Ellis: Startup Marketing (great blog) • Andrew Chen: Growth Hackers (great blog) CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE5
  • 6.
    Startup 1. Ateam launching a new product under conditions of extreme uncertainty 2. A vehicle for testing hypotheses about such an entity Entrepreneurship: the pursuit of opportunity beyond resources you currently control - HBS Professor Howard Stevenson 6 CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE6
  • 7.
    Old School ProductManagement • Report to: Marketing • Output: Requirements Documents • Methodology: Waterfall • Product lifecycles: Years • Decision-Making: Opinion-Driven CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE7
  • 8.
    Modern Product Management • Report to: CEO • Output: Prototypes • Methodology: Agile • Product lifecycles: Weeks • Decision-Making: Data-Driven CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE8
  • 9.
    Customer Development vs. Product Development Product Development Concept/ Product Alpha/Beta Launch/ Bus. Plan Dev. Test 1st Ship Customer Development Customer Customer Customer Company Discovery Validation Creation Building Source: Steve Blank CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE9
  • 10.
    Product Management Skills •Responsibilities: – Define the new product to be built – Secure the resources to build it – Manage its development, launch and ongoing improvement – Lead the cross-functional product team • Attributes: – Ability to influence and lead – Resilience and tolerance for amibiguity – Business judgment and market knowledge – Strong process skills and detail orientation – Fluency with technology and implications on product design, business – Design/UX instincts Mini CEO – with none of the authority CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE10
  • 11.
    The Lean Startup •Many startups fail because they waste capital and time developing and marketing a product that no one wants • Lean startups rapidly and iteratively test hypotheses about a new venture based on customer feedback, then quickly refine promising concepts and cull flops • Being lean does NOT mean being cheap, it is a methodology for optimizing—not minimizing— resources expenditures by avoiding waste • Being lean does NOT mean avoiding rigorous, analytical or strategic thinking 11 CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE11
  • 12.
    Lean Startup Principles •No idea survives first customer contact, so get out of the building ASAP to test ideas • Goal: validation of business model hypotheses, based on rigorous experiments and clear metrics • Minimum viable product (MVP): smallest set of features/marketing initiatives that delivers the most validated learning • Rapidly pivot your MVP/business model until you have validation and product-market fit (PMF) • Don’t scale until you have achieved PMF 12 CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE12
  • 13.
    Crossing The Chasm CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE13
  • 14.
    Where are You? Before Product-Market Fit: After Product-Market Fit: Search & Validation Scaling & Optimization • Lean startup approach • Building a robust, feature-rich • Hunch-driven hypotheses product • Minimum viable product (MVP) • Crossing the chasm • Customer development process • Metrics, analytics, funnels • Selling to early adopters • Designing for virality & • Pivoting scalability • Bootstrapping • Challenges with corporate partnerships • Small, founding team • Building a brand • Product-centric culture; informal roles • Scaling the team; more formal roles • Early in sales learning curve • Scaling a sales force CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE14
  • 15.
    Tools/Techniques • Structured idea generation • Conversion funnel analysis • Business model generation • Landing page optimization • Customer discovery process • SEM/SEO optimization • Focus groups • Inbound marketing design • Customer survey • PR strategy • Persona development • Customer support analysis • Competitor benchmarking • Product feature prioritization • Wireframing • Sales pitch • Prototype development • Lead qualification • Usability testing • Bus dev screening • Charter user program • Net Promoter Score • A/B test • Lifetime value vs. Customer acquisition costs 15 CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE15
  • 16.
    “Lessons Learned” DrivesFunding Business Test Lessons Concept Plan/Canvas Hypotheses Series A Learned Do this first instead of fund raising (or raise seed round to test hypotheses…rigorously) Source: Steve Blank CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE16
  • 17.
    Exercise: Blackberry 10 1. Milk cash cow Strategic Choices 2. Copy iPhone 3. Leapfrog CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE17
  • 18.
    Exercise Instructions • Picka product development methodology – Agile vs. Waterfall • Pick the product manager’s role – Czar – Democratic leader – Oligarchy / committee • Allocate 100 points across key product features – Apps – Screen / keyboard – Form factor (small, light) – Browser / reading • Design a falsifiable test to help you with your scoring CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE18
  • 19.
    A Few Resources •My blog: www.SeeingBothSides.com • Quora on product management: • http://b.qr.ae/W1npOi (product mgt skills) • http://b.qr.ae/sYy4jS (Google product mgt) • HBS Case Note on Product Mgt - http://bit.ly/TQhw7w CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE19
  • 20.
    Product Management 101: TheSearch for Product-Market Fit Jeff Bussgang @bussgang jeff@flybridge.com December 10, 2012 CONFIDENTIAL PRESENTATION | PAGE20

Editor's Notes

  • #16 In rough terms, tools in the left column are used pre-PMF, and those in the right post-PMF. A/B tests are used in both phases.