Int. Journal of Electrical & Electronics Engg. Vol. 2, Spl. Issue 1 (2015) e-ISSN: 1694-2310 | p-ISSN: 1694-2426
109 NITTTR, Chandigarh EDIT-2015
Design of Low Power, High PSRR Error
Amplifier for Low Drop-Out CMOS
Voltage Regulator
Dipendra Singh Patel1
, Pramod Kumar Jain2
, D.S. Ajnar3
Microelectronics & VLSI Design, Electronics & Instrumentation Dept., S.G.S.I.T.S. Indore, India
1
dspdipendra@gmail.com, 2
prjain@sgsits.ac.in, 3
ajnards@gmail.com
Abstract: This paper presents design of an improved Error
amplifier (EA) for Low Drop-Out Voltage Regulator. The
proposed circuit shows good behaviour as compared to the
previous Error Amplifier. The Gain, Unity Gain Bandwidth,
Phase Margin, CMRR and PSRR of an Error Amplifier is
analysed. The proposed circuit is designed on UMC 180nm
CMOS technology with supply voltage of 1.8Volts. All the
simulation results are calculated through SPECTRE
Simulator of cadence.
Keywords: Amplifier, Error amplifier, Regulators, Low Drop-
Out voltage regulators, System-on-chip (SOC), Analog
electronics.
I. INTRODUCTION
As the present market for portable electronic devices
continues to expand around the world to desire for long
battery life drives the search for efficient power
management circuit architecture. The research in analog-
circuit design is mainly focused in power management of
various products, especially those relying on battery
power.[1]-[4] Low drop-out voltage regulator is one of the
important building block in battery operated portable
electronic devices as well as industries and automation
application. Presently the demand of portable and battery
electronics product have forced this circuit to work under
lower voltage condition, high voltage gain and also drop-
out voltage is low.[8] This strategy increase the battery life
by controlling the power level delivered to each functional
block through the use of power management circuit. The
circuit must operate at low voltage and low current to
maximize battery lifetime.
Low dropout regulator are one of the most critical power
management module, as they can provide regulated low
noise and precision supply voltage for noise sensitive
analog blocks.[5]
Fig: 1 Block diagram of LDO regulator
Usually signal determines the minimum input signal that a
circuit could manage; therefore a low noise power supply
is critical for a system. In some systems the input signal is
quite small such as cellular phone and RF circuits, so the
output noise of low dropout regulator is required to be
quite low for the sake of not submerging the input signal.
Fig:2 Structure of Generic CMOS LDO[10]
For all the communication devices such as mobile phone
that have transmission and reception circuits operating at
high frequency, the ripple noise of the power supply line
gives bad influences on the stability at a transmission
frequency and will result in a deteriorated voice or
communication quality.[2]
The objective of this error amplifier is to apply the
practices and theories of the low voltage and low power
voltage regulator. In this paper a well defined method of a
CMOS two stage error amplifier has been generated. The
design of this has been carried out from the scaling of the
device parameter. As it is known that by maintaining
scaling factor to minimum value can reduce the current,
power consumption and area as well. Now an error
amplifier has been defined in its negative feedback
configuration, As it can provide the moderate gain as
compared to open loop, but the problem in this case is the
stability which will be reduced by using the compensation
technique.[10] In this case the Miller compensation
technique is executed in practical where the simplest
frequency compensation technique employs the miller
effect by connecting a compensation capacitor all across
the high gain stage.
In this paper Error Amplifier and its designed
consideration is mentioned in SECTION II. The SECTION
III and SECTION IV show simulated results and
Conclusion respectively.
II. ERROR AMPLIFIER AND DESIGN
CONSIDERATION
Basically low drop-out (LDO) regulator consists of three
blocks. First block represents error amplifier second one is
pass device and third one is feedback network which
provide output to the input of first block which is error
amp. In this paper our main concern is towards error
Int. Journal of Electrical & Electronics Engg. Vol. 2, Spl. Issue 1 (2015) e-ISSN: 1694-2310 | p-ISSN: 1694-2426
NITTTR, Chandigarh EDIT -2015 110
amplifier which is used in the first block of the regulator
(LDO) to reduce the ripple noise voltage and enhance the
Gain. The bias current of the error amplifier cannot be
reduced as a result, a low power low dropout voltage
regulator (LDO) having high power supply rejection ratio
(PSRR) performance cannot be realized with a
conventional LDO structure.[7]-[9]
As we are familiar with the conventional low drop-out
regulator (LDO) in which the dominant pole is located at
very low freq of the output by which freq compensation
can be obtained and better dynamic characteristics can be
achieved.
For such circuit larger capacitor is required which occupied
maximum area of chip, thus area of chip increases. In the
designing of full on chip low drop-out regulator describe in
the reference in which compensation capacitance used in
minimum number. The schematic of proposed Error
Amplifier shown below.
Fig: 3 Proposed Error Amplifier
The Error Amplifier consists of two stages to increase the
Gain. The transistor (M0,M1) is differential stage,
transistor (M5,M8) shows current mirror to provide proper
bias current to the differential stage, transistor (M3,M2)
provides the biasing through the bias current source and
transistor (M4,M7) are the second stage of Error Amplifier
to enhance the Gain.
TABLE: 1
ASPECT RATIO OF MOS TRANSISTORS
Transistors
M0,
M1
M5.
M8
M3,
M2
M7 M4
Aspect
Ratio
(W/L)
3
0.5
7
. 5
6
. 5
87
. 5
37.5
. 5
The relation between load capacitance CL at output and
compensation capacitance CC.
CL≥ 2CC ... ..... ... .. .. .....eq (1)
III. SIMULATION RESULTS
For the proposed circuit, the analyse of Gain, Unity Gain
Bandwidth, Phase Margin, CMMR and PSRR are
obtained. All the simulation is done on SPECTRE
Simulator of cadence tool. The simulation result shown
below.
1. Gain of Error Amplifier
Fig:4 Gain of EA
2. Phase margin and Unity Gain Bandwidth
Fig:5 Phase margin and UGB
3. CMRR of Error Amplifier
CMRR for ERROR AMPLIFIER can be calculated by
taking ratio of differential gain to the common mode gain.
The value of CMRR is determined by subtracting the
differential input gain with common input gain in
decibal(dB). The CMRR values obtained is 87.40dB.
Fig:6 CMRR test bench
Int. Journal of Electrical & Electronics Engg. Vol. 2, Spl. Issue 1 (2015) e-ISSN: 1694-2310 | p-ISSN: 1694-2426
111 NITTTR, Chandigarh EDIT-2015
Fig:7
CMRR of EA
4. PSRR of Error Amplifier
PSRR for the ERROR AMPLIFIER is defined as the ratio
of output ripples with respect to the input ripples at large
frequency range. PSRR is measured with both positive and
negative power supply in decibel (dB). The PSRR value
obtained is 77.54dB.
Fig:8 PSRR test bench
Fig:9 The PSRR simulation result of proposed EA
TABLE 2
Comparison of present results with earlier work done
Parameter
Present
work
Reference
[3] [7] [10]
Technology 0.18um 0.5um 0.5um 0.18um
Supply
voltage 1.8V 2.7V 3.5V 1.2V
Dc gain 64.10dB 60dB 60dB N/A
Phase
margin 74° N/A 43 N/A
GBW(MHz) 31.26 N/A 10.96 N/A
CMRR(dB) 87.40 70 N/A N/A
PSRR(dB) 77.54 40 71 65
Frequency 10-100 100- N/A N/A
range(Hz to
MHz)
10
III. CONCLUSION
The error amplifier implemented in 180nm CMOS process
achieves an improved performance of over 64-dB GAIN,
77-dB PSRR and 87-dB CMRR. The circuit analysis and
simulation results shown are obtained using CADENCE
SPECTRE simulator within the frequency range of 10 Hz
to 100 MHz The new circuit not only reduces ripple and
noise of error amplifier, but also improve stability.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This work has been carried out in SMDP-II, VLSI
laboratory of the Electronics and Instrumentation
Engineering Department of Shri G. S. Institute of
Technology and Science, Indore, India. This SMDP-II,
VLSI project is funded by Ministry of Information and
Communication Technology, Government of India.
Authors are thankful to the Ministry for facilities provided
under this project.
REFERENCES
[1]. Ho-Joon Jang, Yong Seong Roh, Young-Jin Moon, Jeongpyo
Park, and Changsik Yoo "Low Drop-Out (LDO) Voltage
Regulator with Improved Power Supply Rejection" ,Journal of
semiconductor technology and science, Volume 12,no.3,pp 313-
318 ,September 2012.
[2]. W.-J. Huang and S.-I. Liu "PSRR-enhanced low-dropout
regulator", Electronics letters, Vol. 47, No. 1. pp 1-2 6th January
2011.
[3]. Xinquan Lai, Donglai Xu" An Improved CMOS Error
Amplifier Design for LDO Regulators in Communication
Applications", 7th WSEAS Int. Conf. on Electronics, Hardware,
Wireless and Optical Communications, Cambridge, UK, pp 32-
34, February 20-22, 2008
[4]. Robert J Milliken, Josh Silva-Martinez "Full on chip CMOS
voltage regulator", IEEE transactions on circuit and system-I,
regular papers, volume 54,no.9, pp 1879-1889, September 2007.
[5]. GA. Rincon-Mora, "Current Efficient, Low Voltage, Low-
Dropout Regulators." Ph.D. Thesis, Atlanta, GA: Georgia
Institute of Technology, 1996.
[6]. Ramy Tantawy and Elizabeth J. Brauer "Performance
Evaluation of CMOS Low Drop-Out Voltage Regulators", The
47th IEEE ,International Midwest Symposium on Circuits and
Systems, pp 141-144 , 2004.
[7]. Rakesh Selvaraj, Shriram Kalusalingam "Design of error
amplifier for LDO", Department of Electrical Engineering,
Project report, Texas A&M University.
[8]. Jianping Guo, Ka Nang Leung "A 25mA CMOS LDO with -
85dB PSRR at 2.5MHz" IEEE Asian Solid-State Circuits
Conference (A-SSCC), pp 381-384 , 2013
[9]. Sanjay Pithadia and Scot Lester " LDO PSRR Measurement
Simplified" Texas instrument Application report,pp 1-4 14–July
2009.
[10].Zared Kamal, Qjidaa Hassan, Zouak Mohcine, " High PSRR
Full On-Chip CMOS Low Dropout Voltage Regulator for
Wireless Applications ", International Journal of Computer
Applications, Volume 71– No.18, pp 7-14, June 2013.

Design of Low Power, High PSRR Error Amplifier for Low Drop-Out CMOS Voltage Regulator

  • 1.
    Int. Journal ofElectrical & Electronics Engg. Vol. 2, Spl. Issue 1 (2015) e-ISSN: 1694-2310 | p-ISSN: 1694-2426 109 NITTTR, Chandigarh EDIT-2015 Design of Low Power, High PSRR Error Amplifier for Low Drop-Out CMOS Voltage Regulator Dipendra Singh Patel1 , Pramod Kumar Jain2 , D.S. Ajnar3 Microelectronics & VLSI Design, Electronics & Instrumentation Dept., S.G.S.I.T.S. Indore, India 1 dspdipendra@gmail.com, 2 prjain@sgsits.ac.in, 3 ajnards@gmail.com Abstract: This paper presents design of an improved Error amplifier (EA) for Low Drop-Out Voltage Regulator. The proposed circuit shows good behaviour as compared to the previous Error Amplifier. The Gain, Unity Gain Bandwidth, Phase Margin, CMRR and PSRR of an Error Amplifier is analysed. The proposed circuit is designed on UMC 180nm CMOS technology with supply voltage of 1.8Volts. All the simulation results are calculated through SPECTRE Simulator of cadence. Keywords: Amplifier, Error amplifier, Regulators, Low Drop- Out voltage regulators, System-on-chip (SOC), Analog electronics. I. INTRODUCTION As the present market for portable electronic devices continues to expand around the world to desire for long battery life drives the search for efficient power management circuit architecture. The research in analog- circuit design is mainly focused in power management of various products, especially those relying on battery power.[1]-[4] Low drop-out voltage regulator is one of the important building block in battery operated portable electronic devices as well as industries and automation application. Presently the demand of portable and battery electronics product have forced this circuit to work under lower voltage condition, high voltage gain and also drop- out voltage is low.[8] This strategy increase the battery life by controlling the power level delivered to each functional block through the use of power management circuit. The circuit must operate at low voltage and low current to maximize battery lifetime. Low dropout regulator are one of the most critical power management module, as they can provide regulated low noise and precision supply voltage for noise sensitive analog blocks.[5] Fig: 1 Block diagram of LDO regulator Usually signal determines the minimum input signal that a circuit could manage; therefore a low noise power supply is critical for a system. In some systems the input signal is quite small such as cellular phone and RF circuits, so the output noise of low dropout regulator is required to be quite low for the sake of not submerging the input signal. Fig:2 Structure of Generic CMOS LDO[10] For all the communication devices such as mobile phone that have transmission and reception circuits operating at high frequency, the ripple noise of the power supply line gives bad influences on the stability at a transmission frequency and will result in a deteriorated voice or communication quality.[2] The objective of this error amplifier is to apply the practices and theories of the low voltage and low power voltage regulator. In this paper a well defined method of a CMOS two stage error amplifier has been generated. The design of this has been carried out from the scaling of the device parameter. As it is known that by maintaining scaling factor to minimum value can reduce the current, power consumption and area as well. Now an error amplifier has been defined in its negative feedback configuration, As it can provide the moderate gain as compared to open loop, but the problem in this case is the stability which will be reduced by using the compensation technique.[10] In this case the Miller compensation technique is executed in practical where the simplest frequency compensation technique employs the miller effect by connecting a compensation capacitor all across the high gain stage. In this paper Error Amplifier and its designed consideration is mentioned in SECTION II. The SECTION III and SECTION IV show simulated results and Conclusion respectively. II. ERROR AMPLIFIER AND DESIGN CONSIDERATION Basically low drop-out (LDO) regulator consists of three blocks. First block represents error amplifier second one is pass device and third one is feedback network which provide output to the input of first block which is error amp. In this paper our main concern is towards error
  • 2.
    Int. Journal ofElectrical & Electronics Engg. Vol. 2, Spl. Issue 1 (2015) e-ISSN: 1694-2310 | p-ISSN: 1694-2426 NITTTR, Chandigarh EDIT -2015 110 amplifier which is used in the first block of the regulator (LDO) to reduce the ripple noise voltage and enhance the Gain. The bias current of the error amplifier cannot be reduced as a result, a low power low dropout voltage regulator (LDO) having high power supply rejection ratio (PSRR) performance cannot be realized with a conventional LDO structure.[7]-[9] As we are familiar with the conventional low drop-out regulator (LDO) in which the dominant pole is located at very low freq of the output by which freq compensation can be obtained and better dynamic characteristics can be achieved. For such circuit larger capacitor is required which occupied maximum area of chip, thus area of chip increases. In the designing of full on chip low drop-out regulator describe in the reference in which compensation capacitance used in minimum number. The schematic of proposed Error Amplifier shown below. Fig: 3 Proposed Error Amplifier The Error Amplifier consists of two stages to increase the Gain. The transistor (M0,M1) is differential stage, transistor (M5,M8) shows current mirror to provide proper bias current to the differential stage, transistor (M3,M2) provides the biasing through the bias current source and transistor (M4,M7) are the second stage of Error Amplifier to enhance the Gain. TABLE: 1 ASPECT RATIO OF MOS TRANSISTORS Transistors M0, M1 M5. M8 M3, M2 M7 M4 Aspect Ratio (W/L) 3 0.5 7 . 5 6 . 5 87 . 5 37.5 . 5 The relation between load capacitance CL at output and compensation capacitance CC. CL≥ 2CC ... ..... ... .. .. .....eq (1) III. SIMULATION RESULTS For the proposed circuit, the analyse of Gain, Unity Gain Bandwidth, Phase Margin, CMMR and PSRR are obtained. All the simulation is done on SPECTRE Simulator of cadence tool. The simulation result shown below. 1. Gain of Error Amplifier Fig:4 Gain of EA 2. Phase margin and Unity Gain Bandwidth Fig:5 Phase margin and UGB 3. CMRR of Error Amplifier CMRR for ERROR AMPLIFIER can be calculated by taking ratio of differential gain to the common mode gain. The value of CMRR is determined by subtracting the differential input gain with common input gain in decibal(dB). The CMRR values obtained is 87.40dB. Fig:6 CMRR test bench
  • 3.
    Int. Journal ofElectrical & Electronics Engg. Vol. 2, Spl. Issue 1 (2015) e-ISSN: 1694-2310 | p-ISSN: 1694-2426 111 NITTTR, Chandigarh EDIT-2015 Fig:7 CMRR of EA 4. PSRR of Error Amplifier PSRR for the ERROR AMPLIFIER is defined as the ratio of output ripples with respect to the input ripples at large frequency range. PSRR is measured with both positive and negative power supply in decibel (dB). The PSRR value obtained is 77.54dB. Fig:8 PSRR test bench Fig:9 The PSRR simulation result of proposed EA TABLE 2 Comparison of present results with earlier work done Parameter Present work Reference [3] [7] [10] Technology 0.18um 0.5um 0.5um 0.18um Supply voltage 1.8V 2.7V 3.5V 1.2V Dc gain 64.10dB 60dB 60dB N/A Phase margin 74° N/A 43 N/A GBW(MHz) 31.26 N/A 10.96 N/A CMRR(dB) 87.40 70 N/A N/A PSRR(dB) 77.54 40 71 65 Frequency 10-100 100- N/A N/A range(Hz to MHz) 10 III. CONCLUSION The error amplifier implemented in 180nm CMOS process achieves an improved performance of over 64-dB GAIN, 77-dB PSRR and 87-dB CMRR. The circuit analysis and simulation results shown are obtained using CADENCE SPECTRE simulator within the frequency range of 10 Hz to 100 MHz The new circuit not only reduces ripple and noise of error amplifier, but also improve stability. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This work has been carried out in SMDP-II, VLSI laboratory of the Electronics and Instrumentation Engineering Department of Shri G. S. Institute of Technology and Science, Indore, India. This SMDP-II, VLSI project is funded by Ministry of Information and Communication Technology, Government of India. Authors are thankful to the Ministry for facilities provided under this project. REFERENCES [1]. Ho-Joon Jang, Yong Seong Roh, Young-Jin Moon, Jeongpyo Park, and Changsik Yoo "Low Drop-Out (LDO) Voltage Regulator with Improved Power Supply Rejection" ,Journal of semiconductor technology and science, Volume 12,no.3,pp 313- 318 ,September 2012. [2]. W.-J. Huang and S.-I. Liu "PSRR-enhanced low-dropout regulator", Electronics letters, Vol. 47, No. 1. pp 1-2 6th January 2011. [3]. Xinquan Lai, Donglai Xu" An Improved CMOS Error Amplifier Design for LDO Regulators in Communication Applications", 7th WSEAS Int. Conf. on Electronics, Hardware, Wireless and Optical Communications, Cambridge, UK, pp 32- 34, February 20-22, 2008 [4]. Robert J Milliken, Josh Silva-Martinez "Full on chip CMOS voltage regulator", IEEE transactions on circuit and system-I, regular papers, volume 54,no.9, pp 1879-1889, September 2007. [5]. GA. Rincon-Mora, "Current Efficient, Low Voltage, Low- Dropout Regulators." Ph.D. Thesis, Atlanta, GA: Georgia Institute of Technology, 1996. [6]. Ramy Tantawy and Elizabeth J. Brauer "Performance Evaluation of CMOS Low Drop-Out Voltage Regulators", The 47th IEEE ,International Midwest Symposium on Circuits and Systems, pp 141-144 , 2004. [7]. Rakesh Selvaraj, Shriram Kalusalingam "Design of error amplifier for LDO", Department of Electrical Engineering, Project report, Texas A&M University. [8]. Jianping Guo, Ka Nang Leung "A 25mA CMOS LDO with - 85dB PSRR at 2.5MHz" IEEE Asian Solid-State Circuits Conference (A-SSCC), pp 381-384 , 2013 [9]. Sanjay Pithadia and Scot Lester " LDO PSRR Measurement Simplified" Texas instrument Application report,pp 1-4 14–July 2009. [10].Zared Kamal, Qjidaa Hassan, Zouak Mohcine, " High PSRR Full On-Chip CMOS Low Dropout Voltage Regulator for Wireless Applications ", International Journal of Computer Applications, Volume 71– No.18, pp 7-14, June 2013.