A 59-year-old woman presented with new-onset jaundice and anemia 10 days after undergoing surgery for uterine cancer. Laboratory workup found evidence of hemolysis including a positive direct Coombs test. Further testing revealed the patient's red blood cells were sensitizied to the antibiotic cefotetan, indicating drug-induced immune hemolytic anemia. She was treated with transfusions and the hemolysis resolved after discontinuing the offending drug. Drug-induced immune hemolytic anemia is a rare but serious complication that can be triggered by certain antibiotics like cefotetan through non-immune or immune mediated mechanisms.