Document Examination Forgeries/Counterfeiting Handwriting Analysis Chromatography
Questioned Document Analysis typewriting much like firearms, typewriters of the same make and model are pretty much the same daily wear and tear or parts of the machining process can cause “defects” or individual characteristics that translate to paper when the machine is used
Questioned Document Analysis photocopiers and laser printers  (demo) in photocopier, original is placed on glass and exposed using reflected light to a drum that is covered with photosensitve material image of original exists on drum as invisible positive photoelectric charge negatively charged toner is drizzled on drum where it sticks to the positive image paper with a positive charge passes the drum causing the negatively charged toner to transfer to the paper which is then heat sealed with laser printer - image of the original held in memory of computer is written to the photosensitive drum using a laser
Questioned Document Analysis photocopiers and laser printers paper yields clues marks from belts, pinchers, rollers and gears can be matched like toolmarks toner can have unique chemical compositions how toner is placed and fused on paper (ie. clumps, blobs) marks on optics scratches or other marks on glass, lenses or mirrors will leave markings on the printed page that can be matched with the optic
Questioned Document Analysis counterfeit security measures U.S. currency easy to counterfeit! all paper currency after 1993 has microline printing, nylon security threads and a plastic security strip as of 2000, all paper currency was updated except the $1 bill
Questioned Document Analysis counterfeit security measures official documents (i.e. passport) background is printed with intricate pattern of polygons with a color shift in the ink green stars – reflective specks sealed in the paper blue “USA” stamp overlaps photo and background paper three red stars stamped over edge of photo whole page sealed with single sheet of adhesive plastic microline printing in lower right corner
Questioned Document Analysis forgery false making or altering of any writing with intent to defraud four types traced simulation freehand lifted
Questioned Document Analysis forgery traced can use overlays (like tracing paper) transmitted light (as with a light board) tracing indentations left in the page underneath the original  tracing patterns of dots that outline the writing to be forged
Questioned Document Analysis forgery simulation involves the copying of writing from a genuine article, trying to imitate the handwriting of the original freehand written with no knowledge of the appearance of the original just writing off the top of your head and passing it off as something else
Questioned Document Analysis forgery lifted tape is used to lift off a signature then place it on another document detection of forgeries freehand easiest to detect simulation easy to detect – style not as fluid, more hesitations than “comfortable” writing traced and lifted are easy to detect but identity of forger cannot be determined
Questioned Document Analysis handwriting analysis examination of design, shape and structure  determine authorship basic principle is that no two people will write the exact same thing in the exact same way
Questioned Document Analysis handwriting analysis  characteristics letter formations connectors upstrokes retraces down strokes spacing baseline curves size distortions hesitations flying stops
Handwriting Comparisons any object with handwriting or print whose source or authenticity is in doubt is referred to as a questioned document examiners gather documents of known authorship or origin and compare them to individual characteristics of questioned writing
Handwriting Comparisons collecting an adequate number of known writings is critical for determining the outcome of a handwriting comparison unconscious handwriting of 2 different individuals can never be identical writing style of an individual may be altered beyond recognition by influence of drugs or alcohol
Handwriting Comparisons general style at first, children copy standard letter forms for handwriting Zaner-Bloser method Palmer method many pupils have writing styles that are similar to one another minor differences attributable to skill in copying
Handwriting Comparisons general style as initial writing skills improve, writing becomes subconscious innumerable habitual shapes and patterns emerge that distinguish it from all others this is what document examiners look for
Handwriting Comparisons
Handwriting Comparisons variations angularity – 5 degrees Degree 1 – Writing on the surface exaggeration of curves embraces all white surfaces circular shaped letters inflated loops inside letters spread out – broad words Degree 2 – Curvilinear Handwriting predominance of curves over straight strokes softening of angles
Handwriting Comparisons variations angularity – 5 degrees Degree 3 –Semi Curvilinear or Semi Rectilinear no dominance in either curves or angularity Degree 4 – Rectilinear or Linear predominance of straight strokes angular connections tight loops round letters become oval shaped Degree 5 – On the Line or Very Linear suppression of curves exaggeration of rectilinear stroke stick like appearance inside letters are narrow
Handwriting Comparisons variations slope slant
Handwriting Comparisons variations speed
Handwriting Comparisons variations pressure
Handwriting Comparisons variations letter spacing word spacing zones
Handwriting Comparisons variations relative dimensions of letters relative to general public relative to each other
Handwriting Comparisons variations connections extras lack of
Handwriting Comparisons variations pen movement
Handwriting Comparisons variations writing skill spelling grammar word choice
Handwriting Comparisons variations arrangement of writing on paper margins spacing crowding insertions alignment
Handwriting Analysis
Chromatography – Ink Analysis chromatography – family of techniques for separating mixtures paper chromatography separate the dyes used in pens/markers relies on… composition of ink solubility of dye in solvent (water, ethanol…) extent to which ink clings to paper length of paper
Chromatography – Ink Analysis procedure spot of ink carried by solvent through capillary action components of dye (colors) separate mark solvent front and color fronts measure from base line calculate Rf value
Chromatography – Ink Analysis Rf value – retention value ratio of the distance the component traveled relative the distance the solvent traveled

Document Examination

  • 1.
    Document Examination Forgeries/CounterfeitingHandwriting Analysis Chromatography
  • 2.
    Questioned Document Analysistypewriting much like firearms, typewriters of the same make and model are pretty much the same daily wear and tear or parts of the machining process can cause “defects” or individual characteristics that translate to paper when the machine is used
  • 3.
    Questioned Document Analysisphotocopiers and laser printers (demo) in photocopier, original is placed on glass and exposed using reflected light to a drum that is covered with photosensitve material image of original exists on drum as invisible positive photoelectric charge negatively charged toner is drizzled on drum where it sticks to the positive image paper with a positive charge passes the drum causing the negatively charged toner to transfer to the paper which is then heat sealed with laser printer - image of the original held in memory of computer is written to the photosensitive drum using a laser
  • 4.
    Questioned Document Analysisphotocopiers and laser printers paper yields clues marks from belts, pinchers, rollers and gears can be matched like toolmarks toner can have unique chemical compositions how toner is placed and fused on paper (ie. clumps, blobs) marks on optics scratches or other marks on glass, lenses or mirrors will leave markings on the printed page that can be matched with the optic
  • 5.
    Questioned Document Analysiscounterfeit security measures U.S. currency easy to counterfeit! all paper currency after 1993 has microline printing, nylon security threads and a plastic security strip as of 2000, all paper currency was updated except the $1 bill
  • 6.
    Questioned Document Analysiscounterfeit security measures official documents (i.e. passport) background is printed with intricate pattern of polygons with a color shift in the ink green stars – reflective specks sealed in the paper blue “USA” stamp overlaps photo and background paper three red stars stamped over edge of photo whole page sealed with single sheet of adhesive plastic microline printing in lower right corner
  • 7.
    Questioned Document Analysisforgery false making or altering of any writing with intent to defraud four types traced simulation freehand lifted
  • 8.
    Questioned Document Analysisforgery traced can use overlays (like tracing paper) transmitted light (as with a light board) tracing indentations left in the page underneath the original tracing patterns of dots that outline the writing to be forged
  • 9.
    Questioned Document Analysisforgery simulation involves the copying of writing from a genuine article, trying to imitate the handwriting of the original freehand written with no knowledge of the appearance of the original just writing off the top of your head and passing it off as something else
  • 10.
    Questioned Document Analysisforgery lifted tape is used to lift off a signature then place it on another document detection of forgeries freehand easiest to detect simulation easy to detect – style not as fluid, more hesitations than “comfortable” writing traced and lifted are easy to detect but identity of forger cannot be determined
  • 11.
    Questioned Document Analysishandwriting analysis examination of design, shape and structure determine authorship basic principle is that no two people will write the exact same thing in the exact same way
  • 12.
    Questioned Document Analysishandwriting analysis characteristics letter formations connectors upstrokes retraces down strokes spacing baseline curves size distortions hesitations flying stops
  • 13.
    Handwriting Comparisons anyobject with handwriting or print whose source or authenticity is in doubt is referred to as a questioned document examiners gather documents of known authorship or origin and compare them to individual characteristics of questioned writing
  • 14.
    Handwriting Comparisons collectingan adequate number of known writings is critical for determining the outcome of a handwriting comparison unconscious handwriting of 2 different individuals can never be identical writing style of an individual may be altered beyond recognition by influence of drugs or alcohol
  • 15.
    Handwriting Comparisons generalstyle at first, children copy standard letter forms for handwriting Zaner-Bloser method Palmer method many pupils have writing styles that are similar to one another minor differences attributable to skill in copying
  • 16.
    Handwriting Comparisons generalstyle as initial writing skills improve, writing becomes subconscious innumerable habitual shapes and patterns emerge that distinguish it from all others this is what document examiners look for
  • 17.
  • 18.
    Handwriting Comparisons variationsangularity – 5 degrees Degree 1 – Writing on the surface exaggeration of curves embraces all white surfaces circular shaped letters inflated loops inside letters spread out – broad words Degree 2 – Curvilinear Handwriting predominance of curves over straight strokes softening of angles
  • 19.
    Handwriting Comparisons variationsangularity – 5 degrees Degree 3 –Semi Curvilinear or Semi Rectilinear no dominance in either curves or angularity Degree 4 – Rectilinear or Linear predominance of straight strokes angular connections tight loops round letters become oval shaped Degree 5 – On the Line or Very Linear suppression of curves exaggeration of rectilinear stroke stick like appearance inside letters are narrow
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
    Handwriting Comparisons variationsletter spacing word spacing zones
  • 24.
    Handwriting Comparisons variationsrelative dimensions of letters relative to general public relative to each other
  • 25.
    Handwriting Comparisons variationsconnections extras lack of
  • 26.
  • 27.
    Handwriting Comparisons variationswriting skill spelling grammar word choice
  • 28.
    Handwriting Comparisons variationsarrangement of writing on paper margins spacing crowding insertions alignment
  • 29.
  • 30.
    Chromatography – InkAnalysis chromatography – family of techniques for separating mixtures paper chromatography separate the dyes used in pens/markers relies on… composition of ink solubility of dye in solvent (water, ethanol…) extent to which ink clings to paper length of paper
  • 31.
    Chromatography – InkAnalysis procedure spot of ink carried by solvent through capillary action components of dye (colors) separate mark solvent front and color fronts measure from base line calculate Rf value
  • 32.
    Chromatography – InkAnalysis Rf value – retention value ratio of the distance the component traveled relative the distance the solvent traveled