A 72-year-old man presented with subacute onset of bilateral leg weakness and urinary retention. He had a history of prostate cancer in 2013 but defaulted follow-up. On examination, he had a sensory level at T7 with reduced strength and sensation below. Imaging found extensive vertebral metastases from prostate cancer at T5-T6, causing spinal cord compression. Laboratory tests showed highly elevated PSA. The differential diagnosis included metastatic spinal cord compression versus transverse myelitis.