Assessment of Abrasion-Assisted
Material Removal in Wire EDM

I. Menzies, P. Koshy
McMaster University, Canada

58th CIRP General Assembly, Manchester
August 25, 2008
1970

generator technology
coated wires
high pressure flushing
adaptive control

workpiece height & taper
surface finish
machining accuracy & precision
2/20
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
Aspinwall et al (2008)

rough

trim

Machining speed &
surface integrity continue
to be issues of focus in
current wire EDM
research

surface integrity

Kruth et al (2004)

~40X

cutting rate
3/20
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
The issues of
machining speed and
surface integrity are
interlinked

Aspinwall et al (2003)

4/20
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
Enhancing the ejection efficiency is
the key to simultaneously improving
the removal rate and the surface
integrity

Need for innovation
5/20
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
Hybrid machining entails the
integration of processes with
distinct mechanisms of
material removal to exploit
their synergy

El-Hofy (2005)

6/20
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
Grinding + EDM
Thermal softening of workpiece
In-process dressing & declogging

7/20
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
Extension of the concept to wire EDM

wire

rod

Masuzawa et al (1985)
discharge area

Different from Wire Electro Discharge Grinding
8/20
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
wire

Material removal by
melting/vaporization and
two-body abrasion

ph > gw
reference voltage
dielectric strength

9/20
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
Fixed abrasive
diamond wire used in
the electronics industry
Issues with wire guide
and electrical power
feed
10/20
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
average voltage

108 –162 V

peak current

1.2 – 8 A

open voltage

180 V

on time

4.9 μs

off time

100 μs

wire tension

6.8 N

wire speed

5.5 m/min

SAE 1018 steel & Nickel 600
dielectric oil; 1 bar flushing pressure

machining gap 8 – 20 µm
removal rate 0.02 – 0.10 mm2/min

wire failure by embrittlement
experiments using wire with
no abrasives for comparison
of removal rate & recast layer,
and estimation of gap-width

11/20

Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
Wire characterization

180 micron core
50 micron (nominal) diamond
12/20
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
Force measurement by considering force
equilibrium in reference to wire bow and
wire tension

13/20
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
wire sawing

edm

Order of
magnitude
enhancement in
the removal rate
Steepest gradient
in the increase in
removal rate is in
line with the
maximum force
gradient

14/20
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
108 V, 8 A

Increase in the removal
rate is due to abrasion
20 m

162 V, 8 A

15/20
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
wire-EDM

Machined surface

108 V, 8 A

abrasion-assisted

Wire performance
degrades rapidly
with repeated use

used wire
16/20
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
Comparison of recast material
nickel

steel

wire-EDM

abrasion-assisted

17/20
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
Wire feed strategies

18/20
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
Conclusions & Outlook
Proof-of-concept of an innovative abrasionassisted wire EDM process has been presented
The process has the potential to significantly
enhance the removal rate and the quality of the
machined surface, particularly for metal matrix
composites that are difficult to wire EDM
The process is perhaps best implemented on a
twin-wire machine tool
Research effort is required to formulate wires with
aluminum oxide abrasives, with a core that has
good sparking and grain retention characteristics
Electrical discharges could possibly enhance wire
sawing of brittle materials through controlled
thermal shock-induced fracture
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

19/20

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008
Thank you
for
your attention!

Natural Sciences & Engineering
Research Council of Canada

20/20
Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM
I. Menzies, P. Koshy

58th CIRP General Assembly
Manchester, August 25, 2008

Abrasion Assisted Wire EDM

  • 1.
    Assessment of Abrasion-Assisted MaterialRemoval in Wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy McMaster University, Canada 58th CIRP General Assembly, Manchester August 25, 2008
  • 2.
    1970 generator technology coated wires highpressure flushing adaptive control workpiece height & taper surface finish machining accuracy & precision 2/20 Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 3.
    Aspinwall et al(2008) rough trim Machining speed & surface integrity continue to be issues of focus in current wire EDM research surface integrity Kruth et al (2004) ~40X cutting rate 3/20 Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 4.
    The issues of machiningspeed and surface integrity are interlinked Aspinwall et al (2003) 4/20 Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 5.
    Enhancing the ejectionefficiency is the key to simultaneously improving the removal rate and the surface integrity Need for innovation 5/20 Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 6.
    Hybrid machining entailsthe integration of processes with distinct mechanisms of material removal to exploit their synergy El-Hofy (2005) 6/20 Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 7.
    Grinding + EDM Thermalsoftening of workpiece In-process dressing & declogging 7/20 Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 8.
    Extension of theconcept to wire EDM wire rod Masuzawa et al (1985) discharge area Different from Wire Electro Discharge Grinding 8/20 Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 9.
    wire Material removal by melting/vaporizationand two-body abrasion ph > gw reference voltage dielectric strength 9/20 Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 10.
    Fixed abrasive diamond wireused in the electronics industry Issues with wire guide and electrical power feed 10/20 Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 11.
    average voltage 108 –162V peak current 1.2 – 8 A open voltage 180 V on time 4.9 μs off time 100 μs wire tension 6.8 N wire speed 5.5 m/min SAE 1018 steel & Nickel 600 dielectric oil; 1 bar flushing pressure machining gap 8 – 20 µm removal rate 0.02 – 0.10 mm2/min wire failure by embrittlement experiments using wire with no abrasives for comparison of removal rate & recast layer, and estimation of gap-width 11/20 Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 12.
    Wire characterization 180 microncore 50 micron (nominal) diamond 12/20 Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 13.
    Force measurement byconsidering force equilibrium in reference to wire bow and wire tension 13/20 Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 14.
    wire sawing edm Order of magnitude enhancementin the removal rate Steepest gradient in the increase in removal rate is in line with the maximum force gradient 14/20 Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 15.
    108 V, 8A Increase in the removal rate is due to abrasion 20 m 162 V, 8 A 15/20 Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 16.
    wire-EDM Machined surface 108 V,8 A abrasion-assisted Wire performance degrades rapidly with repeated use used wire 16/20 Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 17.
    Comparison of recastmaterial nickel steel wire-EDM abrasion-assisted 17/20 Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 18.
    Wire feed strategies 18/20 Assessmentof abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 19.
    Conclusions & Outlook Proof-of-conceptof an innovative abrasionassisted wire EDM process has been presented The process has the potential to significantly enhance the removal rate and the quality of the machined surface, particularly for metal matrix composites that are difficult to wire EDM The process is perhaps best implemented on a twin-wire machine tool Research effort is required to formulate wires with aluminum oxide abrasives, with a core that has good sparking and grain retention characteristics Electrical discharges could possibly enhance wire sawing of brittle materials through controlled thermal shock-induced fracture Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 19/20 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008
  • 20.
    Thank you for your attention! NaturalSciences & Engineering Research Council of Canada 20/20 Assessment of abrasion-assisted material removal in wire EDM I. Menzies, P. Koshy 58th CIRP General Assembly Manchester, August 25, 2008