A 64-year-old male presented with 10 days of horizontal diplopia that was worse when looking left. Examination revealed an incomitant esotropia of 20 degrees in his left eye with limited abduction, consistent with a left 6th nerve palsy. His medical history included hypertension and diabetes but no headaches, nausea, neurological symptoms, or head trauma. Differential diagnoses included neurogenic 6th nerve palsy, restricted medial rectus muscle, or myasthenia gravis. Further workup and management depended on risk factors, symptoms, and response to treatment.