Wikipedia in Education: Taking Stock
Iolanda Pensa & Luca Botturi, SUPSI
Beat Estermann, Bern University of Applied Sciences
OER Conference, Lucerne, 29 January 2019
Programme
Morning Session
● The Wikimedia/Wikipedia Ecosystem
● Wikimedia in Education – An Overview
Variety of Approaches (Typology)
The Role of Wikimedia in Education
Afternoon Session: Workshop
● Short Round of Introduction
● Wikimedia Education – Relating Our Own Experiences
Wikipedia in the Classroom (Secondary School)
Wikidata Assignments (Tertiary Level)
Wikipedia Games (Primary School)
● Benefits of using Wikipedia in education
● Challenges and how to overcome them
© Bili Bidjocka, Ecriture Infinie, http://www.ecritureinfinie.org.
Edit Wikipedia. Communication campaign in public libraries. Design by Alessandro Serravalle developed within Wikipedia dietro le quinte, 2015 (Bachelor thesis), cc by-sa.
DensityDesign Research Lab-INDACO Department Politecnico di Milano, Share Your Knowledge, 2011-2012, cc by-sa.
The Wikimedia / Wikipedia Family
Imagine a world in which
every single human being
can freely share in the
sum of all knowledge! 

That’s our commitment.
Five Pillars of Wikipedia
1. Wikipedia is an encyclopedia
specific style; notability criteria; no original research
2. Wikipedia is written from a neutral point of view
balanced approach towards controversies; verifiable sources
3. Wikipedia is free content that anyone can use,
edit, and distribute
free copyright licenses
4. Wikipedia’s editors should treat each other with
respect and civility
seek consensus; assume good faith; no personal attacks
5. Wikipedia has no firm rules
be bold!
« The Sum of All Human Knowledge» in form of Linked Open Data
1. A multilingual database
2. With sourced Statements
3. Freely usable by anyone (CC Zero)
4. An important node of the Semantic Web
Wiki(m/p)edia in Education Comes in Many
Flavours
Elements of a Typology...
- school levels: primary, secondary, tertiary; lifelong learning
- institutionalization: curricular, extracurricular
- platforms: Wikipedia, Wikidata, Wikiversity, Wikimedia Commons, …
- formats: exploring; contributing: copyediting, article writing, translating, coding, recording,
photographing, graphical design; games, contests
- group size: individual assignments, group assignments, class/school projects
- class size: 4 - 150
- course subjects: history, art history, literature, writing, technical communication, media
studies, chemistry, regional planning and design, nature conversation, translation, ...
- time frame: 1-hour, 1-day, week, semester, ...
- learning objectives: information retrieval, writing skills, media literacy, critical thinking and
research skills, online collaboration, technical and communication skills, ...
Approach proposed by the Wiki Education Foundation
Wiki Education Foundation https://wikiedu.org/
Improving the Language and Style of Wikipedia Articles
Source: Case Studies: How professors are teaching with Wikipedia
Improving the Content of Wikipedia Articles
Source: Case Studies: How professors are teaching with Wikipedia
Translating Wikipedia Articles
Source: Case Studies: How professors are teaching with Wikipedia
Contributing Photographs and Including them in Wikipedia Articles
Source: Case Studies: How professors are teaching with Wikipedia
Creating Illustrations for Wikipedia Articles
Source: Case Studies: How professors... (CC BY-SA 3.0) by Yue Guan
Creating Educational Videos
Source: Case Studies: How professors are teaching with Wikipedia
Editing Wikipedia and Wikidata
Photos: Shani Evenstein (CC BY-SA 4.0)
“From Web 2.0 to Web 3.0”
Undergraduate Course
at Tel Aviv University
Flavours of Wiki(m/p)edia
in compulsory education
Wikipedia as a multimedia content resource
“How does a racoon look like?”
Handy
Safe
Controlled
Reliable
Wikipedia as a safe online search environment
The Wikipedia scavenger hunt
Closed, more stable and controlled but real environment
Non-AI search tool
Wikipedia for creating special class content
L’isola dei fake
Other information literacy activities
Comparing online (wikipedia +
web) search with offline search
(books, encyclopaedia,
vocabulary)
Search skills in the practice:
identifying keywords, interpreting
snippets, searching within a
document, etc.
Reflecting on different types of
online sources (where
wikipedia is a kind of its own)
Wikipedia as a real case of online collaboration
How is wikipedia organized?
How can 70’000 active
contributors work together?
What happens if we try editing
wikipedia? How shall we
organize our class? How do we
interact with the community?
Thomas Hawk on Flickr.com
Wikipedia as an outlet for digital content
We worked on a research
project… Shall we share the
knowledge we produced?
Brad Flickinger on Flickr.com
Thank You!
Contact:
iolanda.pensa@supsi.ch
beat.estermann@bfh.ch
luca.botturi@supsi.ch
Iolanda Pensa, Beat Estermann,
Luca Botturi, Wikipedia in
Education, 2019. cc by-sa all.
Photo: Lane Hartwell, CC BY-SA 3.0
Workshop
Wikipedia in Education
Iolanda Pensa & Luca Botturi, SUPSI
Beat Estermann, Bern University of Applied Sciences
OER Conference, Lucerne, 29 January 2019
Programme
● Short Round of Introduction
● Wikimedia Education – Relating Our Own Experiences
Wikipedia in the Classroom (Secondary School)
Wikidata Assignments (Tertiary Level)
Wikipedia Games (Primary School)
● Benefits of using Wikipedia in education
● Challenges and how to overcome them
Elements of a Typology...
- school levels: primary, secondary, tertiary; lifelong learning
- institutionalization: curricular, extracurricular
- platforms: Wikipedia, Wikidata, Wikiversity, Wikimedia Commons, …
- formats: exploring; contributing: copyediting, article writing, translating, coding, recording,
photographing, graphical design; games, contests
- group size: individual assignments, group assignments, class/school projects
- class size: 4 - 150
- course subjects: history, art history, literature, writing, technical communication, media
studies, chemistry, regional planning and design, nature conversation, translation, ...
- time frame: 1-hour, 1-day, week, semester, ...
- learning objectives: information retrieval, writing skills, media literacy, critical thinking and
research skills, online collaboration, technical and communication skills, ...
Approach proposed by the Wiki Education Foundation
Wiki Education Foundation https://wikiedu.org/
Wikipedia Primary School, visualization by Giovanni Profeta, https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_Primary_School, cc by-sa.
August 2015 March 2016
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_public_art_in_Douala
What Teachers Think
Insights from a FNS study in South Africa
Botturi, L., Van Zyl, I., & Pensa, I. (2017). Wikipedia at School: teachers’ use and perceptions. The Case
of South Africa. Proceedings of ICERI 2017, Sevilla, Spain,1148-1157.
Language Wikipedia no. of articles
English 5’500’000
Afrikaans 47’000
Zulu/Xhosa/
Sesotho
< 1’000
Majority, school-texts available
Minority, no school-texts available
What Teachers Think: Use of Wikipedia
Usefulness of Wikipedia - Perception by language
Usefulness of Wikipedia - Perception by ICT skills
ICT Skills (proxy)
Wikidata Assignments
Wikidata Assignments @ Bern University of Applied Sciences, E-Government Institute
Photo: Flickr user: Andrew Bossi Long Beach Island, CC BY-SA 2.0
Photo: Ansgar Koreng, CC BY 3.0
Assignment Formats & Learning Targets
Assignment Formats
● Master of Business Informatics
○ “Cases and Exercises”, in groups of 2-3
students, 85h each
○ “Preliminary Study and Master Thesis”,
individual assignment, 90h + 360h
● Gymnasium
○ One-week internship, 40h
Learning Targets
● Ontology development (RDF / WD)
● Dealing with terminology issues; creation of
multilingual vocabularies
● Data wrangling, data cleansing
● Data publication (WD)
● Querying data (RDF)
● Getting acquainted with the community aspects
of LOD publication
Not covered so far (possibly more adapted to students
of informatics):
● Software development
● Machine learning
● Human-computer interaction
Insights
● Assignments to students with complementary competencies (e.g. software
programming) yield the greatest benefits.
● Like with most assignments, there is varying engagement from the side of the
students (cf. high workloads in their studies + job).
● Don’t expect anything from students after they have obtained their mark.
● It is worthwhile focusing assignments on community aspects.
● It helps if the supervisor is an active contributor to Wikidata.
● For some tasks, you need to assist students closely (e.g. creation of properties).
● My own role: somewhere between a volunteer putting in my own time and a paid
supervisor.
Tools
Resources on Wikimedia Outreach
Brochures and Support Materials
Wiki Education Dashboard
Wiki Education Dashboard
Wiki Education Foundation
Wiki Education Foundation https://wikiedu.org/
Benefits / Challenges
Wikipedia in education - taking stock - OER conference lucerne 2019

Wikipedia in education - taking stock - OER conference lucerne 2019

  • 1.
    Wikipedia in Education:Taking Stock Iolanda Pensa & Luca Botturi, SUPSI Beat Estermann, Bern University of Applied Sciences OER Conference, Lucerne, 29 January 2019
  • 2.
    Programme Morning Session ● TheWikimedia/Wikipedia Ecosystem ● Wikimedia in Education – An Overview Variety of Approaches (Typology) The Role of Wikimedia in Education Afternoon Session: Workshop ● Short Round of Introduction ● Wikimedia Education – Relating Our Own Experiences Wikipedia in the Classroom (Secondary School) Wikidata Assignments (Tertiary Level) Wikipedia Games (Primary School) ● Benefits of using Wikipedia in education ● Challenges and how to overcome them
  • 3.
    © Bili Bidjocka,Ecriture Infinie, http://www.ecritureinfinie.org.
  • 4.
    Edit Wikipedia. Communicationcampaign in public libraries. Design by Alessandro Serravalle developed within Wikipedia dietro le quinte, 2015 (Bachelor thesis), cc by-sa.
  • 5.
    DensityDesign Research Lab-INDACODepartment Politecnico di Milano, Share Your Knowledge, 2011-2012, cc by-sa.
  • 6.
    The Wikimedia /Wikipedia Family Imagine a world in which every single human being can freely share in the sum of all knowledge! That’s our commitment.
  • 7.
    Five Pillars ofWikipedia 1. Wikipedia is an encyclopedia specific style; notability criteria; no original research 2. Wikipedia is written from a neutral point of view balanced approach towards controversies; verifiable sources 3. Wikipedia is free content that anyone can use, edit, and distribute free copyright licenses 4. Wikipedia’s editors should treat each other with respect and civility seek consensus; assume good faith; no personal attacks 5. Wikipedia has no firm rules be bold!
  • 8.
    « The Sumof All Human Knowledge» in form of Linked Open Data 1. A multilingual database 2. With sourced Statements 3. Freely usable by anyone (CC Zero) 4. An important node of the Semantic Web
  • 9.
    Wiki(m/p)edia in EducationComes in Many Flavours
  • 10.
    Elements of aTypology... - school levels: primary, secondary, tertiary; lifelong learning - institutionalization: curricular, extracurricular - platforms: Wikipedia, Wikidata, Wikiversity, Wikimedia Commons, … - formats: exploring; contributing: copyediting, article writing, translating, coding, recording, photographing, graphical design; games, contests - group size: individual assignments, group assignments, class/school projects - class size: 4 - 150 - course subjects: history, art history, literature, writing, technical communication, media studies, chemistry, regional planning and design, nature conversation, translation, ... - time frame: 1-hour, 1-day, week, semester, ... - learning objectives: information retrieval, writing skills, media literacy, critical thinking and research skills, online collaboration, technical and communication skills, ...
  • 11.
    Approach proposed bythe Wiki Education Foundation Wiki Education Foundation https://wikiedu.org/
  • 12.
    Improving the Languageand Style of Wikipedia Articles Source: Case Studies: How professors are teaching with Wikipedia
  • 13.
    Improving the Contentof Wikipedia Articles Source: Case Studies: How professors are teaching with Wikipedia
  • 14.
    Translating Wikipedia Articles Source:Case Studies: How professors are teaching with Wikipedia
  • 15.
    Contributing Photographs andIncluding them in Wikipedia Articles Source: Case Studies: How professors are teaching with Wikipedia
  • 16.
    Creating Illustrations forWikipedia Articles Source: Case Studies: How professors... (CC BY-SA 3.0) by Yue Guan
  • 17.
    Creating Educational Videos Source:Case Studies: How professors are teaching with Wikipedia
  • 18.
    Editing Wikipedia andWikidata Photos: Shani Evenstein (CC BY-SA 4.0) “From Web 2.0 to Web 3.0” Undergraduate Course at Tel Aviv University
  • 19.
    Flavours of Wiki(m/p)edia incompulsory education
  • 20.
    Wikipedia as amultimedia content resource “How does a racoon look like?” Handy Safe Controlled Reliable
  • 21.
    Wikipedia as asafe online search environment The Wikipedia scavenger hunt Closed, more stable and controlled but real environment Non-AI search tool
  • 22.
    Wikipedia for creatingspecial class content L’isola dei fake
  • 23.
    Other information literacyactivities Comparing online (wikipedia + web) search with offline search (books, encyclopaedia, vocabulary) Search skills in the practice: identifying keywords, interpreting snippets, searching within a document, etc. Reflecting on different types of online sources (where wikipedia is a kind of its own)
  • 24.
    Wikipedia as areal case of online collaboration How is wikipedia organized? How can 70’000 active contributors work together? What happens if we try editing wikipedia? How shall we organize our class? How do we interact with the community? Thomas Hawk on Flickr.com
  • 25.
    Wikipedia as anoutlet for digital content We worked on a research project… Shall we share the knowledge we produced? Brad Flickinger on Flickr.com
  • 26.
    Thank You! Contact: iolanda.pensa@supsi.ch beat.estermann@bfh.ch luca.botturi@supsi.ch Iolanda Pensa,Beat Estermann, Luca Botturi, Wikipedia in Education, 2019. cc by-sa all. Photo: Lane Hartwell, CC BY-SA 3.0
  • 27.
  • 28.
    Wikipedia in Education IolandaPensa & Luca Botturi, SUPSI Beat Estermann, Bern University of Applied Sciences OER Conference, Lucerne, 29 January 2019
  • 29.
    Programme ● Short Roundof Introduction ● Wikimedia Education – Relating Our Own Experiences Wikipedia in the Classroom (Secondary School) Wikidata Assignments (Tertiary Level) Wikipedia Games (Primary School) ● Benefits of using Wikipedia in education ● Challenges and how to overcome them
  • 30.
    Elements of aTypology... - school levels: primary, secondary, tertiary; lifelong learning - institutionalization: curricular, extracurricular - platforms: Wikipedia, Wikidata, Wikiversity, Wikimedia Commons, … - formats: exploring; contributing: copyediting, article writing, translating, coding, recording, photographing, graphical design; games, contests - group size: individual assignments, group assignments, class/school projects - class size: 4 - 150 - course subjects: history, art history, literature, writing, technical communication, media studies, chemistry, regional planning and design, nature conversation, translation, ... - time frame: 1-hour, 1-day, week, semester, ... - learning objectives: information retrieval, writing skills, media literacy, critical thinking and research skills, online collaboration, technical and communication skills, ...
  • 31.
    Approach proposed bythe Wiki Education Foundation Wiki Education Foundation https://wikiedu.org/
  • 33.
    Wikipedia Primary School,visualization by Giovanni Profeta, https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_Primary_School, cc by-sa. August 2015 March 2016
  • 34.
  • 35.
    What Teachers Think Insightsfrom a FNS study in South Africa Botturi, L., Van Zyl, I., & Pensa, I. (2017). Wikipedia at School: teachers’ use and perceptions. The Case of South Africa. Proceedings of ICERI 2017, Sevilla, Spain,1148-1157. Language Wikipedia no. of articles English 5’500’000 Afrikaans 47’000 Zulu/Xhosa/ Sesotho < 1’000 Majority, school-texts available Minority, no school-texts available
  • 36.
    What Teachers Think:Use of Wikipedia
  • 37.
    Usefulness of Wikipedia- Perception by language
  • 38.
    Usefulness of Wikipedia- Perception by ICT skills ICT Skills (proxy)
  • 39.
  • 40.
    Wikidata Assignments @Bern University of Applied Sciences, E-Government Institute Photo: Flickr user: Andrew Bossi Long Beach Island, CC BY-SA 2.0 Photo: Ansgar Koreng, CC BY 3.0
  • 41.
    Assignment Formats &Learning Targets Assignment Formats ● Master of Business Informatics ○ “Cases and Exercises”, in groups of 2-3 students, 85h each ○ “Preliminary Study and Master Thesis”, individual assignment, 90h + 360h ● Gymnasium ○ One-week internship, 40h Learning Targets ● Ontology development (RDF / WD) ● Dealing with terminology issues; creation of multilingual vocabularies ● Data wrangling, data cleansing ● Data publication (WD) ● Querying data (RDF) ● Getting acquainted with the community aspects of LOD publication Not covered so far (possibly more adapted to students of informatics): ● Software development ● Machine learning ● Human-computer interaction
  • 42.
    Insights ● Assignments tostudents with complementary competencies (e.g. software programming) yield the greatest benefits. ● Like with most assignments, there is varying engagement from the side of the students (cf. high workloads in their studies + job). ● Don’t expect anything from students after they have obtained their mark. ● It is worthwhile focusing assignments on community aspects. ● It helps if the supervisor is an active contributor to Wikidata. ● For some tasks, you need to assist students closely (e.g. creation of properties). ● My own role: somewhere between a volunteer putting in my own time and a paid supervisor.
  • 43.
  • 44.
  • 45.
  • 46.
  • 47.
  • 48.
    Wiki Education Foundation WikiEducation Foundation https://wikiedu.org/
  • 49.