Taylor's University
[CSC 60603]
Lee Kim Thiam 0310710
Liew Yong Sheng 0315108
Ho Fung Cheang 0321793
Wong Geng Sen 0321690
Muhd. Hasif b. Alias 0316413
PART A
The software currently could not
add in slides to an existing
presentation.
Automatically creates folder for
user based off of things unknown to
use.
Do not allow reorganization of
results.
Its ability to flexibly change
rulesets in the Ruleset Manager
Automated Analysis and Checking
Presentation and Communication
Information Take-off and Reporting
 Bim interoperability
Work with data in multiple formats, including
IFC4
 Revit Server
Collaborate on shared models across a WAN
within office without worrying information being
interrupted.
 Construction coordination
Cloud-connected office-to-field workflows using
A360, a Cloud-based collaboration service.
 Autodesk Exchange add-in
applications
Extend Revit functionality and constantly getting
updates, allowing user to stick to one software
for all.
 Big system requirement
(over 15GB space)
 A fussy program even for
experienced worker
(take times and patiences)
- -
 More flexible Annotation Tags &
Modernized text layout and editing
Create a tag with a calculation (easier to find)
and additional editing tools for increased control.
 Top range product of Exactal
 BIM software
 Powerful project costing tool
 Complete Estimating Solution
 Advanced on-screen electronic
measurement system
 One of the most common construction
software
2D take off
 Supports various drawing file formats
(PDF, SWG, DWF, DGN..)
 On-screen measurement
3D take off
 Visualise their measurement in 3D
 Better understand of drawing
 Accurate estimate quantities
 Clearer section and part detail
Workbooks
 Powerful spreadsheet based workbooks
live-linked to the drawings
 BQ, Estimation
 Better control of all data information
 Sub-contractor comparison workbooks
Auto-Revisioning
 Compares drawings and highlights the
changes.
 Identify revisions and update quantities.
Subcontractor Comparison workbook
 Compare the subcontractors information.
 Live link report and quotation detail.
Network Capability
 Multiple users work on the same project at
once.
Initial setup cost
 Pay for software and installation.
 High spec computer.
 Training needed.
Rebar detection
 Main reinforcement bar could not be
detected.
 Extra measurement need.
Projection of windows
 Illustrated at the bottom of the wall in 3D
view.
 Cannot detect the actual high of windows.
 Fluctuated windows cost.
 Allows users to visualize the building even before the construction
has begun.
 The software also provides users to share updated information to each
department at ease should there be any changes on the project.
 It provides the ability for users to measure directly from drawing
models be it in 2D, 3D or BIM format.
 It is also able to integrate with cost planning, taking-off and billing
designed for cost consultants as well as contractors.
Measurement
 Measures DWG, DWF and DWFx
files.
 Measures from IFC.
 Allows drag and drop of
measurements.
 Image formats supported
(bmp, gif, jpg, tif)
 Measurements collection.
Multi-file support
Measures Raster format image files.
Measures from PDFs as image files.
Uses object snaps for accuracy.
Enables entity measurements for
model files.
Measures collections.
Auto-Scheduling
Enables grouping of like items.
Measures schedules of like items.
Handles multiple schedules.
Measurements can be dragged from
schedules.
Multi-level sortation.
Slicing
 Allows slicing of 3D model with up to
3 planes.
 Uses surface of an object to define
slice plane.
 Slice planes can be rotated.
 Measurements can be taken on the
slice plane.
 Includes auto-slicing on X, Y and Z
planes.
Training is Needed
Team Communication
Expensive Initial Cost
PART B
BIM CAD
MAN
Round 1
	Earliest	stage	in	construction,	where	consultant	work	
				closely	to	client.
	Feasibility	studies,	roughly	estimate	the	work	and	cost	
				of	the	project	
	Suggest	procurement	system.
	Estimate	budget	for	the	client	and	recommendation.
3D	model	visualize
	+	Construct	a	3D	model	that	represents	their	idea
	+	Better	understanding	of	the	building
	+	Preparation	and	forecast	challenges	
Capture	Reality
	+	Site	condition	information	compiled	and	shared	in	a	model	
	+	Understand	the	site	conditions	and	forecast	the	problem	
Initial	Cost	
-	Cost	of		BIM	QS	computer	software
-	Required	certain	range	of	computer	spec	
-	Professional	training
Better	visualization	than	manual	measurement	
	+	No	confusion	on	drawing	style	
	+	Faded	on	drawing	and	unclear	section	
	+	Alter	the	size	and	resolution	of	the	drawing
Initial	Cost	
-	Cost	for	computer	software
-	Required	certain	range	of	computer	spec	
-	Professional	training
Cost	effective
	+	Cheapest	method	compared	to	the	others
	+	No	extra	cost	for	software	and	installation	
	+	Cost	mainly	from	printing	drawings	and	dimensions
No	training	needed	
	+	Quantity	surveyor	have	already	exposed	to	manual	measurement
	+	No	need	for	extra	training
More	time	consuming	
-	Human	manually	measuring	
-	Calculation	mistakes,	human	errors
-	More	manpower
Round 2
+	Capture	existing	condition	of	the	site	so	that	the	team	will	
					have	a	good	idea	on	how	they	should	design	the	building.
	+	Reduce	wastage	of	drawing	papers	since	designs	can	be	easily	
					edited.
	+	Able	to	stimulate	and	visualize	things	such	as	sunlight	or	wind	
					directions	or	seasonal	weathers.
	+	Clashes	of	electrical	circuit	can	be	detected	early	in	the	beams	
					or	slabs	thus,	avoiding	conflict.
	-	Some	people	may	not	understand	the	BIM	software.
	-	Users	may	be	getting	wrong	information	due	to	different		
				format	in	doing	the	software.
+	Costly	mistakes	in	design	or	production	can	be	avoided.
	+	Documentation	can	be	printed	in	various	forms	for	multiple	
					users.
	+	Ease	of	document	reproduction	and	cloning
	+	Visualization	of	complex	technical	elements
	+	Clarity	of	documentation.
	+	Easier	to	apply	new	ideas.
	-	Requires	training	to	be	knowledgeable	in	the	software
	-	Some	people	may	not	understand	the	software
	-	Users	may	be	getting	wrong	information	due	to	different		-	
				format	in	doing	the	software
+	Does	not	require	the	user	to	be	computer	literated.
	+	Work	can	still	be	done	when	there	is	short	or	no	electricity	supply
	+	Senior	shareholders	may	find	it	easier	to	understand	as	they	need	not	to		
				get	used	to	understanding	it	unlike	software	programmes.
	-	Time	consuming	to	complete	project.
	-	Work	done	may	not	be	neatly	organized.	
	-	Difficult	to	share	updated	information	to	other	department	of	the	project.
Round 3
	Construct	accordingly	to	schedule,	budget	and	as	well	
					finding	the	right	person	to	get	the	job	done.
	Bills	of	Quantities	as	well	as	suggesting	the	best	
					contractor	for	the	project	provided	to	the	client	to		
					ensure	integrity	and	efficiency	for	the	job
Production Time
Quality
Contract Requirement
Legal Responsibility
Configuration of automation -
Accuracy -
Data Management -
Limitation of Usage
Flexibility in workflow -
Production Time
Errors
Round 4
Attend site meetings
Manage contract variations
Handle disputes
Prepare final account
Prepare Cash flow statement
Prepare interim payment
Ensure cost within budget
Prepare subcon schedule
Efficiency towards Variations
+ identify changes/errors and make amendment in one click.
Accuracy towards Resources
+ extract quantity specifically and in proper order reducing waste.
Great project facilitator
+ follow up project activites, cost and time schedule and provide overall
visualization.
Expensive in everyway
- Need training, tedious program
- initial and monthly subscription
- computer spec requirement
Clarity of Output
+ reducing misinterpretation and uncertainty in reading plan.
Accurate measurement
+ the drawings measured are in actual size
Affordability of Software
- individually priced and expensive.
- operator must update his skills along the release of CAD software update.
Function limitation
- Limit to measuring quantities only.
Cost	Effective
	+	No	training	required	as	student	are	already	familiarized	with	manual	works.	
	+	No	extra	cost	for	machinery	or	software	except	for	printing	the	paper	format	
					for	inputs.
		Slower	progress
-	Working	progress	is	slow,	with	addition	of	delay	due	to	changes	and	error,	and	
			also	the	need	for	checking	and	amendment.
-	Time	consuming	because	of	the	absent	of	3D,	4D,	5D	system	capability.
	
	Output	accuracy
-	cost	data	can	only	accept	error	about	≧10%	(meaning	measurement	must	be	
			correct,	which	is	hard	and	tedious	work	for	manual)
-	cost	data	price	constantly	changing,	thus	the	input	must	be	constantly	updated.
Round 5
[ ]
 Prepares	the	summary	of	final	account	report.
 Report	must	be	submitted	on	completion	of	defects	
period.
 After	the	construction	phase,	the	handover	and	close	
out		phase	occurs.
 Final	phase	occurs	after	that,	which	is	known	as	In	Use,	
in	accordance	to	the	RIBA	plan	of	work.
 Phase	includes	the	handing	over	of	the	project	or	building	to	its	
rightful	client.
 Contract	between	contractor	and	client	ends.
 Performance	evaluation	and	feedback	is	made	for	use	in	future	
projects.
 Final	account	will	be	produced	and	a	certificate	of	completion	is	
awarded.
	Phase	includes	stating	the	duties	carried	out	within	Post-
				Occupancy	Evaluations.
	Used	for	operation	of	the	building.
Efficient	Data	Management	
	+	Able	to	manage	a	lot	of	data.
	+	Assists	users	in	updating	the	building	manual.	
	+	Will	still	be	stored	even	after	completion	of	project	for	future	references	and	
					improvement		of	current	building.
	Easier	management	and	operation	
	+	Records	and	archives	costs	and	schedules	for	future	similar	projects.	
	+	Easier	to	manage	and	anticipate	future	projects	without	implementing	more	
					cost.
	-	Coordination	between	contractor	and	designer	is	needed.
	-	Requires	a	lot	of	involvement	between	contractor	and	designer	from	
design	stage	defect	period.
Data		Management
	+	Manages	data	easily	without	the	worry	of	computer	system	requirements.
	+	Changes	in	design	during	the	construction	stage	up	to	the	final	account	
can	be	easily	brought	forward.	
	-	Requires	skilled		personnel.
	-	Workers	with	low	knowledge	may	not	know	the	proper	use	of	blocks		and	
may	lead	to	error	in	update	of	design	and	final	account.
Cost Effectiveness
+ Cheapest method to uphold.
+ BIM and CAD require purchase of software.
Low Training Requirements
+ Graduates start off with skills in manual measurement.
+ Less time spent for training.
Lower	quality	and	accuracy	of	data.
Existence	of	human	error.
Can	sometimes		miss	out	important	factors	in	final	account.
BIM
WIN LIAO!
THE END
$ A+

Software app present (QS)