Islamic 
Architecture 
[ARC 
2343] 
Project 
2: 
Literature 
Review 
Name: 
Nurul 
Jannah 
Masturah 
Jailani 
Student 
ID: 
0310210 
Tutor: 
Pn. 
NorhayaI 
Ramli
APA 
References 
Title 
Keywords 
Defini6on 
Content 
Omer, 
S. 
A 
Conceptual 
Framework 
for 
Islamic 
Architecture 
(PhD). 
InternaIonal 
Islamic 
University 
Malaya. 
Conceptual 
Framework 
of 
Islamic 
Architecture 
Tawhidic, 
Islamic 
architecture, 
concept, 
implicaIons, 
Tawhid 
means 
asserIng 
the 
unity 
or 
oneness 
of 
Allah. 
Tawhid 
is 
the 
Islamic 
concept 
of 
monotheism. 
The 
word 
tawhid 
is 
derived 
from 
the 
words 
wahid 
and 
ahad 
that 
mean 
“one”, 
“unique” 
and 
“peerless”. 
• . 
• The 
implicaIons 
of 
tawhid 
for 
Islamic 
architecture 
are 
rather 
ideological. 
Isma’il 
al-­‐ 
Faruqi 
said 
that 
the 
influence 
the 
concept 
of 
tawhid 
exerts 
on 
Islamic 
civilizaIon 
is 
such 
that 
it 
gives 
the 
laer 
its 
idenIty 
impressing 
it 
by 
its 
own 
mould. 
• The 
idea 
of 
tawhid 
gives 
Islamic 
architecture 
its 
conspicuous 
idenIty. 
It 
also 
creates 
in 
Muslims 
an 
unprecedented 
tawhidic 
outlook 
on 
building 
acIviIes 
so 
that 
there 
exists 
the 
highest 
level 
of 
compaIbility 
between 
buildings 
and 
their 
users. 
Tawhid 
ensures 
that 
Islamic 
architecture 
and 
Muslims 
forge 
a 
producIve 
and 
peaceful 
alliance. 
• The 
character 
of 
Islamic 
architecture 
is 
such 
that 
it 
tries 
its 
best 
to 
disguise 
its 
mundane 
naturalisIc 
factors 
and 
features 
that 
may 
hinder 
a 
beholder’s 
focus 
poinIng 
in 
turn 
to 
a 
higher 
order 
of 
expression 
and 
meaning. 
The 
beholder’s 
aenIon 
is 
directed 
towards 
the 
desired 
end 
by 
various 
ingenious 
arIsIc 
and 
structural 
ways 
and 
methods 
that 
are 
meant 
to 
yield 
an 
intuiIon 
of 
the 
real 
essence 
of 
the 
Transcendent 
and 
its 
divine 
infinity 
and 
perfecIon.
APA 
References 
Title 
Keywords 
Defini6on 
Content 
al 
Faruqi, 
L. 
(1981). 
God 
in 
Visual 
Aesthe;c 
Expression: 
A 
Compara;ve 
Study 
in 
Transcendence 
Symboliza;on. 
Temple 
University 
Philadelphia. 
God 
in 
Visual 
AestheIc 
Expression 
Arts, 
architecture, 
Islamic, 
tawhid, 
explicit, 
implicit 
content 
The 
monotheisIc 
doctrine 
revealed 
by 
Allah 
to 
the 
Prophet 
Muhammad 
is 
know 
as 
tawhid 
(i.e., 
“the 
act 
or 
acIon 
of 
making 
one”). 
Tawhid 
denies 
the 
figural 
representaIon 
of 
God 
in 
Islamic 
Arts 
and 
Architecture. 
• Since 
God 
for 
the 
Muslim 
is 
an 
uerly 
and 
unfailingly 
trascendent 
and 
abstract 
deity, 
no 
being 
or 
object 
in 
nature 
is 
proper 
representaIve 
or 
descripIve 
symbol 
for 
Him. 
In 
consequence, 
Muslim 
art 
has 
never 
depicted 
Allah 
in 
anthropomorphic 
or 
zoomorphic 
form, 
in 
fact, 
fosters 
a 
distaste 
for 
the 
associaIon 
of 
the 
Divine 
with 
any 
figure 
from 
nature. 
• The 
Islamic 
doctrine 
of 
tawhid 
did 
not 
only 
deny 
the 
figural 
representaIon 
of 
God. 
This 
tended 
to 
draw 
the 
aenIon 
of 
the 
viewer 
away 
from 
this 
world 
in 
order 
to 
contemplate 
and 
derive 
an 
intuiIon 
of 
the 
completely-­‐ 
other-­‐than-­‐this-­‐world 
UlImate 
Reality. 
• In 
Islamic 
arts 
and 
architecture, 
nothing 
is 
given 
the 
status 
of 
holiness; 
no 
idols 
and 
objects 
of 
worship. 
Nothing 
in 
nature, 
not 
even 
the 
infinite 
paern, 
can 
be 
equated 
with 
Transcendence 
by 
the 
person 
possessed 
by 
the 
doctrine 
of 
tawhid. 
Thus, 
it 
allows 
Muslims 
to 
be 
true 
to 
the 
belief 
that 
God 
is 
completely 
abstract, 
transcendent 
and 
infinite 
Being.
APA 
References 
Title 
Keywords 
Defini6on 
Content 
Yildiz, 
S. 
(2011). 
What 
Does 
Make 
a 
City 
Islamic?. 
Interna;onal 
Journal 
Of 
Business 
And 
Social 
Science, 
2(8). 
What 
does 
make 
a 
City 
Islamic? 
Islamic 
city, 
tawhid, 
Muslim 
community, 
principles, 
characterisIcs 
At 
the 
heart 
of 
Muslim 
society, 
lies 
the 
faith 
of 
tawhid 
(oneness) 
and 
this 
is 
the 
main 
principle 
on 
which 
Islamic 
city 
is 
based, 
just 
like 
Muslim 
society. 
This 
common 
idenIty 
formed 
by 
Muslim 
society 
– 
whether 
it 
is 
called 
“Islamic 
community”, 
“Islamic 
ummah” 
or 
“Islamic 
culture” 
– 
is 
the 
decisive 
and 
fundamental 
characterisIc 
of 
Islamic 
ciIes. 
• This 
common 
idenIty 
formed 
by 
Muslim 
society 
– 
whether 
it 
is 
called 
“Islamic 
community”, 
“Islamic 
ummah” 
or 
“Islamic 
culture” 
– 
is 
the 
decisive 
and 
fundamental 
characterisIc 
of 
Islamic 
ciIes.13 
Besides, 
the 
tawhid 
concepIon 
is 
found 
in 
every 
aribute 
– 
such 
as 
physical, 
poliIcal, 
economical, 
social 
and 
cultural 
traits 
– 
of 
Islamic 
city 
both 
transcendently 
and 
immanently. 
Therefore, 
the 
aforemenIoned 
characterisIc 
of 
Muslim 
society 
provides 
that 
Islamic 
city 
consItutes 
an 
enIty 
with 
all 
its 
aspects, 
and 
that 
these 
ciIes 
form 
a 
common 
type. 
• In 
Islamic 
thought, 
the 
world 
is 
completely 
temporary/evanescent 
and 
unstable. 
Nevertheless, 
beyond 
all 
the 
temporary 
forms 
and 
images 
of 
the 
world 
– 
or 
of 
the 
city 
– 
there 
is 
a 
spirit 
always 
permanent. 
This 
is 
the 
Tawhid 
concepIon 
that 
emphasizes 
both 
a 
numerical 
oneness 
and 
the 
unity 
of 
mulItude. 
According 
to 
Islamic 
thought, 
the 
universe 
is 
accepted 
as 
one 
of 
three 
verses 
(the 
book, 
the 
man, 
the 
universe) 
by 
Allah.
APA 
References 
Title 
Keywords 
Defini6on 
Content 
Kovacevic, 
E. 
(2014). 
Islamic 
architecture 
and 
its 
conflicts 
with 
contemporary 
Islamic 
architecture. 
InternaIonal 
University 
of 
Sarajevo. 
Islamic 
architecture 
and 
its 
conflicts 
with 
contemporary 
Islamic 
architecture 
Islamic 
architecture, 
principles, 
unified, 
The 
noIon 
of 
Tawhid 
in 
architecture 
is 
the 
formless 
essence 
between 
the 
nature 
of 
space, 
forms, 
order, 
and 
orients 
and 
the 
place 
where 
man 
connects 
with 
the 
presence 
of 
divine 
unity. 
One 
of 
the 
most 
important 
example 
is 
holy 
Ka’bah. 
Ka’bah 
is 
representaIve 
of 
being 
unified 
among 
the 
believers. 
Each 
year 
in 
the 
specific 
period 
Muslim 
people 
go 
there 
to 
accomplish 
one 
of 
the 
essenIal 
religious 
obligaIon. 
It 
is 
called 
‘’hadj’’. 
Regardless 
being 
wealthy, 
wise, 
more 
religious 
or 
less 
religious, 
the 
only 
condiIon 
is 
enough 
financial 
status 
to 
fulfill 
all 
cost 
of 
trip 
and 
basic 
life 
needs 
during 
this 
worship. 
Every 
year 
all 
these 
people 
force 
themselves 
to 
gather 
there 
for 
only 
one 
goal 
is 
that 
compleIng 
their 
sacred 
obligaIon 
and 
the 
Ka’bah 
is 
the 
only 
one 
place 
where 
Muslim 
people 
can 
accomplish 
their 
sacred 
obligaIon. 
That 
acIon 
can 
be 
good 
example 
to 
illustrate 
first 
principle 
of 
Islamic 
architecture.
APA 
References 
Title 
Keywords 
Defini6on 
Content 
Longhurst, 
C. 
(2012). 
Theology 
of 
a 
Mosque: 
The 
Sacred 
Inspiring 
Form, 
FuncIon 
and 
Design 
in 
Islamic 
Architectur. 
Lonaard 
Magazine, 
(8). 
Tawhid, 
mosque, 
theology, 
principles, 
divine 
Islam 
teaches 
that 
God 
is 
one 
(aḥad) 
and 
that 
His 
divine 
oneness 
is 
self-­‐ 
evident 
based 
on 
His 
infinity 
and 
omnipresence. 
Masājid 
seek 
to 
capture 
this 
by 
projecIng 
the 
principles 
of 
Tawḥīd 
—God’s 
Oneness, 
aḥadiyya 
—his 
divine 
Unity, 
and 
waḥdat 
al-­‐wujūd 
—the 
unity 
of 
all 
creaIon, 
into 
their 
architectural 
designs 
and 
decoraIon. 
• Tawḥīd 
exhibits 
how 
an 
indispensable 
relaIonship 
exists 
between 
the 
external 
world 
of 
forms 
and 
the 
interior 
world 
of 
divine 
realiIes. 
The 
physical 
contextualisaIon 
of 
this 
concept 
sheds 
light 
on 
the 
visible 
and 
invisible 
nature 
of 
Islam’s 
architectural 
and 
aestheIc 
ideals— 
God 
as 
Aẓ 
-­‐Ẓāhir— 
The 
Manifest, 
The 
Evident, 
and 
Al-­‐Bāṭin 
—The 
Hidden, 
The 
Unmanifest. 
• Ayatullah 
Khamenei 
explains 
that 
the 
masjid 
translates 
tawḥīd 
into 
“the 
objecIvity 
of 
creaIon, 
a 
planned 
and 
computed 
order 
in 
the 
world 
[…] 
a 
sort 
of 
dynamism 
in 
funcIon 
and 
purpose.” 
• Khamenei 
explains: 
“To 
describe 
the 
sense 
of 
space 
or 
building 
typology 
that 
tawhid 
imparts, 
would 
be 
to 
observe 
the 
course 
of 
nature 
and 
translate 
it 
into 
a 
materiality 
occupying 
space 
for 
the 
purpose 
of 
giving 
praise 
to 
God.” 
• A 
strong 
sense 
of 
idenIty 
and 
consistency 
tends 
towards 
auniversally 
recognisable 
aestheIc 
signature 
on 
masājid 
. 
This 
signature 
is 
rooted 
in 
Islamictheology 
and 
the 
Muslim 
sense 
of 
community.Imbued 
with 
the 
principles 
of 
tawḥid 
and 
waḥdat 
al-­‐wujūd 
mosque 
decoraIon 
underscores 
God’sdivine 
aributes.
Islamic 
Architecture 
Project 
2 
– 
Ques6ons 
1. Which 
part 
of 
the 
mosque 
can 
you 
feel 
the 
atmosphere 
of 
Tawhid? 
-­‐ 
In 
my 
opinion, 
the 
place 
where 
the 
Imam 
leads 
the 
congregaIonal 
prayers. 
The 
Imam 
unites 
the 
Muslims 
in 
the 
mosque. 
2. 
Why 
is 
it 
important 
to 
adopt 
the 
concept 
of 
Tahwid 
in 
the 
mosque? 
-­‐ 
To 
ensure 
the 
oneness 
of 
Allah, 
in 
every 
aspect 
of 
a 
mosque. 
And 
to 
strengthen 
the 
silaturrahim 
bond 
between 
Muslim 
worshippers. 
3. 
Does 
the 
aestheIc 
design 
of 
the 
mosque 
give 
off 
a 
Tawhidic 
presence? 
-­‐ 
It’ 
a 
very 
beauIful 
mosque. 
It 
makes 
us 
come 
to 
pray, 
and 
invite 
our 
families 
and 
friends 
to 
come 
to 
pray 
here. 
4. 
What 
kind 
of 
acIviIes 
held 
by 
the 
mosque 
to 
create 
the 
feeling 
of 
Tawhid? 
-­‐ 
They 
hold 
Arabic 
classes, 
events, 
weddings 
etc. 
All 
kinds 
of 
acIviIes 
to 
teach 
Muslims 
on 
the 
religion, 
bringing 
everyone 
together. 
5. 
Does 
the 
Tawhidic 
atmosphere 
of 
the 
mosque 
contributes 
to 
the 
spiritual 
connecIon 
between 
worshippers 
and 
God? 
-­‐ 
It 
helps 
us 
being 
immersed 
during 
prayers, 
where 
everyone 
gathers 
together. 
6. 
Does 
further 
understanding 
of 
Tawhid 
will 
help 
you 
being 
immersed 
during 
prayers? 
-­‐ 
Yes, 
it 
does. 
7. 
Which 
part 
of 
the 
design 
of 
the 
mosque 
that 
you 
like 
most? 
-­‐ 
I 
personally 
like 
the 
dome 
of 
the 
mosque 
most. 
It 
is 
very 
beauIful 
and 
big, 
making 
me 
feel 
rather 
small. 
8. 
Does 
any 
of 
the 
ornamentaIon 
of 
the 
mosque 
give 
you 
an 
uncomfortable 
feeling? 
Why? 
-­‐ 
I 
don’t 
think 
so. 
I 
think 
every 
part 
of 
the 
mosque 
is 
very 
beauIful 
and 
pleasing 
to 
the 
eye. 
9. 
In 
your 
opinion, 
does 
the 
mosque 
itself 
a 
representaIon 
of 
Tawhid? 
If 
not, 
which 
mosque? 
-­‐ 
Yes 
it 
does. 
With 
it’s 
grand 
look, 
it 
calls 
out 
to 
every 
Muslims 
and 
even 
non-­‐Muslims 
to 
visit 
this 
mosque. 
10. 
If 
you 
were 
to 
take 
part 
in 
the 
re-­‐designing 
the 
mosque, 
what 
would 
you 
input 
in 
order 
to 
create 
a 
beer 
spiritual 
feeling 
to 
the 
mosque? 
-­‐ 
Maybe 
add 
more 
trees 
around 
the 
mosque? 
To 
give 
more 
privacy 
from 
the 
busy 
roads 
beside 
the 
mosque 
compound.

Islamic architecture project 2

  • 1.
    Islamic Architecture [ARC 2343] Project 2: Literature Review Name: Nurul Jannah Masturah Jailani Student ID: 0310210 Tutor: Pn. NorhayaI Ramli
  • 2.
    APA References Title Keywords Defini6on Content Omer, S. A Conceptual Framework for Islamic Architecture (PhD). InternaIonal Islamic University Malaya. Conceptual Framework of Islamic Architecture Tawhidic, Islamic architecture, concept, implicaIons, Tawhid means asserIng the unity or oneness of Allah. Tawhid is the Islamic concept of monotheism. The word tawhid is derived from the words wahid and ahad that mean “one”, “unique” and “peerless”. • . • The implicaIons of tawhid for Islamic architecture are rather ideological. Isma’il al-­‐ Faruqi said that the influence the concept of tawhid exerts on Islamic civilizaIon is such that it gives the laer its idenIty impressing it by its own mould. • The idea of tawhid gives Islamic architecture its conspicuous idenIty. It also creates in Muslims an unprecedented tawhidic outlook on building acIviIes so that there exists the highest level of compaIbility between buildings and their users. Tawhid ensures that Islamic architecture and Muslims forge a producIve and peaceful alliance. • The character of Islamic architecture is such that it tries its best to disguise its mundane naturalisIc factors and features that may hinder a beholder’s focus poinIng in turn to a higher order of expression and meaning. The beholder’s aenIon is directed towards the desired end by various ingenious arIsIc and structural ways and methods that are meant to yield an intuiIon of the real essence of the Transcendent and its divine infinity and perfecIon.
  • 3.
    APA References Title Keywords Defini6on Content al Faruqi, L. (1981). God in Visual Aesthe;c Expression: A Compara;ve Study in Transcendence Symboliza;on. Temple University Philadelphia. God in Visual AestheIc Expression Arts, architecture, Islamic, tawhid, explicit, implicit content The monotheisIc doctrine revealed by Allah to the Prophet Muhammad is know as tawhid (i.e., “the act or acIon of making one”). Tawhid denies the figural representaIon of God in Islamic Arts and Architecture. • Since God for the Muslim is an uerly and unfailingly trascendent and abstract deity, no being or object in nature is proper representaIve or descripIve symbol for Him. In consequence, Muslim art has never depicted Allah in anthropomorphic or zoomorphic form, in fact, fosters a distaste for the associaIon of the Divine with any figure from nature. • The Islamic doctrine of tawhid did not only deny the figural representaIon of God. This tended to draw the aenIon of the viewer away from this world in order to contemplate and derive an intuiIon of the completely-­‐ other-­‐than-­‐this-­‐world UlImate Reality. • In Islamic arts and architecture, nothing is given the status of holiness; no idols and objects of worship. Nothing in nature, not even the infinite paern, can be equated with Transcendence by the person possessed by the doctrine of tawhid. Thus, it allows Muslims to be true to the belief that God is completely abstract, transcendent and infinite Being.
  • 4.
    APA References Title Keywords Defini6on Content Yildiz, S. (2011). What Does Make a City Islamic?. Interna;onal Journal Of Business And Social Science, 2(8). What does make a City Islamic? Islamic city, tawhid, Muslim community, principles, characterisIcs At the heart of Muslim society, lies the faith of tawhid (oneness) and this is the main principle on which Islamic city is based, just like Muslim society. This common idenIty formed by Muslim society – whether it is called “Islamic community”, “Islamic ummah” or “Islamic culture” – is the decisive and fundamental characterisIc of Islamic ciIes. • This common idenIty formed by Muslim society – whether it is called “Islamic community”, “Islamic ummah” or “Islamic culture” – is the decisive and fundamental characterisIc of Islamic ciIes.13 Besides, the tawhid concepIon is found in every aribute – such as physical, poliIcal, economical, social and cultural traits – of Islamic city both transcendently and immanently. Therefore, the aforemenIoned characterisIc of Muslim society provides that Islamic city consItutes an enIty with all its aspects, and that these ciIes form a common type. • In Islamic thought, the world is completely temporary/evanescent and unstable. Nevertheless, beyond all the temporary forms and images of the world – or of the city – there is a spirit always permanent. This is the Tawhid concepIon that emphasizes both a numerical oneness and the unity of mulItude. According to Islamic thought, the universe is accepted as one of three verses (the book, the man, the universe) by Allah.
  • 5.
    APA References Title Keywords Defini6on Content Kovacevic, E. (2014). Islamic architecture and its conflicts with contemporary Islamic architecture. InternaIonal University of Sarajevo. Islamic architecture and its conflicts with contemporary Islamic architecture Islamic architecture, principles, unified, The noIon of Tawhid in architecture is the formless essence between the nature of space, forms, order, and orients and the place where man connects with the presence of divine unity. One of the most important example is holy Ka’bah. Ka’bah is representaIve of being unified among the believers. Each year in the specific period Muslim people go there to accomplish one of the essenIal religious obligaIon. It is called ‘’hadj’’. Regardless being wealthy, wise, more religious or less religious, the only condiIon is enough financial status to fulfill all cost of trip and basic life needs during this worship. Every year all these people force themselves to gather there for only one goal is that compleIng their sacred obligaIon and the Ka’bah is the only one place where Muslim people can accomplish their sacred obligaIon. That acIon can be good example to illustrate first principle of Islamic architecture.
  • 6.
    APA References Title Keywords Defini6on Content Longhurst, C. (2012). Theology of a Mosque: The Sacred Inspiring Form, FuncIon and Design in Islamic Architectur. Lonaard Magazine, (8). Tawhid, mosque, theology, principles, divine Islam teaches that God is one (aḥad) and that His divine oneness is self-­‐ evident based on His infinity and omnipresence. Masājid seek to capture this by projecIng the principles of Tawḥīd —God’s Oneness, aḥadiyya —his divine Unity, and waḥdat al-­‐wujūd —the unity of all creaIon, into their architectural designs and decoraIon. • Tawḥīd exhibits how an indispensable relaIonship exists between the external world of forms and the interior world of divine realiIes. The physical contextualisaIon of this concept sheds light on the visible and invisible nature of Islam’s architectural and aestheIc ideals— God as Aẓ -­‐Ẓāhir— The Manifest, The Evident, and Al-­‐Bāṭin —The Hidden, The Unmanifest. • Ayatullah Khamenei explains that the masjid translates tawḥīd into “the objecIvity of creaIon, a planned and computed order in the world […] a sort of dynamism in funcIon and purpose.” • Khamenei explains: “To describe the sense of space or building typology that tawhid imparts, would be to observe the course of nature and translate it into a materiality occupying space for the purpose of giving praise to God.” • A strong sense of idenIty and consistency tends towards auniversally recognisable aestheIc signature on masājid . This signature is rooted in Islamictheology and the Muslim sense of community.Imbued with the principles of tawḥid and waḥdat al-­‐wujūd mosque decoraIon underscores God’sdivine aributes.
  • 7.
    Islamic Architecture Project 2 – Ques6ons 1. Which part of the mosque can you feel the atmosphere of Tawhid? -­‐ In my opinion, the place where the Imam leads the congregaIonal prayers. The Imam unites the Muslims in the mosque. 2. Why is it important to adopt the concept of Tahwid in the mosque? -­‐ To ensure the oneness of Allah, in every aspect of a mosque. And to strengthen the silaturrahim bond between Muslim worshippers. 3. Does the aestheIc design of the mosque give off a Tawhidic presence? -­‐ It’ a very beauIful mosque. It makes us come to pray, and invite our families and friends to come to pray here. 4. What kind of acIviIes held by the mosque to create the feeling of Tawhid? -­‐ They hold Arabic classes, events, weddings etc. All kinds of acIviIes to teach Muslims on the religion, bringing everyone together. 5. Does the Tawhidic atmosphere of the mosque contributes to the spiritual connecIon between worshippers and God? -­‐ It helps us being immersed during prayers, where everyone gathers together. 6. Does further understanding of Tawhid will help you being immersed during prayers? -­‐ Yes, it does. 7. Which part of the design of the mosque that you like most? -­‐ I personally like the dome of the mosque most. It is very beauIful and big, making me feel rather small. 8. Does any of the ornamentaIon of the mosque give you an uncomfortable feeling? Why? -­‐ I don’t think so. I think every part of the mosque is very beauIful and pleasing to the eye. 9. In your opinion, does the mosque itself a representaIon of Tawhid? If not, which mosque? -­‐ Yes it does. With it’s grand look, it calls out to every Muslims and even non-­‐Muslims to visit this mosque. 10. If you were to take part in the re-­‐designing the mosque, what would you input in order to create a beer spiritual feeling to the mosque? -­‐ Maybe add more trees around the mosque? To give more privacy from the busy roads beside the mosque compound.