Identification
Part -2
Dr Nikita Prabhakaran
Junior Resident
Department of Forensic Medicine
Thiruvananthapuram
• Gaurav Mukhi case
• “Youngest best player in ISL”
• “ Emerging player of the match” Award
• Alleged to be of over age
• ???????
Identification - 2
• Race
• Sex
•Age
• Stature
•Not the duty of other doctors !!!!!!!!!
• How to estimate age in the living and the dead?????
Major things to look for:
• (1) TEETH
• (2) BONE-ossification of bones
• (3)Secondary Sexual Characters
• (4) General Development- stature + psychomotor
Note:
• Infants- in utero features
• Children- general developmental milestones
Teeth
Temporary
teeth
Permanent
teeth
Physiological
changes
Alveolar cavity in mandible
3-4 month IU life
Cellular tooth germ
(crown)
Root grows
Lifting the
crown outside
Temporary
tooth eruption
At birth
Rudiments of all temporary
teeth + 1st permanent
molars
• Root reabsorbs
• Unsupported crown
falls off
• Permanent teeth
erupts
• Temporary Teeth = 2 incisors + 1 canine + 0 premolars + 2 molars
(5 * 4 = 20 teeth) 2102
2102
• Permanent Teeth = 2 incisors + 1 canine + 2 premolars + 3 molars
(8 * 4 = 32 teeth)
2123
2123
Temporary teeth Permanent Teeth
• Smaller, lighter, narrower (exception
temporary molars >>> permanent
premolars)
• Heavier, stronger, broader
• Anterior teeth - vertical • Inclined a little forward
• Milk white in colour • Ivory white in colour
• Quick attrition – less mineralisation • Less attrition
• Enamel- thinner • Thicker ( less constant)
• Marked constriction between
crown and root
• No such constriction
Temporary teeth Permanent Teeth
Anterior teeth-
Labial surface
Smoother Perikymata (depressions)
Incisal edges No mamelons Mamelons present
(wear away quickly)
Posterior teeth- Molars Buccal and lingual
surfaces-flatter
Less flat
Roots of molars Smaller + more divergent Larger+ less divergent
(8-12m)
8
10 18 14 24
6
(6-8m)
12
(12-14 m)
18
(18-20m)
14 24
(20-24m)
Upper
Lower
Medial Lateral
6
8 10
12
18
18
14
14
24
24
7
(7-8)
8
(8-9)
11
(11-12)
9
(9-11)
10
(10-12)
6
(6-7)
12
(12-14)
18
(>17)
Central
Incisor
Lateral
Incisor
Canine PM-1 PM-2 M-1 M-2 M-3
7 8
9
10
11
6
12
18
Mixed Dentition
Age= (No: of permanent teeth – 5) * 4
Between the age of 6-11 years
Successional & Superadded teeth
• Successional- those permanent teeth that replace other teeth
• Super added- those added to the existing set of teeth, do not
replace any teeth ( eruption increases the number of teeth )
Gustafson’s Method
•>21 years old
• Physiological changes of age in dental tissues
•6 characteristics
• (1) Attrition- due to wear and tear from mastication
• (2) Periodontosis - regression of the gums
• (3) Secondary dentin – develop from the walls within the cavity
• (4) Cementum apposition- secondary cementum incremental lines
• (5) Root Resorption- starts at the apex
• (6) Root Transparency- >30 years – canals in the dentine (deposition)
Take the sum of
scores formula
AGE
Bone
CLAVICLE
Medial end
18-20 Yrs
22-23 Yrs
6 m IU
7 m IU
9 m IU
60 Yrs
40 Yrs
STERNUM
acromion
coracoid
14 Yr
18 Yr
SCAPULA
head
greater
lesser
tuberosity
1 Yr
3 Yr
5 Yr
6 Yr
(16-18Yr)
capitulum
trochlea
Lateral epicondyle
13 Yr
11 Yr
2 Yr
14Yr
(14-17Yr)
Medial epicondyle
8 Yr
Upper end -radius
Lower end -radius
6 Yr
2 Yr 6 Yr
10 Yr
Upper end -ulna
Lower end -ulna
RADIUS AND ULNA
(14-17Yr)
(14-18Yr)
P
TQ
LS
CTM
H
TD
1- capitate
2-hamate
3-triquetral
4-lunate
5-trapezoid
5-scaphoid
6-trapezium
11-12-pisciform
CARPAL BONES
2
2-4
2-4
2-4
2-4 14-17 Yr
14 yr (18 yr)
(11-14 yr)
(7-8 yr)
16 yr
(19 yr-F)
(21 yr -M)
PELVIS
Triradiate cartliage
Ilia crest
Ischial tuberosity
Ischiopubic ramus
4-5 m IU
6-7 m IU
I
II
III
IV
V 8m IU (14 Yr)
(20-25) Yr
SACRUM
Head
Lower end of femur
1 yr
4 yr
11 yr
9 m IU
(15 yr)
(14- 17 yr)
(14- 17 yr)
(14- 17 yr)
FEMUR
Greater trochanter
Lesser trochanter
Upper end -Tibia
Lower end -Tibia
Just after birth
(14-17 yr)
2 yr
(14-17 yr)
4 yr
Upper end -Fibula
Lower end -Fibula
TIBIA AND FIBULA
(14-17 Yr)
TARSAL BONES
Calcaneum
5 m IU
Talus
7 m IU
Cuboid
9 m IU
40-50 50
30-40
40-50
50-60
50-60
60-70
40-50
80
Cranial Sutures
Case
• A school student has won long jump in district level in the sub-junior
category
(sub-junior << 14 )
• Allegations came that she was above 16 years
????
Sexual development
•Tanners staging
General development
Age determination of foetus
Rule of Hasse
• First 5 months of IU life 
Crown-heel length=square of the months of gestation
• After that Age in lunar months * 5
1st month/ 4 weeks
• I cm in length
• 2.5 g grey coloured oval mass= pigeons egg
• attached to the chorion with a very short cord
• limb buds nodules
2nd month/ 8 weeks
• 4 cm
• Sex is indistinct
• Webbed hands and feet P
3rd month/12 weeks
• 9 cm long
• Eyes are closed, pupillary memb++
• Sex – rarely indistinguishable
4th month/ 16 weeks
• 13 to 16 cm long
• Sex distinguishable
• Convolutions of brain+
• Breast buds seen as dots
1/4th
5th month/20 weeks
• 25 cm length
• Vernix caseosa ++
• Light hair in the head
• Lanugo on the body
6th month/24 weeks
• 30 cm length
• Wrinkled appearance
• Eyebrows, eyelashes+
• Testicles –close to kidneys
7th month/ 28 weeks
• Length:35 cm
• Thick finger nails( not reaching the tip)
• Eyelids partly open.
• Testes- ext inguinal ring
• Caecum in RIF+
• Period of viability
8th month/32 weeks
• Length 40 cm
• Lanugo disappears from the face,
• Scalp hair thickens-1.5 cm length
• Nails have reached the tips
• Left testis descended
9th month/36 weeks
• 45 - 47 cm
• Lanugo hair has complete disappeared
• Vernix caseosa at the flexures of joints
10th month/40 weeks
• Full term
• Lanugo – absent except in shoulders
• Nails – project beyond, toenails reach tip
• Umbilicus-central part between xiphoid and
pubis
• Rectum : Dark brown meconium +
Medicolegal Importance of Age
• 3 months First trimester- one doctor is enough for MTP
• 4 months Quickening – quick unborn child Culpable
Homicide
• > 5 months- illegal MTP
• 7 months period of viability
• 1 year  Infant ( Infanticide)
• 5 years < 5 years in the custody of the mother
• (The Hindu minority and guardianship)
• 7 years Criminal responsibility
“ any act done by a child less than 7 years is not an offence (s 82 IPC)”
7-12 years: if he proves he did not attain such understanding-not
punishable
Exception: 5 years Railway act : child above 5 years should be held
responsible for wrecking a train
• 10 years
• Child < 10 years - kidnapped/ abducted punishment
10years  property is stolen Kidnapping
16 years (males) from local
guardianship
Kidnapping
18 years (females) from
local guardianship
Kidnapping
21 years female- imported for
illicit intercourse
Kidnapping
Kidnapping Abduction
Even with will
by illegal means
By decietfulness
• 12 years
• Age of consent ( S 89 IPC)
• Age of consent for general physical examination
• No consent is valid if age <12 years( S 90 IPC)
• < 12 years- gives his evidence in the court of Law
without oath
•14 years <14 years not allowed to work in any factory
cannot be employed for any work
•16 years : child- < 16 years (old juvenile act)
Now > 18 years ( JJA,2000 + POCSO)
16-18 years  rape / murder tried as adults
No death penalty/life term imprisonment
•18 years:
• Age of majority
• Right to vote
• Marriage for girls
• Consent for undergoing surgery
• Consent for sexual Intercourse
• Consent for acts intended to cause grievous hurt (boxing, fencing)
• Age for donating organs
• 21 years
• Age for marriage in adult males
• 60 years
• Senior Citizen- males
• (females- 56/58 years)
Discussion
• A child of age 6 years gave a rat poison ( offering it as a sweet) to his
grandmother and the grandmother dies… will he be responsible????
• A male of 21 years marries a female of 15 years … is it offence????
• A child of 12 years is diagnosed with umbilical hernia.
•Should we take a consent????
•From whom????
AGE in The LIVING
• General development
• Teeth Eruption
• Radiological
Any disparity Radiological
Age in The Dead
• External features
• Teeth- Gustafson’s
• Ossification- reddish brown
centre surrounded by bluish
white cartilage
• Fusion- sutures+ sternum
• Others-Rib phase analysis
• Pubic symphysis
Important questions
• Temporary and permanent teeth
• Successional and superadded teeth
• Gustafson’s technique
• Age estimation in the living/dead
• MLI of age
• Practical  X-rays
THANK YOU

Identification - Age estimation

  • 1.
    Identification Part -2 Dr NikitaPrabhakaran Junior Resident Department of Forensic Medicine Thiruvananthapuram
  • 3.
    • Gaurav Mukhicase • “Youngest best player in ISL” • “ Emerging player of the match” Award • Alleged to be of over age • ???????
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
    •Not the dutyof other doctors !!!!!!!!!
  • 7.
    • How toestimate age in the living and the dead?????
  • 8.
    Major things tolook for: • (1) TEETH • (2) BONE-ossification of bones • (3)Secondary Sexual Characters • (4) General Development- stature + psychomotor
  • 9.
    Note: • Infants- inutero features • Children- general developmental milestones
  • 10.
  • 11.
    Alveolar cavity inmandible 3-4 month IU life Cellular tooth germ (crown) Root grows Lifting the crown outside Temporary tooth eruption At birth Rudiments of all temporary teeth + 1st permanent molars • Root reabsorbs • Unsupported crown falls off • Permanent teeth erupts
  • 12.
    • Temporary Teeth= 2 incisors + 1 canine + 0 premolars + 2 molars (5 * 4 = 20 teeth) 2102 2102 • Permanent Teeth = 2 incisors + 1 canine + 2 premolars + 3 molars (8 * 4 = 32 teeth) 2123 2123
  • 13.
    Temporary teeth PermanentTeeth • Smaller, lighter, narrower (exception temporary molars >>> permanent premolars) • Heavier, stronger, broader • Anterior teeth - vertical • Inclined a little forward • Milk white in colour • Ivory white in colour • Quick attrition – less mineralisation • Less attrition • Enamel- thinner • Thicker ( less constant) • Marked constriction between crown and root • No such constriction
  • 16.
    Temporary teeth PermanentTeeth Anterior teeth- Labial surface Smoother Perikymata (depressions) Incisal edges No mamelons Mamelons present (wear away quickly) Posterior teeth- Molars Buccal and lingual surfaces-flatter Less flat Roots of molars Smaller + more divergent Larger+ less divergent
  • 17.
    (8-12m) 8 10 18 1424 6 (6-8m) 12 (12-14 m) 18 (18-20m) 14 24 (20-24m) Upper Lower Medial Lateral
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
    Mixed Dentition Age= (No:of permanent teeth – 5) * 4 Between the age of 6-11 years
  • 22.
    Successional & Superaddedteeth • Successional- those permanent teeth that replace other teeth • Super added- those added to the existing set of teeth, do not replace any teeth ( eruption increases the number of teeth )
  • 23.
    Gustafson’s Method •>21 yearsold • Physiological changes of age in dental tissues •6 characteristics
  • 24.
    • (1) Attrition-due to wear and tear from mastication • (2) Periodontosis - regression of the gums • (3) Secondary dentin – develop from the walls within the cavity • (4) Cementum apposition- secondary cementum incremental lines • (5) Root Resorption- starts at the apex • (6) Root Transparency- >30 years – canals in the dentine (deposition)
  • 25.
    Take the sumof scores formula AGE
  • 26.
  • 28.
  • 29.
    6 m IU 7m IU 9 m IU 60 Yrs 40 Yrs STERNUM
  • 30.
  • 31.
    head greater lesser tuberosity 1 Yr 3 Yr 5Yr 6 Yr (16-18Yr) capitulum trochlea Lateral epicondyle 13 Yr 11 Yr 2 Yr 14Yr (14-17Yr) Medial epicondyle 8 Yr
  • 32.
    Upper end -radius Lowerend -radius 6 Yr 2 Yr 6 Yr 10 Yr Upper end -ulna Lower end -ulna RADIUS AND ULNA (14-17Yr) (14-18Yr)
  • 33.
  • 34.
    14 yr (18yr) (11-14 yr) (7-8 yr) 16 yr (19 yr-F) (21 yr -M) PELVIS Triradiate cartliage Ilia crest Ischial tuberosity Ischiopubic ramus
  • 36.
    4-5 m IU 6-7m IU I II III IV V 8m IU (14 Yr) (20-25) Yr SACRUM
  • 37.
    Head Lower end offemur 1 yr 4 yr 11 yr 9 m IU (15 yr) (14- 17 yr) (14- 17 yr) (14- 17 yr) FEMUR Greater trochanter Lesser trochanter
  • 38.
    Upper end -Tibia Lowerend -Tibia Just after birth (14-17 yr) 2 yr (14-17 yr) 4 yr Upper end -Fibula Lower end -Fibula TIBIA AND FIBULA
  • 39.
    (14-17 Yr) TARSAL BONES Calcaneum 5m IU Talus 7 m IU Cuboid 9 m IU
  • 40.
  • 41.
    Case • A schoolstudent has won long jump in district level in the sub-junior category (sub-junior << 14 ) • Allegations came that she was above 16 years ????
  • 43.
  • 44.
  • 45.
  • 46.
    Rule of Hasse •First 5 months of IU life  Crown-heel length=square of the months of gestation • After that Age in lunar months * 5
  • 47.
    1st month/ 4weeks • I cm in length • 2.5 g grey coloured oval mass= pigeons egg • attached to the chorion with a very short cord • limb buds nodules
  • 49.
    2nd month/ 8weeks • 4 cm • Sex is indistinct • Webbed hands and feet P
  • 50.
    3rd month/12 weeks •9 cm long • Eyes are closed, pupillary memb++ • Sex – rarely indistinguishable
  • 51.
    4th month/ 16weeks • 13 to 16 cm long • Sex distinguishable • Convolutions of brain+ • Breast buds seen as dots 1/4th
  • 52.
    5th month/20 weeks •25 cm length • Vernix caseosa ++ • Light hair in the head • Lanugo on the body
  • 55.
    6th month/24 weeks •30 cm length • Wrinkled appearance • Eyebrows, eyelashes+ • Testicles –close to kidneys
  • 56.
    7th month/ 28weeks • Length:35 cm • Thick finger nails( not reaching the tip) • Eyelids partly open. • Testes- ext inguinal ring • Caecum in RIF+ • Period of viability
  • 57.
    8th month/32 weeks •Length 40 cm • Lanugo disappears from the face, • Scalp hair thickens-1.5 cm length • Nails have reached the tips • Left testis descended
  • 58.
    9th month/36 weeks •45 - 47 cm • Lanugo hair has complete disappeared • Vernix caseosa at the flexures of joints
  • 59.
    10th month/40 weeks •Full term • Lanugo – absent except in shoulders • Nails – project beyond, toenails reach tip • Umbilicus-central part between xiphoid and pubis • Rectum : Dark brown meconium +
  • 60.
    Medicolegal Importance ofAge • 3 months First trimester- one doctor is enough for MTP • 4 months Quickening – quick unborn child Culpable Homicide • > 5 months- illegal MTP • 7 months period of viability • 1 year  Infant ( Infanticide)
  • 61.
    • 5 years< 5 years in the custody of the mother • (The Hindu minority and guardianship) • 7 years Criminal responsibility “ any act done by a child less than 7 years is not an offence (s 82 IPC)” 7-12 years: if he proves he did not attain such understanding-not punishable Exception: 5 years Railway act : child above 5 years should be held responsible for wrecking a train
  • 63.
    • 10 years •Child < 10 years - kidnapped/ abducted punishment 10years  property is stolen Kidnapping 16 years (males) from local guardianship Kidnapping 18 years (females) from local guardianship Kidnapping 21 years female- imported for illicit intercourse Kidnapping
  • 64.
    Kidnapping Abduction Even withwill by illegal means By decietfulness
  • 65.
    • 12 years •Age of consent ( S 89 IPC) • Age of consent for general physical examination • No consent is valid if age <12 years( S 90 IPC) • < 12 years- gives his evidence in the court of Law without oath
  • 66.
    •14 years <14years not allowed to work in any factory cannot be employed for any work •16 years : child- < 16 years (old juvenile act) Now > 18 years ( JJA,2000 + POCSO) 16-18 years  rape / murder tried as adults No death penalty/life term imprisonment
  • 67.
    •18 years: • Ageof majority • Right to vote • Marriage for girls • Consent for undergoing surgery • Consent for sexual Intercourse • Consent for acts intended to cause grievous hurt (boxing, fencing) • Age for donating organs
  • 68.
    • 21 years •Age for marriage in adult males • 60 years • Senior Citizen- males • (females- 56/58 years)
  • 69.
    Discussion • A childof age 6 years gave a rat poison ( offering it as a sweet) to his grandmother and the grandmother dies… will he be responsible????
  • 70.
    • A maleof 21 years marries a female of 15 years … is it offence????
  • 71.
    • A childof 12 years is diagnosed with umbilical hernia. •Should we take a consent???? •From whom????
  • 72.
    AGE in TheLIVING • General development • Teeth Eruption • Radiological Any disparity Radiological Age in The Dead • External features • Teeth- Gustafson’s • Ossification- reddish brown centre surrounded by bluish white cartilage • Fusion- sutures+ sternum • Others-Rib phase analysis • Pubic symphysis
  • 73.
    Important questions • Temporaryand permanent teeth • Successional and superadded teeth • Gustafson’s technique • Age estimation in the living/dead • MLI of age • Practical  X-rays
  • 74.