1) The current policy and funding mechanisms in the UK broadly result in effective delivery of ecosystem services from peatlands, but there is room for improvement. 2) Moving towards more place-based payments for ecosystem services schemes could better coordinate delivery of multiple ecosystem services at relevant scales. This involves combining public and private funding schemes. 3) Key barriers include limited markets and demand for private payment schemes, uncertainty around metrics and verification, and obstacles to collaboration across different land ownerships. Overcoming these barriers could help optimize ecosystem service delivery from peatlands in the UK.