Option D.1
12 IB Biology 2011
   Miss Werba
• The conditions of pre-biotic Earth
    • Experiments of Miller and Urey
    • Hypothesis regarding first catalysts
    • Theory that regarding RNA and replication
    • Possible origin of membranes and prokaryotic
      cells
    • Endosymbiotic theory for the origin
      of eukaryotes
MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                            2
D.1.1




    • There are processes that were needed for the
      spontaneous generation of life on Earth:
          – Non-living synthesis of simple organic molecules
          – Assembly of these molecules into polymers
          – Inheritance possible once self-replicating
            molecules originated
          – Packaging of these molecules into membranes


MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                      4
D.1.1




        6
D.1.1
D.1.3
D.1.4




    • 15 billion years after the “Big Bang”, the planets
      began to form.
    • The atmosphere on Earth at this time probably
      contained a variety of inorganic molecules:
          –    Water vapour
          –    Methane
          –    Ammonia
          –    Hydrogen
          –    Carbon dioxide

MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                  7
D.1.1
D.1.3
D.1.4




    • The energy for forming the organic molecules was
      provided by:
          – frequent thunder storms and lightning strikes
          – volcanic activity
          – meteorite bombardment
          – high temperatures due to
            greenhouse gases
          – UV radiation
            (no ozone so was extreme)

MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                   8
D.1.1
D.1.3
D.1.4




    • These elements and inorganic molecules are
      presumed to have been sufficient for life to begin.
    • The organic molecules may have been generated on
      Earth or introduced from space.




MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                   9
D.1.1
D.1.3
D.1.4




    • The hypothesis that life on Earth originated by
      introduction of complex organic chemicals or even
      bacteria via comets is called panspermia.
    • A shower of comets about
      4 thousand million years ago
      could have introduced complex
      organic molecules and water to
      the Earth and initiated chemical
      evolution.

MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                 10
D.1.1




    • There was little to no oxygen in the atmosphere at
      the time, as any oxygen was absorbed by rocks.
    • This meant that there was no oxygen to steal
      electrons away from other atoms (ie. oxidise them).
    • This would have resulted in a ‘reducing atmosphere’
      which would have made the joining of simple
      molecules to form more complex ones more likely.



MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                   12
D.1.1




    • Experiments have shown that it is possible to form
      organic molecules in a reducing atmosphere
    • However it is very difficult to do when there is
      oxygen in the atmosphere
    • This polymerisation process would allow the larger
      chemicals needed by cells to form.




MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                  13
D.1.1




    • How were polymers — the basis of life itself —
      assembled????
    • In solution, hydrolysis of a growing polymer would
      soon limit the size it could reach.
    • This has led to a theory that early polymers were
      assembled on solid, mineral surfaces that protected
      them from degradation.
    • In lab experiments they have been synthesized on
      clay.
MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                   14
D.1.1
D.1.5




    • In current cells, DNA can replicate but it needs the
      help of enzymes (proteins) to do this.
    • The proteins are assembled based on information
      carried on the DNA and transcribed into RNA.

    • So what came first.....
      the DNA to make proteins or
      the proteins to make the DNA?!?!?!?!?

MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                    16
D.1.1
D.1.5




    • The synthesis of DNA and RNA requires proteins.
    • So:
       – proteins cannot be made without nucleic acids
         and
       – nucleic acids cannot be made without proteins

    • Wrong!


MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                17
D.1.1
D.1.5




    • The synthesis of nucleotides and their bases could
      have happened easily.
    • Once this had occurred, it is not hard to see how a
      single strand of RNA could have formed.
    • Once this had occurred, complementary base pairing
      could have resulted in the non-enzymatic replication
      of RNA.



MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                    18
D.1.1
D.1.5




                            SOURCE: Purcell, D. (2009)



MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                            19
D.1.1
D.1.5




    • Self-replicating molecules are molecules that are
      able to undergo replication.
    • They are able to act as a template for copies of
      themselves to be made.
    • The only biological molecules capable of self-
      replication are DNA & RNA.
    • Unlike DNA, RNA sequences are capable of self-
      replication: it can catalyse its formation from
      nucleotides in the absence of proteins.
MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                 20
D.1.1
D.1.5




                            SOURCE: Purcell, D. (2009)



MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                         21
D.1.1
D.1.5




    • The discovery that certain RNA molecules have
      enzymatic activity provides a possible solution.
    • These RNA molecules — called ribozymes—
      incorporate both the features required of life:
          – storage of information
          – the ability to act as catalysts
    • Active ribozymes can be easily assembled from
      shorter olignonucleotides (strands of nucleotides).

MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                   22
D.1.1
D.1.5




    • Ribozymes have been synthesized in the laboratory
      and can catalyze exact complements of themselves.

    • The ribozyme serves as both:
       – the template on which short lengths of RNA
         ("oligonucleotides“) are assembled, following the
         rules of base pairing and
       – the catalyst for covalently linking these
         oligonucleotides.

MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                    23
D.1.1
D.1.5




                            SOURCE: Purcell, D. (2009)




MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                        24
D.1.1
D.1.5




    • Evidence for this ideas is provided by the fact that
      many of the cofactors that play so many roles in life
      are based on ribose:
                               ATP
                               NAD
                               FAD
                          coenzyme A
                           cyclic AMP
                               GTP
MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                     25
D.1.1
D.1.6




    • The development of the lipid bilayer was imitated in
      the laboratory by Fox and his co-workers
    • They heated amino acids without water and
      produced long protein chains
    • When water was added and
      the mixture cooled, small
      stable microspheres or
      coacervates were formed

MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                    27
D.1.1
D.1.6




    • The coacervates seemed to be able to accumulate
      certain compounds inside them so that they became
      more concentrated than outside
    • They also attracted lipids and
      formed a lipid-protein layer
      around them




MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                 28
D.1.1
D.1.6




    • If we assume that the coacervates also combined
      with self-replicating molecules such as RNA, we are
      looking at a very primitive organism...
    • This is thought to have happened about 3.8 billion
      years ago




MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                   29
D.1.1
D.1.6




                            SOURCE: Purcell, D. (2009)




MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                        30
D.1.1
D.1.6




                            SOURCE: Purcell, D. (2009)




MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                        31
D.1.1
D.1.6




    • The aggregates or coacervates are also known as
      protobionts or proto cells.
    • The most successful liposomes (protobiont in
      presence of lipids) at surviving would have passed on
      their characteristics and developed into early
      prokaryotes!




MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                     32
D.1.1
D.1.6




                            SOURCE: McFadden, G. (2009)
MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                 33
D.1.1
D.1.6




                            SOURCE: McFadden, G. (2009)
MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                 34
D.1.2




    • Stanley Miller and Harold Urey worked on trying to
      confirm some of these ideas regarding pre-biotic
      Earth.
    • In 1953, Miller set up an apparatus to simulate
      conditions on the early Earth.
    • The apparatus contained a warmed flask of water
      simulating the primeval sea and an atmosphere of
      water, hydrogen gas, CH4 (methane), and NH3
      (ammonia).
MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                  36
D.1.2




        37
D.1.2




    • Sparks were discharged in the synthetic atmosphere
      to mimic lightning.
    • Water was boiled, while a condenser cooled the
      atmosphere, raining water and any dissolved
      compounds back to the miniature sea.
    • The simulated environment produced many types of
      amino acids and other organic molecules leading
      them to conclude the pre-biotic synthesis of organic
      molecules was possible.
MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                    38
D.1.2




MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY   39
D.1.2




    • This spontaneous generation of organic molecules
      was supported by investigation of meteorites.

    • In 1970, a meteorite was found
      to contain 7 different amino
      acids, 2 of which are not found
      in living things on Earth.



MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                40
D.1.7




MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY   SOURCE: McFadden, G. (2009)   42
D.1.7




                            SOURCE: McFadden, G. (2009)
MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                 43
D.1.7




    • Prokaryotes had the planet to themselves for about 2
      billion years!
    • Oxygen began to gradually accumulate in the
      atmosphere on Earth.
    • Bacteria evolved naturally to contain a form of
      chlorophyll, which then allowed a simple form of
      photosynthesis to occur.



MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                    44
D.1.7




    • This caused an explosive rise in the levels of
      atmospheric oxygen known as the oxygen
      catastrophe.
    • This had an irreversible effect on the subsequent
      evolution of life.
    • The remaining chemicals in the “chemical soup” in
      the oceans were broken down into carbon dioxide
      and oxidised sediments.

MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                 45
D.1.7




    • In addition, a layer of ozone (O3) began to form in
      the upper atmosphere.
    • This protected the planet
      from UV radiation from
      the Sun and blocked the
      production of new organic
      chemicals in the
      “chemical soup”.


MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                   46
D.1.8




                            SOURCE: McFadden, G. (2009)



MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                 48
D.1.8




                            SOURCE: McFadden, G. (2009)
MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                 49
D.1.8




                            SOURCE: McFadden, G. (2009)
MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                 50
D.1.8




    • Grypania is ~2mm in diameter, so it is too big to be a
      prokaryotic cell.
    • Tappania is definitely too big and complicated to be
      prokaryotic.
    • Bangiomorpha had 3D structure! Definitely too
      complicated to be prokaryotic!




MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                      51
D.1.8




    • The oldest fossils of eukaryotic cells have been found
      to be approximately 1.5 billion years old.
    • The endosymbiotic theory from Lyn Margulis (1967)
      tries to explain how eukaryotic cells may have
      evolved.
    • Endosymbiosis: the condition in which one organism
      lives inside the cell of another organism
    • Both cells benefit from this - the cells no longer can
      live separately from each other
MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                      52
D.1.8




MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY   53
D.1.8




    • Mitochondria and chloroplasts were once free living
      bacteria cells:
          – Mitochondria aerobic bacteria
          – Chloroplasts photosynthetic bacteria
    • These cells were “swallowed up” by other cells by
      endocytosis  cells engulfed but not eaten



MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                   54
D.1.8




MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY   55
D.1.8




MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY   56
D.1.8




    • Mitochondria:
      – additional energy (aerobic respiration) and
        receives protection

    • Chloroplast:
       – provide food by photosynthesis and receives
         protection



MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                              57
D.1.8




    • Prokaryotes are similar to mitochondria and
      chloroplasts:
       – Similar size
       – Similar ribosomes (70S)
       – Contain DNA that is different from the nucleus
       – Surrounded by double membrane
       – Formation of new organelles resembles binary
         fission

MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                 58
D.1.8




    • The four eukaryotic kingdoms are:
       – Protoctista
       – Fungi
       – Plantae
       – Animalia
    • Eukaryotic cells have some advantages over
      prokaryotic cells so the early eukaryotes survived
      and proliferated
    • Hence the wide diversity of species we know today!
MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY                                  59

D.1 origin-of-life-on-earth

  • 1.
    Option D.1 12 IBBiology 2011 Miss Werba
  • 2.
    • The conditionsof pre-biotic Earth • Experiments of Miller and Urey • Hypothesis regarding first catalysts • Theory that regarding RNA and replication • Possible origin of membranes and prokaryotic cells • Endosymbiotic theory for the origin of eukaryotes MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 2
  • 4.
    D.1.1 • There are processes that were needed for the spontaneous generation of life on Earth: – Non-living synthesis of simple organic molecules – Assembly of these molecules into polymers – Inheritance possible once self-replicating molecules originated – Packaging of these molecules into membranes MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 4
  • 6.
  • 7.
    D.1.1 D.1.3 D.1.4 • 15 billion years after the “Big Bang”, the planets began to form. • The atmosphere on Earth at this time probably contained a variety of inorganic molecules: – Water vapour – Methane – Ammonia – Hydrogen – Carbon dioxide MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 7
  • 8.
    D.1.1 D.1.3 D.1.4 • The energy for forming the organic molecules was provided by: – frequent thunder storms and lightning strikes – volcanic activity – meteorite bombardment – high temperatures due to greenhouse gases – UV radiation (no ozone so was extreme) MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 8
  • 9.
    D.1.1 D.1.3 D.1.4 • These elements and inorganic molecules are presumed to have been sufficient for life to begin. • The organic molecules may have been generated on Earth or introduced from space. MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 9
  • 10.
    D.1.1 D.1.3 D.1.4 • The hypothesis that life on Earth originated by introduction of complex organic chemicals or even bacteria via comets is called panspermia. • A shower of comets about 4 thousand million years ago could have introduced complex organic molecules and water to the Earth and initiated chemical evolution. MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 10
  • 12.
    D.1.1 • There was little to no oxygen in the atmosphere at the time, as any oxygen was absorbed by rocks. • This meant that there was no oxygen to steal electrons away from other atoms (ie. oxidise them). • This would have resulted in a ‘reducing atmosphere’ which would have made the joining of simple molecules to form more complex ones more likely. MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 12
  • 13.
    D.1.1 • Experiments have shown that it is possible to form organic molecules in a reducing atmosphere • However it is very difficult to do when there is oxygen in the atmosphere • This polymerisation process would allow the larger chemicals needed by cells to form. MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 13
  • 14.
    D.1.1 • How were polymers — the basis of life itself — assembled???? • In solution, hydrolysis of a growing polymer would soon limit the size it could reach. • This has led to a theory that early polymers were assembled on solid, mineral surfaces that protected them from degradation. • In lab experiments they have been synthesized on clay. MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 14
  • 16.
    D.1.1 D.1.5 • In current cells, DNA can replicate but it needs the help of enzymes (proteins) to do this. • The proteins are assembled based on information carried on the DNA and transcribed into RNA. • So what came first..... the DNA to make proteins or the proteins to make the DNA?!?!?!?!? MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 16
  • 17.
    D.1.1 D.1.5 • The synthesis of DNA and RNA requires proteins. • So: – proteins cannot be made without nucleic acids and – nucleic acids cannot be made without proteins • Wrong! MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 17
  • 18.
    D.1.1 D.1.5 • The synthesis of nucleotides and their bases could have happened easily. • Once this had occurred, it is not hard to see how a single strand of RNA could have formed. • Once this had occurred, complementary base pairing could have resulted in the non-enzymatic replication of RNA. MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 18
  • 19.
    D.1.1 D.1.5 SOURCE: Purcell, D. (2009) MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 19
  • 20.
    D.1.1 D.1.5 • Self-replicating molecules are molecules that are able to undergo replication. • They are able to act as a template for copies of themselves to be made. • The only biological molecules capable of self- replication are DNA & RNA. • Unlike DNA, RNA sequences are capable of self- replication: it can catalyse its formation from nucleotides in the absence of proteins. MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 20
  • 21.
    D.1.1 D.1.5 SOURCE: Purcell, D. (2009) MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 21
  • 22.
    D.1.1 D.1.5 • The discovery that certain RNA molecules have enzymatic activity provides a possible solution. • These RNA molecules — called ribozymes— incorporate both the features required of life: – storage of information – the ability to act as catalysts • Active ribozymes can be easily assembled from shorter olignonucleotides (strands of nucleotides). MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 22
  • 23.
    D.1.1 D.1.5 • Ribozymes have been synthesized in the laboratory and can catalyze exact complements of themselves. • The ribozyme serves as both: – the template on which short lengths of RNA ("oligonucleotides“) are assembled, following the rules of base pairing and – the catalyst for covalently linking these oligonucleotides. MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 23
  • 24.
    D.1.1 D.1.5 SOURCE: Purcell, D. (2009) MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 24
  • 25.
    D.1.1 D.1.5 • Evidence for this ideas is provided by the fact that many of the cofactors that play so many roles in life are based on ribose: ATP NAD FAD coenzyme A cyclic AMP GTP MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 25
  • 27.
    D.1.1 D.1.6 • The development of the lipid bilayer was imitated in the laboratory by Fox and his co-workers • They heated amino acids without water and produced long protein chains • When water was added and the mixture cooled, small stable microspheres or coacervates were formed MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 27
  • 28.
    D.1.1 D.1.6 • The coacervates seemed to be able to accumulate certain compounds inside them so that they became more concentrated than outside • They also attracted lipids and formed a lipid-protein layer around them MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 28
  • 29.
    D.1.1 D.1.6 • If we assume that the coacervates also combined with self-replicating molecules such as RNA, we are looking at a very primitive organism... • This is thought to have happened about 3.8 billion years ago MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 29
  • 30.
    D.1.1 D.1.6 SOURCE: Purcell, D. (2009) MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 30
  • 31.
    D.1.1 D.1.6 SOURCE: Purcell, D. (2009) MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 31
  • 32.
    D.1.1 D.1.6 • The aggregates or coacervates are also known as protobionts or proto cells. • The most successful liposomes (protobiont in presence of lipids) at surviving would have passed on their characteristics and developed into early prokaryotes! MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 32
  • 33.
    D.1.1 D.1.6 SOURCE: McFadden, G. (2009) MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 33
  • 34.
    D.1.1 D.1.6 SOURCE: McFadden, G. (2009) MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 34
  • 36.
    D.1.2 • Stanley Miller and Harold Urey worked on trying to confirm some of these ideas regarding pre-biotic Earth. • In 1953, Miller set up an apparatus to simulate conditions on the early Earth. • The apparatus contained a warmed flask of water simulating the primeval sea and an atmosphere of water, hydrogen gas, CH4 (methane), and NH3 (ammonia). MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 36
  • 37.
  • 38.
    D.1.2 • Sparks were discharged in the synthetic atmosphere to mimic lightning. • Water was boiled, while a condenser cooled the atmosphere, raining water and any dissolved compounds back to the miniature sea. • The simulated environment produced many types of amino acids and other organic molecules leading them to conclude the pre-biotic synthesis of organic molecules was possible. MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 38
  • 39.
    D.1.2 MISS J WERBA– IB BIOLOGY 39
  • 40.
    D.1.2 • This spontaneous generation of organic molecules was supported by investigation of meteorites. • In 1970, a meteorite was found to contain 7 different amino acids, 2 of which are not found in living things on Earth. MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 40
  • 42.
    D.1.7 MISS J WERBA– IB BIOLOGY SOURCE: McFadden, G. (2009) 42
  • 43.
    D.1.7 SOURCE: McFadden, G. (2009) MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 43
  • 44.
    D.1.7 • Prokaryotes had the planet to themselves for about 2 billion years! • Oxygen began to gradually accumulate in the atmosphere on Earth. • Bacteria evolved naturally to contain a form of chlorophyll, which then allowed a simple form of photosynthesis to occur. MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 44
  • 45.
    D.1.7 • This caused an explosive rise in the levels of atmospheric oxygen known as the oxygen catastrophe. • This had an irreversible effect on the subsequent evolution of life. • The remaining chemicals in the “chemical soup” in the oceans were broken down into carbon dioxide and oxidised sediments. MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 45
  • 46.
    D.1.7 • In addition, a layer of ozone (O3) began to form in the upper atmosphere. • This protected the planet from UV radiation from the Sun and blocked the production of new organic chemicals in the “chemical soup”. MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 46
  • 48.
    D.1.8 SOURCE: McFadden, G. (2009) MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 48
  • 49.
    D.1.8 SOURCE: McFadden, G. (2009) MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 49
  • 50.
    D.1.8 SOURCE: McFadden, G. (2009) MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 50
  • 51.
    D.1.8 • Grypania is ~2mm in diameter, so it is too big to be a prokaryotic cell. • Tappania is definitely too big and complicated to be prokaryotic. • Bangiomorpha had 3D structure! Definitely too complicated to be prokaryotic! MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 51
  • 52.
    D.1.8 • The oldest fossils of eukaryotic cells have been found to be approximately 1.5 billion years old. • The endosymbiotic theory from Lyn Margulis (1967) tries to explain how eukaryotic cells may have evolved. • Endosymbiosis: the condition in which one organism lives inside the cell of another organism • Both cells benefit from this - the cells no longer can live separately from each other MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 52
  • 53.
    D.1.8 MISS J WERBA– IB BIOLOGY 53
  • 54.
    D.1.8 • Mitochondria and chloroplasts were once free living bacteria cells: – Mitochondria aerobic bacteria – Chloroplasts photosynthetic bacteria • These cells were “swallowed up” by other cells by endocytosis  cells engulfed but not eaten MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 54
  • 55.
    D.1.8 MISS J WERBA– IB BIOLOGY 55
  • 56.
    D.1.8 MISS J WERBA– IB BIOLOGY 56
  • 57.
    D.1.8 • Mitochondria: – additional energy (aerobic respiration) and receives protection • Chloroplast: – provide food by photosynthesis and receives protection MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 57
  • 58.
    D.1.8 • Prokaryotes are similar to mitochondria and chloroplasts: – Similar size – Similar ribosomes (70S) – Contain DNA that is different from the nucleus – Surrounded by double membrane – Formation of new organelles resembles binary fission MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 58
  • 59.
    D.1.8 • The four eukaryotic kingdoms are: – Protoctista – Fungi – Plantae – Animalia • Eukaryotic cells have some advantages over prokaryotic cells so the early eukaryotes survived and proliferated • Hence the wide diversity of species we know today! MISS J WERBA – IB BIOLOGY 59