Redefining openness: a vision for Open PracticesGráinne Conole,The Open University, UKKeynote, EFQUEL Conference, Lisbon, 9th September 2010
OrientationFocusSocial inclusionOpen, social and participatorymediaA vision of openness – Open PracticesDesigning and using OEROlnetOPALOpen Educational Resource Practices (OEP)DefinitionDerivationTheOPAL OEP quality cubeInnovationQuality
Open, social and participatory mediaNew tools/practices are leading to new forms of learning and teachingSharingMedia sharingWeb 2.0CommunicatingBlogs & wikisNetworkingSocial networkingInteractingVirtual worldsShift from:Web 1.0 – content repository and static informationWeb 2.0 – user generated content and social mediation
A typology of new technologies(Conole and Alevizou, 2010), Review of Web 2.0 tools in Higher Educationhttp://cloudworks.ac.uk/cloudscape/view/1895
Redefining openness…DesignCourses design & shared openlyDeliveryUse of free tools & resourcesWhat is/will be the impact of an increasingly open technologically mediated learning environment in learning and teaching?Peer critiquingSharingRepurposingOpen practicesNetworkingInquiryCollectiveintelligenceEvaluationCritical reflectionResearchSharing of research dataAlso see Alex Couros, Edmedia, 2010
Digital skills (Jenkins, et al., 2008)PlayPerformanceVisualisationAppropriationNegotiationMulti-taskingSimulationNetworkingDistributed cognitionCollective intelligenceTransmedia navigationJudgment
Open Educational Resources (OER)Basic definitionThe open provision of educational resources, enabled by information and communication technologies, for consultation, use and adaptation by a community of users for non-commercial purposes (UNESCO 2002)Broader definitionLearning resourcesCourseware, content modules, learning objects, learner support & assessment tools, online learning communitiesResources to support teachersTools for teachers and support materials to enable them to create, adapt and use OER; training materials for teachersResources to assure the quality of education and educational practices (UNESCO 2004)
Pedagogically rich
Level of granularity‘Atomistic’: based around learning objects (Merlot)‘Holistic: aligned to course structures (MIT)FormatSimple, primarily text-basedRich multi-faceted multimediaPedagogyRelatively neutralEmbeddedOER models
A vision of transformationBeyond content – focus on activity and useLearners as self-directed and autonomousMore of a focus on sharing, refinement, iteration, critical reflectionOER as a potential catalyst to transforming educational practiceImprovements in social inclusion, quality and innovation
The reality gapParadoxesTechnologies not fully exploitedLittle evidence of use of OERPredominance of ‘old practices’Media sharingBlogs & wikisReasonsTechnical, pedagogical, organisational…“Lack of time, research vs. teaching, lack of skills, no rewards, no support….”Solutions?Models and frameworksLearning designPedagogical patternsOpen Educational ResourcesVirtual worlds &online gamesSocial networking
Exploring/applying “openness”DesignCourses design & shared openlyDeliveryUse of free tools & resourcesOpenEvaluationCritical reflectionResearchSharing of research data
Open DesignOpen DeliveryOpen ResearchX-DeliaOpen Evaluation
CloudworksA space for sharing and discussing learning and teaching ideasApplication of web 2.0 practiceExamples for teachers & learners to share/discussA space for collaboration & communication Helps develop skills needed for engaging with new technologies’
TitleAuthorCoreTagsLocationDiscussionsImprovements
Olnet: Open Learning networkNetworkFrom producing open resources to use of open resourcesBuild capacity
Find evidence
Refine the issuesResearchFellowshipsConole, McAndrew & Demtriadis, Forthcoming
Learning analytics: gather & representing dataConference, Canada, February 2011
Making reuse possibleConole, McAndrew & Demtriadis, Forthcoming
Explicit design
Design, use, reuseDesignDesignUsesDepositsRepurposes & depositsUsesOEROERTeacher ALearner ALearner BTeacher BCreatesChoosesDepositsQuiz + beginners routeQuiz + advanced route
From resources to practices
The OPAL vision22Focus on the practice around OER rather than the resourcesBetter understanding will lead to improvements in the quality of OER and more innovationOpen Educational Resource PracticeOEP constitute the range of practices around the creation, use and management of OER with the intent to improve quality and innovate education.
Abstracting dimensions of PracticeApproach60+ case studies of OER collectedDimensions of OEP derivedDerivation of the OEP cube modelValidationSpotlight on OER on CloudworksEDEN workshopOER activity on CloudworksOngoing online consultation processhttp://cloudworks.ac.uk/cloudscape/view/2105
Validation: OER activity on Cloudworks27 Cloudscapes and 13 Clouds evaluatedKinds of activitiesReviews, events, debates, otherIntentional, practical, socialTypes of CloudsInstructional, informational, archival Notes, resource aggregator, project descriptions, discussion & debate spaces, interviewsAlevizou et al. 2010
Emergent issues from OER researchMotivations for sharing and incentives for participation Financial sustainability and licensing jurisdictions OER tracking, usage patterns and users motivations Quality and credentialsEffectiveness metrics Types of research and dissemination of empirical results Linking research with policy and practice
The OEP cube modelTHE DIMENSION: What?Strategies and PoliciesBarriers and Success FactorsTools and Tool PracticesSkills Development and SupportTHE CONTEXT: Where?Macro level  (society)Meso level  (organisation)Micro level  (individuals)MATURITY: How well is it established?Initial (not yet started)ManagedDefinedOptimizing (embedded / advanced)CONTEXTMATURITYDIMENSION26
Refining the dimension27QA modelsPartnership ModelsStrategies & PoliciesBusiness ModelsCONTEXTSustainability StrategiesBarriersBarriers and Success FactorsSuccess FactorsMATURITYToolsDIMENSIONTools & tool practicesTool Practices12 skills of evolving digital literacyHenry JenkinsCYBERLEARNING REPORTDigital LiteracySkills Development & SupportSupport structures and  processes
Maturity ViewINITIAL (not yet started): Process unpredictable, poorly controlled and reactiveMANAGED: Process characterized for projects and is often reactive.DEFINED: Process characterized for the organisation and is proactive (Projects tailor their process from the organisation’s standard)OPTIMIZING (embedded / advanced): Process is measured and controlled, the focus on process improvement28CONTEXTMATURITYDIMENSION
The cube model291AX1BX1AX1BX1BX1BX1AY1BXLevels1BY1BX1BY3AXMacro-level: SocietalMeso-level: OrganisationMicro-level: Individual2AX1BY3BX2BX3CX2AX2BX3DX2BX2BX2AY2BX2BY2BX2BY2AX3AX2BY2BX3BX2CX3AX3BX2DX3BX3BX3AY3BX3BY3BX3BY1AX3BY1BXStrategies & policiesBarriers & successfactorsTools & toolpracticesSkillsDev &Support1CX1DXLevel of maturityOptimizingDefinedManagedInitialDimensionsOER embedded in strategyInstitutional OER repositoryAdapted from diagram by T. Koskinen
Uses and benefitsThree usesBenchmarkingGuidanceReflection and comparisonBenefitsGuides users in understanding how to think about the key issues.Flexible enough to cover the multiple stakeholdersSub-cubes provide practical illustrative examplesUseful as a mechanism for institutions to self-benchmark30
Mapping the case studies31
Final thoughtsA vision of OEP for inclusion, innovation & qualityLearning and the context of learning have changedWe need new approaches to learning and teachingHow can we harness increasingly sophisticated tools and OERs?How can we support innovation in the use and reuse of OER?Will openness enable or restrict social inclusion?What are the quality implications in an increasingly open context?How can we ensure research better informs policy and practice?
SourcesMash ups http://www.flickr.com/photos/richardellard/4524139966/Molecule http://www.flickr.com/photos/8272941@N07/498827420/Periodic table http://www.flickr.com/photos/chemheritage/3984920162/Music sheet http://www.flickr.com/photos/anyaka/21848267/One world http://www.flickr.com/photos/psd/2731067095/World of warcraft http://www.flickr.com/photos/shardsofblue/3981216281/Questionmarkhttp://www.flickr.com/photos/crystaljingsr/3914729343/http://suifaijohnmak.files.wordpress.com/2009/11/communication-sep08_leskovec_tdef_page_03_480.jpgYin-Yang image  http://learn4kicks.files.wordpress.com/2009/09/yinyangconceptmap.gifImperial collage second life island http://knowledgecast.wordpress.com/2009/07/10/icl-tour2/Personal Inquiry project http://www.pi-project.ac.uk/resources/E-Portfolios http://www.jiscinfonet.ac.uk/infokits/e-portfolios  

Conole lisbon

  • 1.
    Redefining openness: avision for Open PracticesGráinne Conole,The Open University, UKKeynote, EFQUEL Conference, Lisbon, 9th September 2010
  • 2.
    OrientationFocusSocial inclusionOpen, socialand participatorymediaA vision of openness – Open PracticesDesigning and using OEROlnetOPALOpen Educational Resource Practices (OEP)DefinitionDerivationTheOPAL OEP quality cubeInnovationQuality
  • 3.
    Open, social andparticipatory mediaNew tools/practices are leading to new forms of learning and teachingSharingMedia sharingWeb 2.0CommunicatingBlogs & wikisNetworkingSocial networkingInteractingVirtual worldsShift from:Web 1.0 – content repository and static informationWeb 2.0 – user generated content and social mediation
  • 4.
    A typology ofnew technologies(Conole and Alevizou, 2010), Review of Web 2.0 tools in Higher Educationhttp://cloudworks.ac.uk/cloudscape/view/1895
  • 5.
    Redefining openness…DesignCourses design& shared openlyDeliveryUse of free tools & resourcesWhat is/will be the impact of an increasingly open technologically mediated learning environment in learning and teaching?Peer critiquingSharingRepurposingOpen practicesNetworkingInquiryCollectiveintelligenceEvaluationCritical reflectionResearchSharing of research dataAlso see Alex Couros, Edmedia, 2010
  • 6.
    Digital skills (Jenkins,et al., 2008)PlayPerformanceVisualisationAppropriationNegotiationMulti-taskingSimulationNetworkingDistributed cognitionCollective intelligenceTransmedia navigationJudgment
  • 7.
    Open Educational Resources(OER)Basic definitionThe open provision of educational resources, enabled by information and communication technologies, for consultation, use and adaptation by a community of users for non-commercial purposes (UNESCO 2002)Broader definitionLearning resourcesCourseware, content modules, learning objects, learner support & assessment tools, online learning communitiesResources to support teachersTools for teachers and support materials to enable them to create, adapt and use OER; training materials for teachersResources to assure the quality of education and educational practices (UNESCO 2004)
  • 8.
  • 9.
    Level of granularity‘Atomistic’:based around learning objects (Merlot)‘Holistic: aligned to course structures (MIT)FormatSimple, primarily text-basedRich multi-faceted multimediaPedagogyRelatively neutralEmbeddedOER models
  • 10.
    A vision oftransformationBeyond content – focus on activity and useLearners as self-directed and autonomousMore of a focus on sharing, refinement, iteration, critical reflectionOER as a potential catalyst to transforming educational practiceImprovements in social inclusion, quality and innovation
  • 11.
    The reality gapParadoxesTechnologiesnot fully exploitedLittle evidence of use of OERPredominance of ‘old practices’Media sharingBlogs & wikisReasonsTechnical, pedagogical, organisational…“Lack of time, research vs. teaching, lack of skills, no rewards, no support….”Solutions?Models and frameworksLearning designPedagogical patternsOpen Educational ResourcesVirtual worlds &online gamesSocial networking
  • 12.
    Exploring/applying “openness”DesignCourses design& shared openlyDeliveryUse of free tools & resourcesOpenEvaluationCritical reflectionResearchSharing of research data
  • 13.
    Open DesignOpen DeliveryOpenResearchX-DeliaOpen Evaluation
  • 14.
    CloudworksA space forsharing and discussing learning and teaching ideasApplication of web 2.0 practiceExamples for teachers & learners to share/discussA space for collaboration & communication Helps develop skills needed for engaging with new technologies’
  • 15.
  • 16.
    Olnet: Open LearningnetworkNetworkFrom producing open resources to use of open resourcesBuild capacity
  • 17.
  • 18.
    Refine the issuesResearchFellowshipsConole,McAndrew & Demtriadis, Forthcoming
  • 19.
    Learning analytics: gather& representing dataConference, Canada, February 2011
  • 20.
    Making reuse possibleConole,McAndrew & Demtriadis, Forthcoming
  • 21.
  • 22.
    Design, use, reuseDesignDesignUsesDepositsRepurposes& depositsUsesOEROERTeacher ALearner ALearner BTeacher BCreatesChoosesDepositsQuiz + beginners routeQuiz + advanced route
  • 23.
  • 24.
    The OPAL vision22Focuson the practice around OER rather than the resourcesBetter understanding will lead to improvements in the quality of OER and more innovationOpen Educational Resource PracticeOEP constitute the range of practices around the creation, use and management of OER with the intent to improve quality and innovate education.
  • 25.
    Abstracting dimensions ofPracticeApproach60+ case studies of OER collectedDimensions of OEP derivedDerivation of the OEP cube modelValidationSpotlight on OER on CloudworksEDEN workshopOER activity on CloudworksOngoing online consultation processhttp://cloudworks.ac.uk/cloudscape/view/2105
  • 26.
    Validation: OER activityon Cloudworks27 Cloudscapes and 13 Clouds evaluatedKinds of activitiesReviews, events, debates, otherIntentional, practical, socialTypes of CloudsInstructional, informational, archival Notes, resource aggregator, project descriptions, discussion & debate spaces, interviewsAlevizou et al. 2010
  • 27.
    Emergent issues fromOER researchMotivations for sharing and incentives for participation Financial sustainability and licensing jurisdictions OER tracking, usage patterns and users motivations Quality and credentialsEffectiveness metrics Types of research and dissemination of empirical results Linking research with policy and practice
  • 28.
    The OEP cubemodelTHE DIMENSION: What?Strategies and PoliciesBarriers and Success FactorsTools and Tool PracticesSkills Development and SupportTHE CONTEXT: Where?Macro level (society)Meso level (organisation)Micro level (individuals)MATURITY: How well is it established?Initial (not yet started)ManagedDefinedOptimizing (embedded / advanced)CONTEXTMATURITYDIMENSION26
  • 29.
    Refining the dimension27QAmodelsPartnership ModelsStrategies & PoliciesBusiness ModelsCONTEXTSustainability StrategiesBarriersBarriers and Success FactorsSuccess FactorsMATURITYToolsDIMENSIONTools & tool practicesTool Practices12 skills of evolving digital literacyHenry JenkinsCYBERLEARNING REPORTDigital LiteracySkills Development & SupportSupport structures and processes
  • 30.
    Maturity ViewINITIAL (notyet started): Process unpredictable, poorly controlled and reactiveMANAGED: Process characterized for projects and is often reactive.DEFINED: Process characterized for the organisation and is proactive (Projects tailor their process from the organisation’s standard)OPTIMIZING (embedded / advanced): Process is measured and controlled, the focus on process improvement28CONTEXTMATURITYDIMENSION
  • 31.
    The cube model291AX1BX1AX1BX1BX1BX1AY1BXLevels1BY1BX1BY3AXMacro-level:SocietalMeso-level: OrganisationMicro-level: Individual2AX1BY3BX2BX3CX2AX2BX3DX2BX2BX2AY2BX2BY2BX2BY2AX3AX2BY2BX3BX2CX3AX3BX2DX3BX3BX3AY3BX3BY3BX3BY1AX3BY1BXStrategies & policiesBarriers & successfactorsTools & toolpracticesSkillsDev &Support1CX1DXLevel of maturityOptimizingDefinedManagedInitialDimensionsOER embedded in strategyInstitutional OER repositoryAdapted from diagram by T. Koskinen
  • 32.
    Uses and benefitsThreeusesBenchmarkingGuidanceReflection and comparisonBenefitsGuides users in understanding how to think about the key issues.Flexible enough to cover the multiple stakeholdersSub-cubes provide practical illustrative examplesUseful as a mechanism for institutions to self-benchmark30
  • 33.
  • 34.
    Final thoughtsA visionof OEP for inclusion, innovation & qualityLearning and the context of learning have changedWe need new approaches to learning and teachingHow can we harness increasingly sophisticated tools and OERs?How can we support innovation in the use and reuse of OER?Will openness enable or restrict social inclusion?What are the quality implications in an increasingly open context?How can we ensure research better informs policy and practice?
  • 35.
    SourcesMash ups http://www.flickr.com/photos/richardellard/4524139966/Moleculehttp://www.flickr.com/photos/8272941@N07/498827420/Periodic table http://www.flickr.com/photos/chemheritage/3984920162/Music sheet http://www.flickr.com/photos/anyaka/21848267/One world http://www.flickr.com/photos/psd/2731067095/World of warcraft http://www.flickr.com/photos/shardsofblue/3981216281/Questionmarkhttp://www.flickr.com/photos/crystaljingsr/3914729343/http://suifaijohnmak.files.wordpress.com/2009/11/communication-sep08_leskovec_tdef_page_03_480.jpgYin-Yang image http://learn4kicks.files.wordpress.com/2009/09/yinyangconceptmap.gifImperial collage second life island http://knowledgecast.wordpress.com/2009/07/10/icl-tour2/Personal Inquiry project http://www.pi-project.ac.uk/resources/E-Portfolios http://www.jiscinfonet.ac.uk/infokits/e-portfolios  

Editor's Notes

  • #17 What is Olnet? – open learning network – is a 3 year initiative backed by The William and Flora Hewlett Foundation. With $3m of funding it is a partnership between the OU and Carnegie Mellon University building on the experience that they have gained in developing and researching Open Educational Resources (OER). The Hewlett foundation that has invested more than $90m in establishing OER wants to find out more about benefits – what is the evidence? How should people learn with them? What issues does the community still need to solve? OLnet will develop a networked community of researchers and practitioners – offering them support, events and a chance to contribute evidence and questions. OER acts as a unifying theme that will generate sub-issues that need to be considered. Projects will carry out different streams of research looking at such things as design, collaborative learning and the developing world. Funded fellowships will bring in external expertise and offer a programme of exchanges and support for research ideas.