Approach to the Audit
9
1
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Lecture 9
Approach to the Audit
Approach to the Audit
9
Team spirit & co-operation = successful audit
Auditors set the “TONE” for the audit.
2
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Approach to the Audit
9
Key Success Factor: Auditor Attitude
MUST BE POSITIVE/VALUE-ADD
 I really am here to help.
 I am not here to find fault.
 We are on the same team.
 Together we can find
opportunities.
 This benefits the business.

3
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Approach to the Audit
9
4
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Relations between auditors and auditees
are critical for a successful audit. The
auditor influences these relationships by:
1. Understanding the communications process
2. Minimizing barriers to communication
3. Creating the climate for good communications
4. “LISTENING” carefully to auditees
Approach to the Audit
9
Recipient
decodes &
interprets
Feedback
5
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Communications Process
Sender
encodes
Message
Approach to the Audit
9
Barriers to effective communication
Physical
Intellectual
Psychological
6
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Find example for each of them
Approach to the Audit
9
Create a Climate for Good Communications:
• Space (where are you auditing?)
• Timing (what time of day?)
• Eye contact (how much?)
• Body language (watch and control)
• Cultural sensitivities (research if necessary)
7
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Approach to the Audit
9
8
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Space and Place considerations:
 A l l o w “personal”space
 R i g h t location (auditees work space
o
rconference room?)
Seating plan
Minimum physicaldistraction
 D e s k between people may be a barricade
Auditor & auditees should be oneteam
Approach to the Audit
9
Time Considerations:
 L e a v e auditees some time beforey
o
u
arrive
Respect auditees’ time & stayo
n
schedule
• Never too far ahead of schedule
• Never LATE
Consider:
customary timings
meals
siesta
closing time
9
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Approach to the Audit
9
How much eye contact?
Western communication culture requires a lot
o
feye contact
Elsewhere close eye contact may be offensive
o
rimpolite
 L a c k of eye contact doesn’t have to mean
attempt to hide information
10
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Approach to the Audit
9
11
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
70% of Communication is NON-VERBAL
Body language
Postures, gestures, facial
expressions
Communicates mass o
f
information
Uncontrolled messages m
a
y
upset auditee
Common meanings
Cultural differences
Paralanguage
Dialect
Speed
Loudness, Softness
Coughs
Intonation
Breaks
Other matters
Approach to the Audit
9
Cultural Sensitivities
Audits may be carried
out i
nmulti-cultural
environment
 B e aware of cultural
differences & sensitivities
Research specific issues
Understand how to establish
rapport with auditees
12
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Approach to the Audit
9
Cultural Sensitivities - examples
Do I shake
hands with
everyone?
What is the private
space?
Beware of offensive
gestures!
13
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Approach to the Audit
9
Good Listening is ESSENTIAL
Eliminate distractions
Listen forcontent
Suspend judgement
Listen forthemes
 U s e spare time
 S e e k clarification
14
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Approach to the Audit
9
Bad habits to avoid (i.e. not listening)
 Faking attention
 Pre-occupation
 Over-reaction
 Interrupting the speaker
 Listening without looking
 Listening only to what we want to hear
 Using listening time to collect the thought
¡NO!
15
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Approach to the Audit
9
Interviewing – A CRITICAL Audit Step
Interviews provide essential objective evidence.
Good communications are essential to good interviews.
So, put the auditee AT EASE.
• Be Friendly.
• Explain why you are here.
• Ask for their help.
• Ask if they have questions.
• Show an interest in what THEY do.
• Explain your observations.
16
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Approach to the Audit
9
Interviewing Technique
Interviews are not interrogations.
 A s k questions in conversational
manner.
 We a v e questions intogeneral
conversation.
 D o not cross question.
 Av o i d question answerexercise.
Aspects?!
17
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Approach to the Audit
9
Questioning Technique for Interviews
Questions should:
 y i e l d relevantinformation
 n o t suggest answers
 n o t contain emotive
words or implications
Three Question types:
 o p e n questions
closed anddirect
questions
clarifying questions
Avoid leading questions
Don’t ask antagonising questions
18
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Approach to the Audit
9
Open Questions - auditor friends
What? Why? Where? Who? When? How?
Yield informative answer
Limits - conversation may get side-tracked!
One way to avoid diluting:
Show me!
19
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Approach to the Audit
9
20
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Closed and direct questions
Closed questions- answer: Yes/No
Direct questions- answer: few words
Intended to yield very specificinformation
Disadvantages:
• do not bring much information
• if used too often may create impression of cross -
examination
Approach to the Audit
9
21
Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
Clarifying Questions
Intended to clarify, retrieve full informationa
n
d
prevent misunderstanding
 A l l o w to grasp fullpicture
Disadvantages:
• if used too often may create impression that you
were not listening
• are time-consuming
• if you are not prepared to listen in full don’t ask them

Approach to the Audit

  • 1.
    Approach to theAudit 9 1 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse Lecture 9 Approach to the Audit
  • 2.
    Approach to theAudit 9 Team spirit & co-operation = successful audit Auditors set the “TONE” for the audit. 2 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
  • 3.
    Approach to theAudit 9 Key Success Factor: Auditor Attitude MUST BE POSITIVE/VALUE-ADD  I really am here to help.  I am not here to find fault.  We are on the same team.  Together we can find opportunities.  This benefits the business.  3 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
  • 4.
    Approach to theAudit 9 4 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse Relations between auditors and auditees are critical for a successful audit. The auditor influences these relationships by: 1. Understanding the communications process 2. Minimizing barriers to communication 3. Creating the climate for good communications 4. “LISTENING” carefully to auditees
  • 5.
    Approach to theAudit 9 Recipient decodes & interprets Feedback 5 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse Communications Process Sender encodes Message
  • 6.
    Approach to theAudit 9 Barriers to effective communication Physical Intellectual Psychological 6 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse Find example for each of them
  • 7.
    Approach to theAudit 9 Create a Climate for Good Communications: • Space (where are you auditing?) • Timing (what time of day?) • Eye contact (how much?) • Body language (watch and control) • Cultural sensitivities (research if necessary) 7 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
  • 8.
    Approach to theAudit 9 8 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse Space and Place considerations:  A l l o w “personal”space  R i g h t location (auditees work space o rconference room?) Seating plan Minimum physicaldistraction  D e s k between people may be a barricade Auditor & auditees should be oneteam
  • 9.
    Approach to theAudit 9 Time Considerations:  L e a v e auditees some time beforey o u arrive Respect auditees’ time & stayo n schedule • Never too far ahead of schedule • Never LATE Consider: customary timings meals siesta closing time 9 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
  • 10.
    Approach to theAudit 9 How much eye contact? Western communication culture requires a lot o feye contact Elsewhere close eye contact may be offensive o rimpolite  L a c k of eye contact doesn’t have to mean attempt to hide information 10 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
  • 11.
    Approach to theAudit 9 11 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse 70% of Communication is NON-VERBAL Body language Postures, gestures, facial expressions Communicates mass o f information Uncontrolled messages m a y upset auditee Common meanings Cultural differences Paralanguage Dialect Speed Loudness, Softness Coughs Intonation Breaks Other matters
  • 12.
    Approach to theAudit 9 Cultural Sensitivities Audits may be carried out i nmulti-cultural environment  B e aware of cultural differences & sensitivities Research specific issues Understand how to establish rapport with auditees 12 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
  • 13.
    Approach to theAudit 9 Cultural Sensitivities - examples Do I shake hands with everyone? What is the private space? Beware of offensive gestures! 13 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
  • 14.
    Approach to theAudit 9 Good Listening is ESSENTIAL Eliminate distractions Listen forcontent Suspend judgement Listen forthemes  U s e spare time  S e e k clarification 14 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
  • 15.
    Approach to theAudit 9 Bad habits to avoid (i.e. not listening)  Faking attention  Pre-occupation  Over-reaction  Interrupting the speaker  Listening without looking  Listening only to what we want to hear  Using listening time to collect the thought ¡NO! 15 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
  • 16.
    Approach to theAudit 9 Interviewing – A CRITICAL Audit Step Interviews provide essential objective evidence. Good communications are essential to good interviews. So, put the auditee AT EASE. • Be Friendly. • Explain why you are here. • Ask for their help. • Ask if they have questions. • Show an interest in what THEY do. • Explain your observations. 16 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
  • 17.
    Approach to theAudit 9 Interviewing Technique Interviews are not interrogations.  A s k questions in conversational manner.  We a v e questions intogeneral conversation.  D o not cross question.  Av o i d question answerexercise. Aspects?! 17 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
  • 18.
    Approach to theAudit 9 Questioning Technique for Interviews Questions should:  y i e l d relevantinformation  n o t suggest answers  n o t contain emotive words or implications Three Question types:  o p e n questions closed anddirect questions clarifying questions Avoid leading questions Don’t ask antagonising questions 18 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
  • 19.
    Approach to theAudit 9 Open Questions - auditor friends What? Why? Where? Who? When? How? Yield informative answer Limits - conversation may get side-tracked! One way to avoid diluting: Show me! 19 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse
  • 20.
    Approach to theAudit 9 20 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse Closed and direct questions Closed questions- answer: Yes/No Direct questions- answer: few words Intended to yield very specificinformation Disadvantages: • do not bring much information • if used too often may create impression of cross - examination
  • 21.
    Approach to theAudit 9 21 Issue: 01.01. 2019 MMC/INTAS- EMS Internal Auditor TrainingCourse Clarifying Questions Intended to clarify, retrieve full informationa n d prevent misunderstanding  A l l o w to grasp fullpicture Disadvantages: • if used too often may create impression that you were not listening • are time-consuming • if you are not prepared to listen in full don’t ask them