SlideShare a Scribd company logo
What is co-limitation, really?
Team Shoestring:
Joel Blum
Tim Fahey
Melany Fisk
Christy Goodale
Shinjini Goswami
Mariann Johnston
Ed Rastetter
Craig See
Matt Vadeboncoeur
Adam Wild
Ruth Yanai
And many, many more!
Nutrient limitation of productivity
Elser et al. (2007) Ecology Letters
• Syntheses of fertilization studies predict N and P co-limitation
Nutrient limitation of productivity
• Syntheses of fertilization studies predict N and P co-limitation
• Defined by the way we detect it: larger productivity response to
N+P together than to either alone
• What underlies that treatment response?
– Additive
– Synergistic
NP NPCon
NP NPCon
General Project Questions
1. Is productivity in the northern hardwood forest co-limited
by N and P?
2. Do soil nutrient interactions contribute to co-limitation?
Mid-age forest Mature forest
Young: 15-20 yrs
Mid-age: 35-40 yrs
Mature: 100+ yrs
Study Sites
3 sites:
•Jeffers Brook
•HBEF
•BEF
2 stands per site:
1 mid-age
1 mature
9 stands at BEF:
3 young
3 mid-age
3 mature
Study Sites
Study Sites
4 (sometimes 5) plots per stand
Treatments
(And sometimes
Ca)
N (30 kg/ha/yr)
P (10 kg/ha/yr)
N+P
Control
• DBH (trees > 10 cm) and soil processes quantified pre- and post-treatment
General Project Questions
1. Is productivity in the northern hardwood forest co-limited
by N and P?
- no (varies, but mostly P-limited)
2. Do soil nutrient interactions contribute to co-limitation?
Interactions between soil N and P availability
Soil
solution
Organic nutrients
Microorganisms
Plants
Leaching
Resin strips measure what’s in soil solution
Interactions between soil N and P availability
• Threshold P,
above which N is
very low
• Plant and
microbial
evidence suggest
that microbial
uptake of N
suppresses
availability to
plants
Interactions between soil N and P availability
Interactions between soil N and P availability
Soil
solution
Organic nutrients
Microorganisms
Plants
Leaching
P
P
N
P
N
• Microbial uptake of N suppresses availability to plants
• Expect plant productivity in NP plots to begin to exceed that
in P plots
• Co-limitation?
Conclusions
1. Is productivity in the northern hardwood forest co-limited
by N and P?
- no
2. Do soil nutrient interactions contribute to co-limitation?
- if “co-limitation” is detected, it will be sequential
- arising from nutrient interactions, rather than
simultaneous limitations by multiple nutrients
3. New hypothesis: alleviating microbial P limitation induces
N limitation over time
1. predict that plant and microbial responses to N+P will
soon exceed those to P

More Related Content

What's hot

MeganMcNellie_ESA2015_v9
MeganMcNellie_ESA2015_v9MeganMcNellie_ESA2015_v9
MeganMcNellie_ESA2015_v9
Megan McNellie
 
BushfireConf2015 - 1. Be prepared: climate change and the NSW bushfire threat.
BushfireConf2015 - 1. Be prepared: climate change and the NSW bushfire threat. BushfireConf2015 - 1. Be prepared: climate change and the NSW bushfire threat.
BushfireConf2015 - 1. Be prepared: climate change and the NSW bushfire threat.
Bushfire Program - Nature Conservation Council NSW
 
BushfireConf 2015 - 5. Where has all the fire gone? Quantifying the spatial...
BushfireConf 2015 - 5. Where has all the fire gone? Quantifying the spatial...BushfireConf 2015 - 5. Where has all the fire gone? Quantifying the spatial...
BushfireConf 2015 - 5. Where has all the fire gone? Quantifying the spatial...
Bushfire Program - Nature Conservation Council NSW
 
Forest ecology mendel university
Forest ecology mendel universityForest ecology mendel university
Forest ecology mendel university
Muhammad Rehan
 
Climate change threats to southeastern coastal plain forests: an ecosystem se...
Climate change threats to southeastern coastal plain forests: an ecosystem se...Climate change threats to southeastern coastal plain forests: an ecosystem se...
Climate change threats to southeastern coastal plain forests: an ecosystem se...
Northern Institute of Applied Climate Science
 
Laws of nature
Laws of natureLaws of nature
Laws of nature
Len Fontanilla
 
Adapting to Climate Change in Northeastern Freshwater Ecosystems
Adapting to Climate Change in Northeastern Freshwater EcosystemsAdapting to Climate Change in Northeastern Freshwater Ecosystems
Adapting to Climate Change in Northeastern Freshwater Ecosystems
Northern Institute of Applied Climate Science
 
The Difference a Species Makes on Freshwater Microbial Communities
The Difference a Species Makes on Freshwater Microbial CommunitiesThe Difference a Species Makes on Freshwater Microbial Communities
The Difference a Species Makes on Freshwater Microbial Communities
Graham Sustainability Institute at the University of Michigan
 
One stand at a time: Silvicultural options for stand-level response to clim...
One stand at a time: Silvicultural options  for stand-level response  to clim...One stand at a time: Silvicultural options  for stand-level response  to clim...
One stand at a time: Silvicultural options for stand-level response to clim...
Northern Institute of Applied Climate Science
 
A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush: ecological time preference and b...
A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush: ecological time preference and b...A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush: ecological time preference and b...
A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush: ecological time preference and b...
Megan Evans
 
Leona D'Agnes' April 30 Presenation
Leona D'Agnes' April 30 PresenationLeona D'Agnes' April 30 Presenation
Leona D'Agnes' April 30 Presenation
Chinaenviro
 
Intro To Forest Ecology
Intro To Forest EcologyIntro To Forest Ecology
Intro To Forest Ecology
divangou
 
Recent evidence on unequal access to nature during COVID-19
Recent evidence on unequal access to nature during COVID-19Recent evidence on unequal access to nature during COVID-19
Recent evidence on unequal access to nature during COVID-19
Ben Wheeler
 
Overview of PEREC
Overview of PERECOverview of PEREC
Overview of PEREC
agraziano
 
Adaptation in the real-world: Connectivity and Transition in the Deerfield Wa...
Adaptation in the real-world: Connectivity and Transition in the Deerfield Wa...Adaptation in the real-world: Connectivity and Transition in the Deerfield Wa...
Adaptation in the real-world: Connectivity and Transition in the Deerfield Wa...
Northern Institute of Applied Climate Science
 
Exploring the effects of climate change on marine species using linked data
Exploring the effects of climate change on marine species using linked dataExploring the effects of climate change on marine species using linked data
Exploring the effects of climate change on marine species using linked data
Prashant Gupta
 
Bird-Resume-Conservation
Bird-Resume-ConservationBird-Resume-Conservation
Bird-Resume-Conservation
Zachary Bird
 
Honors -Ecology introduction 1011
Honors -Ecology introduction 1011Honors -Ecology introduction 1011
Honors -Ecology introduction 1011
Michael Edgar
 
Beyond IPCC Scenarios:
Synergies Between Climate Adaptation and Mitigation
 a...
Beyond IPCC Scenarios:
Synergies Between Climate Adaptation and Mitigation
 a...Beyond IPCC Scenarios:
Synergies Between Climate Adaptation and Mitigation
 a...
Beyond IPCC Scenarios:
Synergies Between Climate Adaptation and Mitigation
 a...
CIFOR-ICRAF
 
JBryant_Poster2016
JBryant_Poster2016JBryant_Poster2016
JBryant_Poster2016
Joshua Bryant
 

What's hot (20)

MeganMcNellie_ESA2015_v9
MeganMcNellie_ESA2015_v9MeganMcNellie_ESA2015_v9
MeganMcNellie_ESA2015_v9
 
BushfireConf2015 - 1. Be prepared: climate change and the NSW bushfire threat.
BushfireConf2015 - 1. Be prepared: climate change and the NSW bushfire threat. BushfireConf2015 - 1. Be prepared: climate change and the NSW bushfire threat.
BushfireConf2015 - 1. Be prepared: climate change and the NSW bushfire threat.
 
BushfireConf 2015 - 5. Where has all the fire gone? Quantifying the spatial...
BushfireConf 2015 - 5. Where has all the fire gone? Quantifying the spatial...BushfireConf 2015 - 5. Where has all the fire gone? Quantifying the spatial...
BushfireConf 2015 - 5. Where has all the fire gone? Quantifying the spatial...
 
Forest ecology mendel university
Forest ecology mendel universityForest ecology mendel university
Forest ecology mendel university
 
Climate change threats to southeastern coastal plain forests: an ecosystem se...
Climate change threats to southeastern coastal plain forests: an ecosystem se...Climate change threats to southeastern coastal plain forests: an ecosystem se...
Climate change threats to southeastern coastal plain forests: an ecosystem se...
 
Laws of nature
Laws of natureLaws of nature
Laws of nature
 
Adapting to Climate Change in Northeastern Freshwater Ecosystems
Adapting to Climate Change in Northeastern Freshwater EcosystemsAdapting to Climate Change in Northeastern Freshwater Ecosystems
Adapting to Climate Change in Northeastern Freshwater Ecosystems
 
The Difference a Species Makes on Freshwater Microbial Communities
The Difference a Species Makes on Freshwater Microbial CommunitiesThe Difference a Species Makes on Freshwater Microbial Communities
The Difference a Species Makes on Freshwater Microbial Communities
 
One stand at a time: Silvicultural options for stand-level response to clim...
One stand at a time: Silvicultural options  for stand-level response  to clim...One stand at a time: Silvicultural options  for stand-level response  to clim...
One stand at a time: Silvicultural options for stand-level response to clim...
 
A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush: ecological time preference and b...
A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush: ecological time preference and b...A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush: ecological time preference and b...
A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush: ecological time preference and b...
 
Leona D'Agnes' April 30 Presenation
Leona D'Agnes' April 30 PresenationLeona D'Agnes' April 30 Presenation
Leona D'Agnes' April 30 Presenation
 
Intro To Forest Ecology
Intro To Forest EcologyIntro To Forest Ecology
Intro To Forest Ecology
 
Recent evidence on unequal access to nature during COVID-19
Recent evidence on unequal access to nature during COVID-19Recent evidence on unequal access to nature during COVID-19
Recent evidence on unequal access to nature during COVID-19
 
Overview of PEREC
Overview of PERECOverview of PEREC
Overview of PEREC
 
Adaptation in the real-world: Connectivity and Transition in the Deerfield Wa...
Adaptation in the real-world: Connectivity and Transition in the Deerfield Wa...Adaptation in the real-world: Connectivity and Transition in the Deerfield Wa...
Adaptation in the real-world: Connectivity and Transition in the Deerfield Wa...
 
Exploring the effects of climate change on marine species using linked data
Exploring the effects of climate change on marine species using linked dataExploring the effects of climate change on marine species using linked data
Exploring the effects of climate change on marine species using linked data
 
Bird-Resume-Conservation
Bird-Resume-ConservationBird-Resume-Conservation
Bird-Resume-Conservation
 
Honors -Ecology introduction 1011
Honors -Ecology introduction 1011Honors -Ecology introduction 1011
Honors -Ecology introduction 1011
 
Beyond IPCC Scenarios:
Synergies Between Climate Adaptation and Mitigation
 a...
Beyond IPCC Scenarios:
Synergies Between Climate Adaptation and Mitigation
 a...Beyond IPCC Scenarios:
Synergies Between Climate Adaptation and Mitigation
 a...
Beyond IPCC Scenarios:
Synergies Between Climate Adaptation and Mitigation
 a...
 
JBryant_Poster2016
JBryant_Poster2016JBryant_Poster2016
JBryant_Poster2016
 

Similar to What is co-limitation, really?

Could co-limitation be caused by different nutrients limiting shoots and root...
Could co-limitation be caused by different nutrients limiting shoots and root...Could co-limitation be caused by different nutrients limiting shoots and root...
Could co-limitation be caused by different nutrients limiting shoots and root...
melnhe
 
Soil Enzyme Activity Indicates P Limitation in northern hardwood forest
Soil Enzyme Activity Indicates P Limitation in northern hardwood forestSoil Enzyme Activity Indicates P Limitation in northern hardwood forest
Soil Enzyme Activity Indicates P Limitation in northern hardwood forest
melnhe
 
N-P co-limitation in young northern hardwood forest. Tim Fahey
N-P co-limitation in young northern hardwood forest. Tim FaheyN-P co-limitation in young northern hardwood forest. Tim Fahey
N-P co-limitation in young northern hardwood forest. Tim Fahey
melnhe
 
Rome 2015
Rome 2015Rome 2015
Rome 2015
Lionel68
 
Marklein CNP stoichiometry
Marklein CNP stoichiometryMarklein CNP stoichiometry
Marklein CNP stoichiometry
Noam Ross
 
Phosphorus Cycling Spring 2016
Phosphorus Cycling Spring 2016Phosphorus Cycling Spring 2016
Phosphorus Cycling Spring 2016
Jeremy LeLean
 
HB 2018- Back on a shoestring
HB 2018- Back on a shoestringHB 2018- Back on a shoestring
HB 2018- Back on a shoestring
melnhe
 
Fisk lter comp
Fisk lter compFisk lter comp
Fisk lter comp
melnhe
 
MELNHE overview 2016
MELNHE overview 2016MELNHE overview 2016
MELNHE overview 2016
melnhe
 
Agren 2012 - by Brian Smithers
Agren 2012 - by Brian SmithersAgren 2012 - by Brian Smithers
Agren 2012 - by Brian Smithers
Noam Ross
 
GROWTH AND PERFORMANCE OF EGGPLANT.pptx
GROWTH AND PERFORMANCE OF EGGPLANT.pptxGROWTH AND PERFORMANCE OF EGGPLANT.pptx
GROWTH AND PERFORMANCE OF EGGPLANT.pptx
JunalynDajotoy
 
Mycorrhizal type and co-limitation of forest productivity. Noah Blumenthal
Mycorrhizal type and co-limitation of forest productivity. Noah BlumenthalMycorrhizal type and co-limitation of forest productivity. Noah Blumenthal
Mycorrhizal type and co-limitation of forest productivity. Noah Blumenthal
melnhe
 
Root foraging for apatite is influenced by N and P availability
Root foraging for apatite is influenced by N and P availabilityRoot foraging for apatite is influenced by N and P availability
Root foraging for apatite is influenced by N and P availability
melnhe
 
Biodiverse - Rosauer talk @ iEvoBio conference June 2010
Biodiverse - Rosauer talk @ iEvoBio conference June 2010Biodiverse - Rosauer talk @ iEvoBio conference June 2010
Biodiverse - Rosauer talk @ iEvoBio conference June 2010
Dan Rosauer
 
Plant Competition in Temperate Regions
Plant Competition in Temperate RegionsPlant Competition in Temperate Regions
Plant Competition in Temperate Regions
Mark McGinley
 
Amy Ickowitz, CIFOR "Trees and Dietary Diversity in Africa"
Amy Ickowitz, CIFOR "Trees and Dietary Diversity in Africa"Amy Ickowitz, CIFOR "Trees and Dietary Diversity in Africa"
Amy Ickowitz, CIFOR "Trees and Dietary Diversity in Africa"
Independent Science and Partnership Council of the CGIAR
 
Sigma xi presentation
Sigma xi presentationSigma xi presentation
Sigma xi presentation
mbmerrigan
 
Sigma xi presentation
Sigma xi presentationSigma xi presentation
Sigma xi presentation
mbmerrigan
 
Soil fertility evaluation P K MANI
Soil fertility evaluation  P K MANISoil fertility evaluation  P K MANI
Soil fertility evaluation P K MANI
P.K. Mani
 
Trees and-dietary-diversity-in-africa
Trees and-dietary-diversity-in-africaTrees and-dietary-diversity-in-africa
Trees and-dietary-diversity-in-africa
Teresa Borelli
 

Similar to What is co-limitation, really? (20)

Could co-limitation be caused by different nutrients limiting shoots and root...
Could co-limitation be caused by different nutrients limiting shoots and root...Could co-limitation be caused by different nutrients limiting shoots and root...
Could co-limitation be caused by different nutrients limiting shoots and root...
 
Soil Enzyme Activity Indicates P Limitation in northern hardwood forest
Soil Enzyme Activity Indicates P Limitation in northern hardwood forestSoil Enzyme Activity Indicates P Limitation in northern hardwood forest
Soil Enzyme Activity Indicates P Limitation in northern hardwood forest
 
N-P co-limitation in young northern hardwood forest. Tim Fahey
N-P co-limitation in young northern hardwood forest. Tim FaheyN-P co-limitation in young northern hardwood forest. Tim Fahey
N-P co-limitation in young northern hardwood forest. Tim Fahey
 
Rome 2015
Rome 2015Rome 2015
Rome 2015
 
Marklein CNP stoichiometry
Marklein CNP stoichiometryMarklein CNP stoichiometry
Marklein CNP stoichiometry
 
Phosphorus Cycling Spring 2016
Phosphorus Cycling Spring 2016Phosphorus Cycling Spring 2016
Phosphorus Cycling Spring 2016
 
HB 2018- Back on a shoestring
HB 2018- Back on a shoestringHB 2018- Back on a shoestring
HB 2018- Back on a shoestring
 
Fisk lter comp
Fisk lter compFisk lter comp
Fisk lter comp
 
MELNHE overview 2016
MELNHE overview 2016MELNHE overview 2016
MELNHE overview 2016
 
Agren 2012 - by Brian Smithers
Agren 2012 - by Brian SmithersAgren 2012 - by Brian Smithers
Agren 2012 - by Brian Smithers
 
GROWTH AND PERFORMANCE OF EGGPLANT.pptx
GROWTH AND PERFORMANCE OF EGGPLANT.pptxGROWTH AND PERFORMANCE OF EGGPLANT.pptx
GROWTH AND PERFORMANCE OF EGGPLANT.pptx
 
Mycorrhizal type and co-limitation of forest productivity. Noah Blumenthal
Mycorrhizal type and co-limitation of forest productivity. Noah BlumenthalMycorrhizal type and co-limitation of forest productivity. Noah Blumenthal
Mycorrhizal type and co-limitation of forest productivity. Noah Blumenthal
 
Root foraging for apatite is influenced by N and P availability
Root foraging for apatite is influenced by N and P availabilityRoot foraging for apatite is influenced by N and P availability
Root foraging for apatite is influenced by N and P availability
 
Biodiverse - Rosauer talk @ iEvoBio conference June 2010
Biodiverse - Rosauer talk @ iEvoBio conference June 2010Biodiverse - Rosauer talk @ iEvoBio conference June 2010
Biodiverse - Rosauer talk @ iEvoBio conference June 2010
 
Plant Competition in Temperate Regions
Plant Competition in Temperate RegionsPlant Competition in Temperate Regions
Plant Competition in Temperate Regions
 
Amy Ickowitz, CIFOR "Trees and Dietary Diversity in Africa"
Amy Ickowitz, CIFOR "Trees and Dietary Diversity in Africa"Amy Ickowitz, CIFOR "Trees and Dietary Diversity in Africa"
Amy Ickowitz, CIFOR "Trees and Dietary Diversity in Africa"
 
Sigma xi presentation
Sigma xi presentationSigma xi presentation
Sigma xi presentation
 
Sigma xi presentation
Sigma xi presentationSigma xi presentation
Sigma xi presentation
 
Soil fertility evaluation P K MANI
Soil fertility evaluation  P K MANISoil fertility evaluation  P K MANI
Soil fertility evaluation P K MANI
 
Trees and-dietary-diversity-in-africa
Trees and-dietary-diversity-in-africaTrees and-dietary-diversity-in-africa
Trees and-dietary-diversity-in-africa
 

More from melnhe

Distinguishing N and P addition from the air using imaging spectroscopy. Alex...
Distinguishing N and P addition from the air using imaging spectroscopy. Alex...Distinguishing N and P addition from the air using imaging spectroscopy. Alex...
Distinguishing N and P addition from the air using imaging spectroscopy. Alex...
melnhe
 
Germinants: The next generation. Denise Rauschendorfer
Germinants: The next generation. Denise RauschendorferGerminants: The next generation. Denise Rauschendorfer
Germinants: The next generation. Denise Rauschendorfer
melnhe
 
Grow with the changes: Forest succession and woody debris. Joe Nash
Grow with the changes: Forest succession and woody debris. Joe NashGrow with the changes: Forest succession and woody debris. Joe Nash
Grow with the changes: Forest succession and woody debris. Joe Nash
melnhe
 
Litterfall and soil respiration fluxes in the MELNHE study. Thomas Mann
Litterfall and soil respiration fluxes in the MELNHE study. Thomas MannLitterfall and soil respiration fluxes in the MELNHE study. Thomas Mann
Litterfall and soil respiration fluxes in the MELNHE study. Thomas Mann
melnhe
 
Fine dining: root morphology, mycorrhizal colonization, and nutrient amendmen...
Fine dining: root morphology, mycorrhizal colonization, and nutrient amendmen...Fine dining: root morphology, mycorrhizal colonization, and nutrient amendmen...
Fine dining: root morphology, mycorrhizal colonization, and nutrient amendmen...
melnhe
 
Sugar maple leaf characteristics vary with depth in the crown and nutrient ad...
Sugar maple leaf characteristics vary with depth in the crown and nutrient ad...Sugar maple leaf characteristics vary with depth in the crown and nutrient ad...
Sugar maple leaf characteristics vary with depth in the crown and nutrient ad...
melnhe
 
The timing of senescence affects foliar p resorption dan hong
The timing of senescence affects foliar p resorption   dan hongThe timing of senescence affects foliar p resorption   dan hong
The timing of senescence affects foliar p resorption dan hong
melnhe
 
Space wars the fight for light in the stands of bartlett sarah congress
Space wars  the fight for light in the stands of bartlett   sarah congressSpace wars  the fight for light in the stands of bartlett   sarah congress
Space wars the fight for light in the stands of bartlett sarah congress
melnhe
 
Having a stake in nutrient cycling effects of n and p addition on wood decay...
Having a stake in nutrient cycling  effects of n and p addition on wood decay...Having a stake in nutrient cycling  effects of n and p addition on wood decay...
Having a stake in nutrient cycling effects of n and p addition on wood decay...
melnhe
 
Fruiting response of ectomycorrhizal fungi to nutrient additions claudia vi...
Fruiting response of ectomycorrhizal fungi to nutrient additions   claudia vi...Fruiting response of ectomycorrhizal fungi to nutrient additions   claudia vi...
Fruiting response of ectomycorrhizal fungi to nutrient additions claudia vi...
melnhe
 
Does the fate of n depend on p availability in soil - samuel butler
Does the fate of n depend on p availability in soil   - samuel butlerDoes the fate of n depend on p availability in soil   - samuel butler
Does the fate of n depend on p availability in soil - samuel butler
melnhe
 
Belowground c allocation estimated as soil respiration minus aboveground litt...
Belowground c allocation estimated as soil respiration minus aboveground litt...Belowground c allocation estimated as soil respiration minus aboveground litt...
Belowground c allocation estimated as soil respiration minus aboveground litt...
melnhe
 
Baby boomers are there any surviving germinants from the recent mast year -...
Baby boomers  are there any surviving germinants from the recent mast year  -...Baby boomers  are there any surviving germinants from the recent mast year  -...
Baby boomers are there any surviving germinants from the recent mast year -...
melnhe
 
And you thought there were no earthworms in our forests
And you thought there were no earthworms in our forests  And you thought there were no earthworms in our forests
And you thought there were no earthworms in our forests
melnhe
 
Intro for asm workshop see
Intro for asm workshop seeIntro for asm workshop see
Intro for asm workshop see
melnhe
 
Asm2018 7 young
Asm2018 7 youngAsm2018 7 young
Asm2018 7 young
melnhe
 
Asm2018 6 dietze
Asm2018 6 dietzeAsm2018 6 dietze
Asm2018 6 dietze
melnhe
 
Asm2018 5 yanai
Asm2018 5 yanaiAsm2018 5 yanai
Asm2018 5 yanai
melnhe
 
Asm2018 4 y.yang
Asm2018 4 y.yangAsm2018 4 y.yang
Asm2018 4 y.yang
melnhe
 
Asm2018 3 mgreen
Asm2018 3 mgreenAsm2018 3 mgreen
Asm2018 3 mgreen
melnhe
 

More from melnhe (20)

Distinguishing N and P addition from the air using imaging spectroscopy. Alex...
Distinguishing N and P addition from the air using imaging spectroscopy. Alex...Distinguishing N and P addition from the air using imaging spectroscopy. Alex...
Distinguishing N and P addition from the air using imaging spectroscopy. Alex...
 
Germinants: The next generation. Denise Rauschendorfer
Germinants: The next generation. Denise RauschendorferGerminants: The next generation. Denise Rauschendorfer
Germinants: The next generation. Denise Rauschendorfer
 
Grow with the changes: Forest succession and woody debris. Joe Nash
Grow with the changes: Forest succession and woody debris. Joe NashGrow with the changes: Forest succession and woody debris. Joe Nash
Grow with the changes: Forest succession and woody debris. Joe Nash
 
Litterfall and soil respiration fluxes in the MELNHE study. Thomas Mann
Litterfall and soil respiration fluxes in the MELNHE study. Thomas MannLitterfall and soil respiration fluxes in the MELNHE study. Thomas Mann
Litterfall and soil respiration fluxes in the MELNHE study. Thomas Mann
 
Fine dining: root morphology, mycorrhizal colonization, and nutrient amendmen...
Fine dining: root morphology, mycorrhizal colonization, and nutrient amendmen...Fine dining: root morphology, mycorrhizal colonization, and nutrient amendmen...
Fine dining: root morphology, mycorrhizal colonization, and nutrient amendmen...
 
Sugar maple leaf characteristics vary with depth in the crown and nutrient ad...
Sugar maple leaf characteristics vary with depth in the crown and nutrient ad...Sugar maple leaf characteristics vary with depth in the crown and nutrient ad...
Sugar maple leaf characteristics vary with depth in the crown and nutrient ad...
 
The timing of senescence affects foliar p resorption dan hong
The timing of senescence affects foliar p resorption   dan hongThe timing of senescence affects foliar p resorption   dan hong
The timing of senescence affects foliar p resorption dan hong
 
Space wars the fight for light in the stands of bartlett sarah congress
Space wars  the fight for light in the stands of bartlett   sarah congressSpace wars  the fight for light in the stands of bartlett   sarah congress
Space wars the fight for light in the stands of bartlett sarah congress
 
Having a stake in nutrient cycling effects of n and p addition on wood decay...
Having a stake in nutrient cycling  effects of n and p addition on wood decay...Having a stake in nutrient cycling  effects of n and p addition on wood decay...
Having a stake in nutrient cycling effects of n and p addition on wood decay...
 
Fruiting response of ectomycorrhizal fungi to nutrient additions claudia vi...
Fruiting response of ectomycorrhizal fungi to nutrient additions   claudia vi...Fruiting response of ectomycorrhizal fungi to nutrient additions   claudia vi...
Fruiting response of ectomycorrhizal fungi to nutrient additions claudia vi...
 
Does the fate of n depend on p availability in soil - samuel butler
Does the fate of n depend on p availability in soil   - samuel butlerDoes the fate of n depend on p availability in soil   - samuel butler
Does the fate of n depend on p availability in soil - samuel butler
 
Belowground c allocation estimated as soil respiration minus aboveground litt...
Belowground c allocation estimated as soil respiration minus aboveground litt...Belowground c allocation estimated as soil respiration minus aboveground litt...
Belowground c allocation estimated as soil respiration minus aboveground litt...
 
Baby boomers are there any surviving germinants from the recent mast year -...
Baby boomers  are there any surviving germinants from the recent mast year  -...Baby boomers  are there any surviving germinants from the recent mast year  -...
Baby boomers are there any surviving germinants from the recent mast year -...
 
And you thought there were no earthworms in our forests
And you thought there were no earthworms in our forests  And you thought there were no earthworms in our forests
And you thought there were no earthworms in our forests
 
Intro for asm workshop see
Intro for asm workshop seeIntro for asm workshop see
Intro for asm workshop see
 
Asm2018 7 young
Asm2018 7 youngAsm2018 7 young
Asm2018 7 young
 
Asm2018 6 dietze
Asm2018 6 dietzeAsm2018 6 dietze
Asm2018 6 dietze
 
Asm2018 5 yanai
Asm2018 5 yanaiAsm2018 5 yanai
Asm2018 5 yanai
 
Asm2018 4 y.yang
Asm2018 4 y.yangAsm2018 4 y.yang
Asm2018 4 y.yang
 
Asm2018 3 mgreen
Asm2018 3 mgreenAsm2018 3 mgreen
Asm2018 3 mgreen
 

Recently uploaded

HOW DO ORGANISMS REPRODUCE?reproduction part 1
HOW DO ORGANISMS REPRODUCE?reproduction part 1HOW DO ORGANISMS REPRODUCE?reproduction part 1
HOW DO ORGANISMS REPRODUCE?reproduction part 1
Shashank Shekhar Pandey
 
Immersive Learning That Works: Research Grounding and Paths Forward
Immersive Learning That Works: Research Grounding and Paths ForwardImmersive Learning That Works: Research Grounding and Paths Forward
Immersive Learning That Works: Research Grounding and Paths Forward
Leonel Morgado
 
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 6) Chemistry of Proteins
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 6) Chemistry of ProteinsGBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 6) Chemistry of Proteins
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 6) Chemistry of Proteins
Areesha Ahmad
 
waterlessdyeingtechnolgyusing carbon dioxide chemicalspdf
waterlessdyeingtechnolgyusing carbon dioxide chemicalspdfwaterlessdyeingtechnolgyusing carbon dioxide chemicalspdf
waterlessdyeingtechnolgyusing carbon dioxide chemicalspdf
LengamoLAppostilic
 
Applied Science: Thermodynamics, Laws & Methodology.pdf
Applied Science: Thermodynamics, Laws & Methodology.pdfApplied Science: Thermodynamics, Laws & Methodology.pdf
Applied Science: Thermodynamics, Laws & Methodology.pdf
University of Hertfordshire
 
Authoring a personal GPT for your research and practice: How we created the Q...
Authoring a personal GPT for your research and practice: How we created the Q...Authoring a personal GPT for your research and practice: How we created the Q...
Authoring a personal GPT for your research and practice: How we created the Q...
Leonel Morgado
 
Direct Seeded Rice - Climate Smart Agriculture
Direct Seeded Rice - Climate Smart AgricultureDirect Seeded Rice - Climate Smart Agriculture
Direct Seeded Rice - Climate Smart Agriculture
International Food Policy Research Institute- South Asia Office
 
AJAY KUMAR NIET GreNo Guava Project File.pdf
AJAY KUMAR NIET GreNo Guava Project File.pdfAJAY KUMAR NIET GreNo Guava Project File.pdf
AJAY KUMAR NIET GreNo Guava Project File.pdf
AJAY KUMAR
 
Modelo de slide quimica para powerpoint
Modelo  de slide quimica para powerpointModelo  de slide quimica para powerpoint
Modelo de slide quimica para powerpoint
Karen593256
 
Eukaryotic Transcription Presentation.pptx
Eukaryotic Transcription Presentation.pptxEukaryotic Transcription Presentation.pptx
Eukaryotic Transcription Presentation.pptx
RitabrataSarkar3
 
Sciences of Europe journal No 142 (2024)
Sciences of Europe journal No 142 (2024)Sciences of Europe journal No 142 (2024)
Sciences of Europe journal No 142 (2024)
Sciences of Europe
 
23PH301 - Optics - Optical Lenses.pptx
23PH301 - Optics  -  Optical Lenses.pptx23PH301 - Optics  -  Optical Lenses.pptx
23PH301 - Optics - Optical Lenses.pptx
RDhivya6
 
Describing and Interpreting an Immersive Learning Case with the Immersion Cub...
Describing and Interpreting an Immersive Learning Case with the Immersion Cub...Describing and Interpreting an Immersive Learning Case with the Immersion Cub...
Describing and Interpreting an Immersive Learning Case with the Immersion Cub...
Leonel Morgado
 
ESR spectroscopy in liquid food and beverages.pptx
ESR spectroscopy in liquid food and beverages.pptxESR spectroscopy in liquid food and beverages.pptx
ESR spectroscopy in liquid food and beverages.pptx
PRIYANKA PATEL
 
Randomised Optimisation Algorithms in DAPHNE
Randomised Optimisation Algorithms in DAPHNERandomised Optimisation Algorithms in DAPHNE
Randomised Optimisation Algorithms in DAPHNE
University of Maribor
 
8.Isolation of pure cultures and preservation of cultures.pdf
8.Isolation of pure cultures and preservation of cultures.pdf8.Isolation of pure cultures and preservation of cultures.pdf
8.Isolation of pure cultures and preservation of cultures.pdf
by6843629
 
Juaristi, Jon. - El canon espanol. El legado de la cultura española a la civi...
Juaristi, Jon. - El canon espanol. El legado de la cultura española a la civi...Juaristi, Jon. - El canon espanol. El legado de la cultura española a la civi...
Juaristi, Jon. - El canon espanol. El legado de la cultura española a la civi...
frank0071
 
The cost of acquiring information by natural selection
The cost of acquiring information by natural selectionThe cost of acquiring information by natural selection
The cost of acquiring information by natural selection
Carl Bergstrom
 
在线办理(salfor毕业证书)索尔福德大学毕业证毕业完成信一模一样
在线办理(salfor毕业证书)索尔福德大学毕业证毕业完成信一模一样在线办理(salfor毕业证书)索尔福德大学毕业证毕业完成信一模一样
在线办理(salfor毕业证书)索尔福德大学毕业证毕业完成信一模一样
vluwdy49
 
The debris of the ‘last major merger’ is dynamically young
The debris of the ‘last major merger’ is dynamically youngThe debris of the ‘last major merger’ is dynamically young
The debris of the ‘last major merger’ is dynamically young
Sérgio Sacani
 

Recently uploaded (20)

HOW DO ORGANISMS REPRODUCE?reproduction part 1
HOW DO ORGANISMS REPRODUCE?reproduction part 1HOW DO ORGANISMS REPRODUCE?reproduction part 1
HOW DO ORGANISMS REPRODUCE?reproduction part 1
 
Immersive Learning That Works: Research Grounding and Paths Forward
Immersive Learning That Works: Research Grounding and Paths ForwardImmersive Learning That Works: Research Grounding and Paths Forward
Immersive Learning That Works: Research Grounding and Paths Forward
 
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 6) Chemistry of Proteins
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 6) Chemistry of ProteinsGBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 6) Chemistry of Proteins
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 6) Chemistry of Proteins
 
waterlessdyeingtechnolgyusing carbon dioxide chemicalspdf
waterlessdyeingtechnolgyusing carbon dioxide chemicalspdfwaterlessdyeingtechnolgyusing carbon dioxide chemicalspdf
waterlessdyeingtechnolgyusing carbon dioxide chemicalspdf
 
Applied Science: Thermodynamics, Laws & Methodology.pdf
Applied Science: Thermodynamics, Laws & Methodology.pdfApplied Science: Thermodynamics, Laws & Methodology.pdf
Applied Science: Thermodynamics, Laws & Methodology.pdf
 
Authoring a personal GPT for your research and practice: How we created the Q...
Authoring a personal GPT for your research and practice: How we created the Q...Authoring a personal GPT for your research and practice: How we created the Q...
Authoring a personal GPT for your research and practice: How we created the Q...
 
Direct Seeded Rice - Climate Smart Agriculture
Direct Seeded Rice - Climate Smart AgricultureDirect Seeded Rice - Climate Smart Agriculture
Direct Seeded Rice - Climate Smart Agriculture
 
AJAY KUMAR NIET GreNo Guava Project File.pdf
AJAY KUMAR NIET GreNo Guava Project File.pdfAJAY KUMAR NIET GreNo Guava Project File.pdf
AJAY KUMAR NIET GreNo Guava Project File.pdf
 
Modelo de slide quimica para powerpoint
Modelo  de slide quimica para powerpointModelo  de slide quimica para powerpoint
Modelo de slide quimica para powerpoint
 
Eukaryotic Transcription Presentation.pptx
Eukaryotic Transcription Presentation.pptxEukaryotic Transcription Presentation.pptx
Eukaryotic Transcription Presentation.pptx
 
Sciences of Europe journal No 142 (2024)
Sciences of Europe journal No 142 (2024)Sciences of Europe journal No 142 (2024)
Sciences of Europe journal No 142 (2024)
 
23PH301 - Optics - Optical Lenses.pptx
23PH301 - Optics  -  Optical Lenses.pptx23PH301 - Optics  -  Optical Lenses.pptx
23PH301 - Optics - Optical Lenses.pptx
 
Describing and Interpreting an Immersive Learning Case with the Immersion Cub...
Describing and Interpreting an Immersive Learning Case with the Immersion Cub...Describing and Interpreting an Immersive Learning Case with the Immersion Cub...
Describing and Interpreting an Immersive Learning Case with the Immersion Cub...
 
ESR spectroscopy in liquid food and beverages.pptx
ESR spectroscopy in liquid food and beverages.pptxESR spectroscopy in liquid food and beverages.pptx
ESR spectroscopy in liquid food and beverages.pptx
 
Randomised Optimisation Algorithms in DAPHNE
Randomised Optimisation Algorithms in DAPHNERandomised Optimisation Algorithms in DAPHNE
Randomised Optimisation Algorithms in DAPHNE
 
8.Isolation of pure cultures and preservation of cultures.pdf
8.Isolation of pure cultures and preservation of cultures.pdf8.Isolation of pure cultures and preservation of cultures.pdf
8.Isolation of pure cultures and preservation of cultures.pdf
 
Juaristi, Jon. - El canon espanol. El legado de la cultura española a la civi...
Juaristi, Jon. - El canon espanol. El legado de la cultura española a la civi...Juaristi, Jon. - El canon espanol. El legado de la cultura española a la civi...
Juaristi, Jon. - El canon espanol. El legado de la cultura española a la civi...
 
The cost of acquiring information by natural selection
The cost of acquiring information by natural selectionThe cost of acquiring information by natural selection
The cost of acquiring information by natural selection
 
在线办理(salfor毕业证书)索尔福德大学毕业证毕业完成信一模一样
在线办理(salfor毕业证书)索尔福德大学毕业证毕业完成信一模一样在线办理(salfor毕业证书)索尔福德大学毕业证毕业完成信一模一样
在线办理(salfor毕业证书)索尔福德大学毕业证毕业完成信一模一样
 
The debris of the ‘last major merger’ is dynamically young
The debris of the ‘last major merger’ is dynamically youngThe debris of the ‘last major merger’ is dynamically young
The debris of the ‘last major merger’ is dynamically young
 

What is co-limitation, really?

  • 1. What is co-limitation, really? Team Shoestring: Joel Blum Tim Fahey Melany Fisk Christy Goodale Shinjini Goswami Mariann Johnston Ed Rastetter Craig See Matt Vadeboncoeur Adam Wild Ruth Yanai And many, many more!
  • 2. Nutrient limitation of productivity Elser et al. (2007) Ecology Letters • Syntheses of fertilization studies predict N and P co-limitation
  • 3. Nutrient limitation of productivity • Syntheses of fertilization studies predict N and P co-limitation • Defined by the way we detect it: larger productivity response to N+P together than to either alone • What underlies that treatment response? – Additive – Synergistic NP NPCon NP NPCon
  • 4. General Project Questions 1. Is productivity in the northern hardwood forest co-limited by N and P? 2. Do soil nutrient interactions contribute to co-limitation?
  • 5. Mid-age forest Mature forest Young: 15-20 yrs Mid-age: 35-40 yrs Mature: 100+ yrs Study Sites
  • 6. 3 sites: •Jeffers Brook •HBEF •BEF 2 stands per site: 1 mid-age 1 mature 9 stands at BEF: 3 young 3 mid-age 3 mature Study Sites
  • 7. Study Sites 4 (sometimes 5) plots per stand
  • 8. Treatments (And sometimes Ca) N (30 kg/ha/yr) P (10 kg/ha/yr) N+P Control • DBH (trees > 10 cm) and soil processes quantified pre- and post-treatment
  • 9. General Project Questions 1. Is productivity in the northern hardwood forest co-limited by N and P? - no (varies, but mostly P-limited) 2. Do soil nutrient interactions contribute to co-limitation?
  • 10. Interactions between soil N and P availability Soil solution Organic nutrients Microorganisms Plants Leaching Resin strips measure what’s in soil solution
  • 11. Interactions between soil N and P availability
  • 12. • Threshold P, above which N is very low • Plant and microbial evidence suggest that microbial uptake of N suppresses availability to plants Interactions between soil N and P availability
  • 13. Interactions between soil N and P availability Soil solution Organic nutrients Microorganisms Plants Leaching P P N P N • Microbial uptake of N suppresses availability to plants • Expect plant productivity in NP plots to begin to exceed that in P plots • Co-limitation?
  • 14. Conclusions 1. Is productivity in the northern hardwood forest co-limited by N and P? - no 2. Do soil nutrient interactions contribute to co-limitation? - if “co-limitation” is detected, it will be sequential - arising from nutrient interactions, rather than simultaneous limitations by multiple nutrients 3. New hypothesis: alleviating microbial P limitation induces N limitation over time 1. predict that plant and microbial responses to N+P will soon exceed those to P