Creativity#2: Creativity Development
Tathagat Varma
Knowledgepreneur
http://thoughtleadership.in
Why research in creativity has
been neglected?
  Traditional belief that creativity was hereditary, and
hence, nothing could be done to make some “Creative”
  It was believed that only a few people had the ability to
create, so no need to focus on that minority
  Hard workers were more likely to be successful than the
creative types, and hence little incentive there.
  Creative people were considered “sex inappropriate”,
and hence focus more on “practical” skills
  Creativity is difficult to study and measure
Child Development – Elizabeth Hurlock
Hurlock
  Creativity is making something new and different, and thus unique (even if others
might have made something very similar)
  However, creativity doesn’t always (have to) lead to products that can be observed
and judged. E.g., in daydreaming
  Hence creativity is more of a process – it is the act of producing than the end result
of the act!
  Creativity is more goal-directed, even though the goal might be no more than the
immediate pleasure the person derives from the activities.
  Requires “divergent thinking” (Guilford) while conformity and everyday problem
solving comes from convergent thinking
  Creativity is often synonymous with imagination and fantasy, and is a form of
mental play. A form of controlled imagination.
  The ability to create depends on the acquisition of accepted knowledge.
Is Creativity inherited?
  It was earlier believed that creativity was inherited, and
nothing needs to be done to develop it – it will develop
“automatically”
  However, now we recognize that all children have the
potential to be creative, though they differ in the
degree of creativity they possess
  In 2009, a HBR study published that Creativity is 20%
inherited and 80% learned behavior.
  Recent research seems to suggest that heredity might
have little more role than thought previously!
Is Creativity same as
Intelligence?
  Creativity makes use of knowledge previously acquired,
and hence depends on the intellectual capabilities of
the individual
  To that end, there is a positive correlation
  However, we do see exceptions!
Creativity Syndrome
  A cluster of related traits among the creative people
  Flexibility, nonconformity, need for autonomy, need for
independence, high aspiration, self-discipline,
playfulness, liking the manipulation of ideas,
assertiveness, reserve, self-assurance, sense of humor,
open-mindedness, intellectual persistence, self-
confidence, curiosity, enjoyment of calculated risk
when success depends on own ability, sex-inappropriate
interests, timidity in social situations, preference for
fantasy over real adventures, venturesomeness, and
pursuit of self-chosen interests
Critical Periods in
Development of Creativity
  5-6 years: getting ready to school, they must learn to accept
authority – the more stricter it is, the more it could stifle
creativity
  8-10 years: desire to be accepted by the social group forces
conformance to the group’s set norms
  13-15 years: peer acceptance, especially from opposite sex,
controls the adolescent behavior
  17-19 years: preparation for the vocation could require
conforming to a standard pattern
  Normally peak during 30s and 40s, and either pleateu or
gradually decline
Variations in Creativity
  Gender:
  Socioeconomic Status:
  Ordinal Position:
  Family Size:
  Urban vs Rural:
  Intelligence:
Variations in Creativity
  Gender: Boys show greater creativity than girls,
especially as childhood advances – perhaps because of
how they are treated differently than girls (e.g., take
risks, be more independent, take more initiative, etc.)
Variations in Creativity
  Socioeconomic Status: children from higher
socioeconomic status tends to be more creative –
however more due to democratic child-training than
authoritarian training, and environmental factors /
access to resources
Variations in Creativity
  Ordinal Position: order of birth seems to have an
impact on creativity –not because of hereditary reasons
but more because of environmental ones.
  Middle, later-born and only children are likely to be
more creative than the first-born!
  Typically, first-born is subjected to more pressure to
confirm to parental expectations, which encourage a
child to be a “conformer” rather than a “creator”
Variations in Creativity
  Family Size: by and large, children form small families
tend to be more creative
  In large families, authoritarian child-training controls
and less favorable socioeconomic conditions are more
likely to prevail and mitigate against the development
of creativity.
Variations in Creativity
  Urban vs Rural: Children from urban environments
tend to be more creative.
  It could be attributed, in general, to authrotarian
training beong more common in rural homes, and also
the rural environment offering less stimulation than
the large environments of cities
Variations in Creativity
  Intelligence: at every age, brighter children show more
creativity compared to their peers.
Conditions that foster
creativity
  Time: have low regimentation to provide for free time to play and try out things
  Solitude: away from pressures imposed by the social groups
  Encouragement: unconditional encouragement free from criticism and ridicule
  Materials: materials to play with and stimulate experimentation and exploration
  Stimulating Environment: providing the environment of encourage and support
Unpossessive Parent-Child Relationhsip: Balance between overprotective and
overpossessive
  Child-training methods: Democratic and permissive child training at home and
school
  Opportunities to acquire knowledge: Create opportunities to acquire the
knowledge to build the foundations for further creativity
Expression of Creativity in
Childhood
  Animism: tendency to ascribe consciousness to inanimate objects. Begins ~2 years
and peaks ~4-5 years before rapidly disappearing as the child enters school
  Dramatic Play: parallels the animistic thinking, and they accept and assign roles
and play them out. Generally tapers off while entering school, unless considered ok
in thire social groups. Mostly reproductive.
  Constructive Play: When children lost interest in dramatic play, the turn to
constructive play, e.g. making things (from mud, clay, blocks, paper, etc.) and
drawing. Initially, it is mostly reproductive, and mostly solitary.
  Imaginary Companions: could be a person, or animal or something a child creates
in fantasy to play the role of companion, though most tend to be of their own age
and sex, have a name and obey the child! Found more prevalent in brighter
children, but most common in timid or sensitive, etc.
  Daydreaming: A form of mental play, usually called “fantasy”, it provides an escape
or defensive mechanism from unsatisfying reality, with the dreamer mostly being
the central character. It peaks around puberty.
Expression of Creativity in
Childhood
  White Lies: a white lie is a falsehood that the person telling actually believes
in, and not the same as an adult lying. The intent is not to deceive others, but
self aggrandizement, as opposed to lied that are for self-protection.
  Humor: ability to perceive something comic and to produce it, could show a
level of personal adjustment but also has a high creative quotiant
  Storytelling: starts as reproductive initially, and later on become creative.
Tends to be more with those who have had imaginary companions. Is also less
prone to criticism, compared to say, drawing, this creating better social
interactions.
  Aspirations for Achievement: aspirations for achievement, though unrealistic
initially, tend to help a child make personal and social adjustments, and also
limit the “impossible dreamer”
  Concepts of Ideal Self: what would they rather be, their physical self-concepts
and psychological self-concepts, they provide for better social adjustment
opportunities
Hazards to Creativity
  Failure to Stimulate Creativity
  Inability to Detect Creativity in Time
  Unfavorable Social Attitudes towards Creativity
  Unfavorable Home Conditions
  Unfavorable School Conditions
  Excessive Daydreaming
Recap
  Early childhood activities might appear to be
innocuous, or cute or sometimes even crazy to us
grownups, but they have a significant role in personal
and social development and adjustment of children.
  In addition, it has a huge impact on creativity
development among children.
  While there might be some hereditary influence on the
innate intelligence, the environmental factors have a
majority influence on the early development of
creativity in a child, and hence extremely important.
  In next class, we will discuss the creative process.
References
http://brainpickings.org/2013/09/06/what-is-creativity/
http://osho.com/highlights-of-oshos-world/what-is-creativity
http://www.ted.com/topics/creativity
http://hbr.org/topic/creativity
http://www.coursera.org/learn/creativity-innovation
http://www.coursera.org/learn/ignite-creativity
http://www.entrepreneur.com/topic/creativity
http://www.coursera.org/learn/creative-problem-solving
http://www.quora.com/The-Arts-What-standards-are-used-to-determine-if-something-is-
creative-or-not-and-what-triggers-inspiration
  The Sources of Creativity and Innovation, http://www.fpspi.org/pdf/innovcreativity.pdf
References
  For a more creative brain, follow these 5 steps,
http://jamesclear.com/five-step-creative-process
  It’s time to bury the idea of the Lone Genius
Innovator,
https://hbr.org/2016/04/its-time-to-bury-the-idea-of-
the-lone-genius-innovator
Books
  Orbiting the Giant Hairball – A Corporate Fool’s
Guide to Surviving with Grace, Gordon MacKenzie
  A Whack on the Side of the Head – How You Can be
More Creative, Roger Von Oech
  The Little Prince, Antoine de Saint-Exupery
  A Technique for Producing Ideas: the simple five-step
formula anyone can use to be more creative in business
& in life!, James Webb Young
  Child Development – Elizabeth Hurlock

Lecture 2: Creativity Development

  • 1.
    Creativity#2: Creativity Development TathagatVarma Knowledgepreneur http://thoughtleadership.in
  • 2.
    Why research increativity has been neglected?   Traditional belief that creativity was hereditary, and hence, nothing could be done to make some “Creative”   It was believed that only a few people had the ability to create, so no need to focus on that minority   Hard workers were more likely to be successful than the creative types, and hence little incentive there.   Creative people were considered “sex inappropriate”, and hence focus more on “practical” skills   Creativity is difficult to study and measure Child Development – Elizabeth Hurlock
  • 3.
    Hurlock   Creativity ismaking something new and different, and thus unique (even if others might have made something very similar)   However, creativity doesn’t always (have to) lead to products that can be observed and judged. E.g., in daydreaming   Hence creativity is more of a process – it is the act of producing than the end result of the act!   Creativity is more goal-directed, even though the goal might be no more than the immediate pleasure the person derives from the activities.   Requires “divergent thinking” (Guilford) while conformity and everyday problem solving comes from convergent thinking   Creativity is often synonymous with imagination and fantasy, and is a form of mental play. A form of controlled imagination.   The ability to create depends on the acquisition of accepted knowledge.
  • 4.
    Is Creativity inherited?  It was earlier believed that creativity was inherited, and nothing needs to be done to develop it – it will develop “automatically”   However, now we recognize that all children have the potential to be creative, though they differ in the degree of creativity they possess   In 2009, a HBR study published that Creativity is 20% inherited and 80% learned behavior.   Recent research seems to suggest that heredity might have little more role than thought previously!
  • 5.
    Is Creativity sameas Intelligence?   Creativity makes use of knowledge previously acquired, and hence depends on the intellectual capabilities of the individual   To that end, there is a positive correlation   However, we do see exceptions!
  • 6.
    Creativity Syndrome   Acluster of related traits among the creative people   Flexibility, nonconformity, need for autonomy, need for independence, high aspiration, self-discipline, playfulness, liking the manipulation of ideas, assertiveness, reserve, self-assurance, sense of humor, open-mindedness, intellectual persistence, self- confidence, curiosity, enjoyment of calculated risk when success depends on own ability, sex-inappropriate interests, timidity in social situations, preference for fantasy over real adventures, venturesomeness, and pursuit of self-chosen interests
  • 7.
    Critical Periods in Developmentof Creativity   5-6 years: getting ready to school, they must learn to accept authority – the more stricter it is, the more it could stifle creativity   8-10 years: desire to be accepted by the social group forces conformance to the group’s set norms   13-15 years: peer acceptance, especially from opposite sex, controls the adolescent behavior   17-19 years: preparation for the vocation could require conforming to a standard pattern   Normally peak during 30s and 40s, and either pleateu or gradually decline
  • 8.
    Variations in Creativity  Gender:   Socioeconomic Status:   Ordinal Position:   Family Size:   Urban vs Rural:   Intelligence:
  • 9.
    Variations in Creativity  Gender: Boys show greater creativity than girls, especially as childhood advances – perhaps because of how they are treated differently than girls (e.g., take risks, be more independent, take more initiative, etc.)
  • 10.
    Variations in Creativity  Socioeconomic Status: children from higher socioeconomic status tends to be more creative – however more due to democratic child-training than authoritarian training, and environmental factors / access to resources
  • 11.
    Variations in Creativity  Ordinal Position: order of birth seems to have an impact on creativity –not because of hereditary reasons but more because of environmental ones.   Middle, later-born and only children are likely to be more creative than the first-born!   Typically, first-born is subjected to more pressure to confirm to parental expectations, which encourage a child to be a “conformer” rather than a “creator”
  • 12.
    Variations in Creativity  Family Size: by and large, children form small families tend to be more creative   In large families, authoritarian child-training controls and less favorable socioeconomic conditions are more likely to prevail and mitigate against the development of creativity.
  • 13.
    Variations in Creativity  Urban vs Rural: Children from urban environments tend to be more creative.   It could be attributed, in general, to authrotarian training beong more common in rural homes, and also the rural environment offering less stimulation than the large environments of cities
  • 14.
    Variations in Creativity  Intelligence: at every age, brighter children show more creativity compared to their peers.
  • 15.
    Conditions that foster creativity  Time: have low regimentation to provide for free time to play and try out things   Solitude: away from pressures imposed by the social groups   Encouragement: unconditional encouragement free from criticism and ridicule   Materials: materials to play with and stimulate experimentation and exploration   Stimulating Environment: providing the environment of encourage and support Unpossessive Parent-Child Relationhsip: Balance between overprotective and overpossessive   Child-training methods: Democratic and permissive child training at home and school   Opportunities to acquire knowledge: Create opportunities to acquire the knowledge to build the foundations for further creativity
  • 16.
    Expression of Creativityin Childhood   Animism: tendency to ascribe consciousness to inanimate objects. Begins ~2 years and peaks ~4-5 years before rapidly disappearing as the child enters school   Dramatic Play: parallels the animistic thinking, and they accept and assign roles and play them out. Generally tapers off while entering school, unless considered ok in thire social groups. Mostly reproductive.   Constructive Play: When children lost interest in dramatic play, the turn to constructive play, e.g. making things (from mud, clay, blocks, paper, etc.) and drawing. Initially, it is mostly reproductive, and mostly solitary.   Imaginary Companions: could be a person, or animal or something a child creates in fantasy to play the role of companion, though most tend to be of their own age and sex, have a name and obey the child! Found more prevalent in brighter children, but most common in timid or sensitive, etc.   Daydreaming: A form of mental play, usually called “fantasy”, it provides an escape or defensive mechanism from unsatisfying reality, with the dreamer mostly being the central character. It peaks around puberty.
  • 17.
    Expression of Creativityin Childhood   White Lies: a white lie is a falsehood that the person telling actually believes in, and not the same as an adult lying. The intent is not to deceive others, but self aggrandizement, as opposed to lied that are for self-protection.   Humor: ability to perceive something comic and to produce it, could show a level of personal adjustment but also has a high creative quotiant   Storytelling: starts as reproductive initially, and later on become creative. Tends to be more with those who have had imaginary companions. Is also less prone to criticism, compared to say, drawing, this creating better social interactions.   Aspirations for Achievement: aspirations for achievement, though unrealistic initially, tend to help a child make personal and social adjustments, and also limit the “impossible dreamer”   Concepts of Ideal Self: what would they rather be, their physical self-concepts and psychological self-concepts, they provide for better social adjustment opportunities
  • 18.
    Hazards to Creativity  Failure to Stimulate Creativity   Inability to Detect Creativity in Time   Unfavorable Social Attitudes towards Creativity   Unfavorable Home Conditions   Unfavorable School Conditions   Excessive Daydreaming
  • 19.
    Recap   Early childhoodactivities might appear to be innocuous, or cute or sometimes even crazy to us grownups, but they have a significant role in personal and social development and adjustment of children.   In addition, it has a huge impact on creativity development among children.   While there might be some hereditary influence on the innate intelligence, the environmental factors have a majority influence on the early development of creativity in a child, and hence extremely important.   In next class, we will discuss the creative process.
  • 20.
  • 21.
    References   For amore creative brain, follow these 5 steps, http://jamesclear.com/five-step-creative-process   It’s time to bury the idea of the Lone Genius Innovator, https://hbr.org/2016/04/its-time-to-bury-the-idea-of- the-lone-genius-innovator
  • 22.
    Books   Orbiting theGiant Hairball – A Corporate Fool’s Guide to Surviving with Grace, Gordon MacKenzie   A Whack on the Side of the Head – How You Can be More Creative, Roger Von Oech   The Little Prince, Antoine de Saint-Exupery   A Technique for Producing Ideas: the simple five-step formula anyone can use to be more creative in business & in life!, James Webb Young   Child Development – Elizabeth Hurlock