Immobilisation and Storage of Nuclear Waste Dr John Roberts Dalton Nuclear Institute The University of Manchester NI Rough Guide to the Nuclear Industry 2010
Radioactive Waste Generation Military programmes Hospitals and research laboratories Nuclear Energy Industry Mining and milling of uranium ores reprocessing of fuel discharged from reactors decommissioning
Massive Source of Energy In an AGR reactor 1 tonne of U is equivalent to 20,000 tonnes of coal In a fast reactor - equivalent to 2,000,000 tonnes of coal A typical nuclear power station requires 40 tonnes of fuel per year - one lorry load per fortnight An equivalent coal power station requires 3,000,000 tonnes per year - two train loads per day
Worldwide Nuclear Industry
UK Radwaste Sources
UK Radwaste Volumes
Nuclear Fuel Cycle Return to customers for final disposal Enrichment Conversion Uranium Ore Natural Uranium All plant requires final decommissioning Recycle Fuel (MOX) Electric Power Reactor Transport Reprocessing Spent Fuel Storage Waste Management Fuel Fabrication Recycled Uranium
Nuclear Reactor Fuel  - Originally uranium metal but now  many variations typically 75 tonnes for 1000 MWe Moderators  - carbon, H 2 O, D 2 O Cladding  - contains fuel and prevents  release of radioactive fission products Coolant  - gas or liquid circulated through core of reactor for heat extraction Control rods  - usually B or Cd with large  σ c  Shield  - usually steel and concrete used for radiation protection and pressure vessel
Magnox Fuel Assembly 1 fuel rod per assembly, Magnox cladding, U metal fuel
PWR Fuel Assembly 264 fuel rods per assembly, Zircaloy cladding, UO 2  fuel
AGR Fuel
Pebble Fuel
Storage of Spent Fuel Spent fuel is highly radioactive and very (thermally) hot Initially stored in ponds at the reactor site Water cools the rods and acts as shielding Can also be stored in dry stores with air cooling
Storage Pond Dungeness storage pond, Kent
Storage Pond THORP storage pond at Sellafield
Water Shielding
Reprocessing Only about 4% of U is burnt up 235 U content reduced to less than 1% Some Pu remains from fission reactions Reprocessing separates the U and Pu from waste products by chopping up the fuel rods and dissolving them in acid U can re-enriched Pu can blended with U to produce MOX fuel
LLW - Wastes not exceeding 4 GBq/t alpha or 12 GBq/t beta/gamma discarded equipment, tools, protective clothing ILW - Above levels of LLW but not significantly heat generating stripped/leached remains of cladding or PCM HLW - Significantly heat generating fission products UK Waste Classification
Challenges of Radioactive Waste
Total Waste Volume 2007
Waste by Activity Total conditioned waste volumes from each business activity Total volume 1,750,000 m 3 57% Commercial Reprocessing 30% Commercial Reactors 9% Research & Development 2% Ministry  of Defence 1% Medical & Industrial <1% Fuel Fabrication & Uranium Enrichment
LLW
Low Level Waste
LLW Container
LLW Repository near Drigg
LLW Repository near Drigg
ILW
Magnox Fuel Assembly 1 fuel rod per assembly, Magnox cladding, U metal fuel
Magnox De-canning
Magnox Swarf
Magnox Swarf
Solid Waste
Transport of Drums
Testing of Drums
Container Testing •  Tests are impact from 25 m and 1000 ˚C  •  Bounding hazards encompassed by these two criteria are: •  building collapse •  roof collapse •  aircraft crash •  train crash •  explosives / explosive gases •  crane failure / aggressive feature •  seismic fault •  train fire •  flammable gases •  explosion •  electrical fire •  package fire •  overheating
Results
HLW
Vitrification of HLW
Storage of Canisters
Nuclear Power Generation 80 year lifetime use of electricity for 1 person generates this much high level waste
Dounreay
Dounreay Shaft
Dounreay Shaft - past Excavated in the 1950s during construction of under sea tunnel for the discharge of low level liquid effluent 4.6m diameter, 65m deep On completion a concrete plug was used to separate the shaft from the tunnel and it was allowed to fill up with groundwater In 1958 the Scottish Office authorised the UKAEA to use the shaft as a disposal facility for radioactive waste More than 11,000 disposals took place until 1977 Environmental legislation has been tightened and the UKAEA are now required to remove all waste from the Shaft
Dounreay Shaft 1984
Borehole Plan
Shaft Platform - Schematic
Shaft Platform - Actual
Shaft - Waste Retrieval The shaft was isolated in 2008 ahead of programme and budget Waste retrieval can now commence Radioactive conditions mean that everything must be done by remote control Complications include -  quantity and diversity of the waste working depth amount of corrosion after 50 years Base of shaft is immersed in 60 m of contaminated water In March 2010 it was announced that waste retrieval will be deferred until the completion of the site license competition
Waste Retrieval Plant
What next ?? HLW and ILW can be successfully immobilised in either cement, glass or bespoke ceramics Where should the waste be moved to for storage (retrievable) or disposal (non-retrievable) ?
Possible Options Disposal in Space Disposal in Ice Sheets Disposal in Subduction Zones Direct Injection Disposal at Sea Sub-seabed Disposal Dilute and Disperse
Probable Options Indefinite Storage Near Surface Disposal (Phased) Deep Disposal Very-deep Borehole Disposal
Underground Storage USA have (de)selected Yucca Mountain South Korea have selected Gyeongju Finland have selected Olkiluoto Sweden has selected Forsmark France, Belgium and Switzerland all have experimental sites
What is the UK doing ? Set up a committee - CoRWM Committee for Radioactive Waste Management Presented recommendations to government in July 2006 Government accepted all the recommendations in November 2006
CoRWM Summary Geological disposal is the best form of long-term management Coupled with safe and secure interim storage Development of volunteerism/partnership approach to secure facility siting Government’s response Accepted CoRWM’s proposal on geological disposal Accepted need for safe and secure interim storage Supportive of exploring the concept of volunteerism/partnership arrangements (recognising that geological/scientific requirements must be met)
Nuclear Decommissioning  Authority Established April 1st 2005 All civil nuclear liabilities Two aims reduce the predicted cost of nuclear clean-up maintain the required skillsbase £70 billion budget
NDA Sites
Hunterston A
Hunterston A Located near West Kilbride, 2 units 160 MWe each, first grid connection 1964, shutdown 1990 Area of 15 hectares Current site end state plans are removal of all waste and buildings to be cleared with the site delicensed, landscaped and available for alternate use Key dates 2006 - Construction of ILW store complete 2014 - All operational ILW retrieval/processing complete 2017 - Entry into care and maintenance stage 2090 - Final site clearance and closure
Hunterston ILW Store
Hunterston ILW Store
Sellafield
Sellafield Located on the West Cumbrian coast, supported the nuclear power programme since the 1940s. Operations include processing of fuels removed from nuclear power stations, mixed oxide (MOX) fuel fabrication and storage of nuclear materials and radioactive wastes Area of 262 hectares Site end state will be decommissioned to passively safe state with plutonium and uranium stored on site
Äspö Hard Rock Laboratory
Multibarrier Concept
Spent Fuel Canister
Phased Disposal Concept
Underground Access
Vault Concept
Very-Deep Borehole Disposal
Drill the first stage of the borehole Insert the casing. Pour in the cement basement. Drill the next stage of the borehole. Insert the casing. Pour in the cement basement Drill the next stage of the borehole Constructing the Borehole And so on, down to > 4 kms 0.6 - 0.8 m diameter Constructing the Borehole Drill the first stage of the borehole Insert the casing Pour in the cement basement Drill the next stage of the borehole Insert the casing Pour in the cement basement Drill the next stage of the borehole And so on, down to > 4 km
Placement of Canisters Insert the casing Insert the canisters Pour in the grout and allow it to set Placement of Canisters Insert the casing Insert the canisters Pour in the grout  and allow it to set
Separation of Canisters Insert Bentonite clay Insert another stack of canisters Repeat until the bottom km of the borehole is filled 4 kms Separation of Canisters Insert Bentonite clay Insert another stack of canisters Repeat until the bottom km of the  borehole is filled
Sealing the Borehole Pour in some backfill (crushed granite) Insert heater and seal the borehole Pour in more backfill and seal the borehole again 3 km deep (topmost canister) Fill the rest of the borehole with backfill Sealing the Borehole 3 km deep (topmost canister) Pour in some backfill (crushed granite) Insert heater and seal the borehole Pour in more backfill and seal the  borehole again Fill the rest of the borehole with backfill
Natural Analogues I Isolating Clay 50 ancient tree stumps found  preserved in Dunarobba, Italy Trees had grown 1.5 million years ago They had not yet begun to rot Clay isolated them from oxygen and water
Natural Analogues II Canadian deposit/repository Cigar Lake uranium deposit lies 430m below ground Thickness 1- 20 m Width 50 -100 m Length 2 km Surrounded by clay there is  there no radiological trace  at the surface
Natural Analogues III Fossil Reactors Most famous is in Oklo, Gabon A layer of uranium ore is sandwiched between sandstone and granite. Water trickling through moderated the neutrons allowing fission of the uranium A chain reaction occurred until the water was boiled away Reactor worked on and off for more than a million years HLW created held in place by the rocks, Pu had only travelled 3m in almost two billion years
Useful Websites http://www.nltv.co.uk http://www.nuclearliaison.com http://www.rwin.org.uk http://www.corwm.org.uk http://www.nda.gov.uk http://www.sellafield.com http://www.nuclearinst-ygn.com

Immobilisation and Storage of Nuclear Waste

  • 1.
    Immobilisation and Storageof Nuclear Waste Dr John Roberts Dalton Nuclear Institute The University of Manchester NI Rough Guide to the Nuclear Industry 2010
  • 2.
    Radioactive Waste GenerationMilitary programmes Hospitals and research laboratories Nuclear Energy Industry Mining and milling of uranium ores reprocessing of fuel discharged from reactors decommissioning
  • 3.
    Massive Source ofEnergy In an AGR reactor 1 tonne of U is equivalent to 20,000 tonnes of coal In a fast reactor - equivalent to 2,000,000 tonnes of coal A typical nuclear power station requires 40 tonnes of fuel per year - one lorry load per fortnight An equivalent coal power station requires 3,000,000 tonnes per year - two train loads per day
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
    Nuclear Fuel CycleReturn to customers for final disposal Enrichment Conversion Uranium Ore Natural Uranium All plant requires final decommissioning Recycle Fuel (MOX) Electric Power Reactor Transport Reprocessing Spent Fuel Storage Waste Management Fuel Fabrication Recycled Uranium
  • 8.
    Nuclear Reactor Fuel - Originally uranium metal but now many variations typically 75 tonnes for 1000 MWe Moderators - carbon, H 2 O, D 2 O Cladding - contains fuel and prevents release of radioactive fission products Coolant - gas or liquid circulated through core of reactor for heat extraction Control rods - usually B or Cd with large σ c Shield - usually steel and concrete used for radiation protection and pressure vessel
  • 9.
    Magnox Fuel Assembly1 fuel rod per assembly, Magnox cladding, U metal fuel
  • 10.
    PWR Fuel Assembly264 fuel rods per assembly, Zircaloy cladding, UO 2 fuel
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
    Storage of SpentFuel Spent fuel is highly radioactive and very (thermally) hot Initially stored in ponds at the reactor site Water cools the rods and acts as shielding Can also be stored in dry stores with air cooling
  • 14.
    Storage Pond Dungenessstorage pond, Kent
  • 15.
    Storage Pond THORPstorage pond at Sellafield
  • 16.
  • 17.
    Reprocessing Only about4% of U is burnt up 235 U content reduced to less than 1% Some Pu remains from fission reactions Reprocessing separates the U and Pu from waste products by chopping up the fuel rods and dissolving them in acid U can re-enriched Pu can blended with U to produce MOX fuel
  • 18.
    LLW - Wastesnot exceeding 4 GBq/t alpha or 12 GBq/t beta/gamma discarded equipment, tools, protective clothing ILW - Above levels of LLW but not significantly heat generating stripped/leached remains of cladding or PCM HLW - Significantly heat generating fission products UK Waste Classification
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
    Waste by ActivityTotal conditioned waste volumes from each business activity Total volume 1,750,000 m 3 57% Commercial Reprocessing 30% Commercial Reactors 9% Research & Development 2% Ministry of Defence 1% Medical & Industrial <1% Fuel Fabrication & Uranium Enrichment
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28.
    Magnox Fuel Assembly1 fuel rod per assembly, Magnox cladding, U metal fuel
  • 29.
  • 30.
  • 31.
  • 32.
  • 33.
  • 34.
  • 35.
    Container Testing • Tests are impact from 25 m and 1000 ˚C • Bounding hazards encompassed by these two criteria are: • building collapse • roof collapse • aircraft crash • train crash • explosives / explosive gases • crane failure / aggressive feature • seismic fault • train fire • flammable gases • explosion • electrical fire • package fire • overheating
  • 36.
  • 37.
  • 38.
  • 39.
  • 40.
    Nuclear Power Generation80 year lifetime use of electricity for 1 person generates this much high level waste
  • 41.
  • 42.
  • 43.
    Dounreay Shaft -past Excavated in the 1950s during construction of under sea tunnel for the discharge of low level liquid effluent 4.6m diameter, 65m deep On completion a concrete plug was used to separate the shaft from the tunnel and it was allowed to fill up with groundwater In 1958 the Scottish Office authorised the UKAEA to use the shaft as a disposal facility for radioactive waste More than 11,000 disposals took place until 1977 Environmental legislation has been tightened and the UKAEA are now required to remove all waste from the Shaft
  • 44.
  • 45.
  • 46.
  • 47.
  • 48.
    Shaft - WasteRetrieval The shaft was isolated in 2008 ahead of programme and budget Waste retrieval can now commence Radioactive conditions mean that everything must be done by remote control Complications include - quantity and diversity of the waste working depth amount of corrosion after 50 years Base of shaft is immersed in 60 m of contaminated water In March 2010 it was announced that waste retrieval will be deferred until the completion of the site license competition
  • 49.
  • 50.
    What next ??HLW and ILW can be successfully immobilised in either cement, glass or bespoke ceramics Where should the waste be moved to for storage (retrievable) or disposal (non-retrievable) ?
  • 51.
    Possible Options Disposalin Space Disposal in Ice Sheets Disposal in Subduction Zones Direct Injection Disposal at Sea Sub-seabed Disposal Dilute and Disperse
  • 52.
    Probable Options IndefiniteStorage Near Surface Disposal (Phased) Deep Disposal Very-deep Borehole Disposal
  • 53.
    Underground Storage USAhave (de)selected Yucca Mountain South Korea have selected Gyeongju Finland have selected Olkiluoto Sweden has selected Forsmark France, Belgium and Switzerland all have experimental sites
  • 54.
    What is theUK doing ? Set up a committee - CoRWM Committee for Radioactive Waste Management Presented recommendations to government in July 2006 Government accepted all the recommendations in November 2006
  • 55.
    CoRWM Summary Geologicaldisposal is the best form of long-term management Coupled with safe and secure interim storage Development of volunteerism/partnership approach to secure facility siting Government’s response Accepted CoRWM’s proposal on geological disposal Accepted need for safe and secure interim storage Supportive of exploring the concept of volunteerism/partnership arrangements (recognising that geological/scientific requirements must be met)
  • 56.
    Nuclear Decommissioning Authority Established April 1st 2005 All civil nuclear liabilities Two aims reduce the predicted cost of nuclear clean-up maintain the required skillsbase £70 billion budget
  • 57.
  • 58.
  • 59.
    Hunterston A Locatednear West Kilbride, 2 units 160 MWe each, first grid connection 1964, shutdown 1990 Area of 15 hectares Current site end state plans are removal of all waste and buildings to be cleared with the site delicensed, landscaped and available for alternate use Key dates 2006 - Construction of ILW store complete 2014 - All operational ILW retrieval/processing complete 2017 - Entry into care and maintenance stage 2090 - Final site clearance and closure
  • 60.
  • 61.
  • 62.
  • 63.
    Sellafield Located onthe West Cumbrian coast, supported the nuclear power programme since the 1940s. Operations include processing of fuels removed from nuclear power stations, mixed oxide (MOX) fuel fabrication and storage of nuclear materials and radioactive wastes Area of 262 hectares Site end state will be decommissioned to passively safe state with plutonium and uranium stored on site
  • 64.
    Äspö Hard RockLaboratory
  • 65.
  • 66.
  • 67.
  • 68.
  • 69.
  • 70.
  • 71.
    Drill the firststage of the borehole Insert the casing. Pour in the cement basement. Drill the next stage of the borehole. Insert the casing. Pour in the cement basement Drill the next stage of the borehole Constructing the Borehole And so on, down to > 4 kms 0.6 - 0.8 m diameter Constructing the Borehole Drill the first stage of the borehole Insert the casing Pour in the cement basement Drill the next stage of the borehole Insert the casing Pour in the cement basement Drill the next stage of the borehole And so on, down to > 4 km
  • 72.
    Placement of CanistersInsert the casing Insert the canisters Pour in the grout and allow it to set Placement of Canisters Insert the casing Insert the canisters Pour in the grout and allow it to set
  • 73.
    Separation of CanistersInsert Bentonite clay Insert another stack of canisters Repeat until the bottom km of the borehole is filled 4 kms Separation of Canisters Insert Bentonite clay Insert another stack of canisters Repeat until the bottom km of the borehole is filled
  • 74.
    Sealing the BoreholePour in some backfill (crushed granite) Insert heater and seal the borehole Pour in more backfill and seal the borehole again 3 km deep (topmost canister) Fill the rest of the borehole with backfill Sealing the Borehole 3 km deep (topmost canister) Pour in some backfill (crushed granite) Insert heater and seal the borehole Pour in more backfill and seal the borehole again Fill the rest of the borehole with backfill
  • 75.
    Natural Analogues IIsolating Clay 50 ancient tree stumps found preserved in Dunarobba, Italy Trees had grown 1.5 million years ago They had not yet begun to rot Clay isolated them from oxygen and water
  • 76.
    Natural Analogues IICanadian deposit/repository Cigar Lake uranium deposit lies 430m below ground Thickness 1- 20 m Width 50 -100 m Length 2 km Surrounded by clay there is there no radiological trace at the surface
  • 77.
    Natural Analogues IIIFossil Reactors Most famous is in Oklo, Gabon A layer of uranium ore is sandwiched between sandstone and granite. Water trickling through moderated the neutrons allowing fission of the uranium A chain reaction occurred until the water was boiled away Reactor worked on and off for more than a million years HLW created held in place by the rocks, Pu had only travelled 3m in almost two billion years
  • 78.
    Useful Websites http://www.nltv.co.ukhttp://www.nuclearliaison.com http://www.rwin.org.uk http://www.corwm.org.uk http://www.nda.gov.uk http://www.sellafield.com http://www.nuclearinst-ygn.com