www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
Flash down the plan
Damien Caldwell
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
So what is this all about
In 2010, Steve Jobs banished Adobe Flash from the
iPhone
July 2017 Adobe itself has finally conceded: giving the
end of 2020 as its end-of-life date
“We encourage content creators to migrate any existing Flash
content to these new open formats by 2020”
Adobe
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
HTML5 v Flash
Comparing HTML5 & Flash is like comparing Microsoft Excel & Adobe
Photoshop
Feature HTML5 Flash
Requires a “player” to be installed No Yes
Runs on mobile devices Yes Selective
Running speed on different platforms High Slow
Supported by iOS Yes No
Different experience based on the browser Yes No
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
It’ s not a simple case of clicking CONVERT
browser support
lms support
interaction
conversions
video format
optimisation
source files
accessibility
security
design
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
The process
1
Audit
2
Prioritise
3
Estimate
4
Reprioritise
5
Migrate
6
Test
Success factor: Assign a PM to take the strain
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
1
Audit
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
ID Title –
Level
Pub.
Location
Source Flash
%
LMS Mthly
Users
Tool Duration Level of
interactivity
(H, M,L)
1 Health &
Safety –
Level 1
Internal
LMS
Aurion Server 100%
Flash
ND 52 A SL1 15 mins M
2 Diversity –
n/a
Internal
LMS
Aurion Server 100%
Flash
ND 22 A SL2 25 mins L
3 Manual
Handling –
n/a
Internal
LMS
Internal Server 75%
Flash
LU 300 Code 30 mins H
4 IT Security
– n/a
External
LMS
Unknown Flash &
HTML5
ND 47 Lectora 30 mins H
5 Fire Safety
– Level 2
Internal
LMS
Aurion Server HTML5
only
Totara 33 Capt. 40 mins M
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
1
Audit
Success factor:
• Spend the time to do a comprehensive audit of ALL your content
across all platforms
• Agree your audit criteria
What other criteria might you use?
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
2
Prioritise
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
Priority Course
ID
Active
participants
(monthly)
Compliance Up coming initiative /
demand
Change in strategic
direction
% Flash
1 1 52 No No New policy: Nov 2017 100% core
2 4 47 No Part of induction
25 new starts Oct 2017
No 50% core
Branches to HTML5
3 2 7 Change in legislation due
Jan 2018
No No 50% supplementary only
• Compliance / regulatory requirements
• Up coming initiatives / demand
• Change in strategic direction – editorial review or requirement for new
training
• % Flash content – supplementary Vs core content in the Flash
components
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
2
Prioritise
Success factor:
• Assign a weighting to your criteria
How would you prioritise the transition?
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
3
Estimate
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
Calculate
Sample /
Pilot
E = (b + m + w) / 3
Test
Plan
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
4
Reprioritise
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
Priority Course ID Estimate (days) Test plan score (if available)
1 1 2 9
2 4 1 -
3 2 1 4
Based on:
• Estimations
• Pilot – Test Plan results
In this case the test plan carries a
score of 1 to 9, based on a set of
criteria (Test Plan – step 3).
Only available if course was part of
the pilot @ step 3 or is highly
comparable to another object that
was included in the pilot.
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
5
Migrate
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
5
Migrate
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
6
Test
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
Phased
Release
Device
OS
BrowserAddons
Permissions
6
Test
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
In summary
• Ensure readiness of supporting aspects
• Draw up the priority list of courses to be
converted from Flash to HTML5
• Validate that all assets and prerequisites are in
place
• Understand the pros and cons (the trade-off
between the punch of learning design capability
that Flash offers and what HTML5 can offer)
www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAINING AND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS
Thanks
& Questions

Flash Down the Pan

  • 1.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS Flash down the plan Damien Caldwell
  • 2.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS So what is this all about In 2010, Steve Jobs banished Adobe Flash from the iPhone July 2017 Adobe itself has finally conceded: giving the end of 2020 as its end-of-life date “We encourage content creators to migrate any existing Flash content to these new open formats by 2020” Adobe
  • 3.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS HTML5 v Flash Comparing HTML5 & Flash is like comparing Microsoft Excel & Adobe Photoshop Feature HTML5 Flash Requires a “player” to be installed No Yes Runs on mobile devices Yes Selective Running speed on different platforms High Slow Supported by iOS Yes No Different experience based on the browser Yes No
  • 4.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS It’ s not a simple case of clicking CONVERT browser support lms support interaction conversions video format optimisation source files accessibility security design
  • 5.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS The process 1 Audit 2 Prioritise 3 Estimate 4 Reprioritise 5 Migrate 6 Test Success factor: Assign a PM to take the strain
  • 6.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS 1 Audit
  • 7.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS ID Title – Level Pub. Location Source Flash % LMS Mthly Users Tool Duration Level of interactivity (H, M,L) 1 Health & Safety – Level 1 Internal LMS Aurion Server 100% Flash ND 52 A SL1 15 mins M 2 Diversity – n/a Internal LMS Aurion Server 100% Flash ND 22 A SL2 25 mins L 3 Manual Handling – n/a Internal LMS Internal Server 75% Flash LU 300 Code 30 mins H 4 IT Security – n/a External LMS Unknown Flash & HTML5 ND 47 Lectora 30 mins H 5 Fire Safety – Level 2 Internal LMS Aurion Server HTML5 only Totara 33 Capt. 40 mins M
  • 8.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS 1 Audit Success factor: • Spend the time to do a comprehensive audit of ALL your content across all platforms • Agree your audit criteria What other criteria might you use?
  • 9.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS 2 Prioritise
  • 10.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS Priority Course ID Active participants (monthly) Compliance Up coming initiative / demand Change in strategic direction % Flash 1 1 52 No No New policy: Nov 2017 100% core 2 4 47 No Part of induction 25 new starts Oct 2017 No 50% core Branches to HTML5 3 2 7 Change in legislation due Jan 2018 No No 50% supplementary only • Compliance / regulatory requirements • Up coming initiatives / demand • Change in strategic direction – editorial review or requirement for new training • % Flash content – supplementary Vs core content in the Flash components
  • 11.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS 2 Prioritise Success factor: • Assign a weighting to your criteria How would you prioritise the transition?
  • 12.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS 3 Estimate
  • 13.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS Calculate Sample / Pilot E = (b + m + w) / 3 Test Plan
  • 14.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS 4 Reprioritise
  • 15.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS Priority Course ID Estimate (days) Test plan score (if available) 1 1 2 9 2 4 1 - 3 2 1 4 Based on: • Estimations • Pilot – Test Plan results In this case the test plan carries a score of 1 to 9, based on a set of criteria (Test Plan – step 3). Only available if course was part of the pilot @ step 3 or is highly comparable to another object that was included in the pilot.
  • 16.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS 5 Migrate
  • 17.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS 5 Migrate
  • 18.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS 6 Test
  • 19.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS Phased Release Device OS BrowserAddons Permissions 6 Test
  • 20.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS In summary • Ensure readiness of supporting aspects • Draw up the priority list of courses to be converted from Flash to HTML5 • Validate that all assets and prerequisites are in place • Understand the pros and cons (the trade-off between the punch of learning design capability that Flash offers and what HTML5 can offer)
  • 21.
    www.aurionlearning.comE-LEARNING | TRAININGAND SUPPORT | PLATFORMS Thanks & Questions

Editor's Notes

  • #16 Test Plan Criteria Variables included Additional code, e.g., JavaScript Through conversion how does it compare to the Flash version
  • #21 Ensure readiness of supporting aspects. This includes browser support for HTML5, Learning Management System support for mobile learning solutions, and updates to your security policy. Draw up the priority list of courses to be converted from Flash to HTML5. Begin the migration exercise by picking a small number of courses, migrate, and perform a user testing for the feedback. More significantly, assess if the impact you had envisioned is being created (that is, better learning experience for the learners). Validate that all assets and prerequisites are in place. We often see delays (typically post the pilot phase) on account of all assets not being accounted for and accessible. Again, this must be in place and availability of assets should be in line with the migration project schedule. Understand the pros and cons (the trade-off between the punch of learning design capability that Flash offers and what HTML5 can offer). This is probably the most significant aspect to watch out for. The kind of user experience that HTLML5-based designs offer is different from the Flash-based approach. It is very important to understand this, identify the frames that will have a different user experience and have a clear Instructional Design support in place to map certain frames of legacy Flash courses to HTML5.