Helping Students Achieve Academic SuccessAngela M. Housand, Ph.D.Ahousand@gmail.comConfratute 2008University of Connecticut
Students who are self-regulated learners are “metacognitively, motivationally, and behaviorally active participants in their own learning process”.(Zimmerman, 1989, p. 329)
Active engagement in the learning process produces increases in academic performance.(Ablard & Lipschultz, 1998; Ames, 1984; Corno, 1986, 1989; Dweck, 1986; Schunk & Rice; 1985, 1987, 1991; Zimmerman, 1989; Zimmerman & Martinez-Pons, 1990)
How can we, as educators, help students take personal initiative in the process of learning?
How can we shift the responsibility of learning to students?
How can we help students achieve their potential?
Self-Regulated LearnersCompared with low achieving students, high achievers more frequently: Set specific learning goalsUse a variety of learning strategiesSelf-monitorAdapt their efforts systematicallywww.gifted.uconn.edu/siegle/selfregulation/section4.html
Self-RegulationLearners with high levels ofself-regulation havegood control over theattainment of their goals.
IndividualFactorsPersonal EffortIntrinsic MotivationGoal OrientationSelf-efficacyAgeGender(Blair & Razza, 2007; McWhaw & Abrami, 2001; Miles & Stine-Morrow, 2004; Zimmerman & Martinez-Pons, 1986, 1988, 1990)
	Gifted students tend to be more self-regulated than their average performing peers.Self-Regulated Learners(Zimmerman & Martinez-Pons, 1990)
Self-Regulated LearnersThere still exists a large degree of variation among gifted students in their use of strategies associated with self-regulated learning.(Ablard & Lipschultz, 1998; Risemberg & Zimmerman, 1992; Zimmerman & Martinez-Pons, 1990)
Self-Regulated Learners	This variation may explain why some gifted students become highly productive, contributing members of society and others are in danger of underachievement.
SQuality of WorkQuality of WorkAbilityEffortR2 = .66R2 = .63R2 = .11Quality of WorkQuality of WorkEffortR2 = .52AbilityTeacher Rating of StudentsStudent Self-Rating(Siegle & McCoach)
Self-Regulated LearningSelf-regulation of behaviorControl of resources and environmentSelf-regulation of motivation and affectControl of motivational beliefsSelf-regulation of cognitionControl of various cognitive strategies for learningZimmerman (1989)
Cyclical and Ongoing
When will I start?Where will I work?How will I get started?What will help me?What might hinder me?
Am I accomplishing what I planned to do?Am I being distracted?Is this taking more time than I thought?Am I in a setting where I can accomplish the most?How can I encourage myself to keep working?
Did I accomplish what I planned to do?Was I distracted and how did I get back to work?Did I plan enough time or did it take longer than I thought?In which situation did I accomplish the most work?
The first requisiteof success is the ability to apply your physical and mental energies to one problem without growing weary.-Thomas Edison
http://www.21stcenturyskills.org/
Three Categories ofSelf-Regulation StrategiesPersonal:	How a student organizes and interprets informationBehavioral	Actions that a student takesEnvironmental	Structuring of the physical environment and seeking
Personal SR StrategiesOrganizing and transforming informationOutliningSummarizingRearranging materialsHighlightingFlashcardsDraw pictures, diagrams, chartsWebs/mapping
Personal SR StrategiesGoal setting and planningSequencing, timing, and completingTime managementPacing
Personal SR StrategiesKeeping recordsNote-takingRecording marksPortfolioDrafts of assignments
Personal SR StrategiesSelf-monitoringLists of errors madeReflection logs/JournalsWeekly self-evaluationsSelf-assessment checklists and inventoriesRecording marksTime-on-task analysisPodcast or videoDiscussion with teacher
Personal SR StrategiesRehearsing and memorizingMnemonic devicesTeaching someone else the materialMaking sample questionsVisualizationRepetitionRhyming / RappingCreate Categories
Behavioral SR StrategiesSelf-evaluatingWhat does the teacher want me to do?What do I want out of it?What did I learn today?What did I do well?What am I confused about?What do I need to get help with?What do I still need to do?
Behavioral SR StrategiesSelf-consequatingTreats to motivate (Self-reinforcement)Delay of gratificationArranging or imagining punishment
Environmental SR StrategiesEnvironmental structuringSelecting or arranging the physical settingIsolating; Eliminating or minimizing distractionsShort and frequent study
Environmental SR StrategiesSeeking informationLibrary resourcesInternet resourcesReviewing cardsRereading records, tests, textbooks
Environmental SR StrategiesSeeking assistanceFrom peersFrom teachers or other adultsEmulating exemplary models
Environmental InfluencesOpportunities for help seekingProvision of complex tasksExplicit strategy instructionChoice in and control over activitiesStudent participation in evaluation(Boekaerts & Corno, 2005; DeCorte, Verschaffel, & DeVen, 2001; Folkesson & Swalander, 2007; Hadwin et. al., 2001; Perry, 1998; Perry, Hutchinson, & Thauberger, 2007; Perry, Norby, & VandeKamp, 2003; Perry, Phillips, & Dowler, 2004; Turner, 1995)
Research Tells Us…When the learning environment provides:	Opportunities for help-seeking from resources, peers, and teacherStudents Engage in Self-Regulated Learning Behaviors
Classroom StrategiesSuns and CloudsProvide materialsPost-itsResources (computer, access to media)Opportunities to regain focus:Personal timer (10 minutes)Get up, get a drink, stretch
Research Tells Us…When the learning environment provides:Complex tasks that extend over time, allow for variation in expression style, and integrate multiple processes, both cognitive and proceduralStudents Engage in Self-Regulated Learning Behaviors
Complex TasksStudents responsible for classroom
Cleaning / Organizing
Classroom set-up
Jobs that extend over time
Jobs rotate less frequently
Choice of jobs
Decision-making within jobComplex TasksGive students a purpose for the task
During the process
For completion
Require student reflection
Progress
ProcessClassroom Opportunities for Providing Complex Tasks?
Classroom Opportunities for Providing Complex TasksGroup Projects Independent ProjectsOpen-ended QuestioningInvestigation CentersLearning ContractsActivity Menus
Independent ProjectsAsk the question:Will you be able to stay interested in this topic for an extended period of time?
The first requisiteof success is the ability to apply your physical and mental energies to one problem without growing weary.-Thomas Edison
Independent ProjectsProject Ideas on the Web: 	http://www.gifted.uconn.edu/Siegle/CurriculumCompacting/section14.html
Independent ProjectsPlanning Templates by Googling:  Management PlanWizard Project Maker
Timeline:Start Date
Completion Date
Progress Report            DatesProject Description:What do you hope to find out or learn?
Intended Project(s):In what ways will you share your work?
How, when, and where     will you share and communicate the results of your project with other people?What Format Will Your Project Take? What will your product be?
Getting Started:What skills, resources and materials will I need?Who is the intended audience?
Identifying a Variety of Expression Styles
You Know its Working When…Most students can start to work without any reminders beyond the initial directions.Verbal guidance or environmental reminders of self-regulation strategies is not needed.
You Know its Working When…The activity choices offered demonstrate responsiveness to specific student interests and varied expression styles in product development.The activity choices offered include open-ended options to extend the challenge of previous activities.
You Know its Working When…Most students demonstrate visible enthusiasm and task commitment for their chosen activity.The physical arrangement, organization, and access to resources in the environment enhances activity outcomes.
Open Ended Questioning: A Resource
SEM-R Bookmarks
Research Tells Us…When the learning environment provides:	Explicit strategy instruction, both domain specific and metacognitive strategy instructionStudents Engage in Self-Regulated Learning Behaviors
Domain Explicit StrategiesReading Strategies as an example
Strategies vs. Skillsin ReadingReading skills = instruction in the following:Word identificationFluencyVocabularyComprehensionStudy skillsReading strategies = process where the reader interacts with the text to create meaningCoiro, 1998
Comprehension StrategiesBefore, During, and After ReadingDetermining ImportanceMaking ConnectionsQuestioningMetacognitionMaking InferencesVisualizingSummarizingParis, 2004
Metacognitive Strategy InstructionSelf-Regulation Strategies as an Example
Strategies vs. SkillsSelf-regulation skills = instruction in the following:Eliminating distractionsNote TakingOutliningWebs/MappingCategorizationSelf-regulation strategies = process where individual takes initiative and responsibility for her own success
Self-Regulation StrategiesOrganizingGoal Setting / PlanningRecord KeepingSelf-MonitoringSelf-EvaluatingSelf-ConsequatingSeeking Assistance
Research Tells Us…When the learning environment provides:	Choice and volitional control over processes, timing, challenge level, and outcome or product of learning tasksStudents Engage in Self-Regulated Learning Behaviors
Volitional ControlSet clear expectations in advance
Provide reminders
Bring students attention to their behavior when they lose self-regulationVolitional ControlClassroom structures that provide access to materials
Systems for recurring activities
Restroom / Drink
Library
Opportunities for monitoring behaviorSEM-R: An ExampleThree Phase Reading Enrichment ProgramExtension of Joe Renzulli and Sally Reis’ Schoolwide Enrichment ModelDesigned to promote enjoyment of reading and increase self-regulation in reading
Ground Rules for SIRYou must have a book to readIf you aren’t enjoying a book and have given it a fair chance, ask the teacher to help you choose a new one.Remain in your reading area during SIROnly reading is happeningMinimal quiet talkingDo your best reading the whole time
Student keeping a recordStudent tracking progressStudent assessment of goal attainmentHigher order thinking & metacognitive strategy use
Student reflection on readingStudent participation in assessment and reviewExplicit strategy instructionPurpose for reading and goal settingEfficacy building via specific feedback
Research Tells Us…When the learning environment provides:Opportunities for students participate in the process of evaluating their own work. Students Engage in Self-Regulated Learning Behaviors
Henegar 2005
A Teacher How-toGuide learners’ self-beliefs, goal setting, and expectationsHelp students frame information in a positive mannerProvide specific cues
A Teacher How-toPromote reflective dialogueModeling (e.g. think aloud)Student practiceGroup discussions

Day2 Helping Students... 2009

  • 1.
    Helping Students AchieveAcademic SuccessAngela M. Housand, Ph.D.Ahousand@gmail.comConfratute 2008University of Connecticut
  • 2.
    Students who areself-regulated learners are “metacognitively, motivationally, and behaviorally active participants in their own learning process”.(Zimmerman, 1989, p. 329)
  • 3.
    Active engagement inthe learning process produces increases in academic performance.(Ablard & Lipschultz, 1998; Ames, 1984; Corno, 1986, 1989; Dweck, 1986; Schunk & Rice; 1985, 1987, 1991; Zimmerman, 1989; Zimmerman & Martinez-Pons, 1990)
  • 4.
    How can we,as educators, help students take personal initiative in the process of learning?
  • 5.
    How can weshift the responsibility of learning to students?
  • 6.
    How can wehelp students achieve their potential?
  • 7.
    Self-Regulated LearnersCompared withlow achieving students, high achievers more frequently: Set specific learning goalsUse a variety of learning strategiesSelf-monitorAdapt their efforts systematicallywww.gifted.uconn.edu/siegle/selfregulation/section4.html
  • 8.
    Self-RegulationLearners with highlevels ofself-regulation havegood control over theattainment of their goals.
  • 9.
    IndividualFactorsPersonal EffortIntrinsic MotivationGoalOrientationSelf-efficacyAgeGender(Blair & Razza, 2007; McWhaw & Abrami, 2001; Miles & Stine-Morrow, 2004; Zimmerman & Martinez-Pons, 1986, 1988, 1990)
  • 10.
    Gifted students tendto be more self-regulated than their average performing peers.Self-Regulated Learners(Zimmerman & Martinez-Pons, 1990)
  • 11.
    Self-Regulated LearnersThere stillexists a large degree of variation among gifted students in their use of strategies associated with self-regulated learning.(Ablard & Lipschultz, 1998; Risemberg & Zimmerman, 1992; Zimmerman & Martinez-Pons, 1990)
  • 12.
    Self-Regulated Learners This variationmay explain why some gifted students become highly productive, contributing members of society and others are in danger of underachievement.
  • 13.
    SQuality of WorkQualityof WorkAbilityEffortR2 = .66R2 = .63R2 = .11Quality of WorkQuality of WorkEffortR2 = .52AbilityTeacher Rating of StudentsStudent Self-Rating(Siegle & McCoach)
  • 14.
    Self-Regulated LearningSelf-regulation ofbehaviorControl of resources and environmentSelf-regulation of motivation and affectControl of motivational beliefsSelf-regulation of cognitionControl of various cognitive strategies for learningZimmerman (1989)
  • 15.
  • 16.
    When will Istart?Where will I work?How will I get started?What will help me?What might hinder me?
  • 17.
    Am I accomplishingwhat I planned to do?Am I being distracted?Is this taking more time than I thought?Am I in a setting where I can accomplish the most?How can I encourage myself to keep working?
  • 18.
    Did I accomplishwhat I planned to do?Was I distracted and how did I get back to work?Did I plan enough time or did it take longer than I thought?In which situation did I accomplish the most work?
  • 19.
    The first requisiteofsuccess is the ability to apply your physical and mental energies to one problem without growing weary.-Thomas Edison
  • 20.
  • 21.
    Three Categories ofSelf-RegulationStrategiesPersonal: How a student organizes and interprets informationBehavioral Actions that a student takesEnvironmental Structuring of the physical environment and seeking
  • 22.
    Personal SR StrategiesOrganizingand transforming informationOutliningSummarizingRearranging materialsHighlightingFlashcardsDraw pictures, diagrams, chartsWebs/mapping
  • 23.
    Personal SR StrategiesGoalsetting and planningSequencing, timing, and completingTime managementPacing
  • 24.
    Personal SR StrategiesKeepingrecordsNote-takingRecording marksPortfolioDrafts of assignments
  • 25.
    Personal SR StrategiesSelf-monitoringListsof errors madeReflection logs/JournalsWeekly self-evaluationsSelf-assessment checklists and inventoriesRecording marksTime-on-task analysisPodcast or videoDiscussion with teacher
  • 26.
    Personal SR StrategiesRehearsingand memorizingMnemonic devicesTeaching someone else the materialMaking sample questionsVisualizationRepetitionRhyming / RappingCreate Categories
  • 27.
    Behavioral SR StrategiesSelf-evaluatingWhatdoes the teacher want me to do?What do I want out of it?What did I learn today?What did I do well?What am I confused about?What do I need to get help with?What do I still need to do?
  • 28.
    Behavioral SR StrategiesSelf-consequatingTreatsto motivate (Self-reinforcement)Delay of gratificationArranging or imagining punishment
  • 29.
    Environmental SR StrategiesEnvironmentalstructuringSelecting or arranging the physical settingIsolating; Eliminating or minimizing distractionsShort and frequent study
  • 30.
    Environmental SR StrategiesSeekinginformationLibrary resourcesInternet resourcesReviewing cardsRereading records, tests, textbooks
  • 31.
    Environmental SR StrategiesSeekingassistanceFrom peersFrom teachers or other adultsEmulating exemplary models
  • 32.
    Environmental InfluencesOpportunities forhelp seekingProvision of complex tasksExplicit strategy instructionChoice in and control over activitiesStudent participation in evaluation(Boekaerts & Corno, 2005; DeCorte, Verschaffel, & DeVen, 2001; Folkesson & Swalander, 2007; Hadwin et. al., 2001; Perry, 1998; Perry, Hutchinson, & Thauberger, 2007; Perry, Norby, & VandeKamp, 2003; Perry, Phillips, & Dowler, 2004; Turner, 1995)
  • 33.
    Research Tells Us…Whenthe learning environment provides: Opportunities for help-seeking from resources, peers, and teacherStudents Engage in Self-Regulated Learning Behaviors
  • 35.
    Classroom StrategiesSuns andCloudsProvide materialsPost-itsResources (computer, access to media)Opportunities to regain focus:Personal timer (10 minutes)Get up, get a drink, stretch
  • 36.
    Research Tells Us…Whenthe learning environment provides:Complex tasks that extend over time, allow for variation in expression style, and integrate multiple processes, both cognitive and proceduralStudents Engage in Self-Regulated Learning Behaviors
  • 37.
  • 38.
  • 39.
  • 40.
  • 41.
  • 42.
  • 43.
    Decision-making within jobComplexTasksGive students a purpose for the task
  • 44.
  • 45.
  • 46.
  • 47.
  • 48.
    ProcessClassroom Opportunities forProviding Complex Tasks?
  • 49.
    Classroom Opportunities forProviding Complex TasksGroup Projects Independent ProjectsOpen-ended QuestioningInvestigation CentersLearning ContractsActivity Menus
  • 50.
    Independent ProjectsAsk thequestion:Will you be able to stay interested in this topic for an extended period of time?
  • 51.
    The first requisiteofsuccess is the ability to apply your physical and mental energies to one problem without growing weary.-Thomas Edison
  • 52.
    Independent ProjectsProject Ideason the Web: http://www.gifted.uconn.edu/Siegle/CurriculumCompacting/section14.html
  • 53.
    Independent ProjectsPlanning Templatesby Googling: Management PlanWizard Project Maker
  • 55.
  • 56.
  • 57.
    Progress Report DatesProject Description:What do you hope to find out or learn?
  • 58.
    Intended Project(s):In whatways will you share your work?
  • 59.
    How, when, andwhere will you share and communicate the results of your project with other people?What Format Will Your Project Take? What will your product be?
  • 60.
    Getting Started:What skills,resources and materials will I need?Who is the intended audience?
  • 61.
    Identifying a Varietyof Expression Styles
  • 63.
    You Know itsWorking When…Most students can start to work without any reminders beyond the initial directions.Verbal guidance or environmental reminders of self-regulation strategies is not needed.
  • 64.
    You Know itsWorking When…The activity choices offered demonstrate responsiveness to specific student interests and varied expression styles in product development.The activity choices offered include open-ended options to extend the challenge of previous activities.
  • 65.
    You Know itsWorking When…Most students demonstrate visible enthusiasm and task commitment for their chosen activity.The physical arrangement, organization, and access to resources in the environment enhances activity outcomes.
  • 66.
  • 67.
  • 68.
    Research Tells Us…Whenthe learning environment provides: Explicit strategy instruction, both domain specific and metacognitive strategy instructionStudents Engage in Self-Regulated Learning Behaviors
  • 69.
    Domain Explicit StrategiesReadingStrategies as an example
  • 70.
    Strategies vs. SkillsinReadingReading skills = instruction in the following:Word identificationFluencyVocabularyComprehensionStudy skillsReading strategies = process where the reader interacts with the text to create meaningCoiro, 1998
  • 71.
    Comprehension StrategiesBefore, During,and After ReadingDetermining ImportanceMaking ConnectionsQuestioningMetacognitionMaking InferencesVisualizingSummarizingParis, 2004
  • 72.
  • 73.
    Strategies vs. SkillsSelf-regulationskills = instruction in the following:Eliminating distractionsNote TakingOutliningWebs/MappingCategorizationSelf-regulation strategies = process where individual takes initiative and responsibility for her own success
  • 74.
    Self-Regulation StrategiesOrganizingGoal Setting/ PlanningRecord KeepingSelf-MonitoringSelf-EvaluatingSelf-ConsequatingSeeking Assistance
  • 75.
    Research Tells Us…Whenthe learning environment provides: Choice and volitional control over processes, timing, challenge level, and outcome or product of learning tasksStudents Engage in Self-Regulated Learning Behaviors
  • 76.
    Volitional ControlSet clearexpectations in advance
  • 77.
  • 78.
    Bring students attentionto their behavior when they lose self-regulationVolitional ControlClassroom structures that provide access to materials
  • 79.
  • 80.
  • 81.
  • 82.
    Opportunities for monitoringbehaviorSEM-R: An ExampleThree Phase Reading Enrichment ProgramExtension of Joe Renzulli and Sally Reis’ Schoolwide Enrichment ModelDesigned to promote enjoyment of reading and increase self-regulation in reading
  • 84.
    Ground Rules forSIRYou must have a book to readIf you aren’t enjoying a book and have given it a fair chance, ask the teacher to help you choose a new one.Remain in your reading area during SIROnly reading is happeningMinimal quiet talkingDo your best reading the whole time
  • 87.
    Student keeping arecordStudent tracking progressStudent assessment of goal attainmentHigher order thinking & metacognitive strategy use
  • 88.
    Student reflection onreadingStudent participation in assessment and reviewExplicit strategy instructionPurpose for reading and goal settingEfficacy building via specific feedback
  • 89.
    Research Tells Us…Whenthe learning environment provides:Opportunities for students participate in the process of evaluating their own work. Students Engage in Self-Regulated Learning Behaviors
  • 91.
  • 92.
    A Teacher How-toGuidelearners’ self-beliefs, goal setting, and expectationsHelp students frame information in a positive mannerProvide specific cues
  • 93.
    A Teacher How-toPromotereflective dialogueModeling (e.g. think aloud)Student practiceGroup discussions