27 JULY 2015
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
1
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
TAPESH AJMERA
Hydrogeologist Specialist
27 JULY 2015
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
2
Introduction
Factors Inhibiting Effective Project
Develop Mitigating Measures
Outline
27 JULY 2015
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
3
Project control: projects finish on time, within budget and achieving other
project objectives.
Constantly measuring progress; evaluating plans; and taking corrective
actions when required.
Methods: Gantt Bar Chart, Program Evaluation and Review Technique (PERT)
and Critical Path Method (CPM)
Software: Microsoft Project, Asta Power Project, Primavera, etc.
Introduction
Proportion of projects that encounter cost and time
overruns
Proportion of
project
Time overrun Cost overrun
>90% 2.90% 4.40%
60-90% 1.50% 7.40%
40-60% 8.80% 11.80%
10-40% 48.50% 35.30%
<10% 38.20% 41.20%
Design changes
Risk and uncertainty associated with projects
Inaccurate evaluation of projects time/duration
Non performance of subcontractors and nominated suppliers
Complexity of works
Discrepancies in contract documentation, and contract and specification
interpretation disagreement
Unpredictable weather conditions
Low skilled manpower and lack of proper training and experience on PM
Inflation of prices
Factors Inhibiting Effective Project
27 JULY 2015
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
4
Preventive measures
active measures that would be put in place during the planning stage of a
project
Predictive measures
utilise some tools or techniques to look into the current situation in a bid to
spot potential future problems.
Corrective measures
reactive measures that only act after the event
may not be as effective as preventive or predictive measures
corrective-preventive measures
Organisational measures
Develop Mitigating Measures
27 JULY 2015
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
5
Impact on project cost-> often underestimated.
Information don't provide in time-> difficulty of design management.
Lack of detailed design specification -> lead to contractor pricing the risk
Lack of clear distinction between design change and design development
Design Changes
27 JULY 2015
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
6
Type of
measure
Design Changes-Practice
Preventive
Clear distinction between a design change and a design development
at the outset of a project
Corrective-predictiveEnsuring the cause of a design change is always determined
Corrective
Determination of the provision of the design change within the building
contract
predictive
Identification of potential design changes as a risk and devising a
strategy for managing the risk especially in design and build projects
Corrective-predictive
Ensuring the time and cost implication of a design change is always
determined and agreed before going ahead with the change whenever
possible
Preventive
Notification of all the relevant project parties of how they will be
impacted and the schedule and cost implication of a design change
before going ahead with the change
27 JULY 2015
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
7
Early risk identification-> absolutely essential for effective project
Risk management-> allocated a cost and time for risk
Use
sophisticated quantitative risk management systems,
identified through brainstorming sessions,
risk workshops and analysed qualitatively.
risk register-should be live document
Risks and Uncertainties
27 JULY 2015
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
8
Type of
measure
Risks and Uncertainties-Practice
Preventive
Having a risk register in place for the project as early as possible (e.g.
from tender stage)
Preventive Proper identification, allocation and management of risks
Preventive
Assigning cost and/or time implication to all identified risks on the risk
register whenever possible.
Preventive
Ensuring the risk register is open to all relevant member of the project
team.
Corrective
Having a strategy already developed for solving each of the identified
risks in case they come to fruition
Preventive
Conducting a risk workshop involving all relevant project parties at the
outset of the project in order to identify potential risks.
27 JULY 2015
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
9
Evaluated without any scientific basis and but quite
Often programmes->on gut feeling.
Usually practitioners->under pressure from clients to deliver projects,
especially commercial speculative projects
unachievable time scales
Programme developed
inexperienced planners
don't have good understanding of construction process
Inaccurate Evaluation of Project Time Duration
27 JULY 2015
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
10
Type of
measure
Inaccurate Evaluation of Project Time Duration-Practice
Organisational Ensuring the project planner is well trained in the construction process
Preventive
Preparation of the project programme with input from the construction
site management/production team
Preventive
Developing the programme (schedule) using science based methods
augmented by experience and not relying on gut feeling alone
Preventive
Educating and advising client on alternative if an
unachievable/unrealistic project timescale is stipulated
Organisational
Having the courage to refuse unrealistic project timescale by clients
unwilling to yield to professional advise
Preventive
Developing the project programme of works using experienced
planners that have appreciation of the various construction disciplines
27 JULY 2015
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
11
Interface issues-> different project stages, phases or different trades
Not adequately understand the complex of projects
Not understanding how the complexities involved in a project are interrelated
Breaking down projects into manageable chunks-reduce complexity
Adequate planning->essential for mitigating
Complexity of Works
27 JULY 2015
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
12
Type of
measure
Complexity of Works-Practice
Preventive Breaking the project down into manageable chunks
Preventive Making sure the project is properly understood before embarking on it.
Preventive
Detailed review of the information relating to the work before
embarking on it
Preventive Development a project execution plan for the work before starting on it
Corrective Having enough resources to deal with the complexity
Preventive
Allocating to the project experienced personnel that have handled
similar type of complexity in the past
27 JULY 2015
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
13
Reiterated as a major obstacle to effective project control.
fault of the subcontractor-> lack of effective management by the main
contractor.
Working relationship: contractor and subcontractors -> essential in project
control.
Relationship exist in practice
Supply chain management: contractors, subcontractors and suppliers
Financial buoyancy of potential subcontractors
Non-performance of Subcontractors
27 JULY 2015
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
14
Type of
measure
Non-performance of Subcontractors-Practice
Preventive
Properly directing the subcontractor to ensure they know what is
expected of them in relation to the project
Organisational Developing a good working relationship with subcontractors
Predictive
Putting a system in place for early identification of non-performance in
subcontract works/packages in order to nip it in the bud as soon as
possible.
Predictive
Utilising performance measurements e.g. S-curve, KPI to monitor the
output/performance of subcontractors on their work package
Organisational Ensuring there is a committed supply chain that can be used
Corrective
Having a process in place that mutually allows non-performing
subcontractors to be removed from the supply chain
27 JULY 2015
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
15
Acknowledgement
27 JULY 2015
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
16
› Majority of material of this presentation have been taken from a journal paper
and report;
› Olawale, Y., and Sun M. (2010), Construction Management and Economics, 28 (5),
509 – 526.
› KMPG prepared a report (2012) "Study on project schedule and cost overruns to
Government of India"
27 JULY 2015
COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
17

COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS_TKAJ

  • 1.
    27 JULY 2015 COSTAND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 1 COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS TAPESH AJMERA Hydrogeologist Specialist
  • 2.
    27 JULY 2015 COSTAND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 2 Introduction Factors Inhibiting Effective Project Develop Mitigating Measures Outline
  • 3.
    27 JULY 2015 COSTAND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 3 Project control: projects finish on time, within budget and achieving other project objectives. Constantly measuring progress; evaluating plans; and taking corrective actions when required. Methods: Gantt Bar Chart, Program Evaluation and Review Technique (PERT) and Critical Path Method (CPM) Software: Microsoft Project, Asta Power Project, Primavera, etc. Introduction Proportion of projects that encounter cost and time overruns Proportion of project Time overrun Cost overrun >90% 2.90% 4.40% 60-90% 1.50% 7.40% 40-60% 8.80% 11.80% 10-40% 48.50% 35.30% <10% 38.20% 41.20%
  • 4.
    Design changes Risk anduncertainty associated with projects Inaccurate evaluation of projects time/duration Non performance of subcontractors and nominated suppliers Complexity of works Discrepancies in contract documentation, and contract and specification interpretation disagreement Unpredictable weather conditions Low skilled manpower and lack of proper training and experience on PM Inflation of prices Factors Inhibiting Effective Project 27 JULY 2015 COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 4
  • 5.
    Preventive measures active measuresthat would be put in place during the planning stage of a project Predictive measures utilise some tools or techniques to look into the current situation in a bid to spot potential future problems. Corrective measures reactive measures that only act after the event may not be as effective as preventive or predictive measures corrective-preventive measures Organisational measures Develop Mitigating Measures 27 JULY 2015 COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 5
  • 6.
    Impact on projectcost-> often underestimated. Information don't provide in time-> difficulty of design management. Lack of detailed design specification -> lead to contractor pricing the risk Lack of clear distinction between design change and design development Design Changes 27 JULY 2015 COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 6
  • 7.
    Type of measure Design Changes-Practice Preventive Cleardistinction between a design change and a design development at the outset of a project Corrective-predictiveEnsuring the cause of a design change is always determined Corrective Determination of the provision of the design change within the building contract predictive Identification of potential design changes as a risk and devising a strategy for managing the risk especially in design and build projects Corrective-predictive Ensuring the time and cost implication of a design change is always determined and agreed before going ahead with the change whenever possible Preventive Notification of all the relevant project parties of how they will be impacted and the schedule and cost implication of a design change before going ahead with the change 27 JULY 2015 COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 7
  • 8.
    Early risk identification->absolutely essential for effective project Risk management-> allocated a cost and time for risk Use sophisticated quantitative risk management systems, identified through brainstorming sessions, risk workshops and analysed qualitatively. risk register-should be live document Risks and Uncertainties 27 JULY 2015 COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 8
  • 9.
    Type of measure Risks andUncertainties-Practice Preventive Having a risk register in place for the project as early as possible (e.g. from tender stage) Preventive Proper identification, allocation and management of risks Preventive Assigning cost and/or time implication to all identified risks on the risk register whenever possible. Preventive Ensuring the risk register is open to all relevant member of the project team. Corrective Having a strategy already developed for solving each of the identified risks in case they come to fruition Preventive Conducting a risk workshop involving all relevant project parties at the outset of the project in order to identify potential risks. 27 JULY 2015 COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 9
  • 10.
    Evaluated without anyscientific basis and but quite Often programmes->on gut feeling. Usually practitioners->under pressure from clients to deliver projects, especially commercial speculative projects unachievable time scales Programme developed inexperienced planners don't have good understanding of construction process Inaccurate Evaluation of Project Time Duration 27 JULY 2015 COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 10
  • 11.
    Type of measure Inaccurate Evaluationof Project Time Duration-Practice Organisational Ensuring the project planner is well trained in the construction process Preventive Preparation of the project programme with input from the construction site management/production team Preventive Developing the programme (schedule) using science based methods augmented by experience and not relying on gut feeling alone Preventive Educating and advising client on alternative if an unachievable/unrealistic project timescale is stipulated Organisational Having the courage to refuse unrealistic project timescale by clients unwilling to yield to professional advise Preventive Developing the project programme of works using experienced planners that have appreciation of the various construction disciplines 27 JULY 2015 COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 11
  • 12.
    Interface issues-> differentproject stages, phases or different trades Not adequately understand the complex of projects Not understanding how the complexities involved in a project are interrelated Breaking down projects into manageable chunks-reduce complexity Adequate planning->essential for mitigating Complexity of Works 27 JULY 2015 COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 12
  • 13.
    Type of measure Complexity ofWorks-Practice Preventive Breaking the project down into manageable chunks Preventive Making sure the project is properly understood before embarking on it. Preventive Detailed review of the information relating to the work before embarking on it Preventive Development a project execution plan for the work before starting on it Corrective Having enough resources to deal with the complexity Preventive Allocating to the project experienced personnel that have handled similar type of complexity in the past 27 JULY 2015 COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 13
  • 14.
    Reiterated as amajor obstacle to effective project control. fault of the subcontractor-> lack of effective management by the main contractor. Working relationship: contractor and subcontractors -> essential in project control. Relationship exist in practice Supply chain management: contractors, subcontractors and suppliers Financial buoyancy of potential subcontractors Non-performance of Subcontractors 27 JULY 2015 COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 14
  • 15.
    Type of measure Non-performance ofSubcontractors-Practice Preventive Properly directing the subcontractor to ensure they know what is expected of them in relation to the project Organisational Developing a good working relationship with subcontractors Predictive Putting a system in place for early identification of non-performance in subcontract works/packages in order to nip it in the bud as soon as possible. Predictive Utilising performance measurements e.g. S-curve, KPI to monitor the output/performance of subcontractors on their work package Organisational Ensuring there is a committed supply chain that can be used Corrective Having a process in place that mutually allows non-performing subcontractors to be removed from the supply chain 27 JULY 2015 COST AND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 15
  • 16.
    Acknowledgement 27 JULY 2015 COSTAND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 16 › Majority of material of this presentation have been taken from a journal paper and report; › Olawale, Y., and Sun M. (2010), Construction Management and Economics, 28 (5), 509 – 526. › KMPG prepared a report (2012) "Study on project schedule and cost overruns to Government of India"
  • 17.
    27 JULY 2015 COSTAND TIME CONTROL OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 17