Collaboration for Sustainability in a Networked Worldwww.wordle.net-Rebecca PetzelBlekinge Institute of Technology
OutlineOverviewBackgroundSustainability & COINsResearchResultsSustainability AssessmentBarriers to UsePractitioner RecommendationsConclusions
BackgroundThe Sustainability Challenge1987 U.N. Brundtland Report1988 the Sustainability Principles2002: "sustainable development simply calls for more collaboration since the changes needed exceed the capacity of individual actors."
BackgroundIn What ways can COINs be part of a movement towards a sustainable society?Harnessing Collective IntelligenceThe Framework for Strategic Sustainable Development
ResearchResearch & MethodologyUsed creative tension of backcastingSurveys (32 people)Interviews (18 people)Participant ObservationFeedback & Dialogue
ResResults: assessmentSustainability AssessmentBridging Ingenuity GapSocially sustainable structuresSelf-organization, Diversity, InterdependenceLow-impact TechnologyResource inefficienciesAccess ConcernsLack of systems perspective
Results: barriers76.5 % of people globally lack Internet Access http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2053/2229752965_ae28533a0a_o.jpg
Results: barriersDigital Immigrants perceive technology a bit differently than digital nativeshttp://seacreatures.deviantart.com/art/Old-People-14159737
Results: barriersFrom hierarchy to wirearchy is a tough transitionhttp://www.jarche.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/04/wirearchy.jpg
Results: barriershttp://www.lrdc.pitt.edu/schunn/sword/plagiarism.jpgNot everyone thinks of intellectual property the same way
Results: barriershttp://nirel.deviantart.com/art/Scream-17026336Sometimes technology is frustrating
Results: barriersWithout the presence of face to face collaboration- dysfuntional argumentation can create roadblocks
Results: barriershttp://digitalminds.deviantart.com/art/Pain-in-the-ass-101307904Web collaborations can suffer from poor signal to noise ratios
Results: barriersThe web presents new communication challenges: people say things on-line they wouldn’t say face to facehttp://auleaf.deviantart.com/art/Screw-You-127132471
Results: barriersOver-controlling leadership can stifle a collaborationhttp://altair4444.deviantart.com/art/Puppet-Not-15196569
Results: barriersCollaborations fail through lack of shared vision, trust or transparent communication: the pillars of successful COINshttp://marthema.deviantart.com/art/Together-35327305
Results: barriers“The biggest challenge to harnessing the collective intelligence of the world to help solve some of the very serious problems we have around sustainability….has to do with people knowing not only how to use the software, but ideas around critical thinking and collaboration.”– Howard Rheingold
Results: recommendationsHow to collaborate?When to collaborate Perfect Invitation Collaborator experience designLead by example Strategic considerations for COINs
ConclusionsSustainability & COINsCOINs support social sustainabilityCOINs CAN support environmental sustainabilityThe FSSD & COINsInnovation!
ConclusionsValidity & Further ResearchTime ConcernsEmerging factors in rapidly developing fieldDetailed resource assessment of distributed workingCollaboration Ninjas
Conclusions“the danger is not that we ask too much of the Internet, but too little…it could be a new platform for how we could organize ourselves, to find knowledge together, to work out what is true and to decide together what we should do about it”–Tim Berners-Lee
AppendixFramework for Strategic Sustainable Development (FSSD)Understand the system- the natural laws that define the biosphere and societies relationships with the earth. Interdependence, diversity, self-organization, laws of thermodynamicsSystemSuccess on a principled level. The minimum requirements necessary for success. The sustainability principles are a minimumSuccessStrategic guidelines to guide decision making processes. Importantly backcasting as a strategic guideline and guidelines for socially sustainable processes of relating: transparency, cooperation, openness, inclusiveness, involvementStrategicActionsPrioritized steps put into action, following strategic guidelines for success in the systemAppropriate tools including management techniques and monitoring processes to guide implementation of strategic toolsTools
AppendixThe Sustainability PrinciplesTo become a sustainable society we must...eliminate our contribution to the progressive buildup of substances extracted from the Earth's crust (for example, heavy metals and fossil fuels)2. eliminate our contribution to the progressive buildup of chemicals and compounds produced by society (for example, dioxins, PCBs, and DDT )3. eliminate our contribution to the progressive physical degradation and destruction of nature and natural processes (for example, over harvesting forests and paving over critical wildlife habitat); and4. eliminate our contribution to conditions that undermine people’s capacity to meet their basic human needs (for example, unsafe working conditions and not enough pay to live on). v
AppendixResearch Questions

Collaborative Innovation Networks for Sustainability

  • 1.
    Collaboration for Sustainabilityin a Networked Worldwww.wordle.net-Rebecca PetzelBlekinge Institute of Technology
  • 2.
    OutlineOverviewBackgroundSustainability & COINsResearchResultsSustainabilityAssessmentBarriers to UsePractitioner RecommendationsConclusions
  • 3.
    BackgroundThe Sustainability Challenge1987U.N. Brundtland Report1988 the Sustainability Principles2002: "sustainable development simply calls for more collaboration since the changes needed exceed the capacity of individual actors."
  • 4.
    BackgroundIn What wayscan COINs be part of a movement towards a sustainable society?Harnessing Collective IntelligenceThe Framework for Strategic Sustainable Development
  • 5.
    ResearchResearch & MethodologyUsedcreative tension of backcastingSurveys (32 people)Interviews (18 people)Participant ObservationFeedback & Dialogue
  • 6.
    ResResults: assessmentSustainability AssessmentBridgingIngenuity GapSocially sustainable structuresSelf-organization, Diversity, InterdependenceLow-impact TechnologyResource inefficienciesAccess ConcernsLack of systems perspective
  • 7.
    Results: barriers76.5 %of people globally lack Internet Access http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2053/2229752965_ae28533a0a_o.jpg
  • 8.
    Results: barriersDigital Immigrantsperceive technology a bit differently than digital nativeshttp://seacreatures.deviantart.com/art/Old-People-14159737
  • 9.
    Results: barriersFrom hierarchyto wirearchy is a tough transitionhttp://www.jarche.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/04/wirearchy.jpg
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
    Results: barriersWithout thepresence of face to face collaboration- dysfuntional argumentation can create roadblocks
  • 13.
  • 14.
    Results: barriersThe webpresents new communication challenges: people say things on-line they wouldn’t say face to facehttp://auleaf.deviantart.com/art/Screw-You-127132471
  • 15.
    Results: barriersOver-controlling leadershipcan stifle a collaborationhttp://altair4444.deviantart.com/art/Puppet-Not-15196569
  • 16.
    Results: barriersCollaborations failthrough lack of shared vision, trust or transparent communication: the pillars of successful COINshttp://marthema.deviantart.com/art/Together-35327305
  • 17.
    Results: barriers“The biggestchallenge to harnessing the collective intelligence of the world to help solve some of the very serious problems we have around sustainability….has to do with people knowing not only how to use the software, but ideas around critical thinking and collaboration.”– Howard Rheingold
  • 18.
    Results: recommendationsHow tocollaborate?When to collaborate Perfect Invitation Collaborator experience designLead by example Strategic considerations for COINs
  • 19.
    ConclusionsSustainability & COINsCOINssupport social sustainabilityCOINs CAN support environmental sustainabilityThe FSSD & COINsInnovation!
  • 20.
    ConclusionsValidity & FurtherResearchTime ConcernsEmerging factors in rapidly developing fieldDetailed resource assessment of distributed workingCollaboration Ninjas
  • 21.
    Conclusions“the danger isnot that we ask too much of the Internet, but too little…it could be a new platform for how we could organize ourselves, to find knowledge together, to work out what is true and to decide together what we should do about it”–Tim Berners-Lee
  • 22.
    AppendixFramework for StrategicSustainable Development (FSSD)Understand the system- the natural laws that define the biosphere and societies relationships with the earth. Interdependence, diversity, self-organization, laws of thermodynamicsSystemSuccess on a principled level. The minimum requirements necessary for success. The sustainability principles are a minimumSuccessStrategic guidelines to guide decision making processes. Importantly backcasting as a strategic guideline and guidelines for socially sustainable processes of relating: transparency, cooperation, openness, inclusiveness, involvementStrategicActionsPrioritized steps put into action, following strategic guidelines for success in the systemAppropriate tools including management techniques and monitoring processes to guide implementation of strategic toolsTools
  • 23.
    AppendixThe Sustainability PrinciplesTobecome a sustainable society we must...eliminate our contribution to the progressive buildup of substances extracted from the Earth's crust (for example, heavy metals and fossil fuels)2. eliminate our contribution to the progressive buildup of chemicals and compounds produced by society (for example, dioxins, PCBs, and DDT )3. eliminate our contribution to the progressive physical degradation and destruction of nature and natural processes (for example, over harvesting forests and paving over critical wildlife habitat); and4. eliminate our contribution to conditions that undermine people’s capacity to meet their basic human needs (for example, unsafe working conditions and not enough pay to live on). v
  • 24.

Editor's Notes

  • #9 Series of pictures for barriers and emerging factors all with one-liners- copy from Alice-how2 guide-series of pictures for some specific recommendations-conclusion- recommendations for further research-validity
  • #10 Series of pictures for barriers and emerging factors all with one-liners- copy from Alice-how2 guide-series of pictures for some specific recommendations-conclusion- recommendations for further research-validity
  • #15 Series of pictures for barriers and emerging factors all with one-liners- copy from Alice-how2 guide-series of pictures for some specific recommendations-conclusion- recommendations for further research-validity
  • #16 Series of pictures for barriers and emerging factors all with one-liners- copy from Alice-how2 guide-series of pictures for some specific recommendations-conclusion- recommendations for further research-validity
  • #17 Series of pictures for barriers and emerging factors all with one-liners- copy from Alice-how2 guide-series of pictures for some specific recommendations-conclusion- recommendations for further research-validity
  • #18 Series of pictures for barriers and emerging factors all with one-liners- copy from Alice-how2 guide-series of pictures for some specific recommendations-conclusion- recommendations for further research-validity
  • #22 Series of pictures for barriers and emerging factors all with one-liners- copy from Alice-how2 guide-series of pictures for some specific recommendations-conclusion- recommendations for further research-validity
  • #24 Series of pictures for barriers and emerging factors all with one-liners- copy from Alice-how2 guide-series of pictures for some specific recommendations-conclusion- recommendations for further research-validity