Clean Development
Mechanism Explained


             EfficientCarbon
Carbon Credits

                   Carbon being traded as a commodity

    Voluntary and binding agreements

                         CER and audited credits


So what really are Carbon Credits and what does Clean
       Development Mechanism (CDM) mean?

 To understand these, we need to first look at the Kyoto Protocol.


                                 www.efficientcarbon.com
                                 Phone: +91 9000345588
                              gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                           © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
The Kyoto Protocol
•   A protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate
    Change (UNFCCC or FCCC), aimed at fighting global warming.

•   Sets binding targets for 37 industrialized countries and the European
    community to reduce their Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emissions.

•   Binding countries to meet their targets primarily through national markets

•   Additional means of meeting targets through three market based
    mechanisms:
     –   Emissions trading – known as “the carbon market"
     –   Joint implementation (JI) and
     –   Clean development mechanism (CDM)



•   First two mechanisms relevant to Annex I / Annex II countries and the third
    is relevant to developing countries.

                                             www.efficientcarbon.com
                                             Phone: +91 9000345588
                                          gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                                       © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
The Kyoto Protocol
•   Parties to UNFCCC are classified as:
     –   Annex I countries - industrialized countries and economies in transition

     –   Annex II countries - developed countries which pay for costs of developing countries

     –   Developing countries like India.




                                                  www.efficientcarbon.com
                                                  Phone: +91 9000345588
                                               gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                                            © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
That brings us to CDM
• In simple terms, CDM is a GHG exchange program

• The theory is that atmosphere is equally polluted by
  GHG‟s wherever they come from and equally benefits
  from GHG cuts, wherever they come from.

• So in effect, if a company cannot control its pollution, it
  can buy some amount of „clean credits‟ from someone
  who has worked hard to cut down pollution – “Polluter
  pays”.

• Hence you have companies bound to Kyoto protocol
  buying carbon credits from organisations which invest in
  developing clean development mechanism projects
                               www.efficientcarbon.com
                               Phone: +91 9000345588
                            gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                         © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
Companies pay cash




                 CLEAN DEVELOPMENT
                     MECHANISM


                                                                  Organisations
Companies in                                                    developing CDM
Annex – I                                                               projects
countries




               Organisations give certified carbon credits
                             www.efficientcarbon.com
                             Phone: +91 9000345588
                          gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                       © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
Certified Emission Reduction (CER)
• Primary unit of measurement of
  the Carbon reduced by the
  project

• Given by CDM executive board

• Certification that a project has
  managed to reduce 1 tonne of
  CO2 eq per year

• Approximate price of a single
  CER ranges from $10 - $35
  depending on the trading
  exchange and market
  conditions
                                   www.efficientcarbon.com
                                   Phone: +91 9000345588
                                gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                             © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
One of the key factors for approval of a CDM project is
                    the Additionality constraint.



   Additionality
                                                     Emissions

Kyoto Protocol specifies that emission                                                  CER / Carbon
reductions are only to be certified under                                                 Credits

the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM)
if they are additional to any that would
occur in the absence of the certified
project activity.
                                                                                                 Time
                                                                      Project started




                                   www.efficientcarbon.com
                                   Phone: +91 9000345588
                                gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                             © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
Pre-Requisites of a CDM project
•   Additionality constraint

•   To be „Hosted‟ by a Non Annex-I country (like India) which meets some
    basic constraints
     – Adhere to UNFCCC conventions
     – Establish a Designated National Authority

•   Co-development by host country and an Annex-I country

•   Validation by a Designated Operational Entity (DOE) and meeting the
    CDM requirements

•   Registration with the CDM Executive Board post review to ensure
    compliance

•   Verified and Certified by the DOE as resulting in real, additional,
    verifiable and measurable emission reductions after commissioning of
    operations.
                                       www.efficientcarbon.com
                                       Phone: +91 9000345588
                                    gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                                 © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
A CDM Project can be in many areas

Renewable
                     Clean Energy                  Energy Efficiency            Construction
  Energy




                       Waste                                                   Afforestation &
Transport                                                Solvent Use
                     Management                                                 Green Cover




            Agriculture             HFC/PFC                            Rest/Others




                                    www.efficientcarbon.com
                                    Phone: +91 9000345588
                                 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                              © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
Before starting a CDM
project, a project baseline
has to be established.      This is to establish the amount of
                                        greenhouse gases that would have been
                                        emitted without this CDM project.


 Baseline Estimation Process



  Identify      Define     Estimate                                     Assess      Monitor
                                                     Evaluate
               sources                                                              baseline
  Baseline        for
                              the                       the            uncertain   Methodol-
  Scenario                 baseline                 estimation           -ties
              estimation                                                              ogy




                                    www.efficientcarbon.com
                                    Phone: +91 9000345588
                                 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                              © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
So to summarise...
Establish Additionality


    Establish Baseline


        Verify Baseline


             Get Approval from CDM Executive Board
             (EB)


                 Kick off the CDM project activity


                                   www.efficientcarbon.com
                                   Phone: +91 9000345588
                                gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                             © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
The Actual CDM Activity
         Project Stage                       Who does it?                       Activity Span        Time Span

    • Project Design Document              Project Developers /
                                                                                                1 month     Expenses
1     (PDD) Preparation                        Consultants

                                             GOE / Ministry of
    • Host Country Approval                  Environment and                                    6 months
2                                                 Forests
                                                                                  One Time                        12
                                                                                   Activity     NA(depen
    • Validation by DOEs                             DOE                                          ds on           to
3                                                                                                project)
                                                                                                                  18
                                                                                                Up to 6
    • Project Registration                        CDM EB                                        months            M
4
                                                                                                                  O
                                                                                                                  N
                                          Project Developer                                                       T
    • Monitoring                                                                                Regular
5                                              and DOE                                                            H
                                                                                                                  S
                                                                                   Annual       Up to 2
    • Verification and Certification       DOE and CDM EB                          Activity     months
6



    • Issue of CERs                                                                             Up to 1.5    Project
                                                  CDM EB                                        months
7                                                                                                           Monetised


                                             www.efficientcarbon.com
                                             Phone: +91 9000345588
                                          gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                                       © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
Costs in CDM Activity
• Project Development and Implementation costs

• Transaction Costs
   – Consultant Fees

   – Registration with Designated National Authority (DNA)

   – Validation and Monitoring fee to Designated Operational
     Authority (DOE)

   – CER Issuance fee

   – Contribution to UNFCCC adaptation fund
      • 2% of the CERs will be deducted adaptation fund by CDM Executive Board.




                                    www.efficientcarbon.com
                                    Phone: +91 9000345588
                                 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                              © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
CDM Benefits to Annex-1 countries
• Reduction in overall emission mitigation costs

• Flexibility in meeting emission reduction
  commitments

• Investment Opportunities




                           www.efficientcarbon.com
                           Phone: +91 9000345588
                        gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                     © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
CDM Benefits to Developing Countries
• Additional financing for sustainable development
  projects in the country

• Technology transfer and development

• Mitigates local environment pollution

• Jobs and infrastructure development opportunities




                             www.efficientcarbon.com
                             Phone: +91 9000345588
                          gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                       © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
Risks and critiques
• Future beyond 2012 uncertain

• Meagre interest shown by the Govt in developing its
  own CDM projects

• Proving additionality difficult in some cases

• Carbon credits being traded as financial instruments give
  provision to misuse the intention behind CDM

• “Developed countries being let off by paying money to
  clean up their footprint” – Wide opinions
                               www.efficientcarbon.com
                               Phone: +91 9000345588
                            gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                         © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
Sources
• http://cdm.unfccc.int/Projects/index.html

• http://cdm.unfccc.int/methodologies/PAmethodologies/tools/am-
  tool-01-v5.2.pdf

• http://www.cdmcapacity.org

• http://ies.lbl.gov/iespubs/43418.pdf

• http://www.cdmindia.nic.in/

• http://unfccc.int/kyoto_protocol/items/2830.php

• http://www.cdmpakistan.gov.pk

• http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_Development_Mechanism

• www.cdmrulebook.com
                                  www.efficientcarbon.com
                                  Phone: +91 9000345588
                               gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                            © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
CDM Facilitation
       Project Initiation                                                       CDM Facilitation
• Project Evaluation                                                 • Baseline Studies

• Project Comparison                                                 • PDD Documentation

• Cost Analysis                                                      • Host Country Approval
                                                                     Facilitation
• Financial Modeling – NPV, IRR
                                                                     • Registration Facilitation
• CER Generating Potential
Analysis                                                             • Preparation of Monitoring
                                                                     Report
• Project Technology Identification,
Analysis and Selection                                               • Project Verification and CER
                                                                     Issuance Facilitation
• Supplier Identification
                                                                     • New Baseline Methodologies
• Creation of Full Project Plan                                      Development



                                             www.efficientcarbon.com
                                             Phone: +91 9000345588
                                          gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                                       © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
Our Services
CARBON MANAGEMENT ADVISORY


  SUSTAINABILITY CONSULTING


    WATER MANAGEMENT


      ENERGY EFFICIENCY


 RENEWABLE ENERGY ADVISORY


      CDM FACILITATION

             www.efficientcarbon.com
             Phone: +91 9000345588
          gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
       © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
Contact us
Harsha: +91 9000345588
Pradeep: +91 9052224701
Office: +91 40 40128206


gogreen@efficientcarbon.com

www.efficientcarbon.com

www.twitter.com/efficientcarbon

www.facebook.com/efficientcarbon

                     www.efficientcarbon.com
                     Phone: +91 9000345588
                  gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
               © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
"Sustainability is not only absolutely necessary considering the
situation our planet is in, we as companies are also overdue to
take responsibility. We can't wait for governments. Companies
have to lead the way…
                                    - Jochen Zeitz, CEO, Puma Corp.




                                                    Thank You
                                www.efficientcarbon.com
                                Phone: +91 9000345588
                             gogreen@efficientcarbon.com
                          © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved

Clean development mechanism basics

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Carbon Credits Carbon being traded as a commodity Voluntary and binding agreements CER and audited credits So what really are Carbon Credits and what does Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) mean? To understand these, we need to first look at the Kyoto Protocol. www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 3.
    The Kyoto Protocol • A protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC or FCCC), aimed at fighting global warming. • Sets binding targets for 37 industrialized countries and the European community to reduce their Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emissions. • Binding countries to meet their targets primarily through national markets • Additional means of meeting targets through three market based mechanisms: – Emissions trading – known as “the carbon market" – Joint implementation (JI) and – Clean development mechanism (CDM) • First two mechanisms relevant to Annex I / Annex II countries and the third is relevant to developing countries. www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 4.
    The Kyoto Protocol • Parties to UNFCCC are classified as: – Annex I countries - industrialized countries and economies in transition – Annex II countries - developed countries which pay for costs of developing countries – Developing countries like India. www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 5.
    That brings usto CDM • In simple terms, CDM is a GHG exchange program • The theory is that atmosphere is equally polluted by GHG‟s wherever they come from and equally benefits from GHG cuts, wherever they come from. • So in effect, if a company cannot control its pollution, it can buy some amount of „clean credits‟ from someone who has worked hard to cut down pollution – “Polluter pays”. • Hence you have companies bound to Kyoto protocol buying carbon credits from organisations which invest in developing clean development mechanism projects www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 6.
    Companies pay cash CLEAN DEVELOPMENT MECHANISM Organisations Companies in developing CDM Annex – I projects countries Organisations give certified carbon credits www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 7.
    Certified Emission Reduction(CER) • Primary unit of measurement of the Carbon reduced by the project • Given by CDM executive board • Certification that a project has managed to reduce 1 tonne of CO2 eq per year • Approximate price of a single CER ranges from $10 - $35 depending on the trading exchange and market conditions www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 8.
    One of thekey factors for approval of a CDM project is the Additionality constraint. Additionality Emissions Kyoto Protocol specifies that emission CER / Carbon reductions are only to be certified under Credits the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) if they are additional to any that would occur in the absence of the certified project activity. Time Project started www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 9.
    Pre-Requisites of aCDM project • Additionality constraint • To be „Hosted‟ by a Non Annex-I country (like India) which meets some basic constraints – Adhere to UNFCCC conventions – Establish a Designated National Authority • Co-development by host country and an Annex-I country • Validation by a Designated Operational Entity (DOE) and meeting the CDM requirements • Registration with the CDM Executive Board post review to ensure compliance • Verified and Certified by the DOE as resulting in real, additional, verifiable and measurable emission reductions after commissioning of operations. www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 10.
    A CDM Projectcan be in many areas Renewable Clean Energy Energy Efficiency Construction Energy Waste Afforestation & Transport Solvent Use Management Green Cover Agriculture HFC/PFC Rest/Others www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 11.
    Before starting aCDM project, a project baseline has to be established. This is to establish the amount of greenhouse gases that would have been emitted without this CDM project. Baseline Estimation Process Identify Define Estimate Assess Monitor Evaluate sources baseline Baseline for the the uncertain Methodol- Scenario baseline estimation -ties estimation ogy www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 12.
    So to summarise... EstablishAdditionality Establish Baseline Verify Baseline Get Approval from CDM Executive Board (EB) Kick off the CDM project activity www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 13.
    The Actual CDMActivity Project Stage Who does it? Activity Span Time Span • Project Design Document Project Developers / 1 month Expenses 1 (PDD) Preparation Consultants GOE / Ministry of • Host Country Approval Environment and 6 months 2 Forests One Time 12 Activity NA(depen • Validation by DOEs DOE ds on to 3 project) 18 Up to 6 • Project Registration CDM EB months M 4 O N Project Developer T • Monitoring Regular 5 and DOE H S Annual Up to 2 • Verification and Certification DOE and CDM EB Activity months 6 • Issue of CERs Up to 1.5 Project CDM EB months 7 Monetised www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 14.
    Costs in CDMActivity • Project Development and Implementation costs • Transaction Costs – Consultant Fees – Registration with Designated National Authority (DNA) – Validation and Monitoring fee to Designated Operational Authority (DOE) – CER Issuance fee – Contribution to UNFCCC adaptation fund • 2% of the CERs will be deducted adaptation fund by CDM Executive Board. www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 15.
    CDM Benefits toAnnex-1 countries • Reduction in overall emission mitigation costs • Flexibility in meeting emission reduction commitments • Investment Opportunities www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 16.
    CDM Benefits toDeveloping Countries • Additional financing for sustainable development projects in the country • Technology transfer and development • Mitigates local environment pollution • Jobs and infrastructure development opportunities www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 17.
    Risks and critiques •Future beyond 2012 uncertain • Meagre interest shown by the Govt in developing its own CDM projects • Proving additionality difficult in some cases • Carbon credits being traded as financial instruments give provision to misuse the intention behind CDM • “Developed countries being let off by paying money to clean up their footprint” – Wide opinions www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 18.
    Sources • http://cdm.unfccc.int/Projects/index.html • http://cdm.unfccc.int/methodologies/PAmethodologies/tools/am- tool-01-v5.2.pdf • http://www.cdmcapacity.org • http://ies.lbl.gov/iespubs/43418.pdf • http://www.cdmindia.nic.in/ • http://unfccc.int/kyoto_protocol/items/2830.php • http://www.cdmpakistan.gov.pk • http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_Development_Mechanism • www.cdmrulebook.com www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 19.
    CDM Facilitation Project Initiation CDM Facilitation • Project Evaluation • Baseline Studies • Project Comparison • PDD Documentation • Cost Analysis • Host Country Approval Facilitation • Financial Modeling – NPV, IRR • Registration Facilitation • CER Generating Potential Analysis • Preparation of Monitoring Report • Project Technology Identification, Analysis and Selection • Project Verification and CER Issuance Facilitation • Supplier Identification • New Baseline Methodologies • Creation of Full Project Plan Development www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 20.
    Our Services CARBON MANAGEMENTADVISORY SUSTAINABILITY CONSULTING WATER MANAGEMENT ENERGY EFFICIENCY RENEWABLE ENERGY ADVISORY CDM FACILITATION www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 21.
    Contact us Harsha: +919000345588 Pradeep: +91 9052224701 Office: +91 40 40128206 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com www.efficientcarbon.com www.twitter.com/efficientcarbon www.facebook.com/efficientcarbon www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved
  • 22.
    "Sustainability is notonly absolutely necessary considering the situation our planet is in, we as companies are also overdue to take responsibility. We can't wait for governments. Companies have to lead the way… - Jochen Zeitz, CEO, Puma Corp. Thank You www.efficientcarbon.com Phone: +91 9000345588 gogreen@efficientcarbon.com © efficientcarbon, All rights reserved