A 47-year-old obese male suffered a cardiac arrest at home and paramedics were called. Paramedics performed CPR, secured the patient's airway with an i-gel, administered epinephrine and amiodarone, and defibrillated multiple times. Extraction of the patient was difficult due to his size and the home's layout, interrupting chest compressions. The patient remained in asystole and died in the hospital. While guidelines were generally followed, opportunities were identified to improve outcomes through different drug protocols, better airway devices, and mechanical CPR devices to maintain compressions during difficult extractions.