Medical Error
Case Study
Edited by
Abdalla Ibrahim
Accreditation Specialist
Healthcare Surveyor
Original Lecture by Dr. Samir Omar, Health Care Quality Advisor
Adopted with permission on December 2014
Objectives
 Learn step-by-step what to do when medical error
occurs and how to report it
 Learn how to identify root cause of a medical error
and how to prevent its recurrence
 Motivate your colleagues to foster a patient safety
culture
The Story
On Sunday morning, Mr. XX
had attended my clinic due
to marked polyuria. His RBS
was 28.8 mmol/L,
otherwise he was
completely normal.
The Story
I’ve prescribed N. saline 1.5 L ,
IV, over 2 hours and 5.0 u of
regular insulin by direct IV push
/ 30 minutes, until his RBS is 9.0
mmol/l.
The Story
 I’ve been called to give the IV
injection, Which was easily
done.
The Story
 Twenty minutes later, my
patient was very much
apprehensive, sweating and
started shivering. His RBS was
0.8 mmol/l.
The Story
My nurse had told me
that I’ve pushed 50.0
u of regular insulin in
the IV line.
What Happened?
What Happened?
 On Sunday 5/12/2014, at 9:12 am,
 In the treatment room,
 I had injected Mr. XX a doe of 50.0 u of regular
insulin intravenously,
 Which resulted in severe hypoglycemia.
1- Identify
What is your immediate
action?
I did the followings immediately:
• Stop N. Saline
• Start 5% glucose 1.0 liter, IV
• Give 50 ml of 50% glucose IV / 30 min until RBS is
9.0 mmol/l
• Call Ambulance and transfer to A/E and…
2- Immediate Action
Immediate notification
Dr.
In-charge
Quality
Coordinator
Person on
authority
Senior
On Duty
3- Notify
Who else can notify?
Doctor other
than the
offender.
A Nurse who
witnessed the
incident
Any other
attendant,
even a visitor
In order not to forget the
facts!!!
 Document only the facts of what occurred and
treatment given
 Do Not document:
◦ Blame
◦ Subjective feelings or thoughts
◦ Opinions
• Refer to organization “Incident Report” Form
4- Document
How to document?
9.00
Pt.
Attend
9:15
RBS
28.8
9:20
prescribe
9:25
Nurse
prepare
9:30
Dr.
Pushed
insulin
9:45
Pt.
reaction
9:46
RBS
0.8mmol
9:47
Glucose
infusion
10:15
RBS
5.4
mmol
10:16
Transfer
To
SMC
• 9:00 am, Mr. XX had attended my clinic complaining of
giddiness.
• 9:15 am, his RBS was tested (28.8 mmol/l).
• 9:20 am, I prescribed Regular insulin 5.0 u, iv/30
minutes, until RBS is 9.0 mmol/l and N. Saline 1.5 l/2
hours.
Time line analysis
9.00
Pt.
Attend
9:15
RBS
28.8
9:20
prescribe
9:25
Nurse
prepare
9:30
Dr.
Pushed
insulin
9:45
Pt.
reaction
9:46
RBS
0.8mmol
9:47
Glucose
infusion
10:15
RBS
5.4
mmol
10:16
Transfer
To
SMC
• 9:25, nurse YY prepared 50.0 u of regular insulin and
kept them in kidney shaped basin at patient’s side table.
• 9:30 am I’ve arrived at the patient side to push the dose
in the IV line.
• 9:45 am, I was informed that my patient is sweaty and
very nervous and shivering.
Time line analysis
• 9:45 am, his RBS retested, found 0.8 mmol/l.
• 9:47 am, 1.0 L of 5% glucose was IV given, 50 ml of
50% glucose iv/30 min until RBS is 9.0 mmol.
• 10:15 am, patient was referred to A/E. his last RBS was
5.4 mmol/l.
9.00
Pt.
Attend
9:15
RBS
28.8
9:20
prescribe
9:25
Nurse
prepare
9:30
Dr.
Pushed
insulin
9:45
Pt.
reaction
9:46
RBS
0.8mmol
9:47
Glucose
infusion
10:15
RBS
5.4
mmol
10:16
Transfer
To
SMC
Time line analysis
How to admit your medical
errors?
5- Disclosure
1. Open communication with patient and family
2. Talk in privacy
3. Keep telephone closed, prevent distraction
4. Let a colleague attend the discussion
5. No blames
6. Don't be defensive
Disclosure Technique
5- Disclosure
Disclosure Technique
Describe what happened in facts, not opinion
Tell consequences of the event
Tell steps being taken to manage the event
Tell steps being taken to prevent recurrence
Express your sorrow and regret
Which is better!!
Burry the whole thing Disclose the event
Why disclosure
 Literature shows that after an
unanticipated outcome, the
patient and family want to
know honestly:
 What happened?
 How it happens?
 How hospital will prevent
future events?
Why disclosure
 We are our patient’s
advocates
 Rebuilds trust
 Keep good Doctor-Patient
relationship
Reporting:
Do we have a policy for clinical
incidents?
 Follow you own Reporting
Policy and process
 Use your own Reporting
Form
6- Reporting
What do you expect next?
 To determine sequence of events that led to
consequence
 To take corrective action &
recommendations
 To prevent recurrence of the incident
7- Investigate
Who can investigate?
Investigation Team
 Employee ‘s supervisor
 Safety officer
 Safety committee
representative
 Employee involved
What does investigators
want?
How to investigate?
Case Review
Root Cause Analysis
5 Way Chart
In response to adverse event THREE possible
ways of investigations are found:
Case Review
• To decide if the medical care offered is
of accepted standards?
• If not, the offender physician may be
subjected to certain supports.
• To recommend corrective measures
such as education and training
System Nurse
Patient had
received over
dose of
insulin
No
written
P&P
Environment
Dim light
Poor
maintenance
PatientDoctor
Pt did not speak up
Pt unaware of speak
up initiative
Miss interpret
dose
Dim light
Poor maintenance
Did not check/recheck
dose
No written
P&P
Used illegal
format
Unaware of
legal format
Did not check dose
before inj
No written P&P
Root Cause Analysis and fish bone graph
Exhausted
Overworking
Hours
Patient
received
insulin over
dose
Doctor
Dr. Used
illegible
number form.
Dr. Unaware of
eligible format
No DPP for
prescrip
writing
Dr. did not
check dose
before inj.
No DPP for
drug admin
Nurse
Mis-interpret
dose
Dim light
Poor light
maitenance
Nurse did not
use check-
recheck
method
No DPP for
drug admin
Environment
Dim light
Poor light
maintenance
System
No DPP for
drug admin.
Patient
Pt. did not
speak up
Pt. unaware of
speak up
initiative
5 whys? chart
What are the possible
mistakes done?
* Used unusual number format (5.0)
* Did not recheck the 7 Rs before pushing
medicine
* Misinterpret prescription
* Did not obey 7 Rs before giving injection
* Did not speak up before pushing injection.
What are the possible
mistakes done?
The
7
Rights
Poor
maintenance of
lighting in the
treatment
room.
What are the Root Causes of the
event
Unaware of
(Do NOT DO
LIST).
Physician
Unaware of
the Speak
Up Initiative
Patients
• No written
policy &
procedure of
drug
administration
• Overworking
Hours for
nurses
System Environment
Recommendations
1. Educate doctors on DO Not DO List.
2. Educate patients about Speak Up Initiatives.
3. Provide a written policy and procedure for
drug administration.
4. Improve maintenance in the treatment room.
5. Never to blame or judge liability
8- Change
Clinical
incident
identify
Immediate
action
notify
Disclosure
Report
Investigate
Change
Monitor
Evaluate
Medical Error
Management
What about the Error
maker!
Error maker!!
How does he feel??
• Shame
• Afraid of punishment
• Isolated
• Worthless
• His opinion and advice are not
required
How do we respond
to error maker?
TRUST:
• Treatment in just
• Respect
• Understanding and compassion
• Supportive care
• Transparency and opportunity to
contribute
• Talk to some one for:
• Reaffirmation of their
professional competency
• Validation in their decision
making ability.
• Reassurance of self worth.
What does he need?
• Learning /changing.
• Involving in other issues
• Physical activity/distraction
• Seeking support e.g. counselling
What does She/he need?
Any
Question
Medical error Case Study

Medical error Case Study

  • 1.
    Medical Error Case Study Editedby Abdalla Ibrahim Accreditation Specialist Healthcare Surveyor Original Lecture by Dr. Samir Omar, Health Care Quality Advisor Adopted with permission on December 2014
  • 2.
    Objectives  Learn step-by-stepwhat to do when medical error occurs and how to report it  Learn how to identify root cause of a medical error and how to prevent its recurrence  Motivate your colleagues to foster a patient safety culture
  • 3.
    The Story On Sundaymorning, Mr. XX had attended my clinic due to marked polyuria. His RBS was 28.8 mmol/L, otherwise he was completely normal.
  • 4.
    The Story I’ve prescribedN. saline 1.5 L , IV, over 2 hours and 5.0 u of regular insulin by direct IV push / 30 minutes, until his RBS is 9.0 mmol/l.
  • 5.
    The Story  I’vebeen called to give the IV injection, Which was easily done.
  • 6.
    The Story  Twentyminutes later, my patient was very much apprehensive, sweating and started shivering. His RBS was 0.8 mmol/l.
  • 7.
    The Story My nursehad told me that I’ve pushed 50.0 u of regular insulin in the IV line.
  • 8.
  • 9.
    What Happened?  OnSunday 5/12/2014, at 9:12 am,  In the treatment room,  I had injected Mr. XX a doe of 50.0 u of regular insulin intravenously,  Which resulted in severe hypoglycemia. 1- Identify
  • 10.
    What is yourimmediate action? I did the followings immediately: • Stop N. Saline • Start 5% glucose 1.0 liter, IV • Give 50 ml of 50% glucose IV / 30 min until RBS is 9.0 mmol/l • Call Ambulance and transfer to A/E and… 2- Immediate Action
  • 11.
  • 12.
    Who else cannotify? Doctor other than the offender. A Nurse who witnessed the incident Any other attendant, even a visitor
  • 13.
    In order notto forget the facts!!!  Document only the facts of what occurred and treatment given  Do Not document: ◦ Blame ◦ Subjective feelings or thoughts ◦ Opinions • Refer to organization “Incident Report” Form 4- Document
  • 14.
  • 15.
    9.00 Pt. Attend 9:15 RBS 28.8 9:20 prescribe 9:25 Nurse prepare 9:30 Dr. Pushed insulin 9:45 Pt. reaction 9:46 RBS 0.8mmol 9:47 Glucose infusion 10:15 RBS 5.4 mmol 10:16 Transfer To SMC • 9:00 am,Mr. XX had attended my clinic complaining of giddiness. • 9:15 am, his RBS was tested (28.8 mmol/l). • 9:20 am, I prescribed Regular insulin 5.0 u, iv/30 minutes, until RBS is 9.0 mmol/l and N. Saline 1.5 l/2 hours. Time line analysis
  • 16.
    9.00 Pt. Attend 9:15 RBS 28.8 9:20 prescribe 9:25 Nurse prepare 9:30 Dr. Pushed insulin 9:45 Pt. reaction 9:46 RBS 0.8mmol 9:47 Glucose infusion 10:15 RBS 5.4 mmol 10:16 Transfer To SMC • 9:25, nurseYY prepared 50.0 u of regular insulin and kept them in kidney shaped basin at patient’s side table. • 9:30 am I’ve arrived at the patient side to push the dose in the IV line. • 9:45 am, I was informed that my patient is sweaty and very nervous and shivering. Time line analysis
  • 17.
    • 9:45 am,his RBS retested, found 0.8 mmol/l. • 9:47 am, 1.0 L of 5% glucose was IV given, 50 ml of 50% glucose iv/30 min until RBS is 9.0 mmol. • 10:15 am, patient was referred to A/E. his last RBS was 5.4 mmol/l. 9.00 Pt. Attend 9:15 RBS 28.8 9:20 prescribe 9:25 Nurse prepare 9:30 Dr. Pushed insulin 9:45 Pt. reaction 9:46 RBS 0.8mmol 9:47 Glucose infusion 10:15 RBS 5.4 mmol 10:16 Transfer To SMC Time line analysis
  • 18.
    How to admityour medical errors? 5- Disclosure
  • 19.
    1. Open communicationwith patient and family 2. Talk in privacy 3. Keep telephone closed, prevent distraction 4. Let a colleague attend the discussion 5. No blames 6. Don't be defensive Disclosure Technique 5- Disclosure
  • 20.
    Disclosure Technique Describe whathappened in facts, not opinion Tell consequences of the event Tell steps being taken to manage the event Tell steps being taken to prevent recurrence Express your sorrow and regret
  • 21.
    Which is better!! Burrythe whole thing Disclose the event
  • 22.
    Why disclosure  Literatureshows that after an unanticipated outcome, the patient and family want to know honestly:  What happened?  How it happens?  How hospital will prevent future events?
  • 23.
    Why disclosure  Weare our patient’s advocates  Rebuilds trust  Keep good Doctor-Patient relationship
  • 24.
    Reporting: Do we havea policy for clinical incidents?  Follow you own Reporting Policy and process  Use your own Reporting Form 6- Reporting
  • 25.
    What do youexpect next?  To determine sequence of events that led to consequence  To take corrective action & recommendations  To prevent recurrence of the incident 7- Investigate
  • 26.
    Who can investigate? InvestigationTeam  Employee ‘s supervisor  Safety officer  Safety committee representative  Employee involved
  • 27.
  • 28.
    How to investigate? CaseReview Root Cause Analysis 5 Way Chart In response to adverse event THREE possible ways of investigations are found:
  • 29.
    Case Review • Todecide if the medical care offered is of accepted standards? • If not, the offender physician may be subjected to certain supports. • To recommend corrective measures such as education and training
  • 30.
    System Nurse Patient had receivedover dose of insulin No written P&P Environment Dim light Poor maintenance PatientDoctor Pt did not speak up Pt unaware of speak up initiative Miss interpret dose Dim light Poor maintenance Did not check/recheck dose No written P&P Used illegal format Unaware of legal format Did not check dose before inj No written P&P Root Cause Analysis and fish bone graph Exhausted Overworking Hours
  • 31.
    Patient received insulin over dose Doctor Dr. Used illegible numberform. Dr. Unaware of eligible format No DPP for prescrip writing Dr. did not check dose before inj. No DPP for drug admin Nurse Mis-interpret dose Dim light Poor light maitenance Nurse did not use check- recheck method No DPP for drug admin Environment Dim light Poor light maintenance System No DPP for drug admin. Patient Pt. did not speak up Pt. unaware of speak up initiative 5 whys? chart
  • 32.
    What are thepossible mistakes done? * Used unusual number format (5.0) * Did not recheck the 7 Rs before pushing medicine * Misinterpret prescription * Did not obey 7 Rs before giving injection * Did not speak up before pushing injection.
  • 33.
    What are thepossible mistakes done? The 7 Rights
  • 34.
    Poor maintenance of lighting inthe treatment room. What are the Root Causes of the event Unaware of (Do NOT DO LIST). Physician Unaware of the Speak Up Initiative Patients • No written policy & procedure of drug administration • Overworking Hours for nurses System Environment
  • 35.
    Recommendations 1. Educate doctorson DO Not DO List. 2. Educate patients about Speak Up Initiatives. 3. Provide a written policy and procedure for drug administration. 4. Improve maintenance in the treatment room. 5. Never to blame or judge liability 8- Change
  • 36.
  • 37.
    What about theError maker!
  • 38.
    Error maker!! How doeshe feel?? • Shame • Afraid of punishment • Isolated • Worthless • His opinion and advice are not required
  • 39.
    How do werespond to error maker? TRUST: • Treatment in just • Respect • Understanding and compassion • Supportive care • Transparency and opportunity to contribute
  • 40.
    • Talk tosome one for: • Reaffirmation of their professional competency • Validation in their decision making ability. • Reassurance of self worth. What does he need?
  • 41.
    • Learning /changing. •Involving in other issues • Physical activity/distraction • Seeking support e.g. counselling What does She/he need?
  • 42.