A look at the similarities and differences between ADDIE and Dick and Carey Instructional Design Models

1. ADDIE vs Dick and Carey
Instructional Design Models
By Latoya Burrows

2. ADDIE Model
This model is the first of its kind
and hence is referred to as the
classic model for all other models
use it as a base to design their own.

3. Dick and Carey Model
This model is also referred to as
The Systems Approach Model.

4. What is similar between the two
models?
Uses a Systematic approach
ADDIE and Dick and Carey Models complete all phases none is skipped or
exempted.
Analysis is the first phase
Evaluation takes place

5. Distinguishing between the Two:
ADDIE
• Consists of 5 phases
• Use mainly in business and
organizational environments
• Must succeed with excellence in one
phase before moving to the next
• More Linear model
Dick & Carey
• Consists of 10 detailed phases
• Used in curriculum development in
schools
• Behaviourist approach
• More Agile model

6. ADVANTAGES
ADDIE
• Widely used in business and
education
• Uses a sequential order that is clear
and structured
Dick and Carey
• Uses a systematic process with
measurable and straightforward
objectives
• Evaluation and revision can take
place throughout

7. CHALLENGES
ADDIE
• Uses a linear approach which
doesn’t make it as flexible
• Strict approach that takes a lot of
time and can be very expensive
• Has to be completed with no
mistakes before you can move from
one phase to the next
Dick and Carey
• Too many phases which can take
up a lot of time
• Each phase is of importance and
must be completed

8. CONCLUSION
• Both ADDIE and Dick and Carey are widely used Instructional Design
Models
• Depending on the task at hand one can determine which works best for each
as its pros and cons

9. SOURCES
Arshavskiy, Marina (2017) Instructional Design for Elearning: Esssential
guide to creating successful elearning courses,
2nd Edition
http://www.bing.com/images/
https://id-models.wikispaces.com/Dick+and+Carey+Design+Model
https://trainingindustry.com/wiki/addie-model/?utm_content=cpdc