Compare and Contrast the ADDIE Model to Dick and Carey Model What is fundamentally the same with each model and likewise, what is different? Identify at least one advantage and one challenge that each ID model presents when compared to each other.

1. COMPARE AND
CONTRAST THE
ADDIE TO DICK
AND CAREY
MODEL

2. ADDIE Model to
Dick and Carey
Model
•ADDIE model is the traditional and system
ID model that consists of 5 phases:
Analysis, Design, development,
implementation, and evaluation.
ADDIE
•Dick and Carey model promotes a system
view of instruction instead of viewing
instruction as a sum of isolated work.
DICK &
CAREY
•Used mainly in business and
organizational environments.
ADDIE
•Used in curriculum development and
schools
DICK &
CAREY

3. ADDIE Model to Dick
and Carey Model
ADDIE
DICK &
CAREY
ADDIE
DICK &
CAREY
It is a must to
succeed with
excellence in
one phase
before moving
to the next.
Behaviorist
approach
More Linear
Model
More Agile
model

4. SIMILARITIES
Both model share common concentration on
input, output and whole design of a
curriculum
They are both instruments of instructional
design
Both models provide the guidelines or
frameworks to organize and construct the
process of creating guided teachings
initiatives.

5. DIFFERENCES
ADDIE model is set up to evaluate in
fifth and final phase in its approach
whiles the Dick and Carey model has
evaluation throughout each phase of the
method.
ADDIE is more flexible whiles Dick and
Carey is more detailed and straight
forward.
In ADDIE evaluation only happens in the
fifth and final phase whiles in Dick and
Carey evaluation happens throughout
each phase of the method.
ADDIE comprises of 5 components whiles
Dick and Carey comprises of 10
components.

6. SUMMARY
It follows a linear
approach and has
more applications.

7. IT DOES NOT STIFF CREATIVITY.

8. IT IS MORE EXPENSIVE.

9. IT IS MORE
TIME
CONSUMING

10. 11/4/2022
THANK YOU
Nana Komeh Berghult
HRD-647: PRINCPLS INSTR & DIGTL