ADDIE vs Dick and Carey Model. A description of the models, their similarities and and differences.

1. ADDIE VS DICK
AND CAREY
MODEL
Instructional Design 647
By: Cheryl Nesbitt

2. What is the
ADDIE MODEL?
The Addie model is an instructional design methodology used to help
organize and streamline the production of your course content.
ADDIE Is:
 Analysis – Is understanding the problem.
 Design - Designing the learning Programme, defining learning objectives
and planning the structure and content.
 Development - Taking information gathered to develop learning materials
and activities
 Implementation - Once the content has been finalized and all the hard
work is out of the way. It is ready for launch.
 Evaluation – Understanding how effective training is by gathering
feedback from learners. What works, what does not and how to improve.

3. What is the
Dick and Carey
MODEL ?
Created by: Walter Dick, Lou Carey, and James Carey
developed this comprehensive and detailed
process in 1978.
higean.com/2020/07/29
The Dick & Carey instructional design
model (AKA the Systems Approach
Model) is a 10 step process for
planning and designing effective
learning initiatives.
It includes all five stages of the
ADDIE model, but adds further
depth and structure as well. It also
has more focus on design and less
focus on implementation than the
ADDIE model, builds in iterative
development through ongoing
revised instructions.

4. Compare ADDIE & DICK and CAREY 4
The similarity between both models is in its
system approaches, which focuses on the
input, output, and process of a curriculum’s
design. Both models focuses on what learners
must know and can be revised using
evaluations from the learning processes.

5. HOW are these MODELS Different?
ADDIE
 Consists of 5 Phases
 More linear Design
 Evaluation is done at the final phase
5
Dick and Carey model
 Consists of 10 detailed Phases
 More Agile Design
 Evaluation is conducted at every phase,
additional evaluation is conducted to revise
the instructions to ensure a phases is
successful.

6. Advantages
Advantages
and Disadvantages of ADDIE
Disadvantages

7. • The model can be used in various subject
areas in schools as well as in the business
world
• Is very flexible.
• This model is very goal-oriented and works
as a system, .
• Other components of the model
interconnect with each other and is
developed from an initial starting point
• This model takes the learners and their
prior knowledge and preconceived notions
into consideration.
• The learners' entry behaviors affect the
decision making in the design process
• Learners' needs can be addressed and
expectations can be met.
7
Advantages and
Disadvantages of DICKAND CAREY

8. References
DDIE model: What is it and why is it useful? (2020, July 29). Amphigean. https://amphigean.com/2020/07/29/addie-model-what-is-it-
and-why-is-it-useful/
Compare & contrast ADDIE and Dick and Carey models. (2018, March 19). Share and Discover Knowledge on SlideShare.
https://www.slideshare.net/ingridsears1/compare-contrast-addie-and-dick-and-carey-models-91173075
Compare and contrast ADDIE model to Dick and Carey model. (n.d.). Share and Discover Knowledge on SlideShare.
https://www.slideshare.net/AthenaRussell2/compare-and-contrast-addie-model-to-dick-and-carey-model?qid=3d5c55fc-bec3-4d63-b1a2-
0dd90e174491&v=&b=&from_search=7
The comparison of ADDIE model and Dick & Carey model in designing a curriculum. (n.d.). gittahuri.
https://gittahuri.blogspot.com/2013/01/the-comparison-of-addie-model-and-
dick.html#:~:text=The%20ADDIE%20model%20has%20five,two%20big%20parts%20of%20evaluations
Davis, C. (n.d.). Overview of Instructional Design. Pacific Crest. https://www.pcrest.com/research/fgb/2_4_1.pdf
The Dick and Carey instructional design model. (2020, October 14). The World of Work Project. https://worldofwork.io/2019/08/dick-
carey-instructional-design-model/
Dick and Carey model & Gagne’s 9 events. (2016, May 17). Instructional Technologies & Material Design.
https://brkyzz.wordpress.com/instructional-design/dick-and-carey-model-gagnes-9-events/
Instructional design: Everything you need to know. (2021, March 14). Synapse. https://getsynapse.com/instructional-design-everything-
you-need-to-know/
Papina. (2014, October 5). The ADDIE model. SlideServe. https://www.slideserve.com/papina/the-addie-model
8