The document discusses and compares two instructional design models: the ADDIE model and the Dick and Carey model. The ADDIE model consists of 5 sequential stages - analysis, design, development, implementation, and evaluation. In contrast, the Dick and Carey model has 10 iterative phases and emphasizes clear, measurable learning objectives. Both models take a systems approach but differ in their number of steps and evaluation processes. Overall, the document concludes that both models can be useful tools for instructional designers to create concise and engaging training materials.

1. ADDIE and Dick and
Carey Model
Faith Phillips
06/06/2021
HRD-647-OL-2102: DIGITAL DESIGN FOR E-LEARNING

2. Introduction to Addie
Addie is an acronym for the five stages of a development process:
• Analysis
• Design
• Development
• Implementation
• Evaluation.

3. Cont’d
• The ADDIE model relies on each stage being done in the given order but
with a focus on reflection and iteration

4. Introduction to Dick and Carey
• The Dick and Carey Model is an instructional systems design
(ISD) model taking a systems approach and based on the research of
Walter Dick of Florida State University and Lou and James Carey of the
University of South Florida. Design and conduct a formative assessment to
determine how to improve instruction.

5. Strengths
ADDIE Model
Most widely used model and is the foundation for other ID models.
· It is flexible and can be used for traditional instruction and across many industries.
· Is most effective when testing for easily measurable criteria
· Allows for collaboration at each level and at any and every stage
· Evaluation is a key component built into ADDIE
· Structured guidance for design

6. Strengths
Dick and Carey Model
• The main strength of the model is that the designer requires clear and
measurable learning objectives, thereby developing instruction as a systematic
process.

7. Difference
• Each model has its own unique characteristics and elements that make up
each phase. The five phases of the ADDIE model: analysis, designing,
development, implementation, and evaluation, have a clear meaning and
understanding. This step-by-step method occurs linearly with easy distinction
in progression. With the Dick and Carey model, it includes much more detail
phases. The Dick and Carey consist of ten detail phases that are executed
iteratively rather than linearly like the Addie model.

8. Similarity
• There is a similarity between both the ADDIE and Dick and Carey models
of instructional design. The system approaches that are both models are on
the input, the output, and the process of designing the curriculum. The two
differences are the number of steps put into each model and the evaluation
process of each method of design.

9. Conclusion
• While there are similarities and difference between ADDIE and the Dick and
Carey models, both models are good tools that be used by trainers to have a
more concise , engaging, efficient and deliberate training materials.