112 Portugal – eCall Implementation Open Issues
Vitor Judicibus, Head of Critical Communications Multidisciplinary Team, General Secretariat of Internal Administration
Event-Driven Architecture Masterclass: Integrating Distributed Data Stores Ac...
EENA 2018 - eCall implementation remaining issues
1. 112 Portugal
eCall Implementation and Open Issues
EENA Conference 2018, 25-27 April – Ljubljana, Slovenia
Vítor Judícibus
General Secretariat of Internal Administration
Head of Critical Communications Multidisciplinary Team
2. EENA Conference 2018 | 112 Portugal eCall Implementation and Open Issues
General Framework
ADMINISTRAÇÃO INTERNA
(Internal Administration)
PLANEAMENTO E INFRAESTUTURAS
(Planning and infrastructure)
- Technology
- Physical Facilities
- Logistics
- Human
Resources
- Operational
Management
- Periodic Technical
Inspections
- End of Life Vehicles
PSAPPSAP VEHICLES
3. EENA Conference 2018 | 112 Portugal eCall Implementation and Open Issues
112COSul
National PSAP
Regional PSAP
Districts where 112 calls were
handled in the respective Regional
PSAP
Districts where the 112 calls were
handled by the National PSAP - 112
COSul ( 112 South Operational
Center)
Madeira
Azores
PSAP Scenario in 2015
Porto
Lisbon
4. EENA Conference 2018 | 112 Portugal eCall Implementation and Open Issues
112COSul
Madeira
Azores
National PSAPs
Regional PSAP’s
Standard 112 calls and eCalls from these are
handled by the new 112 CONor
(112 North Operational Center)
Standard 112 calls from theses regions are
handled by the respective Regional PSAP
while eCalls are handled in the National
PSAPs
Standard 112 calls and eCalls from these
districts are handled by the - 112 COSul (112
South Operational Center)
1. Build up a new National PSAP in Porto (112 CONor)
2. Upgrade the National PSAP in Lisbon (112 COSul)
3. Fit both National PSAPs with eCall technology
4. Route all the 112 calls with origin in mainland to the
most appropriate National PSAP
5. Route the eCalls generated all over the country
(including Madeira and Azores) to the right
National PSAP
Goals
6. Shut down the 11 Regional PSAPs in mainland
Goals Achieved
Lisbon
Portugal is eCall ready since 28th September 2017
112CONor
Porto
Goals for 2017Current Scenario
5. EENA Conference 2018 | 112 Portugal eCall Implementation and Open Issues
112 CONor (North Operational Center)
112 COSul (South Operational Center)
CONor & COSul
6. EENA Conference 2018 | 112 Portugal eCall Implementation and Open Issues
Dangerous goods
DATEX integration
eCall Box
(IVS)
Mobile
Operators
PSAP
Technology
Conformity
Assessment
Voice & eCall
eCall Implementation
7. EENA Conference 2018 | 112 Portugal eCall Implementation and Open Issues
Activation of eCall Flag
Integration of eCall in PSAP interfaces
Integration of eCall modem with the SIP Server
Conformity of eCall modem
eCall
Modem
eCall
Application
During the Conformity Assssment the following subsystems of the implemented eCall infrastructure were
tested. The eCall modem was already certified by a competent entity.
Conformity Assessment
8. EENA Conference 2018 | 112 Portugal eCall Implementation and Open Issues
PSAP
Certified
Equipment?
Yes
LAB (IEP)
Evaluation
of Suitability for use
Report
PSAP
Certificate of Equipment +
Report of Suitability for Use
No
LAB
Report
Evaluation of
conformity of the
components and
Suitability for use
PSAP
Conformity Assessment
Report, including
Equipment Assessment
and System Usability
ISO17025 ISO17025
IEP – Instituto Eletrotécnico Português (Portuguese Electrotechnical Institute)
Conformity Assessment Schema
9. EENA Conference 2018 | 112 Portugal eCall Implementation and Open Issues
The Suitability for Use eCall tests are translated through five rated Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) that are
defined in the session 7.2 of the document “I_HeERO Milestone 9 Conformance Assessment documentation -
part 2”.
The eCall tests were executed using certified IVS’s. Each IVS device was triggering the needed electronic
transactions for stimulating the generation and the logging of the relevant data for calculating the KPIs that assess and
rate the behavior of the PSAP under test. According to the reference document there are three possible ratings that
each KPI can get: “High Quality”, “Standard” and “Basic”.
• Success rate of completed eCall using 112
• Success rate of call-backs
• Success rate of correct MSDs
• Success rate of correct re-transmitted MSDs
• Duration of voice channel blocking
KPI’s
Conformity Assessment
10. EENA Conference 2018 | 112 Portugal eCall Implementation and Open Issues
S.O.S.
112
eCall Voice Test
Position
PSAP
Calltaking
Position
eCall Test
Real 112 voice call
eCall voice
received
Test
IVS
Real 112 voice
Call received
Incorrect configuration of the handset generated a fake eCall
Issue #1- Ghost Calls (2015)
11. EENA Conference 2018 | 112 Portugal eCall Implementation and Open Issues
ETSI Standard - ETSI 3GPP TS 24.008
Issue #1- Ghost Calls
12. EENA Conference 2018 | 112 Portugal eCall Implementation and Open Issues
The most common audit finding was the mobile handsets sending all bits set to "1"
Trace Example – Incorrect eCall
All bits are
set to 1
Issue #1- Ghost Calls (2015)
13. EENA Conference 2018 | 112 Portugal eCall Implementation and Open Issues
Emergency Category Bits
Type of call
X6 ="1" 00 10 00 00 Manual eCall
X7="1" 01 00 00 00 Automatic eCall
Other combinations Default Normal Emergency Call
In place in Portugal since 21st September 2017
Corrective action implemented in Portugal by all MNO’s
Alternative corrective action
Configuration of the PSAP Modem in PUSH-mode
- In this case we have near 5 seconds of silence
during the call while the PSAP tries to detect
the IVS initiation signal.
Issue #1- Ghost Calls (2017)
14. EENA Conference 2018 | 112 Portugal eCall Implementation and Open Issues
August 2017 Sept 2017
Issue #1- Ghost Calls (2017)
15. EENA Conference 2018 | 112 Portugal eCall Implementation and Open Issues
Stage
1
Stage
2
Two last digits
dropped
Receiving and
handling eCall
15 Digits17 Digits 15 Digits
eCall Callback
Impossible
MSISDN 15 Digits
Incoming eCall with
17 digits (15 + “00”)
00 882 123456789012
International
call prefix
International
call prefix
Outgoing Call with
“13” digits + 00
00 882 1234567890 12
MSISDN 13 Digits
These two digits were
dropped in the stage 1, so
the number is incomplete
and callback is not
possible
Issue #2 – 15 digit MSISDN Numbering
16. EENA Conference 2018 | 112 Portugal eCall Implementation and Open Issues
Stage
1
Stage
2
Stage
3
Removing the TWO
Leading ZEROS
Receiving and
handling eCall
15 Digits17 Digits 15 Digits 17 Digits
eCall Callback
successful
Adding the TWO
Leading ZEROS
MSISDN 15 Digits
Incoming eCall with
17 digits (15 + “00”)
00 882 123456789012
International
call prefix
International
call prefix
Outgoing Call with
17 digits (15 + “00”)
00 882 123456789012
MSISDN 15 Digits
Workaround already in place in Portugal
Issue #2 – 15 digit MSISDN Numbering
17. EENA Conference 2018 | 112 Portugal eCall Implementation and Open Issues
Recommendations
• Commit official entities with decision-making responsibilities;
• Use a reliable and knowledge network (I_HeERO role was a paramount importance);
• Slice the eCall implementation, to isolate the tasks complexity;
• Assign a work consortium team with the right skills to deal with each part of the eCall
chain;
• eCall is not an out of the box solution!!!
• Needs Tests, tests, tests …
• Share the issues, the solutions and the results, with all stakeholders.
18. EENA Conference 2018 | 112 Portugal eCall Implementation and Open Issues
THANK YOU
HVALA
OBRIGADO
Vítor Judícibus
General Secretariat of Internal Administration
Head of Critical Communications Multidisciplinary Team
Portugal
vjudicibus@sg.mai.gov.pt