SlideShare a Scribd company logo
The Web of Wealth 
Resiliency and Opportunity 
or Driver of Inequality? 
Thomas Shapiro, PhD 
Institute on Assets and Social Policy 
Neighborhood Partnerships RE: Conference 
October 29, 2014
Patricia Arrora’s Story 
• Work 
• Community 
• Family 
• Home
Toxic Inequality 
• Different Sort and Experience of Inequality 
• Quantitative Dimensions 
• Qualitative Meanings 
• Dysfunctional for Human, Community, 
Economic Development
Perfect Storm 
• Demographic Shift: Majority-Minority 
• Historic High Inequality Meets Falling 
Standard of Living 
• Racial Wealth Gap
The Widening Racial Wealth Gap 
1984 - 2011
President Obama, 50th Anniversary, March on 
Washington 
• “Yes, there have been examples of 
success within black America that would 
have been unimaginable a half century 
ago… 
• The gap in wealth between races has not 
lessened, it's grown.”
What’s Driving the Increasing Racial Wealth Gap 
Number of Years of Homeownership 28% 
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 
Household Income 
College Education 
Unemployment 
Financial Support/Inheritance 
17% 
6% 
5% 
4%
How Policy Increases Inequality 
• MID-- Mortgage Interest Deduction 
• Estate Tax 
• Let’s move from the DC-centric view to 
families in our communities.
From Safety Net to Launch 
• Anti-Poverty programs Lifts 40,000,000 Out of 
Poverty 
• Cornerstone of asset strategy is Emergency + 
Opportunity 
• our aspiration, social justice, equity not 
served until sustainable well-being achieved 
for communities, families.
The Private Safety Net: Facilitating Resilience 
1 in 5 Leveraging Mobility families received 
help from the web of wealth for 
unanticipated life events. 
Quianna Fountain: 
“when we move [in] the next 45 to 60 days I will 
probably have to borrow money… from my brother and 
his wife. You know, at least in the interim until I get the 
deposit back from this lady.”
Improving Family Well- 
Being 
• ¼ Leveraging Mobility 
families received well-being 
family help 
• Paulette Rotella – help 
with housing
Opportunity Investments 
• Impact on house 
purchased 
• Bachelor Degree – 
worker earns 84% 
more over life-time 
than high-school 
graduate
Inheriting Status 
• Transformative assets 
• Capital that provided income 
• Nicola and Jessica Bzdell
Leveraging Mobility Series 
iasp.brandeis.edu tmshapiro 
The Leveraging Mobility Study is funded by The Ford Foundation 
Released Reports 
• Hard Choices: Navigating the 
Economic Shock of Unemployment 
• Leveraging Mobility: Building 
Wealth, Security, and Opportunity 
for Family Well-Being 
• Employment Capital: how work 
builds and protects wealth 
• Keeping Dreams Alive: the Lane- 
Changer Costs of Financial 
Disruptions 
• The Web of Wealth: facilitating 
resilience and opportunity or 
reproducing inequality? 
Future Reports 2014 
• Location, location, location: the 
importance of neighborhood for 
building wealth 
• Facing retirement insecurity: 
managing for tomorrow
THANKS! 
tshapiro@brandeis.edu 
iasp.brandeis.edu @ IASP_Heller 
@ tmshapiro 
IASP is searching for a Senior Research Associate, to learn more please 
visit www.iasp.brandeis.edu
The Challenge of a Weak Web of Wealth 
“We’re all working class people. I have two 
brothers…the one brother who works…as a bus 
driver….Another brother who is a surveyor for 
the state, so we’re all working class, we’re all 
blue collar….I can’t call them up for money 
because they are just working too…in both 
families we’re probably the most stable…” 
—Ashley Dudley
Innovative Models: Emergency Wealth 
Sharing Funds 
New Hampshire: 
Neighbor Helping 
Neighbor Fund 
Community Action Agencies 
and Utility companies 
http://nhnfund.org 
Build Wealth 
Minnesota Hardship 
Fund 
- Grant/loan combination 
- Repayment in 9 months 
- Alternative to payday 
loans 
www.buildwealthmn.org/ 
hardship.php
Strengthen Government Emergency Programs 
Expand the supply of 
affordable and 
emergency housing 
• Support for rapid re-housing 
programs 
• Support for maintenance 
of existing affordable 
housing stock 
• Additional development 
of affordable housing 
Update and reform 
unemployment insurance 
• Expand eligibility criteria 
Increase awareness about 
eligibility for 
unemployment and other 
emergency programs
Strengthen Existing Wealth-Building 
First time home-buyer 
assistance 
• Down-payment and 
closing costs 
assistance – e.g. City of 
Boston 
• Sustainable mortgages 
– e.g. Community 
Advantage Program 
• Low down-payment 
mortgages 
Support employment 
wealth building 
• Matched retirement 
savings 
• Investments in education 
Individual family savings 
• Emergency Savings 
Programs 
• Child Savings Accounts
Leveraging Mobility Series 
iasp.brandeis.edu tmshapiro 
The Leveraging Mobility Study is funded by The Ford Foundation 
Released Reports 
• Hard Choices: Navigating the 
Economic Shock of Unemployment 
• Leveraging Mobility: Building 
Wealth, Security, and Opportunity 
for Family Well-Being 
• Employment Capital: how work 
builds and protects wealth 
• Keeping Dreams Alive: the Lane- 
Changer Costs of Financial 
Disruptions 
• The Web of Wealth: facilitating 
resilience and opportunity or 
reproducing inequality? 
Future Reports 2014 
• Location, location, location: the 
importance of neighborhood for 
building wealth 
• Facing retirement insecurity: 
managing for tomorrow

More Related Content

What's hot

Ewan Fisher
Ewan Fisher Ewan Fisher
Ewan Fisher
Alison Clyde
 
Tackling loneliness presented by Mick Ward Outer East community committee jan...
Tackling loneliness presented by Mick Ward Outer East community committee jan...Tackling loneliness presented by Mick Ward Outer East community committee jan...
Tackling loneliness presented by Mick Ward Outer East community committee jan...
Leeds City Council
 
The Canadian Experience. Susan Phillips
The Canadian Experience. Susan PhillipsThe Canadian Experience. Susan Phillips
The Canadian Experience. Susan PhillipsGiving Centre
 
Maps, Apps and Storytelling
Maps, Apps and StorytellingMaps, Apps and Storytelling
Maps, Apps and StorytellingDavid Wilcox
 
Emerging opportunities and tensions in community foundations’ development in ...
Emerging opportunities and tensions in community foundations’ development in ...Emerging opportunities and tensions in community foundations’ development in ...
Emerging opportunities and tensions in community foundations’ development in ...Giving Centre
 
DC-based Eisenhower Fellows journey through China
DC-based Eisenhower Fellows journey through China DC-based Eisenhower Fellows journey through China
DC-based Eisenhower Fellows journey through China
thezadivya
 
Giving Circles and Democratizing Philanthropy
Giving Circles and Democratizing PhilanthropyGiving Circles and Democratizing Philanthropy
Giving Circles and Democratizing PhilanthropyGiving Centre
 
MLS Participant Guide
MLS Participant GuideMLS Participant Guide
MLS Participant Guide
mobilizedotorg
 
Generation Connection
Generation ConnectionGeneration Connection
Generation Connection
YourPBC
 
Special Letter from Timothy McClimon, President of American Express Foundation
Special Letter from Timothy McClimon, President of American Express FoundationSpecial Letter from Timothy McClimon, President of American Express Foundation
Special Letter from Timothy McClimon, President of American Express Foundationmobilizedotorg
 
Building Livelihoods for Rural Youth: A Gendered Perspective
Building Livelihoods for Rural Youth: A Gendered PerspectiveBuilding Livelihoods for Rural Youth: A Gendered Perspective
Building Livelihoods for Rural Youth: A Gendered Perspective
African Regional Strategic Analysis and Knowledge Support System (ReSAKSS)
 
Engaging our youth in Islamic Activities
Engaging our youth in Islamic ActivitiesEngaging our youth in Islamic Activities
Engaging our youth in Islamic Activities
Al-Mahmud Ali
 
Using mentorship to encourage diversity in organizational leadershi pppt (1)
Using mentorship to encourage diversity in organizational leadershi pppt (1)Using mentorship to encourage diversity in organizational leadershi pppt (1)
Using mentorship to encourage diversity in organizational leadershi pppt (1)
Michael Adams
 
Community builder team training
Community builder team trainingCommunity builder team training
Community builder team training
forevermanchestercommunities
 

What's hot (18)

Ewan Fisher
Ewan Fisher Ewan Fisher
Ewan Fisher
 
Tackling loneliness presented by Mick Ward Outer East community committee jan...
Tackling loneliness presented by Mick Ward Outer East community committee jan...Tackling loneliness presented by Mick Ward Outer East community committee jan...
Tackling loneliness presented by Mick Ward Outer East community committee jan...
 
The Canadian Experience. Susan Phillips
The Canadian Experience. Susan PhillipsThe Canadian Experience. Susan Phillips
The Canadian Experience. Susan Phillips
 
Maps, Apps and Storytelling
Maps, Apps and StorytellingMaps, Apps and Storytelling
Maps, Apps and Storytelling
 
Emerging opportunities and tensions in community foundations’ development in ...
Emerging opportunities and tensions in community foundations’ development in ...Emerging opportunities and tensions in community foundations’ development in ...
Emerging opportunities and tensions in community foundations’ development in ...
 
DC-based Eisenhower Fellows journey through China
DC-based Eisenhower Fellows journey through China DC-based Eisenhower Fellows journey through China
DC-based Eisenhower Fellows journey through China
 
Aging in the Shadows
Aging in the ShadowsAging in the Shadows
Aging in the Shadows
 
Giving Circles and Democratizing Philanthropy
Giving Circles and Democratizing PhilanthropyGiving Circles and Democratizing Philanthropy
Giving Circles and Democratizing Philanthropy
 
MLS Participant Guide
MLS Participant GuideMLS Participant Guide
MLS Participant Guide
 
Portfolio
PortfolioPortfolio
Portfolio
 
SOWK 200
SOWK 200SOWK 200
SOWK 200
 
Generation Connection
Generation ConnectionGeneration Connection
Generation Connection
 
Special Letter from Timothy McClimon, President of American Express Foundation
Special Letter from Timothy McClimon, President of American Express FoundationSpecial Letter from Timothy McClimon, President of American Express Foundation
Special Letter from Timothy McClimon, President of American Express Foundation
 
Building Livelihoods for Rural Youth: A Gendered Perspective
Building Livelihoods for Rural Youth: A Gendered PerspectiveBuilding Livelihoods for Rural Youth: A Gendered Perspective
Building Livelihoods for Rural Youth: A Gendered Perspective
 
Engaging our youth in Islamic Activities
Engaging our youth in Islamic ActivitiesEngaging our youth in Islamic Activities
Engaging our youth in Islamic Activities
 
Using mentorship to encourage diversity in organizational leadershi pppt (1)
Using mentorship to encourage diversity in organizational leadershi pppt (1)Using mentorship to encourage diversity in organizational leadershi pppt (1)
Using mentorship to encourage diversity in organizational leadershi pppt (1)
 
Community builder team training
Community builder team trainingCommunity builder team training
Community builder team training
 
Moving Toward A Transformative Dialogue on Race: Understanding the Importance...
Moving Toward A Transformative Dialogue on Race: Understanding the Importance...Moving Toward A Transformative Dialogue on Race: Understanding the Importance...
Moving Toward A Transformative Dialogue on Race: Understanding the Importance...
 

Similar to Web of Wealth - Thomas Shapiro - 2014 RE:Conference

Learning and Development: Preventing Generational Poverty | Economic opportun...
Learning and Development: Preventing Generational Poverty | Economic opportun...Learning and Development: Preventing Generational Poverty | Economic opportun...
Learning and Development: Preventing Generational Poverty | Economic opportun...
angela_silveira
 
Top Ten for 2 Gen
Top Ten for 2 GenTop Ten for 2 Gen
Top Ten for 2 Gen
Chris Singer
 
Epip wawf-using a gender lens
Epip wawf-using a gender lensEpip wawf-using a gender lens
Epip wawf-using a gender lens
EPIPNational
 
Alumni Motivation Under the Microscrope
Alumni Motivation Under the MicroscropeAlumni Motivation Under the Microscrope
Alumni Motivation Under the MicroscropeConverge Consulting
 
From Boomers to Millennials: Generation Specific Volunteer Recruitment, Reten...
From Boomers to Millennials: Generation Specific Volunteer Recruitment, Reten...From Boomers to Millennials: Generation Specific Volunteer Recruitment, Reten...
From Boomers to Millennials: Generation Specific Volunteer Recruitment, Reten...
Sarah Bradbury
 
Housing Strategic Communications and Advocacy
Housing Strategic Communications and AdvocacyHousing Strategic Communications and Advocacy
Housing Strategic Communications and Advocacy
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
Coaching For Success 2016
Coaching For Success 2016Coaching For Success 2016
Coaching For Success 2016Missy Woods
 
EOA2015: Amplifying the Community Voice
EOA2015: Amplifying the Community VoiceEOA2015: Amplifying the Community Voice
EOA2015: Amplifying the Community Voice
PIHCSnohomish
 
Chatham savannahsafetynetcouncil 3-26-13-v1.2
Chatham savannahsafetynetcouncil 3-26-13-v1.2Chatham savannahsafetynetcouncil 3-26-13-v1.2
Chatham savannahsafetynetcouncil 3-26-13-v1.2Marvin Heery
 
Public Relations Campaign Book - Habitat for Humanity Orange County
Public Relations Campaign Book - Habitat for Humanity Orange CountyPublic Relations Campaign Book - Habitat for Humanity Orange County
Public Relations Campaign Book - Habitat for Humanity Orange County
MeredithHardy2
 
2015-2016 Community Listening Report
2015-2016 Community Listening Report2015-2016 Community Listening Report
2015-2016 Community Listening Reportjesspadilla
 
Chatham savannahsafetynetcouncil 3-26-13
Chatham savannahsafetynetcouncil 3-26-13Chatham savannahsafetynetcouncil 3-26-13
Chatham savannahsafetynetcouncil 3-26-13
Marvin Heery
 
Racial Wealth Inequality: Myths, Realities, and What Can be Done About It Wor...
Racial Wealth Inequality: Myths, Realities, and What Can be Done About It Wor...Racial Wealth Inequality: Myths, Realities, and What Can be Done About It Wor...
Racial Wealth Inequality: Myths, Realities, and What Can be Done About It Wor...
Bonner Foundation
 
Media gender ppt (short)
Media gender ppt (short)Media gender ppt (short)
Media gender ppt (short)
Madhusudan Rao Datrika
 
Place Matters Presentation by David Williams
Place Matters Presentation by David WilliamsPlace Matters Presentation by David Williams
Place Matters Presentation by David Williams
NewPublicHealth
 
2015 Urban Extension Conference-The Culture of Personal Finance-05-15
2015 Urban Extension Conference-The Culture of Personal Finance-05-152015 Urban Extension Conference-The Culture of Personal Finance-05-15
2015 Urban Extension Conference-The Culture of Personal Finance-05-15
Barbara O'Neill
 
Homelessness Policy Review and Resources FINAL
Homelessness Policy Review and Resources FINALHomelessness Policy Review and Resources FINAL
Homelessness Policy Review and Resources FINALAbigail Christiansen
 
Your Home Matters Campaign Summary
Your Home Matters Campaign SummaryYour Home Matters Campaign Summary
Your Home Matters Campaign SummarySilver Caoili
 

Similar to Web of Wealth - Thomas Shapiro - 2014 RE:Conference (20)

Learning and Development: Preventing Generational Poverty | Economic opportun...
Learning and Development: Preventing Generational Poverty | Economic opportun...Learning and Development: Preventing Generational Poverty | Economic opportun...
Learning and Development: Preventing Generational Poverty | Economic opportun...
 
FINALBATEMANBOOK
FINALBATEMANBOOKFINALBATEMANBOOK
FINALBATEMANBOOK
 
Top Ten for 2 Gen
Top Ten for 2 GenTop Ten for 2 Gen
Top Ten for 2 Gen
 
Epip wawf-using a gender lens
Epip wawf-using a gender lensEpip wawf-using a gender lens
Epip wawf-using a gender lens
 
Alumni Motivation Under the Microscrope
Alumni Motivation Under the MicroscropeAlumni Motivation Under the Microscrope
Alumni Motivation Under the Microscrope
 
From Boomers to Millennials: Generation Specific Volunteer Recruitment, Reten...
From Boomers to Millennials: Generation Specific Volunteer Recruitment, Reten...From Boomers to Millennials: Generation Specific Volunteer Recruitment, Reten...
From Boomers to Millennials: Generation Specific Volunteer Recruitment, Reten...
 
Housing Strategic Communications and Advocacy
Housing Strategic Communications and AdvocacyHousing Strategic Communications and Advocacy
Housing Strategic Communications and Advocacy
 
Coaching For Success 2016
Coaching For Success 2016Coaching For Success 2016
Coaching For Success 2016
 
EOA2015: Amplifying the Community Voice
EOA2015: Amplifying the Community VoiceEOA2015: Amplifying the Community Voice
EOA2015: Amplifying the Community Voice
 
Chatham savannahsafetynetcouncil 3-26-13-v1.2
Chatham savannahsafetynetcouncil 3-26-13-v1.2Chatham savannahsafetynetcouncil 3-26-13-v1.2
Chatham savannahsafetynetcouncil 3-26-13-v1.2
 
Public Relations Campaign Book - Habitat for Humanity Orange County
Public Relations Campaign Book - Habitat for Humanity Orange CountyPublic Relations Campaign Book - Habitat for Humanity Orange County
Public Relations Campaign Book - Habitat for Humanity Orange County
 
2015-2016 Community Listening Report
2015-2016 Community Listening Report2015-2016 Community Listening Report
2015-2016 Community Listening Report
 
Chatham savannahsafetynetcouncil 3-26-13
Chatham savannahsafetynetcouncil 3-26-13Chatham savannahsafetynetcouncil 3-26-13
Chatham savannahsafetynetcouncil 3-26-13
 
Racial Wealth Inequality: Myths, Realities, and What Can be Done About It Wor...
Racial Wealth Inequality: Myths, Realities, and What Can be Done About It Wor...Racial Wealth Inequality: Myths, Realities, and What Can be Done About It Wor...
Racial Wealth Inequality: Myths, Realities, and What Can be Done About It Wor...
 
Media gender ppt (short)
Media gender ppt (short)Media gender ppt (short)
Media gender ppt (short)
 
Place Matters Presentation by David Williams
Place Matters Presentation by David WilliamsPlace Matters Presentation by David Williams
Place Matters Presentation by David Williams
 
2015 Urban Extension Conference-The Culture of Personal Finance-05-15
2015 Urban Extension Conference-The Culture of Personal Finance-05-152015 Urban Extension Conference-The Culture of Personal Finance-05-15
2015 Urban Extension Conference-The Culture of Personal Finance-05-15
 
MA21 - Real Lives
MA21 - Real LivesMA21 - Real Lives
MA21 - Real Lives
 
Homelessness Policy Review and Resources FINAL
Homelessness Policy Review and Resources FINALHomelessness Policy Review and Resources FINAL
Homelessness Policy Review and Resources FINAL
 
Your Home Matters Campaign Summary
Your Home Matters Campaign SummaryYour Home Matters Campaign Summary
Your Home Matters Campaign Summary
 

More from NeighborhoodPartnerships

Kevin Jeffries, Consumer Liaison, Oregon Department of Consumer and Business ...
Kevin Jeffries, Consumer Liaison, Oregon Department of Consumer and Business ...Kevin Jeffries, Consumer Liaison, Oregon Department of Consumer and Business ...
Kevin Jeffries, Consumer Liaison, Oregon Department of Consumer and Business ...
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
Laura Choi, Senior Research Associate – Community Development, Federal Reserv...
Laura Choi, Senior Research Associate – Community Development, Federal Reserv...Laura Choi, Senior Research Associate – Community Development, Federal Reserv...
Laura Choi, Senior Research Associate – Community Development, Federal Reserv...
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
Health as Housing
Health as HousingHealth as Housing
Health as Housing
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
Lisa Massena, Executive Director, Oregon Retirement Savings Plan
Lisa Massena, Executive Director, Oregon Retirement Savings PlanLisa Massena, Executive Director, Oregon Retirement Savings Plan
Lisa Massena, Executive Director, Oregon Retirement Savings Plan
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
Cupid Alexander, Housing Program Specialist, Portland Housing Bureau, How We ...
Cupid Alexander, Housing Program Specialist, Portland Housing Bureau, How We ...Cupid Alexander, Housing Program Specialist, Portland Housing Bureau, How We ...
Cupid Alexander, Housing Program Specialist, Portland Housing Bureau, How We ...
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
Kylie Patterson, Senior Policy Manager, CFED – Closing the Racial Wealth Divide
Kylie Patterson, Senior Policy Manager,  CFED – Closing the Racial Wealth DivideKylie Patterson, Senior Policy Manager,  CFED – Closing the Racial Wealth Divide
Kylie Patterson, Senior Policy Manager, CFED – Closing the Racial Wealth Divide
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
Jonath Colon, President, Hispanic Metropolitan Chamber, Microenterprise Devel...
Jonath Colon, President, Hispanic Metropolitan Chamber, Microenterprise Devel...Jonath Colon, President, Hispanic Metropolitan Chamber, Microenterprise Devel...
Jonath Colon, President, Hispanic Metropolitan Chamber, Microenterprise Devel...
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
Sheryl Lane, Director of Partnerships and Policy, EARN, Sparking Savings and ...
Sheryl Lane, Director of Partnerships and Policy, EARN, Sparking Savings and ...Sheryl Lane, Director of Partnerships and Policy, EARN, Sparking Savings and ...
Sheryl Lane, Director of Partnerships and Policy, EARN, Sparking Savings and ...
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
ECO Northwest, Hood River Housing Needs Analysis
ECO Northwest, Hood River Housing Needs AnalysisECO Northwest, Hood River Housing Needs Analysis
ECO Northwest, Hood River Housing Needs Analysis
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
Jesús Gerena, Family Independence Initiative
Jesús Gerena, Family Independence InitiativeJesús Gerena, Family Independence Initiative
Jesús Gerena, Family Independence Initiative
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
Dr. Crystal Hall, The Evans School of Social Policy, University of Washington...
Dr. Crystal Hall, The Evans School of Social Policy, University of Washington...Dr. Crystal Hall, The Evans School of Social Policy, University of Washington...
Dr. Crystal Hall, The Evans School of Social Policy, University of Washington...
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
Business Oregon, Janet Soto: Entrepreneurship Strategy
Business Oregon, Janet Soto: Entrepreneurship StrategyBusiness Oregon, Janet Soto: Entrepreneurship Strategy
Business Oregon, Janet Soto: Entrepreneurship Strategy
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
Hacienda CDC, Carlos Garcia: Financial Capability
Hacienda CDC, Carlos Garcia: Financial CapabilityHacienda CDC, Carlos Garcia: Financial Capability
Hacienda CDC, Carlos Garcia: Financial Capability
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
CFPB Your Money Your Goals Toolkit Training
CFPB Your Money Your Goals Toolkit TrainingCFPB Your Money Your Goals Toolkit Training
CFPB Your Money Your Goals Toolkit Training
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
Oregon IDA Roadshow: The data behind the Initiative
Oregon IDA Roadshow: The data behind the InitiativeOregon IDA Roadshow: The data behind the Initiative
Oregon IDA Roadshow: The data behind the Initiative
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
Removing barriers to improve access to housing opportunity
Removing barriers to improve access to housing opportunityRemoving barriers to improve access to housing opportunity
Removing barriers to improve access to housing opportunity
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
What does it cost to create housing opportunity?
What does it cost to create housing opportunity?What does it cost to create housing opportunity?
What does it cost to create housing opportunity?
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
Housing First in Oregon
Housing First in OregonHousing First in Oregon
Housing First in Oregon
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
What’s working? Strategies to create inclusive communities, mitigate and reve...
What’s working? Strategies to create inclusive communities, mitigate and reve...What’s working? Strategies to create inclusive communities, mitigate and reve...
What’s working? Strategies to create inclusive communities, mitigate and reve...
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 
Housing Opportunity in Oregon: A look at needs
Housing Opportunity in Oregon: A look at needsHousing Opportunity in Oregon: A look at needs
Housing Opportunity in Oregon: A look at needs
NeighborhoodPartnerships
 

More from NeighborhoodPartnerships (20)

Kevin Jeffries, Consumer Liaison, Oregon Department of Consumer and Business ...
Kevin Jeffries, Consumer Liaison, Oregon Department of Consumer and Business ...Kevin Jeffries, Consumer Liaison, Oregon Department of Consumer and Business ...
Kevin Jeffries, Consumer Liaison, Oregon Department of Consumer and Business ...
 
Laura Choi, Senior Research Associate – Community Development, Federal Reserv...
Laura Choi, Senior Research Associate – Community Development, Federal Reserv...Laura Choi, Senior Research Associate – Community Development, Federal Reserv...
Laura Choi, Senior Research Associate – Community Development, Federal Reserv...
 
Health as Housing
Health as HousingHealth as Housing
Health as Housing
 
Lisa Massena, Executive Director, Oregon Retirement Savings Plan
Lisa Massena, Executive Director, Oregon Retirement Savings PlanLisa Massena, Executive Director, Oregon Retirement Savings Plan
Lisa Massena, Executive Director, Oregon Retirement Savings Plan
 
Cupid Alexander, Housing Program Specialist, Portland Housing Bureau, How We ...
Cupid Alexander, Housing Program Specialist, Portland Housing Bureau, How We ...Cupid Alexander, Housing Program Specialist, Portland Housing Bureau, How We ...
Cupid Alexander, Housing Program Specialist, Portland Housing Bureau, How We ...
 
Kylie Patterson, Senior Policy Manager, CFED – Closing the Racial Wealth Divide
Kylie Patterson, Senior Policy Manager,  CFED – Closing the Racial Wealth DivideKylie Patterson, Senior Policy Manager,  CFED – Closing the Racial Wealth Divide
Kylie Patterson, Senior Policy Manager, CFED – Closing the Racial Wealth Divide
 
Jonath Colon, President, Hispanic Metropolitan Chamber, Microenterprise Devel...
Jonath Colon, President, Hispanic Metropolitan Chamber, Microenterprise Devel...Jonath Colon, President, Hispanic Metropolitan Chamber, Microenterprise Devel...
Jonath Colon, President, Hispanic Metropolitan Chamber, Microenterprise Devel...
 
Sheryl Lane, Director of Partnerships and Policy, EARN, Sparking Savings and ...
Sheryl Lane, Director of Partnerships and Policy, EARN, Sparking Savings and ...Sheryl Lane, Director of Partnerships and Policy, EARN, Sparking Savings and ...
Sheryl Lane, Director of Partnerships and Policy, EARN, Sparking Savings and ...
 
ECO Northwest, Hood River Housing Needs Analysis
ECO Northwest, Hood River Housing Needs AnalysisECO Northwest, Hood River Housing Needs Analysis
ECO Northwest, Hood River Housing Needs Analysis
 
Jesús Gerena, Family Independence Initiative
Jesús Gerena, Family Independence InitiativeJesús Gerena, Family Independence Initiative
Jesús Gerena, Family Independence Initiative
 
Dr. Crystal Hall, The Evans School of Social Policy, University of Washington...
Dr. Crystal Hall, The Evans School of Social Policy, University of Washington...Dr. Crystal Hall, The Evans School of Social Policy, University of Washington...
Dr. Crystal Hall, The Evans School of Social Policy, University of Washington...
 
Business Oregon, Janet Soto: Entrepreneurship Strategy
Business Oregon, Janet Soto: Entrepreneurship StrategyBusiness Oregon, Janet Soto: Entrepreneurship Strategy
Business Oregon, Janet Soto: Entrepreneurship Strategy
 
Hacienda CDC, Carlos Garcia: Financial Capability
Hacienda CDC, Carlos Garcia: Financial CapabilityHacienda CDC, Carlos Garcia: Financial Capability
Hacienda CDC, Carlos Garcia: Financial Capability
 
CFPB Your Money Your Goals Toolkit Training
CFPB Your Money Your Goals Toolkit TrainingCFPB Your Money Your Goals Toolkit Training
CFPB Your Money Your Goals Toolkit Training
 
Oregon IDA Roadshow: The data behind the Initiative
Oregon IDA Roadshow: The data behind the InitiativeOregon IDA Roadshow: The data behind the Initiative
Oregon IDA Roadshow: The data behind the Initiative
 
Removing barriers to improve access to housing opportunity
Removing barriers to improve access to housing opportunityRemoving barriers to improve access to housing opportunity
Removing barriers to improve access to housing opportunity
 
What does it cost to create housing opportunity?
What does it cost to create housing opportunity?What does it cost to create housing opportunity?
What does it cost to create housing opportunity?
 
Housing First in Oregon
Housing First in OregonHousing First in Oregon
Housing First in Oregon
 
What’s working? Strategies to create inclusive communities, mitigate and reve...
What’s working? Strategies to create inclusive communities, mitigate and reve...What’s working? Strategies to create inclusive communities, mitigate and reve...
What’s working? Strategies to create inclusive communities, mitigate and reve...
 
Housing Opportunity in Oregon: A look at needs
Housing Opportunity in Oregon: A look at needsHousing Opportunity in Oregon: A look at needs
Housing Opportunity in Oregon: A look at needs
 

Recently uploaded

Understanding the Challenges of Street Children
Understanding the Challenges of Street ChildrenUnderstanding the Challenges of Street Children
Understanding the Challenges of Street Children
SERUDS INDIA
 
NHAI_Under_Implementation_01-05-2024.pdf
NHAI_Under_Implementation_01-05-2024.pdfNHAI_Under_Implementation_01-05-2024.pdf
NHAI_Under_Implementation_01-05-2024.pdf
AjayVejendla3
 
What is the point of small housing associations.pptx
What is the point of small housing associations.pptxWhat is the point of small housing associations.pptx
What is the point of small housing associations.pptx
Paul Smith
 
PD-1602-as-amended-by-RA-9287-Anti-Illegal-Gambling-Law.pptx
PD-1602-as-amended-by-RA-9287-Anti-Illegal-Gambling-Law.pptxPD-1602-as-amended-by-RA-9287-Anti-Illegal-Gambling-Law.pptx
PD-1602-as-amended-by-RA-9287-Anti-Illegal-Gambling-Law.pptx
RIDPRO11
 
PPT Item # 5 - 5330 Broadway ARB Case # 930F
PPT Item # 5 - 5330 Broadway ARB Case # 930FPPT Item # 5 - 5330 Broadway ARB Case # 930F
PPT Item # 5 - 5330 Broadway ARB Case # 930F
ahcitycouncil
 
Get Government Grants and Assistance Program
Get Government Grants and Assistance ProgramGet Government Grants and Assistance Program
Get Government Grants and Assistance Program
Get Government Grants
 
Many ways to support street children.pptx
Many ways to support street children.pptxMany ways to support street children.pptx
Many ways to support street children.pptx
SERUDS INDIA
 
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) AmendmentPPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
ahcitycouncil
 
PPT Item # 8 - Tuxedo Columbine 3way Stop
PPT Item # 8 - Tuxedo Columbine 3way StopPPT Item # 8 - Tuxedo Columbine 3way Stop
PPT Item # 8 - Tuxedo Columbine 3way Stop
ahcitycouncil
 
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptxMHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
ILC- UK
 
PPT Item # 6 - 7001 Broadway ARB Case # 933F
PPT Item # 6 - 7001 Broadway ARB Case # 933FPPT Item # 6 - 7001 Broadway ARB Case # 933F
PPT Item # 6 - 7001 Broadway ARB Case # 933F
ahcitycouncil
 
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdfPACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
Mohammed325561
 
Opinions on EVs: Metro Atlanta Speaks 2023
Opinions on EVs: Metro Atlanta Speaks 2023Opinions on EVs: Metro Atlanta Speaks 2023
Opinions on EVs: Metro Atlanta Speaks 2023
ARCResearch
 
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 372024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
JSchaus & Associates
 
PPT Item # 7 - BB Inspection Services Agmt
PPT Item # 7 - BB Inspection Services AgmtPPT Item # 7 - BB Inspection Services Agmt
PPT Item # 7 - BB Inspection Services Agmt
ahcitycouncil
 
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
GrantManagementInsti
 
The Role of a Process Server in real estate
The Role of a Process Server in real estateThe Role of a Process Server in real estate
The Role of a Process Server in real estate
oklahomajudicialproc1
 
ZGB - The Role of Generative AI in Government transformation.pdf
ZGB - The Role of Generative AI in Government transformation.pdfZGB - The Role of Generative AI in Government transformation.pdf
ZGB - The Role of Generative AI in Government transformation.pdf
Saeed Al Dhaheri
 
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 362024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
JSchaus & Associates
 
一比一原版(QUT毕业证)昆士兰科技大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(QUT毕业证)昆士兰科技大学毕业证成绩单一比一原版(QUT毕业证)昆士兰科技大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(QUT毕业证)昆士兰科技大学毕业证成绩单
ukyewh
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Understanding the Challenges of Street Children
Understanding the Challenges of Street ChildrenUnderstanding the Challenges of Street Children
Understanding the Challenges of Street Children
 
NHAI_Under_Implementation_01-05-2024.pdf
NHAI_Under_Implementation_01-05-2024.pdfNHAI_Under_Implementation_01-05-2024.pdf
NHAI_Under_Implementation_01-05-2024.pdf
 
What is the point of small housing associations.pptx
What is the point of small housing associations.pptxWhat is the point of small housing associations.pptx
What is the point of small housing associations.pptx
 
PD-1602-as-amended-by-RA-9287-Anti-Illegal-Gambling-Law.pptx
PD-1602-as-amended-by-RA-9287-Anti-Illegal-Gambling-Law.pptxPD-1602-as-amended-by-RA-9287-Anti-Illegal-Gambling-Law.pptx
PD-1602-as-amended-by-RA-9287-Anti-Illegal-Gambling-Law.pptx
 
PPT Item # 5 - 5330 Broadway ARB Case # 930F
PPT Item # 5 - 5330 Broadway ARB Case # 930FPPT Item # 5 - 5330 Broadway ARB Case # 930F
PPT Item # 5 - 5330 Broadway ARB Case # 930F
 
Get Government Grants and Assistance Program
Get Government Grants and Assistance ProgramGet Government Grants and Assistance Program
Get Government Grants and Assistance Program
 
Many ways to support street children.pptx
Many ways to support street children.pptxMany ways to support street children.pptx
Many ways to support street children.pptx
 
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) AmendmentPPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
 
PPT Item # 8 - Tuxedo Columbine 3way Stop
PPT Item # 8 - Tuxedo Columbine 3way StopPPT Item # 8 - Tuxedo Columbine 3way Stop
PPT Item # 8 - Tuxedo Columbine 3way Stop
 
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptxMHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
 
PPT Item # 6 - 7001 Broadway ARB Case # 933F
PPT Item # 6 - 7001 Broadway ARB Case # 933FPPT Item # 6 - 7001 Broadway ARB Case # 933F
PPT Item # 6 - 7001 Broadway ARB Case # 933F
 
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdfPACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
 
Opinions on EVs: Metro Atlanta Speaks 2023
Opinions on EVs: Metro Atlanta Speaks 2023Opinions on EVs: Metro Atlanta Speaks 2023
Opinions on EVs: Metro Atlanta Speaks 2023
 
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 372024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
 
PPT Item # 7 - BB Inspection Services Agmt
PPT Item # 7 - BB Inspection Services AgmtPPT Item # 7 - BB Inspection Services Agmt
PPT Item # 7 - BB Inspection Services Agmt
 
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
 
The Role of a Process Server in real estate
The Role of a Process Server in real estateThe Role of a Process Server in real estate
The Role of a Process Server in real estate
 
ZGB - The Role of Generative AI in Government transformation.pdf
ZGB - The Role of Generative AI in Government transformation.pdfZGB - The Role of Generative AI in Government transformation.pdf
ZGB - The Role of Generative AI in Government transformation.pdf
 
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 362024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
 
一比一原版(QUT毕业证)昆士兰科技大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(QUT毕业证)昆士兰科技大学毕业证成绩单一比一原版(QUT毕业证)昆士兰科技大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(QUT毕业证)昆士兰科技大学毕业证成绩单
 

Web of Wealth - Thomas Shapiro - 2014 RE:Conference

  • 1. The Web of Wealth Resiliency and Opportunity or Driver of Inequality? Thomas Shapiro, PhD Institute on Assets and Social Policy Neighborhood Partnerships RE: Conference October 29, 2014
  • 2. Patricia Arrora’s Story • Work • Community • Family • Home
  • 3. Toxic Inequality • Different Sort and Experience of Inequality • Quantitative Dimensions • Qualitative Meanings • Dysfunctional for Human, Community, Economic Development
  • 4. Perfect Storm • Demographic Shift: Majority-Minority • Historic High Inequality Meets Falling Standard of Living • Racial Wealth Gap
  • 5. The Widening Racial Wealth Gap 1984 - 2011
  • 6. President Obama, 50th Anniversary, March on Washington • “Yes, there have been examples of success within black America that would have been unimaginable a half century ago… • The gap in wealth between races has not lessened, it's grown.”
  • 7. What’s Driving the Increasing Racial Wealth Gap Number of Years of Homeownership 28% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% Household Income College Education Unemployment Financial Support/Inheritance 17% 6% 5% 4%
  • 8. How Policy Increases Inequality • MID-- Mortgage Interest Deduction • Estate Tax • Let’s move from the DC-centric view to families in our communities.
  • 9. From Safety Net to Launch • Anti-Poverty programs Lifts 40,000,000 Out of Poverty • Cornerstone of asset strategy is Emergency + Opportunity • our aspiration, social justice, equity not served until sustainable well-being achieved for communities, families.
  • 10.
  • 11. The Private Safety Net: Facilitating Resilience 1 in 5 Leveraging Mobility families received help from the web of wealth for unanticipated life events. Quianna Fountain: “when we move [in] the next 45 to 60 days I will probably have to borrow money… from my brother and his wife. You know, at least in the interim until I get the deposit back from this lady.”
  • 12. Improving Family Well- Being • ¼ Leveraging Mobility families received well-being family help • Paulette Rotella – help with housing
  • 13. Opportunity Investments • Impact on house purchased • Bachelor Degree – worker earns 84% more over life-time than high-school graduate
  • 14. Inheriting Status • Transformative assets • Capital that provided income • Nicola and Jessica Bzdell
  • 15. Leveraging Mobility Series iasp.brandeis.edu tmshapiro The Leveraging Mobility Study is funded by The Ford Foundation Released Reports • Hard Choices: Navigating the Economic Shock of Unemployment • Leveraging Mobility: Building Wealth, Security, and Opportunity for Family Well-Being • Employment Capital: how work builds and protects wealth • Keeping Dreams Alive: the Lane- Changer Costs of Financial Disruptions • The Web of Wealth: facilitating resilience and opportunity or reproducing inequality? Future Reports 2014 • Location, location, location: the importance of neighborhood for building wealth • Facing retirement insecurity: managing for tomorrow
  • 16. THANKS! tshapiro@brandeis.edu iasp.brandeis.edu @ IASP_Heller @ tmshapiro IASP is searching for a Senior Research Associate, to learn more please visit www.iasp.brandeis.edu
  • 17. The Challenge of a Weak Web of Wealth “We’re all working class people. I have two brothers…the one brother who works…as a bus driver….Another brother who is a surveyor for the state, so we’re all working class, we’re all blue collar….I can’t call them up for money because they are just working too…in both families we’re probably the most stable…” —Ashley Dudley
  • 18. Innovative Models: Emergency Wealth Sharing Funds New Hampshire: Neighbor Helping Neighbor Fund Community Action Agencies and Utility companies http://nhnfund.org Build Wealth Minnesota Hardship Fund - Grant/loan combination - Repayment in 9 months - Alternative to payday loans www.buildwealthmn.org/ hardship.php
  • 19. Strengthen Government Emergency Programs Expand the supply of affordable and emergency housing • Support for rapid re-housing programs • Support for maintenance of existing affordable housing stock • Additional development of affordable housing Update and reform unemployment insurance • Expand eligibility criteria Increase awareness about eligibility for unemployment and other emergency programs
  • 20. Strengthen Existing Wealth-Building First time home-buyer assistance • Down-payment and closing costs assistance – e.g. City of Boston • Sustainable mortgages – e.g. Community Advantage Program • Low down-payment mortgages Support employment wealth building • Matched retirement savings • Investments in education Individual family savings • Emergency Savings Programs • Child Savings Accounts
  • 21. Leveraging Mobility Series iasp.brandeis.edu tmshapiro The Leveraging Mobility Study is funded by The Ford Foundation Released Reports • Hard Choices: Navigating the Economic Shock of Unemployment • Leveraging Mobility: Building Wealth, Security, and Opportunity for Family Well-Being • Employment Capital: how work builds and protects wealth • Keeping Dreams Alive: the Lane- Changer Costs of Financial Disruptions • The Web of Wealth: facilitating resilience and opportunity or reproducing inequality? Future Reports 2014 • Location, location, location: the importance of neighborhood for building wealth • Facing retirement insecurity: managing for tomorrow

Editor's Notes

  1. I’m going to talk briefly here today about the research brief IASP recently released “The Web of Wealth: Resiliency and Opportunity or Driver of Inequality?”. This report draws from a larger study “Leveraging Mobility” a project to examine inequities in how families build an I do want to highlight my co-authors Tatjana Meschede, Alexis Man, Janet Boguslaw, and Tom Shapiro. This brief examines the ways in which families use financial transfers from their extended family in a variety of different ways, and the differences this makes in their lives. During the course of this presentation I will touch on key points from the brief providing some data points and stories to illustrate our findings, and then I ‘ll spend some time discussing the implications for programming particularly from the perspective of philanthropic organizations.
  2. Housing, homeownership largest driver
  3. $2.3 Trillion over 5 years; Half to MID, Housing; about $200 Billion/year. Comparison: HUD $35 B; CBDG=$35 Billion. Where does the $200 B go?? This is a classic example of how national policy actually creates inequality. Is that the purpose of policy, hardly.
  4. So let’s start by talking about who receives financial transfers. The data in this slide comes from our analysis of the Panel Survey on Income dynamics, a nationally representative longitudinal survey. We followed the same households over a more than a quarter of a century to look at who received any financial transfer. Overall approximately one-third – 35% - of households received extended family financial transfers. When we did our analysis looking through a race lens, we saw a contrasting picture. African American headed households were much less likely to receive extended family financial transfers than were white headed households. As you can see in this slide, 46% of white households received a financial transfer. While only 10% of African American households did. This lower prevalence of receiving a financial transfer was compounded by the lower amounts that African American families received. The median financial transfer to white households was $83,692 while African Americans received about two thirds of this amount - $52,240. We then looked at the median change in wealth for those households who received a transfer. White households grew their wealth by $282,000 while African American households great their wealth by only $20,000. There are likely many other compounding variables that impact this difference in the median growth in wealth, but we know from other studies that have controlled for a variety of different variables, that the difference in the change in wealth between white households and African American households is impacted by these differences in the frequency and the amount of financial transfers that occur over the life-course. What are the implications of having access to these financial transfers or what we call a web of wealth?
  5. We draw on the Leveraging Mobility interview data to explore the ways that webs of wealth benefited families. A key advantage of having access to a web of wealth is for emergency help. Donna Hays loaned her sister money when she fell on tough times and then she said “If I’m having a bad month, she’ll loan me [back] to get through it.” Quianna Fountain also often drew on support from her brother and sister-in-law. She referred to her brother and his wife as the Bank of Tina and Marie. In 2010 when we spoke to her she needed to ask for help again from her brother. She said “When we move [in] the next 45 to 60 days I will probably have to borrow money… from my brother and his wife. You know, at least in the interim until I get the deposit back from this lady.”
  6. Extended family members often helped out in other ways by providing cash as gifts, paying for services and durable items, or providing in kind service such as childcare, services which were not emergencies, but helped to create well-being. The graphic web on this slide shows how often families in the Leveraging Mobility study received different kinds of help over the twelve year period between the first and second interviews. While not directly financial help, there were financial implications for the family since such help freed up income and wealth to be used for other purposes. One quarter of the Leveraging Mobility families received help with such services that helped to improve family well-being and impacted the family bottom line indirectly. Paulette Rotella was one of those who received such help. Over the years she relied on housing support from her mother to make ends meet. In 1998, she had just moved out of her mother’s house where she was living with her daughter rent free. She moved into an apartment in the same building which she was able to access because her mother knew the landlord. She lived in this apartment for the 12 years between interviews, and then shortly before we interviewed her in 2010 again, she had to move back in with her mother because her employer reduced her overtime hours and she couldn’t afford the rent any more. Paulette’s mother provided a critical support for Paulette to ensure she did not become homeless.
  7. In the Leveraging Mobility study, families often received help from the extended web of wealth to invest in opportunities for their off-spring or themselves. Just under half of the LM families used family help to invest in kids camps, private schools, college tutors, college education or a home. These investments help create opportunities and build wealth. A college educated child with a BA will earn 84% more over their lifetime than a high school graduate. And buying a home earlier in the life-course enables a family to build equity. Race played a role however. In L.M. of all white families interviewed, nearly two thirds received opportunity investments from extended family, while only a little more than one-third of African American families interviewed received such opportunity investments. The implications of such disparities is huge. Maybe talk about Soledad Givelber or the Cotters if time.
  8. For some families the amounts of wealth that were passed on were what we call “transformative” or sufficiently substantial and steady over time that a family’s economic status was shifted to a higher class. These are transformative assets providing wealth far beyond the achievements of the individual family members. Often they were in the form of capital such as stocks and bonds and land. Nearly one in four LM families received a financial transfer in the form of capital large enough to provide some income. Large and transformative asset transfers overwhelmingly went to white families. Among LM families nearly nine out of ten families that received more than $50,000 in financial help were white, while only just over one in ten were African American. Insert their story here. Nicola and Jessica Bzdell were one such family. Until just shortly before the 2010 interview, Jessica and Nicole Bzdell lived in a house in an East Coast city neighborhood. Both worked in non-profit jobs; their combined household income was $80,000. They did not have savings for college so they used their home’s equity to pay for their daughter’s college. Nicole’s mother lent them $300,000 to purchase a rural farm with the intention of moving in with them. While waiting for their urban home to sell Nicole’s mother passed away. Nicole was surprised to discover that she was sole beneficiary of her mother’s estate valued at $1 million in stocks and at least $300,000 in cash. When the urban house sold they netted an additional $200,000. Jessica and Nicole now had minimal housing expenses, an annual income of $40,000 from the stocks and cash to draw on if needed. Despite Nicole’s health related unemployment, Jessica could still take her $25,000 a year dream job. The inheritance shifted th efamily into the top decile of wealth holdings in the U.S. Jessica and Nicole inherited Nicole’s mother’s wealth status, moving them beyond their own achievements in work and education.
  9. Released four reports/briefs- encourage you to download/take a look. Four more to be released in 2014 Common theme through the data is that the resources you can access and the way policy is structured impacts families and communities ability to stabilize and advance. So this brief was just one example of the kind of data we are mining and the ways it contributes to policy discussions and product and service development. Questions/comments?
  10. Released four reports/briefs- encourage you to download/take a look. Four more to be released in 2014 Common theme through the data is that the resources you can access and the way policy is structured impacts families and communities ability to stabilize and advance. So this brief was just one example of the kind of data we are mining and the ways it contributes to policy discussions and product and service development. Questions/comments?
  11. Many families did not have a strong web of wealth. These families in LM were more often lower-income and African American. Ashley Dudley, an African American mother summed it up with this quote: “We’re all working class people. I have two brohters… the one brother who works… as a bus driver… Another brother who is a surveyor for the state, so we’re all working class, we’re all blue collar… I can’t call them up for money because they are just working too… in both families we’re probably the most stable.” Whatever the multiple reasons that families could not draw on their extended family for financial help, how a family fared, depended on the other resources available. Both Margaret Dove and Ashley Dudley, neither of whom had extended family wealth, were able to build wealth through their employers which provided them with savings they could draw on if need be. Heather Beanne, who when describing why there was no extended family wealth said “we’re a family of addicts”, found that her employer provided a first time homebuyers program that with downpayment assistance and a good mortgage enabled her to access homeownership to build some stability and wealth to leave her children. By contrast, without good alternative programs some ended up homeless. At the same time as losing her job, Gwedolin Rollins was cut out of family help when her father died because of her sexual orientation. Without good housing programs in the city she lives in, Gwedolin has found herself without housing and struggling to get back on her feet. The role of private and public programs is clearly critical in stepping in to fill the needs for families who lack the web of wealth.
  12. Ultimately the webs of wealth that families have access to mirror and exacerbate the broader inequities in the distribution of wealth by race and class in the US. We need to make sure that through both the public, private and non-profit sectors that we ensure all families have access to the same set of benefits – well-being, security and opportunity – that are obtained through access to a strong web of wealth. I want to spend a little time delving into some promising models of non-profit and public programs that we think can begin to fill the gaps that are left when families do not have access to a healthy web of wealth. For families that are financially vulnerable and without a web of wealth to draw on in an emergency, programs such as New Hampshire’s Neighbor Helping Neighbor Fund, or Build Wealth Minnesota’s Hardship fund offer the means for households to cover emergency costs. Started in 1986, New Hampshire’s Neighbor helping Neighbor Fund is a partnership between utility companies and community action agencies. Customers of the utility companies can donate money into a fund which is then tapped into when another customer has a problem paying their utility bill for some reason. The target customers for this emergency assistance fund are customers who do not qualify for the normal community action provided fuel assistance programs in the state. The Hardship Fund at Buildwealth Minnesota was created to minimize the impact of unforeseen catastrophe's that tend to deteriorate a family's financial position. The fund is a gratitude loan/grant fund that allows a family to use up to $4000 one time per year in the event of a major hardship such as a sudden loss of household income, death or disability of a family member, major unforeseen repairs or breakdowns, major medical or student hardships. The fund has no repayment plan or term with the exception of a nine (9) month maturity date. Only families enrolled and active in the long-term Financial Literacy program are eligible to utilize the fund. It is hoped that this fund will discourage the use of the new wave of pay-day loans and other predatory lending products that have been on the rise in recent months. The Hardship Fund provides families that have gone through an unforeseen incident or catastrophe that causes financial strain on the family temporary relief until they are back on their feet.
  13. Public programs have the capacity to address the need for emergency support during a crisis. Many programs already exist in both the public and the non-profit sector. Expanding the supply of affordable and emergency housing would support the need for housing in a crisis. Currently the wait times for emergency housing support can be very long meaning in practice many families need to draw on families for that support or become homeless. Rapid rehousing programs are programs that prioritize moving a family experiencing homelessness into permanent housing as quickly as possible. It includes three components – help identifying housing, rent and move-in financial assistance, and case management and services. Evaluations of the model point to its effectiveness. Unemployment insurance is another emergency financial assistance program that needs to be expanded and updated. Many workers are not eligible for the program, or aware of their eligibility and African American workers have lower rates of eligibility and awareness of eligibility.
  14. While addressing emergency assistance for households who do not have access to a web of wealth is important, we must not forget the needs for promoting wealth building that ultimately improves family well-being and stability. There are many existing wealth building programs worth looking at. One of the major ways that families have historically built wealth and stability is through purchasing a home. Families without a web of wealth are at a disadvantage in pursuing this goal since they do not have easy access to downpayment assistance, or even help qualifying for a mortgage. Many existing programs help to achieve this goal with downpayment assistance or sustainable and low-cost mortgages. While the financial crisis has discouraged the promotion of homeownership as a wealth-building tool, we must remember that there are responsible ways to promote homeownership in building wealth and financial stability. In other words, let’s not throw out the baby with the bathwater. Other wealth building programs, such as promoting wealth building through work, and helping families build individual family savings through matched savings programs can be beneficial, for example, emergency savings accounts, a form of individual savings accounts. Children’s savings accounts are yet another way for families to build wealth. Ultimately we need to look carefully at how programming impacts
  15. Released four reports/briefs- encourage you to download/take a look. Four more to be released in 2014 Common theme through the data is that the resources you can access and the way policy is structured impacts families and communities ability to stabilize and advance. So this brief was just one example of the kind of data we are mining and the ways it contributes to policy discussions and product and service development. Questions/comments?