A2 Media Studies – Unit
G324: Documentary
Evaluation
Question 3: What have you learned from your audience
feedback?
Introduction
When completing the research and planning process of our project, we
created a questionnaire to develop an understanding of our target
audience. Plus, we wanted to identify what features and information
audiences would like to know about ‘Health & Fitness’ in a television
documentary. In our initial questionnaire we asked males and females
aged 20-50+ if they were knowledgeable about the topic to see if, and
how we could help inform our audiences. This questionnaire lead us to
define a level of information and guidance in our documentary, which
worked very well. On the back of this success, we thought it would be
appropriate to create an additional questionnaire for the purpose of
gaining an understanding of audience feedback in relation to our
documentary, radio trailer and magazine article. We questioned a large
group of people in our target audience to feedback information about
our products.
Television Documentary

We questioned our audience, ‘On           On a scale of 1 - 10, how well would
a scale of 1 - 10, how well would         you say the documentary held your
you say the documentary held                           attention?
your attention?’. The results from    7
this were very pleasing. All of the
audience feedback was rated 6-        6
10, who said that the
documentary held their attention.     5
The majority of the audience
                                      4
suggested that the documentary
was on a scale of 8 for holding       3
their attention. This was very
successful and we feel as if our      2
documentary definitely holds
significant content within the        1
opening five minutes.                 0
                                          1   2   3   4   5    6   7   8   9     10
Television Documentary

We asked our target audience             Did you find that the sound levels
through the questionnaire, a                 were balanced and even?
simple yes or no question, ‘Did
                                    14
you find that the sound levels
were balanced and even?’. The       12
response from this was
overwhelming for ‘yes’ 12 people    10
said that they were balanced and
a small minority of 2 people said   8
no they were not. From this it is
clear that our sound levels were    6
well thought out and strong. The
                                    4
minority shows that they may
need a little tweaking in places.   2

                                    0
                                                yes                  no
Television Documentary

This basic question ‘Did you find          Did you find that you could relate to
that you could relate to any of the             any of the documentary?
documentary?’ was asked to
                                      16
ensure we had targeted our
audience precisely. The result was    14
as expected and 100% of the
audience response was ‘yes’.          12
Therefore, our documentary fits       10
its target audience perfectly and
our research and planning tasks       8
had all worked in our favor to
                                      6
create a strong and targeted
documentary.                          4

                                      2

                                      0
                                                   yes                  no
Television Documentary

We used a lot of colour in our            Were the colours managed
documentary so we want to gain                   effectively?
audience feedback to see if this
                                     16
was effectively used and well
composed so we asked ‘Were the       14
colours managed effectively?
                                     12
‘. The response was clear, 100% of
the audience said ‘yes’, which       10
illustrates that our colours were
appropriate and not too              8
overpowering, which is the effect    6
we wanted to achieve in our
documentary.                         4

                                     2

                                     0
                                               yes            no
Television Documentary

Due to targeting an adult audience
we wanted to develop a somewhat            Do you think that the tone of the
sophisticated tone to our                   documentary is sophisticated?
documentary. We asked our
audience ‘Do you think that the       14
tone of the documentary is
sophisticated?’ We had a positive     12
response from this question, the
majority (12 People), expressed       10
that our documentary was
sophisticated. However a minority
(2 people), said that our             8
documentary was not
sophisticated. The response suggest   6
that we had a strong sense of
sophistication, however in parts
this could have been improved.        4
Overall, we set out to achieve a
sophisticated tone and we feel this   2
was achieved, predominantly
through an authoritative voiceover.   0
                                                  yes                 no
Television Documentary

In our documentary we took a lot           Do you think that the shots for
of time and attention to detail to
create well framed compositions            the documentary were framed
abiding by the rule of thirds.                    appropriately?
Whether this was in the editing or    16
filming process it was one of the
main factors which we took in to      14
account. So, when asking for          12
audience feedback we felt it
essential to ask ‘Do you think that   10
the shots for the documentary
were framed appropriately?’. The      8
response was clear, 100% of the       6
audience said the shots were
framed appropriately, therefore       4
showing that the effort and
                                      2
attention we underwent was
successful.                           0
                                                  yes              no
Television Documentary

The final question we asked our             Do you think that the expert
audience, in relation to our            interview extracts were informative
television documentary was, ‘Do
                                                    and useful?
you think that the expert
                                   16
interview extracts were
informative and useful?’. We       14
asked this due to wanting a high
                                   12
level of information to be
presented to an intelligent and    10
understanding audience. The
                                   8
response was successful 100% of
our audience said yes, therefore   6
showing that we had planned our    4
expert interview questions and
documentary structure              2
appropriately.                     0
                                                yes                 no
Double Page Spread Article

When showing our audience our           On a scale of 1 - 10, how well would
television documentary
opening, we wanted feed back on          you say the double page spread
our double page spread article            article has been put together?
too. So, we asked questions         8
related to our double page spread
to gain some feedback. The first    7
question we asked was ‘On a         6
scale of 1 - 10, how well would
you say the double page spread      5
article has been put together?’
The results for this were           4
successful, the majority of the     3
audience voted for 8, suggesting
that the double page spread was     2
composed well. Plus, all of the
                                    1
responses were 6 or above
making our double page spread       0
successful in the was it has been
                                        1   2   3   4   5    6   7   8   9     10
composed.
Double Page Spread Article

Then next question we asked our            Do you think that we used and
audience was ‘Do you think that          developed common conventions of
we used and developed common
                                               double page spreads?
conventions of double page
                                    16
spreads?’, we asked this due to
wanting a high level of             14
professionalism in our work and
                                    12
we thought it would be good to
gain an understanding of how        10
well we achieved this. Our
                                    8
audience response was
brilliant, audiences voted 100%     6
‘yes’, suggesting that our double   4
page spread developed common
conventions very well.              2
                                    0
                                                yes               no
Double Page Spread Article

The final question we posed to              Stylistically, do you find that the use
our audience in relation to our                    of colour is appropriate?
double page spread was
                                       12
‘Stylistically, do you find that the
use of colour is appropriate?’, we
asked this question due to our         10
lack of colour in our design and
the only colour was from stills.       8
Considering this, the majority of
our audience (10 people) said          6
that the colour was appropriate
and a minority said no (4 people).     4
This shows that our use of colour
seemed professional, but maybe         2
due to the topic we could have
introduced more colour in parts        0
of our double page spread.
                                                     yes                   no
Radio Trailer

As well as asking our audience for         On a scale of 1 - 10, how well would
feed back on the television
documentary and double page                 you say the radio trail article has
spread article, we wanted to gain                  been put together?
an understanding of audience           7
feedback in relation to our radio
trailer. The first question we posed   6
for our audience was, ‘On a scale of
1 - 10, how well would you say the     5
radio trail article has been put
together?’. The results from this      4
were very successful, the majority
of our audience voted for 8 and all    3
of our audience questioned voted
for 7 or above. This suggests that     2
our radio trailers structure was
successful in delivering information   1
as an appealing factor to our
audience.                              0
                                           1   2   3   4   5    6   7   8   9     10
Radio Trailer

We wanted to develop an                    Do you feel inclined or persuaded to
understanding of how well our                 watch the documentary after
radio trailer attracts audiences to
                                              listening to the radio trailer?
our television documentary, so
                                      16
we asked ‘Do you feel inclined or
persuaded to watch the                14
documentary after listening to
                                      12
the radio trailer?’. The response
to this was extremely                 10
successful, 100% of our audience
                                      8
said yes. This illustrates that the
connection between our radio          6
trailer and television                4
documentary is significant and
appeals to our target audience.       2
                                      0
                                                   yes                 no
Radio Trailer

We wanted to be precise in the             Do you think that there are enough
use of extracts from our television            extracts used in the trailer?
documentary, so we asked our
                                      14
audience, ‘Do you think that
there are enough extracts used in     12
the trailer?’. The response from
this was strong; the high majority    10
of the target audience responded
yes and a small minority of 2          8
people said no. This illustrates
that we used the appropriate           6
amount of extracts but there may
have been room for one or two          4
more in places, but on a whole
                                       2
the radio trailer was composed
with a significant amount of           0
extracts.
                                                   yes                no
Radio Trailer

The final question we posed to           Do you believe that the radio trail
our audience was, ‘Do you believe          uses common conventions?
that the radio trail uses common
                                    16
conventions?’. We asked this
question due to the amount of       14
research we did in to the
conventions of radio trailers and   12
we wanted to ensure that we had     10
applied these frameworks to our
media product. The response         8
from this was highly
                                    6
successful, 100% of the audience
said yes. This shows that we had    4
developed a strong advert, which
abides by the common                2
conventions of radio trailers.      0
                                                yes                  no
Conclusion
Overall, gaining audience feedback for our main product and two
ancillary tasks has been insightful. We set out to gain an
understanding of whether we targeted our audience appropriately
with the right content, stylistics and imagery. We have been very
successful with audience feedback and audience’s have said that our
products all work well in provoking attention and leading them to
view the other products. We have learnt that if we were to improve
products, we could use more colour on the double page
spread, more extracts in the radio trailer and maybe slightly tweak
sound levels on the documentary. But, ultimately the audience
feedback suggests that our products have been extremely successful
with appropriate content for out targeted spectator.

Gregory McLaney - Unit G324 - Evaluation - Q3

  • 1.
    A2 Media Studies– Unit G324: Documentary Evaluation Question 3: What have you learned from your audience feedback?
  • 2.
    Introduction When completing theresearch and planning process of our project, we created a questionnaire to develop an understanding of our target audience. Plus, we wanted to identify what features and information audiences would like to know about ‘Health & Fitness’ in a television documentary. In our initial questionnaire we asked males and females aged 20-50+ if they were knowledgeable about the topic to see if, and how we could help inform our audiences. This questionnaire lead us to define a level of information and guidance in our documentary, which worked very well. On the back of this success, we thought it would be appropriate to create an additional questionnaire for the purpose of gaining an understanding of audience feedback in relation to our documentary, radio trailer and magazine article. We questioned a large group of people in our target audience to feedback information about our products.
  • 3.
    Television Documentary We questionedour audience, ‘On On a scale of 1 - 10, how well would a scale of 1 - 10, how well would you say the documentary held your you say the documentary held attention? your attention?’. The results from 7 this were very pleasing. All of the audience feedback was rated 6- 6 10, who said that the documentary held their attention. 5 The majority of the audience 4 suggested that the documentary was on a scale of 8 for holding 3 their attention. This was very successful and we feel as if our 2 documentary definitely holds significant content within the 1 opening five minutes. 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
  • 4.
    Television Documentary We askedour target audience Did you find that the sound levels through the questionnaire, a were balanced and even? simple yes or no question, ‘Did 14 you find that the sound levels were balanced and even?’. The 12 response from this was overwhelming for ‘yes’ 12 people 10 said that they were balanced and a small minority of 2 people said 8 no they were not. From this it is clear that our sound levels were 6 well thought out and strong. The 4 minority shows that they may need a little tweaking in places. 2 0 yes no
  • 5.
    Television Documentary This basicquestion ‘Did you find Did you find that you could relate to that you could relate to any of the any of the documentary? documentary?’ was asked to 16 ensure we had targeted our audience precisely. The result was 14 as expected and 100% of the audience response was ‘yes’. 12 Therefore, our documentary fits 10 its target audience perfectly and our research and planning tasks 8 had all worked in our favor to 6 create a strong and targeted documentary. 4 2 0 yes no
  • 6.
    Television Documentary We useda lot of colour in our Were the colours managed documentary so we want to gain effectively? audience feedback to see if this 16 was effectively used and well composed so we asked ‘Were the 14 colours managed effectively? 12 ‘. The response was clear, 100% of the audience said ‘yes’, which 10 illustrates that our colours were appropriate and not too 8 overpowering, which is the effect 6 we wanted to achieve in our documentary. 4 2 0 yes no
  • 7.
    Television Documentary Due totargeting an adult audience we wanted to develop a somewhat Do you think that the tone of the sophisticated tone to our documentary is sophisticated? documentary. We asked our audience ‘Do you think that the 14 tone of the documentary is sophisticated?’ We had a positive 12 response from this question, the majority (12 People), expressed 10 that our documentary was sophisticated. However a minority (2 people), said that our 8 documentary was not sophisticated. The response suggest 6 that we had a strong sense of sophistication, however in parts this could have been improved. 4 Overall, we set out to achieve a sophisticated tone and we feel this 2 was achieved, predominantly through an authoritative voiceover. 0 yes no
  • 8.
    Television Documentary In ourdocumentary we took a lot Do you think that the shots for of time and attention to detail to create well framed compositions the documentary were framed abiding by the rule of thirds. appropriately? Whether this was in the editing or 16 filming process it was one of the main factors which we took in to 14 account. So, when asking for 12 audience feedback we felt it essential to ask ‘Do you think that 10 the shots for the documentary were framed appropriately?’. The 8 response was clear, 100% of the 6 audience said the shots were framed appropriately, therefore 4 showing that the effort and 2 attention we underwent was successful. 0 yes no
  • 9.
    Television Documentary The finalquestion we asked our Do you think that the expert audience, in relation to our interview extracts were informative television documentary was, ‘Do and useful? you think that the expert 16 interview extracts were informative and useful?’. We 14 asked this due to wanting a high 12 level of information to be presented to an intelligent and 10 understanding audience. The 8 response was successful 100% of our audience said yes, therefore 6 showing that we had planned our 4 expert interview questions and documentary structure 2 appropriately. 0 yes no
  • 10.
    Double Page SpreadArticle When showing our audience our On a scale of 1 - 10, how well would television documentary opening, we wanted feed back on you say the double page spread our double page spread article article has been put together? too. So, we asked questions 8 related to our double page spread to gain some feedback. The first 7 question we asked was ‘On a 6 scale of 1 - 10, how well would you say the double page spread 5 article has been put together?’ The results for this were 4 successful, the majority of the 3 audience voted for 8, suggesting that the double page spread was 2 composed well. Plus, all of the 1 responses were 6 or above making our double page spread 0 successful in the was it has been 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 composed.
  • 11.
    Double Page SpreadArticle Then next question we asked our Do you think that we used and audience was ‘Do you think that developed common conventions of we used and developed common double page spreads? conventions of double page 16 spreads?’, we asked this due to wanting a high level of 14 professionalism in our work and 12 we thought it would be good to gain an understanding of how 10 well we achieved this. Our 8 audience response was brilliant, audiences voted 100% 6 ‘yes’, suggesting that our double 4 page spread developed common conventions very well. 2 0 yes no
  • 12.
    Double Page SpreadArticle The final question we posed to Stylistically, do you find that the use our audience in relation to our of colour is appropriate? double page spread was 12 ‘Stylistically, do you find that the use of colour is appropriate?’, we asked this question due to our 10 lack of colour in our design and the only colour was from stills. 8 Considering this, the majority of our audience (10 people) said 6 that the colour was appropriate and a minority said no (4 people). 4 This shows that our use of colour seemed professional, but maybe 2 due to the topic we could have introduced more colour in parts 0 of our double page spread. yes no
  • 13.
    Radio Trailer As wellas asking our audience for On a scale of 1 - 10, how well would feed back on the television documentary and double page you say the radio trail article has spread article, we wanted to gain been put together? an understanding of audience 7 feedback in relation to our radio trailer. The first question we posed 6 for our audience was, ‘On a scale of 1 - 10, how well would you say the 5 radio trail article has been put together?’. The results from this 4 were very successful, the majority of our audience voted for 8 and all 3 of our audience questioned voted for 7 or above. This suggests that 2 our radio trailers structure was successful in delivering information 1 as an appealing factor to our audience. 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
  • 14.
    Radio Trailer We wantedto develop an Do you feel inclined or persuaded to understanding of how well our watch the documentary after radio trailer attracts audiences to listening to the radio trailer? our television documentary, so 16 we asked ‘Do you feel inclined or persuaded to watch the 14 documentary after listening to 12 the radio trailer?’. The response to this was extremely 10 successful, 100% of our audience 8 said yes. This illustrates that the connection between our radio 6 trailer and television 4 documentary is significant and appeals to our target audience. 2 0 yes no
  • 15.
    Radio Trailer We wantedto be precise in the Do you think that there are enough use of extracts from our television extracts used in the trailer? documentary, so we asked our 14 audience, ‘Do you think that there are enough extracts used in 12 the trailer?’. The response from this was strong; the high majority 10 of the target audience responded yes and a small minority of 2 8 people said no. This illustrates that we used the appropriate 6 amount of extracts but there may have been room for one or two 4 more in places, but on a whole 2 the radio trailer was composed with a significant amount of 0 extracts. yes no
  • 16.
    Radio Trailer The finalquestion we posed to Do you believe that the radio trail our audience was, ‘Do you believe uses common conventions? that the radio trail uses common 16 conventions?’. We asked this question due to the amount of 14 research we did in to the conventions of radio trailers and 12 we wanted to ensure that we had 10 applied these frameworks to our media product. The response 8 from this was highly 6 successful, 100% of the audience said yes. This shows that we had 4 developed a strong advert, which abides by the common 2 conventions of radio trailers. 0 yes no
  • 17.
    Conclusion Overall, gaining audiencefeedback for our main product and two ancillary tasks has been insightful. We set out to gain an understanding of whether we targeted our audience appropriately with the right content, stylistics and imagery. We have been very successful with audience feedback and audience’s have said that our products all work well in provoking attention and leading them to view the other products. We have learnt that if we were to improve products, we could use more colour on the double page spread, more extracts in the radio trailer and maybe slightly tweak sound levels on the documentary. But, ultimately the audience feedback suggests that our products have been extremely successful with appropriate content for out targeted spectator.